Criteria Excellent Satisfactory Need improvement Unsatisfactory
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 General (20%) Format (10%) This report is very well The report reflects The report reflects minimal The report is inconsistent in structured. The information consistent structure. structure flaws. Information structure which impedes the is very well organized and Information is organised and has been organised to interpretation and unity of sequenced to convey its sequenced to convey the convey meaning to the the report for the reader. intended meaning to the intended meaning to the reader. Titles/subtitles are The analysis does not follow reader which allows easy reader. Titles/subtitles are included. a logical or organised reading. Selected organised and included to structure. headings/subtitles improve assist reading. Formatting report consistency and elements do not always accuracy. support main points. Writing (10%) The plan has a writing style The plan has a writing style The writing style lacks Plan is clearly the work of that is uniform throughout that is uniform throughout uniformity at times and is multiple authors with the paper and appropriate the paper and appropriate not always appropriate for a different writing styles, for this type of written for this type of written marketing plan. There is margins, printer fonts, paper project. There is no project. There is no some indication of multiple types, etc. indication that the paper indication that the paper authors (e.g., different involved multiple authors. involved multiple authors. fonts, different paper, etc.). There is no spelling and grammar errors. Current Situation Analysis (25%) Market Summary (15%) Description of market Description of market The description of the Description of the environment is supported environment is supported supported market supported market with facts and figures with facts and figures environment is explained environment, market (statistical data). Market size (statistical data). Market size without the support of facts trends, market needs, and (in measurable number) is (in measurable number) is and figures (statistical data). market growth were poorly assessed and explained. assessed and explained. Market trends, market explained and were not Market trends is identified Market trends is identified needs, and market growth relevant to the topic of the to show the tendency of to show the tendency of are identified and explained marketing plan. market changes in market changes in consumer but are not interrelated. consumer behaviours based behaviours based on on preceding analysis. preceding analysis. Market Market needs is identified needs is identified and and explained based on explained based on market market trend analysis. trend analysis. Market Market growth is assessed, growth is assessed. and provide TAM, SAM and SOM for the next 3 to 5 years. Competition and SWOT The competitive advantage The competitive advantage Competitive analysis is Poor competitive and SWOT Analysis (3%) (differentiation or (differentiation or explained without analysis uniqueness) of the uniqueness) of the mentioning the competitive product/service is presented product/service is presented advantage (differentiation and compared to what but not compared to what or uniqueness) of the competitors have. A competitors have. A product/service. thorough SWOT analysis is thorough SWOT analysis is Competition analysis only provided, based on the provided, based on the compares the company's previous analysis. previous analysis. products/services with other competitors' products/services. A thorough SWOT analysis is provided but not based on the previous analysis. Product Offering (5%) Provide an overview of the Provide an overview of the Provide an overview of the Poor overview of the product/service value(s) product/service value(s) in product/service value(s) but product/service values offered to customers and accordance with the these values are not related these values indicate characteristics and features to the characteristics and features of the uniqueness (differentiation), of the product/service product/service offered to creative and attractive. offered to customers. customers Keys to success and critical Provides the key success Provide the key success Provide key success factors Poor or no attempt to issues (2%) factors that most influence factors that most influence and describe market identify the right keys to the company's plans to the company's overall plans. problems or risks that are success and critical achieve its marketing Describe general market not related to the topic of problems. objectives. Describe any problems or risks that may the marketing plan. market problems or risks arise during the preparation that may arise during the and execution of the preparation and execution marketing plan. of the marketing plan Marketing Strategy (30%) Mission (2%) The mission statement The mission statement Provide a mission statement Poor a mission statement. describes the describes the but do not describe the product/service value of the product/service value(s) product/service value(s). offered to the market, offered to the market, customer benefits and customer benefits and company benefits. All company benefits. Mission mission statements have slogan is included these three elements: Cause, Action, and Impact. Mission slogan is included. Marketing objectives Strategic marketing Strategic marketing Poor marketing objectives No marketing objective. (In this report, you must objectives are clearly stated objectives are clearly stated. are stated. provide strategic marketing and linked to the mission of objectives not operational the company/organisation. marketing objectives) (3%) Segmentation (10%) Market segments are clearly Market segments are clearly Market segments are Market segments are poorly identified and exhibit identified and exhibit identified but lacks the identified. homogeneity among the homogeneity among the existing cluster segment's key needs, segment's key needs, homogeneity. uniqueness, and general uniqueness, and general reactions to marketing reactions to marketing tactics. Market segment tactics. Market segment cluster names are clearly cluster names are not defined and stated. clearly defined and stated. Target markets (5%) One or more target markets One or more target markets One or more target markets Target market not identified are identified and selected are identified and selected are identified but not from the previous from the previous selected from the previous segmentation analysis. The segmentation analysis. segmentation analysis reasons for choosing the There is no reason to target market are provided choose the target market and logical. Target market provided and logical. Target tagline provided. (5 points) market tagline provided. Positioning (10%) Identify an attractive and Identify an attractive and Identify an attractive and Poor positioning strategy relevant positioning strategy relevant positioning strategy relevant positioning strategy analysis and explanation related to the target market related to the target market related to the target market and the product/service and the product/service but the product/service value(s) as described in the value(s) as described in the value is not explicitly stated Product Offering related to Product Offering related to in the positioning the brand image. Positioning the brand image. description. tagline provided. Marketing Program (20%) Product Strategy (5%) Develop a product strategy Develop a product strategy Describe packaging, Does not provide that delivers that delivers labeling, product features description of product product/service value(s) as product/service value as and specifications but not strategy. described in the previous described in the previous related to the target market product offering. Describe product offering. Explain and positioning packaging, labeling, product packaging, labeling, features (uniqueness) as described in features and specifications and product specifications the previous section. according to the target according to the target market and positioning market. (uniqueness) as described in the previous section. Pricing Strategy (5%) Develops detailed list of the Explains the pricing Pricing strategies are No objectives and poor costs involved in strategies that are suitable described but do not match strategy. determining the prices of to the target market(s), the target market, the product/service. positioning and marketing positioning, and marketing Explains the pricing objective(s). objectives. strategies that are suitable to the target market(s), positioning and marketing objective(s). Communication and Implement logical Implement logical Explain the application of Do not consider Influence Strategy (5%) integrated marketing integrated marketing the promotional mix advertising, sales communications (IMC) communications (IMC) without relation to the promotion, (promotional mix) in (promotional mix) according marketing objectives of the PR, or personal selling accordance with the to a consistent target market. promotion strategy. communication strategy communication strategy consistent with the target with the target market and market, and positioning to achieve marketing strategy (brand image) and objectives. to achieve marketing objectives. Channel Strategy (5%) Choose the right distribution Choose the right distribution Explain the distribution No objectives and poor channel(s) according to the channel(s) in accordance channel but not in strategy target market(s), positioning with the target market(s) accordance with the target strategy (brand image) and and marketing objectives. market and marketing marketing objectives. objectives. Implementation and Marketing Control (5%) Implementation, Marketing Provides a detailed Provides a detailed Provides a broad and Does not provide a Organisation and Implementation, marketing Implementation, marketing ambiguous Implementation, contingency plan and Contingency Plan (5%) organisation, and organisation, and marketing organisation, and marketing plan control. contingency plan over the contingency plan over the contingency plan. next 5 years. next 3 years.