You are on page 1of 75

STI- College Global City

1
Senior High School
Chapter 1

THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND

Introduction

Electricity is the presence and flow of electric charge. Using electricity we

can transfer energy in ways that allow us to accomplish common chores.[1] Its

best-known form is the flow of electrons through conductors such as copper wires.

The word "electricity" is sometimes used to mean "electrical energy". They

are not the same thing - electricity is a transmission medium for electrical energy,

like sea water is a transmission medium for wave energy. An item which allows

electricity to move through it is called a conductor. Copper wires and other metal

items are good conductors, allowing electricity to move through them and transmit

electrical energy. Plastic is a bad conductor, also called an insulator, which does

not allow much electricity to move through it so will stop transmission of electrical

energy.

Transmission of electrical energy can occur naturally (as in lightning), or be

produced (as in a generator). It is a form of energy which we use to power

machines and electrical devices. When electrical charges are not moving,

electricity is called static electricity. When the charges are moving they are an

electric current, sometimes called 'dynamic electricity'. Lightning is the most


STI- College Global City
2
Senior High School
known - and dangerous - kind of electric current in nature, but sometimes static

electricity causes things to stick together.

Electricity can be dangerous, especially around water because water is a

form of good conductor as it has impurities like salt in it. Since the nineteenth

century, electricity has been used in every part of our lives. Until then, it was just a

curiosity seen in the lightning of a thunderstorm.

Background of the Study

The idea of perpetual motion machine appears for the first time in the east

and to be exact in the 12th century A.D in India. In ancient Greece and in Rome,

but also during the later Antiquity it hasn’t been reported a perpetual motion

machine not even as a theoretical version. In the bibliography of Middle Ages and

renaissance the perpetual motion machines are reffered as: Perpetuum mobile

naturae and perpetuum mobile physicae. Perpetual Motion Machine, There is a

scientific consensus that perpetual motion in an isolated system violates either the

first law of thermodynamics, the second law of thermodynamics, or both. The first

law of thermodynamics is a version of the law of conservation of energy. The

second law can be phrased in several different ways, the most intuitive of which is

that heat flows spontaneously from hotter to colder places; relevant here is that

the law observes that in every macroscopic process, there is friction or something
STI- College Global City
3
Senior High School
close to it; another statement is that no heat engine (an engine which produces

work while moving heat from a high temperature to a low temperature) can be

more efficient than a Carnot heat engine operating between the same two

temperatures. A perpetual motion machine of the first kind produces work without

the input of energy. It thus violates the first law of thermodynamics: the law of

conservation of energy.

A perpetual motion machine of the second kind is a machine which spontaneously

converts thermal energy into mechanical work. When the thermal energy is

equivalent to the work done, this does not violate the law of conservation of

energy. However, it does violate the more subtle second law of thermodynamics

(see also entropy). The signature of a perpetual motion machine of the second

kind is that there is only one heat reservoir involved, which is being spontaneously

cooled without involving a transfer of heat to a cooler reservoir. This conversion of

heat into useful work, without any side effect, is impossible, according to the

second law of thermodynamics.

A perpetual motion machine of the third kind is usually (but not always) [self-

published source] defined as one that completely eliminates friction and other

dissipative forces, to maintain motion forever (due to its mass inertia). (Third in

this case refers solely to the position in the above classification scheme, not the

third law of thermodynamics.) It is impossible to make such a machine, as

dissipation can never be completely eliminated in a mechanical system, no matter


STI- College Global City
4
Senior High School
how close a system gets to this ideal (see examples in the Low Friction section).

Some common ideas recur repeatedly in perpetual motion machine designs.

Many ideas that continue to appear today were stated as early as 1670 by John

Wilkins, Bishop of Chester and an official of the Royal Society. He outlined three

potential sources of power for a perpetual motion machine, "Chymical [sic]

Extractions", "Magnetical Virtues" and "the Natural Affection of Gravity".[1]

The seemingly mysterious ability of magnets to influence motion at a distance

without any apparent energy source has long appealed to inventors. One of the

earliest examples of a magnetic motor was proposed by Wilkins and has been

widely copied since: it consists of a ramp with a magnet at the top, which pulled a

metal ball up the ramp. Near the magnet was a small hole that was supposed to

allow the ball to drop under the ramp and return to the bottom, where a flap

allowed it to return to the top again. The device simply could not work. Faced with

this problem, more modern versions typically use a series of ramps and magnets,

positioned so the ball is to be handed off from one magnet to another as it moves.

The problem remains the same.

Perpetuum Mobile of Villard de Honnecourt (about 1230).

The "Overbalanced Wheel".


STI- College Global City
5
Senior High School
Gravity also acts at a distance, without an apparent energy source, but to get

energy out of a gravitational field (for instance, by dropping a heavy object,

producing kinetic energy as it falls) one has to put energy in (for instance, by lifting

the object up), and some energy is always dissipated in the process. A typical

application of gravity in a perpetual motion machine is Bhaskara's wheel in the

12th century, whose key idea is itself a recurring theme, often called the

overbalanced wheel: moving weights are attached to a wheel in such a way that

they fall to a position further from the wheel's center for one half of the wheel's

rotation, and closer to the center for the other half. Since weights further from the

center apply a greater torque, it was thought that the wheel would rotate for ever.

However, since the side with weights further from the center has fewer weights

than the other side, at that moment, the torque is balanced and perpetual

movement is not achieved.[24] The moving weights may be hammers on pivoted

arms, or rolling balls, or mercury in tubes; the principle is the same.

Perpetual motion wheels from a drawing of Leonardo da Vinci.

Another theoretical machine involves a frictionless environment for motion. This

involves the use of diamagnetic or electromagnetic levitation to float an object.

This is done in a vacuum to eliminate air friction and friction from an axle. The

levitated object is then free to rotate around its center of gravity without

interference. However, this machine has no practical purpose because the rotated

object cannot do any work as work requires the levitated object to cause motion in
STI- College Global City
6
Senior High School
other objects, bringing friction into the problem. Furthermore, a perfect vacuum is

an unattainable goal since both the container and the object itself would slowly

vaporize, thereby degrading the vacuum.

Theoretical Framework

This study is anchored on the Customer Service Skills Model (2013) which

delineates the 3 skills, namely: customer focus, personal characteristics and

customer service challenge.

Figure 1. Customer Service Skills (Fornell and Rust 2012)

These skills are the typical ones that drive excellent customer service. An

organization primarily deals with customers start to finish, should embody these

skills for an optimal output (Fornell and Rust, 2012).


STI- College Global City
7
Senior High School
Customer service skills of frontline employees is considered as an integral

part of any facet of industry and it defines the future of any organization. The rapid

advances in technology based systems related to internet are leading to

fundamental ways in how different organizations interact. This applies to the

relation of an organization with its customer (Hong et al., 2007).

Conceptual Framework

Using the foregoing Theoretical Framework, the researcher came up with

the following Research Paradigm (Figure 2) which underscores the Input-

Process- Output (IPO) framework.

INPUT
The customer service PROCES
skills of the sales
representative as
S
assessed by two Administration of
researcher-made
groups of respondents
survey questionnaires
classified as sales
representatives itself Use of statistical tools
and their supervisors. and treatment

Analysis and
Interpretation

OUTPUT
Employee
Training
Program
STI- College Global City
8
Senior High School

Figure 2. Research Paradigm

Figure 2 shows the Input-Process-Output (IPO) Framework in describing

the flow of this study. The Input Box contains the study variables- Profile of the

respondents in terms of age, gender, highest educational attainment, job

classification, and length of service.

This study also determined the customer service skills of the sales

representative as assessed by two groups of respondents classified as sales

representatives itself and their supervisors. These make up the Input Box.

The Process Box explains how the gathered data are processed-

administration of survey tool/ instrument to target respondents, tally and coding of

data, and use of statistical tools and techniques. And finally, the Output Box

engages how these data were used to provide an enhanced employee training

program.

Statement of the Problem


STI- College Global City
9
Senior High School
The customer service skills of the sales representatives at Arrow

Electronics Asia- Singapore Proprietary Limited were assessed by its supervisors

and sales representatives. The results were made integral in providing an

employee training program to improve the customer service skills of its

representatives.

Specifically, the following questions were answered:

1. What is the profile of the two groups of respondents as to:

1.1. age;

1.2. gender;

1.3. educational background;

1.4. job classification; and

1.5. length of service?

2. How do the two groups of respondents assess the customer service skills of

the sales representatives in terms of:

2.1. Customer focus;

2.2. Personal Characteristics; and

2.3. Customer service challenges?

3. How significant are the differences in the assessments of the two groups of

respondents on the customer service skills of the sales representatives?


STI- College Global City
10
Senior High School
4. Based on the results of the study, what employee training program to improve

the customer service skills of the sales representatives can be offered?

Hypothesis

1. There is no significant difference in the assessments of the two groups of

respondents on the customer service skills of the sales representatives.

Scope and Limitations of the Study

Perpetual Motion Generator, a product so simple yet so helpful in reducing

our electricity bills. This product can create Energy, or so we called, Electrical

energy, for it uses a ‘DC motor’. We decided to Re-create this product and

improve it. This product (Perpetual Motion Generator) can give free electricity to

the people. Though it may seem that it is impossible , it creates free energy that

will last a very long time. The product has no energy source. Though this product

can violate 2 laws of thermodynamics. according to the 1st law of

thermodynamics ( Conservation ) , it states that “energy can not be created nor

destroyed in an isolated system” . The 2nd Law of thermodynamics states that “

the entropy of any isolated system always increases” . Products like this are
STI- College Global City
11
Senior High School
impossible but we aim to test it out and succeed it. Imagine building a life size

Perpetual motion generator, it can replace the wind mills . It can power a whole

town when it is fast enough. The greater the speed , the greater the voltage. The

spin can be stop if another strong force try to stop it.

Significance of the Study

This study will benefit the following sectors:

Arrow Electronics Asia-Singapore Proprietary Limited. This study will

provide guidelines to the company on how they can improve customer service

specifically for the sales representative. This will also serve as a tool to test the

current effectiveness of the company’s customer-focused programs and provide a

long-term plan across with respect to an improved pre and post customer

satisfaction strategies.

