You are on page 1of 54

An introduction to economic geography

globalization uneven development and


place Third Edition. Edition Danny
Mackinnon
Visit to download the full and correct content document:
https://textbookfull.com/product/an-introduction-to-economic-geography-globalization-
uneven-development-and-place-third-edition-edition-danny-mackinnon/
More products digital (pdf, epub, mobi) instant
download maybe you interests ...

Simple Statistical Tests for Geography 1st Edition


Danny Mccarroll

https://textbookfull.com/product/simple-statistical-tests-for-
geography-1st-edition-danny-mccarroll/

An introduction to work and organizational psychology :


an international perspective Third Edition Chmiel

https://textbookfull.com/product/an-introduction-to-work-and-
organizational-psychology-an-international-perspective-third-
edition-chmiel/

China’s Uneven and Combined Development Steven Rolf

https://textbookfull.com/product/chinas-uneven-and-combined-
development-steven-rolf/

An Introduction to Computational Macroeconomics


Economic Methodology Anelí Bongers

https://textbookfull.com/product/an-introduction-to-
computational-macroeconomics-economic-methodology-aneli-bongers/
An Introduction to Psychological Science Third Canadian
Edition Mark Krause

https://textbookfull.com/product/an-introduction-to-
psychological-science-third-canadian-edition-mark-krause/

Geographies of Development An Introduction to


Development Studies Robert Potter

https://textbookfull.com/product/geographies-of-development-an-
introduction-to-development-studies-robert-potter/

Between Empire and Globalization: An Economic History


of Modern Spain 1st Edition Albert Carreras

https://textbookfull.com/product/between-empire-and-
globalization-an-economic-history-of-modern-spain-1st-edition-
albert-carreras/

Worldviews an introduction to the history and


philosophy of science Third Edition Dewitt

https://textbookfull.com/product/worldviews-an-introduction-to-
the-history-and-philosophy-of-science-third-edition-dewitt/

Introduction to geography people places environment


Dahlman

https://textbookfull.com/product/introduction-to-geography-
people-places-environment-dahlman/
An Introduction to
Economic Geography

In the context of great economic turmoil and uncertainty, the emergent conflict between
continued globalisation and growing economic nationalism means that a geographical
economic perspective has never been so important. An Introduction to Economic Geography
guides students through the key debates of this vibrant area, exploring the range of ideas and
approaches that invigorate the wider discipline.
This third edition includes new chapters on finance, cities and the digital economy,
consumption and the environment. Underpinned by the themes of globalisation, uneven
development and place, the text conveys the diversity of contemporary economic geography
and explores the social and spatial effects of global economic restructuring. It combines a
critical geographical perspective on the changing economic landscape with an appreciation of
contemporary themes such as neoliberalism, financialisation, innovation and the growth of new
technologies.
An Introduction to Economic Geography is an essential textbook for undergraduate students
taking courses in Economic Geography, Globalisation Studies and more broadly in Human
Geography. It will also be of much interest to those in Planning, Business and Management
Studies and Economics.

Danny MacKinnon is Professor of Regional Development and Governance and Director of the
Centre for Urban and Regional Development Studies (CURDS) at Newcastle University, UK.

Andrew Cumbers is Professor in Regional Political Economy at the University of Glasgow, UK.
An Introduction to
Economic Geography
Globalisation, Uneven Development
and Place
Third Edition

Danny MacKinnon and


Andrew Cumbers
Third edition published 2019
by Routledge
2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, OX14 4RN

and by Routledge
711 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10017

Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business

© 2019 Danny MacKinnon and Andrew Cumbers

The right of Danny MacKinnon and Andrew Cumbers to be identified as authors of this work has
been asserted by them in accordance with sections 77 and 78 of the Copyright, Designs and
Patents Act 1988.

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form
or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including
photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission
in writing from the publishers.

Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and
are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe.

First published by Pearson Education Limited 2007


Second edition published by Routledge 2014

British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data


A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data


A catalog record has been requested for this book

ISBN: 978-1-138-92450-5 (hbk)


ISBN: 978-1-138-92451-2 (pbk)
ISBN: 978-1-315-68428-4 (ebk)

Typeset in MinionPro
by Apex CoVantage, LLC

Visit the eResources: www.routledge.com/9781138924512


Contents

List of figures ix
List of tables xii
Preface to the third edition xiv

Part 1 FOUNDATIONS 1

1 Introducing economic geography 3


1.1 Introduction 3
1.2 Key themes: globalisation, uneven development and place 5
1.3 The economy and economic geography 14
1.4 A political economy approach 17
1.5 Outline of the book 22

2 Approaches to economic geography 26


2.1 Introduction 26
2.2 Spatial analysis 29
2.3 The new economic geography 32
2.4 Geographical political economy 34
2.5 New approaches in economic geography 42
2.6 Summary 53

3 From regional specialisation to global integration: changing


geographies of production 58
3.1 Introduction 58
3.2 The dynamics of capitalist production 59
3.3 Industrialisation and regional specialisation 70
3.4 From Fordism to flexible production 77
3.5 New international divisions of labour 86
3.6 Summary 92

v
Contents

Part 2 RESHAPING THE ECONOMIC LANDSCAPE:


DYNAMICS AND OUTCOMES 97

4 Capital unbound? Spatial circuits of finance and investment 99


4.1 Introduction 99
4.2 Money, credit and debt 100
4.3 The changing geographies of money 102
4.4 Financial crises and cycles 106
4.5 The 2008–09 crisis, recession and faltering recovery 109
4.6 The financialisation of the economy? 119
4.7 Financialisation and the urbanisation of capital 123
4.8 Summary 126

5 Managing capitalism: states and changing forms


of economic governance 130
5.1 Introduction 130
5.2 Understanding the changing nature of the ‘qualitative state’ 131
5.3 States as managers of national and regional economies 135
5.4 Varieties of capitalism 143
5.5 Neoliberalism, crisis and austerity 147
5.6 Governing urban and regional development 156
5.7 Summary 162

6 Restructuring work and employment 167


6.1 Introduction 167
6.2 Conceptualising labour, work and social reproduction 168
6.3 Globalisation and the restructuring of work 174
6.4 Polarisation, flexibilisation and precarity in the labour market 180
6.5 Labour agency in the global economy 185
6.6 Summary 193

7 Geographies of development 197


7.1 Introduction 197
7.2 The project of development 198
7.3 Theories of development 204
7.4 Divergent trajectories of development 211
7.5 Trade, liberalisation and livelihoods 214
7.6 Contesting development: new forms of social and political mobilisation 217
7.7 Summary 221

vi
Contents

Part 3 REWORKING URBAN AND REGIONAL ECONOMIES 225

8 Connecting cities: transport, communications and


the digital economy 227
8.1 Introduction 227
8.2 Transport infrastructure and urban and regional development 228
8.3 Changing geographies of the digital economy 234
8.4 The sharing economy 240
8.5 Smart cities 244
8.6 Summary 248

9 Global production networks and regional development 254


9.1 Introduction 254
9.2 The global production networks (GPN) approach 256
9.3 Global production networks and regional development 265
9.4 Attracting and embedding FDI as a development strategy 272
9.5 Summary 277

10 Urban agglomeration, innovation and creativity 282


10.1 Introduction 282
10.2 Cities, agglomeration and knowledge 283
10.3 Cities, innovation and clusters 287
10.4 Creative cities 295
10.5 Summary 303

Part 4 REORDERING ECONOMIC LIFE 307

11 Consumption and retail 309


11.1 Introduction 309
11.2 Understanding consumption, consumers and commodities 310
11.3 Changing patterns of consumption 313
11.4 Spaces and places of consumption 317
11.5 The restructuring and internationalisation of retail 325
11.6 Summary 328

12 Economic geography and the environment 331


12.1 Introduction 331
12.2 Nature, climate change and economic development 332

vii
Contents

12.3 A critical economic geography of the environment 336


12.4 Sustainability transitions: the multi-level perspective and beyond 343
12.5 The emerging economic geography of energy transition 347
12.6 Summary 354

13 Alternative economic geographies 358


13.1 Introduction 358
13.2 Capitalism and its alternatives 359
13.3 Alternative economic spaces 363
13.4 Alternative global networks of trade and development 373
13.5 Summary 377

