Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ANSWER: b
REFERENCES: Sources of Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.01 - Identify the sources of information that are available to
investigators.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: a
REFERENCES: Sources of Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.01 - Identify the sources of information that are available to
investigators.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: b
REFERENCES: Sources of Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.01 - Identify the sources of information that are available to
investigators.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: b
REFERENCES: Sources of Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.01 - Identify the sources of information that are available to
investigators.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: b
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.02 - Explain what the goal of interviewing and interrogation is.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: a
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.02 - Explain what the goal of interviewing and interrogation is.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
7. To improve communication:
a. ask complex questions that will confuse the suspect and make him or her more likely to tell the truth.
b. stand so that the suspect can see more of you.
c. use a public setting.
d. prepare your questions and tactics in advance.
ANSWER: d
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.02 - Explain what the goal of interviewing and interrogation is.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: b
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.02 - Explain what the goal of interviewing and interrogation is.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: c
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.03 - Explain the different types of questions used during interviews
and interrogations and when to use each.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
10. Which type of interview technique calls for using a secluded, quiet place that is free of distractions, and is effective
for obtaining information from victims and witnesses who are having difficulty remembering an event?
a. reflective memory lead
b. suppressed memory trap
c. cognitive interview
d. subliminal inflection
ANSWER: c
REFERENCES: The Interview
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.03 - Explain the different types of questions used during interviews
and interrogations and when to use each.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: d
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.03 - Explain the different types of questions used during interviews
and interrogations and when to use each.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: b
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.03 - Explain the different types of questions used during interviews
and interrogations and when to use each.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: d
REFERENCES: The Interview
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.04 - Describe how to conduct interviews when multiple people are
at the scene.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
14. People may volunteer information if approached correctly. Consequently, which technique is useful to demonstrate
when conducting an interview?
a. developing rapport
b. developing an intimate relationship
c. using bribery and gratuities
d. using flattery and guile
ANSWER: a
REFERENCES: The Interview
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.04 - Describe how to conduct interviews when multiple people are
at the scene.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: c
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.05 - Compare and contrast the approaches used to appeal to
reluctant interviewees.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
Cengage Learning Testing, Powered by Cognero Page 4
16. Once a confession has been obtained, investigators should:
a. corroborate the confession using independent evidence.
b. stop the investigation.
c. let the confession prove the case.
d. submit the case for prosecution based on the confession.
ANSWER: a
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.05 - Compare and contrast the approaches used to appeal to
reluctant interviewees.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
17. The Fifth Amendment right to counsel hinges on the issue of:
a. exigency.
b. guilt.
c. privacy.
d. custody.
ANSWER: d
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.05 - Compare and contrast the approaches used to appeal to
reluctant interviewees.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
18. Which case highlighted the issue of the public safety exception to the Miranda warning requirement?
a. New York v. Quarles
b. Mapp v. Ohio
c. Lawson v. Kolender
d. Arizona v. Mincey
ANSWER: a
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.06 - Explain what the Miranda warning is and when it must be
given.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
19. In Miranda v. Arizona, who won the ultimate appeal and why?
a. Miranda, because he had been beaten to confess
b. Miranda, because his rights had not been explained to him properly
c. Arizona, because the police had cautioned Miranda properly
d. Arizona, because Miranda voluntarily confessed
ANSWER: b
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.06 - Explain what the Miranda warning is and when it must be
given.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: d
REFERENCES: Scientific Aids to Obtaining and Evaluating Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: a
REFERENCES: Scientific Aids to Obtaining and Evaluating Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: b
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.08 - Explain what significance a confession has in an investigation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
23. Under the Bruton rule, which resulted from Bruton v. United States (1968), a defendant’s Sixth Amendment right
to confront and cross-examine witnesses against him or her is violated if:
a. the defendant recants a confession.
b. the defendant waives Miranda rights.
c. a confessing defendant’s statement is used against a nonconfessing defendant at their joint trial.
d. the witnesses recant.
