Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In a Hybrid Fiber Reinforced Concrete (HFRC), two or more different types of fibers are
rationally combined to produce a cementitious composite that derives benefits from each
of the individual fibers and exhibits a synergistic response. The main aim of the present
experimental investigation was to use different volume fractions of polypropylene fiber
(PPF) and continuously crimped steel fibers to produce HFRC and thus to evaluate its
performance under compression, tension, flexure, shear and impact types of loading.
Based on I.S. Code method of mix design, proportion of different ingredients was
obtained to get M25 grade concrete. Samples were prepared with by varying the volume
fraction of fibers from 0 to 1.0%. Total 9 different types of HFRC matrices were
considered for performance evaluation. The result shows that replacement of optimum
steel content with 0.5% fibers yields improved strength.
CONTENT
CHAPTER
TITLE PAGE NO.
NO.
INTRODUCTION 1-5
1
1.1 General
1
2.1 General
6
3.2.4 Water 15
3.3.1 Introduction 17
4.1 General 23
5 CONCLUSION 26
REFERENCES 27
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 GENERAL
1
1.2 FIBER REINFORCED CONCRETE
(FRC)
The main disadvantage of the plain concrete is its brittle character. Fibers are introduced
into the concrete to make them ductile and such concrete is called fiber reinforced
concrete. Fiber- reinforced concrete (FRC) is concrete containing fibrous material
which increases its structural integrity. It contains short discrete fibers that are uniformly
distributed and randomly oriented. Fibers include steel fibers, glass fibers, synthetic
fibers and natural fibers – each of which lead varying properties to the concrete. In
addition, the character of fiber-reinforced concrete changes with varying concretes, fiber
materials, geometries, distribution, orientation, and densities.
The concept of using fibers or as reinforcement is not new. Fibers have been used as
reinforcement since ancient times. In the 1900s, asbestos fibers were used in concrete. In
the 1950s, the concept of composite materials came into being and fiber-reinforced
concrete was one of the topics of interest. Once the health risks associated with asbestos
were discovered, there was a need to find a replacement for the substance in concrete
and other building materials. By the 1960s, steel, glass (GFRC), and synthetic fibers
such as polypropylene fibers were used in concrete. Research into new fiber-reinforced
concretes continues today.
FRC is the concrete which overcomes some of the limitations of ordinary concrete.
Some of advantages are
High modulus of elasticity for effective long-term reinforcement, even in the hardened
concrete.
Ideal aspect ratio (i.e. relationship between Fiber diameter and length) which makes
them excellent for early-age performance.
Easily placed, Cast, Sprayed and less labor intensive than placing
2
rebar.
shapes.
FRC possesses enough plasticity to go under large deformation once the peak load
has been reached.
Fibers are usually used in concrete to control cracking due to plastic shrinkage and to
drying shrinkage. They also reduce the permeability of concrete and thus reduce bleeding
of water. Some types of fibers produce greater impact–, abrasion–, and shatter–resistance
in concrete. Generally fibers do not increase the flexural strength of concrete, and so
cannot replace moment– resisting or structural steel reinforcement. Indeed, some fibers
actually reduce the strength of concrete. Some research indicated that using fibers in
concrete has limited effect on the impact resistance of the materials. This finding is very
important since traditionally, people think that ductility increases when concrete is
reinforced with fibers. The results also indicated that the use of micro fibers offers better
impact resistance to that of longer fibers.
The main disadvantage of FRC is its low impact strength. Using different
types of fibers increases impact strength. A Hybrid Fiber Reinforced
Concrete (HFRC) is formed from a combination of different types of fibers,
which differ in material properties, remain bonded together when added in
concrete and retain their identities and properties. In this study, steel fiber
and polypropylene fiber are used.
