Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2
3
4
5
Fig. 1. Location of dysplastic and accessory
thyroid tissue. Dysplastic and accessory
thyroid tissue can be separated according
to its structure, cystic (wave-filled circles) 6
or solid (grey circles), and to its location,
which is presented in a left view (left) and
in a front view (right) of the neck. 1 = Lin-
gual thyroid; 2 = suprahyoidal ectopic tis-
pothyroidism is poorly estimated and varies widely with caecum, to the mediastinum. The caudal end of the thy-
environmental factors. roglossal duct proliferates laterally to form a bilobated
Thyrotoxicosis is mainly due to Graves’ disease, but gland by E30. This apparent descent and lateral expan-
there may be some specific non-autoimmune aetiologies sion of the organ may merely result from relocalization of
in young patients. the thyroid relative to the heart development and to hor-
This article reviews medical practices and presents in- izontal stretching by the cervical structures. The thyro-
formative imaging contributions to the diagnosis of most glossal duct will finally partly fragment and degenerate
paediatric thyroid dysfunctions. Source data come from (E40) and is often visible in adults by thyroid scanning in
Medline, endocrinology textbooks and imaging guide- an upper and median location in the neck or as a pyrami-
lines. Thyroid imaging is of little interest in central hy- dal lobe. In the new gland, thyroid cells will differentiate
pothyroidism and will not be discussed here. towards thyroid hormone synthesis which is detectable
from gestational week 11 [9].
These phases of thyroid organogenesis explain the
Morphofunctional Development of Thyroid and possible locations of ectopic or accessory thyroid tissue,
Consequences for Imaging depicted and readily classified by imaging (fig. 1).
Dysgenesis (1:4,500)
Ectopia focal N, S +/– focal, hyperE relatively frequent
Athyreosis Ab Ab uw absent tissue possible FN with US
Hypoplasia faint, diffuse N, S uw reduced volume possible FP with US
Hemiagenesis single lobe N uw single lobe absent left lobe 80%
Thyroglossal duct cysts Ab Ab uw cystic prefer US
Pyramidal lobe, thyroid rests focal N uw focal possible FN with US
Dyshormonogenesis (1:30,000)
Defective R-TSH faint or Ab N, S uw volume S hypoplasia, 123I>99mTc
NIS defects faint or Ab Ab, S uw goitre no 123I stomach uptake
TPO mutations diffuse goitre A C>P goitre relatively frequent
THOX mutations diffuse goitre A P/C goitre rare
Up = Uptake; PDS = perchlorate discharge test: the wash out (wo) of 123I may be partial (P, wo: 10–50%) or complete (C, wo >50%);
N = normal; hyperE = hyperechoic ultrasound pattern; Ab = absent; uw = unwanted test; FN = false-negative result; US = ultrasound;
FP = false-positive result; Var. = variable; hypoE = hypoechoic ultrasound pattern; DEHAL = iodothyrosine dehalogenase.
a
Abnormality in Tg pinocytosis or hydrolization.
b Imaging varies widely in thyroiditis according to the aetiology (see also table 4) and the evolution of the disease which is often
topic selection. Most authors consider hypoplastic glands significantly differs depending on the pharmaceutical
as dysplastic though they are correctly located in the product used. With 99mTc, more patients are wrongly
neck. Hypoplastic glands in permanent CH account for overclassified as athyrotic due to the lack of sensitivity of
about 15% of normally located glands. Some ectopic the 99mTc thyroid scintigraphy (TS). Ectopic glands can
glands also present with organification defects but are be identified by both isotopes, but in cases where the ec-
usually classified in the dysplastic group [16]. The eutop- topic tissue is close to the mouth, it can be masked or ob-
ic group includes patients with transient hypothyroidism scured by oral activity, using 99mTcO4. Finally, eutopic
(130%) in an apparently normal gland or permanent hy- tissue and dyshormonogenetic goitres are best identified
pothyroidism, with or without goitre. Most of the latter with 123I which further indicates where the molecular de-
patients have dyshormonogenetic goitres of which 30– fect takes place. However, in centres where 123I is not rou-
50% have a positive perchlorate discharge test. tinely available, 99mTCO4 can nevertheless effectively
Based on the present review and on studies which spe- identify most patients with thyroid aplasia and eutopic
cifically compared isotopes, 123I appears slightly more goitres and identify a large proportion of patients with
advisable than 99mTc in CH [17–19]. Indeed, the overall ectopy.
