Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Finals Poly
Finals Poly
SCREENING TEST
• A Screening test is administered to find out
TWO PRIMARY APPROACH IN POLYGRAPH TESTING if the examinee has denied any
involvement on relevant questions
1. DECEPTION TEST pertaining to a single or multiple issue of
• An approach in polygraph testing that is concern. This test is designed to develop
conducted to determine the involvement important information and investigate the
of an examinee to a known incident or to possible involvement of the examinee to
multiple issues of concern. The method that the issue. Screening test provides concrete
will be use varies according to the basis for decision making in hiring personnel
examiner’s preference and purpose of the for high risk position. However, it cannot not
test. These include any of the following be used as a standalone technique when
polygraph techniques: the examinee exhibits significant reactions
- Zone Comparison Technique to any issue of concern. A follow- up
- Modified General Question Technique examination is recommended to address
- Directed Lie Screening Test the matter that needs to be verified.
- Relevant-Irrelevant Technique Screening test can also serves as a
deterrence factor for non-compliance with
2. RECOGNITION TEST agency policies, rules and regulations
• This approach in polygraph testing is (Nelson 2015). Screening test is used for the
intended to determine if the examinee has following purposes:
knowledge about the issue being tested. - Pre-Employment Testing
An examinee who are knowledgeable on - Periodic Audit Testing
the case information or facts, will exhibits - Post-Conviction Sexual Offender Test
physiological reaction when confronted
with the item relevant to the test. The type Screening polygraph test can be an effective
of recognition test are as follows: method in monitoring the persons under the
- Searching Peak of Tension Test program of non-institutional correction. It will not
- Known Solution Peak of Tension Test only serve as a process of determining their
- Concealed Information Test compliance with the rules and regulations but also
- Acquaintance Test as deterrence for violating the conditions set by
the board. The possible implementation of
USES OF POLYGRAPH TESTING screening test in parole and probation program
1. Diagnostic Test may add to the volume of work load. But it will
• This test is conducted to person suspected create job opportunities to criminologist who have
of involvement on a particular issue under interest in polygraph practice.
investigation. The examinee is tested based
on the available facts, circumstances or THE POLYGRAPH EXAMINER
evidence of the allegation to determine his • is one who is skilled and capable to detect
possible involvement or non-involvement. deception or verify truth of statement
The purpose of diagnostic test is to obtain a through instrumentation or the use of
conclusion that will serve as basis for a mechanical devise.
decision (Nelson 2015). The future of the • The instrument or devise utilized to detect
examinee as well of his family can be deception or verify truthfulness of the
affected by the opinion rendered by the statements must meet the basic
polygraph examiner. It is imperative on the instrumentation requirement of being
part of the polygraph examiner to remain capable of recording simultaneously on a
objective and employ the appropriate moving chart the physiological responses.
testing technique to achieve the highest The following are qualification and qualities
level of accuracy of the test result. expected of a polygraph examiner are:
Diagnostic test as used in the investigation
of crimes produced high level of decision 1. He must remember that he is an impartial
accuracy, when administered in a single seeker of the truth, conducts his examination in
issue - specific test. a professional and ethical manner, and never
allow his personal feelings, sympathies, or RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE INVESTIGATOR TO THE
prejudice influence the result of the EXAMINER
examination. 1. He must not wait until the last minute, after all
investigative methods and techniques have
2. He should constantly bear in his mind his failed, the test should never be used as a last
primary responsibility to his subject to give them resort.
all possible safeguards against error and must
never accept for polygraph examination, any 2. He must not fail to investigate the case before
subject whose physical or mental health or seeking assistance. The polygraph examination
state makes him unfit. does not establish whether a crime has been
committed or not. Faulty or incomplete
3. Technically, he must have a complete investigation places the examiner in a position
knowledge of the instrument and its potentials to ask weak questions rather than strong
and limitations, the most modern polygraph specific ones
technique, proficiency in the conduct of the
polygraph examination, test construction and 3. He should not depend on the mass screening
chart interpretation. of possible suspects to produce the guilty party
except when no reasonable amount of
4. Morally, he must have a sincere desire to be a investigation had produced a likely suspect or
polygraph examiner in its strictest sense, by materially narrowed down the number of
devoting himself to the polygraph profession possible suspect;
through maintenance of a high personal
integrity and increasing personal proficiency 4. Not to stop investigation if polygraph
through constant study and research. examination is deferred or temporarily delay
RESPONSIBILITIES OF POLYGRAPH EXAMINER TO HIS 5. He must not ask the test to bolster the evidence
SUBJECT submitted to the court. This is a display of doubt
1. The polygraph examiner recognizes the fact always build up to the benefit of an accused,
that his primary responsibly must be to the and in numerous instances, the opinion of the
person who has voluntary submitted himself to examiner is accepted by the court in favor of
a polygraph examination. the defense rather for the prosecution;
2. He should never conduct examination on 6. He must not use polygraph as a props, ruse or
person without first the appraisal of the trickery to secure confession or for the
subject's constitutional rights, rights against self- evaluation of the mental and physical state of
incrimination. the suspect; and
3. He should never perform examination to any 7. He should not tell anyone that the polygraph
person unless the instrument he is going to would decide whether the subject or suspect is
utilize is in good working condition and makes innocent or guilty. The court makes the
a continuous permanent recording in a moving decision.
chart of at least two physiological tracings.
