Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Performance Based Design - Fire Investigation
Performance Based Design - Fire Investigation
Fire Protection
Performance Based
Design
S.B Nurcahya
Member of NFPA International &
Indonesian Fire Protection Association
1
3/17/2021
2
3/17/2021
3
3/17/2021
Proper Calculation
Proper Calculation
4
3/17/2021
Hazen-Williams
friction loss formula
SI – Imperial
US Standard Standard
5
3/17/2021
Hazen-Williams C Values
(roughness coefficient)
C Value Multiplier
Table shall be used with a
Hazen-Williams C factor of
120 only. For other values of
C, the values in
6
3/17/2021
Darcy - Weisbach
friction loss formula
Hazen Darcy
Williams Weisbach
7
3/17/2021
8
3/17/2021
Contoh soal
Flow rate in pipe: 350 US gpm
Elbow Diameter pipe: 4 in
Tee
90°Dia.4”
3 ft Dia.4”
Elbow
Pipe Material: Black Steel Pipe
3 ft
BSP
90°Dia.4” SCH 40 ASTM-A53
BSP SCH40
Dia.4”5 ft
Dry Sprinkler System
SCH40 BSP
Dia.4” 10 ft SCH40
Dia.4”
Pertanyaan:
1. Hitung Total Friction loss
??? pada pipa sistem tersebut :
350 US GPM @
2. Berapa tekanan rata2 di
100 Psi ujung pipa sistem tersebut :
Jawaban
Langkah-1:
Material Qty EL Total
Hitung total
Tee BSP SCH 40 dia.4 1 20 20 ft
“equivalent length” in
pipe fitting 90°Elbow BSP SCH 40 2 10 20 ft
Jumlahkan dia.4 in
dengan total Straight Pipe BSP SCH 21 Ft
40 dia.4 in
panjang pipa lurus
“straight pipe” TOTAL : 61 ft
9
3/17/2021
Jawaban.. (lanjutan)
Langkah 2:
Material: Black Steel Pipe SCH
Tentukan Hazen- 40 dia 4”
Williams C factor Hazen-Williams C Value: 100
berdasarkan Material C Value multiplier: 0,713
Hazen-Williams C factor:
100 * 0.713 = 71,3
C Value Multiplier
Jawaban.. (lanjutan)
Langkah-3:
Hitung Total Friction
Loss
Hitung tekanan rata2
di ujung Pipa
= (4,52 * (350^1,85)) / ((71,3^1,85) *(4^4,87))
Tekanan di Ujung Pipa yg
= (4,42 * 50877,5) / (2680,5 * 855,1)
= 224878,6 / 2292096
ditentukan =
P’ = P – Ƥ
Ƥ= 0,1 Psi / ft
P’ = 100 – 6,1 = 93,9 Psi
10
3/17/2021
Contoh soal
Flow rate in pipe: 750 US gpm
Elbow Diameter pipe: 6 in
Tee
90°Dia.6”
4 ft Dia.6”
Elbow
Pipe Material: Black Steel Pipe
4 ft
BSP
90°Dia.6” SCH 40 ASTM-A53
BSP SCH40
Dia.6”6 ft
Stand pipe System
SCH40 BSP
Dia.6” 12 ft SCH40
Dia.6”
Pertanyaan:
1. Hitung Total Friction loss
118,3 pada pipa sistem tersebut :
750 US
Psi 2. Berapa tekanan rata2 di
GPM @ 120 ujung pipa sistem tersebut :
Psi
Light Hazard
11
3/17/2021
Material Selection
12
3/17/2021
The Plates
13
3/17/2021
Material Selection..
(specification)
Fire Pump
Centrifugal pump, Specially for the Fire Protection System
purpose
Shall be have pump & driven plate
Have rate 25 to 5000 US GPM, and shall be rated on 40 Psi (2,7
Kg/cm²) net pressure
Shall furnish not less than 150 percent of rated capacity at not
less than 65 percent of total rated head
For horizontal pumps, shall be able to operate with a suction lift
of −3 psi (−0.2 bar) at the lowest water level and at 150 percent
of the rated flow
The shutoff head shall not exceed 140 percent of rated head.
14
3/17/2021
15
3/17/2021
16
3/17/2021
Material Selection..
(specification)
Pump driven:
Shall be calculate based on 150% pump
performance
The engine driven type shall be compressed
combustion type (Not Injection Fuel type)
Engine driven selection was adjusted with
derate correction calculation
17
3/17/2021
EHcorr = [(Ca+Ct)-1]x216
Where :
EHcoor= Corrected Horse Power
Ca = Correction from Altitude
Ct = Correction from Amb. Temp
18
3/17/2021
Contoh Soal:
An engine rated at 95 hp is used to drive a
fire pump in Puncak Cisarua, where the
elevation is 7000 ft (2134 m) above sea
level and the ambient temperature could
be 105°F (40.5°C). What is the adjusted
rating of this engine?
