25% 20% 15% 10% Quality of Piece was Piece was Piece had little Piece had no Writing written in an written in an style or voice style or voice extraordinary interesting style style and voice and voice Gives some new Gives no new information but information Very Somewhat poorly and very poorly informative and informative and organized organized well-organized organized
Grammar, Virtually no Few spelling A number of So many
Usage & spelling, and spelling, spelling, Mechanics punctuation or punctuation punctuation or punctuation grammatical errors, minor grammatical and errors grammatical errors grammatical errors errors that it interferes with the meaning