You are on page 1of 221

 

     

   

 
 

%&'"  ()  !"#$      
1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0


$3
%4 &5 

673
* :;  &5  . 8
 
 @ A"  B
$ C DE F
<" =)&>" ?  
LMGM K J1GHIG

: N O C

a`SbT _`] 2Y Y^W


Y Y[\R]?U  SZT1 %YV TUVWTX RS?S T }
eH!>  { =)TT a(R%T7 TSbUS8 ][TYcU  S[ST

 
 : 
3 
$ : fDg

  f
h"
.1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0

%&'"  ()  !"#$      

:    [ $

%4 &5 2  :i < 


* :;  &5 .8 :%&


$3

6,

:   
>,
+ ,  -
./ 0

%&'"  ()        #$  : k"  -l  Cj"  @   
>, `b&"O
m1' ! 2 *  
FO N3 p FO @ *   + ,  -
o @ 0
  nq 2   n&"o [ >O : 

n&"o

. nq @ v  ( ete ) 1$ r F  ,$   


.F  n&4 xy F") h" %zX  { w!   | FO : 

w!

:wl"  18
.(e 2 HMM) r
}~ nzO *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       + " [3 KG
.(e 2 It) r
}~ nzO *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + " [3 KL
()         + " 0 `yV M,MG + " $ lD~3  )   #$   KI
+       + " 2 &
 8 {" }~ *   + ,  -
o @ 0
  + %&'" 
.%&'"  !l)   &
 *   + ,  -
o @ 0
 
.       nV ~"? `F  B
$ [ ?V    $ V8 [8 KH

:X "  18


.+ ,  -
o 3 y 0 j (j  0  #  0 B
$ `&  KG
.`&  0 k3 *O  F&
-
 @ 
 x n.,O x  KL
.0

   :V E &"1) x  KI
.0

F  D   E &"1) x  KH
.lb"  #$ B
$ C D
(z 8 Xz  ~O3 x  Ke

Department: Administrative Sciences


Specialty: Administrative Sciences
Study Abstract
Study title: morale and its relationship to the organizational loyalty of the
employees of the Saudi Shura Council from their prospective .
Student: Bader Mohammed AlJeraisy
Advisor: Prof. Mohammed Sayed Hamzawi
Research Problem: The study problem is represented in the following question:
what is the relationship between morale level and the organizational loyalty for
the employees in the Saudi Shura Council from their prospective?
Study Poplation : It consists of all the employees in the Saudi Shura Council from
the (h to the fourteenth grade who are 575 workers at all the sec,ons .
Research Methodology : The study followed the descriptive survey methodology
through the use of research as a tool to collect data.
Main results:
1- The morale level of the employees in the Saudi Shura Council is high with
degree (4.00/5).
2- The organizational loyalty level for all the employees in the Saudi Shura Council
is high with degree (3.97/5)..
3- There is a direct relationship that has a statistical evidence at the level 0.01
between the morale level and the organizational loyalty level of workers in the
Saudi Shura Council. Therefore, it is clear that the better morale is of the workers,
the more they have organizational loyalty.
4- The individuals of the study sample agree on the ways that help raising morale
in this study.
Main recommendations:
1- To improve the human l relations between managers and employees inside
departments and sections of the Shura Council.
2- There is a necessity to encourage the supreme administration in the Council to
agree on the initiatives that lead to work improvement .
3-It is necessary to take in consideration intangible incentives of the workers.
4-It is of high value to maintain the physical well being for employees .
5-It is necessary to install exceptional allowances for the efficient workes.

(13

xE   (<   .. 0&b  * N3


    
V  D   !F 8
'E `  
O8 | ) *Z  %&
 N3
k  * 
+ ?"  B
$ &$  C
 8 3 N3
~ . *TT
"! .. X i5 ` N3
n " *! x *18

}~F 

?O >7
B
X &5 )  `&y F B
$ #  x#D  ED  "O "&  *Z  &E
: 0 q8 FX \ B
$ 
$ 
) 
~ a a 2 FV    Z1 3 k  [y %
$  8 2  >78  ;yV
.~   z  1 F$ 2 (, 2 iD
z 
? *Z  $  B
$ Fl + ,  -
o -l k  N3 [") r  >,  ' ?O8
*Ab>  ; 2 7  "  *"8 `z   x  N3  !   V @ -
 0


  C&>" 
E xA 
X  @ `z    28 *Z  + ,  -
o $
.A ` $  :.V 0  A {X X8     C: ) [  
 i

2 :: F$  "  "  



      -l k  N3 C X  >, 
xZO8 nq %F>  $  "  " 
   
 &$ x  N3 *  ?X
Z1 p #3 ! 2  ZF  B
$  
  xZO8 =X D >   4
. !&
$ 2 0
1  #<  %&
 D 
    
  -l x  *"8 %&
 %l$ *?O *>7  8 &
[y <
O    Z1 B
$ %&
 67 < O *Z  * :;  &5  "  "
! " [>V    Z1 3 `F @ &
$ "

! CZ #8 `F X   &

[8 V  D  
$ 2 [8 N O F  =#l %z @ '   D DO
."; i , >
2 `   (?V `&  (# x    x >"  ($8 >78 [8 O z )
E ;8 ?   7 . :(:$ x  f B
$ "

8 ! 8 ($ $8

&5 *   &5 D  X "  ` , D   *:&?  i " :xZO


. F  n&4 V  [8 N O  =#l .C# (#$ $ 8

}~F 

 " &l







     

    



'

"#$ %&

-

() *+,

.$/ *+,

.%&1 *+,

345 *+,
' $ 9:  %;< : .$1 7


<"

>

9:  %;<

9:  (?@#

9:  B

9:   D

9:  '$4

G  $ (F

9: KL   M : IJ  7


2KL  :O : N?$

L 0$  : .$1 QR

TU  =

=>

 D1 >

=E

L 0$  T*? :F# V

=W

L 0$ <  +


M A

>\

L 0$  X YZ[ 7<  C

V>

L 0$  (&[<$ K< E

VP

L 0$  ] , H

A>

^* KL  ?  : IJ  QR

A>

^* KL  ?  TU < =

AH

^* KL  ?   D >

C\

^* KL  ?  +


_ V

C>

^* KL  ? Y  !`*L  A

E=

^* KL  ?  74< C

EH

^* KL  ?  X YZ[ 7<  E

WA

ab+c$ ^* KL  ?  :Zd H

WP

^* KL  ? $ L 0$  e ,5  W

P=

2'  f:;  gh ij YkRc : Q J  QR

=\=

"   (9:  : N cZ

=\=

L 0$  " (9:  =

=\A

^* KL  ?  " (9:  >

=\H

"   (9:  lj m "  V


9:  bUL (n : Q J  7


==\

9:  oUL<

==\

9:  p*h

===

9:  L j

==>

9:  Y'

==>

9:  Y' L =

==A

9:  Y' qr >

=>>

9:  Y' 3 RF# (n V

=>V

9:  X <  +
4 m 91 s A
Ub+c ;,L<$ 9:  (c 7 t$ uj : p   7


=>H

L   'v wr " o+L 

=V=

9:  x9y " o+L 


z r#$ 9:  o+c : g<M 7


=EP

9:  r5_

=H=

9:  o+c

=HP

9:  ( r#

=W>

:'
$ pn

=P\

9:  345<

C 4 &l
zD  



 

0b~F  $ %&'"  ()  `~

      + "  5 F 2 ?"


F z 8 ` 

      + "  5 z *" >  `


" 

%&'"  ()   5 F 2 ?"


F z 8 ` 

%&'"  ()  + "  5 z *" >  `


" 

      nV `F  5 F 2 ?"


F z 8 ` 

      nV `F  5 z *" >  `


" 

&  A" V   $ V8 n O

%&
 `1 A" V   $ V8 n O

zv  FO A" V   $ V8 n O

-
 `&    A" V   $ V8 n O

      + "  5 B
$   V8  ."

%&'"  ()  + "  5 F$ B


$   V8  ."

  *A" 0 #   ) " [ A FO `  wl"

      nV `F  5 F$ B


$   V8  ."

@ z
(One Way ANOVA) *~ 2F"  `
wl"

&  A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   V8  3 < "


&  V @ z
" LSD " F" wl"
@ z
( One Way ANOVA ) " *~ 2F"  `
" wl"

%&
 `1 A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   V8  3 < "
%&
"  * " V @ z
" LSD " F" wl"
@ z
( One Way ANOVA ) " *~ 2F"  `
" wl"

zv  FO A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   V8  3 < "
zv  FO V @ z
" LSD " F" wl"
@ z
( One Way ANOVA ) " *~ 2F"  `
" wl"

`&    A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   $ V8  3 < "
-
 `&    V @ z
" LSD " F" wl"

C>7 &l
zD  



 

GH

")       0 # 

    
 

O *  $ %&'"  ()   <O `~

A" $ %&'"  ()   #

%&'"  ()  2 >O @ x$ `


* 

tM

%&'"  ()  AzO @ x$ `


  :O >

tL

[.1 + %&'"  () 

%&'"  ()        0 #
 

+ ,  -
o @ '  , 3  <

GMM

+ ,  -
%&'"  `>

GM

~# &l
zD  



 

GG

!zlv !ly &l 0&> F" (G) 




LMM

l!   X @ F") (L) 




C  `Dz 
1 8   
>,
?
  
>,
  )jO
  618
  8
   ~
1z 
<D

C  `Dz 
1 8   
>,
JJ?J
'  %1 ` xE %~ 7  &'"  & ,  *Z  D  D"
C ~ 
    <O  "~
 ^  x~  *Z  * E
FDO   
2 !> / &' (8 @ &"  <"  `z>O  `F 
'O `> %l & "[ "   Z1 | O ? .!V18 ? ! 3

 @ V .
  O z  B
$ O  $&") z  %~   `&,"
D  [8 &) ! -z  
$ * -z  
 x V 
*8  [cV k"  'O ` x  1 %~   *4  >" ([) *,F 
 ? 2 $ &o =8 V "O [8 i ` &'"  F ?V FO ) &'
.&'"  F n * "  `& O }   
$, 2$ AF "

<D 2 =$ 0b~F  C O " (G) + 
   `&  2$         ! 
&$  z    ,  z 
N3 $ zD A,O %!V )  #DzO @ |z
" [3 
<D Z1 %zv 
[ >O   = ~
, *Z  `&  z    ,    $, &o
.(e) " 3 8 F


%1  1)  2 =(:  O %&'"  ()   [8 (G) [.1 +


  ?V . 8 Z  
 Co @ 0b~F  &"1 n 
`&  ?O " " @   `8  " @  Z %&'"  () 
B
$ iD !" @ % :O [ x" &' ^ }~ "%$&")
C>78 2  &" C C# 2 <
  *   Ay"  D V 
.(IM ) .&"  2"  zD"  ~ C>78 N3 >>
z  i 4 Dp  B
$ x 
$ @ bE 1) |&"1 ?
N3 |$  * >z  @  #  / =( 2! 
" @ 0


[8 N3 |V1  
   =  *," `>, &' @ `  ,
.
V , Z1  F.[ >O
z  E  > $, &!"zD %&'"  ()        ",O }~
8 C "O 6  b  5 1F"$   Z1 [cV &' @ z 
 xz
! 2 *   + ,  -
o @ 0
  + %&'"  ()  B
$      
. 1'

  
>,
!$ z8  wl"  | ?V " x(z>  nV ^ D  [  
 "! 2 1 [8 0
   7 $ xAF  " 2 F  ." 
..~ & F"  $, -~8  =,  >

x Co @  l7       Xp , [8 N3 (GL) 


 A,
,   V8   1$, 0
  ' ! 8 2$ Ab>  [  
O
[ 1  ." 6   "Western Electric" 7 @ *Z  l  }F 
    {FX8 # 2  b    E `F "Hawthorn"
.(Le)  , b >   ?  0   
0 FO #$ 1 [8         O *Z  0b~F  2 Ab>  +
( (LMM* p) [  " 
y x " +8 A"      
FO [ b~F  ~) & (LMMt 6$) -4 A"

(LMMeE) %zv 

Dh,  &  A" Z x~ B


$ ` %&'"  ()       
" ) ( LMMI O $) *?  &  8 (LMMe )

(LMML F$)

.(G *& ) (LMM 1: ) (LMM


[       | O       '  [cV }~F  #3 ( @
" ) 2 `      `b &
"  8  "  F  B
$ D"? !?F<O
(LMM * p) (LMMt 6$) (LMML F$) (LMM 1: ) (LMM

E) (G *& ) (J1GHMt *? ) (G +) (Ge #)
.(LMM *<$) (LMM [;) (LMM
   8 ^? ?   $ b  5   $ &
$ ~ B
$ }~F
0FO 
~)  cV + ,  -
o @ }~F  `&$ C# 2  %&'"  ()  B
$   
  &" y"  !
& 0zv  ()  F B
$ O  F
 #$  !v
Z1 @  8  D *8 .[Z") xb `&  @ l:  ^&E $ >"

()  @ = D [ >        @ z 2$ = [ > [8 2> C&$


B
$ 6 
=    Z1 (3 N3 ~ }~F  + ( B
$ .%&'" 
zh"  8 F
  1 '  n @ !O wl" N3 C X
2A" 2Z1 0 # 
@   Z1 
>, X 2> B
$ ( + ,  -
o @ 1\ 2
:k"  %l  Cj" 

2 *   + ,  -
./ 0

%&'"  ()        #$ 
m1' !

  )jO
J  
>, %l  Cj"  2  E   )jO X ?"7 2>
:k"    B
$
J! 2J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       + "  -
m1'
J! 2J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + "  -
m1'
+J %J&'"  () J  + "       + " 0 FO)   -
m*   + ,  -
o @ 0
 
J! 2J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F  -
m1'
+:J O    5 C ~ 0 F (\ @ lD~3  )  V  O `1 -
m zv  Dh,  A" F

  618
0
J
%J&'"  ()        #$ B
$ 6 "  N3  E   6
J$z  6J1 ? C# 2       >
& + ,  -
./
: " 
J! 2J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       + " [ -
.1'
.1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0

%&'"  ()  + " [ -
0
J  +J %&'"  ()         FO  B
$ 6 "  -
.*   + ,  -
./
J! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F [ -
.1'
C J~ 0 F (\ @ lD~3  )  V 1 [ 3  B
$ 6 "  -
.zv  Dh,  A" F +: O    5

  8
:&
 -
\ B
$ (  (? 3 $ 0

%&'"  ()        8 [
.2A" 2Z ?
" &
 '  * >z   8 @  
@ ! xz") "O } A" ^?  8  <O   C 
.+8 &
$

:
&  -
%J&'"  () J       #$ C "O    C  2 " O
J @ !"   [cV 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0


.  / <FO ~"? X "  (<$3 %
z  n 
BJ
$ !J xz") D"?O ) F?O 1l V [  @   8 B
."O
 F ," +  >E $<?  V @ ` *   + ,  -
o
.! &V `& 
() J  J    J  nV N3  `  ` zO N3   B O
.*   + ,  -
o @ 0

%&'" 
`>,J 1O [8 l!  wl"  X "  (<$3 C# 2   C 
.+ ,  -
./ 0
 
 F
  1 '  2 `
?"  @ %
&$

   ~
+J %J&'"  () J         @ `b&"O :$   E -
.*   + ,  -
./ 0
 
JFO [
, 2 *   + ,  -
o %zv / `b&"O :,F   E -
.,$    FO N3 p
J   J>
& J  J/ + ,  -
./ `b&"O :>  E -
.  
  x8 F<O V " *Z  (J1GHIG)   ""V ::   E -
. `
nq

1z 
<D
:%
    
<D `&,O
     
J1) J$ &o Jy (G) -h<  !V  :=~#<X       K
!lJj J&'  0
 
 >  z   E  
.( eI ) `&  @ !l# &$8
0
J  +J z   E y   Z1 @       }~F  6  K
^? B
$ !'O & ^& `&  N3 ! VO  *   + ,  -
./
.  Z1 @      

%&'"  () 
)  ,  + " y (LMMH) * !z  V  : =~#<X %&'"  ()  K
!VJ1 #J !&? :" )  "&' (3 v  $  "
.(GG ) ! 3 (&") h"V) !  FO) l   , 
+ ,J  -J
./ 0
J   D?V   Z1 @ %&'"  ()  8 K
 ,J  n &$y z"~) &") @ F  V18 ?" *  
.  Z1 @ %&'"  ()  ^ x8 @ !$  &  3 (&") hz 

b  `Dz 

'  z
p
*'   : =) 8
?     : =

b  `Dz 

'  z
p
*'   : =) 8
 * }~ %&'"  ()        
b&"    5 C "
:k"    B
$ 
=?
< [ >O 6   '    *' 

      :C  }F
:  !z KG
J
$ %$D  -z  
$ %$&") -z  
$   x i" N3 n 2
 J
(J&
 1  AF "  z "  2   !V  * -z 
Az"  8  "  i~X     Z1 2   8 =F ! `     
. ( GIM : G  F,  ) 1A 2 b8
J~ @ C "       " AF O [  8 ? ??E Z1 (.) 
$ 
 O n A  2 [ i ` 2 &  !<  &
 A  ~ B
$ O
J @ 0b~JF  F xAE FO) 2 =Ab iF *Z   Z `7 
.(GMI )  X &O 8 { C 
$,J 
DJ5 N3 A,J J$ {
<D ( Ge ) #  @ &   V
VDO >  ( Sentiments)   ( Attitudes) 1) ( Feelings)

J E N3 A,JO J   [cV z


&4  E N3 A,O D  [8 &>V V
.( G )   FD  1Z  z 
?b  B
$ &"   y (Gt *?  @) :
 C F& 2 2 ` !V 
.(Ie) `&   z
  ` z   %1 8 `&  @ x b
 J  N3 
D | = 7 D       AF O [8 +AV (GG ) %&!V 8
.( GI ) & 8 ^&E  D & (4  )
z   7       :  %,>F,  2$ Z ( Gt )  D   @
%1 V18 O~ ? z  O$X   $&4 n 4 z>O x  
J
& Jz  #$ @ !'O => =  `$z"O z
" ` $ x$ 2 i `
.( L)
 J
1AzO @ (G ) F,  C ? & (&
 : +8 ! 2
. ( GIM ) ( Team spirit) z    V 8   
`&   $&4 V 1 y j  Z1 V (G) :z !V V
t ) &' 618 ? `F @  BD8 CZF  2 n   [  " 
.(
J 8 J& 0
  ! *Z     ") (GL ) 
 $ %1
.( I ) p  =yO `8 !
$ & 2& ^& !,
x Jb Xc O>"  B
$ V 2 $ &o x? 8 ( LMM ) n  + &V
.( GI ) 0  61 ?" F

$q [  > 2Z  V 0 xl     8 l  : 8 (G ) A,


J$&.
#J J$&4 @   @ z  ? $&4 @ ?b  :&"O 
.( Lt ) $&4 618 `8 2 z>
 ")
N3 Jz  nV *Z  i"> % F<   ") 8 (LMMM) [  !V 
! V  ,
" !V 2 !, @ l# , B
$ ^& CF
J [ J
&  *ZJ  nJ&" J ! j !lj 1 ,
.( GHt )
J1Z  J E B
$       {
<D
<V (G F,  @)  F 8 8
.( GIM ) $q @
&  ? *Z  fh,
z 
x:J&" zJX y !V  & @ x   1  ~ y " A 0 " 
% ! $&4 ($8  , 1  ~ B
$
< {
<D %1 $&.

J> 8 " J!V  &    ?? 
 !  1   h"
2 Jb 0>&" `&  B
$ ^  2 $q x %1       [8 ? "[ 
.(G  GH  [ , ) ", 61 ?"
  B
$        !z AzO @ 1 x$ 1 [8 (GG) %&!V 0F
: k" 
: $&4 1) z  1) &"1) 2&"  *
2 N3 ?O       [8 Eric Gardner & Thompson 2 ` C ? }~
x J   ,J  8 $,J @ J$&4 n ~ "  8 $&4    08
. ! 3 (&") C# 2 F7

:        @ =8 $&4 FO Zh"  *


J      N3  "O 0~ $&") 
 6  xl  O ) Z1 `b
: GG%J&!V) . J~ % q 61 %   @ $&4 x b y $&.

. (L K Lt
8   J J
" `D"  7 8 B
$        !z X   $ `>,
$8  Cjz"  ^&E C&  !v8 cV `&     4 N3 A, ^&E
0J AJ V [ [8 8  $      y X  [8 2> 4 Z1 [cV
2> ! ` z    2 C>7 Z1 [cV j,"  ?")   !  O 0?

.(IH : G  + ) zh     
!' 8 B
$ ZO [8

 KL
N3 +8 J      x 
$ &"1 [8 N3 (LMM ) " @ "  A,
6,J") J."  -J  <" f" ~8 w  2 08 0$  3
C V   2 C# N3 6! b  ! C V   V $, AzO
.( GMI )!
$ 'V  $      n F
 
J$  J
>  x D  %1 ??E @       [8 ( LMM ) * p Z
 2$ 13 2> )    Z1 [cV Z `&   @ xl   # 
 V  Z1 ( I ) 0
  x8 2$ =& 8  ?  8 &
"  8  
=JV JzO ) +",O ) FO )       [8 : ( GtI ) n F$ 
.( IG ) `  xE `&
&l# 6 '  0y"  F ."  O !>

JF  D
 `b/ " :  F. Roethlisberger 2$ (G) :z `? &V
BJ
$ :Jz  "  "    @ !"&     
[cV %E 2l>
8 2
Jz> JO J  &'&
x:& #  %1          [8 : =z
x4 
  x 
D~ =8 %!V 1j7 8 !V 2> ) 2> 
$V
i<  %
   &O (8 @ ? *Z  ?"  + ^? V O cV B
$
.( t ) &' @
 J  + " [8 [  2 [8 @ (1982) %&!V O  n B7&" Z1
Quality and Success of

!J"$  x J +J ^J? J1 J  

J!<<  3 2~ B


$ `  ! V B
$ [ X Z management
.( LtG )
2J>  7 18 2       [8 (GI ) 1:   @  
V '"  618 ? @ !~ + x?    V + B
$ # 2 >E
 J  J? l?  &! x?   ^? %1  @        zO
.( I I )  @   
|Jz
" &! 0
 
 @ (Gt) *?  C ? &       O
x  [3 : ?  Z1 (LMM ) n   .( II ) %&'"  `> @ !  
nJV B
$ x?  &' (3 !"&'8 x  2 b8 !l$8 x  2 %1 &'
" x C# 2 "  !  n<"O  &' %1 1V      
.( GH ) V + >" )  

@ J18  z x  n  @ `>,O       [8 (GtI ) n F$ +


xJ [  J"3 x 2 > `
%
?  &4 ."  F >O

& `&  '" z    "  `  AV O [8 3 .( IM )  !o


? X  V "  6 ?" %z> ) ( Gt )  D  N3 A,
.( IG )  $      N3 *O &
 #$
 %1 8 &        N3 * iF  AF ~ N3 %1    "
J    J  0J J#  0FJ (G) J `>,J       &
."
: "

(G)  `>7


")       0 # 
JJJJJ zO

 JJJ 
  
zh

")

zh

 zO

(L :G:z :D)

2ZJ  h7 ? } 61 = 3 =#>O :


"O x &'"  xV
@ () Jp !J  &    " n x ,  zO    =  [
& 

cV zh      n " z>  ? [>3 2   B


$ . `>, 
* [8 y7 2  ` [  ? !" F< ^ V    ?   ? &O Z~
+J @ . " z N3   *   F." !$F73 1 $ N3
G :z )  ? &O @ [ z" ` <  + B
$ !> 
F?"  AD? 
. ( I L 
Jl!  
D 2 `> `&  $&4       ? (LMMG ) ?  
J$&4 J) {
<D 
$
<  1 1V8 0          [
x4 " B
$  `D 2       [  ( Group cohesiveness
.( eL ) x , z  ~  0

?" 2
=VJ1 J"  (G) Z & `&   @ 0

      nV [3
      (V @ |
,V [3 x [3 ` ?? x B
$ %F =8
r J ("  0
  0 7 ZO " r  3 N3 + 0
  0
 ~   N3 `DO [8 2>  [8 8  . (Lt ) `&  2
b>O   @ '~) }~ " Ryan and Smith" } [ 8 &
0 #$ 1 [8 xb>  Z x `&  6 v [ >O [8 [  $   E !V
.( M ) C&  0 xl        x1'  Z1
!  "O   2$ `?O ) xAF 8 V    [8 (G ) &5 C ?O
.( GIt)  :V E V>&
' F<O 8   nV  ?O $ , 
 J  J&O [  n<" #V   :&"O %!V (G) :z A, &
[ n<"JO %!V x$   !$ (%7 ` [  x~ x !   
B
$ `&  i Z K8 $ `  |
  $  -z   2 g

J$ J8 =J$ !7 i?$ =!7 \  $ F8 !"&O !"X !
$ 'V
.( M)
:%
  C# 2       8 {"O F  B
$ (
 + -> O &' @ x 
$V z B
$ 7       [8 K
.61 ? @ x? 
[J J&! !  J |z
" &! &' @ 0
 
 B
$ O 8 K
.%&'"  `> @ 1 
.") zO ( @ x z x        `>,O K
%JF ZJ J!$zO 2 8 $       z 2>& 2 8 K
.   B
$ !"X !
$ 'V

      &"1)  <O KI
   |&$O       8  !z [8 (G) F,  Z
.( GLt )N    E (8 *>  C @ |8  xAb>  &

Jl  @ J"y x | " [8  =b~ )3 $D  @  !z Z1 h"
`lJ @ &J ) +J 2 @  2 ~8  | [8  C&$
[8 BJ?  -zJ  (J&
$ ?"$ [ }~ .( GML : .  
$)  ? 
J<  J'  F<O  2$   n [ >O B
$ `&  %1 !"zv

J8 2J $:J  Z1 y< |"F8 ."  2> V F" $  > 
. V VDO
 B
$  D  B
$ &"  C: ) "V
BJ
$ `J&  iJ y ?"$) n `&  @       y 6"$) 8 
 n O C&
V"  w ?O B
$ x #$ y,     Z ! 
ZJ1 |
,JV  Welfare Capitalism  8  1V  $   1 !
$
CZJF
g )       [8 x ; | !z 8 V "$ }~ x>z 
. ( GGG GGM : .  
$ )  C
2ZJ  x CJ ? @   "  [ " 3 " [cV (GG ) %&!V Z &
(J&
$ J1 J  &       x1v AzO 6," B
$ !8  :
H. Simon [ J  1 ! C Z  <O 
  

  2 [ \

0b~JF  &"1  | }~ " ( GIe ) 1A C. Barnard  "7
J |J 0J~       / %$D  -z  
$ x )o @
@ ,J  ?$ Z %$D  -z  
$ Co @ Hawthorn [  
J" #>,J AF>  ? "  !v3 6!" %b w C# 2 2,  [? 
@ 0b~F  2 $ ( !>
   ,  w  Z1 @ "7 x(z>  "#$
[8 0b~JF
{O .( eI eL : LMMG ?  ) "2< @ V1  
x(3 2 `&  6 v 2$ x " `  z B
$ Ay"  @ z ` $ 1
@ J    
{ !V  %$ 2$ z8 ` V# ~ "V 
nJ %$&") !
>O $ & 1 @ C&
   ?
!  @ `& 
. (GGG : . 
$) .  i `&   

Co @  l7 |FX        Xp , [8 (GG ) %&!V C ?