19
3/17/2021
EHcorr = [(Ca+Ct)-1]x95
= [(0.80 + 0.973) − 1] × 95
= 73,4 HP
Contoh soal
An engine rated at 95 hp is used to drive a
fire pump in Malang, where the elevation
is 4000 ft above sea level and the ambient
temperature could be 95°F. What is the
adjusted rating of this engine?
20
3/17/2021
Material Selection..
(specification)
Jockey Pump
Flow rate (Q) = 1% Fire pump rate
Pressure rate (P) = 10% above fire pump
shut-off (churn pressure)
Sprinkler Valve
21
3/17/2021
Where:
K = K-factor
Q = Flow rate
P = Pressure
22
3/17/2021
Sprinkler Head
Sprinkler Head
23
3/17/2021
Proper Installation
Engine Driven
Horizontal Split Case FP
24
3/17/2021
25
3/17/2021
26
3/17/2021
Vortex plate:
For the pump(s) taking suction from a stored
water supply, a vortex plate shall be installed
at the entrance to the suction pipe. Square
steel vortex plate with dimensions at least
twice the diameter of the suction pipe.
Distance above the bottom of tank is one-half
the diameter of the suction pipe with minimum
of 6 in. (152 mm)
27
3/17/2021
Eccentric Installation
Reducer at pump
intake is eccentric
and installed with flat
side up
28
3/17/2021
Circulation discharge
relief Valve relief Valve
Install for Electric Driven Fire Install for Engine Driven Fire
Pump Pump
Objective, to safe the system Objective, to safe the system
from over pressure during pump from over pressure during pump
operation without opening operation over speed
29
3/17/2021
30
3/17/2021
31
3/17/2021
Pump Accessories
Pressure Gauge
A 3½ inch pressure
gauge,
Rate of at least 100
(suction) and 200
psi (discharge) and
a range of at least
twice the working
pressure of the
pump
Pump Accessories
A listed, float-
operated,
automatic, air
release valve (no
less than ½ inch in
size) is provided
32
3/17/2021
Engine Battery
33
3/17/2021
34
3/17/2021
35
3/17/2021
Sprinklers under
pitched roofs
36
3/17/2021
Sprinkler Obstruction
Positioning of sprinklers
Obstructions against to avoid obstructions to
walls discharge
Sprinkler Obstruction
37
3/17/2021
Detector Installation
Guide NFPA 72e
38
3/17/2021
39
3/17/2021
40
3/17/2021
41
3/17/2021
Any Question..??
42
3/17/2021
Fire Investigation
S.B Nurcahya
Member of NFPA International &
Indonesian Fire Protection Association
Fire Investigation:
Reff:
NFPA 921, Guide for Fire and Explosion
Investigations-2017 edition
1
3/17/2021
Fire Investigation:
Fire Investigation:
Cause of Fire:
Natural Undetermined
Accidental Intentional
2
3/17/2021
Heat Transfer
Conduction
Transfer of heat by direct contact of one body to another
(pipes, beams, etc.)
Convection
Transfer of heat by some circulating medium (either gas or
liquid)
Convection is the form of heat transfer most responsible for
the spread of structural fires.
Radiation
Heat being transferred from one area to another without direct
contact with the area, and without any circulating hot gases to
help “bathe” the area in heat. It is heat in the form of energy
which travels through space or materials as waves.
3
3/17/2021
CONDUCTION
Vertical Horizontal
Api menyebar melalui panas yang dihantarkan oleh bahan penghantar panas,
bisa berupa sekat partisi atau dinding atau bahan konduktor lain pada suatu
ruangan sehingga membakar ruangan lain yang ada disebelahnya
CONVECTION
4
3/17/2021
RADIATION
energi panas dari material yang terbakar meningkatkan suhu bahan lain yang
ada disekitar bahan yang terbakar sampai mencapai titik bakar, sehingga bahan
lain yang teradiasi tersebut turut terbakar
Flashover
Stage of fire when a room or other area
becomes heated to the point when flames
flash over the entire surface or area.
Common cause of secondary fires
Indicators:
Surface burning (a grey-black color w/ hairline cracks,
rather than deep char)
Lack of an accelerant residue
Lack of normal fire spread
Demarcation or separation line in the structure – an
imaginary line between a heated area & a cooler area.
5
3/17/2021
FLASHOVER
Metode Systematis
6
3/17/2021
7
3/17/2021
8
3/17/2021
Success in
Recognizing
Arson begins
with
recognizing
possible
Arson Fire
Patterns
“Once point of origin is determined, the
cause of the fire is determined”
9
3/17/2021
Pemeriksaan Exterior
Lakukan pemeriksaan eksterior 360
derajat dari lokasi kebakaran.
Hasil pemeriksaan eksterior harus
sepenuhnya didokumentasikan.