Business Entities. This study will serve as a reference for all business

entities engaged in customer service or any business that involves customer

interaction. This will also help companies in training their employees especially

front liners who have direct contact with customers.

Customer Service Practitioners. This study will guide customer service

practitioners in dealing with different types of customers the best way possible.

They will be able to carry out the expected output of their profession through the

findings of this study by assessing their strategies in conducting customer-based

transactions.
STI- College Global City
12
Senior High School
Future Researchers. This study will provide baseline information that

could be beneficial in the future research for students who desire to conduct a

study of similar topic. The result may serve as a related study to connect the gap

that may left unresolved. While this particular study may have certain

inadequacies, at least, this may give insights and encouragement to undertake a

validation and follow up study.

Definition of Terms

The following terminologies were conceptually and/or operationally defined

for better understanding of this research.

Customer Focus. This refers to creating and instilling a culture of

customer service in which employees are encouraged and expected to go to great

lengths to satisfy customers. Further, high-performing organizations work to

create an environment where employees focus on customer satisfaction in each

encounter, every day.

Customer Service Challenges. This entails the difficulties, challenges,

and problems being faced or encountered by the representatives. Moreover, this

also pertains to hindrances that the employees encounter in the delivery of a

service or product.

Customer Service Skills. Customer service skills are actions of

employees that make sure customers are happy and satisfied. If customers are
STI- College Global City
13
Senior High School
not happy and satisfied with the service they receive, they will go to another

organization. Therefore, it is vital for an organization’s success that their

customers’ needs and expectations are met.

Personal Characteristics. These are attributes that are personal to the

employees which defines the kind of service delivery to the customers.

Training Program. It is a plan of action that will be adopted to enhance the

customer service delivery of the sales representatives which is based on the

issues, problems and concerns found in this study.


STI- College Global City
14
Senior High School

Chapter 2

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES

The following literature and studies, both foreign and local, focused on the

customer service skills. The same provided a clear roadmap, strengthened,

supported, gave credence, and corroborated with the variables mentioned and

were made integral part in this study.

Foreign Literature

Foreign Studies

S. Elangos describes the Bhakaras‟s wheel which invented by

mathematician bhaskara II in 1150 The machine rotates at full speed because the

mercury is at the one side of the wheel nearer the axis and farther from the other

side. Which rotates the wheel, thus produced rotary motion. The energy produced

by the perpetual motion of uniformly. Hence, we may tap the energy from the

rotary motion to our convenient transformation of energy.


STI- College Global City
15
Senior High School
Muhamad Amin has research says Claims of “Free Energy” generation

using Perpetual Motion Machines (PMM) are usually discounted by the scientific

community since PMMs are considered impossible, as a direct corollary of the

Law of Conservation of Energy. However for the scientifically inquisitive mind, the

urge to distill reasons which make some systems appear as PMMs, remains a

factor. Recently a system on permanent magnets has been observed by

the author, whose designer claimed that his system can provide „free energy‟.

In 1981 Nikola Tesla Serbian-American inventor make the actual perpetual

motion machine name as a Tesla Device which rotates on the basis of magnets.

Tesla use the repulsion power of the magnets for rotation of the wheel. Rotary

element has compounded by the stationary casing .Most advantage of this device

is that it rotates continuously till external casing has removed. This stationary

casing and rotating element consist of a magnet which repulse and rotor has

rotates. It requires fix size for its working and rotates vertically. vertical direction

makes it slow and inefficient to rotate with carrying the load of another instrument.

The water fuel cell is a purported perpetual motion machine invented by

American Stanley Allen Meyer (August 24, 1940 – March 21, 1998). He claimed

that an automobile retrofitted with the device could use water as fuel as a

substitute of gasoline. The fuel cell supposedly split water into its component

elements, hydrogen and oxygen. The hydrogen was then burned to generate
STI- College Global City
16
Senior High School
energy, a process that reconstituted the water molecules. According to Meyer, the

device required less energy to perform electrolysis than the minimum energy

requirement predicted or measured by conventional science. If the device worked

as specified, it would violate both the first and second laws of thermodynamics,

allowing operation as a perpetual motion machine. Meyer’s claims about his

“Water Fuel Cell” and the car that it powered were found to be fraudulent by an

Ohio court in 1996.

Local Literature

A study conducted by Lazaro (2012), focused on the relationship between

adversity quotient and performance level measured by the 360-degree feedback system

among selected middle managers in the different departments of the City of Manila.

Specifically, the researcher tested if there was a significant relationship between the

respondents’ profile variables such as age, gender, civil status, and length of service on the

adversity quotient and performance level revealed by the 330-degree feedback system.

Likewise, differences among the ratings given by the different raters of the 360-degree

feedback system were also explored.

Another study undertaken by Lugtu (2010) was to identify the significant

relationship of Adversity Quotient and Personality-Temperament Traits of the

Specific Weapon and Tactics (SWAT) Police Manila. The Findings of the study led

the researcher to come up with the following conclusions: 1) Most of the Special
STI- College Global City
17
Senior High School
Weapons and Tactics Police (SWAT) Police of Manila are in the adulthood level in

human development, are middle-born children, are from average family size, and

are from middle class families. Additionally, majority the SWAT respondents were

on the Police Officer ranks and have been in the Police Service for eleven to

sixteen years. 2) Generally, the respondents have an average level of Adversity

Quotient characterized by being able to significantly navigate life, and thus may

suffer unnecessarily due to life’s frustrations and challenges.

Moreover, the SWAT respondents were found to have average level of the

four dimensions of AQ namely; Control, Origin and Ownership, Reach, and

Endurance. This signifies that most of our SWAT Police are competent and

unbiased enough to do their respective jobs. Majority of the SWAT respondents

have fairly non-discriminatory and unbiased personality patters as revealed by the

Guildford-Zimmerman Temperament Survey. Most of them manifest an average

level of Sociability, Emotional Stability, Thoughtfulness, and Masculinity. In

addition, the respondents were found to have an above average level of General

Activity, Restraint, Ascendance, Objectivity, Friendliness, and Personal Relations.

The existence of non-significance between the levels of Adversity Quotient

to the demographic characteristics to the respondents signifies that the

development of Adversity Quotient is not partial in terms of one’s demographics.

This implies that other factors should be considered in developing one’s level of

AQ. In addition, the existence of non-significance between the Personality-


STI- College Global City
18
Senior High School
Temperament Traits of the respondents to several demographic characteristics

signifies little influence in such.

However, factors like birth order, social experiences, and age might have

little influence in the developmental change in one’s personality. The existence of

non-significance between Adversity Quotient and Personality-Temperament Traits

of the respondents signifies that certain personality traits do not influence the

development of AQ and AQ to personality traits for this group of respondents.

However, Trait Ascendance and Trait Sociability are factors to look into in terms of

the development of AQ and vice versa. By identifying the level of AQ and

personality types of the possible Police candidate, will help the recruitment and

selection unit of SWAT in identifying the right person for the SWAT job. This could

avoid job mismatch and possible future problems in employee performance.

Other related study is by Antwi (2014), the central problem of his study was

to determine the relationship of work attitude, reward systems and personality of

workers to the job performance and motivation. The study is focused on the

following work attitudes: job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and job

involvement. Reward system is composed of extrinsic and intrinsic rewards, while

personality focused only on extroversion and introversion. This study is

quantitative descriptive-correlational in nature.

To get the factual information from the respondents and to determine the

relationship of work attitude, reward system and personality to job performance

and motivation, data were gathered using questionnaire. Based on the hypothesis
STI- College Global City
19
Senior High School
and the findings of this study, it can be concluded that job satisfaction,

organizational commitment, job involvement, reward systems, and personality

correlates with job performance and motivation.

Intrinsic rewards tend to influence job performance and motivation greater

than extrinsic reward. This is because workers were found not to be so dependent

on the rewards offered by the institution, but on their ability to reward themselves.

Age, gender, marital status and work category makes a significant difference in

job performance. Those who tend to perform better are older, male, married and

faculty respondents. The male faculty is the ones who are motivated. Those who

are likely to perform well in the job are the ones who are satisfied, involved,

faculty, male, and have the ability to reward themselves, by having a sense an

accomplishment, fulfillment and security etc. Job satisfaction, intrinsic reward,

being faculty and personality predicts motivation.

The study of De La Cruz (2013) aims to determine the job performance and

job satisfaction of PNP personnel. This study also aims to establish some

personality factor, the educational background and experience correlates with job

performance and job satisfaction. This study was based on the premise that the

factors that contribute to job performance and job satisfaction are educational

attainment, experience, work attitude, emotional maturity, social maturity and

interpersonal relationships.

This study focused on the job satisfaction and performance of the police

officers. The scope of the study was the job satisfaction of PNP officers and their
STI- College Global City
20
Senior High School
correlates. The study was limited to the police officers of 29 municipalities and 3

cities of Nueva Ecija. The study was limited to the calendar year 1997-1998. The

study was also limited to the descriptive method of research and the instruments

used. All the instruments used in the study were presented to the thesis

committee during the thesis proposal defense.

The instruments used in the study, namely emotional maturity scale and

interpersonal skills, which were developed by the researcher were subjected to a

dry-run. Fifty police officers who were not part of the sample were used in the dry-

run to determine the reliability of the instrument. The results of this dry-run were

used to improve the final draft of the instrument. The other instruments used

which had been adapted from the studies were not subjected to a dry-run

anymore since they were already found to be reliable and valid. Based on the

findings at the study, the following conclusions are made: Majority of the police

officers are college graduates, with long years of experience as police officers,

and had been in their present rank for a number of years. Majority of police

officers are satisfied with their job. Most of the police officers have a job

performance rating that is very satisfactory.

There is a significant correlation between job performance and educational

attainment, training, number of years in present rank, but is not significantly

correlated to the number of years as police officers, work attitude, emotional

maturity, social maturity and interpersonal relationships. There is a significant

relationship between job satisfaction and the following variables: educational


STI- College Global City
21
Senior High School
attainment, training, number of years as police officers, number of years in

present rank, work attitude, emotional maturity, social maturity and interpersonal

relationship.