J$ J &"1)  #F  Z1 @ `&   8 | [8  > x
GIe  % ?  `&  #$ [   X  =  &O C&  1 8
  1$,J 0
  ' ! 8 2$ Ab>   &
O 2 [8 Z &
{FJX8 JE Z1 C#  b    E `F [ 1   ,  !
V
E |&&$ &   , b >   ?  0       
$J Z " Testing for selection "# F") " h" N   
8 &  "2~8 (8 `8 2       " ' , B
$ b    E
J N3 Jb    E 8 0
  DO 4 (,3 N3 N    E
.( GI GIe ) >  p 0    p
[J
F  @ >J  J?
 O DDh" z  q 1 |
>7 
 8 @  &V !8  | q  " > .
 " ! 2 [  "
J
$ @  ) : [ $ | GeH  GH  0 &V , 
o
J  J
O wl" | .7  ( b    E C# %$&") -z 
BJ
$   2 : (3 B
$ 
&$ l V 2 !?F<O B
$ iOO  
. ( GL : G F,  ) .       FO)  i 4

    
  flDp KH
2J J1A 2J$       :    zD  flDp 2 $ &o 1 "
: ! F z  1) 1 ' 
`J& O  $&.
# z  C ~ zD  2 %1       [8 K8
.   618 ?" = 

2J> ) kJ"  x7F '~#&


ng ) z x1v       [8 K
. !.l" 1\  2$ 3 x7F !
J$&4 ZJ1 V8 B
$ < %z  8 z         [8 K
zhJO nzOO $&4 Z1 V8  ."
  @ \ !'O =  0
 
J iJ~ $&" z  6 v ` $ 2 $&4   i~
.~ F73 !V18 ? @ `,V 8  2 $&4 V8 VD
2J   !z 8 !$zO @ y"O x?  z x1v       [8 K
. z  $&")  V v `&  FOO  ` 
xl        [8 B
$ !l @ >E 2> A  x$     
[8 K
. ( GIe GII : G F,  ) . zh 8  zO $&4 V8 0F
: [8 " @ ( LMM ) 1:  f
h"
) =~ #
= $ [3 ~ ` 1 i D z$ 8 z  ~       8
A"J N3 J!$zO !z @ ng 3 }~       zO N3 *
.x "
`   <
   2$ 8  :V E BOy"O ) v &
      [8

`&  (8 2 >  &l# 6 '  0  `&   ( "~  2$


.( H ) 0 j l?  0 C z  [  "  1z"  "~) ?b 
$&4 n z  ~ " 7& h"O       [8 ( GG ) %&!V 
1 ^ `&  ?z z C&  2 , B
$ `  `&  @ "z

J    J  "z %1 1) [8 ^8 B


$ Employee Attitudes 0
 
.(Get)

:       @ x `  Ke
[3 `J  ZJ1        @ x `  C ~ 0b~F  (\  O ?
N3 `  Z1 ?O 2>& 2 8 ~) }~F  [8 )3 !
&o @  ~ N3 |,O
: 0$ 
.  F<  `  8
. z  $&") ` 
%JF $ &o @        > 8 l: ?"  5 `  Z1 `b
. 8 &' @       $  B
$ 6 "   !" x?  B
$
N3 J!  cV 
  x ?  y       ( GH ) [ , D 0~ %zV
: %1 8 A  #
.
&$ `  0 #  : C   
. O3 `  0 #  : b   
.( LMG ) l# `  0 #  : } b   
) J     
" [8  Halsey 2$ ( . ) 
$  8  V  Z1
.(GLL ) " !"&" O  6 '  B
$ `   `&   ( "~ )3 [ >
@ JO J  "  [  " 1~  6 '  N3 A,V (G)  $ 8
:  # @ $&.
     

. ", 61 $&.


[ > [8 1$ 2>    8
. Z  " =1 6 Z1 1$ "    
.(Get ) ?" [8 2> 6 [y V 1$  ,   

:  0l 0

"O       [8 (.) &$ i~ Kats + &V
. $&4 V ", 61   K
.(IG ) 6 ?" =$&"  F? <   K

}JF  <  `&$    "Berkowitz :" A " [8 (G ) + Z
[8 J!V `Jq8 " Marqunette | "    >7 @ > %&

J!V JO Jz z  ` 2 nFO 
 3       @ O  D
J
"O =J xAb Z1  F<  Z1 @ [   2    8 "Dh7
Z1 < [8 [ n<"  1 ! [  y" O  6 '  `>
.( It ) xE Z1 @  O  &
" Dh7 [ > 
$ ) 6 ' 
J! 2 AyO  ` $   ( Gt) *   & Roube  0 
%J"  JV  z"  2  ,  : 2    !~  @ C&  '
.(HM ) !
&$ y C&  F3   l z 
: 0"$ &o @ V       B
$ x `  |& ?V &5 8

>"J  (   x( : ! ZO  F<  `&  6 v : N  $ &


. `&  $ `&   ~  O F  @
0
  CDO) ' x?  : @ `b&"O $&") `&  6 v : b  $ &
( GHM GI  G &5 )
:k"    B
$ (  7$ ) ! ` $ x$ (Gt ) " @  D   
. 8
.`&  @ ?")
.`&  6 v K J
.:. ?O 
.(>  x?  K J1
.~" z 
.`&  * (#:  n .)
. 6# !
$ `D" : 
.%$&") :
.(Ie ) 8 `& ?  *
:0
     @ O   "  `   8 ?V (G ) + 8
. !"z  @ CDO) `l

K8

. `  +     K

.  #  `?  "  @ $     K


. O(z ?O `
%$  ?"  K
. i [> @ i z  n K
. !  F<  "#$ x x(z> `  $ K
. 0
  0 #  K
.(I ) i %$&" : `&  AV O K
  &
 >  (: `$zO ? B
$ O  `  ( LMMt ) %#$ `Dz
: 0?7 @
: $&4 !<  2>  `  K8
. 61 ?  K
. .  C&"~ K
. ? .  ? K
. *z  F7  K
: $&4     B
$ O  p `  K
. `&   F K
. 67  K
. `&  K
.( eeG K eeM ) !& &' 618 K

 J  !
$ &" O [  1 ` $  N3 A, ( LMM ) "   @
: %1 z
  
.??" V $ &o n 1 *Z  V `&  *Z  '"  6 z  ? K8
.O @ z  ? K
. `&  @ (# n  F" z  ? K
.  A 8   ~  2 (  $ &.& , '"  x(z K
.(GGG ) z  
?  &4 0zv   ~ K
`J&  !J N  #b  `D"O     
&! ` $ " ( , ) 2 
: %1 `  Z1 +8 i  8 6 ' + #b  `D"O 0~ @ x7F
. 7F 67 z K8
. z `&  2$   K
. `&  @ (#:  n ) K
. '"  @   z  V AV O K
. D") V>  $ K
.(LM G  LMMe E ) 1Z  F  D   E K
J  2J J$ @       @ x `
}~F  %D?O C# 2
`J $ x$ N3 f
       @ !   Z1 | O  
: %
 &V q3 2> [ b~F  [ >z (&
  O

: 6J1 K8
*ZJ  z  8 $&4  7 " 8 ^8 B
$   &
=z O (LMMt ) %#$  8
 @ iFJ ."  "  Z1 @ . (eH )  
 618 ? 
$ iO"
J ?  Z1 N3 
$ 78  .      B
$ !  %!V k"  | 
!? @ < " V ()1  ! | &
  $  zO `'O    Z1 [8"
.( GLG . 
$) " , 6 ? N3
6J1 J 'O @ ($8   > [8 @ [ F V [8 (LMMe ) E Z
[ J>O J$ " 8 (LMM n ) ? &V ( LM ) 1' ! 2 C F?
!EX @ %1 !??
< 61 [y V !zO @ 1O cV   61
.( G ) " &' X
 2J\ V8 < $&.
n O  61 [8 (G) F,  +
. !J> `J&  N3 ! VO xz [ >O =~8 ` $&.
z   z  
iV   Z {FDO ) 61 Z1 [cV !V18 !z $&4 nO $ 2>
.(GHG )  hV ` !?? {FD `

: `&  6 v K
J 
J   2 {FX8 `&  6 v AV " &"1) [8 ( G ) &5 O
x k"  "   >O zg  E `
?O z>  0 B
$ $O }~
.( GI ) V +      

2 !V `&    ,  ( GH ) [ , Z & `&  6 ' D?
=X =z =" `  " ?V ~  `&  "V '    (
J$ 2J>   z) &   ") C  @ iO  &! @ n V
J Z1 ( LLM ) "" 2    ~  2 zg `&  6 v (#
J   J O ?" !X#3 : 0h" V [8 (.) 
$  
) J J&l# `J&  6 v | &
 , @ !
&$ @ hz  !
.(GGt

: CDO) 67 x?  &'8 K


+J       V O 2$ N    [  1 [  x?  [8 7)
. F1 8 1 "  X @   [  ? 2Z  1 1V8
FOcV &' @ 
  + ?
      B
$ {

AF AyO x? 




:# 
8 8 0
     B
$ F
 \ x?  @ :
8
J: ?  g @ 0
  73   ? <
   zO x?  @
 Gt   DJ  ) .    B
$  3 \ k"  `&
 V  x ?  2
. ( II
  67
8 w!" %?  *? 
  [8 (GI ) 1:  A,
      nV N3 *  &$8 (8 @ E 2 8 = 0

%<  }
6J7
8 nF" `&  &"1) ." *Z  *? 
  [8 0~ @
N3 `J <  + @ * cV AD?  + @ " x N3 +8 *Z   
.( HG ) " z        1O

{&J }  =$  =" 67 [ &


 8 N3 ( LMMt ) %#$ i1Z
-lJ
J!  x(z>  | &
 zv  (8 @ E F V
.( eeG ) {X ->  V    nV B
$ $ &
  zO
J<"  + 2$ |8    +~3 wl" [8 ( GI ) 1:  Z
0J       @ 2FO 1 [8 2$ z8   x?        0
8<O  A"  N3 n       '" $ @ %l  iF  [8 
.( HL ) 
O (j *? 
  B
$
&' ` CDO) ' # B
$  " x?   [8 ( LMMe ) E Z
?"J) J4 >"   V O &' @ 0
  x?  0 CDO) V O [
.( LG ) &' @ 0
  "3    B
$ Ay"  N3 * *Z  %z 
CJ&  "~ B
$ 6 "  @ x $ CDO) [8 ( LMM ) n  +
J? 0
J   , &  N3 B
$ 2 D   !
V   !l\
.( Ge ) ! x
:  #  E F73 K
   2  Z = FO  E Z ( F7   &

J~  + "J 2 z  F F73 0  * iO 1 [8 /   
: %1 z  E Z1   
. %z  2 E K
. $&4 N3 &# E K
. n&."  (&") N3 E K

. %"  .
E K
. (GMKGMt LMM "  ) . $&") > ? @ F  K
Jz  +J E 8 { 8  Maslaw
 [8 ( LMMe ) E A,
( [J ) ?"J) ~ `O #$ ~)    
 @ !  
.( Lt ) z  +  E
2 Ab>  ^ *Z  1 =z 
  [ [8 N3 i1ZV ( LMM ) * p 8
 ,J (J&") $&") E  nF,O  $&") ,    z 
2J$ J   6  .( H ) =$&" C F? C V z z 2$  

& z  ?O 2$ %z     2  ~ y " (G)  $   & `& 


J  " `J&  2J 
$  O  l z  l8 @ ! 2 ZF  }~ 2
2J J " &
 x 0 C&  0  #   &
 8 : $
.(LM ) `&  2$         zO N3 *   "z 
'  Z1   2 [ Ab>  8   #  ' @ (  18 2 [3
AyJO BJ
$ (  "7  :1 V  > ^#   [ " 3 Cb8)
[  "    &O  E AV O 0
  &"1 1 @ ) # 
. !       B
$ ^>  2 Z  !
: :V E K J1
nJ  C J? J& J E
"   `  FO `  Z1
Jy !V  }~ =? =FO  V  / FO :V E  [8 (LMM)

   O 8
`8 2 ?lV   1"g i 8 8 `l

8 ` $

J~ 0
J
J? " x(z>  nV @   V  ! %> 
.( Gt ) z
"h ! V 
B<$8  * >z  @ %
  ) [8 2   8 (LMM ) * p  
-J~ $, 2 = > =3 z  F"$    :V
 
>z  1) ) Z1 [8 )3 z z  ?O 2 :  *Z  :z
."
J
J  J z   O @  :V E   8 2 f?O +
.( He)
JV [8 (LMM ) J"  Z       B
$ `  Z1 AyO f &V
3 ZJ , ` ! F |  3  $ V> B
$ 
D [8 [  "
.(GGM ) +8 $ , @ V !
$ `D"  :V E V> | 

: &'"     K
JF  ?E @ 1  x  ?  8 ( LMMH ) * !z  !V 
`JF 2J :" ) ? 8F    x>V  &' z  #$ 2$ O 
0VJ<  0J J
< J&'"  ?b  yO !V [
&   &'  0zv 
.(GM)
   nV `z  $ -8 B
$  ? 
 '   [8 ( LMM ) n  Z
J~  `&  $ (F$8 `&  n iO      V 0

  
`J?  "
 $ $  n

V C  F n C&$ V O F

 J  nJV @ 1JO ` $ !


D? F  z>  `  xyV> i" 
.( Gt K G )   
=J q   O 3 [E F D  6 '  C&  `&" : (G)  $ C ?
J") FJ n"&"  ~ ! F [ 3 8  D  6 '  Z1 -z
+       z iF [cV A 8  8  5 ." Xp
.(Ge ) 2
2  @ | " :  

8  D  [E [8 (.) &$ 

JV8 0 !  O ? 2> $&4    zO 8 z B


$ x ` 
nJ "  
>,J [8 n         B
$  *Z  ! `  %1 $ &
2J$ '     2$ Dh,  A  h" z  [8 3 F X 
>, C 
.(IH II ) $&4 A 

J  8 x ?


" 0 ?  {l
 F<O 0  
  @ "     [3
nJV @ ! `$ (:4 8 xyV> 8 "  @ l  %1 x  $  ` 
.(Lt : G ). 0
     

: i"  K
J~  nJV BJ
$ 2
&$ @ ?V O x B
$ 7 ) `  $ i" 

 %&
$ ^8 B
$ l8 z>
& `  
 i"  `z 8 & .  

@ JO J"V  h" N3 


"  N3 =V 7
*Z  ) [ > [8 B
$
. ( GG : .  
$ ) `& 
JzO
&$ 2$   `   7 i"  l V 2 [8 (G)  $ +
Jo J Zh""O ) %"  V {"O y " &' [8  ,    ~ 
.(ee ) " 

@ iJ"  (8 C&
618 n x$ [8 i 8 ( GH ) [ , C ?
AF V 1 [ 3  wl" iFO  C xA$ F X =V18 )  C "
 ,J [8 `J&" 2 3 `D"  B
$ O + " 0 `   & + " 0
.(LM ) "   F!"V f?  :.  aZ~ ` 
J
&  iJ"  N3 '  >  ~  2 8 +AV ( LMMG ) ?  8
A"  Z 8 3 O1 AO N3 2 z
%   AO N3 6 &
J!l 1  @ Dh,  C " }~  8 1  N3 & " [8  ) =1  [ > [8
B
$ C DE 2 z  2> 
 `>, [ n&" !F
<"  %~   @ X
 J  nV   ." B
$ C DE >O `&  ( #   .")
.(LM ) 0

  

: 1Z   F   E K


2J J
?  D  &4 D  0 FO 1 [8 ( G ) &5  8
.(GI ) ""3 O   l8 z  B
$ 1AyO }~

=X DJ ) &  *8 2 >, *Z  `  [8 N3 " | :z " 78 


 J 2J$ J  z   !$ DV 2 `.p  ,  
*J p ) .J    J  z N3 1  *O ( 
l$ 8 Dh7 `,
.( H  LMM
J! O 6#" 
"g `  Z F   [8 i4 Z1 @ C ?  X#
J&"1 2 8  1 `&  6 ' nD @ 0
  &"1V O&"1 z 
2J b8 i"  ` y" +D  iO  @ v  [8 & iO>  @ 0
 
.   Z>1 l?  8 -l 
->  61 B
$ i"  &"$ `  Z1 `O  8 }~F  +
J `b x4 CDO 67 &'8   z  x?  V O  y [cV K {X
J [8 J CJb `F B
V !", |  + `  n&4 %l 
x?  FOO !
 :V E &'"     8F F<O `&  6 v  61
xAJ J   61 n 2$ N        '"  @
" &V 67 '  8 ) #  [8 & .0
  `&  [ ,
[cV Z 1Z  F   F 0
  ~ B
$ 6 "  CDO) 
&$
J      V O 2$ N    [  1 [  x?  [8 + }~F 
. F1  1 "  X @ !   [  ? 2Z  1 1V8 +

      7 1' K
J& %J!V x7F '~#&
ng ) + z  1 '  l      
J.l" J\ J 2$ )3 '~# ) *V 2 >O ( Gt )  D   
.(L)

J   2J$ x  #   


 ~3 2> cV (G) :z i
: 8 `l #b
. &" 7F CDO) K
. (   `b ) ~" 
&
&" Az"  K
.(GM )       F  K
: 0$  N3     
`l)  8 1 '  (G ) &5 DO
@   " `&  [  C  `>7 B
$ " *Z  {D 
  K8
. $ 
.(GI ) C  Z1  DO  ?<  V ?  K
: `b !
$ ` O       -> O $ 1' 1 [8 ( LMMM ) z7 +
. ( `&  @ V "3 + *8 ) V ZF *Z  !4 K
J>"   z    !
&$   O + V 0 l  .)  K
.! ") + "  ! l  %$&")
!
<O 1AO $ !V &") @ !"F !
&$ 2y 0 j ?" + K
. 
 !" z"~#
.  ? 0F  ~ ` 0<h &$8 2$ 0Fl  F K
.(GMe ) ! j !l# !lj  0 j   K

J/ 0
J  +       B
$ CO  1' DV ( LMMG ) ?  8
:y
.  (&") 1h"V !" $&4  x7 K
  $73 !?? B
$ !X~ j  !  !V1 $&4 V8 FO x  K
. Team Spirit ! z 
J>z" %!J"O J  $&4 V8 0 $D  ~,"  
 8   K
.$&4
`JX " J!&$ 1&"J J!l? B
$ !X~ !$ $&4 ($8 V K
.(eI)
:`b z/           $&4 (G)  $ D
. z   
. Fb 
. ^&E 8 &E
. F~  ?
: `b &
 h" zh        $&4 D
. 
F"  x#F 
.  Dp ~,
. ?~ xA 
. xb F  !4
.(Ge ) j," 
: 0"! 2       1' N3 '  2> F  B
$ (

:          1' (8
.AF ~ N3  ?" Z1 '  ! | [3  y Z1 @ 0b~F  (\  O
: %
 &V `b&"O          1' [8 (GI ) 1:  +AV
C#J 2  " nV `&  i 8  <" l  %   `&  @ F   , 
. Zz"  @ E    $ V ~") ?O
2J nJ
$zO C# 2 !" B
$ 'V  N3 (&") z   7
.   `
. x $  @ `&  < ZzO B
$ E
.(He ) (?
 $&")    $  B
$ 'V
: %
 &       zO 1' 18 fh
V (LMMM) [  8
. ! V 0 X   $
. ", 61 ?" V 0 
6 J'
!z8 `">O :E 2 (%, `,  o B
$ V x
.> 
. O  @ 2 " & @ zO
.x?  E $  2$ yO @ 8
&$ 2$ z  !F"   @ 

.(GHt ) &
'"  * >,  C  @ z
: %
 &       zO $8 1' F,   

. !
>O   !< O 0zv  $q 
. !  !z>O !$ 1j &$8 B
$ 0zv  CF3
zO3 V >3 `&  B
$   " n 0zv   &  " zO
. O 2  ? F 2    n V> ?E 2   O
. O FO O  2  $ &' l `&  0 ? !"~
. !J
$ %J J [ J 0zv J 0J `&
" x(z>  zO
.( GIt GIe : G  F,  )
: zh       1' (
: %
 &V F
      
1' 18 B
$ ( Gt )  D  A,
. `&  &"1) [?V
. `&  2$  " 
. " AO
. + >,  ' xb
. `&  2$ Ay"   
. 
  @ v'z   ,p
.  `&
0
  
. x4 (  
.(IM ). & :  FbO

: %
 &V zh       7 `& cV ( GI ) 1:  8
. `&    &"1) [?V
. y"    F zO (  + " O
. %zv  " 
.( He ) * >,  Z"  xb &
"  {l
 z 
:  "  ?  @    z `l) (LMMe ) E  8 ?
. p 2    xb
.    xb
. i  2$ [D  * >,   
.  [  `?  F
xb
. &&  Z>  B
$ CF
. !" ? $  $7 `F?O
. x4 " [?V
. A  -z  ?b  [?V
. x)F $ `&  2 Z"  xb
.(Gt )    f?   f?   , 
 J  nV J  `D"  [8 N3 (LMM ) 1:  Z  &   B
$
: %
  N3 A, V   
-J 2J> zh      n " 2  $ $    `&" ) K8
. " 2 x $        2&"O [8 x  

DJ 2J yO )    [8 *8 


" A" x?  
&$    K
.  | 2 O z" z
" %!V ~
V ` V +     ?O @  F N3 =&l [  ` K
.(eH ) !z  @  F N3 Z
}~F   DO `b *Z  ( L )  `>,  N3 x7 2>  "  B
$ (
:  Z1 @       &
( L )  `>7
    
 

7 1'

x ` $
.61

    
 $

  
  

    

.`&  6 v
6J7 x?  &'8
.CDO
#  E F73
.)
.:V E
.&'"    

zh

.i" 
.1Z  F   E

      ^ Kt
=J' J F D  
&  2       ^ [8 N3 (LMM) "  A,

!J | xA" x?  F x1v %!V !V x   > `  "
.( GGL ) =?
< =OF "  )
`&  [  )  1&" O         Xp 7 [8 &
J7 Z1 8 ` [8 / ! 2$ 
Dz | ( + >,  i" 
G  J&5 ) . J      !
$ [ >O   E |  -z @ y"O
. (GHG
 J  ^J J N3 V       ^ 2$   : 18 %
 &V
:  
:       ^ : (8
@ [ J>z 0
J  `J 8 ^8 B
$    F  B
$ "$) " =~8
"J J [yJ7  2>O   Z1 [8 } !?
?  ( [ ,F #>,
2J> } (  @ 
>, 3 1       ^ 61 2>  1AZO
:Jz ) xAFJ J&   p 2>  wl"  [ !"4  !&!V !


.(Kt :G
: !8 2 :        [8 (G ) + +
:J: O J&O @ =J1 =  i
O  `  2 x~       " O K
J  2J AbJ>  fh,O @ F  wl" h" 2>  $,
. `F?" @  &l# C
E n &' !  O  `,

0
  x' !z B
$ 6 "  2   wl" C# 2 x n<"O K
.  @ !
, 0

fh,O x8 " O ! 3
J   J!~  2 nVO 1 8 !ED/ &"1) 0
     ,O K
) J! 3 ?O  X "  wl"  C# 2 x 1 @ 2"  N3 *O
. ( HI : G  +
: !       ^? l V x$ N3  $ A,
F  F z
"h  F        @ 6#") + V  K
.
< [ "  ~3 B
$ `&  Z *O 
. 
 CFO CDO) `l +~3 " O K
:G   $ ) x7F A ?< 0

F"  
x V  K
.( Ge GH
:       ^  (
: %
 &       ^? !h" 2>& <  18 fh
O 2>

J nq =? !V  [8 / ? 8 !  
? [ >O  : (
?) KG
BJ
$ Jz  n., !V !  A *8 x~ 
? Z1 [ >O  z
 O 
3  
? [ >O [8 2> . }~F  2  O [  "!  *8 ,
. ( GI : G  $ ) 
? 2V @ x * 0b~ 2 8

[&J 
  i." 3
 Z1 FO $ }~F  B
$ i
V 0zv   ." @ xz 
? B?FO 2> X 
 B
$ C DE
. ( GGL : LMM  "  ) =~8 [ , )  &$8  O 2Z 

2J J> 
! ? y :&"O  =," <  b8 2 %1 : ( F")) KL
J
? 2$ :&"O 8 & i | @ `8  >" AF $ (8 B
$ C DE
:G   $ ) ! wl"  #h"   AzO `
i FO  !
. ( GL

@J>  |  B
$ `D i." [8 1: 2 [8 ( LMM ) * p   &
 J %z ) Z1    D  " 3 (  C D~ [   
AJ  ." N3 *  ") $  .") < `b ?<  Z F
 
J J$ ?<  Z1 $ i." [8 }~F
2> 2> $  A ?
.( H ) 
   y 0F."  , z F")

2> ) k"  x7F '~#&


ng ) z x1v       : ('~#) KI
B
$ [ O  !.l" 1\  2$ ! !"'~# 2> 3 x7F !
+ >J7 "  i"  "  C  '~# 8 #. 8 ?O `>7
. ( GGL LMM  "  ) 0zv 

%&'"  ()  :b  }F


%&'"  ()   !z G
0b~F  &"1 n  %1  1)  2 =(: %&'"  ()    O
 Z %&'"  ()    ?V . 8 Z  
 Co @
&' ^ }~ "%$&") `&  ?O " " @   `8  " @
*   Ay"  D V  B
$ iD !" @ % :O [ x"
zD"  ~ C>78 N3 >> C>78 2  &" C C# 2 <
 
.(IM : G [.1) .&"  2" 

J  
 @ 1z 8  "    y [3 ( LMMH ) *; C ?
%J&'"  () J  J  } $  D 
O :O  D  2  !z">
`J 6#"J J$   V x A" `   " =' 0


:J~ 2&J `O  > x1v  > " O    wl" "
.( )  F  `l 8 "   @ )3 0b~F  &"1

1 '  C# 2 
$ C" ` =  `b ) ^ 5 A {
<D %&'"  () 
1 `  V " 8 =:1 
$ C DE 2> ) 
 <FO 
LMMH * !z ) .
  A" `  2 Ab>    #$z" 
D~
.(G :

"   .   O @ ( & 


 @ () V xAb )  " () " &
>
.(GMe ) ":" ) F xD  ?  ! 
J @ &! F 0"
&> 0"j   N3 x Co @ 0&"! 78 
: " ` [#b O 8 B
$ [<O }~ %&'"  () 
0J J#$   + 8 B
$ %&'"  ()
'O >z  j : N  j 
() J  J JzO [cV Z1 '  ! i~ !V `&   &' v 
AFJ ! CZF  " &'  61y &  3 O z  + %&'" 
. &' `F @
x  y %&'"  ()
j# O  O (LMMe) [ ,   j  Z1 V
() J  @ = $ + " !' *Z  z  . FO "&' n z   <O
: %
 / D" cV  &'  %&'" 
. !"& &' 618 C F? *  ?"$

. &' 2$   2> ! BD8 CZF  "

.( t ) &' @ " $ &" B


$ 'V @   F

() J  (LMM* ) @ " Orelly & Chatman 27 k 8 " 6  &


N3 V  &' z   *Z  %z    y j  Z1 C# 2 %&'" 
FO# i  # 1 [8 N3 78 ? . &'  FO N3 `&  @ )
: %1 &' v  0 %z 

V>&
 O C# 2 &'&
v  [$3 y, : Compliance [$ .G
. &' 2 l 
J&'&
Jv  J J'   %1 : Identification    .L
.  ") 8  
v  618  V O + O %1 : Internalization `&"  ,"  .I
.( GG : LMM  *:J  ) &'
J" *8 )
 8 B
$ *;  & ()
 !z/ ` # k 8 ( 
! [8 `&" A 2 cV O  ~ @ & =V  =3 = !z - ( zv

J?
" J?~#    `F 2 !"
?$ "O ()  `b ( 3 8 ) V  '
() J  yJ ) %&'"  ()
." y %zv    [3 }~ . %zv   
BJ
$ :  8  !z Z1 2 {" O  & %zv  
." %&'" 
@ zv  Z1 [y,   z
-  &' @
& " @ z  6DO
#?$ ? z  # 2 * x$   ." x"V  2>  " 
. ( GM : LMMH *; ) . ) 8 &'&
() 0
:J  '"
 ?"  " 8 B
$ %&'"  ()  (Sheldon) [ 
7 6$
.( IL :LMMe  ) " V18 (3 `&  B
$
61y !?
O V  Z " (LMM) * F$ @ ( Bochanan) [7 V$
ZJ1 [8 J~# . (LMt )   2  ? &$ '  & '" 
.(&") ()  0
?   z "  2$ 
"  " 

:%&'"  ()  !
$  ? l :>O # 0 [7 : 
J&' Jhz  2$ AF "  @ !' : (Identification) (&") ^~ : =) 8
. !& !V1y OZ  $? 
J 2J  "  z  `F 2 : (Involvement)   z   , : =
.   ?    <, y %z 
@ J
 &"J) x z  F $  : (devotion) # : =b 
.( t :LMMt x7  ) 6 '  ` @ &'
`Jb&"  ~ " y %&'"  ()  6  ( Mowday) *  [8  w!  -z B
$
J? `!J" !V " $ B
$ 'V @ i &' 618 ? !V z 
. ( Gt : G    ) . " V18
2J J ~ Jy (LMMH) !" @ ()   "   ?V j# *<$ 8
 h"z 1F"  618   =?V z  `F? " z  0 FO)
J1A N3 C?") B
$ !V `&  &") `z & !?? `8 2 & `& 
.( G )
 J?  
&   ()   !z [8 :  [  2$ (LMM) *:J  Z
.( ) &' 61y Dh,  V18 CF" z  !F /
(JV  <  CZF V  " 8 B
$ ()  " Kantor  " " |V$ 0~ @
. ( : LMMH *; ) '"

J8 B
$ %&'"  ()  6$ " Robbins :J  " [8 (LMMt) 7   Z
@ iJ !VJ18 J  &' C# 2 =V   v  !V [ >   E
.( t ) &' @ &")
(%7 ` B
$ z
! `&  z  [8 +O %1 
  j  : b  j 
B
$ zE C  cV Z &'&
O ."  *Z  |  8  ?  & *
. &?  (7 Z1 &" 2&O  VD"  `
$ %&'"  ()
(LMM) *:J  A, ()

  j  ' ! i~
z  0  FO D &' -8 B
$  ? }~ ( Meyer & Allen) 2 \ 
&"J 8 J&' @ `&  " "? l   >"  ~ @ & &'
8 & `b &' @ `&  2  (%7 ` B
$ zE C  z V !V (?F 
.( GL ) i>
@ x&" ,&
$: y (Gt "  @ ) (Becker 1960) > V$ 
3 J?z [8 B, &' ` z  &b"  ." &' `   ,
. ( Ge ) !O
J  " JF4 1 " ' >   B
$ v  + ()  ( &" 
J$&" J#$ > x 
$ 8  z v  x ? B
$ &" O
. &' @ `&  O C~ @ v  1?z     8  (  &b"
Organizational

%J&'"  [ J"   J!z 1 (G)   C ? & Z1

J "J7) ( Herbert Simon) [ J  1 8 *Z  Equilibrium


JF
<  l$8 '"  0 &V  F" #  [ [Z
 Chester barnard )
AV O  ?O   '"  B
$ V n?O *Z  |  @ .  2 &! `

 JJ 0
JJ  OJJ$ BJJ
$ nJJ?O 0
JJ
FJJ :V JJE
 ?" x$   D V . '"
  z  
.( G )
  :" ) (&") ()  z 0  !z @ =V#"3 1 [8   
& (Loyalty) () V .  -z   @ #b  
<D Z1  
J?"  >V `&, n"  !z Z1 [8 &  FO #$ 2$ F  3 F
(J&") 6J  J& .J V J a  7 
?$  ~ Z !V $,
J) Jz  `   7 1   F"  8 B
$ (Belongingness)
!DJ&?"   [ >O [8 N3 x$ B  $q 2 (: z  [ >  (I :LMMe
J  J$&4 2 (: z  [ > [8 (&") @ ",V  x  z ~ 
JE) !J (:J Jz  [ J> ) $&4 ()  2>& 2 & ! 3 %&"
 J?~) ." N3 A,V (Commitment) :" 3 {
<D 8 .( LMKG:LMMG
() J
J." (Organizational Commitment ) %J&'"  :" )  ?V

$ =#b `&  ?$ 
$ F  / `  :"  #$ &! [ > )  %&'" 
. =V - ()   !z 2$ 
" :" )  !z [cV

%&'"  ()  8 K L
x [ >  ()  [8 ()
%
>   !z 2 =(: %&'"  ()   
J$q 8  ?  8 ! 8 zv  8 x 8 &' : `b z  x~ @  8
. A 8 V  $q 8 `& 
JO1) =J8 `>,J (LMM) *:J  C ? & v &
%&'"  () V
618 v  F" &'&
v  () + "  &
>V &' ` O


() Jv  {  V . 8 ! 8 `>, !"