Part 5 PROSPECTS 381

14 Conclusions 383
14.1 Summary of key themes 383
14.2 Contested futures: globalisation, inequality and populism 385

Glossary 389
Index 405

viii
Figures

1.1 The 13-county Bay Area 4 3.8 Location of the textiles industry in
1.2 Scales of geographical analysis 6 northern England, 1835 74
1.3 ‘A shrinking world’ 7 3.9 Europe in 1875 75
1.4 GDP by country 11 3.10 The US manufacturing belt 76
1.5 Employment in financial and business 3.11 Shipbuilding employment in Britain, 1911 77
services in Britain, 2005 16 3.12 Ford assembly line 78
1.6 Banana split: who gets what in the 3.13 The manufacturing belt in the former
banana chain 18 Soviet Union 80
1.7 Italian industrial districts 20 3.14 The regional distribution of employment
2.1 Demand and supply curves 27 in Britain, 1841–1981 82
2.2 Weber’s locational triangle 30 3.15 The location of ‘Silicon Valley’ 85
2.3 Central places in southern Germany 31 3.16 Hourly compensation costs, in
2.4 Returns to scale 32 US dollars, in manufacturing, for
2.5 Dialectics 35 selected countries 2003, 2015 88
2.6 Urban gentrification in Glasgow 37 3.17 Offshore processing in airline and
2.7 Examples of possible spatial structures 39 insurance industries 90
2.8 The regional development bicycle 47 4.1 The geography of the debt crisis
2.9 Typical mismatch between development in the 1980s 107
strategies and institutions: (a) ‘penny 4.2 Growth of world gross product and
farthing’ equilibrium; (b) ‘square wheels’; gross domestic product by country
and (c) ‘bicycle frame’ situation 48 grouping 2007–17 110
2.10 Towards an alternative model of local 4.3 The geography of foreclosures in the US
industrial evolution 51 as of May 2009 113
2.11 International financial links of 4.4 US unemployment rates by state
south-east England 52 October 2009 114
3.1 The process of production under 4.5 Gross domestic product (GDP) per
capitalism 60 inhabitant in purchasing power standard
3.2 North-east England, regional setting (PPS) in relation to the EU-28 average,
and settlements 62 by NUTS 2 regions, 2014 116
3.3 Kondratiev cycles 66 4.6 Eurozone ten-year government bond
3.4 Chicago and the American railroad yield rates 117
network, 1861 69 4.7 Monthly commodity price indices by
3.5 Surface mail (1866–69) and telegraph commodity group, January 2002–June
transmission (1870), times in days 70 2016 (Index numbers, 2002 = 100) 118
3.6 The process of cumulative causation 72 4.8 Net global capital flows for developed and
3.7 UK manufacturing employment, 1851 73 developing economies 1996–2011 ($Bn) 120

ix
Figures

5.1 A world of states 132 7.8 India: manufacturing exports, wage


5.2 Ownership of Norwegian industry earnings and GDP relative to the rest of
broken down by owner type the world, 1985–2014 214
(NOK billion) 141 7.9 Regional concentrations of textiles and
5.3 Public sector employment as a clothing industry employment in the
percentage of total employment, 2009 main production locations, Tunisia 215
and 2013 142 7.10 An MST protest march 218
5.4 The location of the Singapore-Johor 7.11 Hydrocarbon taxes in Bolivia 1996–2009 220
Bahru-Batam/Bintan growth triangle 8.1 Inverted-U-shaped impact of declining
in South-east Asia 146 transportation costs on agglomeration 229
5.5 The geography of China’s ‘open door’ 8.2 Necessary conditions for transport to
trading policy 150 stimulate regional economic development 230
5.6 Trends in general government debt, as 8.3 The Channel Tunnel and the Eurostar
a percentage of GDP, selected countries Rail network 232
1993–2012 152 8.4 Exponential growth of the internet 234
5.7 Net migration, Ireland (000s), 1987–2013 153 8.5 The video games industry in Montreal,
5.8 Greek GDP and debt levels 2007–14 154 Quebec, Canada 236
5.9 The employment gap in OECD countries 156 8.6 Number of internet users per 100
5.10 The overall result of the UK referendum inhabitants 2000–15 238
on EU membership, 23 June 2016 157 8.7 High-speed internet use for individuals
6.1 Mapping the elite in twenty-first-century by Metropolitan Statistical Area 2013 239
Britain 170 8.8 Airbnb’s tax saving in London 242
6.2 Gender pay gap in selected OECD 8.9 Share of US population participating in
countries 172 the collaborative economy 243
6.3 Share of manufacturing in employment 8.10 New Songdo City, South Korea 246
and value added (current prices) for G7 9.1 The crankshaft’s long journey 255
countries 1970–2012 176 9.2 Apple’s smiling curve and the
6.4 Part-time employment as a proportion of organisation of global value chains 256
total employment: selected countries 182 9.3 A generic production network 257
6.5 Comparisons in levels of legal job 9.4 The laptop PC production network 260
protection in selected countries 1985–2013 183 9.5 Fundamental categories of embeddedness 262
6.6 UK workers employed on zero-hours 9.6 China’s automobile cluster 263
contracts 2000–16 183 9.7 The strategic coupling of regions and
6.7 Trade union density by selected OECD global production networks 266
country 1960–2012 187 9.8 Silicon Glen 268
7.1 The global North and South 198 9.9 Evolving spatial distribution of Taiwanese
7.2 Changing conceptions of development 200 investment in mainland China, 1991–2006 271
7.3 Rostow’s stages of economic development 205 10.1 Metropolitan area growth, United States
7.4 Dependency theory 206 (1980–2000) and human capital (share
7.5 Oxfam cow loan scheme 210 with bachelor’s degree 1980) 286
7.6 Ratio of GDP per capita of selected 10.2 The linear model of innovation 288
countries and country groups to GDP 10.3 The interactive model of innovation 288
per capita of the United States, 1950–2015 211 10.4 Apple’s iPod 289
7.7 GDP growth and changing terms of trade 10.5 Porter’s diamond model 291
in Latin America, 2002–13 212 10.6 Local buzz and global pipelines 294

x
Figures

10.7 Annual number of citations of the term 12.3 The devastating effects of the early
‘creative cities’ as recorded by Google monsoon in Bangladesh, September 2017 335
Scholar, 1990–2012 296 12.4 Central Park amidst skyscrapers 338
10.8 Artist locations in Minneapolis– 12.5 Aerial view of the Fukushima Daiichi
St Paul 298 Nuclear Power Plant 340
10.9 Talent and cultural amenities 299 12.6 The multi-level transitions perspective 344
10.10 Talent and coolness 299 12.7 Global electricity production by fuel
11.1 Christmas consumption 312 type 2014 348
11.2 Macy’s: a famous New York department 12.8 Global new investment in renewable
store with nineteenth-century origins 314 energy by region, 2004–16 349
11.3 (a) The original retail district in 12.9 Top ten onshore wind manufacturers with
nineteenth-century New York; (b) region of manufacture 352
Downtown Manhattan retail area 315 13.1 New Lanark in 1799 360
11.4 McDonald’s in Beijing 318 13.2 The iceberg model 364
11.5 The decline of US retail stores and 13.3 Participants and amount of Trueque
growth of online shopping 323 local currency scheme 369
11.6 The decline of the UK high street 324 13.4 Alternative modes of urban living in
12.1 The link between industrialisation, fossil Glasgow’s community gardens 372
fuels and global warming 333 14.1 The ‘Elephant Graph’: Relative changes in
12.2 Producers of greenhouse gas emissions per capita income by global income level,
by sector 334 1988–2008 386

xi
Tables

2.1 Economics and economic geography 28 5.3 Regional dependence on the public
2.2 Approaches to economic geography I 28 sector: share of public sector in regional
2.3 Fordist and post-Fordist modes of employment and output, UK, 2010 143
regulation 40 5.4 Characterising five types of state 144
2.4 Approaches to economic geography II 43 5.5 Regional inequalities. Variance of the log
3.1 Quantities of wheat and cloth production 67 of regional GDP per capita 158
3.2 The spatial division of labour in 5.6 Regional policy paradigms 160
manufacturing 81 6.1 Summary of social classes 169
3.3 Hymer’s stereotype of the new 6.2 Youth labour force participation by
international division of labour 87 region and sex 1991 and 2014 180
4.1 Geographical development of the 6.3 Distribution of income within selected
financial system 103 developing countries 181
4.2 Top ranked currencies in terms of 7.1 The UNDP Human Development Index 201
distribution of global foreign exchange 7.2 Progress in achieving the Millennium
market turnover 105 Development Goals 202
4.3 Ranking of global financial centres by 7.3 Theories of development 204
Global Financial Centre Index (GFCI) 7.4 Actual and projected annual economic
September 2015 106 growth figures (GDP% change) in
4.4 Key moments in the rolling out of the BRICS economies 2003–15 213
financial crisis 111 7.5 Principles and practices associated with
4.5 European banks with exposed trading post-neoliberalism in Latin America 219
positions with Lehman at time of collapse 111 8.1 High-speed rail lines in the world,
4.6 Government support (loans) and share selected countries 231
purchases of nationalised banks during 8.2 Groups of innovations in the sharing
2008–09 financial crisis (as of 31st March economy 241
2011) 112 9.1 Characteristics of producer-driven and
4.7 The pathway to financialisation: a buyer-driven chains 258
schematic depiction of the changing 9.2 Firms as actors in the global production
relations between finance, production and networks 259
labour in the evolution of capitalism 121 9.3 Firm-specific strategies and
5.1 Major regional economic blocs 134 organisational outcomes in global
5.2 The costs of bailing out the banks, production networks 265
selected countries as of March 2011, 9.4 Advantages and disadvantages of FDI for
percent of 2010 GDP 137 host regions 273

xii
Tables

9.5 Role and functions of local and regional 12.3 Discourses of the green economy 347
development agencies in FDI 275 12.4 The emergent geographical political
9.6 The average share of the total volume of economy of sustainability transition: a
automotive suppliers sourced by Czech- comparison of Danish and Chinese
based foreign firms (in %) 276 success 351
10.1 Territorial innovation models 290 13.1 Top ten cooperatives by
10.2 Different forms of proximity 293 income 2014 361
10.3 Artistic specialisations, selected metros 297 13.2 The Bamako Accord: a manifesto for an
10.4 The creativity index 300 alternative globalisation 362
11.1 Brand values for selected global brands 320 13.3 Diverse identities of childcare and their
11.2 World’s top ten retailers by revenue 2015 325 geographies 365
11.3 The changing orientation of Tesco’s 13.4 Coal-based exclusions from Norwegian
international operations 2000–17 326 Pension Fund, 2017 367
12.1 Main contemporary approaches in 13.5 Key facts and figures on credit unions
geography to economy-nature-society worldwide, 2015 370
relations 337 13.6 Mainstream and alternative economic
12.2 Carbon democracy and energy transition 342 geographies of globalisation 376