ANSWER: c
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.08 - Explain what significance a confession has in an investigation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: d
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.08 - Explain what significance a confession has in an investigation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: c
REFERENCES: Information Versus Intelligence
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.10 - Differentiate between information and intelligence.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
26. Since eyewitness testimony is not always reliable, it is generally regarded as irrelevant to investigating and
prosecuting a case.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: Sources of Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.01 - Identify the sources of information that are available to
investigators.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
27. It is beneficial for officers to question someone suspected of involvement in a crime right after the crime has
occurred.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: Sources of Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.01 - Identify the sources of information that are available to
investigators.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.02 - Explain what the goal of interviewing and interrogation is.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
29. Audio and video recordings are being used more widely as evidence.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.03 - Explain the different types of questions used during interviews
and interrogations and when to use each.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
30. When at a crime scene, witnesses should be separated so they are unable to compare information.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: The Interview
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.04 - Describe how to conduct interviews when multiple people are
at the scene.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
31. Emotional barriers to communication include fear, anger, ingrained attitudes and prejudices, and the instinct for self-
preservation.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.05 - Compare and contrast the approaches used to appeal to
reluctant interviewees.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: The Interview
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.05 - Compare and contrast the approaches used to appeal to
reluctant interviewees.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
33. The Miranda warning advises suspects of their Fourth Amendment rights.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.06 - Explain what the Miranda warning is and when it must be
given.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
34. The Sixth Amendment right to counsel applies to anyone who is questioned by the police.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.06 - Explain what the Miranda warning is and when it must be
given.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
35. The Miranda warning is required during questioning from one private citizen to another private citizen.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.06 - Explain what the Miranda warning is and when it must be
given.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
36. When conducting an interrogation, officers should seek a place where the individual will likely feel the least amount
of stress.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
38. During interrogation, it is permissible to tell a suspect that an accomplice has already confessed when they actually
have not.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: True
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
40. Once a suspect has confessed, the investigation should be ended and all of the facts presented to the prosecuting
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.08 - Explain what significance a confession has in an investigation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
41. Information obtained through the use of truth serums is recognized by the courts as reliable and is admissible,
provided a court order was obtained before the suspect received the serum.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: Scientific Aids to Obtaining and Evaluating Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.09 - Describe what a polygraph is, its role in investigation, and the
acceptability of its results in court.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: Scientific Aids to Obtaining and Evaluating Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.09 - Describe what a polygraph is, its role in investigation, and the
acceptability of its results in court.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: Scientific Aids to Obtaining and Evaluating Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.09 - Describe what a polygraph is, its role in investigation, and the
acceptability of its results in court.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
44. Truth serums are commonly used in criminal cases by the police.
a. True
b. False
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: Scientific Aids to Obtaining and Evaluating Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.09 - Describe what a polygraph is, its role in investigation, and the
acceptability of its results in court.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: False
REFERENCES: Use of Psychics and Profilers
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.09 - Describe what a polygraph is, its role in investigation, and the
acceptability of its results in court.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
46. A(n) _______________ is anyone who can provide information about a case but who is not a complainant,
witness, victim, or suspect.
ANSWER: informant
REFERENCES: Sources of Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.01 - Identify the sources of information that are available to
investigators.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: interrogation
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.02 - Explain what the goal of interviewing and interrogation is.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
48. The _______________ interview method is especially effective for obtaining information from victims and
witnesses who have difficulty remembering an event.
ANSWER: cognitive
REFERENCES: The Interview
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.05 - Compare and contrast the approaches used to appeal to
reluctant interviewees.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
49. _______________ is the capacity to accurately perceive and respond to another person’s thoughts and feelings. It
is an active process rather than a passive experience.
ANSWER: Empathy
REFERENCES: The Interview
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.05 - Compare and contrast the approaches used to appeal to
reluctant interviewees.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
50. The _______________ Amendment states that “[N]o person shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a
witness against himself.”