proportion of patients with eutopic or dysplastic glands
Imaging of Dysplastic Thyroid Tissue sified as lingual thyroid, which may sometimes be visible
TD includes a spectrum of embryogenic defects such or palpable [24], or as tissue in a suprahyoid, hyoid or in-
as athyrosis, hypoplasia, hemiagenesis, ectopic thyroid frahyoid location. The incidence of double ectopic thy-
gland and thyroglossal duct cysts. A genetic origin for TD roid is about 5%. TS indicates in addition whether nor-
is suspected though the molecular defects have only been mally functioning tissue is present or not in the normal
identified in a few patients. Three main genes involved in cervical location. Indeed, ectopic glands are functional
the thyroid development and in the transcriptional con- and their inadvertent surgical removal, if it is misdiag-
trol of the genes encoding the thyroid-specific proteins nosed as a thyroglossal duct cyst, results in iatrogenic hy-
have been identified: the thyroid transcription factors pothyroidism.
TTF1 and TTF2, and Pax 8 [20]. These genes are fre- It is widely accepted that CDU is slightly less sensitive
quently involved in different complex syndromes includ- than TS in children with CH [25]. The agreement be-
ing CH due to TD [21]. On the other hand, homozygous tween the two methods was 0.87 in one recent study [26],
or compound heterozygous inactivating mutations in the though large variations are reported in the literature,
R-TSH have been observed in patients with non-syn- probably because the reproducibility of CDU strongly de-
dromic CH due to thyroid hypoplasia and various de- pends on the physician’s experience and on the genera-
grees of TSH unresponsiveness. Finally, TD is likely to be tion of the apparatus used. For instance, it has been shown
a polygenic and multifactorial disease for which novel that grey-scaled ultrasound are 20% less sensitive than
genes need to be identified [22]. CDU in detecting ectopic tissue [27]. CDU generally suc-
ceeds in determining whether the thyroid is eutopic or
Ectopic Tissue dysplastic, but regularly fails to distinguish athyrotic
123
I TS is the gold standard method for assessing the glands from ectopic ones. Finally, in the literature, rou-
diagnosis of ectopic thyroid tissue [23], the most frequent tine CDU has a wide range of sensitivity (range: 0–90%)
aetiology for dysplasia (fig. 2). Ectopic tissue can be clas- in the detection of ectopic thyroid tissue, though higher
Fig. 2. Scintigraphic imaging of dysplastic thyroid tissue (123I) (frontal view). a Median solitary lingual ectopia;
note the faint uptake of the salivary gland and the low activity of the mouth due to the use of 123I. b Double ec-
topic thyroid with no activity in normal location; the upper is suprahyoidal while the lower is prehyoidal.
c Agenesis of the left lobe. d Absence of contrast in the neck in a baby with athyrosis. Note that the gastric 123I
image is positive (e), excluding an NIS defect; in addition, no significant activity is visible in the mouth using
intravenous 123I.
2 Na+
I– 2 Na+
I–
N
Type 3
DEHAL
MIT
DIT
Protease
I– Type 2
Pendrin
DEHAL THOX2
H 2O 2
P
MIT
AIT
Thyroglobulin
DIT
P I–
TPO
Fig. 3. Scintigraphic-based classification of thyroid DHG. Type 1 tion defects are most often due to a mutation in the TPO gene.
