ST. MARY’S COLLEGE OF TAGUM, INC.

SMCTI
GRADUATE EDUCATION PROGRAM
National Highway, Tagum City, 8100 Davao del Norte, Philippines QTIME
Faith • Excellence • Service
Quality Transformative Ignacian Marian Education

Research Title: ____________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________

Research Adviser: ______________________________________________

Proponent/Researcher: ___________________________________ Major Course: _______________
Date: ____________________________ Time of Defense: ___________________________
Type/Kind of Research: ( ) Quantitative ( ) Qualitative ( ) Experimental
Internal Panelists: 1. _____________________________________
2. _____________________________________
3. _____________________________________
4. _____________________________________
External Panel: ________________________________________

TITLE DEFENSE RUBRIC

Aspect 15 10 5 Score
Manuscript
All important parts of the Some of the parts of
Completeness (15%) Not complete at all.
manuscript are manuscript are missing/
(Parts of a research) Every part is LACKING.
COMPLETE. INCOMPLETE.
ALL ideas included are Some ideas are
appropriate and irrelevant for the study.
Content (30%) Most entries/ideas are
significant for the study. There are sections in
(Accuracy and not appropriate for the
ALL sections of the the manuscript that
significance of study. The manner of
manuscript contain the lacks needed
entries/ideas included the discussion is very
needed information and information and are
in the manuscript) poor.
are discussed discussed
appropriately. inappropriately.
Organization (10%)
The manuscript is very The manuscript is not
(Manuscript Not organized at all.
organized. so organized.
presentation)
Technicalities (10%) Only 0-5 technical errors Only 6-10 technical There are more than 10
(Grammars and other are found. errors are found. The errors are found.
technical aspects like The manuscript is manuscript The manuscript
pagination, etc.) WELL written. is GOOD. is FAIRLY written.
Oral Defense
Answers questions
Communication Most of the time,
Answers questions using using English, Tagalog
Skills (10%) Cebuano is used in
English as the medium. and Cebuano as
(Oral communication) explaining the study
mediums.
Answers questions
Question and Answers SOME of the Answers NONE of the
CLEARLY and
Answer Skills (25%) questions only questions
ACCURATELY

Total Score/15
Overall Rating: (total score/15) x 40+60

Decision:
Approved _______
Approved with Revisions _______
Disapproved ________

________________________________________
Signature Over Printed Name of Panel Member