Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Principia L Is Mo

    Uploaded by

    Yedania Jaramillo Hernandez
    29 views4 pages
    Principalisimo

    Original Title

    Principia l is Mo

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    Principalisimo

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    29 views4 pages

    Principia L Is Mo

    Uploaded by

    Yedania Jaramillo Hernandez
    Principalisimo

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 4

    Julio-Diciembre 2012

    Bioética
    NBTBMMÈEFM
    principialismo
    BIOETHICS BEYOND
    María Teresa Escobar López
    THE PRINCIPLISM

    BIOÉTICA PARA ALÉM


    DO PRINCIPIALISMO

    OO6

    SFWMBUJOPBNCJPFUISSN 1657-47027PMVNFONúmero 2&EJDJØOPáginas 6-9


    BIOÉTICA MÉDICA BASADA EN EVIDENCIAS / Fabio Garzón Díaz

    BIOÉTICA MÁS ALLÁ DEL PRINCIPIALISMO BM JOUFSJPS EF MPT FTQBDJPT DMÓOJDP IPTQJUBMBSJPT  FO MB
    DSFBDJØO F JOTUBMBDJØO EF DPNJUÏT EF ÏUJDB BTJTUFODJBM
    $POSFTQFDUPBMB#JPÏUJDBCBTBEBFOMPTQSJODJQJPT Z EF JOWFTUJHBDJØO  DFOUSPT EF #JPÏUJDB Z FOTF×BO[B
    EFCFOFmDFODJB OPNBMFmDFODJB KVTUJDJBZBVUPOPNÓB  EFMB#JPÏUJDBFOTBMVE-BGVFS[BJOVTJUBEBDPORVFTF
    QSPQVFTUPT QPS #FBVDIBNQ 5  Z $IJMESFTT +  
     EFTBSSPMMØPCFEFDF BMNFOPTFOQBSUF BMBOFDFTJEBE
    FOTVZBDMÈTJDPUFYUP1SJODJQJPTEF²UJDB#JPNÏEJDB  TFOUJEB B mOBMFT EF TJHMP 99 EF CVTDBS SFTQVFTUBT B
    FOFMDPOUFYUPEFMQSPOVODJBNJFOUPEFMB/BUJPOBM$P MPTEJMFNBTTVSHJEPTEFMPTBEFMBOUPTMPHSBEPTQPSMPT
    NJTTJPOFOFM*OGPSNF#FMNPOU  ]
    BNFOPT EFTBSSPMMPUÏDOJDPTZDJFOUÓmDPT MPTSFUPTZEJmDVMUBEFT
    EFVOBEÏDBEBEFBDV×BEPFMUÏSNJOPQPS1PUUFS QVF GSFOUFBMBTQFSTQFDUJWBTEFDBNCJPBOJWFMQPMÓUJDP TP
    EFEFDJSTFRVFIBTJEPGVOEBNFOUBMQBSBTVEFTBSSPMMP DJBMZDVMUVSBM FOVONVOEPDBEBWF[NÈTHMPCBMJ[BEP
    ZEJGVTJØOFTUPTDVBSFOUBB×PT 6O BTVOUP JOOFHBCMF FT RVF FM QSJODJQJBMJTNP  BTÓ
    -B FYQSFTJØO QSJODJQJBMJTNP  QSPWJFOF EF TVT DSÓUJ DPNP IB TJEP TPQPSUF EF MB ÏUJDB NÏEJDB F JOWFTUJHB
    cosZTVTFOUJEPJOJDJBMNFOUFEFTDBMJmDBEPS  asegura UJWBFOMBTÞMUJNBTEÏDBEBT UBNCJÏOTFRVFEBDPSUPZ
    RVF MPT QSJODJQJPT TPO EFNBTJBEP HFOFSBMFT  OP QSF FTJNQFOTBCMFQSFUFOEFSRVFMFEFTPQPSUFBUPEPTMPT
    TFOUBOSFMBDJØOTJTUFNÈUJDBFOUSFTÓZNVFTUSBODPOnJD EJMFNBTÏUJDPTEFOVFTUSPUJFNQP
    UPTJSSFTPMVCMFTFOUSFFMMPT . )PZ FYJTUFO VOB TFSJF EF DVFTUJPOBNJFOUPT
    4JOFNCBSHP SÈQJEBNFOUFprincipialismo TFDPOWJS SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO QSPCMFNBT EF DPOGMJDUPT