Local Studies

Organizational structures of manufacturing companies are currently subject

to major change (Magpantay, 2011). Many capital goods manufacturing

companies have changed their organizational structures in order to become more

responsive to customer needs or to expand into the service business.

In this context, researchers have questioned whether classical product-

focused and geographically-focused organizational forms are still adequate

(Ibanez et al., 2010). Tulli et al. (2007), for example, argued that companies still

tend to have a product-centric view of organizational structures, whereas

customers tend to focus on the relational processes with their suppliers. Often,

manufacturers existing organizational structures do not actively support the

setting up of such relational processes with customers. Such relational processes

concentrate on value creation and increasingly focus on bundles including capital

goods and services, rather than only supplying the product.

As a result, companies are not only extending their total offering towards

integrated solutions that combine products and services to customer specific

solutions; they are also jeopardizing their existing organizational structures. In this
STI- College Global City
22
Senior High School
context, jeopardizing means that companies are looking for more service-focused

and customer-focused organizational structures.

Broga (2015) argued that integrating product and service organizations is a

determinant of success for the development of business-to-business services and

for moving towards a more customer-centric organizational approach. Whether a

capital goods manufacturer should integrate or separate its product and service

organizations depends on the service strategy the company has chosen to use in

order to move into the integrated solutions business.

In order to gain a better understanding of whether it should integrate or

separate its service organization, a company should consider detailed

organizational functions (R&D, manufacturing, sales, marketing, human

resources, etc.) associated with single strategic business units (SBUs), rather

than having the change take place at the overall level of the organization (Auguste

et al., 2016).

Furthermore, Hanag et al. (2010) argued that companies that are

structured with multiple product-focused and service-focused SBUs tend to move

toward customer-focused SBUs. However, despite the increasing number of

academic contributions that examine customer focused and service-focused

organizational structures, they are rarely linked to each other. Given the

interrelated nature of customer and service orientations in the organizational

structure, there is a clear need for systematic research into the common patterns

that underlie the organizational changes. Against this background, this article
STI- College Global City
23
Senior High School
focuses on three primary objectives. Firstly, it looks for common patterns in the

organizational structure when increasing the service orientation. Secondly, it

seeks common themes underlying various aspects of customer orientation in the

organizational structure. Thirdly, the article explores the interrelatedness of

customer and service orientations in the organizational structure.

As explained at the start of this paper, the study makes three main

contributions to the existing research. Firstly, the descriptions of the four patterns

of changes in the potential organizational structures are considered to enlighten

the existing discussion on changes in organizational structures towards a service

orientation.

The increasing importance of service orientation follows Nayo’s (2015)

argumentation that companies should integrate services into the product

organization, as opposed the argument that companies should set up a distinctive

service organization. The creation of a separate organization to handle the service

offering is a determinant of success.

However, Kalledo’s (2013) definition of a separate service organization

might also include what we call emphasizing a service orientation by setting up

service management functions within product SBUs. Although the finding of the

study of Pagalunan (2015) could not be fully supported by the second part of their

argumentation that these newly created units had a dedicated sales force. In the

case of pattern 1, there is no dedicated sales force selling service products.

Specific sales channels and forces for services are only established for pattern 2,
STI- College Global City
24
Senior High School
with a distinctive service SBU. In addition, the findings for patterns 1 and 2

reinforce Nayo’s (2015) argumentation for increasing the importance of

collaborations between organizational units. Pattern 1 requires intra-business unit

collaboration across organizational functions that are responsible for products and

services.

Furthermore, despite the increasing need to manage major customers

through customer-focused SBUs, the needs of many smaller customers can often

be met adequately through product and service SBUs. Thirdly, and most

importantly, the findings link the relatively independent discussions of service and

customer orientations in the context of organizational structures. The four patterns

provide a better understanding of how capital goods manufacturers integrate

increased customer and service focuses within their organizational structures. The

results suggest that managers and researchers should consider that movements

towards service-focused and customer-focused organizational structures are

interrelated (Rustica, 2015).

Zarate (2016) stated that there are simple structural changes in the

organization or replacements of people in particular location that may have

consequences that others promote or hinder changes in attitude and performance

change can alter cultural values, personal values, attitudes and feelings of

individuals within the work environment. Work changes operate through each

employee’s attitudes and feelings towards change. What is important in adjusting


STI- College Global City
25
Senior High School
to change in the bringing about of specific changes through the development of

new attitudes value and/or behavior, either through identification or internalization,

Synthesis

In Synthesis, the three components of Customer Service- Customer Focus,

Personal Characteristics, and Customer Service Challenges were highlighted by

the following reviewed literature and studies.

Customer issues or problems should be addressed outright. This is

emphasized in Spreng (2016) that the same is essential to Customer loyalty and

satisfaction that proved to be the major determinant for long term survival and

financial performance of the company.

Further, anent to addressing customer’s issues or problems, are answers

provided by Anderson et. al. (2013) who states that companies need to develop

an environment inside the organization that is more prone towards meeting

service quality standards according to the customer requirements.

On a careful inspection of the dimensions of quality, a major focus rests on

the component of human interaction in the service delivery that consists of human

behavior and attitudes. The foregoing findings engages Looy et al (2013) who
STI- College Global City
26
Senior High School
emphasizes that customers are not one dimensional in judgment, because a lot of

other factors influence service quality, most researchers agree on these

dimensions of service quality as a measure of service quality.

Stress, as mentioned this review, points to the definition of Lee (2016)

which refers to resilience as a person’s capacity to handle difficulties, demands,

and high pressure without becoming stressed. Resilient people are the one you

can count on to come through when the stakes are high. Resilient people respond

resourcefully to change. Rather than fight change and hang on to old, outdated

ways, they respond to change with confidence and flexibility. This is typically the

quality of resilient people think of when they hear the term. The more resilient

people are, the more quickly they’re able to recover from a setback, make the

best of the new situation, and become a “new and improved” version of

themselves because of it.

Finally, the ability of the employee to deal with the customer’s emotional

charge is described by Zarate (2016) as fight or clash, when people disagree,

because they see a situation differently. Differences in perception are due to

differences in needs, values, personality, preferences and interests, orientation,

education or training, or background experiences. Conflicts normally occur

between sales and marketing, marketing finance, marketing and manufacturing,

production and quality control, and etc.; It is important to practice professionalism

in handling conflict situation.


STI- College Global City
27
Senior High School
STI- College Global City
28
Senior High School
Chapter 3

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

This chapter discusses the methods and procedures used in this study, the

procedure of how the study is investigated; tools use to gather the data as well as

the statistical treatment employed.

Research Methods Used

This study used the descriptive research method due to the

appropriateness to the problem. The researcher assessed the customer service

skills of the sales representatives at Arrow Electronics Asia- Singapore

Proprietary Limited for the purpose of having a reference on employee training

program.

Descriptive research is a type of research that describes what exists in a

current situation and may help to uncover new facts and meaning through

observation, description and documentation of the situation as it normally occurs

(Polit & Hungler 1999). This involves the collection of data that will provide an

account or description of individuals, groups or situations.


STI- College Global City
29
Senior High School

Respondents of the Study

The respondents of the study included the sales representative of Arrow

Electronics Asia-Singapore Proprietary Limited and their supervisors. Below is the

distribution of the respondents of the study.

Table 1

Distribution of Respondents as to Age

Sales
Supervisors Representatives
Category Frequency Percent Frequency Percent
26 to 30 0 - 5 16.7
31 to 35 0 - 3 10.0
36 to 40 0 - 19 63.3
41 to 45 10 55.6 2 6.7
46 and above 8 44.4 1 3.3
Total 18 100.0 30 100.0

The Table above enumerates the age of the two groups of respondents.

Most (f= 10, 55.6 percent) of the supervisor- respondents are already in their early

40’s (between 41 and 45 years old), while the others (f= 8, 44.4 percent) are

already seniors (46 years old and above). On the other hand, majority (f= 19, 63.3

percent) are in their late 30’s (between 36 and 40 years old), and few (f= 5, 16.7
STI- College Global City
30
Senior High School
percent) are still young or those within the 26 and 30 year- old bracket. This data

infers that the employees are just in the right age and position like other business

industries.

Table 2

Distribution of Respondents as to Sex

Sales
Supervisors Representatives
Category Frequency Percent Frequency Percent
Male 5 27.8 7 23.3
Female 13 72.2 23 76.7
Total 18 100.0 30 100.0

The sex of the respondents is presented in Table 2. The female supervisor

and sales representative- respondents are mostly (f= 13 supervisors, 23 sales

representatives) females. This data proves that females are most preferred in jobs

that require interaction with the clients/ customers; as females are thought to be

more accommodating and patient than their male counterparts.


STI- College Global City
31
Senior High School

Table 3

Distribution of Respondents as to Highest Educational Attainment

Sales
Supervisors Representatives
Category Frequency Percent Frequency Percent
technical/
vocational 0 - 5 16.7
bachelor’s 3 16.7 22 73.3
master’s degree 15 83.3 3 10.0
Total 18 100.0 30 100.0

The highest educational attainment of the respondents is reflected in the

foregoing table. Almost all (f= 15, 83.3 percent) of the supervisor- respondents

have completed a master’s degree; while 22 or 73.3 percent of the sales

representative- respondents have at least a bachelor’s degree, and three or 10.0

percent have managed to finish an advanced study. This information indicates

that Arrow, Limited has high regard for education that may be reflected in their

criteria for promotions.


STI- College Global City
32
Senior High School

Table 4

Distribution of Respondents as to Job Classification

Sales
Supervisors Representatives
Category Frequency Percent Frequency Percent
frontline 4 22.2 22 73.3
support 12 66.7 5 16.7
after- sales 2 11.1 3 10.0
Total 18 100.0 30 100.0

Table 4 shows the job classification of the respondents in the Customer

Service Department of Arrow, Limited. A substantial number (f= 12, 66.7 percent)

of the supervisor- respondents are assigned as Support; four (f= 4, 22.2 percent)

are supervising the Frontline operations, and two or 11.1 percent are taking- care

of the After- Sales. The sales representative- respondents however, are mostly (f=

22, 73.3 percent) are in the Frontline office of the Customer Service Department

of Arrow, Limited, while a few (f= 5 and 3; 16.7 and 10.0 percent) are assigned in

Support and After- Sales. This infers that the Customer Service Department of the
STI- College Global City
33
Senior High School
company invests heavily in frontline service or ensuring the best experience for

their clients.

