You are on page 1of 3

Comparison between AM, FM and PM

Types of Modulation AM FM PM

Method of broadcasting electrical


signals that cannot travel very far on
Method of broadcasting electrical
their own. In this method, the signal
signals that cannot travel very far on A method of impressing data onto an
is imposed or 'imprinted' on a carrier
their own. In this method, the signal alternating-current (AC) waveform by
wave whose frequency increases or
is imposed or 'imprinted' on a carrier varying the instantaneous phase of
diminishes with the frequency of the
wave whose amplitude increases or the wave. This scheme can be used
Concept / Theory signal. FM transmission operates in
diminishes with the amplitude of the with analog or digital data. In analog
88 to 108 megahertz frequency band,
signal. AM transmission operates in PM, the phase of the AC signal wave,
and is less susceptible to
the 535 to 1705 kilohertz frequency also called the carrier, varies in a
electromagnetic interference than
band used for shortwave continuous manner.
amplitude modulation (AM).
broadcasting.

Modulator Circuits
This circuit uses two signal The FM modulator circuit (frequency Phase modulation is by no means a
generators to simulate an Amplitude modulation) is built with two common term. It turns out that
Modulated RF carrier wave. The varactors, are used to frequency phase modulation is more relevant in
output can be used to simulate the modulate the oscillator. The 5000 Ω the context of digital RF. In a way,
response of LC and tank circuits. potentiometer is used to bias the though, we can say that PM radio is
varactors for the best linearity. The as common as FM radio simply
Two signal generators are used in this output frequency of approximately because there is little difference
circuit, one representing a high 100 MHz can be adjusted by changing between phase modulation and
frequency (200kHz) RF carrier, VG2, the value of the inductor. frequency modulation. FM and PM
the other signal generator is used to are best considered as two closely
inject a 1KHz audio signal. The two The output frequency can vary as related variants of angle modulation,
signals are mixed and amplified by much 10 MHz on each side. The where “angle” refers to the
the transistor and an amplitude output level of the modulator is -5 modification of the quantity passed
modulated signal appears at the dBm. In this FM modulator prototype to a sine or cosine function.
collector. The DC component is the varactor bias was 7.5V for the
removed by C2 and R3 and the RF best linearity but this could be
output now appears across the load different with other varactors.
resistor R3. Waveforms below are
produced using Tina.

Resilience to noise: One particular -Phase modulation (PM) is a simple


advantage of frequency contrasted to Frequency modulation
modulation is its resilience to signal (FM).
level variations. The modulation -It is used to find out the velocity of a
is carried only as variations in target by removing Doppler data.
frequency. This needs constant carrier which is
Easy to apply modulation at a low achievable during phase modulation
power stage of the however not in FM (frequency
It is simple to implement
transmitter: Another advantage of modulation).
it can be demodulated using a circuit
frequency modulation is -The main benefit of this modulation
Advantages consisting of very few components.
associated with the transmitters. is signal modulation because it
AM receivers are very cheap as no
It is possible to use efficient RF permits computer for communicating
specialized components are needed.
amplifiers with frequency modulated on high-speed using a telephone
signals: It is possible to use non-linear system.
RF amplifiers to amplify FM -When the information is being
signals in a transmitter and these are transmitted without intrusion then
more efficient than the linear the speed rates can be observed.
ones required for signals with any -And one more advantage of PM
amplitude variations (e.g. AM and (phase modulation) is improved
SSB). immunity toward the noise.
-It is not efficient in terms of its FM has poorer spectral efficiency -Phase modulation needs two signals
power usage than some other modulation by a phase variation among them.
-It is not efficient in terms of its use formats: Some phase modulation and Through this, both the two patterns
of bandwidth, requiring a bandwidth quadrature amplitude are required like a reference as well
Disadvantages equal to twice that of the highest modulation formats have a higher as a signal.
audio frequency spectral efficiency for data This type of modulation requires
It is prone to high levels of noise transmission than frequency shift hardware which obtains more
because most noise is amplitude keying, a form of frequency complex due to its conversion
based and obviously AM detectors modulation. technique.
are sensitive to it. Requires more complicated Phase ambiguity arrives if we exceed
demodulator: One of the minors index pi radian of modulation (1800).
disadvantages of frequency Phase modulation index can be
modulation are that the demodulator enhanced by employing frequency
is a little more complicated, and multiplier.
hence slightly more expensive than
the very simple diode detectors used
for AM.
-FM signals are used in technology
such as radars, telemeters, EEG, radio
broadcasting, satellite
Transmitting radio waves and is an
communication and magnetic tape-
integral element of many digital
recording systems.
transmission coding schemes that
-Frequency modulation can be used
support an ample range of wireless
-Broadcast transmissions for the broadcasting of FM radio. This
technologies such as GSM, Satellite
-Air band radio helps in larger signal to noise ratio.
Applications television, and Wi-Fi. Phase
-Single sideband -Telemetry, radar and seismic
modulation is used in digital
-Quadrature amplitude modulation prospecting, EEG monitoring of
synthesizers for generating waveform
newborns etc. also use the technique
and signal PM is used for signal and
of frequency modulation.
waveform generation in digital
-It is also used in music synthesis,
synthesizers.
some systems that use video-
transmission and for magnetic tape-
recording systems.
Refences:

https://www.google.com/search?q=phase+modulation&oq=phase+modulation&aqs=chrome..69i57.3479j0j4&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8

https://www.slideshare.net/vaanipathak/am-fm-pm

https://www.bharathuniv.ac.in/colleges1/downloads/biomed/AM,%20PM%20and%20FM%20modulation%20-%20Gomathi.pdf

http://www.zen22142.zen.co.uk/spice/ammod.htm

http://www.sattvengg.com/2016/08/what-is-modulation-am-fm-and-pm.html

https://www.electroschematics.com/889/fm-modulator/

You might also like