xiii
Preface to the third edition

In this third edition of our textbook, our main aim is with similar content on key processes underpinning
to provide students with a sense of the diversity and the economy, but modified (as three rather than four
vitality of economic geography as a lens to critically chapters) and updated. Part 2, now titled ‘Reshaping the
examine the changing economic landscape. The book economic landscape: dynamics and outcomes’ features
is intended as an introductory text for undergraduate updated substantive chapters on the state, labour and
geography students, preparing them for further more development with a new Chapter 4 (‘Capital unbound?
specialist study. The first and second editions were very Spatial circuits of finance and investment’) that is a
well received both by students and teachers, regarded substantially revised version of Chapter 9 (‘The uneven
as innovative books that, at the same time, strived to geographies of finance’) from our second edition. Parts 3
keep abreast of a dynamic and volatile global economy. and 4, ‘Reworking urban and regional economies’ and
We are gratified by the positive feedback that we have ‘Reordering economic life’, provide a significant amount
received both from students and the course convenors of new material. Part 3 (‘Reworking urban and regional
and tutors that have used the book. economies’) contains two new chapters (Chapters 8 and
As was the case with the second edition, which 10): ‘Connecting cities: transport, communications and
appeared in 2011, and was largely written in the midst the digital economy’ and ‘Urban agglomeration, inno-
of the global financial crisis, this third edition was writ- vation and creativity’, alongside another, ‘Global pro-
ten during a time of continuing economic and politi- duction networks and regional economic development’,
cal turmoil. Alongside the ‘economic’ crisis dimension, that brings together key themes from the second edi-
there is also a sense of ecological crisis as the realities of tion’s chapters on transnational corporations and com-
global warming become increasingly apparent. While modity chains and global production networks. Part 4
the immediate crisis threatening the global economy includes new chapters on ‘Consumption and retail’
may have subsided in recent years, the subsequent (Chapter 11), ‘Economic geography and the environ-
‘recovery’ has been a rather muted affair, with little sign ment’ (Chapter 12) and an updated chapter, ‘Alternative
at the time of writing (February 2018) of renewed stabil- economic geographies’ (Chapter 13).
ity or prolonged growth. In addition to the crisis-prone We have retained the pedagogic features of boxes,
tendencies of the world economy, widening inequalities reflective questions and exercises. In addition to the
between people and places, policies of austerity and the changes we have made to the print version of the book,
growth of a populist backlash against globalisation are this edition is novel in featuring accompanying eRe-
key contemporary trends that are emphasised in this source features on the Routledge website with supple-
third edition. mentary materials for instructors and students.
In seeking to keep abreast of such changes, this third We are very grateful to our editors at Taylor & Fran-
edition has undergone some substantial revision from cis, Andrew Mould and Egle Zigaite, for their support
the second. We have replaced the threefold structure of and endless patience. We would also like to thank the
the second edition: ‘Foundations’; ‘Actors and processes’; six anonymous referees who provided excellent feed-
and ‘Contemporary issues’ with a four-part text (fol- back and suggestions for improvement from the previ-
lowed by a conclusion). Part 1 ‘Foundations’ remains, ous edition and constructive advice on the new edition.

xiv
PART 1
Foundations
Chapter 1
Introducing economic geography
unlikely trigger for social conflict, they had become
Topics covered in this chapter symbolic of acute local concerns about the impact of
a dramatic process of gentrification (the movement of
³ The main themes of the book: wealthier groups into an area) on housing affordability
O globalisation and connections across space; in San Francisco and the Greater Bay Area (Schafran
O uneven geographical development; 2013), a conflict that is being echoed in global cities like
O the importance of place; London. In recent years, the renowned urban charms
³ The meaning of the economy. of San Francisco have made it a popular bedroom city
³ The nature of economic geography as an
for people who work in the booming high-tech indus-
academic subject. tries of ‘Silicon Valley’ – the shorthand term for the
world-leading cluster of electronics and internet indus-
³ The political economy approach to economic
geography that we adopt in this book. tries around San Jose and Palo Alto in the south Bay Area
(Figure 1.1). This has fuelled the gentrification of many
neighbourhoods, with spiralling house prices mak-
ing the city increasingly unaffordable to many lower-
1.1 Introduction income residents, leading to rising eviction rates from
2011 (Corbyn 2014). It is the resultant social tension
In late 2013, a wave of local protests and marches broke that animates the protests against the commuter buses,
out in San Francisco against Google’s commuter buses laid on by Google and other technology companies to
(Corbyn 2014). While commuter buses may seem an transport their workers to their offices in Silicon Valley.

3
Foundations

Folsom
Sacramento
Petaluma Napa Vacaville
Marin Fairfield Elk Grove
Novato Solano
Vallejo Sacramento
San Rafael
Richmond
Concord Lodi
Berkeley Antioch
San Francisco Oakland
Contra Costa Stockton San Joaquin

Hayward Livermore Manteca


Redwood City Tracy
Alameda
San Mateo Fremont Modesto
Palo Alto
Stanislaus
San Jose
Patterson Turlock
Santa Clara

Merced
Gilroy Merced

Los Banos

Figure 1.1 The 13-county Bay Area


Source: Schafran 2013: 668, Figure 1.

This collision between the process of economic immigrants, stretching back over many decades, giving
development based on high-technology industries and the Bay Area its characteristic social and racial diversity.
the existing social fabric of the urban landscape is at the The second theme is uneven development, whereby
heart of the economic geography perspective developed some countries and regions are more prosperous and
in this book, serving to illustrate its main themes. The economically powerful than others. The Bay Area is
first of these themes is globalisation, which refers to the richest major metropolitan area in the US on a per
the increased connections and linkages between people, capita (by population) basis, irrespective of whether
firms and markets located in different places, manifested this is measured by income or wealth, containing more
in flows of goods, services, money, information and peo- millionaires per capita than any other large metro-
ple across national and continental borders. Here, the politan area (ibid.: 23). Yet, as the protests over gen-
San Francisco Bay Area has attracted huge influxes of trification highlight, it is also one of the most socially
investment, becoming the leading centre of venture unequal, symbolising the wider trend of rising inequal-
capital in the United States (US). At the same time, its ity in the US. There are millions of ordinary low- and
booming housing market became a key outlet for the middle-wage workers who are not employed in the
money generated on Wall Street prior to the financial high-tech sector in a region with an extremely high cost
crash of 2008 (Walker and Schafran 2015). In addi- of living (ibid.). Over the past couple of decades, the
tion, economic growth has attracted large numbers of spread of urbanisation and the rising costs of housing

4
Introducing economic geography

in San Francisco and the Inner Bay Area more generally 1.2 Key themes:
have driven many of these groups to live further and
further out in the Central Valley counties of San Joa-
globalisation, uneven
quin, Stanislaus and Merced (Figure 1.1). This process development and place
is generally known as ex-urbanisation, representing an
extension of the well-established trend of suburbanisa- In this section, we build on the Bay Area example
tion to previously free-standing areas. Yet, reflecting its to examine the three main themes of the book –
intense housing boom, the Bay Area has been one of the globalisation, uneven development and place – more
regions worst affected by the post-2008 recession and fully. Our selection of these themes is informed by the
foreclosure (housing repossession) crisis. This has been basic geographical concepts of location and distance,
particularly concentrated in the new outer suburbs scale, space and place.
in the Central Valley, with the city of Stockton being
³ Location is perhaps the most basic geographical
declared bankrupt in 2013.
concept, referring to the geographical position of
Third, the social tensions surrounding gentrifica-
people and objects relative to one another (Coe
tion in the Bay Area also illustrate the theme of place,
et al. 2013), i.e. where things are. This is often rep-
in terms of how particular areas become entangled in
resented by maps (see Figure 1.1), and systems of
wider economic processes and the consequences of
grid references have been developed to convey this
this for their social make-up and identity. From the
information in a precise form. It is clearly related to
origins of San Francisco as the supply centre for the
distance which is the area or space between loca-
Californian gold boom of the late 1840s to the inter-
tions, for example cities such as Hong Kong and
net boom of the past couple of decades, the region has
London. Overcoming what geographers have tra-
been transformed by successive waves of investment
ditionally called the ‘friction’ of distance (the effort
and immigration. The alternative, bohemian identity
and cost of moving objects and people between
of San Francisco was established through the attrac-
locations) requires time and money, for example
tion of burgeoning counter-cultures associated with
the price of a long haul flight between London and
particular neighbourhoods such as hippies in Haight-
Hong Kong. The greatly increased ability of eco-
Ashbury and the gay rights movement in the Castro.
nomic actors such as Transnational corporations
For some residents and critics, it is these identities and
(TNCs) and banks to move money, goods, services,
diverse neighbourhoods that are being threatened by
information and people over large distances as a
gentrification as their social diversity gives way to the
result of the development in transport and commu-
male-dominated, affluent monocultures associated
nication technologies has been of great significance
with high-tech workers and entrepreneurs (Corbyn
for the reorganisation of the international economy
2014). For others, however, the latter are simply the lat-
in recent decades.
est wave of incoming pioneers which the region will be
³ Scale refers to the different geographical levels
able to accommodate in the same fashion as it accom-
modated previous migrants. of human activity, from the local to the regional,
national and global (Figure 1.2). They are import-
ant to the definition and organisation of economies
as indicated by the common use of terms such as
Reflect the local economy, national economy and global
economy by policy-makers, media commentators
Do you think that San Francisco will be able to accom-
modate the large-scale in-migration of high-tech work-
and citizens. It is important to see these different
ers and entrepreneurs whilst retaining its character scales of economic organisation as overlapping and
and identity? interconnected rather than viewing them as entirely
separate.