Perhatikan pola api dan bukti lain yang
mungkin ada atau informasi lain yang
mungkin penting untuk penyelidikan.
10
3/17/2021
Pemeriksaan Exterior
Area yang paling terdampak oleh kebakaran
11
3/17/2021
Pemeriksaan Interior
Keselamatan pertama!
Lakukan dari area dengan kerusakan paling
kecil hingga sebagian besar kerusakan (daerah
yang bernoda asap, rusak, dan hangus ringan
menuju ke area yang ternoda asap, rusak dan
hangus berat)
Waspadai masalah kontaminasi bukti (mis.,
Pengisian bahan bakar peralatan bertenaga
bensin).
12
3/17/2021
Slide 2-25
13
3/17/2021
Intensity Pattern
“V” pattern
Slide 2-28
14
3/17/2021
“V” pattern
Clean burn
Slide 2-30
15
3/17/2021
Slide 2-31
Movement Pattern
16
3/17/2021
Slide 2-33
Slide 2-34
17
3/17/2021
Heat shadowing
Diproduksi oleh
objek yang
menghalangi
perjalanan energi
panas mungkin
padat atau cair,
mudah terbakar
atau tidak mudah
terbakar..
Slide 2-35
18
3/17/2021
Pemeriksaan Interior
19
3/17/2021
“Unnatural” Fire
Damage
One gallon of
gasoline
was poured
here!
“Rainbow-colored”
/ Rainbow marking
sheen
on the surface
of
suppression water
over the
pour area.
20
3/17/2021
Accelerant containers
in or near the scene.
Pemeriksaan Interior
Komponen dapat hangus lebih berat pada sisi
yang menghadap ke sumber api, karena terkena
lebih lama ke sumber panas.
Lubang di langit-langit mungkin membantu
penyebaran api.
Kerusakan bisa disebabkan oleh aktivitas
pemadaman kebakaran.
Mungkin ada bukaan atau kerusakan pada langit-
langit sebelum kebakaran.
21
3/17/2021
Pemeriksaan Interior
Area di atas pintu yang paling dekat
dengan sumber api mungkin memiliki
pembakaran yang lebih parah.
Kerusakan langit-langit adalah pendekatan
pada area asal api, area asal api harus
mengalami kerusakan langit-langit lebih
besar.
Pemeriksaan Interior
Periksa semua kerusakan pada lantai
akibat kebakaran dan bandingkan dengan
kerusakan langit-langit di ruangan / area
asal.
Perhatikan karpet terbakar atau meleleh.
Evaluasi kerusakan dengan teliti lubang yang
terbakar, dan cari:
Tanda-tanda pola yang berbeda dari area yang
terbakar dan tidak terbakar.
22
3/17/2021
Pemeriksaan Interior
Dalam tahap kebakaran penuh (full
developed fire) juga dapat berdampak
pembakaran lantai di sekitar ambang pintu
dan alas tiang akibat radiasi atau sumber
udara (ventilasi).
Dalam tahap
kebakaran penuh
(full developed fire)
juga dapat
berdampak
pembakaran lantai
di sekitar ambang
pintu dan alas tiang
akibat radiasi atau
sumber udara
(ventilasi).
23
3/17/2021
24
3/17/2021
Slide 2-49
Slide 2-50
25
3/17/2021
Pemeriksaan Interior
Kondisi pintu juga dapat memberikan
petunjuk tentang perjalanan api.
Pintu ditutup pada saat kebakaran harus
menunjukkan pola luka bakar yang
merata.
Tepi pintu harus dilindungi agar tidak
terbakar atau hangus.
Pemeriksaan Interior
Apabila pintu tertutup pada saat kebakaran
dengan api di sisi bawah dapat mengindikasikan
penggunaan cairan yang dapat terbakar.
Pintu yang terbuka pada saat kebakaran dapat
memperlihatkan pola terbakar yang berbeda.
Pembakaran harus lebih besar di sisi pintu yang
berengsel.
Jika api berasal dari pembakaran rendah, pola
terbakar di pintu harus miring.
26
3/17/2021
Exterior examination
Burn patterns at ventilation points.
Slide 2-53
Komponen bangunan
nonstruktural.
Mungkin dapat memberikan petunjuk ke tingkat
aktivitas kebakaran pada lokasi terendah.
Rak juga harus dievaluasi untuk pembakaran di
bagian bawah maupun di atas.
Bagian atas sering akan terlindung oleh bahan yang
diletakkan di atasnya.
Jika rak runtuh ke rak lain, akan lebih mudah
temukan area pembakaran dilokasi / titik yg terendah
pada rak tsb
27
3/17/2021
28
3/17/2021
Slide 2-57
Tertarik ke
arah sumber
panas
(lebih dari 25
watt (W))
Slide 2-58
29
3/17/2021
30
3/17/2021
31