    OO7
    UJØ OP TØMP FO MB GPSNB EF MMBNBSMP  TJOP FO UPEB VOB FOUSF MPT NJTNPT QSJODJQJPT EFM QSJODJQJB
    QFSTQFDUJWB EFOUSP EF MB #JPÏUJDB MB DPSSJFOUF QSJODJ MJTNP  QSPCMFNBT EF NBDSPCJPÏUJDB  EF
    QJBMJTUB MB DVBM TF IB JEP EFTBSSPMMBOEP FTQFDJBMNFOUF ÏUJDB NÏEJDB  EF #JPÏUJDB BNCJFOUBM  EF

    SFWMBUJOPBNCJPFUISSN 1657-47027PMVNFONúmero 2&EJDJØOPáginas 6-9


    Julio-Diciembre 2012

    KVTUJDJB TBOJUBSJB Z TPDJBM  EF FRVJEBE  QPS TPMP NFO


    DJPOBSBMHVOPTEFMPTNÈTTFOUJEPT%FTEFMB#JPÏUJDB
    TFQSFHVOUBTPCSFMBDSJTJTNJTNBEFMB#JPÏUJDBBOUF
    MBHSBODBOUJEBEEFQSPCMFNBTÏUJDPTEJGÓDJMFTEFSFTPM
    WFSEFTEFMØHJDBTUSBEJDJPOBMFT&OFTFTFOUJEPTVSHFO
    QSFHVOUBT DPNP {4PO QSPCMFNBT RVF OP DPNQFUFO
    BMB#JPÏUJDB Ø{1FSUFOFDFOBPUSPTDBNQPTDPNPMB
    CJPQPMÓUJDB  {4F FODVFOUSBO FO VO DSVDF EF DBNJOPT
    OO8 EFEJGFSFOUFTEJTDJQMJOBT
    -B DPNQMFKJEBE EF MBT TPDJFEBEFT BDUVBMFT Z MB
    BHVEJ[BDJØOEFMPTQSPCMFNBTBNCJFOUBMFT EFKVTUJDJB
    TBOJUBSJB  MB QPMBSJ[BDJØO EF DSFFODJBT  MPT QSPGVOEPT
    DBNCJPTBOJWFMFEVDBUJWPZTPDJBM FOUSFNVDIBTPUSBT
    SFBMJEBEFTEFOVFTUSPUJFNQP PCMJHBOBQFOTBSOVFWBT
    GPSNBTEFBCPSEBKF OVFWBTFTUSBUFHJBTFOUSFMBTEJWFS
    6O BTVOUP JOOFHBCMF TBTDPSSJFOUFTEFQFOTBNJFOUP BEFNÈTEFUSBCBKPTJO
    UFSZUSBOTEJDJQMJOBSJP&TFTUBEJOÈNJDBQSFDJTBNFOUFMB
    FT RVF FM QSJODJQJBMJT RVFFNQJF[BBNPTUSBSMB#JPÏUJDBFOMPTÞMUJNPTB×PT
    mo, así como ha sido CVTDBS FTQBDJPT JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPT Z USBOTEJDJQMJOBSJPT
    EFNBOFSBNÈTFTUSVDUVSBEBQFOTBOEPEFNBOFSBMPDBM
    TPQPSUF EF MB ÏUJDB DPNP MB DPSSJFOUF EF MB #JPÏUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB QFSP
    NÏEJDBFJOWFTUJHBUJWB EFBMDBODFHMPCBM DPNPFOFTFODJBMPSFGFSÓB1PUUFSBM
    SFGFSJSTFBMB#JPÏUJDBQSPGVOEB
    FO MBT ÞMUJNBT EÏDB &O FTUB FEJDJØO EF MB SFWJTUB TF QSFTFOUBO EJF[ BSUÓ
    EBT UBNCJÏOTFRVF DVMPT EF FYDFMFOUF DBMJEBE JOWFTUJHBUJWB Z SFnFYJWB MPT

    EB DPSUP Z FT JNQFO DVBMFT FOTVNBZPSÓB SFCBTBOMPTMÓNJUFTEFMB#JPÏUJDB


    BOHMPTBKPOB EFQFSTQFDUJWBDMÓOJDB FJOWJUBOBJODVSTJP
    TBCMF QSFUFOEFS RVF OBSFONJSBEBTBÞOQPSDPOTPMJEBSTFFO#JPÏUJDBQFSPRVF

    MFEFTPQPSUFBUPEPT NVFTUSBOMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFUSBCBKPJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP
    1BSB TPMP DJUBS EPT EF MPT BSUÓDVMPT QVCMJDBEPT  FM
    los dilemas éticos de BSUÓDVMP EF .PEFSOJ[BDJØO 3FnFYJWB TPCSF #JPÏUJDB

