You are on page 1of 4

SM

TECHNIFAX Boiler Blowdown…


Good Control Means Savings

TF-10
Proper control of blowdown is a REGULATING
critical part of boiler operation. BLOWDOWN
Insufficient blowdown may lead
to deposits or carryover, while Once specific limits for boiler
excessive blowdown will waste water solids have been set, a
water, heat, and chemicals. practical way is needed to
control solids level on a day-to-
PRINCIPLES OF day basis. Blowdown adjust-
BLOWDOWN ment can be based on simple
boiler water tests; the most
All boiler feedwaters contain common are described below:
some solid impurities. When the
feedwater is evaporated in a Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) -—
boiler, steam is formed from the Measurement of the specific
water, leaving the solids behind. conductance of a neutralized
As a result, the solids gradually sample of boiler water will
build up in the boiler water. To provide a quick, accurate deter-
Figure 1 — Example showing how mination of dissolved solids
control these solids, boiler water boiler water solids are held in check by
is blown down (discharged) and blowdown
level. Control of blowdown can,
replaced with lower solids therefore, be based on µmhos of
feedwater. In effect, blowdown is conductivity. While excessive
related to operating pressure
simply a process of diluting total dissolved solids can occa-
(Table 1). These suggestions
boiler water solids. sionally contribute to scale, they
apply for both steam purity and
most often will cause foaming
To keep the solids from building deposition control.
and carryover.
to unacceptable levels, the The ASME limits are a good
amount of solids removed by Silica — Silica can be used to
starting point in establishing
blowdown must equal the determine blowdown require-
blowdown needs. Operating
amount brought in with the ments of boiler waters where its
experience with a particular
feedwater, as illustrated in concentration is limited due to
boiler then determines whether
Figure 1. The quantity of the potential for selective silica
or not it is practical to deviate
blowdown depends on both the carryover or, under special
from these limits.
amount of feedwater solids and conditions, silica scale. This is
the level of solids that can be A steam purity study will help common practice in boiler
tolerated in a particular boiler. define the limits to minimize systems operating above 900 psi
solids carryover. It can also assist with turbines.
CONTROL LIMITS FOR in determining the maximum
Chlorides — Blowdown can be
solids that can be carried to
BOILER BLOWDOWN effectively controlled by check-
maintain minimum blowdown
ing the concentration of chlo-
The American Society of Me- and maximum energy conserva-
rides in the boiler water. Since
chanical Engineers (ASME) has tion. A steam purity study can
chloride salts are soluble and not
developed a “consensus” on pay for itself very quickly by
usually precipitated in the
operating practices for boiler minimizing blowdown energy
boiler, control based on chlo-
feedwater and blowdown that is losses.
rides is accurate. (This method is

NALCO CHEMICAL COMPANY ONE NALCO CENTER NAPERVILLE, ILLINOIS 60563-1198


SUBSIDIARIES AND AFFILIATES IN PRINCIPAL LOCATIONS AROUND THE WORLD

Registered Trademarks of Nalco Chemical Company ©1995 Nalco Chemical Company


All Rights Reserved Printed in U.S.A. 11-95
Table 1— Water-quality suggestions for reliable, continuous operation of modern The second equation shows that
watertube boilers with superheat, turbines, or process restrictions on steam purity. percent blowdown increases as
Boiler Feedwater Limits Boiler Water Limits (a) feedwater solids increase and
Operating Total Hydrate Specific2 (b) boiler water solids decrease.
Pressure Iron Copper Hardness Silica Alkalinity1 Conductance
(psig) (ppm Fe) (ppm Cu) (ppm CaCO3) (ppm SiO2) (ppm CaCO3) (TDS) Figure 2 graphically illustrates
0 - 300 0.100 0.050 0.300 150 350 3500 these points.
301 - 450 0.050 0.025 0.300 90 300 3000
451 - 600 0.030 0.020 0.200 40 250 2500
601 - 750 0.025 0.020 0.200 30 200 2000
751 - 900 0.020 0.015 0.100 20 150 1500
901 - 1000 0.020 0.015 0.050 8 100 1000
1001 - 1500 0.010 0.010 0.0 2 03 150
1501 - 2000 0.010 0.010 0.0 1 03 100
1
Minimum level of hydroxide alkalinity in boilers below 900 psig must be individually specified with regard
to silica solubility and other components of internal treatment.
2
The maximum value often cannot be obtained without exceeding total alkalinity levels because of
pretreatment. Actual permissible conductance values to achieve desired steam purity must be estab-
lished by careful steam purity measurements.
3
Zero in these cases refers to free sodium or potassium hydroxide alkalinity. Some small variable amount
of total alkalinity will be present and measurable with the assumed congruent control or volatile treatment
employed at these high pressure ranges.
Source: ASME Research Committee on Water in Thermal Power Systems