3
1.3.1 Steel Fiber
Improved ductility
Reduced crack widths and control of crack widths thus improving durability
Polypropylene fibers can be divided into microfibers and macro fibers depending on
their length and the function that they perform in the concrete. An overview of selected
polypropylene fibers available on the market was presented. Moreover, the influence of
polypropylene fibers on physical and mechanical properties of concrete such as
workability; elasticity modulus; compressive, flexural, and tensile strength; toughness;
impact, spalling, freeze-thaw, abrasion resistance; water absorption; porosity; permeability;
4
durability, and eco-friendly and economic properties were discussed. Additionally,
certain restrictions while designing fiber reinforced concrete mixture were mentioned.
The article proved that public spaces are a promising field of polypropylene fiber
reinforced concrete application. Since they are subjected to e.g. unfavorable
environmental conditions, impact damages, surface abrasion, and vandalism, the use of
concrete with enhanced propertied will be undeniably beneficial.
5
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 GENERAL
Hybrid fiber reinforced concrete has been using in different countries for various uses.
Various research works are still going on in different institutions and universities foe
better understanding of material behavior. A large number of literatures are available
which describes mechanical properties of HFRC. But the number of studies related to
properties of hybrid fiber reinforced concrete with steel and polypropylene is very
limited. The available literatures gives valuable data regarding the mix design and
material properties. Some of the literatures which are relevant to the present study are
reviewed here.
AmitRana (2013) studied the influence of steel fibres on flexural strength of concrete.
He found out the optimum quantity of steel fibers required to achieve the maximum
flexural strength for M25 grade concrete. From his experimental work it was found that
with increase in steel fibre content in concrete there was a tremendous increase in
Flexural strength. The experimental program associated with this work involved the
preparation of 11 mixes 0%, .75%, 1%, 1.25%,1.5%,2%, 2.5%, 3%, 4%, 5%, 6% fibre
volume fraction. The results showing that at 1 % steel fibre content flexural strength of
6.46 N/mm2 was observed against flexural strength 5.36 N/mm2 at 0% hence increase of
1.1% flexural strength was obtained.
7
for concrete beam depends on small steel fiber proportion and distribution. The strain
gauges have been installed on beam, to measure level of applied force, deflection and
time to failure of beams. The morphology of crack has been studied. Shear crack,
flexural crack and intermediate shear-flexural crack have been observed. The steel fiber
has been controlled shear crack morphology. Increase quantity of fiber, improves
flexural strength of beam. To improve flexural strength of thin cross section concrete the
proposed method is well suitable. In this research work smooth steel fiber has been used.
It is well known that deformed steel fiber and rough surface steel fiber exhibit better
performance.
8
1.75%, not only the flexural strength but also the toughness indices are increased. Also
the experimental results showed that by increasing the steel fibers, the density,
compressive strength and static modulus of elasticity are increased. The study had shown
that the addition of steel fibers in a concrete improved many mechanical properties of
concrete such as tensile strength, impact strength and toughness. The resulting concrete
material possesses higher tensile strength, consolidated response and ductility.From the
experimental data it had been proved that concrete compressive strength, fiber content
and the fiber aspect ratio are the major effectual parameters for specifying the tensile
strength of fiber content. The experimental investigation was carried out with the
incorporation of steel fibers, silica fume and cement had been shown that a strong
composite was produced with superior crack resistance, improved ductility and strength
behavior. The experimental results were compared with the mathematically modeled
expressions. Regression analysis was of large number of experimental results were
carried out and from that the statistical model was prepared. All the properties of
concrete such as compressive strength and modulus of elasticity were increased by
addition of steel fibers. The review study was carried out for the introduction of steel
fibers to obtain steel fiber reinforced concrete in sustainable and long-lasting concrete
structures. The study found that the workability can be adequate to the concrete by
introducing the super plasticizer without affecting the other properties.
All the literatures discussed above gives an idea about the effect of carbon and steel
fibre addition on concrete and the importance of addition of fibers. Only limited studies
were reported on the hybrid fiber reinforced concrete. Under this context there is an
importance to conduct study on HFRC with steel and polypropylene fiber.
