Response to the comments of the reviewers

To reviewer-1: Thank you for accepting and providing an overall rating for the article. I will carefully
consider your suggestions for future research endeavors. Best regards.

To reviewer-2: Thank you for your accepting and providing overall rating to the article. Best regards.

To reviewer-3: Thank you for your valuable feedback. I have incorporated your comments into the
article, indicated by highlighted sections in yellow. Below, you'll find a summary of the changes made
based on your suggestions. I trust that these revisions address your concerns and enhance the quality
of the paper. Best regards.

Actions acc. to comment-1:

 Table-1, table-2 were re-organized to focus on the specific data. However, their original
versions are presented based on your suggestion.
 Table-3 is deleted based on your suggestion since there is no such original table. It was formed
considering text information from literature.
 The reference for Fig. 4. is related to the literature.
 The original figure is put in Fig. 10 based on your suggestion.
 The reference for Fig. 11. is related to the literature.
 The reference for Fig. 12. is related to the literature.

Actions acc. to comment-2:

English editing is improved by modifying the sections such as abstract, introduction, and
conclusion. Additionally, almost all paragraphs in Section 2 are reconstructed and improved in English
editing. All related modifications are highlighted in yellow.

Actions acc. to comment-3:

Introduction is re-written to emphasize its originality explicitly. It is highlighted yellow in the

revised version of the article. The sentences below are included to state that the study offers
new and unique perspectives on the complex details of ECS design, particularly concerning its
role in protecting against NBC threats in military aviation. It emphasizes the originality and
depth of the study's contributions to the field.

 “This paper presents a departure from conventional literature by offering a

comprehensive review that explicitly addresses the specialized requirements of ECS
systems for NBC protection, a topic that has garnered relatively limited attention in
existing studies.”
 “(4) the promising ECS configuration for the lowest risk of the contamination with NBC
agents.”
 “Through a systematic review, this paper not only synthesizes existing knowledge but
also breaks new ground by providing original insights into the intricacies of ECS design
as it pertains to NBC protection in military aviation.”

Actions acc. to comment-4:

The conclusion has been enhanced for improved clarity and coherence in this version.
Additionally, suggestions for highlighting future research opportunities inspired by the study's
findings have been incorporated. These recommendations are also highlighted in yellow within
the article.