D  / 6D" &'
: k" FV !V18 &'  2 n  ?  g) =8  < cV   &'
) Jv  2J O   &' 
D ?  `V =?V ?  g3 2
.(LL
`l =V z 8 =:1 ()  B
$ C DE 2> ) 3 (LMMe)  O
- !V A" `  2   Ab>  #$z" ." 3 ` z
"h 
J 
$z" 
    '  2 
." 1 ` =' 8 #$
 J!z =  [ > [8 2> ) A" Z1 2 =8 2> A" 2   
$
&' @ p   &  -4 ) : Dh,  &  !V ~ () 
: `&  Xp &  1 (  E $&")  E %&
"  + "
J1 ( ( 2$ xO 
 `&  (8  #?")  ! " )
(`&  $q " ~ 6,&
*? 
   ) : &'"   
A"
O ` . ( &'  xV " `&  V ) `b p `  1
[ J> . () J  2$ `F h" [8 2> ) ! =8 2> ()  @ O 1A
=FFJ )E 2   @ [ > [8 n ) [cV A" 2 
." () 
.( I Ie ) 1 '  2 
@ |J    bE $  2 %&'"  ()  " V (LMMe) [ , 8
JF"  @ $J ) 8 =X D    2 $   Z1 N3  ~
J$ %J&'"  ()   &
 8   O ` iV 0zv  

yJ"  
>, |DO   F |z `&  [  C  z 0zv 
[  ,J nzO %&'"  ()  * 0zv  [8 %zv  ( 2    2$

%
lJ  JFO) 2J CJ$ + "/ `&   x     2  $ 
.(t)
1 [8    2   | ? :(LMMH)
 * !z  C ?
:! &' ! 0
  + %&'"  ()
q l V
@ 0J  +  
@ x l   ? ~8 %&'"  ()  "  8
. &'
. `&
:&" ( ? @ !
. `&  [  2$ w"O    z  &' @ (?F
` F   
!
 >"  2 =: &' `& 0
  + %&'"  ()  z [3 
J  `J&  @ x)JF#   J F
  
  2 :  O
.( Gt ) ih" 
J J&' () 0
  + [ &
 8 ( LMMe) *   
J `J&8 B
$ !V18 ? 1  ?   &' Z1 |$<"
&' * F  =  =8 X !zv  () i> &' |  
$
J  JE @ ?  !":1 C [8 [   |$<" Cb ` B
V . |
 !zv  () :&"O &' (F ! C# 2 `1Z 1  N3 b 
y   " V @ [    [ zv  ()1  , }~ !" @ !zO
. e . xAF x8 2 (:
=J3 2 "   "&' l) {/ z   ? ) 8 (LMMH) *; +
J&' 2$   2> ! BD8 CZF  " Z "&'  61y = 

[8 N3 " zV :


 " 78  . !V " $ &" B
$ 'V @  ?  "F
() *JF ) z V ?~#   &
=5 [ >  0  (3 (3 V ()
C# 2 kE z  2$  (zc # 2  ? " 
?$ " 
&$   "&'
.(t ) &'&
() *F  V18 n ?" [ >O x$   2 >O
:%&'"  ()  8 { O  ?  18 fh
 [8 n<" F 
.&' ` v  
 1) =8 %&'"  ()  `>, K
. =# [ >O [8 2> )  A" `  2 Ab>  #$z" ." `D K
.&' z  B
$ q l V nzO ()
K

%&'"  ()  flD K I
J J B
$ # C# 2 %&'"  ()    $   
flDJ x$ f
h" [8 n<" %&'"  ()  :  flDp 2$ [ b~F 
: %1  %&'"  ()   !z
. &' v  0 FO) + " ? %z  7 `b %&'"  ()  [3
.?  `" `>, &'O Dh7 ` $ x y" %&'"  ()  [3
:&" > F8 x =?V zh 8 nzO [8 `&"  %&'"  ()  [3
. +  1 '  =?  =$    Fb 
CZJ &' 618 FO C F @ 1 [8 `&" nzO %&'"  ()  [3
. &' v   $ &" (?F   5 !??" AF !
J 2J> 7F `>,  @  X !  %&'"  ()  + " [3
. &'  v   7 B
$ x1'  \ C# 2 `V8 `>,

!J 2J$ x:&" z


"  > 8  8 x$ 2 [ >" %&'"  ()  [3
. ( Ge : LMM *:J  ) F 
,J" ) C J? J/ J F8
 "      O X ,
: k"  `&,O z  Z1  V x$ 2  > &' *8 [3 (Reichers
( Rank and File employees) 0Zz"  0zv 
( Clients/ Customers) 2z"

8 (#& 

( Top Managers/ Owners) 


 x

( Puplic at large ) = &$ 0zv  K

@ z  Z1 "7 x   2 - Xp !V18  z  Z1 2 V ` [8


J$ &o *8 (Coalitions) #">O x  @   &' ` ` @ .~ 61
C J #"J>"  Z1 2 `">O ` . ~ &"1  x~ 
" [  > V 2
`J #">"  z   O B
$ ( . 2 [  X nV B
$ C DE
2 
"g ?  61 Z1 . !"??~ C  & V18 `">O V `> [cV &'
J?  6J1 Z #">"  V () k"  `">O N3 `">O 2 V N3 V
" ) . =~ = - %&'"  ()
z
" = 8 1 [8 {" Z>1 . 
"
.( G G Gt

%&'"  ()
xz &  H
`J  8  %&'"  ()  Az" [ b~F  (&
  O  x$ 1
1 $ %
 &V  &  i~X + 1   Z1 '  ! 2 !
:&  Z1

: ()

" ) 8

& ()  %&'" 
  b~  & ()  0 z"  x  B
$ 8 
() J  [cJV %J&'" 
  %b~ ' ! 2&V %$&") -z  (&
$ 
&'  618 B
$ 6 "  0zv &
" !? 2$  
&  X h"
2J &' Z1 n ~ "  B
$ |  -z @ [
&  & ! 3 [ &" 
"J J 3 J78 () J  @ `J ZJ1 . J&' !" $ ->O C#
( Attitudinal Commitment) %1J)

8 %z J ()  B&/ ( Staw, 1977)

. l# *  A" [7 C&$8 @ `b &


"   D  " F, (%7 8 B
$ 2' `F 2  3 ' ()  2   Z1
`Jb DJh,  &'"  `  2 = 2&"O D  Z1  "5 [8 }~
.`J&   &'"  flDp %zv     flD Dh,  & 
2 &' @ V 
  flDp Z1 2$   ()  + " [cV ` ?
xJ ? `&  @ CZFO   !4    E %zv  "  }~
. &' V !? 
(&
$ ' ! `b *Z  (Attitudinal Commitment) %z   ()  ` ? @
`Jb *ZJ  ( Behavioral Commitment) %
  ()  1 %&'" 
 
. %$&") -z  (&
$ ' !

> 2 ` `F 2 ! 3 `X "   


." ( ()  2   Z1
"J ( Salanick, 1977) ) ( Kiesler, 1971) 
 ( Becker, 1964)
`J&  # 2  
&  ^8 B
$ %
  ()  x>V  ?O ( Staw, 1976)
X ."&'/ <  z  #$  <O B
$  p Z  *z 
 
ZJ J' " J8 &$ ( Becker, 1964) > 
  8 p Z1
JV [8 (Becker) J> +J '  Z =?F<V Side- bets theory) (< 
  &' ` 6D"  8
  2 X  y 2? [ FD
[8 [ ,J cV k" 
  Z1 B
$ |FOO  V> : % @
.
  Z1 2$ 
8 1 3 : Z1  ?z
 < # 2  
&  (Salanick, 1977) ) X ?V > i N3
OVDJ" J." &' =<FO {FD z  [3 " ? "&' n ()  #$ z 
=:

  Z1 {FD } "&'  O?"  2$ O    ?  &"
JO~ 2J  2,$ B8 *Z  fh,  [cV Cb `F B
V "  &V z

&' Z1 @ (? O  1)  %&O [8 2>& 2 x~ &' @ 
& 
V   2   B
$ !O C  ) !V k"  !V *Z 
  B
$ (
. +8 &' @ `V8
[8  ) %
  %z  : ()  2 0 &  2Z1 0 z  [cV C~ ` B
$
8  B
$  &! =# [3 ` %&'"  ()  AzO @  2 `V8 ~8
. (I It : G  [.1 )    N3 &! `  ? [8 2>& 2

: ( Angle & Perry *A `8 )


2> %&'"  ()  F8 2$ }F  ^8 B
$  ?O  &  [8 [?"  
:  %&'"  ()  x1v Az" 0l 0 @ !zDO
+J %
J  ()  ` ? K : %&'"  ()
^y z 
^J8 B
$ F %&'"  ()  1  [8 &  Z1 "? K )

"

[ > [8 ) Z1 N3 *



D 8 F"$ z  VDO flD
. =$ <O ="  = =$
  Z1
p 
"  -4 &  z  flD N3 ' cV &  Z = FO
B
$ : &  Z1 [cV Z z 
 B
$  5 1F"$ ?  
`J =8    i N3 &' N3 Dh7 flD 2 V
& 
. &' V () !8 B
$ "  &'
" $ %z  ()  ` ? K : %&'"  ()
^y &'
@ J %&'"  ()    
&  [8 &  Z1 "? K )
. !V `&
." z  0 ! `$z"  " }~ &'
61 E  [8 ^8 B
$  3 '  E Z1 @ z  [cV Z
hJ [8 2 n ) 61 Z1 ? `F @ 8 &' N3  1 
[8 *8 . JV18 JO~ F
" &'  ?O [8 ` ? @ &'&
O O!
B&J  1 CF"  Z1 1  [8 &' z  0  FO 
&$ %1 1 
& 
2J J$ &o 2&J" J?  Z1 (Kotter) O   3 78 *Z  %z  ? 
Jz  0V<  #> F  x5 A 8 x5 [ >O  ! "  :" )
@ `&  2$ z   N3 C>7 2 `>7 *y *O [8  ) !> &'
@ %1 O~   O z  &'  ` O  ?<  [cV k"  . &' Z1

}  `&   &'&
l) $ 8 z  () N3  ?O    `b !8
@ J *JO 6  z  "~ F
" :" ) !?O$ B
$ ZyO  &' [3
CJF" ()  2  1 [ > k"  & 1"  !& ," [8 N3 ! 
.( I L : LMMe *   ) . "&' 0 

: ( [  )
: k"    B
$ %&'"  ()
2 V " Kidron [ " 8
61 z  FO D? : (Moral Commitment) ( %# )  ()  . 8
. V18 & `b 1F"$ &' 
&") z  FO D? : (Calculative Commitment)  ()  .
x7  ) . `V8 :/ +8 &' @ ` `&$    &' ` `&  @
. ( : LMMt 

: ( ?V z" ) 
01 N 3 %&'"  ()   !z V  & %&'"  ()   =   ?V
:  0'
J J
&  %&'"  ()   N3 ) Z ' : kF"  ) K
J %J8 & z    B
$ :"  n !V 0
  &' 0  F"
.&' z  0  F"  
&  C# 2 nV : 2 v  ?"
:V J~ 2J 
$ `D  x: : &'&
z  (&" [cV ) Z1 i /
 ( Simon) [    %&'"  [ "  ' n ) Z1 . . <$

Jl  2 O  O ? [ >O &' , @ z  !3 [8 "V B


$  ?O
 JF  &' &# 0
  nV V . V  OE !$F73  FO"
J3 @ J &) Z1 [y z  " 2$   !l&" !V <


&V `b&"O kF"  ) B
$ 5  O . z  V18 ? @ ! !V18
: %

J&' 2J J ? :V E 2$ fh,    -? ) Z1 [3
O N3  cV +8 &' @ `V8 : V O cV !V l? >3
J! O J$: 2$ 
/  : ) Z1 `b&V . !V `&   &'
%J< ) ) Z1 .  `&   &' @ (?F  8 O >3 N3 z 
. &'&
fh,  () B
$ AyO  +8 i 
.&' ` %&'"  () 
  D ."  $  @ f?
Porter & Smith) }J

O FO z"  ) Z1 : %z  ) K

ZF : ! &' 3  O l , y %&'"  ()  V zX *Z 


ZJ!V . J!V $ (?F  @   F Z !V18 ? @ &' x$ z 
!V . !V18 &'  $  c z   O 8 B
$ %&'"  ()   D )
z  F  :V E  B
$ : *Z  kF"  ) 2  b8 = 8 %<
. l)  =? &' O @
Jz  6J1 0J V "  8 %&'"  ()    %z  &   ' 2
[  ,J &' 61y [  [ ?"  2Z  0
  [cV 
$ . &' 618
? . !V18 &'  @ AF [3 !V `&  @   F [ !'  (&"
O J ^? !V h"    2   @ (%z ) ) Z1 h"

K G : LMMe  *J   ) Fb  D  2 ^? Z1 "  l#


.( L

: ( l#  ) J1
: %1 %&'"  ()
 > 8  8 # 0  : ?V } 2 \  8
Affective component 

8 %z  [ > K

flDh
3 v  ^~3 + " y (LMMH)  <?  * !z  V 
,J  @ J  z  , {&O  > =' !  V "  zv  ! x:&
.( GG ) *
Jz  3  y"  F  Z1 [8 (Gt) &!" @    "  Z
0V,J J J! O 8  #?"  2
& x:& flDh

J'"   V> %&'O  3 B
$ `& O A" Z1 [8 &  !! O
.( Gt ) ! ()  + " B
$ = 3 
J A" l  8 # [ 2 \  [8 (LMM) j# *<$ C ?
DJh,  flDJp : %J1 %zJ  ()   <O @ &! 8 ?"  zv  `F
.( LI ) `&  @ 
<"  `&   flD
Normative Component * 

8 %# [ > K

@ `J&  &"J) J :" )J v   7 y (LMMt) 7   V 


.( )&'

@ (J?F  &") =#8 v   7 8 N3 (LMM) j# *<$ A,


  Z1 . +8 &'/ "  !?? 2>&  z  i 4 N3 '  [  &'
O  (?F   @ `&   i    ^~ ->  ()  2
.( LI )  2 &' " 
`JF 2 4 $   ,  Z1 :   =F  8 (Gt)    "  
( z @ ?V -  `$z"  ,  &  !  &'
J  J  J J<h"  61 n @  ` `&  ZzO
.( Gt )'"

J  ?  2 n  ^~ Z1 `b % D [8 (LMMe) *   Z
"  i?$ 8 ( %$&") nF<"  8 x `b ) &' "  `F z  !F"
.( e )  ( %&'"  nF<"  ) &'
Continunce Component &" [ >

nV "# 0
  3  y (LMMH)  <?  * !z  V$ 
!OJ$ J ?z ? &'&
!l)

!"&" A' !


$ [
D 
.( GG ) &'

2$  %&'"  ()  [8 "V N3 " [ > Z1 [8 (LMML) C Z Z


J&' z  0 ( V>  "  "  `b ) ", D &O
.( LL ) #8 8 z$ 
&$   2 b8
J v  ?O [8 [ > Z1 2$ &!b~ @ (Gt)    "  C ?
B
$ %zv  &  C 2  ?" `  2 $ &./ y" '"  n (?F 

2J `1O 8 zO *8 &' @ O~ 2 ^y ) =(: &b" z  [8 "V


`&$ N3 `?

 A Z1 &b")  8 | 3 X  x  b/ " 
F
J$ |J  `&  (# n Dh,  #
& %<   z  [8 / \
J xJ  !  + ! 2 
"  $?"  ' [8 N3 V3 0 
. ( Gt ) +8 [  &'/ FOO
!J B
$ O %&'"  ()
#b   > Z1 [8 (LMMe) *   Z
#$ 2$ O z  ~ ()    *Z   D"  1 ! ", <  1 F 
 J 0 &V z
" z   E  F [8  2>  `&   &' v 
() J n"&" *Z  8  @  F B?F %z$ ()  *Z  v V ?  
J B?F cV * ?  *  ()  i~X 8  N3 "  B?FV *  &"
.( e ) Z :"
 8  ,
[8 2>& 2 8 &  (GG 2 \   ) 0b~F  2$ (LMM) *:J   
%zJ ) %J&'"  () J
#b   > 2 O z"  0zv  + [ >
 J8 |J () J
 > 1F"$ 8 `>, $ Z1 (*  &"
.( GH )

: &'"  V?b   K


=J |  &'  @ ^ ~8 2 &'"  V?b    O
?  @ `b&"O  &' V? [8 F"$ %&'"  ()  x1v AzO  =
J&' (JF ?
" &' @  &
 i 4 2  Z   x  
2 1A !"F &' #$    "V) Z =&'O =

%J&'"  ()  [8 & V %&'"  ()


% [ >  O + &'
#>, 8 2 [8 F"$ 0zv  F =  =
8    Z1 ' ! 2
() J  0zv   O F 2> *Z 
 &' x3 !  O 
.
>, Z1 `E 2&
=&l# =
8 ? %&'" 
J? F fh,  ~ O 2&" %&'"  ()  [cV  Z1 ' ! i~
() J  [cV 
$ . Dh,  V18 & | &  `&   &' 618
J&' `J
&$ 2$ z   o + " =#8 =#$   &'&
%&'" 
:" ) 2   "&' k  v  [8 . (#:  V> :V E iF
J"  <h
 "O $ "&'  2$ %Dh,  V
 " i N3
2 =  [ > &  Z1 i~ %&'"  ()  [cV 
$ .   i
<O  3
1J' ZJ1 2  ` &'"  1' F FO *Z  z
Z  ^~
0zv J ( 4 $    |  `&    %zv  "  @ 
b&"
. &' "  V C#" N3
BJ
$ [ J>  b8 : %&'"  ()  x1v AzO @ &  Z1 [cV 
$
Z1 N3  ?O  F %1    0F [8 [  ()  B
$ iO"O  wl" 
`J&> ZJ 1 x1'  Z1 i  2 =~ =F $  [ > k"  () 
2 J>" {
D z   &  2 A n 8 & ?   &  @  D?  i 
.(HI HL G  [.1) %&'"  ()   `7 3 8

: %&'"  ()  `~ K e
(&
 `F 2 `~ Z1 B
$ q3 1 - 8 (LMMe) !" @  O
@ J () J  2J   N3 `D %> z  [8 B
$ q3 1 2> 0b~F 
.( I ) z
" `~
: %1  `~ #b ()   <O `~ ~ =#b [7 FV
J&" O `&  N3 v  C  `F 8FO  ."  
~ `b : N  
~
 F >V8 1    O ?   2 v  + V "  B
$
J
O C#J [ > ~ $ x 
~ Z1 " v &
$&") F 
? N3 v  B  
~ Z1 @  ."  $ i"
=  x"z 
`J&   n  "  
"
! CZ '"  2 C F?  B
$ C DE 2
. ( G : LMM *:J  ) . x4
:%1 
~ Z1 C# !'O  "  p [8 (G  ) @ [7 +
. `&  
. ()  O
.    
. ;#" $&4  !v
.   "  3
. '"  $&4 1

.( LL LG ) D   , 
2J " F."  x"z
?~#  x"z  %1 :  `&  
~ : b  
~
B
$ y"  
&$ C# 2 O F3 N3 # z  B    n 8 N3 0"
DJh,   : !  p F 
~ Z1 :&"O ??~ *Z  
. ( HM : LMMe  ) . `&  '"
()    !v :.  2 6 p
BJ
$ 
~ Z1 @ ()  $ 
&$ &" O '"  @ ?b  
~ :b b  
~
(J  >"   !4 0 [ "  
&$ ?O '"  @ v  &b"
() J  + "J x 2$ O  1) 
~ Z1 @ :O v &
x< 
-Jp J  2 =F?O 8FO }~    
~ `D ~ v  + %&'" 
: LMM *:JJ  ) . J&' @
&$ x"V C v  n " v &

.(G

@ (Porter) O (Mowdy) *  2 ` 2 [ (G )    


@   <O &'O @ 0
%&'"  ()  2 >O [8 GL $ &!"
: %1  ""  `~ #
C J Jp 2J Jz
"h  " "  %1 : `&  `F  
~ K
2J$ Jq  #1
O . '"  @ `&
C 
z  `1O   ")
J  +J 6 '
"V  `&
F  O  O 2$ Dh,  z  flD
.( LH ) `&  C F?  >

`J&  JF ?
" `&   x"V 
~ Z1 `b : `&  @ (F  
~ K
=A< =  (Hall) C 1 78 & p Z1 i
O }~  N  !7 
b&"
: LMMe  J ) . !   ()  x `&  ?
" 1)  <O @
. ( HG
J J!'O '"  l) & z  1 &O !V : "  
~ K
. %$&") (&" $O &' n
$zO 2 !F">  
  

:O

*  $ %&'"  ()   <O `~ `b k"  `>, 


(I)  `>7

O *  $ %&'"  ()   <O `~

"  
~
(--? --#
.  
. G "  Gj'
6   ~
.*KL p< 7j   i<
^j*n? *c? Gj'

`&  @ (F  
~

`&  `F  
~

3# (|_ ~


. 7* 
- (? :F#
. 7* 
. 7* ?   *L#

i-<  { (<


. . $ (|M
'  7[# ('9
. 7* ._
. 7* RL  (,#
( Gt : LMML C Z :D)

!V `&   &' z  FO [8 N3 ( Welsch & Lavan) [z 78 
:  0"
~/   ()
@ : ( Organization Entry) !V `&  z    &'&
&) 
~ . 8
.~ &
O V18 OF ? 8 ?"   &' z  " )E i
8

~ Z1 @ : ( Organisational Commitment) %&'"  :" ) 
~ .
!J  &'&
.  ? `8 2 D   !4 CZ B
$ =D~ z  [ >
J"  ) J!V (J?F
xJ F  &'&
%??E (&")  , 8 3 
. ( 19 , 1997   

#J J1 [8  ?V ( O, Reily & Chatman, 1986) [ k 8 8


: %1 z
%&'"  ()    `~
Jz  &J  @ Z1 [ > : ( Compliance) :" ) 8 [$ 
~ . 8
ZJ . &'&
& ." z  !
$ `D  i> B
$ F } &'&

2 z
"h i> B
$ C DE ` ?  [ F
< / :"
 2 <
 `F?" !V
. &'
J
~ Z1 @ : ( Identification) &' z  0 `&"  8 <"  
~ .
2J <

F?O @ iF  %1 &' @ (?F  &") @ z  F [ >O
hz J  J7 N3 *  (&"# "~ nF, &' @ (? [8 . 1AyO
. &' @ = $  >

618 n & z  618 ,"O 


~ Z1 @ : (Adoption) F"  
~ .
6J18 ? @ [y  , ." &'  618 F" z  8FV &' 
. =DJh7 J& 2J$ JV 1 &'  2$ $V [8 V1 =?? '" 
. ( L G : LMMt  7   )

 2&" %&'"  ()  [8 N3 78 8 %


F  2$ (LMM) "  Z
J
&$ @  ~3 n !&? 3 "&' n % >  z  FO
% !
$ 6 "  * %F "&' @   `~ $ z  + "
: %1 0

:" )  <O B
$  O
J
< 1AyJ" &  2 [$ z  C F O : $<  
~

K8

. *   * 8 B
$ C DE `8 2 
$
? `8 2 2 AyO `  z  C F O : Z  n ) 
~ K
 > (>  hz   ,  Z  n .) ? `&  @ l   
.&'&
%&"
(:J &' y `  z  6," N3 A,O  
~ %1 :   
~ K
.( I L ) Dh,  & n "O !& [8 ! (: 1 
[8 J?"  .0b~JF  1 & %&'"  ()  `~ (G)  C  fh

:`~ # {O ( ' 
.[$3 $   !V &'&
&) 
~
.Z  F )  5 <"  )  5 
~

&  @  3 , %&'"  ()  !V ?"  "  F"  ?b  


~
.1  
(G)  C 
0b~F  $ %&'"  ()  `~
(e)

(H)

(I)

(L)

(G)

%
F 

[ * 8

O * 

[V)

[7

1J
J$ J J$  J$  J$  JJ$ JJ
%&'"  ()  %&'"  ()  %&'"  ()  %&'"  ()  %&'"  () 
:`~ #b :`~ #b :`~ #b

: 0"
~/ :`~ #b

JJ
~ KG JJ
~ KG  
~ KG JJ
~ KG JJ
~ KG
$<  [JJJJ$

`&  `F &JJJ)

:" )

 ." 

