Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Francis Adams
The Right to Food
Francis Adams
© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer
Nature Switzerland AG 2021
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are solely and exclusively licensed by the
Publisher, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights
of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on
microfilms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information storage and
retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology
now known or hereafter developed.
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc.
in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such
names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for
general use.
The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and informa-
tion in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither
the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, expressed or implied, with
respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been
made. The publisher remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps
and institutional affiliations.
This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature
Switzerland AG
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
To my beloved boys, Jayden and Adryan
Preface
vii
viii PREFACE
1 Introduction 1
3 Latin America 53
4 Africa 79
6 Asia 125
7 Conclusion 149
Bibliography 165
Index 189
ix
Acronyms
xi
xii ACRONYMS
Introduction
Economic Causes
Poverty is the primary cause of chronic hunger and malnutrition most
everywhere in the world. While food might be available in local markets,
it is often beyond the reach of the poorest households.30 In fact, hunger
and malnutrition frequently exist within the context of food surpluses.
Not only do the poor struggle to purchase sufficient food, but they
rarely have the land, water, seeds, tools, technology, and other resources
needed to grow food for themselves and their families. The food that is
consumed is generally of lower quality and lacks the vitamins, minerals,
and other micronutrients needed to maintain good health. Because
poor communities spend a larger portion of their income on food than
wealthy communities, price increases have a more adverse and destabi-
lizing impact. Poverty and hunger are mutually reinforcing outcomes:
poverty causes hunger by depriving people of the means to buy or
produce sufficient food while hunger causes poverty by limiting the ability
of people to work to their fullest potential.31
Food insecurity is almost always higher in the countryside than in
cities.32 On average, people living in rural areas are almost three times
more likely to be impoverished than those living in urban environ-
ments. The rural poor also have less access to safe water, sanitation,
health care, and other critical public services. Seventy-five percent of the
world’s poor live in rural areas and obtain part or all of their income
from some form of agriculture. However, many of these people do
not have formal titles for the lands that they work. Because govern-
ments rarely recognize communal or customary rights, small-scale farmers
1 INTRODUCTION 7
Political Causes
Governments also contribute to food insecurity. Because rural commu-
nities have little political influence, public sector policies are rarely
structured to meet their needs. Most public resources flow to cities rather
than the countryside. A long-standing bias against agriculture often leaves
rural communities without the tools, technology, and basic infrastructure
needed to increase food production or generate higher incomes. Small-
scale farmers are invariably characterized by low levels of productivity and
glaring inefficiencies in the use of critical inputs. Agricultural sectors are
also characterized by high levels of post-harvest loss. About a quarter of
all crops produced in the developing world are lost because of inade-
quate harvesting techniques, storage facilities, and distribution systems.40
There are also sizable losses in the fishing sector due to poor refrigeration,
8 F. ADAMS
Environmental Causes
An imbalance between a country’s population size and its natural resource
base also causes food insecurity. A country’s natural resources, especially
its land, water, forests, and fisheries, may be insufficient to meet the nutri-
tional needs of a rapidly expanding population. Countries with the highest
population growth are often unable to meet the increasing demands
10 F. ADAMS
International Causes
There are also factors associated with the structure of the global economy
that contribute to food insecurity in the developing world. The trade
in agricultural commodities, for example, frequently works against the
interests of small-scale farmers. Because North American and European
countries heavily subsidize their agricultural sectors, farmers in these
countries can sell their grains on global markets at lower prices than
would otherwise be the case. The dumping of agricultural products
at artificially low prices undermines farmers in poor countries, where
subsidies are either considerably smaller or nonexistent.64 The Agree-
ment on Agriculture (AoA), negotiated under the auspices of the World
Trade Organization (WTO), was presented as an important step toward
reducing subsidies to agricultural producers. However, wealthy coun-
tries retain many of their farm subsidies by employing different forms
of exemption that are allowed under the accord. In addition, WTO rules
have permitted global agribusinesses to appropriate indigenous knowl-
edge of food production by obtaining intellectual property rights (IPR)
over the genetic material of seeds and livestock breeds. Under the new
rules, global agribusinesses have expanded their influence over how food
is produced, processed, marketed, and delivered to consumers around the
world.65
Large-scale acquisitions of land by foreign countries or agribusinesses
also undermine food security in the developing world.66 Land acquisitions
have been entered into with countries in the Persian Gulf and East Asia
that have significant food deficits.67 These acquisitions typically take place
in areas where land governance is weak and customary tenure arrange-
ments are not respected. Although most of these acquisitions have been
1 INTRODUCTION 13
both food aid and food assistance throughout Latin America, Africa, the
Middle East, and Asia. Although “food aid” and “food assistance” are
often used interchangeably, it is important to define each term separately.