(impaired function at the basal membrane) defects are character- Partial defects occur in minor TPO abnormalities and in Pendred
ized by low to blunted contrast despite high TSH plasma levels. syndrome (abnormal pendrin). In rare cases, the peroxide gen-
Late 123I images are more often positive than 99mTc images. Defec- erator is involved due to a mutation in the THOX gene. Type 3
tive R-TSH is often associated with thyroid hypoplasia or reflects defects (postorganification defects) include a goitre with pre-
a transient blockade of the thyrotropin receptor by maternal au- served uptake and a normal organification process (negative per-
toantibodies. Defective or abnormal NIS yields no uptake either chlorate discharge test). Indeed, iodide which has entered the or-
at the thyroid and stomach level. Type 2 defects (impaired func- ganification process cannot be chemically displaced by perchlo-
tion at the apical membrane) are responsible for a reduced iodide rate. Mutations in the Tg gene are relatively frequent compared to
organification. Both scintigraphic contrast and uptake are high other abnormalities such as defective pinocytic resorption of the
and rise quickly in an enlarged thyroid. The perchlorate discharge Tg. Finally, DEHAL1 produce a secondary iodine-deficient state
test is positive with a washout value 110% (150%) in partial (com- due to excessive renal losses of iodine in the form of MIT and
plete) organification defect, respectively. Complete organifica- DIT.
contrast in defective NIS babies provided the isotope has trous eutopic thyroid gland with low thyroidal 123I uptake
been previously injected. Finally, the 123I measurement of is evidenced in the absence of thyroid autoantibodies
the salivary-to-plasma ratio activity is decreased (S/P !1, [39]. Due to the lower signal-to-noise ratio observed with
99m
normal values: S/P 110), while plasmatic Tg levels are Tc, the 99mTc TS may indicate a false-negative result of
usually normal or even high [38]. athyrosis [40]. The TSH, when tested in vitro, has a nor-
mal bioactivity. The biochemical phenotype includes a
Defective R-TSH moderate to high rise in the plasma TSH levels, normal
Diagnosis of TSH unresponsiveness in babies with CH to blunted thyroid hormone levels and detectable Tg lev-
is suspected by imaging when a hypoplastic or non-goi- els. When the gland is orthotopic, a partial resistance to
TSH or euthyroid hyperthyrotopinaemia [41] must be Efflux of iodide at the apical membrane of thyroid fol-
suspected especially when both the thyroxine levels and licular cells is mediated by pendrin and marginally by
the 123I uptake are normal. hAIT, a recently identified apical iodine transporter. Mu-
tations in the pendrin gene [44] cause Pendred’s syn-
Organification Defects drome, clinically defined by the association of goitre,
Transport of iodide towards the apical membrane fol- partial or complete inability to organify iodine and sen-
lows the electrochemical gradient and is a rapid phenom- sorineural deafness. An additional advantage for check-
enon for which no abnormality has yet been evidenced. ing neonates and infants with goitres using 123I TS is that
Iodination of tyrosine residues and further coupling of many Pendred patients do not present with CH and that
iodinated tyrosines to generate thyroxine and/or triiodo- the development of hypothyroidism is far from being sys-
thyronine depend on the critical glycosylated enzyme tematic, especially in iodine-replete areas.