&'&

JJ
~ KL JJ
~ KL JJ
~ KL

JJ
~ KL

nJ ) JJJJ<"  `&  @ (F 

 `& 

Z 

`&" 

JJ
~ KI JJ
~ KI JJ
~ KI
 

F" 

" 


~ KL
'"  @ ?b 

JJ
~ KI
'"  @ ?b 

(t :LMM"  :D)

: %&'"  ()  @ x `  K


|$ O 0zv  + %&'"  ()  [ >O @ x `  !z 0b~F  ) 5 @
z 8 " 78 ?
V  Z = FO zDO |$ O V x `  !V C ~ 1
0~ @ . &'&
&) `F [ >" y,  &'&
v  () [8 " Oliver
:V JE V> N3 V C&$ ?O &'"    [8 N3 78 [  [8
: LMM *:J  ) &'&
()  2 (&") h"V) ^~ N3 *O
. ( G
() J  [ J>O @ $JO  `  0FO  n 0b~F  2 Ab C ~ 
. ()  Z ." !'  *Z 
  { O %&'" 
J  `J  (LMM) *:J  @ & ( Steers, 1977) A"  ?VK8
: %1 $ &o # N3 0zv  + %&'"  ()   7 [ >O @ O
Jv &
DJh,  zD  `&,O : Dh,  zD  : N  $ &
. $&")  E -4 p x 
"  + " & 
*Z  `&  2$ fh,     `&,O : `&  zX : b  $ &
2$ x7F " / z  V  `&  wl" y z  ^~3    ?
+ "5    & `&  @ *"  `&  (8 @  #?") wl" 
O
. `& 
618 F   O $ & Z1 `&,O : `&  @ xp : b b  $ &
:V E V>
&$ (8 !F">  z   !??" B   z 
.( LM ) `&  @

( H)  `>7
A" $ %&'"  ()   #
Dh,  flDp
 E K

"  K
&  K
    K

@ (?F
` F  K

`&  flD

'" 
[  F z K

`&  @ *"  K

`& 
`&  "
` K
618 ?" $
. '" 

`&  2$ B  K


 !

!4 CZF ` K

$&") #$z" XV K


xl  Z"  K
`&   K
`&   $   F K

. 8  ?"

. '"  @ 0
  +
. '"  0  1 K
F  fh,  8 K
.'"

. '"  ?b  K

(IG:G :D)

*ZJ  ( March & Mannari) *  (LMMt) x7    8 


J `>,  {  ' ! 2 %&'"  ()  2 >O @ x$ `  0F
: %&'"  ()  `  Z1 0 #  (e)

( e)  `>7
*  / %&'"  ()  AzO @ x$ ` 

`&  2$  

%&'"  () 

$&") >

`&  @  #?")

0
  
( :LMMtx7   :D)

JV %J&'"  ()  2 >O @ x$ `  [8 (e)  `>,  2 ~#


`J&  J$q  `&  2$   $&") > `b&"O &' @ 0
 
. `&  @  #?")

@ x$J `J  ~ ?V ( Decotis & Summers)  :O > 8 K
: ()  `>,  @ {  1 & &' V  () 
&$ AzO

( )  `>7
  :O > / %&'"  ()  AzO @ x$ ` 
`&  2$  
 V 


 


 
`&  (8

%&'"  () 






     


 
  
 


&'"  flDp
&'"    z 
(t :LMMtx7   :D)

J > nJ V Dh,  flDp `$zO [y C ?  2> ()  `>,  2
 J  + " &'"    z   C3 * &' @ DlD %&'"  
J N3 J &"o `J  Z1 *O }~ `&  2$ 1 V +   
J$  `J&
!J" V J    *Z  &'&
V () + "

:LMMt x7  ) . =$  =& !


& 1(8 %&'"  %Dh,  !

.( t

*    () @ x `


&D" (G) [.1  K 
: A" 2 0"8 0"$ & [.1 n }~  `&   &'&

.Dh,  A"
. %&'"  (F  A"

z  () V |  ~ @ Dh,  A"   [8 [.1 +


 F flDp  &'"  F  1 [ >O [8  ) 3  `&   &'&

! 3 '  2>&  2 %&'"  ()  
&$ [3 .  z  FO ~#O B
$ $O
8  1   }~ z  B
$ A"  Z1 Ay" ." 8 F"$ B
$ 1
(t)  `>,  F  1

.(Ht H ). `&   &' FO x 


:k" 

(t)  `>7


#$)  !  '

 ! # /* 1!2

34* 56
3+7*

 !
-.* +',
zv 

N3 C X 

 E

FO

& 
+ "

%&
" 

p x

Dh,  A"

FO @

@ p   $

kE iD

x  @ p x

 E

@ p x

  

V  `&$

=? 

 !4 $

 \
(   )

B&

(Ht : G[.1 :D)

() J  @ xJ `J  (LMM) *:J   @ k&b   & K J1


` `&, } Dh,  zv  &'"  A" %1 $  8 #b %&'" 
: k"    B
$ %1 $z  A" 2 $ &o 
A" !
b &' @ %&'"  (F 
"O  %1 : &'"  A"
:  "  $z 
Jzv  &' $ ?  &' (F l 1' O  :   D 
2J
<
    x A  CDO) 8 #  ~#D 
. 0zv 
2J J  

C$ *3 + "  @ <


  :O O  : :

. ?  g @ 0
  , $ ?  g @ ~ "  z)
Jzv  2 x&"     A"
O O : zv  A"
:  "  $z  A" !
b `&  #$ 2 8 zv  &'8 2 8 
v  0 x4 #  3 B
$ $O  `  18 2 " O :  
. 0
  0 $     !V  3 &'
&' @ lv  &DO 2& x$ zv  + "5  " :zv  + "5
`&  + "5 FO `&  @  D  ? "    #?") "  :`&,
. &' @ v     C# 2 &' @ 0zv  1

@ x   + " @ x x$ !F~D  : %zv  ?"  " 
. `&  8 x `&  @  D  %zv  : ~#D   

J   nV 4 ( 0zv  :z B


$ x?  %1 : 67 x? 
J&'"  JV?b  `&   B
$ Ay"  @ x?    C# 2 1() i
. 0zv  0    , lv   "5
J$&4 >V ^>  AF O 1 3 v &
*z 
 V : `&  $q
?" C V `>, v 
  O B
$ x %1 ! 3 %&"  1
. !V18
%  `1 &  :  "  $z  A" `&,O : Dh,  A"
. v &
$&")  E p x

[8 B
$  ?zO %&'"  ()  Co @ 0b~F  i
8 [8  ?V %F F$ 8 K
J8 $ &o n 8 N3 !&?O 2> %&'"  ()  + "  
: %
 &
xJ J
"  + " -4 2  `b : Dh,  flDp & 
 E  &<  ?"  1) Dh,  %zv  : p
. Z  ?
 J  JX `b : v   *Z     <FO flDp & 
.    (i$    &
J'"   #?"J J'"  .~ `b : %&'"  `> flD 
. %&'"   &'"  V?b 
. [ J "  ,J J$&4 J1 `Jb : `&  <FO p
. ( LM : LMM *:J  )

N3 J78 %&'"  ()  Co @ |8    '  [8 F  f


h"
: %1 &'" 0
  () &O @ 1O  `  18 2 [8

: $&") > G
." %$&" ' *8 @ 2 ? fh,
$&") FO
O " > D?
J " 0J  'O 8  $q ` z  FO   iO"  " y Z 6 O
2J$ =AFJ O  fh7 B
$ $&4 !zO $&" FO 8  > > [ >O
iJ~ '"  @ F ! V FO .  A > [ >"V 1 7
B J J'"  @ 2J F  V ` FO V  %1 iO" FO
[J?V [ J . !"&O !"> B
$ 'V&
1 ! +D CZF [
 
=J8 =FFJ ! * F  = =~ "  ( >
? 6   *8 ) >
J
?  !J    i `>, !  `&   $&4 V8 `F 2 F 
. '"  O N3 <) 2 <)
@ J!
$ fh,  `D      : ! x$ F8 $&") >&

0J "  @ J  J `&  6 v O! `&  8 &' (
J> 
" J J&'  2 !
$ fh,  `D  F N3 V
.!
*J J1 J   [b~F        !v8 ?
@ 0
J  2 fh7 l =z 8 |
 G $ (Marsh and Mannari)
@ 0
J  `J J  FJ B
$ 6 "  !V1 [   "> ) Co
J> J&'"  @ 0
J  2 `&  [  @ F `8    &'" 

iF [8 0   0

%&'"  ()   x:   z) Z1 [8 !v8
J   Jv  !
$ `D     >  N    n ()  Z1
! BD8 CZ V &") '"
()  [8 + Z . '"  @ l? ."
> 2 B
$8  ? &" @ 0
  F 2$ %8 `>, . `&  @
!"" x !l8 2~ B
$ = 3 ->  !< O $&4  2 : 
. ( HG I : G   ) . V18 ? '"  hV

:    61  K L


J B
$ F< !?? !&!V B
$ x b8 0  ` 61 
J# J' J
.  AO `&  @ ">   V ` 6  0V  
J J z  + ()  & k"   ` D  `? .
. ( He : LMMe )

:0
  ~   K I
@ 0
  V ~ F73 B
$ $O 
  FO B
$ `&  x 
J
" JE 2 $ &o [3 *8 $   
$ 6 " 1 &>V '" 
8 " 3 O7 @
  &"  . V () %zv 
  `>,O B
$ $O
J [cV E Z1 | F78 cV E Z1 F73 B
$ z  x B
$ "F


J  BJ J 2 >O B
$ $ `>, 3 %
 FO 
$ iO"
JE Z1 F73 @ z
'"  x 2$ wO  [ "
  Z1 [ "

: G  *
) . %&'"  ()  (&") [&)    ,  $  "
. ( GL

J J' ! *,F 
  nV  @ }FO ' (&
 n ?
(&")    @ V  ' O F E 
 ' 
 1 ) E
!"~E !"8 V 0

 E |FO  '  2 1A & 
0
   @ '  x$3   &'"  3 B
$ |F 8 F7 @
. E
O z""

: %zv  B  H
@ J
&$ J Jz  !F  $, y %zv  B  (G)   6 
[8 !
$ i  zv  ?O  0 z
z  3 2 B  y, '" 
 J " +J . %zv  B    &! z  ` &
>V  ?O
`D [8 %F  z   7 0 z  
D5 " 1 %zv  B  [8 " Lawler
%zv  B  [8 ( Herzberg)  A1 + " =# V 
$ `D  '"  2 
$
J  ,  @ / 
$ zv  * <O  z   7 V /  2>
 2>&V %zv  B  $ 8 . zv  @ ?"  [>3   F"$)
J  `&  6 v '"   
b&" `&    7 C# 2
.( HI ) 67
8   %$&") : zv  @ 2 ?")
@  ! 2 z  ZF  0 [ "  3 2 y, %zv  B  [8 [ \ +
 J7  3 %zv  B  ? [ "  ?  cV . l $ 2    `& 
. B    ,    O  <   0 [ "  C#"

[8 Jz
%J&'"  ()  %zv    0 O     |z, 
2J () b8 1V8 [ > %zv    2  $  1 O  &'"  F 
. 1A

: :V E ' e
0
J  '"  0 &V #  :: O @ `$V   (Incentives) :V

8  [ >O :V E Z1 . '"  618 ?   V  + ?  :z  %!V V
!; :: O V  V  x3 @  B
$ 1AyO  " $q 8 V   
J  1ZzO @  F" i  B
$ 1AyO  " & . !l)

'"  !"?

 ,J     ,  ()  ?" V 0
  618 '"  618 %$O
. Z  ? B 
N3 *O y!"O  [ < F  @ ~" > " y :VE 6 
O~ nF, *Z 
   <,8 8 , l3 0 
 V   ?O
. ( Ht H : G   ) V18 ? O  O
 x 8 
  8
 2$ (LMML ) *   A, & :VE 
J' :JO . DJ  OE O z" 
< F7 z
?O
`&
^  nVO  F n =#X8 ` "O %1 
  :V E B
$ `&
:V E
2 O | 3 x [cV 
$ m !V !l? 8 &' @ `&  !O F8
61 N3 
D " x? )   ??
< !4  ZF [8 !
$
:V E 2 F &'8 V O [cV Z . Z F :V E  ?O [8 !
V x

`J> J&' 2$ %&'"   2$   x N3 *    8   ( 


.( )  >"  `
?O " )  zO %&'"  ()  x k" 

: %&'"   K
J&'&

  (  A" 6 '  
D5 " %&'"   D?
J!V  DJ
h" J 
&$ $ 

 z & 1V8 !  &


J!l)

!lJ&"  1(8 !


    1 !z 
. ( et  G  %F>  ) " &'&

& &' Dh7 (G )   C ? & 1 %&'"   [cV 


$ (
`J&   B
$ &"  `$V `>, !V18 ? @ &'  [8 ($ 1
%&'"   AV O N3 C X
=  [  0
  &'"  [8 . !V   *Z 
. =  &!ED 4
JF   J&'"  [8 : C Z1 @   !v8 ( LMMe)  C ?O
J  J ^J~ 2  $  D"O  C&
 .,  
[J &"1) 61 ? 4 %&'"  
B
$ `& O 0
 
.( He ) 1V8 + %&'"  () 
@  &'O %1

: &'"  ?b  K t
?b   ", D ? / !
 . V   O V O ?b  O
2$ DO  !z,  8  ">  $  ?" $ & 8 z  n O " %1 &'" 

2J J?"O &'"  ?b  [8 0b~F  + " $q 8   =V8 2
) nJ&4 [8 J
$V  #$ ? @ 0F  '"  V ", 
. 2 (Z @ [ F
?O @ '"    V x(z ? @ *,F  D  B
$ &' &"$ 1 
?b  `&$ [ '"  0
  0 ?b   nV 6 1V x:&" p
ZJ   >" )  x &'&
()  &O @ $&4  @ 8
 :J [  J'  F<O    ?  3  ZzO &' B
$ i
2   @ ~"? ( i~"  , x D/ ` "  B
$ E
. ( tI tL  LMM "  ) .
"  2$ = {" 

: &' V? K
J"~) CJ  1  `&$  AV O 0zv  ~ F7c &' &"1 [3
BJ
$ ! .,O 0zv  0 :&" ( A  O &' 0zv  0 CF"
0J () J  xJ '"   x  x N3 * ?  g @ ,
. '"
0zv 
.O"J) J&'"  JV?b  C ~ ( Nystrom, 1993)  "  |
0J J #$   !v8   D  $   @ %&'"  () 
. ( He : LMMe   ) %&'"  ()  &'"  V?b 

: %$&") nF<"  K
8   ?  &' 
O 2 z  2> " 
&$ 8 (LMML) C Z Z
  O  DO  [8 (  $&4 DO 8 &'  $  F?
 
J?  " Jz  J!V iJ"> J
&$ %1 . m2> 8 &' `&  2$ 
.( IG ) " !V18 &' D n V "O 
  8 A  1)
0VJ<  # !V B
$ !~ &"  &' z  0 (  N3 
&  Z1 6
J~ 2J DlD B
$ :"  z  ( "~ B
$ &' x  F  &! F
. +8 ~ 2 &'"  61 flDh
>"  z  [>3
@ JO nF<"  $ !"
$V &' x(z ? @ !   %&'"  nF<"

( ee  G   ) &' > l) X#3 z  "3 
#b  %&'"  nF<"  
&$ [8 (LMM) "    & 0b~F  +
: ?~#" `~
J1) ?  2 $ &./  : 1 z  "
 }~ : `&  `F  
~ 8
J
~ 
~ Z1 " O &' "
 [8 `F O~ C# F"> 
 8
J&' 2$ V i  `&   F 2$ #  
 # z   :" !
. ! 3 (&") i 
0J J!   !V x7F N  
~ %
O  %1 : !  
~
?FJ  DO ~ & 1  2
 Dh7 2 :&" / z 
O J"  6 p  ,V %
z  &' n z  ,"> 
~ Z1 @ &' 2$

=<,J = J$ {FD B    F3 N3 & V !


$ i
"  C  
? 
. '"  @ =,
J 
J  J8 x4 ?  1) "O !V : C "  
~
tI ) O 2$   DO  [ >" ?"V &' n
$zO @ z  !F"
.( tH

: x? 
8 K GM
J&! [8 J& . 1:z~ 2 C&$8 B
$ Ay"  (Leadership) x?  O
J3 `  `&  c O$ B
$ 1:z~ 2 3 @ 2&>O l?

&' 618 F" !$3 "$q yO i n<" *Z  1 {  l? V . 3
.  Dh7 =V18 1F"$
`& " ='   ">  2 Ab>  @ x?   !z [ b~F  C O 
. `&  &' @ V + %&'"  ()  &O @
J $ J
$V ' F `&$     [8 (LMM ) *:J  +
J J&' @ 0zv 
V x x?  O$ B
$ n?O 0zv &
x:z5
0 [ O [8 !
$ %FV x &/ AF ~ N3 [y" 3 
&  '" 
8 &'8  (  `> &' `>,O   " E 
" X 
.( G ) &' 618 F
<" 0 0zv  ~ 0 V O ?" 0zv 
`F?"J *J [yJ D  Z1 @ (G )   Z &   A,O
ZJ . <
  `5 # [8 i x  E [y C ?  n B,&" = [ ! 

. ?  Z 0
   6"  [8 %? 
  "   B
V
)   J < [8 ! 3 i
< 2Z  VV (&")    ` E [  !V
iDJO ) J$ zD 
 x [3 1j) 2& [8 8 ! V  :O [8 2>
.( L ) !z8 [ FD x?  2> x? 

: '"  @ 0
  , KGG
J ?O y7 2   `&" ! .,O 1>Vy &
0

Xz  ~O3
. `&   @ (F  %$&") %z  4 3   
@ %z  %
?  z   " y (LMML) *   @ & , |V$ 
61 @  z  !V $ 1  $&4 {"O [8  $&4 `&$
@ Jz
kJ z %
?$ "7 " y \ !V$ & . "   @ ,
@ ", [8 B
$ $&4 61 @  , B
$ ., %$q  
.(M) " !$  
: %
 &V `b&"O  5 ^8 # B
$ , 
&$  ?O
`J 4 
&  - h" B
$ &l?  >z  
?  , B
$ * <O 8
.   V  , 
&$
xJ4 z  !l<$c `&
! VO V :V~ x B
$ `& O 8
. 61 ? N3   >" ) F <  # ,&

.   `F?O `&  @ V ! &O B
$ `& O 8

Jg 8 6J1 ?O @ , [ >O ?V ,&


0b~F  DO  O 
. A C ^8 8   @ , 8 #>, `~ 8 ? 
() J  BJ
$ J  @ , 8 @ }FO    2   |
J @ 0  73 [8 B
$ O   Z1 wl" '  | %&'" 
|J ( J ! %&'"  ()  x N3 * !  n @ 
. ( HH : LMMe  )  8 
?$ ,

:      KGL
%J&'"  () J   x N3 *O  zO    [8 (G) *
 Z
J @ J 8 
    @  D?  ." zh       ->$
.(GII ).") O %&'"  ()  O !
$ iO" 
  `& 

.l" %&'"  ()  \ Kt


[ J> J?V  3 =\ [8 & &' z  `&," %&'"  ()  \  "O
BJ
$
&"  Z $ %
 &V )E @ =F
 =F %&'"  ()

:&' z 

: z  B
$ %&'"  ()  \ (8
& &' `&  @ &") @ z  F * ? %&'"  ()  : %zv   
Jz   . %zv   B
$ ->  *Z   
& l8 $ n"&"

ZJ1 ?" =1 `&  k"  V18 1"  &' 618 F"
%zv 

`~ @ %&'"  ()   <O @ =1 =#$ %zv    "$  . 61


. ( I : LMMe *   ) . v "  2 N 8
2Z  V [8 + 0b~F  2 =Ab [8 (G )   C ? : %$ 
 
:J&" J [ J" !V [
&   &'" ()  2  $  [ zD"
=J:"  Jb8 `J&
=; b8 [ > k  %&'"  ()   z  [8 [ 
A,JO Jl8 ""3 2 : *Z  F  =l?
O B  '"  61y
J  J!
$ :>O   ? 18 2 "  %&'"  ()  [8 N3  
.( te )
^J~ J
&$ " Jy ( G * J
 @ )   - O 6$ 
 Jz  ZJ1 JF" z  >V X 
 AO 8 #>,
"") 2   B
$  ?O 
&  Z1 wl"  N3 C X  6 !
 O
1 %zv  8 *   8 " x E 'z
 A 'z
 $ "
."  8  8 
 `>7 N3  w" ?O " y 6$ ?V 1 &! 
.( GIe GIH )  " !  O p 8 
  "3 
&$ @
|J  ZJ1 @  O !V18 6#" B
$ &'"  [8 (G )   +
JbE J >"   !v :O V &
n   <"  @ 
b&" xAF 
b8 `>, !?O i 8 p B
$ i
<    "&
n  ?" 
Jp J18 ~8 "    [cV 
$ ( . ( @ =? O `8 x(z
 J<"  J " A" 
O !  2 2>&"" &'"  Z1 8 ~ <
( J J~ B
$ C   &' (#3  z Z1 ` . ) 7 @ 
l
!J xz") 2>  V $ 3 x >V8  X 8 &
 F 
.( t ) " 2 :  ( 2 `>,

x~ B
$ ~ -> O %&'"  ()  \ [cV +8 ! 2 : Xp v  x~
nzO %&'"  ()  z  :&" }~ `&  3  Xp 0  V
x  zO N3 V3 `&   8    ~  x   2  $ 
. ( I : LMMe *  ) . 
l  O#$
&!"J @ J
 J"  C J? & nzO ()  v V : ! ?" 
. zv  iO @ =?O =O 8 [ > k"  
&$ @ =o [ > (Gt)
6J18 J? @ =!" =X#3 b8 z  ` nzO %&'"  ()  Z
[8 J"?b &' !  "
D 2 [8 + 8 & =V18 1"   &'
.(LM ). X#3 l) B
$ V>" &'
J&'  :  :" ) ! # &' x #8 "~
0 (  &' ` # "  
" >  3 #8   B
$  
J nJzO %&'O () `   7 &
>V !z8 0  0 8 &' ` 
. # Z :" # 8 [ &
 "&'
C J? & 0b~F  [8 Z  4 2 8 )3 l z  Z1 ` 2   B
$
nzO %&'"  ()
F
     C&"~ N3 78 (LMM ) *:J 
J 
& O O nq &b"   nzO %&'"  ()  v V
|J *8 J" ) :O &"1 ` B
$ " `&  `  &' 618
.  :  ~3 2 2$ v  C:$ N3 *  Z1 `&   ,

J$&") JO#$ "JX B
$ (8 B
$ O  z =     
. p

Jzv z %   &") &' @ (?F  B


$ v  X ."
  N3 `D  
l$ z `,     +8 &' @ `V8
.( LH ) !

: &' B
$ %&'"  ()  \ (
() J  2J J $  ! V "O 2Z  VV : " F zO
V i~ 2$ wO  4 %zv  ( [ " !
&$  %zV %&'" 
J J    8   '"  61y !:"  `&
!;
( + "J zO %&'"  ()  0  3 #$   B
$ " :"
@ %l?
"  ! >" ) + " zO N3 wl"  78 & %zv 
.( t t : LMM  "  ) #>, `~
x1Jv J&' !O *8 0zv  O   : 0zv  O 2 E
 &' @   2$ z   O " %zv  "   . xA< &'O
: %1 x$ wl" "  Z . ! FO B?O
J") [#J$ z
>O !  $ z
>O " V :  zO  >" 
.    V D 2 1A $ i" 
0  x(z [?V 2$ . C V : 0"~ 2 ( `< " : ( `< O
}JF  z
 `&  `< O zv   7 z
 2$ b  . &$8 !O `F
. `F  2$
J$&" 8 2 ! / &' " : )DO) $&")  FO
`J&$ $q 2&   2 8 0, 0
  2 `&  O [ [cV  
x $ ?O )  0
  ? B
$ F
 \ "
[ > 6 V >&"

J O !
>O $&4   B
$ O ` . ( z `&  (F$8
.0  ()  V &"  :: O
J!l# 2J =Ab [8 0  'O @ [
  + $ :    z
J!~   JO &   O !   V +8 &'O N3 `&  [ "
.&' @ =F
 =AyO   13 F zh"V    
2J$ :J. O &'"  2 =Ab>V : '"  @ 0zv  B
$ `&  (i$ x
`J 8  0
   $ 8   F 0 " [>  h78 v O
??E 0zv  ? !
! 8 0
  B
$ %z  < `&  . x
! 1 
~ N3 !
X  (")  z  &' @ 0zv  +  "V
. XV C 8  !v $ `&  " *4 A>z"  N3 ! VV <  6"
.( LG LG : LMM + F$ )
J&$ 0FJ5 !
%&'"  ()  0
   7 [3 :   F z
 "  B
$ [ X k"  !V (?F  @ !"F ' !FO)  F ."
.C&$ `< O n &"
 V  + " 0 FO   8    [8 N3 (LMM) "  A,
[ J  %&'"  ()  + " zO [ "&" *Z  VV %&'"  ()  + "
z) %&'"  !l) " 2Z  V n ?  E B
$ =X~ b
@ {J" J `J
 %&'"  ()  0 %>$ FO     8 &
.( t ) !4 CZ @ F   |  @ `&  N3  E
*:JJ  C J? & ()  +  [8 N3 78 2 !V : {D  ?  g
J? !EDJ J *Z  &'&
{D  ?  g @ 1O (LMM )
+ "J    61  ' 2 ?  g "V "$3 2 =) !V18

V> [  " ) $ ~ 0zv  :z N3 ()  * ` <  + nV 
.( LH LI )
$J J&
 %&'"  ()  0
   7  &
 8 (LMM) "   Z1 @
!J?O `J8 2 &' X @ [ > [8 2> AO * 0  ()1 `F?O B
$
.( t ) =8 1) Ap !
$   &' 1 [y  11
A, &   +~3 | : &'&
(z>  <?"  !
FO 3 0  'O N3 &# z  `F 2 %lF ?  [8 (LMM)" 
{FDO nzO () 1V8  ,  &' [  () 2 z   3 ` /
.( t )  &) @ (z>  i  x !"

:%&'"  ()        0 #  K
wlJ" N3 *J J [cV  zO V    | 3 8   |z,
8 JV>&
&'8 F<O 8   nV 2   "
O zO [3 ` !V 
..   ^> 3 8 `  1 V
V h
w
`FJ B
V %&'"  ()  B
$ =8 O       B
$ x `  ' 
2 a` B
$ O ! q :V E 61 ) E x? 
8 : Cb
F"$ & '  2> (()    ) 2A" #>V .%&'"  ()       
1 J'  2J J  & +:  }~ '"  @ )

AzO  >
J8  A A1 [8 (GL, )   .= 3 8 =F
 &'"  
 
$V 0 z  " ~ [)
     > 0 xy" x # 
.(GGM ) . 2~8 B
$ `&  (

* J
) %J&'"  () J   x N3 *O  zO       [ &>V
nV @ =&! =  i
 :z } 78 & %&'"  ()  [cV (GII :G
N3 ! V !V [
&   &' !
&$ [ F !
0
  +      
+J %&'"  ()  z [8 0~ @ &' 618 ?" ^; [  " `& 
%"   <) F
  N3 * /       z N3 * 0
 
) 
J  #>,J 2 A zh " >"   `&  @
.( G Gt : LMMH * !z 
%J&'"  () J  J      0 #
= DO nO [8   C  Z>1
:%&'"  ()        #$ [ N3 B O }~ (  `>, )
( )  `>7
%&'"  ()        #  
x ` $

%&'"  ()  
 zO

      + "
 $

< "

< "

.61
.`&  6 v
67 x?  &'8
.CDO
#  E F73
.)
.:V E

zh

zh

.&'"    
.i" 
.1Z  F   E

.*   + ,  -
o 2$ ZF : } b  }F
@   &'"  <
   DO  #b  !4 +~3 1 + ,  -
o
%zD ) .(  -
o  + ,  -
o 
 : %1       >
&
+ ,  -
./
"O  ?  1  " %
 &V .( G : LMM
:*  

: O  KG
|
X ~       >
& -yO Z x$ `~/ + ,   ?
:%
 & `~ Z1 3 2>  E !"
~
:GLH/J1GIHI  %
1 -
 : N  
~

8 GLH/GL/LM V  J1GIHI/e/LH @ ih" -


o C 8 -yO (
   ( [  = $ (GL) " $ @  * ,  %
1 -
 
$
 ' 1 2> #F  x 8   'O -
 Z  ?V `&">
.!78 " k ~ -
 Z1 &" -
 `&$
:GLe /J1GIHH  * ,  %
1 -
 : b  
~
B
$ ih" -
o `>,O   -
 `~ ?V , xl n O @ F
1 .! O " ($8 # N3 V3 x."  2$ ~

(&
 2 [3 [ > [8

-l   ?  2 =&'O b8 -


 Z1 [ .0 "  h") 0 n&4

@ -
 Z1 `>,O &
O ( .
a08 N3 V3 = $ (Ge) il

%1 ") ~  2 "# $  \   7 ~   |


. &V -yO *Z  + ,  -
o ' x    O
:J1GL/J1GIHe  + ,  -
o :b b  
~
!  B
$ x    ( 1~ O #F     `~ 2&

O 2& 2 >E '  &


"  X ?"  n&"   
N3 78  + ,  -
./
"  ! -  p n   ?  &
" 

>,O %
1 -
   ) 2 =) + ,  -
./ "&O -
 ?
 ~ ~  2 O
 ?   = $ (GL) 1$ r
2Z  ($8
`>,O &
O @ !
&o @   Z1 O .x~    x 
4
.GLt/t/V J1GIH/G/t @ -
 Z1 `~

   -


:GLt/J1GIH  + ,  -
o :   
~
X GLt/t/ V  J1GIH/G/ @ *8   -
 `~ 2 0  
+ ,  -
./ Xp %1  &
"  2 n   ?  ` " %>
 8
($8  2   Z -
 [ >O  C  4 '
=?V -
 `&  }
x,"   8  >E h" " ($ `>,O [cV '
=?V

0" x

. `18 2 ! [3 [ > !"V /  >E 1"g  8 xp `z  `18


-
  !&'O @ !v8 x x,$  @ X ?V -
 ' 8
($8 () 1$ 0z ($y :
 -
.&
' C 8   Z 1 .?  

