Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Likewise, writing has a unique position in language teaching since its acquisition
involves a practice and knowledge of other three language skills, such as listening,
reading and speaking. Moreover, it requires mastering of other skills, such as
metacognitive skills. Learners need to set an objective for their writing, plan it
carefully, think over its layout and logical structure, and then revise it. In the process
of writing they have to use cognitive skills; they have to analyze their sources and
then synthesize them in a compact piece of writing.
II.1STUDY A
Title: THE CHALLENGES IN TEACHING WRITING SKILL AT JUNIOR
HIGH SCHOOL: PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS
By: AMIRUL MUKMININ, S.Pd. M.Sc. Ed. Ph.D.
ENGLISH STUDY PROGRAM, FACULTY OF TEACHER TRAINING
AND EDUCATION, JAMBI UNIVERSITY, 2014
Issue: The study aims to investigate about the challenges of teaching writing for
young language learners, especially in Junior High School, particularly the
Junior High School 11 Kota Jambi and Junior High School 23 Petaling,
Muaro Jambi.
One of the biggest challenges teachers have faced in the classroom has to
do with writing. Teachers have to take care of student’s motivation, their
level of writing and preferred way of learning before preparing any task
(Samia Zerin: 2007). In terms of teaching writing for young language
learners, teachers should consider about some aspects in teaching writing.
Every single lesson requires careful preparation – teachers must consider a
variety of techniques, activities and teaching aids to make the lesson
appealing to the students. Children learning EFL or ESL often face
additional obstacles when learning to form English-language letter.
This study aims to identify the problems faced by the research participants
in teaching writing skills to their students. At the same time by
investigating said problems suggest possible solutions for the said
challenges.
Problems and solutions: In the course of the study the following problems faced
by both students and teacher in learning and teaching writing skills were
identified:
a. Students’ Problems
Lack of vocabulary
Lack of vocabulary is a problem that often occurs during class activity,
and teachers find this hard to handle at times as this presents
limitations for students in writing a paragraph or even a sentence.
Grammar Problems
Grammar is very helpful for effective language skills. Grammar, in
writing skill, determines how a paragraph builds-up and how the ideas
can be understood. Teachers often find their students lack in this
aspect.
Lack of motivation
Many of the students think that writing skill is one of the most
complicated skill because it requires good grammar and vocabulary
skills. In addition to that, the impact of differences in L1 and L2 make
it harder for younger learners to decide on appropriate topics for
writing a paragraph, or even a sentence.
Learning Environment
The study found that students, especially in remote areas, are not really
supported by people around them even their parents. Likewise,
teachers also often found a difficulty to teach in remote areas where
most people think English is not a priority subject for their children to
master.
b. Teachers’ Problems
Difficulty in Student Motivation
This study found that teachers have difficulty to motivate the students
because most of them are uninterested in developing writing skills.
Students think that writing is very difficult and boring to learn.
Different Learning Levels of students
Every student has different writing level abilities. Teachers often have
problems with coming up with writing tasks that can accommodate
different learning levels as this would require tedious multiple
preparations.
c. Solutions:
Instituting a Reward System
In teaching and learning process, rewards and punishments are needed
to motivate the students in the learning process. By instituting a
rewards system, the learners are expected to be competitive to do the
task especially in writing skill.
Using Technology
Encouraging students to use technology not just for their leisure but
for educational purposes can help students in improving their language
and communication skills. Teachers need to make sure however, that
teachers also guide students to use technology effectively and
responsibly.
Organizing the Class
Classroom management is also an important tool to help student cope
up in their lessons, especially lessons in writing where students often
find difficulty complying. Teachers can involve students in different
writing activities such as collaborative writing projects that are
appropriately managed.
Interactive Method
Teachers can provide the appropriate interactive methods such as
talking and writing box, and writing centers.
Conclusions: Teaching writing has different challenges than other language skills,
especially for young language learners. In teaching writing, teachers
should consider about problems that will be faced and they should
provide the solutions for the problems.
II.2STUDY B
Title:CHALLENGES FACED BY STUDENTS AND TEACHERS IN
WRITING SKILLS IN ESL CONTEXT
By: Rachel Nyanamoney Moses, Maslawati Mohamad
Faculty of Education, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Bangi, Malaysia
Issue: English language writing has always been a challenge for second language
students to master. Developing students’ ability in writing is one of the
major challenges faced by the ESL teachers in most schools nowadays.
Nevertheless, writing has always been a major difficulty faced by students
in English language learning, especially in elementary schools. Not only
that, teachers are also facing some challenges in teaching writing skills for
students in elementary schools. Thus, this study aims to explore the
challenges faced by both the students and teachers in learning as well as
teaching writing skills in elementary schools.