Food aid refers to emergency food relief to people with urgent needs
and is typically extended at times of humanitarian crisis. Such aid can be
provided either in-kind or through cash-based transfers and commodity
vouchers. In-kind aid refers to the direct provision of food to people in
need. Bags of rice dropped from cargo planes over drought-stricken lands
or loaves of bread thrown from the back of flatbed trucks to outstretched
hands in overcrowded refugee camps are examples of in-kind aid. Alter-
nately, cash-based transfers and commodity vouchers allow people to
purchase food in local markets. In times of natural disaster or civil conflict,
food aid is absolutely essential and saves countless lives.72
Food assistance, on the other hand, goes beyond short-term emer-
gency relief to address the root causes of food insecurity. WFP defines
food assistance as “… a full range of instruments, activities, and platforms
that empower vulnerable and food-insecure people and communities so
they can regularly have access to nutritious food.”73 Food assistance
is thus structured to build the local resources, knowledge, and capaci-
ties needed to ensure people can either produce or purchase sufficient
food for themselves and their families. This typically involves longer-term
efforts to increase agricultural productivity, promote rural development,
and preserve natural environments.74 The ultimate goal of food assistance
is to eliminate the need for food aid.
The United Nations has led the campaign to end hunger and malnu-
trition in the developing world. This includes a long-term effort to ensure
food is universally recognized as a basic human right as well as the allo-
cation of both food aid and food assistance to poor communities in Latin
America, Africa, the Middle East, and Asia. Three UN-affiliated agen-
cies—the World Food Programme, Food and Agriculture Organization,
and International Fund for Agricultural Development—provide food aid
in response to humanitarian emergencies as well as broader food assistance
to address the root causes of hunger and malnutrition. Food assistance is
often structured to improve agricultural productivity through the distri-
bution of improved seeds, equipment, irrigation, and extension services,
the defense of land rights, or support for farmers associations75 Resources
have also been deployed to foster broader rural transformation, including
the expansion of non-farm employment, diffusion of financial services,
construction of infrastructure, and development of wider markets for
16 F. ADAMS
Chapter Outline
This book begins with international efforts to establish access to safe,
sufficient, and nutritious food as a universally recognized human right
before turning to the work of the three United Nations food agencies in
each region of the developing world. Chapter 2 chronicles the evolution
of the right to food regime beginning with the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights in the early days of the United Nations and ending with
the recent Right to Food resolution of the Human Rights Council. The
major institutional mechanisms that have been established to promote and
defend the right to food are also identified. The latter part of this chapter
describes the purpose, structure, and major programs of the three United
Nations food agencies.
Chapters 3–6 examine food insecurity in Latin America, Africa, the
Middle East, and Asia. The first part of each chapter outlines the nature
and central causes of food insecurity in each region. These chapters
then survey the work of UN agencies in providing emergency food aid,
promoting agricultural productivity, advancing rural development, and
preserving natural environments. The projects identified are representa-
tive of the work undertaken within recent years but are by no means an
exhaustive review of all the activities that these agencies have supported.
Although Latin American countries have made progress in reducing
hunger and malnutrition, nearly 200 million people continue to be food
insecure. Chapter 3 first outlines the parameters of malnutrition in Latin
America and then turns to the economic, political, and environmental
causes of food insecurity. The last section reviews multilateral efforts to
meet the nutritional needs of poor communities in the region. Although
some countries continue to receive emergency food aid, most assis-
tance is structured to improve agricultural productivity, promote rural
development, and preserve natural environments.
Africa has the highest proportion of people who suffer from hunger
and malnutrition of all world regions. Chapter 4 offers a broad outline
of food insecurity in Africa before turning to its central causes. Inter-
national efforts to meet the nutritional needs of poor communities are
then considered. The United Nations provides emergency food aid to
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
you are my guest, politeness prevents my expressing what I think of
your conduct. You can break that pipe to pieces and burn the
stick”—this to his servant—“I do not care to smoke it.”
The priest turned pale, sat silent for a minute, and then said in
apology—
“Yes, yes, you say truly, I have eaten dirt.”
Strange to say, we were very friendly with him afterwards.
The pipe affected by the lower classes is the short chibouque, this
nearly every North Persian of the lower class carries at his back in
his girdle or in his pocket; there is a small clay, brass or iron head,
and a straight stem of cherry-wood, six inches to a foot long, with a
bore some half-inch in diameter through it; there is no mouth-piece,
and it is held to the lips, and not in the teeth. The tobacco smoked is
usually Samsoon, a common kind of coarse Turkish; or Koordi, a
mild tobacco, nearly white in colour, but with a pungent flavour; there
are many other varieties. This Koordi looks like coarse sawdust, and
is quite dry, and is simply the leaf-stalk and stem of the plant
coarsely pounded; to look at it, no one would suppose on a first
inspection that it was tobacco at all: the best comes from
Kermanshah.
A third kind of pipe is used by the Arabs of the Gulf and many
South Persians; it consists simply of a tube of clay, an inch in
diameter, bent at a right or acute angle, and constricted at the
middle; from end to end it measures four to seven inches; one side is
crammed with tobacco, “Tootoon i Koordi;” a coal is placed on it, and
it is passed from hand to hand till the contents are burnt out. It is a
very primitive pipe.
Enough of pipes. By five all the visitors had gone; we dined at
seven, and I retired to sleep in a comfortable bed.