[8 2>  F @ 0O -


 ?  [8 B
$ 
  #4   il  l
.E |$ &
 l 2 x $ B
$ ( 2 b8 n&"
:GL/J1GIHt  + ,  -
o : p 
~
@ # "  (3 
D |" ?V -
   C&$ xb> ='
2 [ x x,$  8 @ C  \ ' z   @ X }~ '
[8 
 `F 2 -
.&
l il 0 O '  Z1 @ 3  # " 
.=  -
 
 ?  -
 `F 2 [ il ih"
b8 [ > "X |   nF @ '

 z   @ -
 2$ X &
| # "  C3  =?~) X  -
 C&$8 A =&'O (#
.x 2,$ n 8 @ (+ ,  -
%
  ' ) :
2 =  = ^ `v  ` O [   Z ' + ,  -
o &"
n O + }~ GeI/J1GItI $ (  -
o -yO [8 N3 ~#D 
x4  >E x:! (  -
o 0 + ,  -
o ~#X 2 Ab> 
 3 C   " O
 `X  `v + ,  -
o 2> !"&'8 V x <
.`F 2 
$ [ *Z  + " 2> [3 ' V
:}E + ,  -
o :   
~
F$ 2 !V
 0z,  0E   &"  @ = =y7 >
& | < $
X3 2$ J1GHGL//Lt   2
$yV #F  @ &' }"  ; :: 
. ' + ,  -
o ' >E ' #b  &'

@  ?
 $ ?  -
.&

  l#  + ,  -
4 '  &"$
.(G KG : LMMI 
 x3 ) .J1GHGH/I/I O
O  @ = $ 0" -l 2 
~ Z1 C# N  O  @ -
 [ >O ?
= > -
 {FX8 b b  O  @ = $ 0 O -l 2 = > -
 X b 
l -l 2 [ >" -
 X    O  Z .= $ 2,$ l -l 2
= &o B?"
 l? 3 B
$ 'V n D") xp 
 `18 2 = $ 0
%
F,  ) .  [8  ?  2 Fh =." l  DDh"  h

.(LMKG LMM

:OXD" + ,  -
o ~#X KL
:      >
& @ >
^ '  2 [ "  b  x @ 
" OXD") " z  >O ? ' 0F + ,  -
o y,)
.(l$8
M/8  %>
  x4 O X @ + ,  -
o '  X [8 7 2 
x?  
<O ." n i "O  <O 
? `b J1GHGL //Lt "

 x3) .  >O ? ! ~ x 0# @ X }~ 2 
.(LG : LMMI

:%
 & %1       >
& @ OXD" + ,  -
o ~#X  8
: ( % ,"  ) %&'"     K8
2   {l
 &' $ ,  C# 2 lv  Z1  "O
(# + ? [8 [8 ` . ` O 2   `J  !V 8 *F  >E
. x,$ p x V &' AzO ZJ  $ 2 J'  X3
~#X }~  n + ,  -
o D" [y O   D  Z1
. V  >E  <

'
:
 Az" 
B< O }~ ' , " ?"  ~ '  2 [ ,  b b  x C g &
Z1 + ,  -
o @  ( 0 ?  ) &' $ , " ~ &'"  <
 
. ZV ' ` O 8   ' " ($8 x,$ ` >
E

:    zO) 1   K


")     zO)  1  : 
$  O [y -
 ' :

2 *8 B
$ 8 !
$ z"  8  ?V  $  ~ @  1&"$ `F !V '

. F 0FO 1 

:      K
: O `l  C# 2 % >E ( B
$     + ,  -
o ^

?
< D ~#D  Z1 ( :  
    @ *8  ( 3
.!V 8 ( 3 @ i~8 =)o -
 {  $
61 2&"  `7 , &"  < : &"
  <p ,
w  2&"O &  !??" :  + D")  &
"   $&")
-
  ? # 2  61
O ?" #     `l 
[8  ` O 2   " 8  13  i 4 
" 2 !",/
x:!8 ,  5  O   
    
q"  `b &"  <
.   
C# 2 -
  ? :  >E x:! 
   ?"  ,

" &V (   V O, @ % >E ( B


$ #) ?"
",
[y =&
$ . : k 6D 
" &V 8  0zv  (8 ,F  + ? 
x:!    nq K 2,   "  O @ :
 (  -
o '
2 =  0 O C# (  -
o -l N3 =  =?O nVO [8 +  >E
  <p @  / ? 3 2 ?  =&"     ` 
.`&  A 2E ~"? 2 O    D   ?   C# &"

.+ ,  -
o N3 nVO 2
% >~ C  *8 ($" ~ + ,  -
: 0 >E 0  ($"
2& n?O   !! O 8 -
 +  
 ~")  O 
. ' 2 2,  b  x&
=?V  OXD"
: ( [  ) ' , " K
. 2,  b b  O V + ,  -
o   XD") 2   Z1 [3
. ZV ' ` O 8   ' , " ~ ($8 x,$ ` %< O 
3  < ( )  `>,  {  .(ILKIM : LMMI 
 x3)
: -
 @ '  ,

( )  `>7
+ ,  -
o @ '  , 3  <
.
 
~
@    `F 2  .
 `F 2 " C&"    >E 2   ,   nq , "O !V
. #  l  n& =$ z, -
 C&$8 C 

-
 
~
( (# )

..
   (# B
$ | D"   ($ 2 v
 ( 3  -
 ` ,&
$ x( %1
( , )
. 
$ | D"  [   x  x ,&
, 
( | D"  )
  B
$ | D"  ". x ` C ~ A8  ($ v
 B
$ .
  &") 
.x x ,

 B
$  O
=F  

0
 ' ! 2FO  ~ @

(  -
o -l
(  -
o
  


0
 ' ! zO3  ~ @
( + ,  -
o (  -
o )

%>
   X3
  x4 @ [#$

([ ) '

(HL : LMMI 


 x3:D)

:+ ,  -

  ,  KI
-
 %'~   
 
" &V + ,  -
`$z     3 @
&) 2 -
 2>  : "     &."  ) @ 
>   
: O ) N3
.(J1GHLH) k     )
.(J1GHLL)     )
. (J1GHLL)     
. (J1GHLI)
 ?" k   0  
.(J1GHG Z - $) %# &' @ ($ C   - o 
.(J1GHLI) &"  [>
   C   ?V8 % +"
.(J1GHLL)    
0  (  q
-
o C    + ,  -  0  (  q @ - $
.(J1GHGt) %.
p [  " 
.(J1GHLH) $&") h
k   0  
.(J1GHLe)     ?V8 @ 
& -  + ,  ,  - o < 
.(J1GHL) k?")   [ 
.(eeKeH : LMM C#!F ) .(J1GHL)    0  (  q

:-
 @    [ ,  KH
+ ,  -

  l#  J1GHGH/I/I O Ge/8  %>
  ~
   [ ,  'O $   F

+ ,  -
o ($8 ?~ l)

.(3 + ,  -
o & ?"  $   + ,  -
zv 

Z1 [8 & .Xp $ ?  Z =?V -


.&
zv    [ ,  'O "
2 ? DO  z
"h -
 3 !  %&'"  `> @ / $ ? 
@  p &'8 *O & l -
 ' n  " ) / -
 -l
. A 
  l#  ?O  -
 x:!8 %zv  B
$       >
&
x7F
 N3 nVO  ":    =3 =  
?" ! + ,  -
o
   x:!8  ng      
-
 n )  !
$ ?V &

: LMMI 
 x3 ). Xp   "  ! -
.&
[3 }~  +
.(e KeH
: *   + ,  -
%&'"  `> ( GM )  `>,  { 

", x3

-l  il i">

($ [ ,   x

 " x3

F  D  [ ,  4 C&$8 x3

?       

)DO) `?  4 C&$8 x3


 
 x

  [ ,  4 C&$8 x3

x$   

p [ ,  4 C&$8 x3

[.
 [ ,

#$ V?b  [ , 

[.
 [ ,   x

%&
 }F  &
"  [ , 

( GM )  `>7

,F    x 4 C&$8 x3

+ ,  -
o -l

 [ ,  4 C&$8 x3

-
 -l il

O>

D") [ ,  4 C&$8 x3

-l  i">

$&") [ ,  4 C&$8 x3

  0

# [ ,  4 C&$8 x3

x$   

p  4 C&$8 x3


4 [ ,

 " "  x3


4 [ ,   x

$&") 
4 'O x3

J1 GHIG + ,  -
%&'"  `>

DF   &  `l  x3

( tH :LMMC#!F  :D)

?   x3

  0 i">

O>

(D~  "  x3

-
 -l $

: x3

-l  $ i">

2,"&
  x

  #  F 7 i">

 <"  <h"  x3

  p x3

k iE x3

  [ ,  x3

[ ,
  x

0zv  [ 7 x3

  

[ :h F 

O>

 " 

#$ #
  x

 )DO) x3

?    
      ?
"   -
<
z   4 @ 0

      " [  (Ge) #  :=) 8
."   z  @
&  `b !V x `        + " V  N3   |V1 
A" Z `&  6 v   :V E (#:  n #  *? 
  n&"o [ >O .iO  %&
 `1 p   $ -4 Dh, 
z  @ <
z   4 @   0" ($ 8 1 =V M 2
 wl"  2

%zX  w!   | FO . =V GI 1?    

B
$ O ) iO  %&
 `1 &   -4 A" [ }~F  ! 3 `X O
[> [ & .lD~3  ) 8 p   $ A" [ &V .     
   + " B
$ `&   F O ) &V       + " B
$ AyO `& 
.  
1 "       :  [ $ (LMMt) 6$  6$  :=
 @    
~ &


%&
 + )o

1D

.(0<
V)-

%&
 + 1D       + " 2$ ,>  N3   |V1 
 $&")  E& -4)A" ( @  
~ &

  n&"o [ >O A" Z1 -4 A" 0 `$z"  (
&  xp&

w!   | FO . =V GLG |>V   $ 8 &
 =&
 LtG 2
      @ lD~3  )  V   !.l"  8 | . % %zX 

&  &
 2 B
$8      0&
 + [8 0FO }~ 
 - A" +: O
.+ A"&
+: O       @ lD~3  )  V  O )

   ^  *?  &  #$ : [  (LMM) 1:   :=b 


.(x 'V/ l" ) 
~ &
   
:N3   |V1 
&
*? 
  8 `v @ &
 ` O  F 2$ 
 AV O -
.!V#" B
$

    &
 "3 B
$ 18       8 B
$ (  (? 3 -
 nq 2   n&"o [ >O  @   *? 
x MIG 1$ r F  x 'V/  >E l" ) 
~ &

w! b~F  |h"  &
 x HM   $ |
&

0 F  FO #$   :  Z1 wl"  8 .   @ %zX 
0 l" ) 
~  + + ?   2 %?  & 
 >E ^  ' ! 2 &
"  &
     
&  0 [ FO) `  r
}~(MMG) + " $ x 'V/
.(MtML) &
"  &
      0 %? 

* + %&'"  D  x3 i 8 " [  (LMM) * p  : = 


! 2 0&
&
      !"#$ > > /  >E  b  ^
."1'
:  618 |

i  > > /  b  ^ *   B


$ 6 "  -
.%&'"  D  x3
.> > /  b  ^ %&
       + " B
$ 6 "  -
/  b  ^ * + D  x3 i 8 0 #  B
$ 6 "  -
.0&
 ' ! 2 0&
&
      + " > >

 IMM 2  >   | &V =&
 GHMG 2   n&"o [ > 
. " @ %zX  w! }~F  h"
:!yV   wl" 8
 b  ^ %&
 + k$ + "/ (        8 nq [8 -
   #   ( }~ 1' ! 2 > > /
.=  $  b  N  0"FO @ `&  2$ 0
 
D  x3 i 8 2 [  " 
8 0 F  FO #$ 1 [8 -
2 0&
&
      + " 0  b  ^ * + %&'" 
.1' !
* Dh,  &  ?   " [  (LMM) "   :=
"&
"  l<  'V5 @ 0&
&
      !"#$ ^
: N3 |V1
< " ^ * Dh,  &  n O ?   B
$ 6 "  -
.l<  'V/
'V/ < " 
~ @ 0&
 +       + " B
$ 6 "  -
.l< 
+ Dh,  &  ?   0   FO #$   2 ?"  -
.l<  < " 
~ @ 0&
 *       0 ^ *

IMM |
l ,$ $ }~F  " =&
 GGt 2   n&"o [ >O 
. " @ %

"  w! % %zX  w! }~F  h" 

:|>V   wl"  8 8

0 (MMe=a)  )  + " $ lD~3  )   V  O )

Dh,  &  ?    3 C ~   V8  ." < "


 %&
 `1 xp   & ) A"&
=?V      
.($&")  E  `1
&! Dh,  &  ?   0   F  FO #$  

.      0
2F"  2 AF  zO  &"o Dh,  &   &"o ?   [8

.0&
&
      + "

%&'"  ()  ?
"   -
&  -"  1 ($ %&'"  ()  " [  (G) *&   :=) 8
"  
   @  (j *? 
-"  1 ($ %&'"  ()  x?  8 0 #  F" N3 |V1 
  -"  1 ($8 nq 2 = >   n&"o [   
  
GHt   kq3 r
&V J1GHGt/GHG %  
  /  

. % %zX  w! " @ }~F  h" = $
:  2$ w"

()  %<
"  *?  &  0 lD~3  )     F
 #$  

.%&'" 
()  %?  *?  &  0 lD~3  )    #$  

.%&'" 
@ &'"     AyO " :[  (LMMH)  <?   * !z   :=
"  4 'V5 @ : l 
  : %&'"  () 
@ 0

%&'"  ()  @ &'"     AyO B
$ 6 "  N3   |V1
2   n&"o [ >O ([ 
z< > ) 'V5 :  l  
. zv  v  tMM 2  > < l ,$ 0 zv  zv  LHHH
. % %zX  }F  .! B
$   &"$
: !$ w" 
. < "  | %&'"  ()  (3 0 F  DO -
. %&'"  ()  &'"     0 &!   FO #$ 1 -
.%&'"  ()  @ &'"       lD~3  ) 8 1 -
+: O %&'"  ()  (3 0 F  DO 0 lD~3  )  V 1 -
.(iO  xp %&
 `1) V   A"&

")
 "#$ %&'"  ()  " :[  (LMMe) [ ,  :=b 
" z  x 
z  x  ") %&'"  ()  0 #   F 2$ ,>  N3 |V1
2  > D $ B
$   |?F  " @ %zX  w! }~F  nFO
2 ` %&'"  ()  0 F
 #$     2$ w" .=, HG
x &  %&'"  ()  0 #$   ) 8 & z  x  ")

()  @   Z  0 lD~3   V  O &  %&


"  + " p
. !l' 2 &' () b8  Z  [8  }~  %&'" 
 !
%&'"  ()  " :[  (LMM )2\ *<$  := 
."[&$ <
 
"   "  x ^/ " 
: N3   |V1 
 [&$ <
 "    + %&'"  ()    -
.`&  (#  
"  !  %&
"  `&  
 yO &'"  Dh,  A" F %&'"  ()  FO +  -
w! [ b~F  nFO  . =V GGe 1?  =V LeM 2   n&"o
. 
 y 
? F") h" %zX 
 ()  N  FO @ (  nzO ()  C  [8   wl"  8 2
.!&
()  A8  `&  ()   (#:  ()  

%&'"  ()  "#$ %z  0>&"  " [  (LMM) %b?   :=
."  / 2 +  Bz,"/ 0
  +
+  Bz,"/ 0
  3 + " B
$ 6 "  !  8 x$ N3   |V1
()  %z  2>&"  0 #  V  N3 |V1 & %&'"  ()
  2
0>&" )   * lD~3  )  V   + 0

%&'" 
zv  =zv  IM 2   n&"o [ >O  0

(%&'"  ()  %z 
%zX  w! }~F  h" xz LGM 1? l ,$ $ "
. " @ %

" 

()
0
  3 B
$ [ ?V    n&"o V8 [8 !V wl"   8 |
3 %z  0>&"  0 lD~3  )   #$   N3 V3 %&'" 
.2 +  Bz,"/ 0

%&'"  ()  3 ! 2 
Dz"   8

: ?     B
$ i? "  -
       ?
"   nq [8  ?      " C# 2
#)  4 @ 0
  B
$ !?F<O }~ &
O 8  O  @ |8
1: ) (LMMt 6$) &
 0&
 B
$ 8 (G *& )
|?zO

.(LMM *< ) (LMM " )

 " (G *&  )

(LMM " )

(Ge

(LMM * p ) (LMM


(LMM 1: ) 2 ` 

.%&'"  ()  8       "#$ ?   


:k"  `&," ?     @ !b    |$ O 
.      )o D K
.%&'"  ()  !"#$       ?   #$ K
.      %&'"  D  x3 i 8 #$ K
.      Dh,  &  0 #  K
.%&'"  ()  &'"     #$ K
.z  x  ")
 %&'"  ()  0 #  K
.%&'"  ()  %z  0>&"  #$ K
\ |z
" & ! |?bF  wl"   O   Z1 618  "
6#" +8  0 ( iO  `1 &  -4) Dh,  A"
.  n&"o

  | O }~ !$  @ ?     n =l:   Z1 z"O


      &'"  Dh,  A" 2 $ 0  #  ! " 
()        #$ B
$ 6 "  C    Z1 [8 )3 %&'"  () 
2 xz") |  1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0

%&'" 
-? 2 xz") | &   Z *'   (   Z1
i
8 [8 &) .  618 ?" &l# [ >O % 1 <O $ h"
"  x %1 F") |h"  ! "  ?    
.=8   Z1 @ !?F<O


.! ( : } b  `Dz 

  w!
  n&"o
  $
  x8
  x8 ( G
  x8 X L
  x8 F<O (3 KI
  @ h" lD~ i  K H

} b  `Dz 

.! (
: !
x8 ( z {  &   $ n&"o 0F   .! `Dz  Z1 C "
F X 2 y"  @ h" &
 ( #  F  n&4  
 lD~ 4  i 8 =    |?F  z>    x8
.   `
@ !h"

  w!
}~ . 
w1 i8 "  *Z  %zX  { w!   | FO
=AF O !$  =? =zX !zX "! n  @ %1 & x1'   B
$ &" 
J!&.~ {J  J/ =J& !zX =& =AF O !DlD { O !zX =z
8 1 J'  JX N3 6! ) w! Z1 + 1 '  n !FO 
. J<O n  !V @ !O "" N3 C X
 " ` 1 & n  X
.(GGG LMM" )

  n&"o
N3 p FO @ *   + ,  -
o @ 0
  nq 2   n&"o [ >"
AJ 
  ). nq @ v  ete 1$ r F  ,$    FO

C#J   (3 x"V C# .(LMGM + ,  -


o 0zv  [ 7 x ,
.J1GHIG/GHIM %    2 b  %  `Dz 

  $
J& (>  "  <  `) lD~ ) &
=?F l ,$ $ "
:%


x 2 . N .P (1 p )
n= 2
D ( N 1) + x 2 p (1 P )
: [8 }~
.n&" .~ = N
.  .~ = n
.(0.50) * O 8 "z n&" @ F  %1 = P
.(0.50) * O 8 "z n&" @ 
&> F  %1 = 1Kp
.(0.05) * O 8 "z F  ?O @ y<p 1 = D
* JO %e J?b  + "J (x~ ) ~  $ * n  & =
.(GIt :G D ) .(I,HG)
J  xz ( LIe ) J   Z1   E     Z1 B
$ (
F<"   
<   B
$ C DE [& F") 2 8 $ n " }~F 
.%lD~ `
"
EX F" ( LHI ) B
$ }~F  `D~ 

  x8
  #  F  
 nq @ h"O  %&
 }F   8  "O
F$) 78 }~ !"$ V8 2 8   n&"o V8 2   )jO B
$
h" .^? F") F") 
? '~# 0   "O 8 ([ \
 8 i8 1F"$   Z #  
 n&4 xy F") }~F 
C D
   618 ?   <  n z"O  %&
 }F 
.(GLe G [ \ F$) 0  n <FO l?~ 
 B
$

  x ( KG


$ V zv  Dh,  A"
" C  (:4 0l: 2 F") | >O
8 (-
 `&    zv  FO %&
 `1 & ) @ 
b  
:%1  5 # 2 [ >"V F" 2 b  (:4
B
$ `&", *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       + "  5 (G
.xF$ (GL )
`&",J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + "  5 (L
.xF$ ( GL ) B
$
`&",J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F  5 (I
.xF$ ( LM ) B
$
(Closed Questionnaire) J
 `>,J    $3 @ }~F  FO 
.C `> 
&"  .")  *Z 

:  "  F  `& &l C    ?V 2 x?V ` ` ?


J Jzh J < "   $  =  $  )
.( = zh
J  B
$ =lD~3 !"4  ""  ?   F  2 xF$ ` (<$3 
:
( I ) < "    ( H )  $    ( e ) =  $ 
.x~  (G) = zh   [" ( L ) zh   
=F  =&l ) :  "  F  `& &l b    ?V 2 x?V ` ` ? &
.( = 8 = =~8
J  B
$ =lD~3 !"4  ""  ?   F  2 xF$ ` (<$3 
:
[" ( L ) =   ( I ) =~8   ( H ) =F    ( e ) =&l
.x~  (G) = 8 
= V  ) :  "  F  `& &l } b    ?V 2 x?V ` ` ? &
.( =#3 V  A V  A 5 V 
J  B
$ =lD~3 !"4  ""  ?   F  2 xF$ ` (<$3 
:
) V  A   ( I ) 5   ( H ) V    ( e ) = V 
.x~  (G) =#3 V  A  [" ( L

  x8 X KL
6J  ) J? J$8  -?O 6  8 2 y"   F") X
[8 i  X  `> x&") C " D  D? & ( HL Ge
[ J>O }J J ~ 2 z ?V  ~ 2 `
"  @ `O
}J~F    .(Gt LMMG[ \ F$) "!h" 2 `>  !z
:C# 2   x8 X 2 y" 

: x + " X 8
2 $ B
$ !$ ? |  ^ @   x8 X + B
$ 6 "

  -"  1 ($8 2 $ xp * + ,  -
o ($8 2 0&>
.(G 
 ) >5 ( Ge ) 0&> $ r
 

   

 l!   D   Z1 x8 $c }~F   0&> (\ ( @
. l!   X @ F") {  (L )

:  x8 F


+       + ")  5 z Fb  %
  O) 2 ?"

: F  z 8 `  h" (*   + ,  -
./ 0
 

(L)  C 
F  z 8 ` 
F z 8 `  &

F  $

 

M,IG

GL

LIG

0
  +       + "
*   + ,  -
./

+J J      + "  5 F [8 {" #$8   wl"  C# 2


JF BJ
$ C  ( M,IG ) r
}~  *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
. F<"
"~#X  

0
  +       + ")   > X
*" >  `
"  K
:(*   + ,  -
./
ZJ  J F `  @  &
 > X  !3 + B
$ 6 "

6ZJ~ 3 F  z 8 `  h"  &
%
>  & X  FO +
`J    J&
%
>  & D   0 FO) `  Z D 
: {D FO)

(I)  C 
+ ,  -
./ 0
  +       + "  5 z *" >  `
" 
*  

` 

` 

z 8 &

FO)

FO)

6Z~ 3

 

{D

D 



xF 

` 

` 

z 8 &

FO)

FO)

6Z~ 3

 

{D

D 


xF 

LIG **M,Het M,HM M,IHL

LIG **M,eGt M,ILI M,HI

LIG **M,ee M,eG M,Le

LIG **M,tLG M,LGH M,Gt

LIG **M,tHM M,Me M,GII

LIG **M,tM M,HL M,GG

LIG **M,L M,eHe M,LHH GM LIG **M,ee M,HtM M,LL

LIG **M,HH M,eIeL M,LHH GG LIG **M,eH M,HG M,L

LIG **M,tH M,ee M,LGe GL LIG **M,HtL M,IHt M,HLM

`yV M,MG  )  + " $ C ** ~#


.D    =V Z5  &

>    0 D  B
$   0 [ A FO `  1 : {D FO) `  *

+       + ")   > z nq [8 {"   C 4 2


0OF  $ &V   Z Fb  x @ 1O (*   + ,  -
./ 0
 
(M,HLM  M,HI ) N3 Fb   2 nVA &!VZ~ [ 0"
 (  G ) 

&8 X &!VZ~ $ +8 }~F  2> ( M,IG ) 2$ =) k "  B
$

Z %
  O) X 0&> `F 2 + " X 2  $  [ "&"O
E 2 `
? *Z    zO   @ Fb   [8 &   $ 
.&!VZE
J > z 0 FO) #  ` [8 ( I )  C 4 2 {" &
J& 0J (*   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       + ") 
 [8 M,MG + " $   xz   =V Z5 %
>  & Z %
> 
.( M,HL M,ILI ) 0 |~ O D FO) # 
+ %&'"  ()  + ")  5 z Fb  %
  O) 2 ?"

: F  z 8 `  h" (*   + ,  -
./ 0
 
(H)  C 
F  z 8 `  { 
F  z 8 `  &

F  $

 

M,HM

GL

LLe

0
J  +J %&'"  ()  + "
*   + ,  -
./

+J %J&'"  () J  + "  5 F [8 {" #$8   wl"  C# 2


JF B
$ C  ( M,HM ) r
}~ nzO *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
. F<"
"~#X  

0
  + %&'"  ()  + ")   > X
*" >  `
"  K
:(*   + ,  -
./

+ Z   F `  @  &


 > X  !3 + B
$ 6 "

D  6Z~ 3 F  z 8 `  h"  &
%
>  & X  FO
JFO) `J    &
%
>  & D   0 FO) `  Z
:{D
(e)  C 
+ ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + "  5 z *" >  `
" 
*  

` 

` 

z 8 &

FO)

FO)

6Z~ 3

 

{D

D 



xF 

` 

` 

z 8 &

FO)

FO)

6Z~ 3

 

{D

D 


xF 

LLe **M,te M,tGL M,I

LLe **M,eM M,HIHI M,LH

LLe **M,e M,eLIM M,tG

LLe **M,tet M,M M,e

LLe **M,tI M,GI M,tIG

LLe **M,L M,eML M,tH

LLe **M,eee M,HII M,e GM LLe **M,Le M,eHHM M,t

LLe **M,tHH M,GI M, GG LLe **M,tIM M,Ht M,tM

LLe **M,GI M,eIM M,tt GL LLe **M,tIe M,tte M,tMI

`yV M,MG  )  + " $ C ** ~#

0J DJ  B
$   0 [ A FO `  1 : {D FO) `  *
.D    =V Z5  &

>   

%J&'"  ()  + ")   > z nq [8 {"   C 4 2


J$ J&V   Z Fb  x @ 1O (*   + ,  -
./ 0
  +
2$ =) (M,e ) N3 Fb   2 nVA !VZ~ [
 (GM )  xF 
X 2  $  n"&"O 8 X !VZ~ $ +8 }~F  2> ( M,HM )
 [8 & 1  $  Z %
  O) X 0&> `F 2 + "
.!VZE E 2 `
? *Z    zO 1  @ Fb 
J > z 0 FO) #  ` [8 ( e )  C 4 2 {" &
J& 0J (*   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + ") 
 [8 M,MG + " $   xz   =V Z5 %
>  & Z %
> 
.M,tGL M,HIHI 0 |~ O D FO) # 
+       nV `F)  5 z Fb  %
  O) 2 ?"