Table 5

Distribution of Respondents as to Length of Service

Sales
Supervisors Representatives
Category Frequency Percent Frequency Percent
2 to 4 years 0 - 3 10.0
5 to 7 years 0 - 15 50.0
8 to 10 years 3 16.7 12 40.0
11 years and
above 15 83.3 0 -
Total 18 100.0 30 100.0

Table 5 engages the Length of Service of the respondents. Majority (f= 15,

83.3 percent) of the supervisor- respondents have been working with Arrow,

Limited for more than 11 years; while three or 16.7 percent for more than 8 but

less than 10 years. The sales representative- respondents on the other hand, are

mostly 5 to 7 years’ (f= 15, 50.0 percent) length of service; while a substantial

number (f=12, 40.0 percent) for at least 8 to 10 years. This information indicates

that the company may have a low attrition rate.


STI- College Global City
34
Senior High School

Sampling Technique

Best and Khan (1993:13) defines a population as a ‘group of individuals

that have one or more characteristics in common that are of interest to the

researchers’. The population is a ‘group of people who are the focus of a

research study and to which the results would apply (Cardwell 1999: 179). Thus,

the population is the group to which the researcher would like to make references.

Purposive sampling technique was used in this study. A purposive sample

is a non-probability sample that is selected based on characteristics of a

population and the objective of the study. This type of sampling can be very useful

in situations when you need to reach a targeted sample quickly, and where

sampling for proportionality is not the main concern. Purposive sampling method

may prove to be effective when only limited numbers of people can serve as

primary data sources due to the nature of research design and aims and

objectives.
STI- College Global City
35
Senior High School
Instrumentation

The research instrument is based on the standardized instruments of the

Customer Service Model Questionnaire which is divided into 3 components that

effectively measures the skills of the said target respondents.

The instrument is tailor-fitted by the researcher to gather the profiles of the

respondents that are deemed necessary. The parts in the said instrument

followed the same sequence as the specific questions posed in Chapter 1.

Data Gathering Procedures

A letter was sent to the head of operations of the Customer Service

Department of Arrow Electronics Asia-Singapore Proprietary Limited. Upon

approval, the researcher facilitated the survey questionnaire to the employees of

the said department. Afterwards, the gathered data were organized, tallied,

analyzed and interpreted.

Statistical Treatment of Data

The frequency distribution, percentage, weighted mean, T-test were the

statistical tools used in the study through the Statistical Package for Social

Science (SPSS) version 20.0.


STI- College Global City
36
Senior High School
Frequency Distribution (f). This tool was used to facilitate the tallying and

counting of frequencies falling under the profile categories.

Percentage (%). This tool was used to find out the part of the whole

respondents’ assessment based on the frequency/tally gathered. The following

formula was used to determine the same based on the variables determined.

----------------------- x 100 = Percentage

Where:
f = Frequency
N = Total Population
100 = constant

Weighted Mean (WM). This was used to determine the Customer Service

Skills of the Sales Representatives at Arrow, Limited. The Weighted Mean was

computed using the formula:

TWF

WM = -------------------------

Where:
WM = Weighted Mean
TWF = Total Weighted Frequency
N = Total Population
STI- College Global City
37
Senior High School

T-Test of Two (2) Independent Samples. Is a two-sample t-test that

examines whether two samples are different and is commonly used when the

variances of two normal distributions are unknown. This test determined the

significant differences in the assessments of the two groups of respondents. The

following formula was employed:

Where:

𝑥̅ 1 = mean of sample 1
𝑥̅ 2 = mean of sample 2
n1 = number of subjects in sample 2
s12 = variance of sample 1
s22 = variance of sample 2

Arbitrary Scale of Values

To determine the customer service skills of the sales representatives of

Arrow Electronics Asia- Singapore, a four-point Likert scale were used that

determined the perception of the two groups of respondents. The following rating

and verbal interpretation used is presented below:

Score Verbal Interpretation Description


STI- College Global City
38
Senior High School
4 Strong (S) This describes the sales
representative possessing the all
the skill or most of the time

3 Moderate (M) This describes the sales


representative to be possessing
the skill partly or some of the time

2 Improvement This describes the sales


Opportunity representative as possessing the
skill very little or not at all

1 Not Applicable (N/A) Not applicable to the sales


representative at this time
STI- College Global City
39
Senior High School

Chapter 4

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS, AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA

This Chapter presents the analysis and interpretation of data pertaining to

the customer service skills of the sales representatives at Arrow Electronics Asia-

Singapore Proprietary Limited.

Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives

Table 6
Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives in terms of Customer
Focus
Sales
Supervisors
Indicator Reps. TWM VI
WM VI WM VI
The Sales Representative…
shows strong commitment to provide our customers
1 M S M
with excellent service. 2.52 3.67 3.10
believes that our customers are important to us, our
2 M S M
department, our agency, and the State in general. 2.58 3.27 2.93
feels that we know and understand what excellent
3 M M M
customer service is. 2.90 2.89 2.90
has a good understanding of what our customers expect
4 M M M
and require 2.67 3.00 2.84
believes that their job providing customer service is
5 M M M
very important, and they understand why. 2.54 3.25 2.90
understands that they are the primary person who will
6 be working with the customers to solve their problem or M M M
2.89 2.57 2.73
answer their questions.
believes that they are members of a team of
7 representatives in their unit who work together on M M M
2.99 2.98 2.99
behalf of our customers.
STI- College Global City
40
Senior High School
knows that the company has a process in place in the
8 event that they don’t have an answer or ready solution, IO IO IO
2.40 2.43 2.42
and they’ll use it.
sees that they are responsible to see that our
9 customers' issues or problems are addressed whether IO M M
2.46 2.69 2.58
or not they are the one with the answer.
wants to deal with our customers' issues correctly the
10 M M M
first time they deal with them. 2.55 2.59 2.57
M M M
Overall Mean 2.65 2.93 2.79
Legend: 3.26- 4.00= Strong (S); 2.51- 3.25= Moderate (M); 1.76- 2.50= Improvement Opportunity (IO); 1.00- 1.75= Not
Applicable (NA); WM= Weighted Mean; VI= Verbal Interpretation
Table 6 discusses the Customer Service Skills of the Sales

Representatives in terms of Customer Focus. The overall mean of 2.65, rated as

‘Moderate’ according to the supervisor- respondents in terms of Customer Focus,

points to ‘Moderate’ Customer Service Skills of the sales representatives as to

believing that they are members of a team of representatives in their unit who

work together on behalf of our customers (WM= 2.99), feeling that they know and

understand what excellent customer service is (WM= 2.90), and understanding

that they are the primary person who will be working with the customers to solve

their problem or answer their questions (WM= 2.89). However, the sales

representatives need ‘Improvement Opportunities’ in terms of seeing that they are

responsible to see that our customers' issues or problems are addressed whether

or not they are the one with the answer (WM= 2.46), and has a process in place

in the event that they don’t have an answer or ready solution, and they’ll use it

(WM= 2.40).

It is imperative that customer issues or problems are addressed outright.

This is emphasized in Spreng (2016) that the same is essential to Customer


STI- College Global City
41
Senior High School
loyalty and satisfaction that proved to be the major determinant for long term

survival and financial performance of the company.

Further, anent to addressing customer’s issues or problems, this problem is

provided answers by Anderson et. al. (2013) who states that companies need to

develop an environment inside the organization that is more prone towards

meeting service quality standards according to the customer requirements.

The sales representative- respondents were honest in rating themselves as

‘Moderate’ in Customer Service Skills, owing to the overall mean of 2.93. Among

their ‘Strong’ points, however, is their ability to show strong commitment to

provide our customers with excellent service (WM= 3.67), and in believing that our

customers are important to us, our department, our agency, and the State in

general (WM= 3.27). On the other hand, the items that need further ‘Improvement

Opportunity’ is in the area of knowing that the company has a process in place in

the event that they don’t have an answer or ready solution, and they’ll use it

(WM= 2.43). In this case, standard operating procedures established by

companies offer important reference materials for the employees. The goal of

which is to ensure that customer needs are met and issues/ problems addressed.

This in turn improves customer satisfaction measurement in developing,

monitoring, and/or evaluating product and service offerings, as well as for

evaluating, motivating, and/or compensating employees.


STI- College Global City
42
Senior High School

Table 7
Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives in terms of Personal
Characteristics

Sales
Supervisors TWM VI
Indicator Reps.
WM VI WM VI

has patience with our customers, even when


1 M M M
their actions are difficult to handle. 2.55 2.89 2.72
shows respect for our customers and our
2 M M M
co-workers. 3.00 3.09 3.05
possesses positive attitude and outlook
3 about their job, our customers, and our S S S
3.50 3.60
agency. 3.70
acts confident in their abilities to do their job
4 and in their interactions with our customers S S S
3.89 3.90
and co-workers. 3.90
manages the stress of their job well, even
5 S S S
when things get tough. 3.68 3.97 3.83
Shows efficiency in all aspects of their job
6 S S S
and handle their time very well. 3.54 3.87 3.71
applies high ethical standards as they fulfil
7 S S S
their job roles and functions. 3.90 3.92 3.91
follows through with our customer to ensure
8 M M M
that they are happy with our services 3.14 3.07 3.11
shows deep concern with the company, the
9 S S S
management, and co-employees 3.56 3.54 3.55
STI- College Global City
43
Senior High School
helps in the maintenance of the company's
10 S S S
facilities, equipment, and amenities 3.65 3.61 3.63

S S S
Overall Mean 3.44 3.56 3.50
Legend: 3.26- 4.00= Strong (S); 2.51- 3.25= Moderate (M); 1.76- 2.50= Improvement Opportunity (IO); 1.00- 1.75= Not
Applicable (NA); WM= Weighted Mean; VI= Verbal Interpretation

Table 7 presupposes the Customer Service Skills of the Sales

Representatives in terms of Personal Characteristics. The overall mean of 3.44,

according to the supervisor- respondents, is rated as Strong in Personal

Characteristics. This means that the sales representative- respondents are Strong

as to applying high ethical standards as they fulfil their job roles and functions

(WM= 2.90), and acting confident in their abilities to do their job and in their

interactions with our customers and co-workers (WM= 3.89). However, the sales

representatives have ‘Moderate’ Customer Service Skills as putting up with our

customers, even when their actions are difficult to handle (WM= 2.55), and in

showing respect for our customers and our co-workers (WM= 3.00), as among the

weak points, which the sales representative- respondents themselves agree as

having challenges or difficulties.

