You are on page 1of 98

CHARTER 4

DESIGN OF SINGLE PILE AND GROUP PILE FOUNDATION

4.1. Soil Properties


In the reference borehole, the upper crust of about 0 to 35ft depth is found to
be Reddish to Yellowish Brown, Silt and Clay. Below 35ft down to about 45ft, the
soil is mostly Yellowish Brown Sand, Sand mixed with some silt. Below 45ft down to
about 55ft depth is found to be Dark grayish colour , Silty-Clay. Below 55ft down to
about 65ft depth is found to be light Bluish colour, Sand. Below 65ft to 80ft depth is
found to be Dark grayish colour, Clay Silt .The water table is found below the ground
surface at 4 ft. The required soil properties for soil report are shown in Table 4.1.

4.2. Calculate the Allowable Bearing Capacity of Soil


The allowable bearing capacity qa is the ultimate bearing capacity qu divided
by an appropriate factor of safety FS. The soil must be capable of carrying the load
from any engineered structure placed upon it without a shear failure and with the
resulting settlements being tolerable for that structure. The allowable bearing capacity
is calculated by three methods;
(a)Meyerhof Method
(b)Hansen Method
(c)SPT

Table4.1. Required Soil Parameters


Depth(ft) N qu(lb/ft2) γ(lb/ft3)
0-10 6 3885.39 53.05
10-25 35 12896.98 71.76
25-30 13 5049.37 49.3
30-35 14 7003.05 51.78
49

Table4.1. continued
Depth(ft) N qu(lb/ft2) γ(lb/ft3)
35-40 13 4073.16 58.02
40-45 16 4468.92 57.44
45-55 17 6272.87 45.55
55-65 33 11754.55 58.65
65-80 29 7948.77 44.34

Where,
γ = density of soil
qu= the unconfined compression strength
N= standard penetration number

4.2.1. Meyerhof’s Method


The influence of the shear strength of soil above the base of the foundation is
considered in this solution. Meyerhof's bearing capacity equation (for vertical load) is
expressed as follows;

qult = cNcscdc + q Nqsqdq + 0.5 γBNγsγdγ (4.1)


(For Ø = 0 condition, Nc = 5.14, Nq = 1, Nr = 0)
Where, c = cohesion of soil
q = effective stress at the bottom of the foundation = γ Df
γ = unit weight of soil
B = width of foundation
Nc, Nq, Nγ = bearing capacity factor
sc, sq, sγ = shape factor
dc, dq, dγ = depth factor
B
sc = 1 + 0.2 Kp L (for any Ø)
sq = sr = 1 (Ø >10˚)
sq = sr = 1 (Ø = 0)
D
√Kp B
dc = 1 + 0.2 (for any Ø)
D
√Kp B
dq = dr = 1 + 0.1 (Ø >10˚)
50

dγ = dr = 1 (Ø = 0)
Kp = tan2 (45 + Ø/2)

Depth,H = 0.5 B tan (45 + Ø/2)

H 1 c1 + H 2 c 2 +⋯+ H n cn
n
∑ Hi
cavg = i=1

4.2.2. Hansen’s Method


This method is also considered the shear strength of soil above the base of the
foundation. Hansen's bearing capacity equation (for vertical load) is express as
follows;

qult= cNcscdc + q Nqsqdq + 0.5 γBNγsγdγ (4.2)


When Ø = 0,

qult= 5.14 su(1 + sc + dc) + q (4.3)


Where,
Nc,Nq,Nr= bearing capacity factor
B
sc = 0.2 L (Ø = 0)
B
sq = 1+ L sin Ø (for all Ø)
B

sγ = 1 – 0.4 L 0.6 (for all Ø)
dc = 0.4k (Ø = 0)
D D
≤1
k = B (for B ; k in radian)
D D
≥1
k = tan-1 B (for B ; k in radian)

dq = 1 + 2 tan-1Ø (1 – sin Ø)2 K (for all Ø)

dγ = 1 (for all Ø)