    OVFTUSPUJFNQP Un punto de conjunción entre la ciencia positivista y


    la Bioética principialista  FTDSJUP QPS FM EPDUPS .JHVFM
    LPUUPX VOBBVUPSJEBENVOEJBMFO#JPÏUJDB DVZPTBQPS
    UFTFOMJCSPT BSUÓDVMPT QPOFODJBTFODPOHSFTPTJOUFS
    OBDJPOBMFT TPO IPZ TJHOJmDBUJWPT  IBCMB EF MB GPSNB
    DPNP MB #JPÏUJDB DPOUFNQPSÈOFB FT WJTUB BMUFSOBUJWB
    NFOUFVOBEJTDJQMJOBFODSJTJT PVOBÏUJDBBQMJDBEBFO
    QMFOP EFTBSSPMMP FYQBOTJWP &M EPDUPS ,PUUPX SFTBMUB
    MBGPSNBOFORVFIPZDPOUJOÞBOMBTQPMÏNJDBTBDBEÏ
    NJDBTZTPDJPMØHJDBTTPCSFTJMB#JPÏUJDBFTVODBNQP
    EFBDDJØOPVOBEJTDJQMJOBZDPNPOPIBZBDVFSEPTP
    CSF DVÈM TFB TV NÏUPEP FQJTUFNPMØHJDP  NÈT BMMÈ EF
    MBEFMJCFSBDJØO QVFTUPRVFJODMVTPDVFOUBDPOPQJOJP
    OFT RVF MF OJFHBO UPEB JNQPSUBODJB QPMÓUJDB P TPDJBM
    1BSB FM FYJTUF MB OFDFTJEBE EF JODMVJS FO TV EJOÈNJDB
    EF USBCBKP  MB EJTDVTJØO TPCSF los severos problemas

    SFWMBUJOPBNCJPFUISSN 1657-47027PMVNFONúmero 2&EJDJØOPáginas 6-9


    BIOÉTICA MÉDICA BASADA EN EVIDENCIAS / Fabio Garzón Díaz

    NOTAS

    socio-económicos de Latinoamérica. Kottow plantea  &TOFDFTBSJPBOPUBSRVFMBDSÓUJDBFOPDBTJPOFTTFUPSOBNVZ


    VOB#JPÏUJDBNÈTBMMÈEFMQSJODJQJBMJTNPRVFUFOHBFO BHVEBZTFMFTDBUBMPHBOPDPNPQSJODJQJPTTJOPTMPHBO$-06
    4&3,% (&35#  
    i"$SJUJRVFPG1SJODJQMJTNw Journal
    DVFOUBMBTEJWFSTBTJOJDJBUJWBTRVFQSPQPOFOiSFOPWBS of Medicine and Philosophy  Q FO KNQPYGPSE
    FMEJTDVSTPCJPÏUJDPEFTEFMBCJPQPMÓUJDBPEFTEFFMSP KPVSOBMTPSH BVUPSFT DPNP 1BCMP 3FRVFOB 
     TPTUJFOF
    CVTUFDJNJFOUPEFMTVKFUPJOEJWJEVBM-PTQSPCMFNBTEF RVFTJCJFOFTFYBHFSBEPEFDJSRVFMPTQSJODJQJPTWJTUPEFFTUB
    NBOFSB TPOVOTMPHBOiMPRVFTÓFTDJFSUPFTRVFMPTGBNP
    MB#JPÏUJDBTFFODVFOUSBOUBOWJODVMBEPTBMPTBTVOUPT TPT QSJODJQJPT EF MB CJPÏUJDB OP TPO FTUSJDUBNFOUF IBCMBOEP
    FDPOØNJDPT QPMÓUJDPT TPDJBMFTZUFDOPDJFOUÓmDPT RVF QSJODJQJPT EF MB SB[ØO QSÈDUJDB  TJOP JOEJDBDJPOFT OPSNBUJWBT
    TFQMBOUFBMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFVOBBVUPSFnFYJØOZMBBQMJ HFOÏSJDBTRVFTFQVFEFOVUJMJ[BSEFEJWFSTPTNPEPTQBSBKVT
    UJmDBS P SFDIB[BS BDDJPOFT RVF ZB QPS PUSBT SB[POFT TF
    DBDJØOEFMQFOTBNJFOUPDPNQMFKPw
    DPOTJEFSBOBDFSUBEBTPEFTBDFSUBEBTw3&26&/"1
     'SBODJTDP 2VFTBEB 3PESÓHVF[ TPCSF Filosofía del 
    4PCSFMBBQMJDBCJMJEBEEFMQSJODJQJBMJTNPOPS