On a careful inspection of the dimensions of quality, a major focus rests on

the component of human interaction in the service delivery that consists of human

behavior and attitudes. The foregoing findings engages Looy et al (2013) who

emphasizes that customers are not one dimensional in judgment, because a lot of

other factors influence service quality, most researchers agree on these

dimensions of service quality as a measure of service quality.


STI- College Global City
44
Senior High School
The sales representative- respondents themselves rate their Personality

Characteristics as Strong, with an overall mean of 3.56. This information

integrates that the employees are able to manage the stress of their job well, even

when things get tough (WM= 3.97), and acting confident in their abilities to do

their job and in their interactions with our customers and co-workers (WM= 3.90).

Stress, as mentioned in the foregoing, points to the definition of Lee (2016),

Resilience refers to a person’s capacity to handle difficulties, demands, and high

pressure without becoming stressed. Resilient people are the one you can count

on to come through when the stakes are high. Resilient people respond

resourcefully to change. Rather than fight change and hang on to old, outdated

ways, they respond to change with confidence and flexibility. This is typically the

quality of resilient people think of when they hear the term. The more resilient

people are, the more quickly they’re able to recover from a setback, make the

best of the new situation, and become a “new and improved” version of

themselves because of it.


STI- College Global City
45
Senior High School

Table 8
Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives in terms of Customer
Service Challenges
Sales
Supervisors
Indicator Reps. TWM VI
WM VI WM VI
views every customer as a unique
1 individual with a need to fulfil, problem to S S S
3.59 3.75
solve, or an issue to address. 3.90
Discovers effectively and try to understand
2 M S S
their customer's point of view. 3.08 3.60 3.34
knows how to recognize the signs of
3 emotional communication (anger, fear, S S S
3.50 3.59
guilt, etc.). 3.67
knows ways to diffuse a customer's
4 emotional "charge" and move the M M M
3.04 3.07
interaction to a problem-solving process. 3.09
does not add to an emotional interaction by
5 S S S
reacting emotionally to it themselves. 3.48 3.57 3.53
knows that some of their customers have
difficulty with the issues or problems they
6 present to them and prepares themselves S S S
3.45 3.40
to handle the stress associated with tough
interactions. 3.34
focuses on the results they can achieve by
solving their customer's difficult problems
7 S S S
and keep these goals firmly in front of them 3.90 3.91
at all times. 3.91
STI- College Global City
46
Senior High School
does not use judgmental or blaming
8 behavior when they interact with customers S S S
3.50 3.58
who are experiencing difficulties. 3.65
recognizes and knows what to do when
they encounter customers who create
difficult circumstances, such as dishonest
9 M M M
interactions, abusive behavior, and 3.05 3.07
defensive/attacking verbal and nonverbal
communication. 3.09
recognizes and knows what to do when
they encounter customers who have
special needs including the elderly, the
10 S S S
disabled, customers from different cultures, 3.97 3.94
and people who speak English as a second
language or don't speak English at all. 3.90
S S S
Overall Mean 3.46 3.57 3.51
Legend: 3.26- 4.00= Strong (S); 2.51- 3.25= Moderate (M); 1.76- 2.50= Improvement Opportunity (IO); 1.00- 1.75= Not
Applicable (NA); WM= Weighted Mean; VI= Verbal Interpretation
Table 8 indulges the Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives

in terms of Customer Service Challenges. According to the supervisor-

respondents, the overall mean of 3.46, rated as Strong, leads to the sales

representatives’ abilities in recognizing and knowing what to do when they

encounter customers who have special needs including the elderly, the disabled,

customers from different cultures, and people who speak English as a second

language or don't speak English at all (WM= 3.97), and focusing on the results

they can achieve by solving their customer's difficult problems and keep these

goals firmly in front of them at all times (WM= 3.90). Both this ‘Strong’ points were

agreed by the sales representative- respondents themselves.

However, the supervisor- respondents rated the sales representative-

respondents (which they agree) as ‘Moderate’ in terms of knowing ways to diffuse

a customer's emotional "charge" and move the interaction to a problem-solving


STI- College Global City
47
Senior High School
process (WM= 3.04), and in recognizing and knowing what to do when they

encounter customers who create difficult circumstances, such as dishonest

interactions, abusive behavior, and defensive/attacking verbal and nonverbal

communication (WM= 3.05), as among the items that need to be improved.

The aforementioned ability of the employee to deal with the customer’s

emotional charge is described by Zarate (2016) as fight or clash, when people

disagree, because they see a situation differently. Differences in perception are

due to differences in needs, values, personality, preferences and interests,

orientation, education or training, or background experiences. Conflicts normally

occur between sales and marketing, marketing finance, marketing and

manufacturing, production and quality control, and etc.; It is important to practice

professionalism in handling conflict situation.

Table 9
Summary of Customer Service Skills of Sales Representatives

Sales
Indicator Supervisors Reps. TWM VI
WM VI WM VI
Customer Focus 2.65 M 2.93 M 2.79 M
Personal Characteristics 3.44 S 3.56 S 3.50 S
Customer Service Challenges 3.46 S 3.57 S 3.51 S

Table 9 presents the summary of Customer Service Skills of Sales

Representatives. As assessed by the supervisor- respondents, the total weighted

mean of 3.46 accrues to the ability of the sales representative- respondents as


STI- College Global City
48
Senior High School
‘Strong’ in handling Customer Service Challenges, followed by the Personal

Characteristics with 3.44; both rated as ‘Strong’; and ‘Moderate’ with 2.65 as to

Customer Focus.

On the other hand, the sales representative- respondents agree that

handling Customer Service Challenges are their strength, followed by Personal

Characteristics (WM= 3.50), but ‘Moderate’ in terms of Customer Focus (WM=

2.93).

Differences in the Assessments of the Grouped Respondents

Table 10
Differences in the Assessments of the Grouped Respondents on the
Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives

t- P-
Indicator value Value Decision Remarks
Customer Focus -2.06 0.0459 Reject Ho Significant
Personal Characteristics -0.62 0.5407 Accept Ho Not Significant
Customer Service
Challenges -0.81 0.4262 Accept Ho Not Significant

Table 9 indicates the Differences in the Assessments of the Grouped

Respondents on the Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives. The

Customer Focus’ t-value of -2.06 with a computed P-value of 0.0459 lesser than

the Probability Value at 0.05 leads to reject the null hypothesis that there is no
STI- College Global City
49
Senior High School
significant difference. In other words, the supervisors are one in pronouncing that

the sales representatives’ Customer Service Skills as to Customer Focus can

further be developed through training and education so as to reach their fullest

potential in fully understanding the needs of the customers. On the other hand,

the two other indicators- Personal Characteristics (t-value= -0.62, P- Value=

0.5407) and Customer Service Challenges (t-value= -0.81, P-value= 0.4262)

leads to accept the null hypothesis.

Proposed Training Program for Sales Representatives

Rationale:

Customer Service Skills is a major component of competencies. This

includes the possession of technical knowledge, practical behaviors and attitudes

which inform the way one operate in working life. The skills are a natural

progression, building on aspects of the person specification in greater detail. This

training program equips the Customer Service employee in better serving their

clienteles that is directly aligned with the Company’s goals.

Objective Strategies Activity Duration


Understands the Understands the Seminar on 2 hours
contribution their role
business makes to the success of
Understanding the
environment in the business goals of Customer
which the Understands the Service
STI- College Global City
50
Senior High School
business needs for the business
to generate increased
operates income and Focus Group 3 hours
and considers understands how their Discussions on
the wider impact team can support this the current
Questions actions
of their where appropriate and
business
decisions and identifies more cost- practices
actions effective approaches
Meets the
expectations of
customers without
compromising budgets
Gets message Clear when they Role Playing 3 hours
communicate
across in a Constructive and
persuasive way positive in what they Teambuilding 5 hours
have to say exercises
Involved at meetings,
asks questions, listens
and gives information
when appropriate
Keeps an open Invites regular Focus Group
feedback on
mind and adapts performance from team
Discussions on
to changes in members and the Working
the working customers Environment
Quickly turns new
environment ideas into clear and
effective improvements
Looks for better ways Brainstorming
of doing things and
suggests improvements
Shares their ideas
with colleagues and
seeks support from
management
in developing those
ideas
Understands Demonstrates Role Playing
common courtesy even
customer needs when customer is
and builds difficult or demanding Focus Group
effective Responds promptly to Discussions on
customer requests and
customer whenever possible
Building
relationships within agreed Relationships with
timeframes Customers
Assesses customer
needs accurately by
listening /sensitive
questioning
Keeps promises made
to customers
Shows awareness of
who their customers are
STI- College Global City
51
Senior High School
Builds own and Identifies what Understanding 5 hours
learning and
others’ development they need
oneself and
confidence, to do their job others: A
knowledge and effectively Teambuilding
Is flexible and willing
skills to adapt and learn
Exercise
Participates fully in
reviews and in agreed Focus Group 3 hours
SMART development Discussions on
objectives
Seeks and responds Difficulties/
positively to feedback Challenges
regarding their learning Encountered in
and development
Feedback
Mechanisms
Prioritizes and Overcomes obstacles Focus Group 4 hours
to ensure work gets
orders activities done on time
Discussions on
to get results Prioritizes workload to Workload
meet important Assignments 2 hours
objectives
Motivates and
encourages people to
achieve planned results
If appropriate to role,
manages team
effectively, delegating
work to use
resources to best effect
Informs colleagues of
changes in priorities and
helps them to plan their
workload
Monitors progress and
puts effort in where it is
most needed
Works with Actively participates Teambuilding 5 hours
within the team
others towards Helps others within
Exercises towards
shared goals the team, sharing improving
cooperatively workload Cooperation and
and Communicates openly Participation
and effectively with
collaboratively other team members
with other teams Focuses on shared
goals playing a full part
in their successful
completion
Is reliable and aware
that consequences of
own behavior affect
others within the team
STI- College Global City
52
Senior High School

Chapter 5

SUMMARY, FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND

RECOMMENDATION

This section shows the summary, findings, conclusions, and

recommendations on the study pertaining to the Customer Service Skills of the

Sales Representatives at Arrow Electronics Asia- Singapore Proprietary Limited.