4.2.3. Bearing Capacity from SPT


51

The Equations of allowable bearing capacity (kip/ft 2) for SPT are


as follows;
( N 1 )60
qnet(all) = 4 (B<4 ft) (4.4)
2
( N 1 ) 60 ( B+1 )
qnet(all) = 4 [ ]
B (B>4.ft) (4.5)

Nη H η B η S η R
N60 = 60 (4.6)

Where,
(N1)60 = CNN60
CN = correction factor
= [1/ (σvo'/Pa)]0.5
N = penetration resistance
ηH = hammer efficiency (%) (0.45 for doughnut hammer)
ηB = correction for borehole diameter
= 0.75 (up to 4 m drill rod)
ηS = sample correction
= 0.8 (with liner: clay)
ηR = correction for rod length
= 1 (65-115 mm diameter)
σvo' = vertical effective stress in KN/m2 or lb/ft2
Pa = 100 KN/m2 or 2000 lb/ft2

By CQHP format, qa from SPT is needed to convert from net to gross pressure
as follows:

qa(gross) = qa(net) + SF
(4.7)

The results of allowable bearing capacity for (Ø = 0) condition by using three


methods and using safety factor is taken as 2.5 and then the results are expressed in
table 4.2.
52

Table4.2. Result of allowable bearing capacity for (Ø = 0) condition (ton/ft2)


Methods Bearing capacity
Meyerhof 0.287
Hansen 0.263
SPT(Braja M Das ) 0.088

The average Allowable Bearing Capacity= (0.287+0.263+0.088)/3= 0.21 ton/ft2


The average Allowable Pressure =0.42 ksf
The total unfactored gravity loads from Table (3.1) = 17466.14 kips
Available foundation area of proposed building = 70 × 90 = 6300 ft2
17466.14
Bearing pressure =
6300
=2.77 ksf > 0.42 ksf
Bearing pressure is greater than the allowable bearing capacity of mat
foundation. Therefore, mat foundation is not suitable for the proposed building. So,
pile foundation is used for proposed structure.

4.3 Design of Pile Foundation and Pile Cap for Case (1)
The design of pile, pile cap and settlement of group piles and single piles are
calculated and then other three cases are also calculated. The material properties, f c’ is
3000psi and fy is 40000psi are also used.

4.3.1. Design of Group Pile Foundation under Axial Load


Pile Group (1) is designed for unfactored load on point 2, 4, 6, 38, 39, 40, 41.
The critical unfactored load is 344.78 kips and so higher full value of 345 kips is used.
These unfactored column loads have been presented in Table (3.3).

4.3.1.1. Pile dimension and allowable bearing capacity


The required soil data are obtained from soil report and factor of safety is
taken as2.5 for groups in deep foundation. Consider 65ft long, 1.5ft diameter straight-
sided shaft-cast-in-place concrete pile.
The average undrained shear strength,
cu(avg)=1/9[(3885.39+12898.98+5049.37+7003.05+4073.16+4468.92+6272.87
+11754.55+ 7948.77)/2]
=3519.73 lb/ft2
From equation 2.12.the ultimate bearing capacity for a pile is,
53

L = Le
(Qu )ult = A p c u N c + p ∑ c a ΔL
L=0

Where,
π π
Ap = (Bb )2 = (1 .5 )2 = 1 .76 ft 2
4 4
2
c u( base) = 7948. 77 /2=3947 .385 lb/ft
D f 65
= = 43 .33> 4
Bb 1.5
Df
> 4 , Nc = 9
From Table 3.1, for Bb