8. He must not think that investigation is over if the
4. He should never render a certain or conclusive test indicated that the subject lied or
verbal or written opinion based on the chart confessed. Evidence and testimonies should
analysis without having administered at least be gathered to prove the facts of the offense
two or more charts. and the allegation against the subject.
3. Recommend the test as a means for the 5. He must refrain from drinking alcoholic
subject to indicate his truthfulness; beverages, taking sedatives, or capsule or
syrup for at least twelve (12) hours prior to the
4. Stress the test's capacity for indicating through test.
the recorded response whether a person is
telling the truth; 6. He must not be suffering from any temporary
illness like headache, toothache, stomach
5. Guarantee the subject that the examiner is ache, fever, menstruation (for female), severe
qualified and impartial to all persons involved colds and coughs.
in the case; and 6. Avoid any claim for the
instrument or examiner that is not backed up 7. He must not be hungry and
by fact.
8. He must not have sex indulgence prior to the
WHAT TAKES PLACE DURING POLYGRAPH test
EXAMINATION?
• The nervous control of the human body
includes the central nervous system (the LIMITATIONS AND RELIABILITY OF POLYGRAPH
brain and the spinal cord) and the EXAMINATIONS (2011)
autonomic or regulating nervous system
which has two complimentary branches: 1. It is an invaluable aid but not a substitute for an
the sympathetic and parasympathetic investigation.
nervous system acting opposite each
other. 2. It is not a lie detector but it is a scientific
• The sympathetic will prevail and over-ride diagnostic instrument.
the parasympathetic, therefore, there will
be changes in the heart rate, pulse rate, 3. It does not determine facts; it records responses
blood pressure, respiratory tracing, psycho in which the subject knows to be true.
galvanic reflexes, time of response to
question, voice tracing, etc. 4. It is as accurate as the examiner is competent.
• the parasympathetic nervous system works
to bring back things to normal when the 5. The test should not be administered unless
conditions of stress have been removed. enough facts of the case have been
• When subject is asked series of questions established to permit the examiner to prepare
the recording of several psycho- a complete set of suitable questions.
physiological reaction and the scientific
interpretations are the basis of the tests by 6. A test must not be administered without the
the examiner. voluntary consent of the subject.
LIMITATION OF THE SUBJECT WHO WILL UNDERGO 7. No indication or presumption of guilt will be
POLYGRAPH EXAMINATION entertained, or a written report submitted
1. The subject must have a goodnight sleep at because the subject refuses to undergo the
least five (5) hours prior to the test. test.
8. A test should not be administered until all
accusations have been explained and
understood by the subject.
Examples:
3. COMPARISON QUESTION
• A questions that is designed to produce a
physiological responses which are
compared to the physiological response of
the applicable relevant questions
TYPES OF COMPARISON QUESTION • Not related to this incident, have you ever
A. Probable-Lie Comparison Question (PLC) caused any damage to someone else's
• It is a question designed to be a probable- property out of revenge?
lie for the examinee. It is similar in nature of • When you live in Manila, have you done
the issue being tested but unrelated by malicious to someone's belonging
time, place, or category. It must be broad • During your 20's, have you ever destroyed
in scope, and time to cover as many of the any object that was not your own?
examinee's past life experiences a as
possible. PLC for Stealing
• As a soldier, have you ever padded your
Example: expense account?
• Before this year, have you ever stolen
anything?
• Before moving in Quezon, have you ever
taken property you your home that was
stolen from somewhere?
• While in high school, have you ever
cheated anyone?
• Between the ages of 20-25, have you ever
obtained anything dishonestly?
V2 - Screening
1. Neutral
2. Sacrifice Relevant
3. Comparison 1
4. Relevant 1 (Secondary)
5. Relevant 2 (Primary)
6. Comparison 2
Tracing Amplitude
• Electrodermal
• Vasomotor
• Motion Sensor
• Cardio – 52 to 70mmHg
• Red – low
• Blue – high
• Green – Ideal
• Do not Increase/decrease
• Pressure during data collection
1. Sacrifice 1. Relevant
Relevant 2. Sacrifice
2. Relevant Relevant
3. Comparison 3. Comparison
4. Neutral 4. Neutral
5. Introductory/ 5. Introductory/
Symptomatic Symptomatic
Chart Markings
• Examiners Comments
• Instrument Adjustment
• Question Modification
• Behavior of the Subject
• Extraneous factors
Average Tracings
• No physiological evidence of change in
the emotional level within the stress area on
the polygraph chart.
• Tonic Level
• Stress Area = start of question until the
second after the answer.
Reaction Tracings
• Shows physiological evidence that the
sympathetic subdivision of the autonomic Respiration Features
nervous system has been more active. • Suppressed Breathing
• Indicating a psychological change from • Apnea
the subject’s average emotional level. • Reduction of Amplitude
• Phasic and/or tonic response. • Slowing
• Temporary increase in baseline
Cardio Features
• Baseline Arousal – Bigger is better
• Duration
• Pulse Deceleration