thyroperoxidase (TPO). A mutation in the TPO gene is
the most frequent molecular abnormality (170%) causing Dyshormonogenetic Eutopic Glands with Normal
a partial or total organification defect [42]. In the latter, Organification
an inactivation mutation of the TPO gene is almost al- When goitre is present and if the TS is well contrasted
ways present. A few patients with goitre, reduced iodine and insensitive to perchlorate administration, the func-
organification and eu- or hypothyroidism, have defective tional integrity of R-TSH, NIS, TPO, THOX and Pendrin
H2O2 generation and mutations in the NADPH oxidase proteins can be assumed. The following abnormalities
gene encoding THOX2 [43]. may finally be taken into consideration: (1) reduced or
Any pathological process which affects iodide efflux, abnormal Tg synthesis [45], which is the most frequent
or iodination and coupling of iodide onto the tyrosyl res- cause [35], (2) impaired colloidal resorption or Tg prote-
idues of the Tg can be scintigraphically characterized by olysis [46], and (3) reduced deiodination process of the
a strong early TSH-related uptake, followed by a quantifi- iodotyrosines MIT and DIT involving disorders of the
able fall in previously taken up 123I after perchlorate ad- DEHAL1 system [12]. In this latter the iodine uptake and
ministration. Indeed, once organified, 123I is insensitive turnover are further stimulated by a secondary iodine-
to perchlorate which only acts as an extracellular selec- deficient state due to excessive renal losses of iode in the
tive inhibitor for de novo isotopic uptake at the NIS form of MIT and DIT. A reliable ‘deiodination’ test had
level. been used by injecting labelled DIT (123I/125I/131I) to fur-
Congenital Graves’ disease diffuse, homoG M ++ hypervascular goitre transient – US as 1st line
Acquired Graves’ disease diffuse, homoG M ++ hypervascular goitre rare <10 years, TSI ++
Mixed Graves’-Hashimoto diffuse, heteroG M+ idem, hypoechoic rare <10 years, TSI +
Iatrogenic (thyroxine) unnecessary unnecessary reduce T4 dosage
Familial toxic hyperplasia diffuse, homoG M hypervascular goitre germline mut. RTSH
McCune-Albright syndrome multifocally M M hypervascular goitre mut. GS␣
Mono (multi)-focal autonomy mono/multifocally M nodular vascularization mut. RTSH (acquired)
Thyroiditis (all types)a low to 0 m hypoechoic transient
homoG = Homogeneous pattern; US = ultrasound; TSI = thyroid-stimulating immunoglobulins; heteroG = heterogeneous; mut.
RTSH = gain of function mutation of the TSH receptor.
a
Aetiology for thyroiditis includes subacute (viral related), iodine-induced, postirradiation (X, gamma or electronic), immuno-
Imaging of Permanent and Acquired Thyrotoxicosis nodules (R-TSH mutation), which are uncommon before
After the age of 10 years, thyrotoxicosis is generally the age of 10 years.
due to Graves’ disease or to forms related to Hashimoto’s In conclusion, imaging of thyroid dysfunction in neo-
strumitis, the latter giving a diffuse though heteroge- nates and babies is very safe and clinically relevant. Both
neous pattern of uptake (fig. 5) with intermediate 123I up- thyroid scan and CDU are useful and complementary, as
take values (15–25%), as in adults. The other various in adults and for many authors combined imaging ap-
causes can also be encountered at this age and have no pears more informative than single scanning. A precise
special imaging features as compared to adults (table 4). knowledge of the underlying disease may help to manage
Resistance to thyroid hormone must be taken into the therapy and optimize genetic counselling. Permanent
consideration when the neonatal screening shows mildly hypothyroidism is mainly due to thyroid ectopia, hypo-
persistent increased TSH levels or later when elevated free plasia and less frequently DHG. Transient hypothyroid-
hormones are measured in the presence of a non-sup- ism is probably underdiagnosed and its identification is
pressed TSH. This rare disease has a widely variable phe- warranted since it permits the discontinuation of lT4
notypic expression which can include a goitre and mild therapy. Though 99mTcO4 often provides a correct diag-
thyrotoxicosis. The thyroid gland is inappropriately over- nosis, most recent publications show that 123I TS is the
stimulated by the TSH and the thyroid scan mimics best nuclear medicine procedure. Indeed, the use of 123I
Graves’ disease though the biochemical context excludes yields a higher accuracy for the detection of ectopic glands
any autoimmune origin. and has a higher detection rate for eutopic glands, for
The differential diagnosis in babies with persistent which transient hypothyroidism is relatively frequent.