Figure 2 — Blowdown needs increase


as feedwater solids increase
not suitable for boilers having water), the valve is opened and
low chloride feed-waters.) It is boiler water discharged. The
important that no variation in continual monitoring of solids in CONTINUOUS (OR
boiler feedwater chloride con- the boiler water allows the maxi- AUTOMATIC) vs MANUAL
centration occur due to zeolite mum solids level to be carried at BLOWDOWN
regenerations or condensate all times. Therefore, a minimum
There are two basic methods for
return swings to maintain a amount of heat, water, and
blowing down a boiler. The first
fixed control target. chemicals is lost, resulting in
is continuous or automatic
TRASAR® — Nalco’s TRASAR greater energy efficiency and
blowdown, which is generally
Technology can be used to maximum plant production.
favored because it yields a more
measure boiler cycles directly, as uniform concentration of boiler
well as to diagnose control valve HOW MUCH BLOWDOWN water solids and can save energy
problems and measure other IS NEEDED by allowing for heat recovery
critical control parameters. Blowdown is frequently ex- from the blowdown water.
Alkalinity — Blowdown control pressed in percentages. It can be Figure 3 illustrates that continu-
by alkalinity is most often used calculated as follows: ous blowdown not only provides
when very high alkalinities, % Blowdown = a more consistent solids level,
which may contribute to carry- but that the maximum concentra-
over, are present. Quantity of Blowdown Water tion of solids in the boiler water
x 100
Quantity of Feedwater is also the average. This helps
Automatic blowdown control-
ensure that the boiler is operat-
lers can also be used to regulate OR
ing at the maximum allowable
blowdown. In these systems, the
% Blowdown = boiler cycles (minimum percent
blowdown valve is controlled by
TDS (µmhos) in Feedwater blowdown), thus saving energy,
a probe that measures the
x 100 makeup water costs, and chemi-
specific conductance of the TDS (µmhos) in Boiler Water cal treatment costs.
boiler water. When the conduc-
tivity reaches a preset limit
(determined by the correspond-
ing solids level of the boiler
A — Average concentration -
continuous blowdown
B — Average concentration -
intermittent blowdown