Summary

The customer service skills of the sales representatives at Arrow

Electronics Asia- Singapore Proprietary Limited were assessed by its supervisors

and managers. The results will be made integral in providing an employee training

program to improve the customer service skills of its representatives. Specifically,


STI- College Global City
53
Senior High School
questions on the two groups of respondents’ assessment on the customer service

skills of the sales representatives in terms of Customer focus, Personal

Characteristics, and Customer Service Challenges were answered. Further, the

null hypothesis that there is no significant difference in the assessments of the two

groups of respondents on the customer service skills of the sales representatives

was tested.

This study used the descriptive research method due to the

appropriateness to the problem where the sample- respondents were purposively

chosen. The research instrument is based on the standardized instruments of the

Customer Service Model Questionnaire which is divided into 3 components that

effectively measures the skills of the said target respondents. The frequency,

percentage, weighted mean, and the T-Test of Two (2) Independent Samples.

Findings

Following are the findings of this study:

Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives

 The overall mean of 2.65, rated as ‘Moderate’ according to the supervisor-

respondents in terms of Customer Focus, points to ‘Moderate’ Customer

Service Skills of the sales representatives as to believing that they are

members of a team of representatives in their unit who work together on

behalf of our customers (WM= 2.99), feeling that they know and
STI- College Global City
54
Senior High School
understand what excellent customer service is (WM= 2.90), and

understanding that they are the primary person who will be working with

the customers to solve their problem or answer their questions (WM= 2.89).

However, the sales representatives need ‘Improvement Opportunities’ in

terms of seeing that they are responsible to see that our customers' issues

or problems are addressed whether or not they are the one with the answer

(WM= 2.46), and knowing that the company has a process in place in the

event that they don’t have an answer or ready solution, and they’ll use it

(WM= 2.40).

The sales representative- respondents were honest in rating themselves as

‘Moderate’ in Customer Service Skills, owing to the overall mean of 2.93.

Among their ‘Strong’ points, however, is their ability to show strong

commitment to provide our customers with excellent service (WM= 3.67),

and in believing that our customers are important to us, our department,

our agency, and the State in general (WM= 3.27). On the other hand, the

items that need further ‘Improvement Opportunity’ is in the area of knowing

that the company has a process in place in the event that they don’t have

an answer or ready solution, and they’ll use it (WM= 2.43). In this case,

standard operating procedures established by companies offer important

reference materials for the employees. The goal of which is to ensure that

customer needs are met and issues/ problems addressed. This in turn

improves customer satisfaction measurement in developing, monitoring,


STI- College Global City
55
Senior High School
and/or evaluating product and service offerings, as well as for evaluating,

motivating, and/or compensating employees.

 The overall mean of 3.44, according to the supervisor- respondents, is

rated as Strong in Personal Characteristics. This means that the sales

representative- respondents are Strong as to applying high ethical

standards as they fulfil their job roles and functions (WM= 2.90), and acting

confident in their abilities to do their job and in their interactions with our

customers and co-workers (WM= 3.89). However, the sales

representatives have ‘Moderate’ Customer Service Skills as putting up with

our customers, even when their actions are difficult to handle (WM= 2.55),

and in showing respect for our customers and our co-workers (WM= 3.00),

as among the weak points, which the sales representative- respondents

themselves agree as having challenges or difficulties.

The sales representative- respondents themselves rate their Personality

Characteristics as Strong, with an overall mean of 3.56. This information

integrates that the employees are able to manage the stress of their job

well, even when things get tough (WM= 3.97), and acting confident in their

abilities to do their job and in their interactions with our customers and co-

workers (WM= 3.90).

 Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives in terms of Customer

Service Challenges’ the overall mean of 3.46, rated as Strong, leads to the
STI- College Global City
56
Senior High School
sales representatives’ abilities in recognizing and knowing what to do when

they encounter customers who have special needs including the elderly,

the disabled, customers from different cultures, and people who speak

English as a second language or don't speak English at all (WM= 3.97),

and focusing on the results they can achieve by solving their customer's

difficult problems and keep these goals firmly in front of them at all times

(WM= 3.90). Both this ‘Strong’ points were agreed by the sales

representative- respondents themselves.

However, the supervisor- respondents rated the sales representative-

respondents (which they agree) as ‘Moderate’ in terms of knowing ways to

diffuse a customer's emotional "charge" and move the interaction to a

problem-solving process (WM= 3.04), and in recognizing and knowing what

to do when they encounter customers who create difficult circumstances,

such as dishonest interactions, abusive behavior, and defensive/attacking

verbal and nonverbal communication (WM= 3.05), as among the items that

need to be improved.

 As assessed by the supervisor- respondents, the total weighted mean of

3.46 accrues to the ability of the sales representative- respondents as

‘Strong’ in handling Customer Service Challenges, followed by the


STI- College Global City
57
Senior High School
Personal Characteristics with 3.44; both rated as ‘Strong’; and ‘Moderate’

with 2.65 as to Customer Focus.

On the other hand, the sales representative- respondents agree that

handling Customer Service Challenges are their strength, followed by

Personal Characteristics (WM= 3.50), but ‘Moderate’ in terms of Customer

Focus (WM= 2.93).

Differences in the Assessments of the Grouped Respondents

 The Customer Focus’ t-value of -2.06 with a computed P-value of 0.0459

lesser than the Probability Value at 0.05 leads to reject the null hypothesis

that there is no significant difference. In other words, the supervisors are

one in pronouncing that the sales representatives’ Customer Service Skills

as to Customer Focus can further be developed through training and

education so as to reach their fullest potential in fully understanding the

needs of the customers. On the other hand, the two other indicators-

Personal Characteristics (t-value= -0.62, P- Value= 0.5407) and Customer

Service Challenges (t-value= -0.81, P-value= 0.4262) leads to accept the

null hypothesis.
STI- College Global City
58
Senior High School

Conclusions

The supervisor- respondents in terms of Customer Focus, assessed the

sales representatives’ as ‘Moderate’. This means that believe that they are

members of a team of representatives in their unit who work together on behalf of

our customers, feels that they know and understand what excellent customer

service is, and understands that they are the primary person who will be working

with the customers to solve their problem or answer their questions. However, the

sales representatives need ‘Improvement Opportunities’ in terms of seeing that

they are responsible to see that our customers' issues or problems are addressed

whether or not they are the one with the answer, and knowing that the company

has a process in place in the event that they don’t have an answer or ready

solution, and they’ll use it.

The sales representative- respondents were honest in rating themselves as

‘Moderate’ in Customer Service Skills. Among their ‘Strong’ points, however, is

their ability to show strong commitment to provide our customers with excellent

service, and in believing that our customers are important to us, our department,

our agency, and the State in general. On the other hand, the items that need

further ‘Improvement Opportunity’ is in the area of knowing that the company has

a process in place in the event that they don’t have an answer or ready solution,

and they’ll use it. In this case, standard operating procedures established by
STI- College Global City
59
Senior High School
companies offer important reference materials for the employees. The goal of

which is to ensure that customer needs are met and issues/ problems addressed.

This in turn improves customer satisfaction measurement in developing,

monitoring, and/or evaluating product and service offerings, as well as for

evaluating, motivating, and/or compensating employees.

According to the supervisor- respondents, the sales representative-s are

rated Strong in Personal Characteristics. This means that the sales

representative- respondents are Strong as to applying high ethical standards as

they fulfil their job roles and functions, and acting confident in their abilities to do

their job and in their interactions with our customers and co-workers. However,

the sales representatives have ‘Moderate’ Customer Service Skills as putting up

with our customers, even when their actions are difficult to handle, and in showing

respect for our customers and our co-workers, as among the weak points, which

the sales representative- respondents themselves agree as having challenges or

difficulties.

The sales representative- respondents themselves rate their Personality

Characteristics as Strong. This information integrates that the employees are able

to manage the stress of their job well, even when things get tough, and acting

confident in their abilities to do their job and in their interactions with our

customers and co-workers.

Customer Service Skills of the Sales Representatives in terms of Customer

Service Challenges’ were rated as Strong. This leads to the sales representatives’
STI- College Global City
60
Senior High School
abilities in recognizing and knowing what to do when they encounter customers

who have special needs including the elderly, the disabled, customers from

different cultures, and people who speak English as a second language or don't

speak English at all, and focusing on the results they can achieve by solving their

customer's difficult problems and keep these goals firmly in front of them at all

times. Both this ‘Strong’ points were agreed by the sales representative-

respondents themselves.

However, the supervisor- respondents rated the sales representative-

respondents (which they agree) as ‘Moderate’ in terms of knowing ways to diffuse

a customer's emotional "charge" and move the interaction to a problem-solving

process, and in recognizing and knowing what to do when they encounter

customers who create difficult circumstances, such as dishonest interactions,

abusive behavior, and defensive/attacking verbal and nonverbal communication,

as among the items that need to be improved.

As assessed by the supervisor- respondents the sales representative-

respondents are ‘Strong’ in handling Customer Service Challenges, followed by

the Personal Characteristics (both rated as ‘Strong’); and ‘Moderate’ as to

Customer Focus.
STI- College Global City
61
Senior High School
On the other hand, the sales representative- respondents agree that

handling Customer Service Challenges are their strength, followed by Personal

Characteristics, but ‘Moderate’ in terms of Customer Focus.