5
Foundations

Global

International/
Macroregional trans-national/
e.g. EU, North America, E. Asia supranational/
connections

National

Translocal
connections
Regional
e.g. California, north-east England

Local
e.g. Silicon Valley, City of London

Workplace

Figure 1.2 Scales of geographical analysis


Source: Castree et al. 2004: xvix.

³ Space is an area of the earth’s surface such as that personalised and comfortable homes. This domestic
contained within the boundaries of a particular transformation of space into place is something with
region or country. It is perhaps the most abstract and which we are all familiar, perhaps from decorating
difficult to grasp of the geographical concepts intro- rooms in university halls of residence or shared flats.
duced here, and is best understood by being related
to distance and place. Although a more general term,
space is related to the more specific notion of dis-
1.2.1 Globalisation and
tance and can also be expressed partly in terms of connections across space
the area between two points (locations) in space and The first underlying theme which runs through this
the time it takes to move between them. At the same book is that economic activities are connected across
time, it is often contrasted with place, particularly space through flows of goods, money, information and
in terms of how spaces can be converted into places people. The concept of (economic) globalisation can
through human occupation and settlement be defined as a process of economic integration on a
³ Place refers to a particular area (space) to which a global scale, creating increasingly close connections
group of people have become attached, endowing it between people and firms located in different places. It
with human meaning and identity. This is evident is manifested in terms of increased flows of goods, ser-
in how the occupation of San Francisco neighbour- vices, money, information and people across national
hoods by particular counter-cultural groups has and continental borders. These flows are not new as
defined their character and identity. The geogra- trading relations between distant people and places
pher Tim Cresswell (2013) illustrates the distinction involving the exchange of goods have existed through-
between space and place by referring to an adver- out much of human history. The notion of globalisa-
tisement in a local furniture shop entitled ‘turning tion, however, emphasises that the volume and scope
space into place’, reflecting how people use furni- of global flows has increased significantly in recent
ture and interior décor to make their houses mean- decades (Dicken 2015). Increased trade and economic
ingful, turning them from empty locations into interaction between distant places is dependent on

6
Introducing economic geography

technology in terms of the ease of movement and com- mobile telephones. The effects of these ‘space-shrinking
munication across space. technologies’ have brought the world closer together,
A new set of transport and communications tech- effectively reducing the distance between places in
nologies has emerged since the 1960s, including jet air- terms of the time and costs of movement and commu-
craft, shipping containerisation, the internet, email and nication (Figure 1.3).

1500–1840

Best average speed of horse-drawn vehicles


and sailing ships was 10 mph

1850–1930

Steam locomotives averaged 65 mph


Steam ships averaged 36 mph
1950s

Propellor aircraft 300–400 mph

1960s

Jet passenger aircraft 500–700 mph

Figure 1.3 ‘A shrinking world’


Source: Dicken 2003: 92.

7
Foundations

Similarly, the rise of new information and commu- financial transactions, the impact of internet technolo-
nications technologies (ICTs) such as the internet have gies, the creation of increasingly global consumer mar-
made it possible for large volumes of information to be kets, the power of TNCs to relocate economic activities
exchanged at a fraction of the previous cost, resulting to other countries, the rise of new economic powers like
in ‘time-space compression’. The term was introduced China, India and Brazil and the role of international
by the geographer David Harvey (1989) who argued economic organisations in managing the global econ-
that the process of ‘time-space compression’ has been omy (Box 1.1). This complexity means that globalisa-
driven by the development of the economy, requiring tion cannot itself be held ultimately responsible as the
geographical expansion in search of new markets, sup- single cause of other related problems such as social and
plies of labour and materials. Investments in transport economic inequality. Such problems are likely to have
and communications infrastructure have facilitated many causes, and national and local factors are often
this process of geographical expansion, reducing the bound up with the operation of global forces. Further-
effects of distance as it becomes easier and cheaper more, globalisation is an ongoing set of processes rather
to transmit information, money and goods between than a final condition that has actually been achieved:
places. As such, time and space are effectively being “although there are undoubtedly globalising forces at
compressed through the development of new tech- work, we do not have a fully globalised world” (ibid.: 7).
nologies. This is not an entirely novel process with a In both the academic literature and much popu-
previous ‘round’ of time-space compression occurring lar commentary, the term globalisation is used in two
towards the end of the nineteenth century through distinct senses (Dicken 2015: 3). The first is empirical
inventions such as railways, steamships, the telegraph or factual, referring to the actual changes that have
and the telephone. occurred in the organisation and operation of the world
While globalisation has become a key buzzword of economy. This is often represented in statistics such as
the last couple of decades, it should not be viewed as a figures on the volume of world trade, financial flows or
single, unified phenomenon or thing, but as a group of the number of internet users. The second is ideologi-
interrelated processes and activities (Dicken 2015: 6). cal and refers particularly to the free market, neolib-
These include the vastly increased volume of global eral ideology or world view of globalisation as a project

Box 1.1

Managing globalisation: international economic organisations

These organisations were created to countries experiencing budget- between rich and poor countries.
at the end of the Second World War ary problems allows the IMF to See www.worldbank.org/
as part of the Bretton Woods sys- set conditions requiring countries ³ The World Trade Organisation
tem, alongside the regime of fixed to reform their economies. See (WTO), established in 1995, tak-
exchange rates. Since the early www.imf.org/ ing over from GATT (the General
1980s, their policies have been ³ The World Bank (officially the Agreement on Tariffs and Trade).
shaped by neoliberalism (Box 1.2). International Bank for Recon- The role of the WTO is to ensure
struction and Development). Its a free and open trading sys-
³ The International Monetary Fund role is to provide development tem, working through successive
(IMF). The role of the IMF is to assistance to countries, mainly ‘rounds’ or conferences where
promote monetary cooperation in the less developed world. The member countries come together
between countries, and to support Bank runs a range of programmes to negotiate agreements. See
economic stability and trade. The and initiatives aimed at reducing www.wto.org/
provision of financial assistance poverty and narrowing the gap

8
Introducing economic geography

(Box 1.2) (ibid.: 3). The two are often confused. While of trade negotiations. It was a key moment in the for-
they are often linked together in practice – typically, mation of a counter-globalisation movement which
for instance, neoliberal world views emphasise certain espouses a more open, participative ‘bottom-up’ model
factual aspects of globalisation such as increases in of globalisation. The counter-globalisation movement
international trade, but exaggerate their meaning and opposes the top-down model of neoliberal globali-
significance to support certain political objectives such sation, associating it with increased corporate con-
as reduced government intervention in the economy – trol, policies of privatisation and liberalisation, and
they have distinct meanings. Accordingly, drawing an large-scale inequality and poverty in the global South
analytical distinction between the empirical and ideo- (developing world) particularly. In the wake of the
logical aspects of globalisation is important because it post-2008 economic crisis, the focus of protest and
helps to develop a clearer understanding of what can be action moved away from globalisation per se to focus
a complex and confusing concept. on issues of inequality and the adoption of austerity
After the collapse of Soviet communism and the policies by governments through movements such as
broader Cold War order, globalisation became closely Occupy and the protests in Greece. This underlines the
tied to claims about the “triumph of free market crucial point that globalisation is not only a topic of
capitalism” (Jones 2010: 9). This was promoted and endless academic discussion, but also the subject of
justified through a neoliberal project that portrays glo- active political contestation and conflict (Routledge
balisation as a mutually beneficial and inevitable pro- and Cumbers 2009).
cess which increases economic well-being by enabling The real significance of the move towards a more
a more efficient allocation of resources through the integrated global economy lies not so much in its quan-
market and free trade, leading to reduced poverty over titative extent (for example, the volume of trade or
the longer term. number of countries involved), but in the qualitative
While the neoliberal project of globalisation transformation of economic relationships across geo-
encountered little sustained opposition through much graphical space (Dicken 2015: 6). This emphasises the
of the 1990s, a new wave of opposition and protest intensification and spending up of economic relations
emerged with the so-called ‘Battle in Seattle’ in Decem- and economic life as the world economy has become
ber 1999. Seattle brought together a large number of increasingly interconnected. As economic geogra-
protesters to demonstrate against neoliberal globali- phers, we are particularly interested in the impact
sation and the WTO’s efforts to launch a new round of these changes on urban and regional economies.