From Table 3.2, for Bb = 1.5ft, Nc= 9


p =πBs =π× 1.5= 4.71 ft
From Table 3.3, for straight-sided shafts drilled concrete pile installed dry or
by the slurry displacement method, if c u(avg) for silt-clay along pile shaft is
3519.73lb/ft2, then ca/cu(avg) = 0.6.The depth of seasonal variation is 3ft to 5ft.
ca = 0.6 cu(avg) = 0.6 × 3519.73 = 2111.84 lb/ft2
From Table 2.4, Effective pile length
Le = L – (depth of seasonal variation)
= 65 – 5 = 60 ft
Qp = 1.76 × 3947.385×9 =62.526 kips
Qf = 4.71 × 2111.84 × 60= 596.806 kips
(Qu)ult = Qp+ Qf
= 659.33 kips
(Qu )ult 659 . 33
= = 263 .73 kips
(Qu) all= FS 2. 5

4.3.1.2 Number of pile and their arrangement


The number piles required to support 345 kips column load will be
n=QuG/Qu(all)=345/263.73=1.31
Try a group of 2 piles arranged in a rectangular pattern with on each side. And
place the pile at 4.5 ft center-to-center spacing with 7 ft x 6.5ft x 2.5ft thick concrete
pile cap. The pile group arrangement is shown in fig 4.1.
54

Figure 4.1 Pile Group Arrangement (2-piles)

The allowable bearing capacity of this pile group can be calculated by the
following two methods.
(a) Block failure of pile group , by using equation ( 2.13 )

(QuG)ult= cuNc( b̄ 2
) + 4 cu( b̄ ) Le
From Table (2.1) Df/B =Df/ ƀ =65/5.5=11.82> 4, Nc =9
From Table (2.2) Bb =1.5ft, Nc =9
Value cu and Le were obtained above,
55

(QuG)ult = 3947.385 x 9 x 5.52 + 4 x 3519.73 x 5.5 x 60


= 5720.72 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult /SF=5720.72/2.5= 2288.29 kips

(b) Sum of ultimate loads of single pile, by using Equation (2.15b)


(QuG)ult= Ge ¿ n ¿ (Qu)ult
S/B = 4.5/1.5=3
From Table (2.5), group efficiency, Ge =0.7
The number of pile = 2 piles
(QuG)ult = 0.7 x 2 x 659.69 = 923.57 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult / SF =932.57/2.5 =369.43 kips(control)
Total load on pile group = unfactored column load + Pile cap weight
= 345+ (7x6.5 x 2.5 x0.15)
= 362.1 kips < (QuG)all =369.43 kips
Therefore, it is acceptable from a bearing capacity point of view.

4.3.1.3 .Pile reinforcement


For piles, a minimum amount of vertical steel reinforcement is 1% of the cross
sectional area of pile and the required longitudinal steel is No.5 bars are used.
As = 0.01 x Ags
=0.01 x π/4 x (1.5)2 x144
= 2.545in2
Number of bars = As / area of no.5 bar
= 2.545/ 0.31
= 8.29 say 9 nos
Perimeter with 3” clear cover = 2 π r
= 2 x 3.14 x (9-3)
= 37.7 in2
Spacing between bars = (Perimeter with 3” clear cover)/(number of
bars)
=37.7/9
= 4.19 in say 4 in

Use 9 # 5 longitudinal bars with 4” c/c spacing in piles.


56

Spirals shall consists of a continuous bar or wire not less than (3/8)’’ diameter
and the clear spacing between turns of the spiral must not exceed 3 in nor be less than
1 in. Therefore, (3/8)”ф spiral steel3” c/c is used throughout the length of pile as
shown in figure4.2.

9#5@ 4"c/c
9#5 longitudinal steel
3/8"pile
18" spiral @3"c/c @ 4" c/c
3" cover
65' 3/8"spiral@3"/3"c/c

3'' cover

18"

Figure4.2. Pile Reinforcement (a) Plan (b) Section

Check for structure pile group capacity


The allowable stress of steel and concrete is taken as 4% of the yield strength
and cylinder strength of concrete.
Structural pile capacity, Qu = (Ags-As)fc+Asfs
fs =0.4 fy =0.4 x 40000 = 16000 psi
fc = 0.4fc’= 0.4x 3000 =1200 psi
Qu = (254.5-2.545)1200 + 2.545x16000 = 343 kips/pile
Structure pile group capacity, (QuG) = n x Qu
= 2 x 343
=686 .1 kip > 369.43 kips
Structural pile group capacity > allowable bearing capacity of pile
So, Structural pile group capacity is satisfactory.