The difference in assessments of the grouped respondents as to Customer

Focus is significant. This infers that the supervisors are one in pronouncing that

the sales representatives’ Customer Service Skills as to Customer Focus can

further be developed through training and education so as to reach their fullest

potential in fully understanding the needs of the customers. On the other hand,

the two other indicators- Personal Characteristics and Customer Service

Challenges leads to accept the null hypothesis.

Recommendations

Following are the recommendations to improve the Customer Service Skills

of the Sales Representatives at Arrow, Limited:

1. That Arrow, Limited Management teams, especially the Customer

Service Department provide a training program towards enhancing the

relationship of the employees with the clients, improving customer care

delivery, addressing issues/ and concerns of the customers. Standard

Operating Procedures or Agreements be established as easy reference


STI- College Global City
62
Senior High School
for the employees. Investments in these training and development

programs may increase employee productivity and ultimately increase

Sales and Profits.

2. The training programs for enhancing Customer Service Skills be used

as reference for all business entities engaged in customer service or

any business that involves customer interaction.

3. Customer Service Practitioners proactively engage and submit

themselves in trainings, seminars, workshops that may enhance their

capabilities. That they inculcate in themselves transparency and

openness to change carry out the expected output of their profession.

4. Future Researchers engage in similar topics of hybrid focus that

effectively connect the gap that may be left unresolved. Certain

inadequacies, at least, may give insights and encouragement to

undertake a validation and follow up study.


STI- College Global City
63
Senior High School

REFERENCES

American Psychological Association (2010). Managing Innovation and Change: A


Critical Guide for Organizations. United Kingdom: Cengage Learning EMEA. King,
L.A., Walker, L.M., Broyles, S.J.

Anderson, Eugene W., Claes Fornell, and Donald R. Lehmann (2013). "Customer
Satisfaction, Market Share and Profitability: Findings from Sweden," Journal of
Marketing, 58

Antwi, H. (2014). Relationship Of Work Attitude, Reward Systems And Personality


Of Workers To The Job Performance And Motivation. Asian Institute of
Management, Manila

Athanassopoulos, K. (2010). Proposed Framework of Customer Satisfaction.


Visual Studies, 17(1), 13-26.

Auguste et al., (2016). Single Strategic Business Units in the Philippines. De La


Salle University.
STI- College Global City
64
Senior High School
Barrick, M.R., Mount, M.K. (2010). The big five personality dimensions and job
performance: A meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology

Batey, M., Furnham, A. (2016). Creativity, intelligence, and personality: A critical


review of the scattered literature. Genetic, Social, and General Psychology
Monographs

Beckett, B. (2014). A Model to Articulate and Classify Consumer Behavior.


Business Marketing, 83, 18.

Binks, K. (2016). Customer Involvement in the Provision of Services. Bowers, K.S.


(1973), Situationism in psychology: An analysis and a critique. Psychological
Review

Bolton, M. (2015). An Investigation into the Determinants of Customer Journal of


Marketing Research, vol.19 no.4

Broga, L. (2015). Integrating Product And Service Organizations. University of the


Philippines.

Brown Jr., L. (2016). Job Satisfaction in Organizations. New York: Harcourt,


Brace, and World.

Carmeli, A., Meitar, R., Weisberg, J. (2016). Self-leadership skills and innovative
behaviour at work. International Journal of Manpower, 27(1)

Chen, S.C., Wu, M.C., Chen, C.H. (2010). Employee’s personality traits, work
motivation and innovative behavior in marine tourism industry. Journal of Service
Science and Management

Churchill, V. & Surprenant, K. (2016). Customer Satisfaction as an Outcome of


Purchase. Intelligence, 39(1), 36-45.

Churchill, V. and Suprenant, K. (2012). Disconfirmation as An Intervening Variable


Affecting Satisfaction. Creativity Research Journal, 13(2), 185-195.

Ciavolino, A. (2010). The Risks of Setting Customer’s Expectations Too High.


Information And Management, vol.43.pp. 271-282

Cronin, H. & Taylor, D. (2014). The NEO Personality Inventory Manual. Odessa,
FL: Psychological Assessment Resources. Costa, P.,
STI- College Global City
65
Senior High School
Cronin, H., Brady, J. and Hult, Y. (2015). Synthesizing and Building On the Efforts
To Conceptualize The Effects Of Quality, Satisfaction, Empirical Assessment

Davidow, K. (2013). From catalog to classification: Murray’s needs and the five-
factor model. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.

De La Cruz, J. (2013). Job Performance And Job Satisfaction Of PNP Personnel.


Trinity University of Asia Graduate Thesis

Digman, J.M. (2011). Personality structure: Emergence of the five-factor model.


Annual Review of Psychology

Dolgova, E., van Olffen, W., van den Bosch, F., Volberda, H. (2010), The
Interaction between Personality, Social Network Position and Involvement in
Innovation Process.

Dawkins, A. (2014) Creativity and openness: Further validation of two creative


product measures. Creativity Research Journal

Ennew, C. & Binks, Martin (2010). “The Impact of Service Quality and
Characteristics on Customer Retention: Small Businesses and their Banks in UK”
British Journal of Management

Fontana, M. (2008). Consumer Behavior Points to a Multi-Optional Society. Future


Banker, 2/2.

Fornell et al. (2016). American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI). Creativity


Research Journal, 16(1), 35-47.

Fornell and Rust (2012). Customer Service Skills Model. 12th Ed., NY: Prentice
Hall.

Goldberg, L.R. (2015). An alternative “description of personality”: The big-five


factor structure. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

Gronroos, G. (2010). Quality Is What Customers Perceive. Advances in Services


Marketing and Management, 3, 1-67.

Hallowell, J. (2011). The relationship of customer satisfaction, customer loyalty


and profitability. European Journal of Personality, 15(4), 297-310.

Hanag et al. (2010). Multiple Product-Focused and Service-Focused SBUs.


University of the East Business Research.
STI- College Global City
66
Senior High School

Heskett, L. (2014). Psychology. United Kingdom: British Psychological Society;


Blackwell Publishing.

Hogan, R. (2016). What is Personality Psychology? Psychological Inquiry –


Commentaries

Hong et al. (2007). Customer Service Skills of Frontline Employees. Great Britain:
Pearson Education Limited. 2nd edition.

Howcroft, et.al. (2011). Attitude and The Usage and Adoption of Home-Based
Banking. Research in Organizational Behavior. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press. p169-
211.

Hsieh, H.L., Hsieh, J.R., Wang, I.L. (2011). Linking personality and innovation:
The role of knowledge management. World Transactions on Engineering and
Technology Education, 9(1)

Hurley, L. & Estelami, V (2016). Service Quality and Satisfaction as Distinct


Constructs. Prezithamil

Ibanez et al. (2010). Classical Product-Focused And Geographically-Focused


Organizational Forms. De La Salle University

Jillian, M. (2014). Transformational and transactional leadership and their effects


on creativity in groups. Creativity Research Journal, 13(2)

Jung, D.I. (2010). Assessing Age Differences In The Performance Of A Particular


Job. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology

Kalledo, O. (2013). Separate Service Organization. University of the Philippines.

Kanter, R. (2016). When a thousand flowers bloom: Structural, collective, and


social conditions for innovation in organizations. In: Staw, B.M., Cummings, L.L.,
editors. Research in Organizational Behavior. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.

Kondo, K. (2011). Customers Value Satisfaction and Quality in Many Different


Ways. Gartner Research, March 23, 2011.

Krashen, L. (2006). Customer satisfaction: how can I measure it? Total Quality
Management. 12(7/8):867-872.
STI- College Global City
67
Senior High School
Kurtenbach, J. (2000), Focusing on customer service. Health Forum Journal,
Sep/Oct, 43(5), 35-37.

Lazaro, R. (2012). Focused On The Relationship Between Adversity Quotient And


Performance Level. University of the Philippines Research Journal.

Lee, M. (2016). Measuring Perceived Service Quality Using Integrated Conjoint


Experiments the International Journal of Bank Marketing, vol.18 no.4

Leonard, F. (2009). Service Improvement Strategy in the Organization. Glencoe


Understanding Psychology. Missouri: Gelncoe Partners. King, N.,

Leonard, F. (2016). Personality, situation, and creativity. In: Handbook of


Creativity. New York: Springer US.

Lehtinen, J. (2012). The relationships between intelligence, personality and


creativity under two conditions of stress. Journal of Educational Psychology

Looy et. al. (2013). Customers’ Dimensional Judgment. Journal of Retailing, Vol.
69. pp.193-215.

Lugtu, P. (2010). Adversity Quotient and Personality-Temperament Traits of the


Specific Weapon and Tactics (SWAT) Police Manila. Polytechnic University of the
Philippines Graduate Thesis.

Maackoy, J. (2016). The factor structure of the 16PF: Twelve primary and three
secondary factors. Personality and Individual Differences, 10(9)

Magpantay, L. (2011). Organizational Structures Of Manufacturing Companies.


Ateneo De Manila University

Martindale, C., Dailey, A. (2016). Creativity, primary process cognition and


personality. Personality and Individual Differences, 20(4)

MacMillan, T. (2014). Why I advocate the five factor model: Joint factor analysis of
NEO-PI with other instruments. In: Buss, D., Cantor, R., editors. Personality
Psychology: Recent Trends and Emerging Directions. New York: Springer-Verlag.

McCrae, R.R. (2012). Four ways five factors are basic. Personality and Individual
Differences
STI- College Global City
68
Senior High School
McDougall, W. (2015). Updating Norman’s “adequacy taxonomy:” Intelligence and
personality dimensions in natural language and in questionnaires. Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology

McDougall, W. & Levesque, L. (2010). Creativity, divergent thinking, and


openness to experience. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

Nayo, H. (2015). The Increasing Importance of Service Orientation. Ateneo De


Manila University

Neill, Y. (2016). Resilience As An Individual’s Capacity to thrive and Fulfil


Potential. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity and the Arts,
2(2), 68.