At about five[4] next morning I am roused by—
“Chai, sahib” (tea, sir); and a lordly individual, with huge
mustachios, a black lambskin cap, a brown cloth inner coat, a blue
cloth outer coat, a broad belt, and a long “kummer” (or straight
broad-bladed sword), dark-blue “shulwar” (what an American calls
pants, and an outfitter pyjamas), and his stockinged feet—his shoes
were outside my door—places a cup of tea, some twice-baked sweet
biscuit, of delicious crispness, and some marmalade, at my side, and
departs. He soon returns with a second cup of tea and a kalian.
As I am a griffin, he draws my attention to the latter being—“Welly
good thing, kalian.”
He then goes through a pantomime suggesting sleep, talking all
the time to me in Persian. I take his advice.
At eight he wakes me, and I find he has a warm tub ready for me. I
dress once again in the clothes of ordinary life, and go down, to find
no one about, for Major S⸺ has gone to the office, and taken the
Colonel with him.
However, my especial chief, Mr. B⸺, soon appears,
accompanied by his big black dog “Topsy,” who comes into all the
rooms and sits on all the settees: there is a fine sense of liberty in
this. Mr. B⸺ warns me that I must not hope to make anything by
practice—that he never did, and I never shall; but that there is a fine
field for gratuitous work.
He then explains to me the Persian system of medicine. It has its
advantages in its delightful simplicity. All diseases are cold or hot. All
remedies are hot or cold. A hot disease requires a cold remedy, and
vice-versâ.
Now, if the Persian doctor is called in, and has any doubt as to the
nature of the disorder, he prescribes a hot remedy, let us say; if the
patient gets better, he was right; if worse, then he prescribes a cold
remedy, and sticks to it. He thus gets over all need for diagnosis, all
physiological treatment, and he cannot, according to his own lights,
be wrong.
His prescriptions contain a multitude of mostly obsolete and inert
drugs, ten being a small number of ingredients, twenty an ordinary
one. Before he is summoned, an omen is taken by the patient and
his friends, as to who shall be called in; when he has seen his
patient, another is taken, as to whether his advice shall be followed
or not. His fee is a few pence, or more generally he undertakes the
case on speculation; so much—of which he is lucky if he gets half—if
the patient gets well; nothing if he doesn’t.
Most of the relatives, friends, and neighbours prescribe various
homely, or at times, powerful remedies, which are all as a rule tried.
Quiet by the sick-bed is unknown; in fact, the patient used to fuss
and noise would be depressed by it. And remedies and contrivances
of a barbarous nature, such as putting a patient in fresh horse-dung,
sewing him up in a raw hide, are the rule rather than the exception.
Usually the European doctor is distrusted, only called in when the
patient is breathing his last, or by the very rich or very poor.
Mr. B⸺ gave me one very good piece of advice. “You will go to
Hamadan—with the Persians novelty is everything. Strike while the
iron is hot, and before the novelty is worn off, and you—well, you will
get lots of experience.”
I was astonished and incredulous—it was all true.[5]
We visited the telegraph-office, and looked round the Colonel’s
garden, returning to breakfast at eleven, and we sat down to a
substantial déjeuner à la fourchette, with country wines, and tea for
those who preferred it. It was followed by the inevitable kalian and
coffee.
I wanted much to see the Zoological Gardens, but we were told
that the Shah had turned the beasts loose. We, however, decided to
go, and we found it so—they were all loose.
The leo-panther, a cross between the lion and panther, a lovely
animal like an immense cat, very tame, allowing one to pat him; two
lions, a bear, two tigers (young ones), walking about with the
antelopes and wild sheep. I must say the presence of the tigers was
not quite pleasant. There is a pretty building—a sort of summer
pavilion—here, belonging to the king, well worth seeing.
A curious incident occurred as Major S⸺, Mr. M⸺, Mr. B⸺,
and I were walking home from these Zoological Gardens; we were
crossing a bit of desert plain behind the gardens towards the Major’s
house. On a sudden we saw come from under the corner of the
garden wall at a shambling trot—a big tawny animal; to discover that
it was a lioness was instantaneous, and it was coming our way. B
⸺, with whom discretion was the better part of valour, did not
hesitate; like the last of the Horatii, he “vowed revenge, and to
pursue it fled.”
We kept on, but fear was in all our hearts—I know it was in mine,
possibly the Major was exempt—but we walked very fast, looking
ever and anon at the advancing lioness. There was apparently no
mistaking the shambling pace of the wild beast; as it got nearer it
turned out to be a big dog. Of course when we arrived at the house
we all laughed at B⸺.
The Major’s dignity and profession forbade his running, Mr. M⸺,
as a diplomat, never of course did anything in a hurry, so couldn’t
run, and as they were present I didn’t like to run, though I itched to
do it. Of course, B⸺ said he knew it was a dog, and ran to frighten
us; if so, his simulation of terror was almost lifelike.
In the evening we dined at the English Mission,[6] where there is a
billiard-table—my last game for some time, I fancy.
CHAPTER IV.
TEHERAN.