non-autoimmune thyrotoxicosis is the rare germline-ac- CDU is increasingly used but demands a skilled physi-
tivating mutation of the TSH receptor [53] and nodular cian to guarantee a good imaging quality. It is especially
thyrotoxicosis of the McCune-Albright syndrome (fig. 6). useful in normally located glands and may reveal addi-
A diffuse homogeneous uptake and an enlarged gland tional information regarding the anatomy of the gland,
were reported on a 99mTc TS of a boy with familial toxic its vascularization and the presence of nodules. Imaging
diffuse hyperplasia [54]. Though in Graves’ disease typi- patterns of autoimmune thyrotoxicosis are very similar
cally high early 123I uptake is expected (15–50%), lower to those observed in adults. CDU is the procedure of
values are suggestive of autonomy (5–15%). This is the choice in imaging neonatal thyrotoxicosis. Nodular thy-
case in the McCune-Albright syndrome (Gs␣ mutation), rotoxicosis should be imaged by a 123I TS and may be sug-
where diffuse or multifocal autonomy is typically imaged gestive of a McCune-Albright syndrome in younger pa-
by the 123I TS. The nodules share the same hypervascu- tients.
larized pattern as in classic autonomously functioning
1 Connelly JF, Coakley JC, Gold H, Francis I, 15 Pusuwan P, Likitmaskul S, Wacharasindhu 28 Takashima S, Nomura N, Tanaka H, Itoh Y,
Mathur KS, Rickards AL, Price GJ, Halliday S, Intarasupht S, Attanatho V, Mungkharak Miki K, Harada T: Congenital hypothyroid-
JL, Wolfe R: Newborn screening for congen- J, Chiewvit S, Pleehachinda R: Thyroid scin- ism: assessment with ultrasound. AJNR Am
ital hypothyroidism, Victoria, Australia, tigraphy in children with hypothyroidism: a J Neuroradiol Roentgenol 1995; 16: 1117–
1977–1997. Part 1. The screening pro- five-year experience. J Med Assoc Thai 1998; 1123.
gramme, demography, baseline perinatal 81:596–601. 29 Niu DM, Chao T, Tiu CM, Chou YH, Chu
data and diagnostic classification. J Pediatr 16 el-Desouki M, al-Jurayyan N, al-Nuaim A, YK, Hwang B: Comparison of radioisotopic
Endocrinol Metab 2001;14:1597–1610. al-Herbish A, Abo-Bakr A, al-Mazrou Y, al- and ultrasonic scanning in the evaluation of
2 La Franchi S: Congenital hypothyroidism: Swailem A: Thyroid scintigraphy and per- neonatal hypothyroidism. Zhonghua Yi Xue
etiologies, diagnosis and management. Thy- chlorate discharge test in the diagnosis of Za Zhi (Taipei) 1995;56:345–350.
roid 1999;9:735–740. congenital hypothyroidism. Eur J Nucl Med 30 Perry RJ, Maroo S, Maclennan AC, Jones JH,
3 Gaudino R, Garel C, Czernichow P, Leger J: 1995;22:1005–1008. Donaldson MD: Combined ultrasound and
Proportion of various types of thyroid disor- 17 Panoutsopoulos G, Mengreli C, Ilias I, Bat- isotope scanning is more informative in the
ders among newborns with congenital hypo- sakis C, Christakopoulou I: Scintigraphic diagnosis of congenital hypothyroidism
thyroidism and normally located gland: a re- evaluation of primary congenital hypothy- than simple scanning. Arch Dis Child 2006;
gional cohort study. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf) roidism: results of the Greek screening pro- 91:972–997.
2005;62:444–448. gram. Eur J Nucl Med 2001;28:529–533. 31 Meller J, Zappel H, Conrad M, Roth C, Em-
4 Rovet JF: Congenital hypothyroidism: long- 18 Shapiro B, Britton K, Fountos A, Granowska rich D, Becker W: 123I-scintigraphy and per-