ANSWER: Fifth
5th
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.06 - Explain what the Miranda warning is and when it must be
given.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
51. The Miranda warning informs suspects of their _______________ Amendment rights.
ANSWER: Fifth
5th
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.06 - Explain what the Miranda warning is and when it must be
given.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: beachheading
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.06 - Explain what the Miranda warning is and when it must be
given.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
ANSWER: deflating
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
54. A(n) _______________ question is to the point and limits the possibility of misinterpretation.
ANSWER: direct
REFERENCES: Interviewing and Interrogating
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
55. The _______________ measures respiration and depth of breathing, changes in the skin’s electrical resistance, and
blood pressure and pulse.
ANSWER: polygraph
REFERENCES: Scientific Aids to Obtaining and Evaluating Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.09 - Describe what a polygraph is, its role in investigation, and the
acceptability of its results in court.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Remember
56. What is the value of the FBI’s National Crime Information Center (NCIC) to investigators?
ANSWER: The NCIC is of great value to investigators. It contains online databases on wanted
and missing persons; stolen guns, securities, articles, boats, license plates, and vehicles;
criminal histories; foreign fugitives and deported felons; gang and terrorist members;
and persons subject to protection orders. The newest generation, NCIC 2000, includes
mug shots and other personal identifying images, such as scars and tattoos; images of
vehicles; an enhanced name search; automated single-finger fingerprint matching; and
information linking. The information in the online databases NCIC and NCIC 2000 can
help investigators to associate logically related records across NCIC files for the same
criminal or crime.
REFERENCES: Sources of Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.01 - Identify the sources of information that are available to
investigators.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
57. What are pen registers and how are they useful to investigators?
ANSWER: Pen registers are electronic devices or programs that record all numbers dialed from a
specific phone line. Title 18 of the U.S. Code defines a pen register as “a device or
process, which records or decodes dialing, routing, addressing, or signaling information
transmitted by an instrument or facility from which a wire or electronic communication
is transmitted…”
REFERENCES: Sources of Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.01 - Identify the sources of information that are available to
investigators.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
ANSWER: The interviewer tries to get the interviewee to recall the scene mentally by using simple
mnemonic techniques aimed at encouraging focused retrieval. These techniques
include allowing interviewees to do most of the talking; asking open-ended questions;
allowing ample time for answers; avoiding interruptions; and encouraging the person to
report all details, no matter how trivial.
REFERENCES: The Interview
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.05 - Compare and contrast the approaches used to appeal to
reluctant interviewees.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
59. How are foreign nationals to be treated when under detention or arrest, and why?
ANSWER: Officers who want to interrogate a person claiming diplomatic immunity should request
the diplomatic identification and check the reverse of the card. A general guideline is to
treat foreign nationals and diplomats as you would want Americans to be treated under
similar circumstances abroad.
Partly because of concern that foreign nationals charged with crimes in the United
States will not fully understand their rights within the complex U.S. legal system, the
Vienna Convention Treaty, signed in 1963, gives foreign nationals the right to contact
their consulate in the event of their detention or arrest. Another treaty signed in 1972
provides diplomatic immunity for certain individuals.
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.06 - Explain what the Miranda warning is and when it must be
given.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
ANSWER: Much will depend on the specific age of the juvenile. Strive to build rapport, perhaps
offer a tour of the building, and show the juvenile where his or her parents will be
waiting. In sex crimes, you should establish what words a child uses to refer to the
private parts of the body. Obtain parental permission before questioning a juvenile,
unless the situation warrants immediate questioning at the scene. Parents usually
permit their juveniles to be questioned separately if the purpose is explained and you
have valid reasons for doing so.
REFERENCES: Questioning Children and Juveniles
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
Indirect inquiry draws out information without mentioning the main subject.
A forced response is elicited by asking a question that will implicate the suspect,
regardless of the answer given.