Olakitan, O. (2011). An examination of the impact of selected personality traits on


the innovative behaviour of entrepreneurs in Nigeria. Nigeria Journal of Business
Management

Oliver, et. al. (2012). Consumer satisfaction to mediate consumer learning. Quality
Management Journal, Vol. 7, Issue 4.

Oliver, P. and Rust, K. (2012). The Price of Customer Service on Productivity.


Journal of Product and Brand management, Vol. 5, No. 2, pp.6-18.

Oliver, P. (2012). Service Quality and Customer Satisfaction. Quality Management


Journal, Vol. 9, Issue 5.

Pagalunan, S. (2015). Separate Service Organization and Single Business Units


in the Philippines. Ateneo De Manila University

Oliver, P. (2013). Service Quality and Customer Satisfaction Model. Quality


Management Journal, Vol. 10, Issue 4.

Palangkaraya, A., Stierwald, A., Webster, E., Jensen, P. (2011). Examining the
Characteristics of Innovative Firms in Australia. Melbourne: A Report for the
Australian Government Department of Innovation, Industry, Science and
Research, Intellectual Property Research Institute of Australia, The University of
Melbourne

Parasuraman, Y. (2015). Perceived service quality and value of customer


satisfaction. International Business and Management
STI- College Global City
69
Senior High School
Parasuraman, Valerie A. Zeithaml, and Leonard L. Berry (2016). A Conceptual
Model of Service Quality and its Implications for Future Research Journal of
Marketing, vol.49

Parasuraman, Y. (2015). Tangible goods have defined and measured quality with
increasing levels of precision. International Business and Management

Patterson, F., Kerrin, M., Gatto-Roissard, G. (2012). Characteristics and


Behaviors of Innovative People in Organisations. London: Literature Review
Prepared for the NESTA Policy & Research Unit, NESTA

Peterson, J. (2016), Intrapreneuring: Why You Don’t Have to Leave the


Organization to Become an Entrepreneur. New York: Harper & Row. Robbins,
S.P., Judge, T.A.,

Pfeiffer, M. (2015). Are intelligence and creativity really so different? Fluid


intelligence, executive processes, and strategy use in divergent thinking.
Intelligence

Reichheld, L. (2014). Building effective and significant relationships through


Customer Satisfaction. Blackwell.

Rabin, D. (2015). Assessing creativity with divergent thinking tasks: Exploring the
reliability and validity of new subjective scoring methods. Psychology of
Aesthetics, Creativity and the Arts

Roberts, G. (2013). Good Customer Service Involves Giving Customers A Good


First Impression Of The Business. Information And Management, vol.43.pp. 271-
282.

Robson, J. (2012). Research Enquiries. New Delhi: Pearson, Prentice Hall.

Rust, K. (2012). Customer Service Satisfactions. Great Britain: Pearson Education


Limited. 2nd edition.

Rust, K. & Oliver, M. (2012). Product Repurchase Frequency and Future


Expectations. Great Britain: Pearson Education Limited. 3rd edition.

Rustica, C. (2015). Interrelation of Service-Focused and Customer-Focused


Organizational Structures. Ateneo De Manila University

Sakthivel et al., (2015). Customer Loyalty and Satisfaction. Boston: Harvard


Business Review.
STI- College Global City
70
Senior High School

Siebert, K. (2016). Resilience in Customer Service. Academy of Management


Journal, 37(3), 580-607.

Spreng, T. (2016). Literature Review on Service Quality and Satisfaction. New


York: Guilford. p66-100.

Stollings (2015). The Four Generations in the Workforce. British Journal of Social
and Clinical Psychology, 16(3), 241-248

Stoltz, K. (2014). Validation of the five-factor model of personality across


instruments and observers. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,

Sullivan, M. (2015). The Dissatisfied Customer. CT: JAI Press. p169-211.

Sureshchandar et. al., (2013). The Concept of Quality. New York: Holt, Rinehart &
Winston.

Sureshchander et. al. (2012). The Complicated Behavior of Employees and the
Customer’s Perception of the Service Quality. Journal of Retailing, 76, 260.

Tam, L. (2014). Customers are the Primary Source of Profit for Most of the Firms.
Annual Review of Psychology, 41(1), 417-440.

Tan, G. (2004). Creativity, divergent thinking, and openness to experience.


Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52(6), 1258-1265.

Taylor, L. (2014). Consumers' Quality Perceptions and Satisfaction Judgments.


Handbook of Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty Measurement. Gower.

Tulli et al. (2007). Product-Centric View Of Organizational Structures. De La Salle


University, Manila

Sanghi, S. (2015). Organizational Behavior. New Delhi: Pearson, Prentice Hall.


Rogers, C. (1961), On Becoming a Person. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Rushton,
J.P. (2009), Creativity, intelligence, and psychoticism. Personality and Individual
Differences

Saunders et al. (2011). Research Strategy. Academy of Management Journal,


37(3), 580-607.

Scott, S.G., Bruce, R.A. (2014). Determinants of innovative behavior: A path


model of individual innovation in the workplace. Academy of Management Journal
STI- College Global City
71
Senior High School

Smith, L. & Houston, W. (2010). Experimenting the Service Quality, Satisfaction


With Services. Journal of Service Science and Management, 3(02), 198.

Swan, F. (2010). Measuring service quality: A re-examination and Journal of


Marketing, vol.56

Walliman, J. (2015). Survey: The Most Common and Popular Method in Business
Research. Missouri: Gelncoe Partners.

Wang, V. (2015). Maximization of customer loyalty. Academy of Management


Journal, 37(3), 580-607.

Woodruff, Y. & Albert, M. (2011). Stability and change in the big five personality
domains: Evidence from a longitudinal study of Australians. Psychology and Aging

Yasin et al. (2013). The Multidimensional Challenges in Business Environment.


San Diego, CA: Academic Press.

Ueltschy et al., (2014). Marketing: Contributions from the Behavioral Sciences.


New York: Harcourt, Brace, and World.

Zarate, Z. (2016). Simple Structural Changes in the Organization. Business


Management Quarterly. University of the Philippines.

Zenithal et al (2013). Interaction Between Customers and Service Providers.


(http://www.ehow.com)

Zeithaml, H. (2010). Intangible Nature of Services. New York: Plenum Press.

Zeithaml, H. (2016). An empirical investigation into the impact of personality on


individual innovation behaviour in the workplace. Procedia-Social and Behavioral
Sciences

Zeithaml et al (2013). Customer’s Evaluation of a Product or Service. International


Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 12, pg.346

Zeithaml et. al. (2016). Customer Satisfaction or Dissatisfaction. International


Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 15, pg.178

Online Resources
STI- College Global City
72
Senior High School
http://www.ehow.com
STI- College Global City
73
Senior High School
APPENDICES
RESEARCH INSTRUMENT

Part I. Respondent’s Profile.


Age :
____ 25 and below _____ 31 to 35 _____ 41 to 45
____ 26 to 30 _____ 36 to 40 _____ 46 and above

Gender :
____ male _____ female

Educational Background :
____ bachelor’s ______ master’s degree _____doctorate
____ technical/ vocational ______ others______________ (pls. specify)

Job classification :
____ frontline ______ support ______ after- sales
____ others ____________________ (pls. specify)

Length of Service :
____ 1 year and below ______ 2 to 4 years ______ 5 to 7 years
____ 8 to 10 years ______ 11 years and above

Part II. Customer Service Skills Assessment on the Sales Representatives.

S = Strong. This describes the sales representative possessing the all the
skill or most of the time.
M = Moderate. This describes the sales representative to be possessing the
skill partly or some of the time.
I = Improvement opportunity. This describes the sales representative as
possessing the skill very little or not at all.
N/A = Not applicable to the sales representative at this time.

Customer Focus
The Sales Representative… S M I N/A
1. shows strong commitment to provide our customers with excellent
service.
2. believes that our customers are important to us, our department,
our agency, and the State in general.
STI- College Global City
74
Senior High School
3. feels that we know and understand what excellent customer
service is.
4. has a good understanding of what our customers expect and
require.
5. believes that their job providing customer service is very
important, and they understand why.
6. understands that they are the primary person who will be working
with the customers to solve their problem or answer their
questions.
7. believes that they are members of a team of representatives in their
unit who work together on behalf of our customers.
8. knows that the company has a process in place in the event that
they don’t have an answer or ready solution, and they’ll use it.
9. sees that they are responsible to see that our customers' issues or
problems are addressed whether or not they are the one with the
answer.
10. wants to deal with our customers' issues correctly the first time
they deal with them.

Personal Characteristics
The Sales Representative… S M I N/A
1. has patience with our customers, even when their actions are
difficult to handle.
2. shows respect for our customers and our co-workers.

3. possesses positive attitude and outlook about their job, our


customers, and our agency.
4. acts confident in their abilities to do their job and in their
interactions with our customers and co-workers.
5. manages the stress of their job well, even when things get tough.

6. Shows efficiency in all aspects of their job and handle their time
very well.
7. applies high ethical standards as they fulfil their job roles and
functions.

Customer Service Challenges


The Sales Representative… S M I N/A
1. views every customer as a unique individual with a need to fulfil,
problem to solve, or an issue to address.
2. Discovers effectively and try to understand their customer's point
of view.
3. knows how to recognize the signs of emotional communication
STI- College Global City
75
Senior High School
(anger, fear, guilt, etc.).
4. knows ways to diffuse a customer's emotional "charge" and move
the interaction to a problem-solving process.
5. does not add to an emotional interaction by reacting emotionally to
it themselves.
6. knows that some of their customers have difficulty with the issues
or problems they present to them and prepares themselves to
handle the stress associated with tough interactions.
7. focuses on the results they can achieve by solving their customer's
difficult problems and keep these goals firmly in front of them at all
times.
8. does not use judgmental or blaming behaviour when they interact
with customers who are experiencing difficulties.
9. recognizes and knows what to do when they encounter customers
who create difficult circumstances, such as dishonest interactions,
abusive behaviour, and defensive/attacking verbal and nonverbal
communication.
10. recognizes and knows what to do when they encounter customers
who have special needs including the elderly, the disabled,
customers from different cultures, and people who speak English
as a second language or don't speak English at all.

You might also like