4.3.2. Design of Pile Cap


From the proposed building, column size, unfactored load,factored load and
material properties are taken as follow;
Square column size = 26” x 26”
57

Unfactored column load = 345 kips


Factored column load = 749 kips
28-day concrete strength, fc’ = 3 ksi
Yield strength for steel, fy = 40 ksi
Assume effective depth, d = 21.5 in
For pile group (1), choose the 7ft x6.5ft rectangular shape concrete cap to
cover the pile group arrangement.

Effective allowable bearing capacity of pile group,Re =(allowable bearing capacity of


group)-(pile cap weight)
= 369.43-17.0625
= 352.378 kips
Average load factor = factored load/unfactored load
=749/345
=2.17
Pile reaction for strength design, Ru =Re x average load factor
= 352.378 x 2.17
= 764.64 kips
Ultimate bearing pressure for strength design, qu =Ru / selected area
= 764.64 / (7 x 6.5)
= 16.81 ksf

4.3.2.1. Punching shear check


The two-way shear is shown in the lower left quadrant of section. Let us
assume that the necessary depth has been found by trial and error procedure and a
check with effective depth d=21.5in. The circular punching shear section is at a
distance d/2 from column face which is 10.75 in around the column. The first term is
four piles on the outside of punching shear section, with the diameter of pile being
18” and the length of pile that lies outside the critical section being 10.75 in as shown
in figure4.3.

Assume d= 21.5 in
LAB = 7 ft x 6.5 ft
= 45.5 ft2
58

Lab = 26” +21.5”


= 47.5 in
b0 = 4 (26” +21.5”)
= 190 in

A 7′ B
18in-pile
a 4.5′
b
6.5′

Two-way area
c d
(10.75in around
column)
C D

Figure4.3. Critical Depth of Punching Shear

Punching shear, Vul =ultimate bearing pressure x punching area

= qu x [(LAB - (Lab)2]

=16.81 x [(7 x6.5)-(47.5/12)2]

=501.47 kips
Norminal punching shear strength, ΦVc= Φ4 √ fc ' bo d

= (0.85 x 4 x √ 3000) x190x21.5)/1000

= 760.732 kips >Vul (Satisfactory)

So, the depth d=21.5 in is adequate for punching shear.

4.3.2.2 One way shear or Beam shear check


One-way shear section is in the left area of section as shown in Figure 4.4. In
this section, one pile is entirely in the critical section.

For X- direction

LAB = 7 ft
59

y = [3.5 – (13/12)-(21.5/12)]=0.625 ft

L = 3.5- (13/12) =2.42 ft

One way shear, Vu2 = bearing capacity x one way shear area

= qu x LAC x y

= 16.81x 6.5 x 0.625

= 68.29 kips

Norminal one way shear strength, ΦVu2 = Φ2 √ fc ' b d

= (0.85 x 2 x √ 3000 x 6.5 x12 x 21.5)/1000

= 156.15 kips >Vu2 (Satisfactory)

7′
A B

x
6.5′

d L
C D

Figure4.4. Critical Section of Beam Shear for X-direction

For Y direction

LAC = 6.5 ft

y = [3.25-(13/12)-(21.5/12)]

= 0.375 ft

L = 3.25-(13/12)

= 2.17

One way shear, Vu2 =bearing capacity x one way shear area

= qu x LAB x y

= 16.81 x 7 x 0.375
60

= 44.13kips

Norminal one way strength, ΦVu2 = Φ2√ fc ' b d

= (0.85 x 2 x √ 3000 x7x 12 x 21.5)/1000

= 168.16 kips > Vu2 (Satisfactory)

So, the depth d = 21.5 in is adequate for beam shear.