Deflating suspects’ egos is often effective. Question the suspect’s skill in committing a
crime known to be his specialty. The suspect may attempt—out of pride—to prove that
it was a professional job. The same results can be obtained by inflatingsuspects’ egos,
praising the skill shown in pulling off the job. Suspects may want to take the credit and
admit their role in the crime.
Projecting blame onto others is another effective way to get suspects talking. When
suspects feel as if others are at fault, they may be more willing to share information
that will ultimately incriminate them.
Rationalizing is another technique that shifts fault away froma suspect. Even though
the suspect committed the act, there was a good reason to justify it.
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
ANSWER: Third-degree is the use of physical force; the threat of force; or other physical, mental,
or psychological abuse to induce a suspect to confess to a crime. Third-degree tactics,
which are illegal, include striking or hitting a suspect, denying food or water or sleep for
abnormal time periods, not allowing a suspect to go to the restroom, having a number of
officers ask questions in shifts for prolonged periods, and refusing normal privileges.
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
64. Discuss the importance of rapport when interviewing a witness or interrogating a suspect.
ANSWER: Rapport is probably the most critical factor in any interview. Rapport is an
understanding between individuals created by genuine interest and concern. It requires
empathy. The techniques for establishing rapport during an interview also apply in an
interrogation.
REFERENCES: The Interview
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.07 - Describe the various techniques used in an interrogation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
65. How should an investigator evaluate and corroborate information learned in interviews or interrogations?
ANSWER: To cross-check a story, review the report and the details of the offense. Determine the
past record, family status, hobbies, and special interests of those questioned. If a
person has a criminal record, determine his or her prior modus operandi. With such
information, you can ask questions in a way that indicates you know what you are
talking about and that deceptive answers will be found out.
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.08 - Explain what significance a confession has in an investigation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
ANSWER: An admission contains some information concerning the elements of a crime but falls
short of a full confession.
67. Describe the circumstances that must accompany a legally obtained confession.
ANSWER: A confession, oral or handwritten, must be given of the suspect’s free will and not in
response to fear, threats, promises, or rewards. The voluntary nature of the confession
is essential.
REFERENCES: The Interrogation
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.08 - Explain what significance a confession has in an investigation.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
68. Outline the various scientific aids available to law enforcement for obtaining and evaluating information.
ANSWER: Science and technology have provided aids to help determine the reliability of informatio
voice stress analyzer (CVSA), hypnosis, and truth serums.
The polygraph scientifically measures respiration and depth of breathing, as well as cha
and pulse rate. It is important to note, however, that the polygraph is an instrument used
questioning. Although the results are not presently admissible in court, any confession o
Hypnosis and truth serums are supplementary tools to investigation. They are not used
for their use have been determined by thorough review.
REFERENCES: Scientific Aids to Obtaining and Evaluating Information
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.09 - Describe what a polygraph is, its role in investigation, and the a
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
ANSWER: Fusion centers are another effective means to transform information into intelligence
and have been a worthy avenue to implement elements of the National Criminal
Intelligence Sharing Plan ( NCISP).
REFERENCES: Information Versus Intelligence
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.10 - Differentiate between information and intelligence.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
ANSWER: Just as it is crucial to obtain parental permission before questioning a youth, officers
should not use a youth as an informant unless the parents know the situation. However,
regardless of parental permission, it is an unwise decision.
REFERENCES: Questioning Children and Juveniles
LEARNING OBJECTIVES: CRIM.HESS.17.06.10 - Differentiate between information and intelligence.
KEYWORDS: Bloom’s: Apply
Wendell Phillips
The demand for the ballot was such a vast advance upon the
former objects proclaimed by the friends of the colored race, that it
startled and struck men as preposterous and wholly inadmissible.
Anti-slavery men themselves were not united as to the wisdom of
such demand. Mr. Garrison himself, though foremost for the abolition
of slavery, was not yet quite ready to join this advanced movement.