II.4STUDY D
Title: INVESTIGATING THE PROBLEMS FACED BY THE TEACHERS
IN DEVELOPING ENGLISH WRITING SKILLS
By: HAFIZ AHMAD BILAL et. al.
Department of English, University of Sargodha, & the Department of
English, University of Lahore, Sargodha Campus, PAKISTAN
Issue: Teaching English writing skills involves developing linguistic and
communicative competence of the learner which is quite a challenging
task. Many factors hinder the process of teaching and learning these skills.
Most of the students of public sector institutes do not perform well in
English writing tasks and ultimately face average or poor results in
academics. The purpose of this study is to highlight the problems which
hinder the teachers in developing English writing skills. This study is not
only to point out the problematic factors but also suggest some remedial
measures to improve the situation.
Conventional Issues
Harmer (2001 & 2007) describes conventional issues related to English
writing skills. These issues are related to the use of lexical items,
punctuation, text format, spellings and syntax. A lot of practice can enable
the learners overcome these issues.
Primary Issues
Broughton, Brumfit, Flavell, Hill and Pincas (2003) point out the
following four kinds of problems related to developing English writing
skills. These include: “(i) Mechanical problems with the script of English;
(ii) Problems of accuracy of English grammar and lexis; (iii) Problems
relating the style of writing to the demands of a particular situation; (iv)
Problems of developing ease and comfort in expressing what needs to be
said.” (p. 116). These problematic areas can be overcome through
effective planning and guided writing.
Issues at Intermediate Level
Students at advanced level or intermediate level feel difficulties in
developing coherent sentences and knitting them in a larger text. At this
stage, students also face problems in developing formal or informal piece
of writing. Writing skills also accompany many other skills which
facilitate the learners to construct their writing (Clementson, 2005).
Factors Involved in Developing Writing Skills
Influence of L1 on L2 Learning
Silva (1993) suggests that second language is usually different from the
first language ‘strategically, rhetorically and linguistically’ (p.669). She
points out that the written assignments of the L2 learners are syntactically
and semantically loose. Usually paragraphs
lack coherence and all this is due to the difference of L2 from L1.
According to Hyland (2003), this difference also affects the thinking
faculty of the learners.
Effects of Multicultural, Multilingual and Psychological Factors
Anees and Raazia (2007) point out some social and psychological factors
which affect L2 writing skills. Social factors include social status, family
background etc and psychological factors include motivational level, age
etc. Lantolf (1999) mentions effects of multicultural and multilingual
background on the learners’ writing skills. Lave and Wenger (1991) also
emphasize that the entire teaching process must be compatible with social
set up and cultural background, which they termed as ‘situated cognition’
(as cited in Hyland, 2003).
Effects of Grammar Teaching on English Writing Skills
Clark (2003) opines that learners must be taught writing process. This
enables the learners to write in any situation. According to the traditional
approach, teaching grammar plays a pivotal role in the process of writing
skills but the latest researches have proved that the grammar teaching has
no significant influence in the development of these skills.
Braddock & Lloyd-Jones, and Schoer (1963) summarize their findings of
many years long research as “….the teaching of formal [traditional]
grammar has a negligible or, because it usually displaces some
instruction and practice in actual composition, even a harmful effect on
the improvement of writing.” (p. 37-38, as cited in Clark, 2003)
Many researchers like Bateman and Zidonis (1996), Barham, Lamb and
Wyllie (1976) have worked on the influence of grammar teaching on
English writing skill. They all conclude that the classes where English
grammar is taught, students lose their interest and they take English
writing skills as a very hard task and such classes become ‘boring,
useless and repetitive’. Hillocks (1986) suggests that usage and
‘mechanics’ of the writing skills must be carefully handled with
appropriate planning (as cited in Clark, 2003).
Research Findings:
Developing writing skills is a slow and gradual process. Many factors involved
may disrupt the teaching and learning process of English writing skills. The
following are the research findings highlighted by the selected population of the
ESL teachers:
i. At intermediate level, most of the students have poor English language
background.
ii. Proper A/V aids are not available to the teachers.
iii. Classes are overcrowded.
iv. Teachers usually follow the traditional approaches for teaching purpose
and they are satisfied with their teaching approach.
v. Teachers cannot give proper time for writing practice during class because
of lengthy syllabus and overcrowded classrooms.