9
2.3.1 OBECTIVE OF THE WORK
10
CHAPTER 3
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAMME
3.1 GENERAL
The main objective is to study the mechanical properties of HFRC with steel and carbon
fibres. For this, control mix was designed and their mechanical properties were tested.
Then FRC were prepared with steel fibre at 0.3%, 0.5% of volume of concrete. The
mechanical properties of this single fibre reinforced concrete are tested and optimum
dosage is obtained. Then polypropylene fibre is added to replace steel fibre at 0.5%,
1.0% of optimum dosage of steel. Then mechanical properties of HFRC mixes were
tested. A total of 30 cubes, 10 cylinders and 10 beams were cast.
The main ingredients used for the manufacture of HFRC are cement, fine aggregate,
coarse aggregate and water. In addition these steel and polypropylene fibers were also
used. Properties of materials were found out by conducting the appropriate tests and the
results obtained for the mix design purpose.
3.2.1 Cement
Physical and chemical properties of cement play a vital role in developing strength of
fresh concrete. Fineness affects water requirements for consistency. From strength point
of view, cement should be finely ground and contains a fair amount of C3S. So in this
study, Ordinary Portland cement (OPC) 33 grade was used and the properties found
out were tabulated in table 3.1
11
Particulars Values
Grade OPC 33
Manufacturer ULTRATECH
Fineness, % 7
Manufactured sand passing through 4.75 mm sieve and retained on 150 micron was used for
the present investigation. Standard testing procedures were adopted and the results were
shown in table 3.2 and 3.3. Fine aggregate used conforms to IS 383-1970
specification( ZONE II)
Particulars Values
12
Table 3.3 sieve analysis of fine aggregate
13
3.2.3 Coarse aggregate
Crushed aggregate of maximum size of 20mm and a minimum size of 4.75mm were
used. The aggregate was selected based on the size of the test specimen. The properties
were determined in lab using standard testing procedures were listed in table 3.4 and 3.5.
Particulars Values
Fineness Modulus 7.08
Uniformity Co-efficient 1.38
Effective size 10.5
Specific gravity 2.64
Water absorption (%) 0.69
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
0.1 1 10 100
14
Table 3.5 sieve analysis of coarse aggregate
40 0 0 0 100
2.36 0 0 100 0
1.18 0 0 100 0
0.60 0 0 100 0
0.30 0 0 100 0
0.15 0 0 100 0
3.2.4 Water
Water used should be free from impurities. Water from college water supply system was
used for both concreting and curing purposes.
15
3.2.5 Steel fiber
Crimped steel fibers (fig.3.3) were used in this investigation. Steel fibers were added as a
volume fraction with respect to the volume of concrete. The properties of steel fibers are
listed in table 3.6.
Length 25 mm
Diameter 0.5 mm
Density 79000N/m3
16
Fig 3.4 Polypropylene fibers
Length 30 mm
Diameter 30 microns
3.3.1 Introduction
Mix design can be defined as the process of selecting suitable ingredients of the concrete
and determining their relative proportions with the object of producing concrete of
certain minimum strength and durability as economically as possible. IS code 10262-
1082and IS code 456-2000 were used for designing OPC33 concrete.
17
Selection of water cement ratio
Water cement ratio required for the target mean strength of 31.6 N/mm2is 0.45.
(From IS 10262-2009)
From table 5, IS 456-2000, the maximum water content for 20mm aggregate equal to
186 litres (for 25 to 50mm slump range).
=191.58 L
=190 L
From table 3, IS 10262- 1982 for 20mm aggregate size air content is 2% volume of
concrete.
Determination of cement
content water cement ratio =
0.45
water = 190 L cement =190/0.45
=422 kg/m3
~350 kg/m3
From table 5 of IS 456-2000 minimum cement content for severe exposure condition.
18
From table 3, IS 10262-1982 for the maximum size of aggregate of 20 mm the amount of
entrapped air in the wet concrete is 2%. Taking this int account and applying equations.