    OO9
    $VFSQPEF+FBO-VD/BODZZ#JPÏUJDBEFMB5SBTQMBOUP  UFBNFSJDBOP 
    #JPÏUJDBXFCDPN
    MPHÓB OPTNVFTUSBRVFFOEJMFNBTBDUVBMFT UBOQVOUVB &MQSJODJQJBMJTNPFTDSJUJDBEPUBNCJÏOQPSMPTQSJO
    DJQJPT FO TJ  QPS MB GPSNB DPNP TF DPOTJEFSB FM
    MFTEFMBCJPÏUJDBFTQFDJBMDPNPFMEFMPTUSBOTQMBOUFT  BDUP NPSBM  FM TVKFUP NPSBM Z TVT WJSUVEFT 1BSB
    OPCBTUBDPOIBDFSVOBNVZCVFOBBQMJDBDJØOEFMQSJODJ VOBBNQMJBDJØOEFVOBWJTJØODSÓUJDBWFS3FRVFOB 
    QJPEFBVUPOPNÓB TPTUJFOFÏMRVFFMDVFSQPFTFMTFSEF 1 
    .PEFMPTEFCJPÏUJDBDMÓOJDB&EJDJØOVOJ
     WFSTJUBSJB4BOUB$SV[EF3PNB
    MBFYJTUFODJB QPSUBOUPEFTEFMBPOUPMPHÓBOBSSBUJWBNBT 1BSBBIPOEBSFOFTUBEJTDVTJØOWFSFOFMQSJNFSUFYUPEFDSÓ
    BMMÈEFMBUÏDOJDBEFQVSBEBZEFMBCVFOBBQMJDBDJØOEF UJDB EFM QSJODJQJBMJTNP DPNQMFUP EF $MPVTFS Z (FSU 
     Z
    QSJODJQJPTEFCFWFSTFFOFMDVFSQPMBFYQSFTJØOPOUPMØ FTDSJUPTDPNPFMEF26*/5"/"5  
    &MQSJODJQJBMJTNPZ
    MB#JPÏUJDB&OFMDVBMBVUPS"OBMJ[BMBTDVBUSPFEJDJPOFTEFM
    HJDBEFMTFSIVNBOPDPOUPEPMPRVFFMMPJNQMJDB
    UFYUPEF#FBVDIBNQZ$IJMESFTT EJTQPOJCMFFOMBXFC CJPF
    UJDBEFTEFBTUVSJBTCMPHTQPUDPN
    María Teresa Escobar López
    Doctorado en bioética
    Editora

    NOTA DEL DIRECTOR

    -B3FWJTUB-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF#JPÏUJDBGVFDSFBEBQPSJOJDJBUJWBEFMB3FDUPSÓBEFMB
    6OJWFSTJEBE.JMJUBS/VFWB(SBOBEBFOFMDPOUFYUPEFM$POHSFTP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPÏ
    UJDBDFMFCSBEPFO#PHPUÈ FOMBTJOTUBMBDJPOFTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE.JMJUBSFOOPWJFNCSF
    EF%FTEFFTFNPNFOUP FMEPDFOUFEFMFOUPODFTEFQBSUBNFOUPEFIVNBOJEB
    EFTZDPPSEJOBEPSEFCJPÏUJDB%PDUPS'BCJP(BS[ØOTFEFTFNQF×ØDPNPFEJUPSIBTUBMB
    FEJDJØOQBTBEB&OOPNCSFEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEZDPNP%FDBOPEFMB'BDVMUBEEF&EVDB
    DJØOZ)VNBOJEBEFTBHSBEF[DPBMEPDUPS(BS[ØOTVUSBCBKPFOMBSFWJTUB TFHVSPEFRVF
    TVMBCPSZDPNQSPNJTPDPOMBCJPÏUJDBFTUBSÈTJFNQSFDFSDBOPEFOVFTUSBQVCMJDBDJØO 
    TPQPSUFEFMB'BDVMUBEZFM%PDUPSBEPFO#JPÏUJDB
    *HVBMNFOUFEPZMBCJFOWFOJEBBMBOVFWBFEJUPSB EPDUPSB.BSÓB5FSFTB&TDPCBS-ØQF[ 
    PEPOUØMPHBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$PMPNCJBFTQFDJBMJTUBFOEPDFODJBVOJWFSTJUBSJB
    EFMB6OJWFSTJEBEFM#PTRVF FTQFDJBMJTUB NBHJTUFSZEPDUPSBEBFOCJPÏUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJ
    EBEFM#PTRVF QSPGFTPSBEFQMBOUB EFMB'BDVMUBEEF&EVDBDJØOZ)VNBOJEBEFT EPDFOUF
    DPNQSPNFUJEBDPOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPÏUJDBFO$PMPNCJB

    Hernando Barrios Tao


    Decano Facultad de Educación y Humanidades
    Director de la Revista Latinoamericana de Bioética

    SFWMBUJOPBNCJPFUISSN 1657-47027PMVNFONúmero 2&EJDJØOPáginas 6-9

    You might also like