Box 1.2

Neoliberalism

A central feature of the period since promotion of free markets and private to the private sector and the dereg-
the 1970s has been a changing property rights and the reduction of ulation of labour markets. Since the
economic policy context, with the state involvement in the economy. It 1970s, it has replaced Keynesianism –
emergence of a dominant set of pol- involves the advocacy of more spe- based on a commitment to full employ-
icy prescriptions which have exerted cific reforms to further this objective ment and state intervention to stimulate
a powerful influence on the think- through measures such as trade lib- growth during periods of recession –
ing of many politicians, business eralisation, financial market deregu- as the dominant mode of thought gov-
leaders, commentators and inter- lation, the elimination of barriers to erning global economic policy-making
est groups. Neoliberalism in simple foreign investment, the privatisation (section 5.5).
terms entails a commitment to the or selling of state-owned enterprises

9
Foundations

In particular, sub-national economies have become broader economic shocks such as the 2008 financial
increasingly exposed to a range of global flows and crash and subsequent recession. Here, we are par-
influences. The impact of globalising forces on local, ticularly interested in the flexibilisation of employ-
regional and national economies can best be under- ment and labour markets that has occurred since the
stood in relation to the following key dimensions of 1980s, linked to a sectoral shift from manufacturing
change (Coe and Jones 2010). to services in developed countries and the growth of
part-time and contract employment, coupled with
³ Financialisation which emphasises the increasing
reductions in employment stability and security (the
role of financial motives, financial markets, financial
end of the job for life). These changes have been most
actors and financial institutions in daily life (Epstein
prevalent in Anglo-Saxon countries such as the US,
2005). This is a process that has been developing
United Kingdom (UK) and Australia, reflecting their
since at least the 1980s, but was dramatically high-
strong attachment to neoliberal policies (Box 1.2)
lighted by the financial crash of 2008 in terms of eco-
which have championed the need to create flexible
nomic reliance on the major banks (‘too big to fail’)
labour markets, supported by curbs on trade union
and high levels of household indebtedness. The latter
power. While flexibility is attractive to business, it is
reflects the easy availability of credit before the crash
associated with greater insecurity and precarity for
as people acquired a range of financial products and
a significant proportion of the workforce (Coe and
services such as mortgages, ‘sub-prime’ loans and
Jones 2010: 6).
credit cards.
³ Increased competition which represents a central
aspect of globalisation through the liberalisation of 1.2.2 Uneven development
trade and the reduction of barriers between national A basic feature of economic development under
markets. This can have very different impacts on capitalism is its geographical unevenness. Uneven
different industries and the cities and regions in development is an inherent feature of the capital-
which they are located. It has enabled some indus- ist economy, reflecting the tendency for growth and
tries and firms to expand into global consumer investment to become concentrated in particular
markets (think of banks and internet search engines locations. These areas may be favoured by a par-
like Google), while exposure to competition and the ticular set of advantages such as their geographical
removal of traditional government protections has position, resource base, availability of capital or the
rendered other industries and firms less competitive, skills and capabilities of the workforce. Once growth
often leading to plant closures and unemployment. begins to accelerate in a particular area, it tends to
This is characteristic of not only some manufactur- ‘suck in’ investment, labour and resources from sur-
ing industries like textiles and steel in developed rounding regions. Capital (investment) is attracted by
countries but also agricultural and other primary the opportunities for profit whilst workers are drawn
industries in developing countries in the global by abundant job opportunities and high wages. Sur-
South, in some cases triggering political protests and rounding regions are often left behind, relegated to a
demonstrations. subordinate role supplying resources and labour to
³ Flexibilisation which refers to the effects of global- the growth area.
isation and increased competition in requiring sub- One key aspect of the process of uneven economic
national and national economies to become more development is that it occurs at different geographical
flexible. This involves them responding quickly and scales (Figure 1.2). This can be illustrated with refer-
efficiently to wider forces of change such as com- ence to three key scales of activity: the global, regional
petition, technological change, market trends and and local.

10
Introducing economic geography

³ At the global level, there is a marked divergence underdeveloped interior (Box 1.3). Developed coun-
between the ‘core’ in North America, Japan and tries are also characterised by regional disparities,
Western Europe and the ‘periphery’ in the ‘global such as the persistent north-south divide which has
South’ of Asia, Latin America and Africa (see characterised the economic geography of the United
Figure 1.4). This pattern reflects the legacy of colo- Kingdom since the 1930s.
nialism, whereby the core countries in Europe and ³ Even on a local level within cities, uneven develop-
North America produced high-value manufac- ment is present in the form of social polarisation
tured goods and the colonies produced low-value between affluent middle-class neighbourhoods and
raw materials and agricultural products. Whilst a poorer inner city areas and public housing schemes
number of East Asian countries, including China, or projects. For example, a study of neighbourhood
have been able to overcome this legacy, experienc- inequality in the eight largest Canadian cities found
ing rapid growth and rising prosperity over the past that it has increased between 1980 and 2005 (Chen
25 years, others, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, et al. 2012). This was due to differential growth in
have been left behind, experiencing conditions of family earnings which rose rapidly for the most
extreme deprivation and poverty. affluent families whilst declining or stagnating for
³ Within individual countries too, economic dispar- the poorer ones. A strong pattern of residential clus-
ities between regions are evident. The rapid eco- tering, whereby affluent people tend to live in afflu-
nomic development of China, for instance, has ent areas and poorer people in poorer ones, meant
opened up a growing divide between the booming that this resulted in increased inequality between
coastal provinces in the south and east and a poor, neighbourhoods.

GDP per capita 2015 (US$ PPP)


80,000

70,000

60,000

50,000

40,000

30,000

20,000

10,000

0
United Arab United Japan European Russia Brazil China Bolivia India Kenya Haiti Somalia
Emirates States Union

Figure 1.4 GDP by country


Source: www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2004rank.html.

11
Foundations

Box 1.3

Rapid economic growth and uneven development in China

Since the Communist regime opened regional inequality often reflects the force, are migrants from the coun-
up its economy to attract foreign speed and magnitude of economic tryside, often leaving their families
investment in 1978, China has expe- and social transformation, meaning behind in their rural villages of origin.
rienced rapid economic development, that it is generally highest in coun- In recent years, the Chinese gov-
becoming a world manufacturing and tries undergoing rapid industrialisa- ernment has placed more emphasis
assembly centre, with the economy tion and development which tends to on the development of the interior,
growing at an average rate of 10 per be concentrated in particular regions linked to a rebalancing away from
cent per year from the early 1980s to (World Bank 2009). Economic growth export-led growth towards the domes-
2012. As a result, GDP per capita was has created a complex pattern of tic market, particularly in response to
35 times higher in 2011 than 1978, regional inequality in China, though the effects of the financial crisis in
lifting over half a million people out of the underlying divide is between 2008 (Yang 2013). This has fostered
poverty (Knight 2013). Rapid growth the coastal regions and the interior. rapid industrial growth in parts of cen-
has, however, created considerable The ‘open door’ policy was initially tral and western China with the city
strains in terms of environmental based on the designation of special of Chongqing in Sichuan province,
degradation, increased inequality and economic zones in the coastal prov- for instance, becoming a key centre
the ruling Communist Party’s ability inces to attract foreign investment, of personal computer manufactur-
to manage the social pressures gener- encouraging these regions to ‘get rich ing (Yang 2017). This highlights the
ated by people’s rising expectations. quick’ (Wei 1999: 51). Coastal prov- dynamic nature of uneven develop-
The rate of GDP growth actually fell inces such as Guangdong, Jiangsu, ment processes, particularly in con-
to an average of 7 per cent between Zhejiang, Fujian and Shandong expe- ditions of rapid economic growth as
2012 and 2015 (although many rienced rapid growth in the 1980s new centres of production emerge
commentators are sceptical of these and 1990s, while much of the inte- while established ones undergo peri-
official figures), sparking fears about rior lagged behind. This fuelled the ods of restructuring. In recent years,
economic slowdown in the context of migration of millions of rural work- as some interior provinces have expe-
reduced demand from China for com- ers to the coastal cities in search of rienced rapid development, the flow
modities such as oil, copper and iron employment, generating what has of migrants to the coastal regions has
ore, as well as broader imbalances in been called the largest mass migra- slowed markedly and some migrant
the economy. tion in human history. As a result, workers have returned to their home
The experience of China since 55 per cent of China’s population areas, with Chongqing, for instance,
1978 is consistent with the argu- now lives in cities, compared to less attracting around 300,000 returning
ment that uneven geographical devel- than 20 per cent in 1978 (Anderlini migrant workers in 2014 (ibid.).
opment is inherent to the process of 2015). About 275 million workers,
economic development. The degree of more than a third of China’s labour

The process of economic development is highly the specialised economic base of formerly prosperous
dynamic in nature as new technologies are developed, regions can be undermined by reduced demand, rising
new forms of customer demand emerge and work costs, competition and the invention of new products
practices change. Over time, patterns of uneven devel- and methods of production. On a global scale, the most
opment are periodically restructured as capital invest- dramatic change in patterns of uneven development is
ment moves between different locations, investing in the emergence of East Asia as a dynamic growth region
those which offer the highest rate of return (profit). over the last 30 years or so (Box 1.3). Within devel-
As a result, new growth regions emerge whilst estab- oped countries, established industrial regions based on
lished ones can experience stagnation and decline. As nineteenth- and early twentieth-century industries such
broader market conditions and technologies change, as coal, steel and shipbuilding have experienced decline