: F  z 8 `  h" (*   + ,  -
./ 0
 

()  C 
F  z 8 `  { 
F  z 8 `  &

F  $

 

M,ete

LM

LLM

0
J  +J       nV `F
*   + ,  -
./

J    J  nV `F  5 F [8 {" #$8   wl"  C# 2


BJ
$ CJ  ( M,ete ) r
}~ nzO *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +
. F<"
"~#X   F

0
  +       nV `F)   > X
*" >  `
"  K
:(*   + ,  -
./
ZJ  J F `  @  &
 > X  !3 + B
$ 6 "

6ZJ~ 3 F  z 8 `  h"  &
%
>  & X  FO +
`J    J&
%
>  & D   0 FO) `  Z D 
:{D FO)

(t)  C 
+ ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F  5 z *" >  `
" 
*  
[

` 

` 

z 8 &

FO)

FO)

6Z~ 3

 

{D

D 



xF 

` 

` 

z 8 &

FO)

FO)

6Z~ 3

 

{D

D 


xF 

LLM **M,tMH M,HI M,eM

GG

LLM **M,Mt M,eLM M,ete

LLM **M,teL M,tLL M,eeI

GL

LLM **M,tL M,tMGt M,eee

LLM **M,te M,tIG M,eeG

GI

LLM **M,e M,eG M,ee

LLM **M,e M,L M,eI

GH

LLM **M,eI M,et M,etG

LLM **M,eM M,LeH M,eIt

Ge

LLM **M,eHe M,eMLL M,et

LLM **M,tMM M,eG M,eet

LLM **M,G M,Gt M,ee

LLM **M,Mt M,ttH M,eHt

Gt

LLM **M,ttI M,tLe M,eeG

LLM **M,LH M,MGH M,eHM

LLM **M,tL M,tG M,eeI

LLM **M,LM M,tLI M,eHI

LLM **M,Ge M,ttt M,eHH

LLM **M,Lt M,tIt M,eHL

LM

LLM **M,t M,ttet M,eHH

GM

`yV M,MG  )  + " $ C ** ~#


.D    =V Z5  &

>    0 D  B
$   0 [ A FO `  1 : {D FO) `  *

J      nV `F)   > z nq [8 {"   C 4 2


J$ J&V   Z Fb  x @ 1O (*   + ,  -
./ 0
  +
2J$ =) (M,et ) N3 Fb   2 nVA !VZ~ [
 (e )  xF 
JX 2  $  n"&"O 8 X !VZ~ $ +8 }~F  2> ( M,ete)
 [8 & 1  $  Z %
  O) X 0&> `F 2 + "
.&!VZE E 2 `
? *Z    zO 1  @ Fb 
J > z 0 FO) #  ` [8 ( t )  C 4 2 {" &
J& 0J (*   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F) 
 [8 M,MG + " $   xz   =V Z5 %
>  & Z %
> 
.( M,L M,eMLL ) 0 |~ O D FO) # 

:  x8 F<O (3 KI



   }~F  FO z 6, 2  O < B
$ C DE 
"J +J8 x !$3 ! i
  V8 B
$ F") n O

&$ `!  ~ ? @    " =' =~ =$ F8 ! q F") n O
( LHI ) 1J$ [J }~ ! q  F") D~  ! q !  O
.J1GHIG/GHIM 
b  %  `Dz  C# `
"
EX F"
w  2$ k iE =lD~3 !"4  F  C3 
.wl"  h" F  `
" }~F   2 (spss)

  @ h" lD~ i  K H


2J   h" ?V ! &  F  `
  618 ?"
Statistical $&") 

lD~ :E h" F lD~ i 
.(SPSS) :  =D"  :  Package for Social Sciences
J# C J " k iE N3 F  C3 :O [8 
)+ ~     5 @ h" ( 
    E ) %&p ^?
)*8 {DJ  
p C B
$ C D
^? # $ B
$ &?O (H=GKe
^?  8 ) ^? @ & `8 N3 &?  Z1 V3  (M,M =e/H
#p C {FX8 Z>1 
p Z B
$ E " ({D  ~  %1
: y &
`J (=#3 V  A / = 8 / = zh  ) `b G,M N3 G 2 
.    6#"y xF$
xJF$ ` (V  A / =/ zh  ) `b L,M N3 G,G 2 
.    6#"y
xJF$ `J J (5 / =~8 / < "  ) `b I,HM N3 L,G 2 
.    6#"y
6#"yJ xF$ ` (V  / =F /  $  ) `b H,LM N3 I,HG 2 
.   
xF$ ` (= V  / =&l / =  $  ) `b e,MM N3 H,LG 2 
.    6#"y

:  "  lD~) -? ~ 


$ V zv  Dh,  flDp B
$ 6 "
  i  >"  -
x8 !&J"O  l    F$  1V8  ."   
. 
 ."J Jz 8 zO + V  " Mean " E  " -
y 
 n (F  < "  ") l    2$   $ V8
.~  " B
$8 i~   iOO @ z
+ V  " Weighted Mean " ({) [  E  " -
JF$ 2J xJF$ ` B
$   $ V8  ." z 8 zO
BJ
$8 iJ~ F  iOO @ z y 
 n    A"
.[  ~  "
+ B
$ 6 "
"Standard Deviation" *  6) h" -
J  A" F$ 2 xF$ `>   $ V8  ." 6
*  6) [8 ~# .E !< " 2$ l    2  5 `>
A"J F$ 2 xF$ `>   $ V8  ." @ |","  { 
:JO zDJ  2J "& | " &
>V l    i N3  
.^? 0 !"",O z  .")
n&"o V8 (\ 6#" 8 - + 2 ?"
* n  F" h" -
.     z
"h ?z  C ~  
Independent Sample ) 
?"J 
(  ) F"8 h" -
0J lDJ~3 J )  V 1 | 3  B
$ 6 "
( TKtest

N3 J?O  A" 6#"c    5   n&"o V8 1


. 0"V
|J 3  B
$ 6 "
( *~ 2F"  `
) 8 (6) F" h" -
 J5 J J  n&"o V8 1 0 lD~3  )  V 1
.0"V 2 b8 N3 ?O  zv  Dh,  A" 6#"  
JV 0J z  X " ( *   V `8 ) ( LSD ) h" -
{J 8  3 0"V 2 b8 N3 ?O  zv  Dh,  A"
ZJ1 JV 0J lD~3  )  V   *~ 2F"  `
F"
.A"

,    `


$ : n   `Dz 
!.l"
  V8 X ?
" wl" 
  
y ?
" wl" 

:n   `Dz 
   `
$
!.l" ,
 J  
J8 ( @ ! 3 `X "     wl" %
DzO $ %
 &V
: wl"  AzO n !V18

  $ V8 X ?


" wl" 
@ 
b&"   $ Vy ?
" 
?" A" 2 $ B
$   Z1  ?O
Z1 ( @ .(-
 `&    zv  FO %&
 `1 &  )
:k"    B
$   $ V8 flD  2> A"
()  C 
&  A" V   $ V8 n O
F 

>" 

& 

L,e

=$ Le 2 `8

I,M

GeI

=$ Ie 2 ` N3 Le 2

L,

tM

=$ He 2 `8 N3 Ie 2

e,

GH

yV =$ He 2

%GMM

LHI

&

"FJ J [ J
b   $ V8 2 ( GeI ) [8 ( )  C 4 2 {"
z  1 =$ Ie 2 `8 N3 Le 2 1&$8   $ V8 kq3 2 %I,M
kJq3 2 %L, "F  [
b ! (tM) [8 0~ @   V8 2 b
 [
b ! (GH ) ` ? =$ He 2 ` N3 Ie 2 1&$8   $ V8
( ) J&  yV =$ He 2 1&$8   $ V8 kq3 2 %e, "F
.=$ Le 2 ` 1&$8   $ V8 kq3 2 %L,e "F  [
b !

()  C 
%&
 `1 A" V   $ V8 n O
F 

>" 

%&
 `1

GM,I

Le

$  

LG,H

eL

* b   


H,

GG

^  >

I,I

k$ 


GI,L

IL

A"

G,

 "

G,

+8

%GMM

LHI

&

2 %H, "F [
b   $ V8 2 (GG) [8 () C 4 2 {"
JV 2J Jb) z  1 ^  > &
 #1   $ V8 kq
J  J$ JV8 kq 2 %LG,H "F [
b ! (eL) ` ?  
2J %GI,L "FJ [
b ! (IL) ` ?  * b   
 &
 #1
"FJ [ J
b !J (Le) A" &
 #1   $ V8 kq
[
b ! () $   &
 #1   $ V8 kq 2 %GM,I
! (H)  k$ 
 &
 #1   $ V8 kq 2 %I,I "F
.  " &
 #1   $ V8 kq 2 %G, "F [
b
(GM)  C 
zv  FO A" V   $ V8 n O
F 

>" 

zv  FO

t,H

p

L,I

 

IL,G

  

Ge,L

It

b 

LG

 " 

I,I

x7 

L,

,$ E

G,L

,$ b 

L,G

,$ b b 

M,H

,$   

M,H

0F

%GMM

LHI

&

"F  [
b   $ V8 2 ( t ) [8 ( GM )  C 4 2 {"
2J b z  1    zv  FO @   $ V8 kq3 2 %IL,G
J$ V8 kq3 2 %L,I "F  [
b ! (H ) [8 0~ @   V8
2J %Ge,L "F  [
b ! (It ) ` ?    zv  FO @  
"FJ  [
b ! (LG ) &  b  zv  FO @   $ V8 kq3
 [
b ! (G )   "  zv  FO @   $ V8 kq3 2 %,
!J ( ) Jp zv  FO @   $ V8 kq3 2 %t,H "F
(t ) x7  zv  FO @   $ V8 kq3 2 %I,I "F  [
b
JE Jzv  FO @   $ V8 kq3 2 %L, "F  [
b !
JFO @ J  J$ V8 kq3 2 %L,G "F  [
b ! (e ) ,$
  $ V8 kq3 2 %G,L "F  [
b ! (I ) ,$ b b  zv 
J$ V8 kq3 2 %M,H "F  `b ! (G )  ,$ b  zv  FO @
.,$    zv  FO @  

(GG)  C 
-
 `&    A" V   $ V8 n O
F 

>" 

-
 `&   

IG,t

tt

`yV   -

IG,t

tt

  GM 2 ` N3   2

LM,L

 Ge 2 ` N3 GM 2

G,e

HM

byV  Ge 2

%GMM

LHI

&

"FJ J [ J
b   $ V8 2 ( tt ) [8 ( GG )  C 4 2 {"
@  `JyV   - -
 !
&$     $ V8 kq3 2 %IG,t
 J J  $ V8 kq3 2 %IG,t "F  [
b ! (tt ) [8 0~
J [ J
b ! (H )` ?    GM 2 ` N3   2 -
 !
&$
2 `8 N3 GM 2 -
 !
&$     $ V8 kq3 2 %LM,L "F
J  J$ V8 kq3 2 %G,e "F  [
b ! (HM )&   Ge
.byV  Ge 2 -
 !
&$  

:   
y ?
" wl"  : =
+ ,J  -J
./ 0
J  +       + " " :C ) C  KG
m" 1' ! 2 *  


" J~ * J  + ,J  -
./ 0
  +       + " B
$ 6
 ">  V8  .") iO    V  E < "   i
+ ,J  -J
./ 0
J  +J       + "  5 F$ B
$   $
  * (  ":k"  C 4 !  & wl
 (GL)  C
"0
  +       + "  5 F$ B
$   $ V8  .
?V  < " i~ = O FO *   + ,  -
./








 
& % !"#

123#1 425
1716
 9
><= %
%"2#

1?4#1 425
>@ !7
" 

>A
4>1 @


C D1EF
 4
H"#
H&I

 
#$
'&%
#

#$
'%

* *

! 
%

#$
#$
#$
),-.!) ,-.!) *+
#

 /+134
 %
 0$ 1%

*
%

* *

* *

*
%

* *

*
%

* *

** <* !.2 ' : 3 >?@< =

4#

*** *

*** *

*** *

*** *

*** *

7

() 

  
$8

4'

" 

**= =

**= =

**= =

**= =

**= =

**= =

**= =

134
  

0, 
(%1

('
./
'

('
./
-

('
+,-


('
 )

('
 )
'

$%

%

$

AA )* -AAB
CAAA2 >AAA:
 #?'D

*-AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAB
#AAAAAAF#H
A? #2' :
,-H

*-AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAB
*J!AAA4#H
.AAAAAAAAAAAAK 
AAL #AA M
>-,

@AAAH *-AAAB
C!2 ,:

*AAAAAAAAAAAAAB
< LN2
OAA-H >AAP
FNQR2

AA )' AAJ!:


AF SAJP
,: <

* -AAAAAAAB
*+'AAAAAAAAAAA2
 ,2#AAAAAAAAAA-+
3AAAAAAAAAAAA,2#-2
 >AAAAAAAA2
3AAAAAAAAAAAA,2#-2
*2

0, 

>?@< = !.2 ' : 3** <*

!"
$

[8 BJ
$ [ J?V    $ V8 [8 {" #$8   wl"  C# 2
1 (e 2 H,MM)  "/  $ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +      
z  %1 (H,LM N3 I,HG 2 ) %&p ^? V 2    z  @ n?  "
* p )  n ."  Z1 z"O   x8 B
$  $   N3 A,O 
%J&
 + k$ + "/ (        8 nq [8 |  ( LMM 
.> > /  b  ^
J$ =lDJ~3   | F  n&4 * n   [8 wl"  2 {"
.F  Z1 C ~   n&"o V8 ' ! 2FO 0F  `yV M,MG + "
 J  + "J B
$   $ V8 ?V  @  zO 1 [8 wl"  2 {"
JzO8 BJ
$ !"?V  0   " *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +   
 i 4 @ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +        "
+ ,J  -J
./ 0
  +        " [8 B
$ !"?V  =  $
+ "J C ~ !"?V  < " |~ O }~ < "  i  @ *  
(H,Ht N3 I,I ) 0J J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +      
0"J
 %&p ^? V 2 p b b  0"z  0   "O < " %1
{     x8 B
$ k "  B
$(=  $  / < "  ) N3 [A,O
-J
./ 0
  +       + " B
$   $ V8 ?V  @  z" 
[8 BJ
$ [ J?V  J  $ V8 [8 wl"  2 {" }~ *   + , 
J @ =J  $ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +        "
i~ = O !FOO  (GM  t  GL  e  H)  F  @ `b&"O i 
:k"  =  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V 
"-J
 `J F %l#: #$ [8 ?"$8 " B1 ( H )  xF  ( .G
 "/ =  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 N  FO

J + ,J  -
./ 0zv  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 H,Ht)
! &V #  + " 2 2~  2:  2 x"z F  ! n 
&$
."~)   B
$  ?O F #$ !

`J~ @ %Jl# $J8 J8 x    78 " B1 ( e )  xF  ( .L
 !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b  FO " `&  #>,
0 #  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 H,HI )  "/ =  $
| & "~)   B
$  ?O F #$ + ,  -
./ 0zv 
[ $J J1 x   [  , 0zv  ()1 `  ?   x?z  ."
.`&  #>, `~ @ !l#
2 b b  FO " %
&$ :8 0~    78 " B1 ( GL )  xF  ( .I
(e 2 H,HI )  "/ =  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~
`J& BJ
$ O? v   , `&   [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
*Z   O z "? 2 :    
> ! ?  `&   
.
&$ :. 0~    7 2 : 
2J J   FO " %l# 0 "~ %'~8 " B1 ( t )  xF  ( .H
(e 2 H,HL )  "/ =  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~
nJ   " ." + ,  -
o @ 0zv  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
.`&  @ !l# "~ ? [ F> `&  @ F  !
FO " x  x    %l# n O8 " B1 ( GM )  xF  ( .e
J "/ =J J $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 p
-
o @ 0zv  0 #  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 H,L)
^) @ 6 D  [  "    "~)   1  #$ + , 

nJ [ ,J" + ,J  -
o @ 0zv   Z `&  
D ? N3
.x  x    F  !
 J   "J [8 B
$ [ ?V    $ V8 [8 wl"  2 {" &
JF  @ `b&"O i  " @  $ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +   
J$ JV8 J?V  i~ = O !FOO  (L    GG  I  ) 
:k"   $  !
$  
2 N  FO " k (X8 n `&$8 8  78 " B1 ( )  xF  ( .G
:  (e 2 H,Ge )  "/  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~
!J F !"~ + ,  -
o @ 0zv  [  O [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F 
nJ [ J
&  yJ [  , !
 ! &V #  x  2 : F 
.!lX8
b  FO " %
&  8 $ O)  78 " B1 ( I )  xF  ( .L
(e 2J H,GM )  "/  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2
`J?O  @ [
&  + ,  -
o @ 0zv  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
J$ JO) [  , !
 `&  (# 0 Dh,  $D  !V
.!
& [  ?
" `J&
%Jl8 (8 %z  ?")  78 " B1 ( GG )  xF  ( .I
) J "/ J $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b b  FO
+ ,J  -J
o @ 0zv J [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,
!l# 0 ! #  x ? ." + ,  -
./ `&  @ ~  [  ,
?") 1 ,  `&  @ #  x$ [  B
$  D~ `&  @
.`&  O @ A>z"  $ %z 

}J~ 2    FO " n" %


&$ [y  78 " B1 ( )  xF  ( .H
:J  (e 2J I,ee )  "/  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V 
8 #>,J [ !  ) + ,  -
o @ 0zv  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F 
!J
J -
 @ `&   F -
 @ !
&$ ! (8 @  X
.n" !
&$ [y [  ,
JFO " #>,J `~ @ %l# 78 " B1 ( )  xF  ( .e
I,eG ) J "/  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 p
(#:J  `F 2 `&  @ [  "    [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2
`~ @ !l# 73 @ [ " ) !
+ ,  -
o @ 0zv  1 
.!! O  #>,
  FO " %
&$ @  ?~8 8 ?"$8 " B1 ( L )  xF  ( .
(e 2J I,HG )  "/  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2
@ !~J. ." + ,  -
o @ 0zv  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
:   `&  @  ! 2$  ?" [  ,  
 ! (8
.!
&$ @  ?" 1?"$ 2
+ ,J  -
./ 0
  [8 B
$ [ ?V    $ V8 [8 wl"  2 {" &
xF  @ `b&" ~ i @ < "        zO [ "&" *  
J "/ " ^ jJ J
  ) ` 
 
  * [8  78" B1 ( G ) 
B
$ [ X + ,  -
o @ ( [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,I)
J< JO iFJ ! j x," [  1AVZ &
"  &' F<O
` 
  ! j [
  1 Z &! Z1 i D   `> 67)
.^ j 
  )

-J
./ 0
J  + %&'"  ()  + " " :b  C  KL
 m" 1' ! 2 *   + ,

" ~ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + " B
$ 6
 ">   .") iO    V  E < "   i
-J
./ 0
J  +J %&'"  ()  + "  5 F$ B
$   $ V8
 :k"  C 4 !  & wl"  ( *   + ,
 (GI)  C
"+ %&'"  ()  + "  5 F$ B
$   $ V8  .
 
?V  < " i~ = O FO *   + ,  -
./ 0



 



/+
0$ 1


! 
%

)  # =$
A ?# 4
D3 'B
E&D

 B $
) E&DG
 0& %$
 H

I%$B
 0E&D
) B,J3
?D$ B
LJ

4$ M%7
 &0 0
) E&DG
+O

8

9

3%:

3

#$

* *

* *

* *

** 7,yv \,\= f< Lj  ' q$v

134
%

 %

4#

*** *

*** *

*** *

*** *

7

(GI)  C  n O
  
$8

4'

**=

**=

**=

**=

**=

**=

**=

" 

134
  

0, 
(%1

('

3

3 ;

$:

=
=

**=

=
= =

 

$%

%

= =




!"
$

)#!' .-$ M


SHRRRRRRRRLQ RRRRRRRRL
0RRRR BRRRR' 0!3TRRRR$
G E&D)

08#RRRRRUJ VRRRRR17
SRRRRRRRRRR' X'RRRRRRRRRR$
E&D

RRRR?) RRRRH BRRRR7


YRRRRRR: 0RRRRRR BRRRRR7
RR+ Z%*RR+
E&D$ 0&' 0

RRRR[' \RRRRR%&7
RRRR) 0RRRR BRRRR&
TRRR+ 0!3_RRR RRL
RRRRR7 BRRRRR RRRRR%a
E&D

0RR %RR b$RR*7


%RR ZRR) RR?$ SRR)
G E&D)

ERR&D) B,RR #RR


YRRRRRRRR&' GRRRRRRRR
#RRRRRRRRRRR: 0-ARRRRRRRRRRR$
d$ S%&)

ERRRR&D 0RRRR3X-1H
RRRR) B,RRRR H#RRRR
0R8 S% 1 #
B 0

eTRRRRRRR7 SRRRRRRRH
RRRR %&RRRR+ 07RRRR%:
BRRRRRRRRRR\ RRRRRRRRRR7
E&D$

/+

>?@< = !.2 ' : 3** <*

[8 BJ
$ [ J?V    $ V8 [8 {" #$8   wl"  C# 2
I,t)  "/  $  %&'"  ()  [ "&" *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
N3 I,HG 2J ) %J&p ^J? V 2    z  @ n?  " 1 (e 2
nJ ."  Z1 z"O   x8 B
$ (=F )  N3 A,O  z  %1 (H,LM
.nzO ()  C  [8 |  (LMM  2\ *<$) 
J$ =lDJ~3   | F  n&4 * n   [8 wl"  2 {"
.F  Z1 C ~   n&"o V8 ' ! 2FO 0F  `yV M,MG + "
-
./ 0
  n" B
$   $ V8 ?V  @  zO 1 [8 wl"  2 {"
-J
./ 0
J  n" B
$ !"?V  0   " %&'"  ()  *   + , 
B
$ !"?V  i 4 @ %&'"  ()  2 =  $  *   + , 
<J " |J~ O }J~ +8 i  @ < "  %&'"  ()  ! "
L, ) 0J  %&'"  ()  *   + ,  -
./ 0
  n" C ~ !"?V 
^J? JV 2J p b b  0"z  0   "O < " %1 (H,G N3
x8 BJ
$ k "  B
$(=  $  / < "  ) N3 [A,O 0"
 %&p
%J&'"  ()  + " B
$   $ V8 ?V  @  z"  {    
J  $ V8 [8 wl"  2 {" }~ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +
J %J&'"  ()  [ "&" *   + ,  -
./ 0
  [8 B
$ [ ?V 
iJ~ =J O &!FOO 0"
 (H  G)  0OF  @ #b&" 0F @ =  $
:k"  =  $  &!
$   $ V8 ?V 
`J&$ J) *! +D CZ 8 [8  " " B1 ( G )  xF  ( .G
=  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 N  FO " -

-J
./ 0
J  [8 N3 J."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 H,G )  "/
J `&  (# n #  `&   2$   [ "&" *   + , 

`&$ ) 1! +D [ ZF [8 [  " !


`&  !l&" 2 :
.-

J   >
& @ + ,  -
o `F?"/ "18 " B1 ( H )  xF  ( .L
J $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b  FO "   
-J
./ 0
  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 H,IH )  "/ =
[ J&"! !
 -
 `F?"/ !
F?" FO [  , *   + , 
.      >
& @ + ,  -
o `F?"/
-J
./ 0
J  [8 BJ
$ [ ?V    $ V8 [8 wl"  2 {" &
@ `Jb&"O iJ  J @  $  %&'"  ()  [ "&" *   + , 
iJ~ =J O !FOO  (GG   GL   L  e  t  )  F 
:k"   $  !
$   $ V8 ?V 
J? `JV -
 @ `&   [8 +8 " B1 ( )  xF  ( .G
J!
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 N  FO " + `&  !
0
  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,H )  "/  $ 
[ J J8 X -
 @ `&   2$ 0 *   + ,  -
./
J [8 [  !
 F  Z1 @ !  0
  V 2 "~) [  " 
.+ `&  ! ? `V -
 @ `& 
[  + ,  -
o @ %
& "  O)  78 " B1 ( t )  xF  ( .L
J $ J J!
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b  FO "  
-J
./ 0
J  [8 N3 J."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,I )  "/
$ [  O 2 -
 @ `&    V O  2$  b8 *   + , 
.  [  + ,  -
o @ !
& "  O) [  , !


@ `J&$8 y 2 8 $ hz   78 " B1 ( e )  xF  ( .I


J !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b b  FO " + ,  -
o
-
./ 0
  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,G )  "/  $
!J
 $&"3 > 2 !"zv  V O  [  *   + , 
.+ ,  -
o @ [
&  y 2 [ $ hz  [  ,
JFO " -J
 2$ :"$ %lX }8 " B1 ( L )  xF  ( .H
2 I,I )  "/  $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2   
[  *   + ,  -
./ 0
  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e
.-
 2$ :"$ !lX [ " !
 : 2 !"zv  " 
@ &"8 [8 n<"8 ~ k ` O &! 8 `F?O8 " B1 ( )  xF  ( .e
J !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 p FO " -
 %
&$
-
./ 0
  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,t )  "/  $
?O 8 X -
 @ !zlv B
$ 'V B
$ [ X *   + , 
[ <"J J~ J `J O &! 8 [
F?" !
 : 2   
.-
 !
&$ @ &")
cJV J8 [> @ `&
=$ |?
O 3 " B1 ( GL )  xF  ( .
  $ V8 ?V  }~ 2   FO " -
 O `F =Ab >Vy
[8 N3 J."  ZJ1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,t )  "/  $  !
$
J 2$   %z  ?") [  , *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
[ >zJ yJV Z ?  ?V wl" 2 0FO & -
 @ `& 
.8 [> @ `&
=$  ?
O 3 -
 O `F =Ab

" + ,  -
o  n  2j8  ?  <"O " B1 ( )  xF  ( .t
J "/ J $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2    FO
+ ,J  -J
./ 0
J  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,tM)
J  (J&") [  ,J -
 @ `&  2$ 1 n 2 *  
<"O  [   ?  [8 B
$ [ ?V  !
 -
.&
%
&  %z 
.+ ,  -
o  n
J~8 zDJ B
$ + ,  -
o `V 8 " B1 ( GG )  xF  ( .
 $  !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b  FO " 0
 
-J
./ 0
J  [8 N3 J."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I, )  "/
!
 + ,  -
o @ `&   !  : [  *   + , 
. 0
  ~8 !"zD !
$ + ,  -
o `V [ ?
-J
./ 0
J  [8 BJ
$ [ ?V    $ V8 [8 wl"  2 {" &
0OF  @ #b&" 0F @ < "  %&'"  ()  [ "&" *   + , 
 &!
$   $ V8 ?V  i~ = O &!FOO 0"
 (GM  I) 
:k"  < "
%l8 0" +  `V8 ?" -
 :z " B1 ( I )  xF  ( KG
<J " J !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 N  FO "`&  @
+ ,  -
./ ?  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,M )  "/
J x  `&  618 ?" 0
  (8 + " 0 B
$  *  
.`&  @ !l8 0" !  `V8 ?" 0
  :z !

`J&  |JO =F
 ~ y"O [8 2> " B1 ( GM )  xF  ( KL
<J " J !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b  FO " -


+ ,J  -
./ 0
  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 L, )  "/
0yO B
$ O  z" + -
 `&  +  + [  *  
.-
 `&   O =F
 y"O [8 2> ~ [y [  !
 !
F?"