In this respect he was in the rear of Mr. Phillips; who saw not only
the justice, but the wisdom and necessity of the measure. To his
credit it may be said, that he gave the full strength of his character
and eloquence to its adoption. While Mr. Garrison thought it too
much to ask, Mr. Phillips thought it too little. While the one thought it
might be postponed to the future, the other thought it ought to be
done at once. But Mr. Garrison was not a man to lag far in the rear of
truth and right, and he soon came to see with the rest of us that the
ballot was essential to the freedom of the freedman. A man’s head
will not long remain wrong, when his heart is right. The applause
awarded to Mr. Garrison by the conservatives, for his moderation
both in respect of his views on this question, and the disbandment of
the American Anti-Slavery Society must have disturbed him. He was
at any rate soon found on the right side of the suffrage question.
The enfranchisement of the freedmen was resisted on many
grounds, but mainly these two: first the tendency of the measure to
bring the freedmen into conflict with the old master-class, and the
white people of the South generally. Secondly, their unfitness, by
reason of their ignorance, servility, and degradation, to exercise so
great a power as the ballot, over the destinies of this great nation.
These reasons against the measure which were supposed to be
unanswerable, were in some sense the most powerful arguments in
its favor. The argument that the possession of suffrage would be
likely to bring the negro into conflict with the old master-class at the
South, had its main force in the admission that the interests of the
two classes antagonized each other and that the maintenance of the
one would prove inimical to the other. It resolved itself into this, if the
negro had the means of protecting his civil rights, those who had
formerly denied him these rights would be offended and make war
upon him. Experience has shown in a measure the correctness of
this position. The old master was offended to find the negro whom
he lately possessed the right to enslave and flog to toil, casting a
ballot equal to his own, and resorted to all sorts of meanness,
violence, and crime, to dispossess him of the enjoyment of this point
of equality. In this respect the exercise of the right of suffrage by the
negro has been attended with the evil, which the opponents of the
measure predicted, and they could say “I’ve told you so,” but
immeasurably and intolerably greater would have been the evil
consequences resulting from the denial to one class of this natural
means of protection, and granting it to the other, and hostile class. It
would have been, to have committed the lamb to the care of the wolf
—the arming of one class and disarming the other—protecting one
interest, and destroying the other—making the rich strong, and the
poor weak—the white man a tyrant, and the black man a slave. The
very fact therefore that the old master-classes of the South felt that
their interests were opposed to those of the freedmen, instead of
being a reason against their enfranchisement, was the most powerful
one in its favor. Until it shall be safe to leave the lamb in the hold of
the lion, the laborer in the power of the capitalist, the poor in the
hands of the rich, it will not be safe to leave a newly emancipated
people completely in the power of their former masters, especially
when such masters have not ceased to be such from enlightened
moral convictions but by irresistible force. Then on the part of the
Government itself, had it denied this great right to the freedmen, it
would have been another proof that “Republics are ungrateful”. It
would have been rewarding its enemies, and punishing its friends—
embracing its foes, and spurning its allies,—setting a premium on
treason, and degrading loyalty. As to the second point, viz.: the
negro’s ignorance and degradation, there was no disputing either. It
was the nature of slavery from whose depths he had arisen to make
him so, and it would have kept it so. It was the policy of the system
to keep him both ignorant and degraded, the better and more safely
to defraud him of his hard earnings; and this argument never
staggered me. The ballot in the hands of the negro was necessary to
open the door of the school house, and to unlock the treasures of
knowledge to him. Granting all that was said of his ignorance, I used
to say, “if the negro knows enough to fight for his country he knows
enough to vote; if he knows enough to pay taxes for the support of
the government, he knows enough to vote; if he knows as much
when sober, as an Irishman knows when drunk, he knows enough to
vote.”