12
Introducing economic geography

whilst new growth centres have emerged in regions It has become increasingly clear in recent years that
such as the south and west of the US (the so-called ‘sun- globalisation is a differentiated and uneven process,
belt’), southern Germany and Cambridge in England. generating different outcomes in different places. In
particular, it seems to be associated with a resurgence
of certain regions as economic units in recent decades.
1.2.3 The importance In particular, the success of dynamic growth regions
such as the City of London, Silicon Valley, Taipei in
of place
Taiwan and Guangdong and Shanghai in China are
The role of place in shaping economic activity is a third rooted in the specialised production systems that have
key theme of this book. As we suggested in the previous flourished there. Geographical proximity seems to
section, processes of uneven geographical development encourage close linkages and communication between
have created distinctive forms of production in partic- firms, enabling them to share information and resources.
ular places. During the nineteenth and early twenti- The existence of a large pool of skilled labour is a crucial
eth century, specialised industrial regions emerged in feature of such regions, allowing firms to recruit easily
Europe and North America. As a result, and workers to move jobs without leaving the local area.
These aspects of the local production system encourage
. . . distinct places are associated with sectoral and
innovation and entrepreneurship, enhancing their com-
functional divisions of labour. In the United States
petitiveness within the global economy.
for example, “Pittsburgh meant steel, Lowell meant
Whilst globalisation is not leading to the erasure of
textiles, and Detroit meant automobiles” (Clark et al.
place in absolute terms, it does undermine traditional
1986: 23), while in the United Kingdom, “one finds
notions of places as homogenous and clearly bounded
metal workers in the Midlands, office professionals
local areas. In response, there is a need to rethink place
in London, miners in South Wales, and academics
in terms of connections and relations across space
in Oxford” (Storper and Walker 1989: 156).
(Massey 1994). It is in this sense that the British geog-
(Peck 1996: 14)
rapher Doreen Massey’s work on the development of a
Although some of these specific associations have been ‘global sense of place’ is of particular interest. Massey
weakened by deindustrialisation, the general point develops a new conception of place as a meeting place,
about distinctive forms of production being associated a kind of node or point where wider social relations and
with particular places remains important. The City of connections come together:
London continues to be associated with finance and
. . . what gives place its specificity is not some
business services, for instance, Los Angeles with mov-
long internalised history but the fact that it is
ies and Milan with clothing design and fashion. Sil-
constructed out of a particular constellation of
icon Valley in California has become the hub of the
social relations, meeting and weaving together at a
internet and social media industries, building on its
particular locus. . . . Instead . . . of thinking of places
previous success in electronics and computers. This
as areas with boundaries around them, they can be
geographical variety of local economies is continually
imagined as articulated moments in networks of
reproduced through the interaction between wider
social relations and understandings . . . and this in
processes of uneven development and local politi-
turn allows a sense of place which is extroverted,
cal, social, economic and cultural conditions. These
which includes a consciousness of its links with the
conditions reflect the economic history of a place in
wider world, which integrates in a positive way the
terms of the particular industries found there and the
global and the local . . .
institutions and practices associated with them. In
(Massey 1994: 154–5)
general, the interaction between the legacies of estab-
lished industries and institutions and emerging forces From this perspective, place can itself be regarded as a
of economic change shapes and moulds the economic process rather than being seen as a static and unchanging
landscape (Massey 1984). entity. Places are connected and linked through wider

13
Foundations

processes of uneven development operating through production – to make or provide particular commodities.
flows of capital, goods, services, information and people. It relies on a supply of resources from nature, mean-
Movement of particular commodities like bananas, for ing that economic activities have a direct impact on the
example, links different parts of the UK to the econo- environment. The commodity, defined as any product
mies of certain Caribbean islands (see Box 1.5). or service that is sold commercially, is so basic to the
workings of the economy that Karl Marx described it
as the ‘economic cell form’ of capitalism. The modern
Reflect economy involves the production and consumption of
a vast array of commodities, spanning everything from
³ Do you agree that specific places (regions) remain smart phones to package holidays (Boxes 1.4, 1.5).
important within a global economy? Justify your Human societies have tended to organise and
answer with examples. structure their economic activities through overar-
ching modes of production. These can be defined as
economic and social systems which determine how
resources are deployed, how work is organised and how
1.3 The economy and wealth is distributed. Economic historians have identi-
economic geography fied a number of modes of production, principally sub-
sistence, slavery, feudalism, capitalism and socialism.
Each of these creates distinctive relationships between
1.3.1 The capitalist economy the main factors of production. Capitalism is clearly the
‘The economy’ refers to the interrelated processes of dominant mode of production in the world today, oper-
production, circulation, exchange and consumption ating at an increasingly global scale. It is defined by pri-
through which wealth is generated (Hudson 2005: vate ownership of the means of production – factories,
1). It is through such processes that people strive offices, equipment and money capital – and the asso-
to meet their material needs, earning a living in the ciated need for most people to sell their labour power
form of wages, profits or rent. Production involves to employers in order to earn a wage. This allows them
combining land (including resources), capital, labour to purchase commodities produced by other firms, cre-
and knowledge – commonly known as the factors of ating the market demand that underpins the capitalist

Box 1.4

Global commodity chains

Global commodity chains (GCCs) link consumers. Global commodity chains including the removal of milk from
together the production and supply have a distinct geography, linking supermarket shelves, against low
of raw materials, the processing of together different stages of produc- prices in August 2015. Exploring the
these materials, the production of tion carried out in different places production and consumption of par-
components, the assembly of fin- (Watts 2014). Some parts of the pro- ticular commodities helps us to trace
ished products, and the distribution, duction process add more value or and uncover economic connections
sales and consumption of these prod- profit, creating tensions between the between places, linking different
ucts. They involve a range of different different participants in the supply localities to global trading networks
organisations and actors, for example chain over who captures this value. and showing how the range of goods
farmers, mining or plantation compa- Relationships between large super- (such as milk) that we consume on a
nies, component suppliers, manu- markets and their suppliers are a daily basis are produced, distributed
facturers, subcontractors, transport good example of this tension, with and sold.
operators, distributors, retailers and farmers in the UK staging protests,

14
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
The Project Gutenberg eBook of Los cien mil hijos
de San Luis
This ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this ebook or online at
www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you will
have to check the laws of the country where you are located before
using this eBook.

Title: Los cien mil hijos de San Luis

Author: Benito Pérez Galdós

Release date: September 11, 2023 [eBook #71614]


Most recently updated: November 5, 2023

Language: Spanish

Original publication: Madrid: Obras de Pérez Galdós, 1904

Credits: Ramón Pajares Box. (This file was produced from images
generously made available by The Internet Archive/Canadian
Libraries.)

*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK LOS CIEN MIL


HIJOS DE SAN LUIS ***
Índice: I, II, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, XIII, XIV, XV, XVI, XVII,
XVIII, XIX, XX, XXI, XXII, XXIII, XXIV, XXV, XXVI, XXVII, XXVIII, XXIX, XXX,
XXXI, XXXII, XXXIII, XXXIV, XXXV, XXXVI.

Nota de transcripción

Los errores de imprenta han sido corregidos.


La ortografía del texto original ha sido modernizada de acuerdo con las normas
publicadas en 2010 por la Real Academia Española.
Las rayas intrapárrafos han sido espaciadas según los modernos usos
ortotipográficos.
Las notas a pie de página han sido renumeradas y colocadas al final del párrafo en
que se las llama.
EPISODIOS NACIONALES

LOS CIEN MIL HIJOS DE SAN LUIS


Es propiedad. Queda hecho el depósito
que marca la ley. Serán furtivos los
ejemplares que no lleven el sello del autor
B. PÉREZ GALDÓS
EPISODIOS NACIONALES
SEGUNDA SERIE

LOS CIEN MIL HIJOS


DE

SAN LUIS

33.000

MA DRID
O B RAS DE P É RE Z G AL DÓ S
132, Hortaleza
1904
EST. TIP. DE LA VIUDA E HIJOS DE TELLO
IMPRESOR DE CÁMARA DE S. M.
C. de San Francisco, 4.
LOS CIEN MIL HIJOS
DE SAN LUIS

Para la composición de este libro cuenta el autor con materiales


muy preciosos. Además de las noticias verbales, que casi son e
principal fundamento de la presente obra, posee un manuscrito que le
ayudará admirablemente en la narración de la parte o tratado que lleva
por título Los cien mil hijos de San Luis. El tal manuscrito es hechura
de una señora, por cuya razón bien se comprende que será dos veces
interesante, y lo sería más aún si estuviese completo. ¡Lástima grande
que la negligencia de los primeros poseedores de él dejara perder una
de las partes más curiosas y necesarias que lo componen! Solo dos
fragmentos sin enlace entre sí llegaron a nuestras manos. Las
laboriosas indagaciones para allegar lo que falta han sido inútiles, lo
que en verdad es muy lamentable, porque nos veremos obligados a
llenar con relatos de nuestra propia cosecha el gran vacío que entre
ambas piezas del manuscrito femenil resulta.
Este tiene la forma de Memorias. Su primer fragmento lleva po
epígrafe De Madrid a Urgel, y empieza así:
I

En Bayona, donde busqué refugio tranquilo al separarme de m


esposo, conocí al general Eguía.[1] Iba a visitarme con frecuencia, y
como era tan indiscreto y vanidoso, me revelaba sus planes de
conspiración, regocijándose en mi sorpresa y riendo conmigo del gran
chubasco que amenazaba a los francmasones. Por él supe en e
verano del 21 que Su Majestad, nuestro católico rey don Fernando
(que Dios guarde), anhelando deshacerse de los revolucionarios po
cualquier medio y a toda costa, tenía dos comisionados en Francia, los
cuales eran:
[1] Puede verse el retrato de este personaje en las Memorias de un
Cortesano de 1815.