7′
A B
L

6.5′

d
y
C D

Figure4.5. Critical Section of Beam Shear for Y-direction

4.3.2.3. Flexural design


The critical sections for flexure are indicated in the lower right quadrant.
Bending moment at the face of the column,

Mu = ωuL2/2

For X-direction

ωu = qu x LAB = 16.81 x 6.5 =109.33 kips/ft

Mu = 109.33 x 12 x (2.42)2/2 = 3841.68 kips-in

To determine the required steel area,

Assume a=1.02 in

As = Mu / Φfy (d-a/2)

= 3841.68/[0.9 x40 x(21.5 -1.02/2)]

= 5.08 in2

Check
61

a = Asfy/ (0.85 fc’b)

= 5.08 x 40 / (0.85 x 3 x 6.5 x12)

= 1.02 in (Satisfactory)

Checking the minimum steel ratio,

As(min) =3 √ fc ' bd/fy ≥ 200bd√ f y

= (3 x √ 3000 x 6.5 x12 x21.5)/40000 ≥ (200x 6.5x 12 x 21.5)/40000

= 6.89 in2 ≥ 8.39 in2

Therefore As(min) = 8.39 in2

The controlling value of 8.39 in2 is larger than 5.08 in2 calculated for bending.

For Y-direction

ωu = qu x LAC = 16.81 x 7 =117.67 kips/ft

Mu = 117.67 x 12 x (2.17)2/2 = 3324.58 kips-in

To determine the required steel area,

Assume a = 0.81 in

As = Mu / Φfy (d-a/2)

= 3324.58/ (0.9 x 40 x (21.5 – 0.81/2))

= 4.38 in2

Check

a = Asfy/ (0.85 fc’b)

= 4.38x40/(0.85 x 3 x7x12)

= 0.81 in (Satisfactory)

Checking the minimum steel ratio,

As (min) =3 √ fc ' bd/fy ≥ 200bd/fy

= (3 x √ 3000 x 7x12 x21.5)/40000 ≥ (200x7x 12 x 21.5)/40000

= 7.42in2 ≥ 9.03in2

Therefore,
62

As(min) =9.03 in2

The controlling value of 9.03 in2 is larger than the 5.08in2 calculated for
bending.

So, choose 11#8 bars with 8” c/c in pile cap for X-direction, furnish 8.64 in2 and 12#8
bars with 7” c/c in pile cap for Y-direction, furnish 9.43 in2.

4.3.2.4 Bearing check

All axial forces and bending moment that act at the bottom section of column
must be transferred to the footing at the bearing surface by compression in the
concrete and by reinforcement.

Pile reaction for strength design =Pu = 764.64 kips

The loaded area, A1 = 26” x26”

Design bearing strength, ΦPn = Φ0.85fc’A1√ A 2/ A 1) ≤ Φ 0.85 fc’2 A1

A2 =the area of the base of the largest frustum of pyramid

ΦPn = 0.7 x 0.85 x 3000 x26 x 26x √ 7 x 6.5 x 144 / 26 x 26 ≤ 0.7 x 0.85 x 3000 x 2 x 26

x 26

= 3756.63 kips ≤ 2413.32 kips

So, Design strength = 2413.32 kips > pile reaction = 764.64 kips (Satisfactory)

Determine the temperature and shrinkage steel

For reinforcing yield strength fy = 40000psi, the temp;&shrinkage ratio ρ= 0.002

At&s =ρbh

= 0.002 x 12 x 30= 0.72 in2/ft

Select #4 bars on 3” center, furnish As= 0.78 in2/ft

4.3.2.5 Dowel bars


63

For different concrete compressive strength, the required steel are used no.6
bars in column.