+ "J       + " 0 FO)   " :} b  C  KI


m" *   + ,  -
o @ 0
  + %&'"  () 
+J %J&'"  ()  + "       + " 0 FO)  B
$ 6 "

 ) " [ A FO `  }~F  h" *   + ,  -
o @ 0
 
: k"  wl"  ( 2A" 0 # 
(GH)  C 4
       + " 0 #   ) " [ A FO `  wl" { 
*   + ,  -
o @ 0
  + %&'"  () 
lD~  ) 
**M,MMM

FO) ` 
M,HH

A"
      + "
%&'"  ()  
`yV M,MG + " $ =lD~3   #$ **

$ lD~3  )   #$   {" #$8   wl"  C# 2


@ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + "       + " 0 `yV M,MG + "
0
  +       + " 2 &
 8 {" }~ *   + ,  -
o
Z1 }~F  :  %&'"  !l) + "  &
 *   + ,  -
o @
  ~  [  , !
0
  +       + " 2 [8 N3 ." 
0
  FO 2 : 8 &  "  `&  O @ 1A>zO 2 `
? `&  @
<  Z1 `  `&  
X  @ F  1 7  !> `&  F
()  + " x N3 *O 0

      zO 2 w"O  1A
  |  ( LMM  %b?  )  n ."  Z1 z"O 0

%&'" 
! 2 
Dz"   8 3 %z  0>&"  0 lD~3  )   #$
.2 +  Bz,"/ 0

%&'"  ()  3

+ ,J  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F ":n   C  KH
m"*  
* J  + ,J  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F B
$ 6 "

iJO  J  V  E < "   i  >"  ~
0
J  +       nV `F  5 F$ B
$   $ V8  .")
:k"  C 4 !  & wl"  ( *   + ,  -
./

() 

    
  
     
          
 
 "
 # $%  
 
! 

$8

4'

" 

**= =

**= =

**= =

**= =

**= =

134
  

0, 
(%1

  



 :
 :
='>1- ===- 8
"?@

$%

%

=
= =

=
=

= =

=
=

= =

=
=

= =

$

#2'AAW<* AAF
3AAA2N 3AAA2#-
3XAAAA4* .AAAAH
Z#AAA< [F#AAA)
( ... 3)#D

#AAA) >RAAA+
AAAAAAAAA< >AAAAAAAAA-
#:#A4 Z,$
3/AAAAAA4# 2 >AAAAAA:
3#: ^

AAAAA ? *<AAAAAF
#6AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAF
`AAAAAAH *.AAAAAA
#AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA4*
`AAAAAAAAAA4*
#bAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA:
Z,$

AAAAA .AAAAA+
`AAAAAAH *+'AAAAAAJ!
#AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA4*
`4*

`,2#AAA- #AAAc
'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA#H
AAAAAA< 3AAAAAA/+!'
#AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA$2
e6W!

>?@< = !.2 ' : 3** <*

!"
$

() 

  
$8

4'

**=

" 

**= =

**= =

**= =

**= =

**=

**=

**=

134
  

0, 
(%1



 :
="?@

 :
=-

'>1-

=-

=- 8

$%

%

=
=

$

*AAAAAK<* AAAAAF
3AAAAA?*!, 3AAAAA#-
g+> !'J 

#AAAAAAX gAAAAAA4# F
`AAAAAAA2 3AAAAAAAH,h
CAAAAAAAA2 `,2#AAAAAAAA-
#! i?

*AAAAAAA< *<AAAAAAAF
`2@AAAAAA! 3-AAAAAA4
Kj> /J!.
`,2#-,

#AAAAAAA-2 lAAAAAAA,-F
'AAA+'^ #AAAX2
>- # M

3AAAAAAD*K #AAAAA$+
SAAA/h! 3/AAA4# 
'AAAA+'$ #AAAAQ<m
`AAAAAAA2 3/.AAAAAAA!Q
'AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
3/+!'

#AA,-F nAAoF
>AAAAA- 3AAAAA)
pAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAF^*
`,2#-,

q C$RAAAAAAAAAAF
ZA,$ < #,-
AAAA! #AAAA/,
`.AcF  rF
>-

7<c#AH #!
`,2#-, 3 -

>?@< = !.2 ' : 3** <*

!"
$

() 

  
$8

4'

**=

" 

**= =

**=

**=

**=

**=

**=

134
  

0, 
(%1



 :
="?@

 :
=-

'>1-

=-

=- 8

$%

%

=
=

= =

=
=

=
=

$

#P#.AA<* AAF
gAAF#Q, 3/AA4# 
3AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAJH#h
3A K #KD,
3,.

3AA^#c#H #AA!
3cc6AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
`,2#-, 3)'/

`,2#A- #RA!4
SAAAAA,-!+ #AAAAA2 AAAAA<
lX#:@H

AAA< >AAA- #AAAKF


CAAAAAAAAA2 ZAAAAAAAAA,$
#AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA-?F
#AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAPs
`,2#-

3AAAAAD*K 3AAAAAP#F
#AAAAAAAAAKm #AAAAAAAA2
tAAAAA,: 6AAAAAc,
3L# u!4 N:

#AAAA4 *#AAAA!
#AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA^#!P#H
`,2#-

q* AAAAAAAAAP
':#.AAAAAAA2 tAAAAAAA,:
>AAP AA< `,2#AA-
lXFNQRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA2
3:#!^

0, 

>?@< = !.2 ' : 3** <*

!"
$

`FJ B
$ [ ?V    $ V8 [8 {" #$8   wl"  C# 2
1 (e 2 I,I)  "/ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV
z  %1 (H,LM N3 I,HG 2 ) %&p ^? V 2    z  @ n?  "
.  x8 B
$ V   N3 A,O 
J$ =lDJ~3   | F  n&4 * n   [8 wl"  2 {"
.F  Z1 C ~   n&"o V8 ' ! 2FO 0F  `yV M,MG + "
 J  nV `F B
$   $ V8 ?V  @  zO 1 [8 wl"  2 {"
`FJ B
$ !"?V  0   " *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +   
BJ
$ ?V  @ !"~ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV
|J~ O }~ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV *8 `F
+ ,J  -J
./ 0
J  +J       nV `F C ~ !"?V  < "
Jb b  0"Jz  0J   "O < " %1 (H,GL N3 I,I ) 0  *  
BJ
$ k "  B
$ (V  / 5) N3 [A,O 0"
 %&p ^? V 2   
      nV `F B
$   $ V8 ?V  @  z"  {     x8
J  $ V8 [8 wl"  2 {" }~ *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +
+ ,J  -J
./ 0
  +       nV `F 2 ,$  O B
$ [ ?V 
 I  L  GG  G  G  GL   G  e)  F  @ `b&"O *  
iJ~ = O !FOO  (GM  Ge  G   Gt  H  GH  t   LM
:k"  !
$   $ V8 ?V 
)  !J J #    p AV O " B1 ( e )  xF  ( .G
!
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 N  FO " ( ... X -V O1
J  p AV O [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 H,GL )  "/

+J `J&  ! 2 `! ( ... X -V O1 )  !  # 
.   !~  2 :   *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
`J&$ $ -
 @ `&  ' `&, [8 " B1 ( G )  xF  ( .L
J!
$ J  $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b  FO "  $  8 F
-J
 @ `&  ' [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 H,M )  "/
0
  + `&  2$   + " 2 :  $  8 F `&$ $
.   !~  2 :   *   + ,  -
./
(Jj  0J xJ CDO)   AV O " B1 ( )  xF  ( .I
J  J$ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b b  FO " -
 ($8 0 j
 J AV O [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 H,Mt )  "/ !
$
J$ 0
J
{J"O -
 ($8 0 j (j  0 x CDO)
.   !~  2 :    C
~ B
$ C DE `&  @ #>,
0 j (j  0 ?"      [8 " B1 ( GL )  xF  ( .H
(e 2 H,Mt )  "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2    FO "
 0 j (j  0 ?"    x [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
J  (j  !zO + " 2 2 0 j (j  0 #>, 2
.   !~  2 :   0
 
)Jo @ F"     0
  E3 " B1 ( G )  xF  ( .e
) J "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 p FO " fDh" 
F"     0
  E3 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 H,Mt
 fDh"  Co @  <"  B
$ 0
  C D~ 2 : fDh"  )o @
.   !~  2 :   &
 E `&  F
O 2$ 1 2 : *Z 

" i"  `?  "


   z  AV O " B1 ( G )  xF  ( .
(e 2 I, )  "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2   FO
iJ"  `?  "
   z  AV O [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
1 , & #>, 4  `&  @  &"1) 0
   7 2 :
.   !~  2 :   &'"     8F F<"
|J  nJ 0
  2 
< ! iO " B1 ( GG )  xF  ( .t
I,M )  "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2    FO " "
nJ 0
J  2 
< ! iO [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2
.   !~  2 :   `&  0
   7 2 `
? " | 
%zv J  `F?"J 0yJ"   V AV O " B1 ( L )  xF  ( .
) J "/ J!
$ J  $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 b  FO " 0


`F?" 0y"   V AV O [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,
J!~  2J :   %zv  [ 0
   7 2 : 0

%zv 
.  
FO " `&  (8 x ! 6  
O " B1 ( I )  xF  ( .
:  (e 2 I, )  "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2  " 
2J J: `&  (8 x ! 6  
O [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F 
2J :   `&  @  ! @ ?b  2 :   <"  0
   7
.   !~ 
xJ4 >V F<" F Xz  3 " B1 ( LM )  xF  ( .GM
J$ JV8 J?V  }~ 2 x7  FO " F"     2 F">
J3 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,t )  "/ !
$  

 ,J JF"   J  2 F"> x4 >V F<" F Xz 


.   !~  2 :   `&  ( @ 2"   <"  0
 
JO(3 `J&  J&'8 &
O { O " B1 ( )  xF  ( .GG
J "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 ,$ E FO " 0


`&  &'8 &
O { O [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,H)
2J `J
?  0

!" ! `&  !  2 : 0

O(3
BJ
$ O [8 2>   zg k"  `&  @ `,   C&"~
.   !~  2 :   0
 
 F&
-
 @ 
 x n.,O " B1 ( t )  xF  ( .GL
J  $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 ,$ b  FO " `&  0 k3 *O
x n.,O [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,t )  "/ !
$
0
J   J7 2 : `&  0 k3 *O  F&
-
 @ 

.   !~  2 :   `&   <O ~"? ?O   B
$ ?
JFO " 0
J
   :V E &"1) " B1 ( GH )  xF  ( .GI
(e 2J I,tH )  "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 ,$ b b 
 7 2 2 0

   :V E &"1) [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
.   !~  2 :   `&  2$   ?"  0
 
J? < iJO>&
FJ ~ AV O " B1 ( H )  xF  ( .GH
J$ JV8 J?V  }~ 2 ,$    FO " &
  z  zX &

AV JO [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,tL )  "/ !
$  
 J7 2J : &
  z  zX &
? < iO>&
F ~

2J : O &l# `&$ 6 v    [8 & `&  @ ~  0


 
.   !~ 
" 0
J
F  D  E &"1) " B1 ( Gt )  xF  ( .Ge
I, ) J "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 ,$ p FO
0

F  D  E &"1) [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2
.   !~  2 :   !"D `&  &"1 0
   7 2 :
JFO " &$y
" &V 0
  x," " B1 ( )  xF  ( .G
(e 2 I, )  "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 ,$  
2J : &$y
" &V 0
  x," [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
 `&  @ ) #  x$ "O }~ "8 !
& &"1) 1 7
.   !~  2 : 
J~ &   O n -
 @ `&  zO3 " B1 ( G )  xF  ( .Gt
J "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 ,$    FO " 0
 
nJ -J
 @ `J&  zO3 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,I)
J~ & J
<O ?" = V 0
  %<  0
  ~ &   O
.   !~  2 :   `&  C# 2 Dh, 
BJ
$ C DJ
(z 8 Xz  ~O3 " B1 ( Ge )  xF  ( .G
J!
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 ,$ b  FO "lb"  #$
J8 JXz  ~O3 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e 2 I,I )  "/
@ 1 !4 -
 ?" 0
   , lb"  #$ B
$ C D
(z
.   !~  2 :   `& 

JFO " 0
  "~ (j  &"1 " B1 ( GM )  xF  ( .G
(e 2J I,L )  "/ !
$   $ V8 ?V  }~ 2 ,$  " 
 2 : 0
  "~ (j  &"1 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
   ) $, ! nF, "~ F
O ? 2$ 0
 
.   !~  2 :   0


 J  nV `F 2 x~ C ~ [ 5   $ V8 [8 wl"  2 {" &
BJ1 ( GI ) J xJF  @ `b&"O *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +   
2 I,I )  "/ " $&") #>, `~ @ 0
  x$ B
$ x ~"
@ $&") `,   ZF )   $ [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  (e
`J&  ?
" 0
  #>, `~ B
$   x$ x [8 & `&  [>
ZJ1 AyO `
?  $&") #>, `~ @ 0
  x$/ =&"1 *FO ) %1
.   !~  B
$ ` 

(\ @ lDJ~3 J )  JV  O `1 ": -p C  Ke


m " zv  Dh,  A" F +: O    5 C ~ 0 F
: &  A" 6#"y z  .G
JV8  3 < " @ lD~3  )  V 1 | 3  B
$ 6 "

" *J~ 2F"  `
" }~F  h" &  A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o
JV8 J 3 < " @ z   ) { " (One Way ANOVA )
:k"  C 4 !  & wl"  ( &  A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o

(G)  C 4


@ z
( One Way ANOVA ) " *~ 2F"  `
" wl"
&  A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8  3 < "
 ) 
lD~
**E

6 &

 "



&o

 

E

 

2F"  D

 

)B  C (

)B  J

'OOOO OOOO>
  OOOO %OOOO%  RB ( C -

B 

)B  C (

)B  J

B 

)B  C (

)B  J

B 

'OOOO OOOO 
 4OOOO %OOOO%  RB ( C -

'OOO OOO>
  OOO XOOO $O O,
%  RB ( C -

7,yv \,\= f< Lj  ' q$v **

J$ lD~3  )  V   $ #$8   wl"  C# 2 {"


+ %&'"  ()  + ") C ~   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
-J
./ 0
J  +J       nV `F  *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
@ 0
J  [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  &  A" 6#"y (*   + , 
J  Z [ y" `&   Z [
&  1&$8 6#" + ,  -
o
.%&'"  !l) + "        8 C ~ 0?z" !

J$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &


+       + ") C ~   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,MG + "
0J z  X "  &  A" 6#"y (*   + ,  -
./ 0
 
" LSD " F" }~F  h"   Z1 ) C ~ &  V 2 0"V `
:k"  wl"  (
(Gt)  C 4
&  V @ z
" LSD " F" wl"
-)
[\

**

**

C- "

,

0, 

 

" ] C-) C-

-) C$\

1 

-) C- " OOOOOOOOOO %OOOOOOOOOO'OOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOO>


 
" ] C- ROOOOOOOOB ( C -OOOOOOOO
-) C%

7,yv \,\C f< Lj  ' q$v *


7,yv \,\= f< Lj  ' q$v **

+ " $ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {"


n&"o V8 byV =$ He 1&$8 2Z    n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me
( J    J  + ") C ~ =$ He 2 `8 N3 Ie 2 1&$8 2Z   
N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  byV =$ He 1&$8 2Z    n&"o V8 D
!J
$ `J&  `z [  , byV =$ He 1&$8 2Z    n&"o V8 [8

2J :J$  `&  C# 2 : 2 Ab>  B


$ 
D~  8 X 8 
.8     !~ 
J$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &
byJV =J$ He 1&$8 2Z    n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,MG + "
( J      + ") C ~ =$ Ie 2 `8 1&$8 2Z    n&"o V8
N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  byV =$ He 1&$8 2Z    n&"o V8 D
 !
$ `&  `z [  , byV =$ He 1&$8 2Z    $ V8 [8
J!~  2 :$  `&  C# 2 : 2 Ab>  B
$ 
D~  8 X 8
.8    

: %&
 `1 A" 6#"y z  .L
J 3 < " @ lD~3  )  V 1 | 3  B
$ 6 "

2F"  `
" }~F  h" %&
 `1 A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8
 3 < " @ z   ) { " (One Way ANOVA ) " *~
!J  & wl"  ( %&
 `1 A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8
:k"  C 4
JV @ ( + #1   "   k  
  ) V w : v

.z  Z1 @ >"  $ 
? x~

(G)  C 4


@ z
( One Way ANOVA ) " *~ 2F"  `
" wl"
%&
 `1 A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8  3 < "
4'
 ;^

**=

**=

" 

0, (


>1

B(-

C>$' -

1 
'OOOO OOOO>
  OOOO %OOOO%  RB ( C -

#:$` H

#:$> v

$

#:$` H

#:$> v

$

#:$` H

#:$> v

$

'OOOO OOOO 
 4OOOO %OOOO%  RB ( C -

'OOO OOO>
  OOO XOOO $OOO,
%  RB ( C -

7,yv \,\= f< Lj  ' q$v **

J$ lD~3  )  V   $ #$8   wl"  C# 2 {"


+       nV `F) C ~   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
ZJ1 }J~F  :  %&
 `1 A" 6#"y (*   + ,  -
./ 0
 
   !~  :: O @ [ F &
 #1 6#" 0
  nq [8 N3 ." 
.*   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F C ~ 0?z" !

$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &
+       + ") C ~   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
-J
./ 0
J  +J %&'"  ()  + "  *   + ,  -
./ 0
 

0"V ` 0 z  X "  %&


 `1 A" 6#"y ( *   + , 
LSD " F" }~F  h" 2  2Z1 ) C ~ %&
 `1 V 2
:k"  wl"  ( "
(G)  C 4
%&
"  * " V @ z
" LSD " F" wl"
 %-

`?- (>
J

*
*

**

'( (
3[

>3a
-)

0, 

**

+#QH

Nr2
*v

*!.^#2

+#QH

Nr2
*v

*!.^#2

**

1 

32#: 3+)#M OOOOOOOO %OOOOOOO'OOOOOOOO OOOOOOOO>


 
'-H ,H ROOOOOB ( C -OOOOO
)#u
%

 `


32#: 3+)#M 4OOOOOOO %OOOOOOO'OOOOOOOO OOOOOOOO 



'-H ,H ROOOOOB ( C -OOOOO
)#u
%

7,yv \,\= f< Lj  ' q$v **


7,yv \,\C f< Lj  ' q$v *

J$ lDJ~3 J )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {"


* Jb  J 
J  X8   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
C ~ + #1 X8    b  X8   n&"o V8 1
JX8    b  X8   n&"o V8 D (       + ")
! * b   
  X8 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  + #1
`J
? *Z   &
"  E `&  F
O  1 ,  
"   <"  @ F
.   !~  2
J$ lDJ~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &
V8 1 ^  >F  X8   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,MG + "
 J  + ") C ~ + #1 X8    b  X8   n&"o
+J #1 X8    b  X8   n&"o V8 D (   

 !" 
X  @ [ F ^  >F  X8 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  : 
.   !~  2 `
? *Z   &
"  E `&  F
O  1 , 
J$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &
J1 ^  >F  X8   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
JV8 DJ (       + ") C ~ A" X8   n&"o V8
JX8 [8 N3 J."  ZJ1 }J~F  :J  A" X8   n&"o
JE `J&  F
O  1 ,  
 !" 
X  @ [ F ^  >F 
.   !~  2 `
? *Z   &
" 
J$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &
* Jb  J 
J  X8   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
(%&'"  ()  + ") C ~ + #1 X8   n&"o V8 1
[8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  + #1 X8   n&"o V8 D

`
?  &
"  !"~ F
" `&  &"1  [  , * b   
  X8
.%&'"  !l) + " 2
J$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &
J1 ^  >F  X8   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
(%J&'"  ()  + ") C ~ A"    b  X8   n&"o V8
."  Z1 }~F  :  A"    b  X8   n&"o V8 D
J"  `J&  0 V "  B
$ x?   [  , ^  >F  X8 [8 N3
.%&'"  !l) + " B
$   
  
J$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &
J1 ^  >F  X8   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,MG + "
DJ (%&'"  ()  + ") C ~ + #1 X8   n&"o V8
[8 N3 J."  ZJ1 }J~F  :  + #1 X8   n&"o V8
  "  `&  0 V "  B
$ x?   [  , ^  >F  X8
.%&'"  !l) + " B
$   


:zv  FO A" 6#"y z  .I


J 3 < " @ lD~3  )  V 1 | 3  B
$ 6 "

`J
" }J~F  h" zv  FO A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8
< " @ z   ) { " (One Way ANOVA ) " *~ 2F" 
J& wl"  ( zv  FO A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8  3
:k"  C 4 ! 
( >"  
? x~ V @ ,$    ,$ b b ) 0"FO w

(LM)  C 4


@ z
( One Way ANOVA ) " *~ 2F"  `
" wl"
zv  FO A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8  3 < "
4'
 ;^

" 

**=

0, (


>1

B(-

C>$' -

1 

#:$` H

#:$> v

'OOOO OOOO>
  OOOO %OOOO%  RB ( C -

$

#:$` H

#:$> v

$

#:$` H

#:$> v

$

'OOOO OOOO 
 4OOOO %OOOO%  RB ( C -

'OOO OOO>
  OOO XOOO $OOO,
%  RB ( C -

7,yv \,\= f< Lj  ' q$v **

J$ lDJ~3  )  V   $ #$8   wl"  C# 2 {"


+ %&'"  ()  + ") C ~   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
-J
./ 0
J  +J       nV `F  *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
nq [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  zv  FO A" 6#"y (*   + , 
J `J&   AyO Z [  " zv  !FO 6#"   $ V8
0
J  + %&'"  ()  + ") C ~ 1' ! 0 V#") 2 `
?
+ ,J  -J
./ 0
  +       nV `F  *   + ,  -
./
.(*  

$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &


+       + ") C ~   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,MG + "
JX J"  zv  FO A" 6#"y (*   + ,  -
./ 0
 
}~F  h"   Z1 ) C ~ zv  FO V 2 0"V ` 0 z 
:k"  wl"  ( " LSD " F"
(LG)  C 4
zv  FO V @ z
" LSD " F" wl"

)\

0, 

$8 
 / c

3.2#W

**

34#.

**

3-H#.

3 2#u

3-4#!

*B#-

*R: 3+#c

*R: 3)#u

*R: 3u#u
t,:@<

1 

%
>
 
'
C -
RB (

%

7,yv \,\C f< Lj  ' q$v *


7,yv \,\= f< Lj  ' q$v **

+ " $ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {"


nJ&"o JV8 J1 p FO   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,MG
nJ&"o V8 D (       + ") C ~      0"FO  
JFO J  $ V8 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  p FO  
.   !~  2 :   ~"? !l `&  ?" [  , p
J$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &
V8 1 ,$ b  FO   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
JV8 D (       + ") C ~      0"FO   n&"o
J  $ V8 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  ,$ b  FO   n&"o
!~  2 :   `&  @ ! p `&   <" [  , ,$ b  FO
.  
J$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &
JV8 J1    FO   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
JV8 DJ (       + ") C ~  "  b  0"FO   n&"o
nJ&"o V8 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :   "  b  0"FO   n&"o
J `&  @ ! p `&   <" [  ,  "  b  0"FO  
.   !~  2 : 

: -
 `&    A" 6#"y z  .H
J 3 < " @ lD~3  )  V 1 | 3  B
$ 6 "

" }J~F  h"J -
 `&    A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8
@ Jz  J ) { " (One Way ANOVA ) " *~ 2F"  `

-
J `J&    A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8  3 < "
:k"  C 4 !  & wl"  (
(LL)  C 4
@ z
( One Way ANOVA ) " *~ 2F"  `
" wl"
-
 `&    A" 6#"8 N3 =?F   n&"o V8  3 < "
4'
 ;^

" 

*=

0, (


>1

B(-

C>$' -

1 

#:$` H

#:$> v

'OOOO OOOO>
  OOOO %OOOO%  RB ( C -

$

#:$` H

#:$> v

$

#:$` H

#:$> v

$

'OOOO OOOO 
 4OOOO %OOOO%  RB ( C -

'OOO OOO>
  OOO XOOO $OOO,
%  RB ( C -

7,yv \,\C f< Lj  ' q$v *

J$ lD~3  )  V   $ #$8   wl"  C# 2 {"


+ %&'"  ()  + ") C ~   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
-J
./ 0
J  +J       nV `F  *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  -
 `&    A" 6#"y (*   + , 
[ J `&  @ ?"  Z [  , -
 !
&$   6#" 0
  [8
()  + ") C ~ 0?z" !
 (#:  `F 2 $  [  "  2 z + "
0
  +       nV `F  *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'" 
.(*   + ,  -
./

$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &


+       + ") C ~   n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
J"  -
J `&    A" 6#"y (*   + ,  -
./ 0
 
 J Z1 ) C ~ -
 `&    V 2 0"V ` 0 z  X
:k"  wl"  ( " LSD " F" }~F  h"
(LI)  C 4
-
 `&    V @ z
" LSD " F" wl"

,
[\

R J

,
-

**
-

0, 

4 Zv
>?@<

t  4 `2
`2 >?
4

>? t `2
3 4 `2

3 4 `2
*u<@

 
 ,
RB (

1 

 % 
> '
RB ( C -
%

7,yv \,\C f< Lj  ' q$v *


7,yv \,\= f< Lj  ' q$v **

J$ lDJ~3 J )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {"


Ge -
J !
&$   2Z    n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,Me + "
2 ` N3   2 -
 !
&$   2Z    n&"o V8 byV 
 J 2Z    n&"o V8 D (       + ") C ~   GM
J  nJ&"o V8 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  byV  Ge -
 !
&$
@ 8 : ?O  B
$ 
D~ byV  Ge -
 !
&$   2Z 
.8     !~  2 :$  `& 

$ lD~3  )  V   #$8   wl"  C# 2 {" &


Ge -
J !
&$   2Z    n&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,MG + "
C J~ `yV   - -
 !
&$   2Z    n&"o V8 byV 
Ge -
 !
&$   2Z    n&"o V8 D (       + ")
!J
&$   2Z    n&"o V8 [8 N3 ."  Z1 }~F  :  byV 
2J :J$  `&  @ 8 : ?O  B
$ 
D~ byV  Ge -

.8     !~ 

X O   wl" : -p `Dz 


  X#
  wl"
  X O

: -p `Dz 
X O   wl"
 ! 3 |
X O  wl"  18    + " fh
 B
$ `Dz  Z1 `&",
.wl" 
O ( @ ~"? X "   8

  X#
.~# n k3 V C DV  B
$   Z1  "~
)j"  !V18 !"8   
>, 
`& C  `Dz  C O
." @ }~F  !h"  
<D 18  !$ i 
()         O k3 =<"   1z `Dz  Z1 @ }~F  C O
0
  +       + " [ @ |
b   " 618 =5 %&'" 
()  + " [ N3   6 & 1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./
N3 J  6J  1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0

%&'" 
+J %J&'"  ()  + "       + " 0 FO)  B
$ 6 " 
J      nV `F [ N3   6  *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
N3 J  6J J&  1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +
 J5 C ~ 0 F (\ 2 lD~3  )  V 1 [ 3  B
$ 6 " 
2 !V18 ?"   |   zv  Dh,  A" F +: O  

+J %J&'"  ()        #$  ) %l  Cj"  B


$   C#
: "  $z  
  z"O *Z  (m*   + ,  -
./ 0
 
J! 2J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       + "  (G
m1'
J! 2J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + "  (L
m1'
0
  + %&'"  ()  + "       + " 0 FO)   (I
m*   + ,  -
o @
J! 2J *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F  (H
m 1'
+:J O    5 C ~ 0 F (\ 2 lD~3  )  V  O `1 (e
m zv  Dh,  A" F
J  BJ
$ `&"78 & 
*'    ?V b  `Dz  8
.!
$ i? "  }~F   
?  
ZJ1 @ }~F  h"   (3   .! } b  `Dz  C O
.6!"   n&"o }~F  { 8  %zX  w!  
.( F") )   x8 $3 z `Dz  Z1 @ }~F  0
! ( F") )   x8 F X (3  }~F  { 8
F<" }~F   !l\ ( @ 0&> 2 $ &o 6, B
$    X @
lDJ~ i J ~  =   F<O z }~F  0  " x8
.   `
@ h"

BJ
$ J  =) J"   wl" `
$ C O ?V n   `Dz  8
.?     wl" n !<   !.l" , !"
8
J18 $    fh
" }~F     Z1 2 -p `Dz  @
.X O  8 "  !.l"

  wl"
0
J  +J       + " " :C ) C  ?
" wl"  K8
m" 1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./
rJ
}J~ J$ `>, nzO   $ V8 +       + " [8 K
.( $ )   Z1 " O (e 2 HMM)
J    
 "  B
$ =  $  [ ?V    $ V8 [8 K
:@ `b&"O *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +
.-
 ` F %l#: #$ [8 ?"$8 KG
.`&  #>, `~ @ %l# $8 8 x    78 KL
.%
&$ :8 0~    78 KI
.%l# 0 "~ %'~8 KH
.x  x    %l# n O8 Ke
+J     
 " " B
$  $  [ ?V    $ V8 [8 K
:@ `b&"O *   + ,  -
./ 0
 

.k (X8 n `&$8 8  78 KG
.%
&  8 $ O)  78 KL
.`&
%l8 (8 %z  ?")  78 KI
.n" %
&$ [y  78 KH
.#>, `~ @ %l# 78 Ke
.%
&$ @  ?~8 8 ?"$8 K
+     
~ + " B
$ < "  [ ?V    $ V8 [8 K
: @ `b&"O *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
.^ j 
  ) ` 
 
  * [8  78 .G

0
J  + %&'"  ()  + " " :b  C  ?
" wl"  K
m" 1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./
rJ
}J~ J$ `>, nzO   $ V8 + %&'"  ()  + " [8 K
. (e 2 It)
+J %&'"  ()
0OF$ B
$ =  $  [ ?V    $ V8 [8 K
:@ [#b&" *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
.-
 `&$  *! +D CZ 8 [8  " .G
.      >
& @ + ,  -
o `F?"/ "18 .L

+ %&'"  ()
F$  B
$  $  [ ?V    $ V8 [8 K
:@ `b&"O *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
.+ `&  ! ? `V -
 @ `&   [8 +8.G
.  [  + ,  -
o @ %
& "  O)  78.L
.+ ,  -
o @ `&$8 y 2 8 $ hz   78.I
.-
 2$ :"$ %lX 8.H
.-
 %
&$ @ &"8 [8 n<"8 ~ k ` O &! 8 `F?O8.e
.-
 O `F =Ab >Vy cV 8 [> @ `&
=$ |?
O 3.
.+ ,  -
o  n  2j8  ?  <"O.t
. 0
  ~8 zD B
$ + ,  -
o `V 8.
+ %&'"  ()
0OF$ B
$ < "  [ ?V    $ V8 [8 K
:@ [#b&" *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
.`&  @ %l8 0" +  `V8 ?" -
 :z KG
.-
 `&  |O =F
 ~ y"O [8 2> KL

 J  + "J 0 FO)   " :} b  C  ?