= 0.98 m3
=190 kg/m3
= 350 kg/m3
gravity of CA =2.64
kg/m3
fa = 607.10 kg/m3
19
ca = (1-p) x fa x Sca/(Sfa x p)
=(1-0.35) X 607.10x2.64/(0.35x2.59)
=1149.24 kg/m3
FA 607.10 kg/m3
CA 1149.24 kg/m3
To the conventional concrete mix steel fibers are added at 0.30%, 0.50% by volume fraction.
Then polypropylene fibers are added to steel fibers at 0.50% and 1.00%. Thus hybrid fibre
concrete mix is obtained. To study the different mechanical properties such as compressive
strength, flexural strength, split tensile strength and modulus of elasticity, specimens were
prepared.
The mixing is done in tilting drum mixer. First coarse aggregates are added to the mixer
after wetting the drum with water. Then fine aggregate are added and they are allowed to
mix thoroughly for 1 min. Then water is added to the mix and mixed for 3 mins. Fibers
are further added to the mix and mixing is done. Then the drum is tilted and mix is
20
poured into pan. The specimens are cast in standard mould of cylinder. Vibrating
machine is used for uniformly placing the concrete mix in the mould. The specimens are
demoulded after 24 hours. They are put in the curing tank for curing. The details of
specimens are given in table 3.9.
The control mix and SFRC are tested for the mechanical properties listed below. The
optimum steel fiber is selected only by testing the SFRC compressive strength. The
HFRC mixes are tested for all the below mechanical properties.
The split tensile strength test is a well-known indirect test used for determining the tensile
strength of concrete. Test was carried out on concrete cylinder of size 150mm x 300mm.
In split tensile strength test, Concrete cylinder was placed with its axis horizontal,
between the loading surface of a compression testing machine and the load was applied
until failure occurred due to a splitting in the plane, containing the vertical diameter of the
specimen. In order to reduce the magnitude of high compression stress near the points of
application of the load, narrow packing strips of plywood were placed between the
specimen and loading plates of the testing machine. The split tensile strength was
determined after 28day water curing.
21
Fig 3.6. split tensile strength test
22
CHAPTER 4
4.1 GENERAL
The specimens are tested for various properties after 28 days of curing. Compressive
strength, split tensile strength were calculated for the specimens.
The split tensile value for both ordinary concrete and FRC cylinder of size 150mm
x300mm for 28 days is shown in table 4.1 and fig 4.1. Steel fibers and polypropylene
fibers are added from 0.3% to 1.0% of volume of concrete.
23
Fig 4.1 split tensile strength of FRC
The split tensile strength of normal control mix for 28 days was 6.72 N/mm2. With
addition of steel fiber and polypropylene fiber split tensile strength increased with
increase in fiber volume fraction.
24
Fig 4.2 : variation of split tensile strength for HFRC
For the hybrid combination of 50% steel fiber and 50% polypropylene fiber, the split tensile
decreased when compared to SFRC mix for 28 days. Thus tensile strength decreased with addition
of hybrid fiber.
25
CHAPTER 5
CONCLUSION
As we conclude this project, the heightened strength observed in the specific FRC mix (0.5% steel
fiber, 0.5% polypropylene fiber) stands as a testament to the efficiency of this innovative approach.
The implications extend beyond the confines of our experiment, offering a practical solution for
engineers and builders seeking reliable materials that push the boundaries of traditional concrete.
This conclusion marks not just the end of a project, but the beginning of a narrative that
encourages further research and application of Fiber Reinforced Concrete in shaping the future of
resilient and sustainable construction.
26
REFERENCES:
[6] Abbas, S., Nehdi, M. L., & Saleem, M. A. (2016). Ultra-high performance concrete:
Mechanical performance, durability, sustainability and implementation challenges.
International Journal of Concrete Structures and Materials, 10(3),271–295.
[7] Amit rana “ some studies on steel fibre reinforced concrete” , Vol 3,2013.
[9] Eren YA. Determination of mechanical properties of hybrid fiber reinforced concrete.
27