Dowel area = 0.005 x gross area of column

= 0.005 x 26 x 26

= 3.38 in2

From table A-2, use 8#6 bars, furnishing3.35 in2 is adequate.

Required development length for compression steel

Ldb = 0.02 db fy / √ fc ' ≥ 0.0003 dbfy

= (0.02 x 0.75 x 40000) / √ 3000≥ 0.0003 x 0.75 x 40000

= 10.95in ≥ 9in

From above the larger of Ldb = 10.95 in say 11in

Allowable length of dowel bars = 21.5 in > Ldb (Satisfactory )

The minimum lap splice = 0.0005 dbfy

= 0.0005 x 0.75 x 40000

= 15 in > minimum splice length = 8 in

Required total dowel length = 11 +15 = 26 in

Take =2.17 ft

For concrete in contact with ground, a minimum cover 3 in is required for


corrosion protection. With d= 21.5 in, measured from the top of the pile cap to the
center of the upper layer of bars, the total thickness of the pile cap that is required in
order to provide 7 in cover for the lowest steel layer.

Total depth of pile cap, h= 21.5+0.5+1+7=30in =2.5 ft


64

Design result for pile cap (1)

Length of pile cap = 7 ft

Width of pile cap = 6.5 ft

Depth of pile cap = 2.5 ft

Clear rebar cover = 3 in

Pile head inset = 4 in

Number of pile =2

Spacing of piles = 4.5 ft

Edge distance = 6 in (for x direction)

Edge distance = 2.5 ft(for y direction )

11#8 for X-direction


26"x26"

12#8 for Y-direction

(a) Plan

8#6 dowel 2.17′long

11#8 for X-direction

12#8 for Y-direction

3"cover
4"pile head

(b) Section

Figure4.6. Pile Cap(1) Reinforcement


65

4.3.3. Settlement of Pile Group


The settlement of piles in cohesive soil primarily consist of the sum of the
short-term settlement occurring as the load is applied and long-term consolidation
settlement occurring gradually as the excess pore pressures generated by loads are
dissipated.

4.3.3.1. Short-term settlement

Short term settlement can be estimated by semiempirial and empirial methods.

(1) Semiempirial method


By using Equation (2.16)
St = Ss + Sp + Sps
St =(Qpa + αsQfa) L / (Ap Ep)+ CpQpa / (B qp)+ CsQfa / (Dfqp)

Total load on pile group = 362.1 kips

The load per pile = 362.1/ 2

= 181.05 kips

From section 4.3.1.1

Qp =62.881 kips

Qp(all) =62.881/2.5

= 25.11 kips

Qf = 596.806 kips

Qf(all) = 596.806/2.5

= 238.84 kips

Total allowable load = Qp(all) + Qf(all)

=25.11 + 238.84

= 263.96 kips

When the actual load on each pile is 181.05 kips.

Qp(actual) = 25.11(181.05/263.96 ) = 17.22 kips


66

Qf(actual) = 238.84(181.05/263.96) = 163.81 kips


αs = 0.5 for uniform distribution of skin friction
L = 65 ft
Ap = 1.76 ft2
Ep = 3.12x106 psi for concrete
From Table 2.6,Cp = 0.03 for pile in clay
qp = Qp/Abase = 62.881/ 1.76
= 35.73 kips/ ft2
From Equation 2.20,

Cs = [0.93 + 0.16 √ Df / B ] Cp
= [0.93+0.16√ 65/1.5] 0.03
= 0.059
Substituting above values in the expression for St;
From equation 2.17,
Ss = ((17.22+0.5x163.81)65x12x103)/(1.77x144x3.12x106)) =0.097 in
From equation 2.18,
Sp = (0.03x17.22x144)/(1.5x12x35.73) = 0.116 in
From equation 2.19,
Sps = ((0.059x163.81x144)/(65x12x35.73)) =0.05 in
From equation 2.16,
St =0.097+0.1163+0.05 = 0.263 in