1.º El mismo general don Francisco Eguía, cuya alta misión era
promover desde la frontera el levantamiento de partidas realistas.
2.º Don José Morejón, oficial de la secretaría de la Guerra, y
después Secretario reservado de Su Majestad con ejercicio de
decretos, el cual tenía el encargo de gestionar en París con e
gobierno francés los medios de arrancar a España el cauterio de la
Constitución gaditana, sustituyéndole con una cataplasma anodina
hecha en la misma farmacia de donde salió la Carta de Luis XVIII.
Alababa yo estas cosas por no reñir con el anciano general, que era
muy galante y atento conmigo; pero en mi interior deploraba, como
amante muy fiel del régimen absoluto, que cosas tan graves se
emprendieran por la mediación de personas de tan dudoso valer. No
conocía yo en aquellos tiempos a Morejón; pero mis noticias eran que
no había sido inventor de la pólvora. En cuanto a Eguía, debo deci
con mi franqueza habitual que era uno de los hombres más pobres de
ingenio que en mi vida he visto.
Aún gastaba la coleta que le hizo tan famoso en 1814, y con la
coleta el mismo humor atrabiliario, despótico, voluble y regañón. Pero
en Bayona no infundía miedo como en Madrid, y de él se reían todos
No es exagerado cuanto se ha dicho de la astuta pastelera que llegó a
dominarle. Yo la conocí, y puedo atestiguar que el agente de nuestro
egregio soberano comprometía lamentablemente su dignidad y aun la
dignidad de la corona, poniendo en manos de aquella infame muje
negocios tan delicados. Asistía la tal a las conferencias, administraba
gran parte de los fondos, se entendía directamente con los partidarios
que un día y otro pasaban la frontera, y parecía en todo ser ella misma
la organizadora del levantamiento y el principal apoderado de nuestro
querido rey.
Después de esto he pasado temporaditas en Bayona, y he visto la
vergonzosa conducta de algunos españoles que sin cesar conspiran
en aquel pueblo, verdadera antesala de nuestras revoluciones; pero
nunca he visto degradación y torpeza semejantes a las del tiempo de
Eguía. Yo escribía entonces a don Víctor Sáez, residente en Madrid, y
le decía: «Felicite usted a los francmasones, porque mientras la
salvación de Su Majestad siga confiada a las manos que por aqu
tocan el pandero, ellos están de enhorabuena.»
En el invierno del mismo año se realizaron las predicciones que yo
por no poder darle consejos, había hecho al mismo Eguía, y fue que
habiendo convocado de orden del rey a otros personajes absolutistas
para trabajar en comunidad, se desavinieron de tal modo, que aquello
más que junta parecía la dispersión de las gentes. Cada cual pensaba
de distinto modo, y ninguno cedía en su terca opinión. A esta variedad
en los pareceres y terquedad para sostenerlos llamo yo enjaezar los
entendimientos a la calesera, es decir, a la española. El marqués de
Mataflorida[2] proponía el establecimiento del absolutismo puro
Balmaseda, comisionado por el gobierno francés para tratar este
asunto, también estaba por lo despótico, aunque no en grado tan
furioso; Morejón se abrazaba a la Carta francesa; Eguía sostenía e
veto absoluto y las dos Cámaras, a pesar de no saber lo que eran una
cosa y otra, y Saldaña, nombrado como una especie de quinto en
discordia, no se resolvía ni por la tiranía entera ni por la tiranía a media
miel.
[2] Conocido por don Buenaventura en las Memorias de un cortesano
y en La segunda casaca.

Entre tanto, el gobierno francés concedió a Eguía algunos millones


de los cuales podría dar cuenta si viviese la hermosa pastelera. Dios
me perdone el mal juicio; pero casi podría jurar que de aquel dinero
solo algunas sumas insignificantes pasaron a manos de los pobres
guerrilleros, tan bravos como desinteresados, que desnudos
descalzos y hambrientos, levantaban el glorioso estandarte de la fe y
de la monarquía en las montañas de Navarra o de Cataluña.
Las bajezas, la ineptitud y el despilfarro de los comisionados
secretos de Su Majestad no cesaron hasta que apareció en Bayona
también con poderes reales, el gran pájaro de cuenta llamado don
Antonio Ugarte, a quien no vacilo en designar como el hombre más
listo de su época.
Yo le había tratado en Madrid el año 19. Él me estimaba en gran
manera, y, como Eguía, me visitaba a menudo, pero sin revelarme sus
planes. Desde que se encargó de manejar la conspiración, seguíala yo
con marcado interés, segura de su éxito, aunque sin sospechar que le
prestaría mi concurso activo en término muy breve. Un día Ugarte me
dijo:
—No se encuentra un solo hombre que sirva para asuntos
delicados. Todos son indiscretos, soplones y venales. ¿Ve usted lo que
trabajo aquí por orden de Su Majestad? Pues es nada en comparación
de lo que me dan que hacer las intrigas y torpezas de mis propios
colegas de conspiración. No me fío de ninguno, y en el día de hoy
teniendo que enviar un mensaje muy importante, estoy como
Diógenes, buscando un hombre sin poder encontrarlo.
—Pues busque usted bien, señor don Antonio —le respondí—, y
quizás encuentre una mujer.
Ugarte no daba crédito a mi determinación; pero tanto le encarec
mis deseos de ser útil a la causa del rey y de la religión, que al fin
convino en fiarme sus secretos.
—Efectivamente, Jenara —me dijo—: una dama podrá desempeña
mejor que cualquier hombre tan delicado encargo, si reúne a la belleza
y gallarda compostura de su persona un valor a toda prueba.
En seguida me reveló que en Madrid se preparaba un esfuerzo
político, es decir, un pronunciamiento, en el cual tomaría parte la
Guardia real con toda la tropa de línea que se pudiese comprometer
pero añadió que desconfiaba del éxito si no se hacían con mucho
pulso los trabajos, tratando de combinar el movimiento cortesano con
una ruidosa algarada de las partidas del norte. Discurriendo sobre este
negocio, me mostró su grandísima perspicacia y colosal ingenio para
conspirar, y después me instruyó prolijamente de lo que yo debía
hacer en Madrid, del arte con que debía tratar a cada una de las
personas para quienes llevaba delicados mensajes, con otras muchas
particularidades que no son de este momento. Casi toda mi comisión
era enteramente confidencial y personal, quiero decir que e
conspirador me entregó muy poco papel escrito; pero, en cambio, me
repitió varias veces sus instrucciones para que, reteniéndolas en la
memoria, obrase con desembarazo y seguridad en las difíciles
ocasiones que me aguardaban.
Partí para Madrid en febrero del 22.
II

Con entusiasmo y placer emprendí estos manejos: con entusiasmo


porque adoraba en aquellos días la causa de la Iglesia y el trono; con
placer, porque la ociosidad entristecía mis días en Bayona. La soledad
de mi existencia me abrumaba tanto como el peso de las desgracias
que a otros afligen y que yo aún no conocía. Separándome de m
esposo, cuyo salvaje carácter y feroz suspicacia me hubieran quitado
la vida, adquirí libertad suma y un sosiego que, después de saboreado
por algún tiempo, llegó a ser para mí algo fastidioso. Poseía bienes de
fortuna suficientes para no inquietarme de las materialidades de la
vida: de modo que mi ociosidad era absoluta. Me refiero a la holganza
del espíritu, que es la más penosa, pues la de las manos, yo, que no
carezco de habilidades, jamás la he conocido.
A estos motivos de tristeza debo añadir el gran vacío de mi corazón
que estaba ha tiempo como casa deshabitada, lleno tan solo de
sombras y ecos. Después de la muerte de mi abuelo, ningún afecto de
familia podía interesarme, pues los Baraonas que subsistían, o eran
muy lejanos parientes, o no me querían bien. De mi infelicísimo
casamiento solo saqué amarguras y pesadumbres; y para que todo
fuese maldito en aquella unión, no tuve hijos. Sin duda Dios no quería
que en el mundo quedase memoria de tan grande error.
Fácilmente se comprenderá que en tal situación de espíritu me
gustaría lanzarme a esas ocupaciones febriles que han sido siempre e
principal goce de mi vida. Ninguna cosa llana y natural ha cautivado
jamás mi corazón, ni me embelesó, como a otros, lo que llaman dulce
corriente de la vida. Antes bien, yo la quiero tortuosa y rápida; que me
ofrezca sorpresas a cada instante y aun peligros; que se interne po
pasos misteriosos, después de los cuales deslumbre más la claridad
del día; que caiga como el Piedra en cataratas llenas de ruido y
colores, o se oculte como el Guadiana, sin que nadie sepa dónde ha
ido.
Yo sentía además en mi alma la atracción de la corte, no pudiendo
descifrar claramente cuál objeto o persona me llamaban en ella, n
explicarme las anticipadas emociones que por el camino sentía m
corazón, como el derrochador que principia a gastar su fortuna antes
de heredada. Mi fantasía enviaba delante de sí, en el camino de
Madrid, maravillosos sueños e infinitos goces del alma, peligros
vencidos y amables ideales realizados. Caminando de este modo y
con los fines que llevaba, iba yo por mi propio y verdadero camino.
Desde que llegué me puse en comunicación con los personajes
para quienes llevaba cartas o recados verbales. Tuve noticias de la
rebelión de los Guardias que se preparaba; hice lo que Ugarte me
había mandado en sus minuciosas instrucciones, y hallé ocasión de
advertir el mucho atolondramiento y ningún concierto con que eran
llevados en Madrid los arduos trámites de la conspiración.
Lo mejor y más importante de mi comisión estaba en Palacio, a
donde me llevó don Víctor Sáez, confesor de Su Majestad. Muchos
deseos tenía yo de ver de cerca y conocer por mí misma al rey de
España y toda su real familia, y entonces quedó satisfecho mi anhelo
Hice un rápido estudio de todos los habitantes de Palacio
particularmente de las mujeres: la reina Amalia, doña Francisca
esposa de don Carlos, y doña Carlota, del infante don Francisco. La
segunda me pareció desde luego mujer a propósito para revolver toda
la corte. De los hombres, don Carlos me pareció muy sesudo, dotado
de cierto fondo de honradez preciosísima, con lo cual compensaba su
escasez de luces, y a Fernando le diputé por muy astuto y conocedo
de los hombres, apto para engañarles a todos, si bien privado del valo
necesario para sacar partido de las flaquezas ajenas. La reina pasaba
su vida rezando y desmayándose; pero la varonil doña Francisca de
Braganza ponía su alma entera en las cosas políticas, y llena de
ambición, trataba de ser el brazo derecho de la corte. Doña Carlota
por entonces embarazada del que luego fue rey consorte, tampoco se
dormía en esto.
Los palaciegos, tan aborrecidos de la muchedumbre constitucional
Infantado, Montijo, Sarriá y demás aristócratas, no servían en realidad
de gran cosa. Sus planes, faltos de seso y travesura, tenían por objeto
algo en que se destacase con preferencia la personalidad de ellos
mismos. Ninguno valía para maldita la cosa, y así nada se habría
perdido con quitarles toda participación en la conjura. Los individuos
de la Congregación Apostólica, que era una especie de masonería
absolutista, tampoco hacían nada de provecho, como no fuera allega
plebe y disponer de la gente fanática para un momento propicio. En los
jefes de la Guardia había más presunción que verdadera aptitud para
un golpe difícil, y el clero se precipitaba gritando en los púlpitos
cuando la situación requería prudencia y habilidad sumas. Los
liberales masones o comuneros vendidos al absolutismo, y que a
pronunciar sus discursos violentos se entusiasmaban por cuenta de
este, estaban muy mal dirigidos, porque con su exageración ponían
diariamente en guardia a los constitucionales de buena fe. He
examinado uno por uno los elementos que formaban la conspiración
absolutista del año 22, para que cuando la refiera se explique en cierto
modo el lamentable aborto y total ruina de ella.

