Activity # 4 (Performance Task 3)
Name: Patidio, John Raven, D.
Date/ Week No. 2/19/2024
DIRECTIONS: Search for an article (2020 - Present) that is related to your strand and evaluate the information using the
table below.
Title of the Article: Students’ perspectives on the ‘STEM belonging’ concept at A-level, undergraduate,
and postgraduate levels: an examination of gender and ethnicity in student
descriptions
(Link Address:) https://rdcu.be/dyXVq
Accuracy
● Is the content of the article
grammatically correct and
comprehensible / grammatically
correct but not comprehensible /
incorrect grammar but comprehensible
/ incorrect grammar and not
comprehensible? Justify your answer
Author
● Is the author and publisher
information included and visible in the
article?
Currency
● Is the content of the article current and
updated frequently?
Fairness
● Is the content of the article balanced,
presenting all sides of an issue and
multiple points of view? Justify your
answer
Relevance
● Is the content of the article relevant to
your topic? Justify your answer
Strand and Section: STEM 11 L-JEREMIAH
Score: _________/25_______________
Answer:
There are no apparent grammatical errors or language issues that
hinder understanding. The ideas presented transition smoothly,
allowing for a comprehensive understanding of the topic
discussed. Therefore, based on the clarity of expression and
logical flow of ideas, it can be concluded that the content is
grammatically correct and comprehensible.
Answer: Yes, the author information is provided in the article.
Author:The author is Gulsah Dost, affiliated with the School of
Education at Durham University in Durham, UK. Additionally, the
corresponding author for correspondence is also Gulsah Dost.
Publisher: The publisher information is not explicitly stated.
Answer: Yes
Date Published:
Received Accepted Published
17 July 2023 01 February 2024 16 February 2024
Answer:
The article appears to focus on exploring various aspects of
STEM belonging from different perspectives, including those
of students from diverse backgrounds. It presents findings
and observations from the study without explicitly indicating
a bias towards a particular viewpoint.
Answer:
The content is highly relevant to the topic of STEM belonging,
as it discusses different phases and themes associated with
individuals' sense of belonging in STEM fields. It explores
various factors, including social interactions, support
networks, and the impact of stereotypes, which are crucial
considerations in understanding STEM participation and
retention.
Overall, while the provided excerpt is grammatically correct
and comprehensible, it lacks information about the author
 and publisher, publication date, and may not present a fully
balanced perspective without access to the complete article.
However, it is highly relevant to the topic of STEM belonging
and provides valuable insights into this area of research.

Rubric:
Excellent (10 pts.) Average (7 pts.) Below Average (4 pts.)
Area of Focus Points
High Achieving Moderate Achieving Poor
A complete response with Good solid response with
Explanation Explanation is unclear.
a detailed explanation. clear explanation.
Shows complete Shows substantial Response shows some
Knowledge understanding of the understanding of the understanding of the
question. question. question.
Goes beyond the Hardly meets the
Meets the requirements
Content requirements of the requirements of the
of the question.
question. question.
Total