Professional Documents
Culture Documents
REPORT
HEALTH ISSUES ASSOCIATED WITH
USAGE OF MASKS AMONG MEDICAL
STUDENTS IN KERALA
CERTIFICATE
HEALTH ISSUES ASSOCIATED WITH USAGE
OF MASKS AMONG MEDICAL STUDENTS IN
KERALA
GUIDED BY SUBMITTED BY
DR MINI S S ABHIRAM KRISHNA
DR BETSY VARGHESE ACHYUTH VINU
ADARSH A
ADARSH GOPAN
ADARSH S CHANDRAN
DATE:
HEAD OF DEPARTMENT
COMMUNITY MEDICINE
OFFICE SEAL
HEALTH ISSUES ASSOCIATED WITH
USAGE OF MASK AMONG MEDICAL
STUDENTS IN KERALA
STATEMENT ABOUT RESEARCHERS
INVESTIGATORS
Abhiram Krishna
2018 MBBS
6282581402
Achyuth Vinu
2018 MBBS
8848443931
Adarsh A
2018 MBBS
8547191446
Adarsh Gopan
2018 MBBS
7356850017
Adarsh S Chandran
2018 MBBS
9207641259
GUIDE
Dr. Mini S S
Professor,
Department of Community Medical,
Government Medical College,
Thiruvananthapuram
CO-GUIDE
Dr. Betsy Varghese,
Junior Resident,
Department of Community Medicine,
Government Medical College,
Thiruvananthapuram
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We wish to thank the almighty God. A volume of this magnitude could
not have been possible without the contributions and guidance of many.
We would like to recognize few specific individuals whose contributions
have been especially helpful.
1. ABSTRACT 7
2. INTRODUCTION 9
3. OBJECTIVE 11
4. REVIEW OF LITERATURE 12
5. METHODOLOGY 13
6. RESULT ANALYSIS 15
7. DISCUSSION 23
8. CONCLUSION 24
9. INFORMED CONSENT 25
10. QUESTONNAIRE 26
11. REFERENCES 29
ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND
The virus mainly spreads among people through close contact via
aerosols and respiratory droplets that are exhaled during talking,
breathing, coughing and sneezing.
Medical professionals use face masks for hours on end, so there are many
logical adverse health and psychic effects associated with long-term use
of face masks. In this context, the study was conducted to estimate these
risks and discover possible correlations between them.
OBJECTIVE
RESULT
A total of 501 responses were received out of which 291 were females,
209 were males and a transgender. The mean age of participants in this
study was 21.62 and median age was 22. The main health issues studied
were nasal symptoms, skin symptoms and mouth symptoms. Regarding
the nasal symptoms 44.9% of participants reported feeling of nasal
discomfort, 29.9% reported nasal congestion or stuffiness, 22.8%
reported nasal blockage or obstruction, 17.2% reported dry nose while
only 8.8% and 8.4% reported burning nose and altered sense of smell
respectively. Among the skin symptoms, 63.5% reported excessive
sweating around the mouth, 54.9% reported acne on concerned area, and
43.7% reported irritation or itchy feeling of nose while only 23.0%
reported rashes or redness of face. Regarding the mouth symptoms 28.1%
reported was dryness around the mouth, 25.3% reported bad breath or
halitosis, while only 17% reported sore throat. Regarding the physical
symptoms 79.0% reported pain behind the ear caused by strap of the
mask, 35.5% reported pain over the nasal bridge due to nose piece and
finally 24.2% reported scar over the nasal bridge. After statistical analysis
of prevalence of various factors and symptoms with the help of Pearson
Chi-Square method, we have found association between the symptoms
and two factors- Place of Place of stay and Whether having Single/Shared
room .
CONCLUSION
Among the health problems studies the main nasal problem reported was
the feeling of nasal discomfort (44.9%), the main skin problem reported
was excessive sweating around the mouth (63.5%), the main mouth
symptoms were dryness around the mouth (28.1%), the main pressure
symptom reported was pain behind the ear caused by the mask strap
(79.0%). After statistical analysis associations was found between more
number of symptoms and place of Place of stay and having shared rooms
INTRODUCTION
The Nose is an important organ in the natural pathway of breathing. It is
also an integral part of face which has multiple functions. Primary
functions of nose are respiration, air conditioning of inspired air,
protection of lower airways, vocal resonance, nasal reflex functions and
olfaction. An average adult inspires about 10000L of air daily. Nose
primarily protects lower airways from infections and other airborne
particles. Nasal vibrissae at entrance act as filter to sift larger particle,
finer particles & bacteria are adhered to mucus which spread like a sheet
all over surface of mucus membrane.
The COVID-19 pandemic that has raged throughout our world was
declared a pandemic on March 11, 2020 by the World Health
Organisation [3]. The cases continue to mount, in waves, across all major
countries of the world and even still continue to do so despite multiple
vaccines being available.
To deal with the rapid spread of this virus the government of India and all
the respective state governments made masks mandatory for all those in
the public sphere. Individuals in the healthcare sector such as doctors,
medical students, nurses recommended wearing N 95 masks for their
protection while at work, leading to prolong usage as a consequence [6].
This prolonged usage was a novelty for all the healthcare providers and
alike. This has not been without its due share of concerns with many
complaining of the mess being uncomfortable, cumbersome, disturbing.
Many have even ventured to say that it may lead to potential ills and
disease. In this study, we will be looking at the physiological and effects
that prolonged usage of masks have on medical students in Kerala [5].
Face masks are vital importance in protective the health workers from the
corona virus disease. The uses of masks became present to forestall the
unfold of Covid 19. It’s been suggested by the government as mandatory.
A study done by Antonio Scarano et al states that N-95 respirators
resulted in facial discomfort associated facial skin symptoms leading to
lower compliance on comparison with surgical masks [2]. as a result of
their prolonged usage of face mask there may an increasing heat at a
lower place the mask that successively decrease the water carrying
capability of air in nose resulting in sensation of dry nose. A study by
Raymond Roberge et al stated that exaggerated thermal perception is one
of the explanations for intolerance of carrying N 95 respirators [10].
OBJECTIVE
PRIMARY OBJECTIVE:
To study the Health, physical, physiological, effects of long term usage of
face mask among medical students in Kerala
SECONDARY OBJECTIVE:
To find out association between the symptoms and factors such age, sex,
place of Place of stay etc.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
In a cross sectional study to assess the Facial Skin Temperature and
Discomfort When Wearing Protective Face Masks: Thermal Infrared
Imaging Evaluation and Hands Moving the Mask' by Antonio Scarano et
al, the increases of skin temperature observed under the mask were
between 0.7±3.3◦C and 1.9±3.5◦C in the respirator [2 7]. These were lower
when the volunteers wore surgical masks. For both types (surgical masks
and N95 respirators), increased skin temperature was observed
at>34.5◦C, a level which may induce slight sensations of thermal
discomfort.
METHODOLOGY
Study Design: Cross sectional study
Study Setting: Medical College across Kerala
Data collection tool: Data was collected through online data collection
tool Google forms.
Statistical Analysis and data management:
Data was automatically entered into excel sheet from Google forms
and was analysed using SPSS statistical software( version 28.0.1.1 )
Qualitative variables were summarised as frequency and proportion.
Quantitative variables were summarised as mean with Standard
deviation and median with interquartile range
Soft copies of the data obtained with the permission and interview
schedule will be kept with the primary researchers.
Informed consent was obtained from participants through Google forms.
All data will be kept confidential and will be used for purpose of this
study only.
RESULT ANALYSIS
Data was collected from 501 participants out of which 58.1% were
females (n=291), 41.7% were males (n=209) and 0.2% were transgender
(n=1). The mean age of participants in the study was 21.54 years (SD =
1.478). The figure 1 and 2 shows age and gender distribution of study
participants.
Figure 1
Histogram
200 Mean = 21.54
Std. Dev. = 1.478
N = 501
150
100
50
0
16 18 20 22 24 26
Age
0.20%
41.72%
58.08%
Mode of transport
Regarding the mode of transport of the participants are given the table 4.
The study showed that 45.5% (n=225) participants depended on own
vehicles for transportation while 54.5% (n=273) participants depended on
public transportation.
N 95 399 79.6
Surgical 55 11.0
79.64%
For the secondary objective of the study that is the association between
all these symptoms and other factors has to be analysed. So as to find an
association, the total number of symptoms reported individually was
calculated for the entire sample size and this ranged from participants
reporting no symptoms to 22 symptoms. As such the median symptoms
reported was calculated to be 9 and the participants were divided into 2
groups, participants who reported more than 9 symptoms and participants
who reported less than 9 symptoms. Using this criteria, the number of
reported symptoms and various factors such as age, sex, place of stay,
mode of transport, whether staying in single or shared room was analysed
and significant association was found with two factors- Place of stay and
Whether staying in single/shared room.
Table 13: Statistical analysis showing association.
Sl. Variables No. of Symptoms Chi P Value 95%
No Square Confidence
>9( per cent) <9( per cent)
. Interval
1. Gender
A total of 501 students participated in the study out of which 291 (58.1%)
were females, 209 (41.7%) were males and a transgender (0.2%).
Participants were aged from 18 - 25 out of which 33.7% were aged 22
years.
The study mainly focussed on the symptoms of nose, skin, mouth,
pressure and physiological problems associated with long term usage of
masks.
When asked about the skin symptoms 63.5% reported excessive sweating
around the mouth, 54.9% reported acne on concerned area, 43.7%
reported irritation or itchy feeling of nose while only 23.0% reported
rashes or redness of face. In a study conducted by P. K. Purushothaman et
al, these same symptoms showed 67.6% reported excessive sweating
around the mouth, 56.0% reported acne on concerned area, 52.0%
reported irritation or itchy feeling of nose while only 39.0% reported
rashes or redness of face. So there id considerable difference in
prevalence of symptoms of itchy feeling of nose and rashes or redness of
face [1].
Regarding pressure symptoms 79.0% reported pain behind the ear caused
by strap of the mask, 35.5% reported pain over the nasal bridge due to
nose piece and finally 24.2% reported scar over the nasal bridge.
Regarding mouth symptoms 28.1% reported dryness around the mouth,
25.3% reported bad breath or halitosis, while only 17% reported sore
throat.
CONCLUSION
The primary objective of our project was to study the heath, physical,
physiological effects of long term usage of face mask among medical
students in Kerala. As we can infer from the studies, Pain behind the ear
because of mask strap (79.0%), excessive sweating around mouth
(63.5%), Acne on face (54.9%), difficulty in performing various
physiological activities such as walking, running, climbing stairs etc.
were found to be the symptoms with most prevalence.
The secondary objective of our project was to find whether there are any
associations between the symptoms and factors such as age, gender, Place
of stay etc. From statistical analysis, we got associations between
symptoms and two factors-Place of stay and whether staying in
Single/Shared room since the p value is less than 0.05 in both the cases.
Students who were staying in Hostels were having more symptoms as
compared to students coming from homes and those who were staying in
shared rooms had more symptoms compared to those who had a single
room.
INFORMED CONSENT
Principle Investigator
…………………………… Signature:
MBBS Student Date:
Government Medical College,
Thiruvananthapuram
1. Name:
2. Age:
3. Sex: a. Male; b. Female; c. Other
4. Types of mask used: a) N 95; b) Surgical; c) Cloth;
2. Scarano, Antonio et al, 2020. “Facial Skin Temperature and Discomfort When
Wearing Protective Face Masks: Thermal Infrared Imaging Evaluation and
Hands Moving the Mask.” International Journal of Environmental Research
and Public Health 17 (13): E4624. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17134624.
5. Zuo, Ying, Wei Hua, Yaxin Luo, and Li Li. 2020. “Skin Reactions of N95
Masks and Medial Masks among Health-Care Personnel: A Self-Report
Questionnaire Survey in China.” Contact Dermatitis 83 (2): 145–47.
https://doi.org/10.1111/cod.13555.
6. Yip, WL, LP Leung, PF Lau, and HK Tong. 2005. “The Effect of Wearing a
Face Mask on Body Temperature.” Hong Kong Journal of Emergency
Medicine 12 (1): 23–27. https://doi.org/10.1177/102490790501200102
8. Sarah P Jones et al, The Imperial College London- YouGov survey and
dashboard, co-led by institute of Global Health innovation principals.
9. Raymond J Roberge et al, Physiologic and fit factor profiles of N95 and P100
filtering face piece respirators for use in hot, humid environments.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26476496/