And now while I am not blind to the evils which have thus far
attended the enfranchisement of the colored people, I hold that the
evils from which we escaped, and the good we have derived from
that act, amply vindicate its wisdom. The evils it brought are in their
nature temporary, and the good is permanent. The one is
comparatively small, the other absolutely great. The young child has
staggered on his little legs, and he has sometimes fallen and hurt his
head in the fall, but then he has learned to walk. The boy in the
water came near drowning, but then he has learned to swim. Great
changes in the relations of mankind can never come, without evils
analogous to those which have attended the emancipation and
enfranchisement of the colored people of the United States. I am
less amazed at these evils, than by the rapidity with which they are
subsiding and not more astonished at the facility with which the
former slave has become a free man, than at the rapid adjustment of
the master-class to the new situation.
Unlike the movement for the abolition of Slavery, the success of
the effort for the enfranchisement of the freedmen was not long
delayed. It is another illustration of how any advance in pursuance of
a right principle, prepares and makes easy the way to another. The
way of transgression is a bottomless pit, one step in that direction
invites the next, and the end is never reached; and it is the same
with the path of righteous obedience. Two hundred years ago, the
pious Doctor Godwin dared affirm that it was “not a sin to baptize a
negro,” and won for him the rite of baptism. It was a small
concession to his manhood; but it was strongly resisted by the
slaveholders of Jamaica, and Virginia. In this they were logical in
their argument, but they were not logical in their object. They saw
plainly that to concede the negro’s right to baptism was to receive
him into the Christian Church, and make him a brother in Christ; and
hence they opposed the first step sternly and bitterly. So long as they
could keep him beyond the circle of human brotherhood, they could
scourge him to toil, as a beast of burden, with a good Christian
conscience, and without reproach. “What!” said they, “baptize a
negro? preposterous!” Nevertheless the negro was baptized and
admitted to church fellowship; and though for a long time his soul
belonged to God, his body to his master, and he poor fellow had
nothing left for himself, he is at last not only baptized, but
emancipated and enfranchised.
In this achievement, an interview with President Andrew
Johnson, on the 7th of February, 1866, by a delegation consisting of
George T. Downing, Lewis H. Douglass, Wm. E. Matthews, John
Jones, John F. Cook, Joseph E. Otis, A. W. Ross, William Whipper,
John M. Brown, Alexander Dunlop, and myself, will take its place in
history as one of the first steps. What was said on that occasion
brought the whole question virtually before the American people.
Until that interview the country was not fully aware of the intentions
and policy of President Johnson on the subject of reconstruction,
especially in respect of the newly emancipated class of the South.
After having heard the brief addresses made to him by Mr. Downing
and myself, he occupied at least three quarters of an hour in what
seemed a set speech, and refused to listen to any reply on our part,
although solicited to grant a few moments for that purpose. Seeing
the advantage that Mr. Johnson would have over us in getting his
speech paraded before the country in the morning papers, the
members of the delegation met on the evening of that day, and
instructed me to prepare a brief reply which should go out to the
country simultaneously with the President’s speech to us. Since this
reply indicates the points of difference between the President and
ourselves, I produce it here as a part of the history of the times, it
being concurred in by all the members of the delegation.
Both the speech and the reply were commented upon very
extensively.
From this time onward, the question of suffrage for the freedmen,
was not allowed to rest. The rapidity with which it gained strength,
was something quite marvelous and surprising even to its advocates.
Senator Charles Sumner soon took up the subject in the Senate and
treated it in his usually able and exhaustive manner. It was a great
treat to listen to his argument running through two days, abounding
as it did in eloquence, learning, and conclusive reasoning. A
committee of the Senate had reported a proposition giving to the
States lately in rebellion in so many words complete option as to the
enfranchisement of their colored citizens: only coupling with that
proposition the condition that, to such States as chose to enfranchise
such citizens, the basis of their representation in Congress should be
proportionately increased; or, in other words, only three-fifths of the
colored citizens should be counted in the basis of representation in
States where colored citizens were not allowed to vote, while in the
States granting suffrage to colored citizens, the entire colored people
should be counted in the basis of representation. Against this
proposition, myself and associates addressed to the Senate of the
United States the following memorial: