COMMENT RESOLUTION SHEET (EN221927-TAL201-9V3-00008)

SI No. AP Comments AIPL Reply

Resolution for comments from Rev. 00 Submission
1. Refer comment on subsequent pages and those on GA drawing, Detail
drawing and incorporate the same in all the document.
1 Noted & Updated comments as per GAD.
Vendor shall maintain the consistency in all document and is responsible for the
same.
2. Vendor to attach the PDF CRS sheet along with updated document for
2 review/approval.CRS format attached below. Noted & attached end of the updated document.
Revised Document without CRS will not be accepted.
Vendor to check saddle for transportation and provide calculation as per G
Noted & saddle transportation calculations are attached in revised document.
3 loading given below.
Saddle Parameters:
4
Not Matching with Drawing, update as per DWG Updated & matched with drawing for both saddles.
Weights:
5
Revise and update in GAD Noted & updated.
Nozzle Schedule:
6 Not matching with GAD Noted & updated.
N4 Nozzle is missing
7
N3 and N4 shall be provided with Blind Flange Noted & Updated.
Electric Immersion Heater Design Pressures and Temperatures:
8
Use Higher Longitudinal Stresses (Flag) - Y Updated.
Field Pressure Test:
9 Type of Pressure Test - UG-99(b) Note [35] We update UG-99(b) only.
Wind Design Code:
10
Importance Factor [k4] - 1.15 Noted & updated 1.15 instead of 1.0
Seismic Design Code:
11
Importance Factor for IS-1893 - 2 Noted & updated 2 instead of 1.0
12 Thickness of Insulation - 152mm typical from 100mm Noted & updated insulation thickness for whole vessel.
NOZZLE N3-DRAIN:
13
Not matching with GAD Noted & updated.
SHELL BODY FLANGE:
14 Noted and updted 482.6 instead of 483.4mm.
Flange Inside Diameter - 482.6mm
Weight Summary:
15 Update Updated.
Earthquake Load Calculation Results:
16
Response reduction factor (Force factor) - 1 Updated.
Lifting Lug Calculations: Lug(s) on Left End of Vessel:
17
Impact Factor - 2 Updated.
Lifting Lug Calculations: Lug(s) on Right End of Vessel:
18 Impact Factor - 2 Updated.
Saddle Calcs:
19
Update detail as per GAD.maintain consistancy Updated the details as per GAD and maintained consistancy.
Input Data for Base Plate Bolting Calculations:
20
Bolt Allowable Stress - 1460 kgf/cm2 Updated.
Nozzle Calcs.: NOZZLE N3-DRAIN:
Noted & updated.
21 Update detail as per GAD.maintain consistancy
Nozzle Calcs.: Noz N1:
1. Provide WRC Calculation, derating Calculation as ug-44b for all process
22 Noted & updated.
nozzles N1 & N2
2. Provide Calculation for N4.
ASME EIH Calc: TUBESHEET:
23 We will provide the tubesheet drawing.
Vendor to provide tubesheet detail to check this calculation.
24 Update tubesheet MOC as SA 182 Gr F321 Noted & updated.
25 Check comment on Flange Calculation and update Noted & updated.
Nozzle Calcs.: NOZZLE N4-VENT:
26
Update detail as per GAD.maintain consistancy Updated the details as per GAD and maintained consistancy.
Our vessel is stacked vessel,few nozzles are placed in bottom vessel and few
Nozzle Calcs.: Noz N2: nozzles are placed in top vessel.We can't do the analysis stcked vessel in Pvelite
27
Why this separate Calculation is provided??? this is already covered above. software.Thats why we are done individually and attached the same for your
approval.
28 Refer Comment on DBE Case and update this MCE calculation Noted & updted.
29 Refer Comment on DBE Case and update this hydrotest case calculation Noted & updted.