II.5STUDY E
Title:THE DIFFICULTIES EXPERIENCED BY TEACHERS IN THE
PROCESS OF PRIMARY READING AND WRITING
INSTRUCTIONS AND THEIR SOLUTION OFFERS FOR
ELIMINATING THESE DIFFICULTIES
Issue: The purpose of the current research is to identify the difficulties that
primary school teachers experience in the primary reading and writing
instruction, and to find out their solution offers for eliminating these
difficulties.
Problems identified in the study:
The following are the difficulties identified in the study as experienced by the
teachers in the process of primary reading and writing instruction:
parental indifference
unreadiness of students
teaching of cursive italic handwriting
lack of professional experience
student absenteeism
lack of interest by students
physical inadequacies
Solutions identified in the study:
education of parents,
carrying out activities suitable for students
change of handwriting type
cooperation with parents
consideration of readiness level
improvement of physical conditions
Conclusion:
The role of the teachers in improving the primary reading and writing instruction
process is very important. In today’s classrooms, a thoughtful and flexible
approach to literacy instruction is required.
It is essential that teachers work in an environment where they feel self-confident,
can express themselves, their demands and opinions are regarded, and are
provided with an opportunity to express the difficulties they experience in order to
increase their performance in the process of reading and writing literacy
education, which is a difficult and rewarding experience for teachers [11], and to
ensure that they can work happily in this process.
In the light of all these findings, the difficulties expressed by teachers, who are the
implementers of the process of primary reading and writing instruction, should be
taken into account in order to improve the quality of the process. In this context,
in-depth studies should be made on the subject matters which teachers perceive as
problems and about which they share solution offers, and results of these studies
should be shared with them. Teachers should be informed about activities to be
performed about these processes.
III. CONCLUSIONS
Writing has always been seen as an important skill in English language
acquisition. This importance is due to the fact that it reinforces grammatical
structures and vocabulary that educators strive to teach their students. It is the area
in which learners need to be offered adequate time to develop their writing skill,
therefore more time should be devoted to it in classrooms so that students will be
prepared to effectively communicate in real life as well as academic situations.
But the reality of the matter is that there are difficulties that both students and
teachers encounter in the process of developing the writing skills of young
learners. Challenges that need to be addressed in order for educators to effectively
ensure that students acquire the necessary productive skills, such as writing.
English teachers are considerably supposed to acquire a number of methods,
strategies, technique and so forth in teaching English particularly the academic
writing that belongs to productive skill. In relation to writing, it requires more
participation and responsibility from the learners in teaching and learning process.
In order to enhance the writing skill of learners, the role and effort of qualified
English teachers need to be taken into account especially as a facilitator and co-
contributor in the writing process.
In the foregoing current literature on teaching writing skills, each has presented its
own challenges as well as solutions and opportunities to address the problems
cited.
The most common student’s problems identified among the five studies cited are
the following:
1. Problems on Student’s Vocabulary
2. Problems on Student’s Grammar, Spelling etc.
3. Student Motivation
4. Lack of student interest in learning writing skills
5. Indifference of parent’s/family members in learning the English language
6. Lack of or limited resources such as reading materials
With regards to teacher’s problems, the following are the most common among the
five literatures cited:
References:
Wahyuningsih, Sri, (2018), Challenges and opportunities of /teaching Academic Writing skills: A
Case Study of students at Iain Kudus, Jurnal Edulingua | Vol 5. No. 1.
Bilal, Hafiz Ahmad et. al., (2013), Investigating the problems faced by the teachers in Developing
English Writing Skills, Asian Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, Vol. 2 No. 3
Gündoğmuş, Hatice Değirmenci, (2018), The Difficulties Experienced by Teachers in the Process of
Primary Reading and Writing Instruction and Their Solution Offers for Eliminating These
Difficulties, Universal Journal of Educational Research, 6(2): 333-339
Mukminin, Amirul, (2014), The Challenges in teaching Writing Skills at Junior High School:
Problems and Solutions, Retrieved from:
https://www.academia.edu/9553692/THE_CHALLENGES_IN_TEACHING_WRITING_SKILL
Mohamad, Maslawati and Moses, Rachel Nyanamoney, (2019), Challenges Faced by Students and
Teachers on Writing Skills in ESL Contexts: A Literature Review, Creative Education, Vol.10 No.13
Goldstein, Dana, (2017, Aug. 2), Why Kids Can’t Write, (The New York Times), Retrieved from:
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/02/education/edlife/writing-education-grammar-students-
children.html
Cole, Jenny and Feng, Jay, (2015), Effective Strategies for Improving Writing Skills of Elementary
English Language Learners, Retrieved from: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED556123.pdf
Rizga, Kristina (2018, August 8), How to Make Students Care About Writing, Retrieved from:
https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2018/08/making-students-care-about-writing/567044/