Nota del autor. A continuación refiere la señora los sucesos del 7


de julio. Aunque su narración es superior a la nuestra, por la graciosa
sencillez y verdad con que toda ella está hecha, la suprimimos, pues
no conviene repetir, aun mejorándolo, lo que ya apareció en otro
volumen.
III

Después de los aciagos días de julio, mi situación, que hasta


entonces había sido franca y segura, fue comprometidísima. No es
fácil dar una idea de la presteza con que se ocultaron todos aquellos
hombres que pocos días antes conspiraban descaradamente
Desaparecieron como caterva de menudos ratoncillos, cuando los
sorprende en sus audaces rapiñas el hombre sin poder perseguirlos, n
aun conocer los agujeros por donde se han metido. A mí me
maravillaba que don Víctor Sáez, hombre de una obesidad respetable
pudiera estar escondido sin que al punto se descubriese su guarida
Los palaciegos se filtraron también, y los que no estaban claramente
comprometidos, como por ejemplo, Pipaón, dieron vivas a la
Constitución vencedora, uniéndose a los liberales.
Tuve además la desgracia de perder varios papeles en casa de un
pobre maestro de escuela donde nos reuníamos, y esto me causó
gran zozobra; pero al fin los encontré, no sin trabajo, exponiéndome a
los mayores peligros. La seguridad de mi persona corrió también no
poco riesgo, y en los días 9 y 10 de julio no tuve un instante de respiro
pues por milagro no me arrastraron a la cárcel los milicianos borrachos
de vino y de patriotería. Gracias a Dios, vino en mi amparo un joven
paisano y antiguo amigo mío, el cual en otras ocasiones había ejercido
en mi vida influencia muy decisiva, semejante a la de las estrellas en la
antigua cábala de los astrólogos.
Pasados los primeros días, pude introducirme en Palacio, a pesa
de la formidable y espesa muralla liberalesca que lo defendía
Encontré a Su Majestad lleno de consternación y amargura
principalmente por verse obligado a poner semblante lisonjero a sus
enemigos y aun a darles abrazos, lo cual era muy del gusto de ellos
en su mayoría gente inocentona y crédula. No me agradaba ver en
nuestro soberano tan menguado corazón; pero si en él concordara e
valor con las travesuras y agudezas del entendimiento, ningún tirano
antiguo ni moderno le habría igualado. Su desaliento y desesperación
no le impidieron que se enamorase de mí, porque en todas las
ocasiones de su vida, bajo las distintas máscaras que se quitaba y se
ponía, aparecía siempre el sátiro.
Temerosa de ciertas brutalidades, quise huir. Brindéme entonces a
desempeñar una comisión difícil para lo cual Fernando no se fiaba de
ningún mensajero; y aunque él no quiso que yo me encargase de ella
porque no me alejara de la corte, tanto insté y con tales muestras de
verdad prometí volver, que se me dieron los pasaportes.
El mes anterior había salido para Francia don José Villar Frontín
uno de los intrigantes más sutiles del año 14, aunque, como salido de
la academia del cuarto del infante don Antonio, no era hombre de gran
iniciativa, sino muy plegadizo y servicial en bajas urdimbres. Llevaba
órdenes para que el marqués de Mataflorida formase una regencia
absolutista en cualquier punto de la frontera conquistado por los
guerrilleros. Estas instrucciones eran conformes al plan del gobierno
francés, que deseaba la introducción de la Carta en España y un
absolutismo templado; pero Fernando, que hacía tantos papeles a la
vez, deseaba que sus comisionados, afectando amor a la Carta
trabajasen por el absolutismo limpio. Esto exigía frecuentes
rectificaciones en los despachos que se enviaban y avisos
contradictorios, trabajo no escaso para quien había de ocultar de sus
ministros todos estos y aun otros inverosímiles líos.
Yo me comprometí a hacer entender a Mataflorida y a Ugarte lo que
se quería, transmitiéndole verbalmente algunas preciosas ideas de
monarca, que no podían fiarse al papel, ni a signo ni cifra alguna. Ya
por aquellos días se supo que la Seo de Urgel había sido ganada a
gobierno por el bravo Trapense, y se esperaba que en la agreste plaza
se constituyera la salvadora regencia. A la Seo, pues, debía yo
dirigirme.
La partida y el viaje no eran problemas fáciles. Esto me preocupó
durante algunos días, y traté de sobornar, para que me acompañase
al amigo de quien antes he hablado. A él no le faltaban en verdad
ganas de ir conmigo al extremo del mundo; pero le contenía el amo
de su madre anciana. No poco luché para decidirle, empleando
razonamientos y seducciones diversas; mas a pesar de la propensión
de su carácter a ciertas locuras y del considerable dominio que yo
empezaba a ejercer sobre él, se resistía tenazmente, alegando
motivos poderosos, cuya fuerza no me era desconocida. Al fin, tanto
pudo una mujer llorando, que él abandonó todo, su madre y su casa
aunque por poco tiempo, con la sana intención de volver cuando me
dejase en paraje donde no existiese peligro alguno. El infeliz
presagiaba sin duda su desdichada suerte en aquella expedición
porque luchó grandemente consigo mismo para decidirse, y hasta
última hora estuvo vacilante.
Aquel hombre había sido enemigo mío, o más propiamente, de m
esposo. Desde la niñez nos conocimos; fue mi novio en la edad en que
se tiene novio. Sucesos lamentables que me afligen al venir a la
memoria, caprichos y vanidades mías me separaron de él, yo creí que
para siempre; pero Dios lo dispuso de otro modo. Durante algún
tiempo estuve creyendo que le odiaba; pero el sentimiento que llenaba
mi alma era, más que rencor, una antipatía arbitraria y voluntariosa
Por causa de ella siempre le tenía en la memoria y en el pensamiento
Circunstancias funestas le pusieron en contacto conmigo diferentes
veces, y siempre que ocurría algo grave en la vida de él o en la mía
tropezábamos providencialmente el uno con el otro, como si el alma de
cada cual, viéndose en peligro, pidiese auxilio a su compañera.
En mí se verificó una crisis singular. Por razones que no son de este
sitio, llegué a aborrecer todo lo que mi esposo amaba y amar todo lo
que él aborrecía. Al mismo tiempo, mi antiguo novio mostraba hacia m
sentimientos tan vivos de menosprecio y desdén, que esto inclinó m
corazón a estimarle. Yo soy así, y me parece que no soy el único
ejemplar. Desde la ocasión en que le arranqué de las furibundas
manos de mi marido, no debí de ser tampoco para él muy aborrecible.
Cuando nos encontramos en Madrid, y desde que hablamos
caímos en la cuenta de que ambos estábamos muy solos. Y si había
semejanza en nuestra soledad, no era menor la de nuestros
caracteres, principal origen quizás de aquella. Hicimos propósito de
echar a la espalda aquel trágico aborrecimiento que antes nos
teníamos, el cual se fundaba en veleidades y caprichosas
monomanías del espíritu, y no tardamos mucho tiempo en conseguirlo
Ambos reconocimos las grandes y ya irremediables equivocaciones de
nuestra primera juventud, y nos maravillábamos de ver tan
extraordinaria fraternidad en nuestras almas. ¡Ser de este modo, habe

You might also like