C — Highest concentration
just before blowdown

D — Lowest concentration
just after blowdown

Figure 3 — Advantages of continuous Makeup


blowdown

Figure 4 — Blowdown heat recovery system


The second method for blowing
down a boiler, manual or inter- ous or automatic blowdown will A typical heat recovery system
mittent, consists of periodically be used to deconcentrate total will incorporate at least one flash
opening the main blowoff valve. solids; manual blowdown will tank and heat exchanger (Figure
This valve is generally located in re- move suspended solids that 4). The pressure of the flash tank
the lower section of the boiler have settled in the lower areas of is determined by the end use of
(i.e., mud drum) where sludge is the boiler. the steam. It may be used as
most likely to collect. While this process steam, building heat or
method is a very efficient way to Continuous blowdown installa-
for heating oil, makeup water, or
remove accumulated sludge tions usually consist of perfo-
feedwater. The blowdown from
from lower portions of the boiler, rated distribution piping a
the flash tank can be flashed
it is not the best method for minimum of four inches below
again for increased energy
controlling total boiler water the steam release surface. The
savings if there is a use for that
solids. blowdown pipe is located in the
steam. Finally, the blowdown
steam drum near the discharge
As Figure 3 illustrates, the from the flash tank is passed
of the generating tubes and away
average boiler solids concentra- through a heat exchanger to
from the feedwater inlet.
tion with intermittent blowdown recover the sensible heat of the
is much less than the maximum water before going to sewer.
MINIMIZING BLOWDOWN
allowable concentration. This Ideally, the sewered water will
HEAT LOSSES be 20°F above the inlet tempera-
results in lower boiler cycle
(higher percent blowdown), As previously stated, the greatest ture of the water to be heated
wasting energy, and increasing advantage of continuous blow- (i.e. makeup water).
makeup water and chemical down is the potential for energy Additional methods for minimiz-
treatment costs. savings by recovering heat from ing blowdown heat losses
the blowdown before it is include increasing the percent of
The most efficient method for
sewered. The type of heat condensate returned to the boiler
keeping dissolved and sus-
recovery system required is and selecting proper chemical
pended solids from accumulat-
dependent on boiler drum treatments such as antifoams,
ing in the boiler will incorporate
pressure, quantity of blowdown, low solids oxygen scavengers
both continuous and manual
and how the recovered heat will and internal treatment programs.
blowdown. In this way, continu-
be used.
These methods will improve Table 2 — Calculating cost of sewering blowdown and amount of heat recoverable
feedwater quality (lower solids). from blowdown
This permits operation at higher
boiler cycles without Required Information
“carryover”, thus reducing
Boiler operating pressure (psia)
blowdown requirements. Steam production (lb/day)
Concentration ratio
CALCULATING Makeup water temp (°F)
Flash tank operating pressure (psia)
RECOVERABLE HEAT Heat exchanger effluent temp (°F)
FROM BLOWDOWN Fuel cost ($/million Btu)
Boiler efficiency (%)
The cost of sewering blowdown,
Cost of Sewering Blowdown
without recovering its heat, and
the amount of heat recoverable 100
1. % blowdown =
from boiler blowdown can be concentration ratio
calculated from some basic
steam production
information. The information 2. lb feedwater = = lb/day
1.00 – % blowdown
required and the calculations are
shown in Table 2. 3. lb blowdown = lb feedwater – lb steam produced

4. heat of blowdown = HSLB-HMW= Btu/Ib


CONCLUSION
5. heat loss without recovery = lb blowdown x heat of blowdown
Blowdown is a crucial part of
good boiler operation. It main- heat loss x fuel cost
6. dollars lost =
tains boiler water solids at an boiler efficiency
acceptable limit to prevent
Recovering Heat from Blowdown
carryover or deposits. However,
excessive amounts of blowdown HSLB-HSLF
can result in wasted fuel, water, 7. lb flashed steam = (lb blowdown) ( VFT )
and treatment chemicals. Proper
control of blowdown by the lb flashed steam
operator is imperative for eco- 8. % blowdown flashed = x 100
lb blowdown
nomical, trouble-free boiler
operation, and maximum plant 9. % blowdown to heat exchanger = 100 – % blowdown flashed
production.
10. lb water to heat exchanger = lb blowdown x % blowdown to heat exchanger
11. heat sewered = HHE-HMW = Btu/lb
12. total heat lost with recovery = heat sewered x lb water to heat exchanger

13. heat recovered = heat loss without recovery - total heat lost with recovery

heat recovered
14. % heat recovery = x 100
heat lost without recovery

NOTES: (refer to Figure 4)


HSLB = enthalpy of saturated liquid at boiler pressure
HMW = enthalpy of makeup water
HSLF = enthalpy of saturated liquid at flash tank pressure
HHE = enthalpy of heat exchanger effluent
VFT = latent heat of vaporization at flash tank pressure

You might also like