" wl"  K
m" *   + ,  -
o @ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + "   

 J  + "J 0 `yV M,MG + " $ lD~3  )   #$  


8 {" }~ *   + ,  -
o @ 0
  + %&'"  ()     
 &
 *   + ,  -
o @ 0
  +       + " 2 &

.%&'"  !l) 

0
J  +J       nV `F ":n   C  ?
" wl"  K 
m"1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./
}J~   Z1 @       nV `F B
$ [ ?V    $ V8 [8 K
. (e 2 II) ?V   |

+J J      nV `F 2 ,$  O B
$ [ ?V    $ V8 [8 K
:@ `b&"O *   + ,  -
./ 0
 
.( ... X -V O1 )  !  #    p AV O .G
. $  8 F `&$ $ -
 @ `&  ' `&, [8 .L
.-
 ($8 0 j (j  0 x CDO)   AV O .I
.0 j (j  0 ?"      [8 .H
.fDh"  )o @ F"     0
  E3 .e
.i"  `?  "
   z  AV O .
." |  n 0
  2 
< ! iO .t

.0

%zv  `F?" 0y"   V AV O .
.`&  (8 x ! 6  
O .
.F"     2 F"> x4 >V F<" F Xz  3 .GM
.0

O(3 `&  &'8 &
O { O .GG
.`&  0 k3 *O  F&
-
 @ 
 x n.,O .GL
.0

   :V E &"1) .GI
.&
  z  zX &
? < iO>&
F ~ AV O .GH
.0

F  D   E &"1) .Ge
.&$y
"  @ 0
  x," .G
.0
  ~ &   O n -
 @ `&  zO .Gt
.lb"  #$ B
$ C D
(z 8 Xz  ~O3 .G
.0
  "~ (j  &"1 .G
J    J  nV `F 2 ~ B
$ !"?V  @ [ 5   $ V8 [8 K
:@ `b&" *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +
.$&") #>, `~ @ 0
  x$ B
$ x ~ .G

2 lD~3  )  V  O `1 ": -p C  ?


" wl"  KJ1
m zv  Dh,  A" F +: O    5 C ~ 0 F (\

JV8 J1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   $ K


 *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + ") C ~   n&"o
.&  A" 6#"y (*   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
N3 Ie 2 1&$8 2Z    n&"o V8 byV =$ He 1&$8 2Z   
2ZJ  J  nJ&"o V8 D (       + ") C ~ =$ He 2 `8
.byV =$ He 1&$8
nJ&"o V8 1 @ `yV M,MG + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
Ie 2 `8 1&$8 2Z    n&"o V8 byV =$ He 1&$8 2Z   
=$ He 1&$8 2Z    n&"o V8 D (       + ") C ~ =$
.byV
JV8 J1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   $ K
(* J  + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F) C ~   n&"o
.%&
 `1 A" 6#"y
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
J b  JX8   n&"o V8 1 * b   
  X8  
nJ&"o V8 D (       + ") C ~ + #1 X8  
.+ #1 X8    b  X8  
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,MG + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
J  J b  X8   n&"o V8 1 ^  >F  X8  
  n&"o V8 D (       + ") C ~ + #1 X8
.+ #1 X8    b  X8

nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   K


C J~ A" X8   n&"o V8 1 ^  >F  X8  
.A" X8   n&"o V8 D (      + ")
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
#1J X8   n&"o V8 1 * b   
  X8  
#1J X8   n&"o V8 D (%&'"  ()  + ") C ~ +
.+
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
J  J b  X8   n&"o V8 1 ^  >F  X8  
J b  X8   n&"o V8 D (%&'"  ()  + ") C ~ A"
.A"  
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,MG + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
+ #1 X8   n&"o V8 1 ^  >F  X8  
.+ #1 X8   n&"o V8 D (%&'"  ()  + ") C ~
JV8 J1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   $ K
 *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + ") C ~   n&"o
JFO A" 6#"y (*   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F
.zv 
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,MG + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
C ~      0"FO   n&"o V8 1 p FO  
.p FO   n&"o V8 D (       + ")

nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   K


 J    0"FO   n&"o V8 1 ,$ b  FO  
.,$ b  FO   n&"o V8 D (       + ") C ~
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
C J~  J"  b  0"FO   n&"o V8 1    FO  
. "  b  0"FO   n&"o V8 D (       + ")
JV8 J1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   $ K
 *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()  + ") C ~   n&"o
  A" 6#"y (*   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F
.-
 `& 
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,Me + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
  2Z    n&"o V8 byV  Ge -
 !
&$   2Z   
( J      + ") C ~   GM 2 ` N3   2 -
 !
&$
.byV  Ge -
 !
&$   2Z    n&"o V8 D
nJ&"o JV8 1 @ `yV M,MG + " $ lD~3  )  V   K
  2Z    n&"o V8 byV  Ge -
 !
&$   2Z   
nJ&"o JV8 D (       + ") C ~ `yV   - -
 !
&$
.byV  Ge -
 !
&$   2Z   

  X O
( ... X -V O1 )  !  #    p AV O B
$ `&  
.+ ,  -
o 3 y
. $  8 F `&$ $ -
 @ `&  ' `&, [8 x$ x  
.-
 ($8 0 j (j  0 x CDO)   AV O 
-J
o 3 Jy 0J j (j  0 #  0 B
$ `&  
.+ , 
.fDh"  )o @ F"     + ,  -
./ 0
  E3 
.+ ,  -
./ 0

i"  `?  "
   z  AV O 
." |  n 0
  2 
< ! iO x$ x  
.0

%zv  `F?" 0y"   V AV O B
$ `&  i 
.`&  (8 x ! 6  
" 0
  nV %F 
 J  2J FJ"> xJ4 >V F<" F Xz  AV O "" 
.F" 
.0

O(3 `&  &'8 &
O { O i 
.`&  0 k3 *O  F&
-
 @ 
 x n.,O x  
.0

   :V E &"1) x  
.&
  z  zX &
? < iO>&
F ~ AV " &"1) 

.0

F  D   E &"1) i 
.&$y
"  @ 0
  x," %F 
.lb"  #$ B
$ C D
(z 8 Xz  ~O3 x  
.0
  "~ &"1) x  
.$&") #>, `~ @ 0
  x$ B
$ E 

n D &l

n D &l


Dh,  flDp "#$ %&'"  ()  :(LMMH) $ C# *;
.HGKG (G) LH  .x    
 .! &' O @ F 
!h"  D  x3 .O" :(LMMI)   ( %F
F 
!:"  0&
&
      !"#$ [ @    b  ^  
.[ .
 
   [&$   .(x , A)  "   .%&'" 
-
o ($ *7) `   :(LMM) > F$  7 %
$ C#!F 
.N   F< .+ ,  -
o . .+ , 
  %zv  ( !"#$       :(LMMe) F$ &5 E
. 

      :  .(x , A) A"
?F<O  :*?  &  %&'"  ()  #$ :(LMMG) .7 E
      >
& @  4 F    ZV @ &4 %zv  B
$
. 

      :   .(x , A) A"  
1z&
 ^  * !V  .(LMM) (1 
E
z  C 'V5 @ %&'"  ()  !"#$  "   
<D
.-
   .    .(x , A) A"   .  
+ %&'"  ()   E 0 #  .(LMM) %z<  [;
:-
 .(x , A) A"   .<
z   4 @ "   ($8
.  .   

?O '  $ 
$V 3 + " 0 #  .(LMMH) C x E
@ &'"  ?b  %&'"  ()  %zv    %zv  ( 2 ` (
(G) G   
 :  
   
o . p  
.KG
^ * + %&'"  D  x3 i 8 .(LMM) ;8 * p
.1' ! 2 0&
&
      !"#$ > > /  >E  b 
 "  x)   "  
 +?  8   .(x , A) A"  
.> > .<h" 
>
&   (  ) # @ + ,  :(LMMI) 
 x3
.+ ,  -
o .       
.%&'"  ()  !"#$ `&  : (LMMe) [?&$   *  
. 

        . (x , A) A"  

  .(G) (&5   % qO) } :z
.,  nF<
D   x1?  .`&  @
  n&"& F"> :F * -z  
$ : (LMM) [ , *1 n 
.n "  ,


 4  x 
  : (LMMM) z7  [ 
.n "  , 
2  ,  % ?  $X :(LMMt) [&
 
x7  
.E  .[&$ .%&'"  () 

  %zv          + "  :(G) :V : 


.(G) I  .  F
O 
o .O
      ^  *?  &  #$ :(LMM) x  1: 
+?  8   .(x , A) A"   .x 'V/ l" ) 
~ &

.> > .<h"   "  x)   "  

"#$ ?   (j *? 
  :(GI) X %
$ 1: 
A) A"   . 
   @ -"  1 ($      
. 
   .  .(x ,

  5 * -z  
$ :(GL) 2~ *! 

.

   &' :[&$ 
()  B
$ 18 zv  Dh,  flDp .(LMMM) F$ # 
.  . 

      .(x , A) A"   .%&'" 
@ <
z   4 @ 0

      .(Ge) x ; C# #
.-
 .  .    .(x , A) A"   .   z 
0       >
& @  ,   ."  :(LMM) 2; F$ %
F, 
.Ap *  2; F$  .6 4 . <"  

  
o .`&  (8 @ x `  :(GL)
 C# , 
.e  .x) D") :: F$

.">
     .* -z  
$ :(G) &5 &$ F, 

   "#$  (j *?  &  .(Gt) 7 &5  D 


  .      >
& @ 0&
 $3 
> -"  1 ($   
. 
     .(x , A) A"
   >
& @    <
 :(LMM)  F$   %zD 
.G.  
.%
  }F  @   .~  C  :(G) % F$ D 
.bE  "  <  :x1? 
  .`&  @  #  :(G) 2;  F$ 1 3 -h< 
. !V
 
 $ F<
 .%&'" 

%$D  -z  
$ :(G) ? F$ V 
..6 

   Dh,  &  0 #  :(LMML) ;8   %~  F$


A) A"   .   z  @ Xp  "   %&
 +   
.  .    .-
 .(x ,
.  .V x3 
$ @ " :(GtI) 1 F$ n F$
8  .[&$ .O8 lF *) '"  :(LMM)  * F$
.n "  ,

.F 8 O 8  !z :%&
 }F  : (G) [ \ [ F$
.,  $F<
>z   [&$

    %&'"  ()  : (Gt)


     " 
.tKGL (tM) G  .* 
o .V x `  :: F$

()  + " nV @ F"  w    :(LMM) -; ` , " 


. 

      :   .( x , A) A"   .%&'" 
^ * Dh,  &  ?   .(LMM) 6  " 
A)A"   .&
"  l<  'V5 @ 0&
&
      !"#$
.> > .<h"   "  x)   "  
 +?  8   .(x ,
:   .
  
 @ }F  N3 ` .(Ge) X 6 
.[>F  F">
1D 1 "       .(LMMt) +1 6$ F$ 6$

o .(0<
V)-
  @    
~ &
 %&
 + )o
.G KG (I) LG   
 :  .   
"   !
%&'"  ()  .(LMM) [ \ 6$ *<$

 "  

+?  8   
o .[&$ &<
 
"   "  x ^/
.LKGI (L) G  ) $&")
.  .L .,F    x3 :(LMMt) ? F$  %#$
.- 0$ F"> .x1?  .) #  @ :  :(.) 2; F$ &$
*?  &  -"  1 ($ %&'"  ()  .(G) F$ *& 
GG   
 :  
   
o . 
   @  (j
.GIH KGGG (G)
%&'"  ()  2 ` AyO  F ( .(LMMH) F$ *& 

8   
o .&'"    z  %zv  ( B
$ `&  %zv   
.G GGe (G) G  ) $&")  "  

+? 

0 0zv &


%&'"  ()  + " .(LMM) ;8 V * 
:  .(x , A) A"   .>   
 
 @ 0> 
. 
  
+ *?  &  ! ()  0 #  : (LMMI) [ y O $
  .-
 .(x , A) A"   .<
z  <
  x @ 0
.  . 
i">   . A .%$D  -z  
$ :(G) &5 `  $
.&


~ &
 + %&'"  ()  Dh,  &  .(LMMe) " 
: -
 .(x , A) A"   .-
 'V5 @  >E ^ @ 
.  .   
@ &'"     AyO :(LMMH) y,  <?  %&!V* !z 

o . &"
   &' : x1?  .x    
 .%&'"  () 
.L   LH
!   .x1?  . ,F  + ?  x :(GG)  D %&!V
.e.  
.   !   .x1?  .
  
 ? : (Ge)  D %&!V
 .F<"  '  0 ! -z  
$ : (LMMG)  &5 n ? 
.n "  ,
 

+         *?  &  :(Gt) ~ *? 


  "  
. :: F$
   .(x , A) A"   . 0&

. x 
.%&'"  ()  "#$ %z  0>&"  :(LMM) *F$ i D %b? 
. 

        .(x , A) A"  
  .%&'"  ()  B
$ 
  `&   8 .(LMMG) &5 <? 
.  . 

      .(x , A) A"
. ,   : ~   .%&'" 
  .(G) A $ %F> 
K b~ 1z 8 K%&'"   <"  : (G) B  *

.,  $F<
`l  : [&$.

o ." x @       8 .(G) 2  #X A! &5
. $  II   ") z>  : ! i"  ") z>  
D
.D
,
#z  F"> . A .%$D  -z  
$ :(GH)  $ [ ,
.G .n " 
x  ")
 "#$ %&'"  ()  .(LMMe)  $ [ ,
.GIKte (H) II  $&") 
 : | >    
o .z 
.[&$ .F 3 F
 : %&'"  ()  : (G) 28  
.  

%&'"  ()  0 `&  0 #  .(Ge) ~ F$ A


(L) Ie    x 
o .Dh,  zD  %zv    (
.LHI KLMt
1 &       "#$ %z   D .(G) % +
  .(x , A) A"   .&
"  -
 ?< @     &

.-
 .  . 
.   
 n&o .   .  : (LMMH) [ \ # F$ [ 1
.    ,  F"> .H
( + " B
$ 8 %&'"  ()  : (LMML) X C Z1 C Z
. 

        .(x , A)A"  .%zv 
$ F< .*   &
%&'"  ()  : (G) ;8 2; F$ [.1
. 

    8

  ~#
.!zlv !ly &l 0&> F" :(G) 

.l!   X @ F") :(L) 


( G ) 

!zlv !ly &l 0&> F"

 

     

   

 
 

( F" )
+ ,  -
./ 0

%&'"  ()  B
$       8
1' ! 2 *  
$3
%4 &5 2 

%&
 6,
* :;  &5 .8

LMGM

~  2;   

 &


 "  " x 


: O  ; >
$ # 

%&'"  ()  !"#$       " [   $c  8 8 xV  yV


A"  ` %
&>O i
<"& " 1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0


. 

      2  
 @
!&>" >"
F" Z1 >8 0 n }~F  [cV   Co @ >Op ='
: "      !"(# + F$ C ~ *8  ( 3
.1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0
  +       + " :C   
.1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()   :b   
.1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0

      nV `F :} b   
^ x8 [ >"  O  # "  B
$ F"  ( c >"  >  >Dh7 2 =
.>  O X > =7 X
  f  
F?O
}~F 
%4 &5 
MeeHIHL C 

zv  Dh,  F  : =) 8


&  G
=$ Ie 2 `8 N3 Le 2

(L

byV =$ He 2

(H

=$ Le 2 `8
=$ He 2 `8 N3 Ie 2

(G
(I

$&")  E L
:$8

(L

:"

(G

`8

(H

<

(I

%&
 `1 I



(L

$  

(G

A"

(H

^  >

(I

 "

(e

zv  FO H
 

(L

p

(G

b 

(H

  

(I

x7 

 " 

(e

,$ b 

,$ E

(t

( GM

,$ b b 

,$   

() ................ :-
 `&    Ke

    5 : =
      + " : C   
-J
./ 0
J  +J J      + " -?O  F  2 $ &o %
 &V

.F p @ #$ n !


$ "?V  + "  (  *   + , 
xF   +

F +

 +

 &

 &
xF 

xF 

'~#
&! A

&!

F

F

A


xF 

^ j& - `:
  * [8  78

%
&$ @  ~8  8 ?"$8

%
&  8 $ Cjz"   78

-J
 `J   %l#: #$ [8 ?"$8




`J~ @ %Jl# $J8 8 x    78
`&  `,
%Jl#: J O8 J 
>, ! O $
!
~ @ ,
%l# 0 "~ >/  78
AD `&    [8  78
-
 ? |O8 &
 x    78
-
 p V3 C&$y ?
<O8
k (X8 n `&$8 8  7
n" %
&$ [y  78
 8   %l# n O8

GM
GG
GL
GI

%
&$ @ %z  ?")  78

GH

%
&  8 $    78

Ge

x3 @ [ 8 $ -
.&
"7

%&'"  ()   : b   
+ ,J  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()     F  2 $ &o %
 &V

.F p @ #$ n !


$ "?V  + "  (  *  

'~#

 +

F +

 +

 &
xF   &
xF 
A

&!

&!

F

xF 

F



xF 


n " 1  b8 *! +D CZ 8 [8  " 8
&$8 @ -
  B
$ $8 %
'$ [> y -
 2$ %lX :"$ 8
. V `&

@ %Jl8 0J" *  `V8 8 -


. `& 
@ &"J8 [8 n<"J8 ~ k ` O &! *8 `F8
. -
 %
&$
-
o @ `&$8 y 2 8 $ hz   7
+ , 
J n <"O  2j8  ?  2 =Ab [8 8
+ ,  -
o
+ ,J  -
o @ `&  "  =   8
. !V `&  * 8 |  2 2   [ 
J>
& @ + ,J  -
o `F?"/ "18 3 ??~
     
`J&
!4 ? 2 2~ 1 -
 [8 ?"$8
V
`&
-
 `&  O @ A>z"  %
$ i D  2
+8 !
2 `V8 iO \ [> @ `&
=$ |?
O 3
-
 @ `&  O8 2 cV kE O

G
L
I
H
e

GM
GG

      nV `F : } b   
-J
./ 0
J  +J       nV `F { O  F  2 $ &o %
 &V

.F p @ #$ n !


$ "?V  + "  (  *   + , 
xF  8 +

F +

 +

 &

 &
xF 

xF 

'~#
A

&!

&!

F

F

A


xF 

nJ -J
 @ `&  z" [8 *   2



0
  ~ &   O
`F?"J 0yJ"   V AV O ! 2
0

%zv 
6J  J
O `J&  618 ~8 [ > [8
x !
iJ [J> AV " -
 "  [8 i
z
"h C&$  F<
? < iO>&
F ~ AV " %F
&
  z  zX &

J J#    p AV O x 
J JX -JV O1 )  !

L
I
H
e

( ..        $D


0J xJ CDO)   AV O ! 2
($ 0 j (j 
xJF * -J
 @ 
 x n.,O
`&  0 N3 *O
JO(3 `&  &'8 &
O  7
0


B
$ i
"
#  
  {  [8
O#>, `&  6 v

GM

-
 0

D    AV O ! 2

GG

! 0
    <O  {" [8

GL

&$y
"  @.0
  x,"

GI

'~#

8 +

F +

 +

 &
xF 

 &
xF 

xF 

&!

&!

F

F

A


xF 

J<p wJ  BJ
$ 0
  #3
 <" 

GH

CJ&$8 2J$ z") (j  &"1


0
  "~

Ge

h"J *ZJ  J  


8  
`&  (8 (j 

2J J
< ! iO *   2
" |  n 0
 

Gt

(Jj  0 ?"      [8 i
0 j

 #>, `~ @ 0  x$

,  + " n iO  i" [8

LM

J   :V EJ * `>, &"1)


0


LG

BJ
$ C D
(z 8 Xz  ~O3
.   V> lb"  #$

LL

 8 F `&$ $ `&  ' `&, [8


 $

LI

D  0
    &"1) *   2
F 

LH

`J?  J"
J   Jz  AV O
i" 

Le

xJ$ BJ
$ -
 @ v "  &"$
i [> @ i ` 

-J
 @ J?   b  ' x$
F<"  @  

Lt

)o @ F"     0


  E3
fDh" 

x4 >V F<" F Xz  3


-
 @ F"     2 F">

2 `&  &
O v  B?
" [8 %F
~ 

IM



!zlv 0&> (y &l


`&  !

)

 

z C\   2 ;8 .

F$  $ ;8 .8

*,F  &5 `$3 .8

 <  ;8 0 .8

*Ab>  ; 2 7 .8

!,  %
$ 2   . (

% F  ; 2   .8

f
 &5 2   .8

`V % X .8

 

      
   
 &$

%F>  A 2 $ .8

GM

 

      $&") 
  -l

?   zEF$ .8

GG

? F  :: F$ F$ .

GL

&E "  !V .

GI

<?  % C\ F$ &5 .8

GH

 &5 %"V &5 .8

Ge

+ ,  -
o $ K
=?  0&
 
   n&"  F"  w  &$ K
 

      (D~  "  : -l
+ ,  -
o $ K
=?  ,     K
 

      -"  1 $
+ ,  -
o $ K
&
  "  w1 "8 K
=?  z   "  

    &4 -l K
 

      
   
 `
+ ,  -
o $ K
+?  8   %&
 -
 $ K
+ ,  -
o $ K
=?  
"   "   il w1 "8 K
+ ,  -
o $ K
=?  :: F$
     
  -l K

+ ,  -
o $ K
=?   
   ) 
 
 ` K
+ ,  -
o $ K
=?  
 F
x) !  $  il K
+ ,  -
o $ K
=?   
   F  :  K
 

      -"  1 $

( L ) 

l!   X @ F")

 'z~

+ ,  -
./ v  />  

: O  ; >


$ # 
%&'"  ()  !"#$       " [  &
$  $ 3 %zV
0
  B
$   %1 " 1' ! 2 *   + ,  -
./ 0


=)&>" ,$    ~ p FO [
, 2 *   + ,  -
./
Z1 ? [y }~F  6,"  
 @ A"  B
$ C D

.  )    F  B
$ C D
|&&X  F")
 !V xF$ ` x( ?V F")  5 B
$ #) >"  `\
[ >"  ) nq [ =&
$ 8 2$  &J i [> @ #$ n
.%&
 }F   )3 h"O 2   &"1)   `5
.?"  "  f  C F? 
zO  >  O 2~ > =7

}~F 
%4 &5 2 

Dh,  F  : =) 8
:&  G
=$ Ie 2 `8 N3 Le 2

=$ Le 2 `8

yV =$ He 2

=$ He 2 `8 N3 Ie 2
: %&
 `1 L

* b   


$  

k$ 


^  >

 "

A"
. ............... : (~) +8
zv  FO I

 

p

b 

  

x7 

 " 

,$ b 

,$ E

,$   

,$ b b 
-
 `&   KH

  GM 2 `8 N3   2

`yV   e

byV  Ge 2

 Ge 2 `8 N3 GM 2

  

 5 : =

      + " : C   
+ ,  -
./ 0
  +       + " -?O  F  2 $ &o %
 &V
.F p @ #$ n !
$ "?V  + "  (  *  






= zh

zh

< "





 $

=  $

xF 

) `J 
 
  * [8  78
.^ j 
 

.%
&$ @  ?~8  8 ?"$8

.%
&  8 $ O)  78

`J JF %l#: #$ [8 ?"$8


.-

`~ @ %l# $8 8 x    78
.`&  #>,

H
e

.#>, `~ @ %l# 78

.%l# 0 "~ B'~8

.k (X8 n `&$8 8  7

.n" %
&$ [y  78

.x  x    %l# n O8 GM
.`&
%l8 (8 %z  ?")  78 GG
.%
&$ : 0~    78 GL

%&'"  ()   : b   
+ ,  -
./ 0
  + %&'"  ()     F  2 $ &o %
 &V
.F p @ #$ n !
$ "?V  + "  (  *  
@ F  V18 ?" *   + ,  -
./ 0
   y %&'"  ()  6  )
.(  3 (&") hz   ,  n &$y z"~) &")
= 8

=

=~8

=F 

=&l

xF 

.-
 `&$  *! +D CZ 8 [8  "

.-
 2$ :"$ %lX 8

@ %Jl8 0J" *  `V8 ?" -


 :z

.      >
& @ + ,  -
o `F?"/.`& 
"18

-J
o @ `&$8 y 2 8 $ hz   7

.+ , 
.+ ,  -
o  n  2j8  ?  <"O

.  [  + ,  -
o @ %
& "  O)  78

%
&$ @ &"8 [8 n<"8 ~ k ` O &! 8 `F?O8

.-

`&  ! ? 2~ -
 @ `&   [8 +8
.+
.-
 `&  |O =F
 ~ y"O [8 2>

GM

. 0
  ~8 zD %
$ + ,  -
o `V 8

GG

`JF =Ab >Vy \ [> @ `&


=$ |?
O 3
.-
 O

GL

      nV `F : } b   
+ ,  -
./ 0
  +       nV `F { O  F  2 $ &o %
 &V
.F p @ #$ n !
$ "?V  + "  (  *  
V  A

=#3

V 

5

V 

V 

xF 

=

.0

%zv  `F?" 0y"   V AV O

G
L

.`&  (8 x ! 6  


O

. &
  z  zX &
? < iO>&
F ~ AV O

(.... X -V O1 )  !  #    p AV O

.-
 ($8 0 j (j  0 x CDO)   AV O

`&  0 N3 *O  F&


-
 @ 
 x n.,O

.0

O(3 `&  &'8 &
O { O

.&$y
"  @ 0
  x,"

.0
  ~ &   O n -
 @ `&  zO3

.0
  "~ (j  &"1
." |  n 0
  2 
< ! iO
.0 j (j  0 ?"      [8
.$&") #>, `~ @ 0  x$ B
$ x ~

GM
GG
GL
GI

.lb"  #$ B
$ C D
(zU 8 Xz  ~O3

GH
Ge

. $  8 F `&$ $ `&  ' `&, [8

.0

F  D   E &"1)
.i"  `?  "
   z  AV O

Gt
G

.fDh"  )o @ F"     0


  E3

.F"     2 F"> x4 >V F<" F Xz  3

LM

.0

   :V E &"1)

You might also like