(2) Empirical method


By using Equation (2.21)
St = B/100 + (Qua L) / (Ap Ep)
Ep = Ec = 3.12x106 psi
St = 18/100 + (181.05x65x12x103)/(1.77x144x3.12x106)
= 0.36 in
The higher of the above two methods estimated by the semiempirical and
empirical method is 0.36 in.
Settlement of pile group can be calculated by the equation (2.22)

S
G = St √( b̄/ B )
67

=036
√(6.5/ 1.5 )
= 0.75 in

4.3.3.2. Long term settlement

Unit weight of soil is taken from layer 2 of soil report data to calculate the

effective stress of soil. The water table is found below the ground surface at 4ft.

σ'(at length L)
=(53.03x10+71.76x15+49.3x5+51.78x5+58.02x5+57.44x5+45.55x10+
58.65x10+44.34x15)/1000
=4.397 kip/ft2
=2.20 ton/ft2
Moisture content,ω = 22.68%
PL = 24.69%
LL = 43.7%
Liquidity Index = (ω-PL)/(LL-PL)
= (22.68-24.69)/(43.7-24.69)
=-0.11
From figure 2.5, Ṕc = 20 ton/ft2
Over Consolidation Ratio (OCR), = Ṕc/ σ'
=20/2.20
= 9.10 >4
OCR is greater than 4, therefore the clay soil is highly overconsolidation. So,
the consolidation settlement due to loads on pile foundations would not occur. And
then other layers are also overconsolidation.
The calculated settlement of pile group is 0.75 in. This is less than the
allowable settlement of 1 in. Therefore the design pile diameter, length and group
arrangement is acceptable.

4.3.4. Design of Single Pile Foundation under Axial Load


The design of pile and settlement of single pile is calculated by the following;
68

4.3.4.1. Pile Dimension and Allowable bearing Capacity


Consider 65ft long, 3ft diameter straight-sided shaft cast-in-place concrete
pile. From section 4.3.1.1.The average undrained shear strength
cu(avg) =3519.73 lb/ft2
2
c u( base) =3947 .385 lb/ ft

From Equation 2.12


L = Le

( Qu )ult = Ap cu Nc + p L=o ca ΔL

Where,
π π
Ap = (Bb )2 = (3 )2 = 7 . 065 ft 2
4 4
Df 65
= = 21. 67> 4
Bb 3
Df
> 4 , Nc = 9
From Table 2.1, for Bb

From Table 2.2, for Bb = 3ft, Nc=7


The lower of these two values is 7
p =πBs=π× 3= 9.42 ft
From Table 3.3, for straight-sided shafts drilled concrete pile installed dry or
by the slurry displacement method, if c u(avg) for silty-clay along pile shaft is
3519.73lb/ft2, then ca/cu(avg) = 0.6.The safety factor 2.5 is used.
ca = 0.6 cu (avg) = 0.6 × 3519.73 = 2111.84 lb/ft2
From Table 2.4,
Le = L – (depth of seasonal variation)
= 65 – 5 = 60 ft
Qp = (7.065x3947.385x7)/1000 =195.36 kips
Qf = (9.42× 2111.84 × 60)/1000= 1193.61 kips
(Qu)ult = Qp+ Qf
= 1388.83 kips
69

(Qu )ult 1193. 61


= = 555 .53 kips
(Qu) all = FS 2.5
(Qu) all = 555.53kips is greater than 345 kips. Therefore, it is acceptable from a
bearing capacity point of view.

4.3.4.2 Pile reinforcement


For piles, a minimum amount of vertical steel reinforcement is 1 % of the
cross sectional area of pile. The required longitudinal steel in piles are used no.9 bars.
As = 0.01 x Ags
=0.01 x π/4 x (3)2 x 144 =10.1736 in2
Number of bars = As / area of no.9 bar
= 10.1736/ 1
= 10.1736 say 11 nos
Perimeter with 3” clear cover = 2 π r
= 2 x 3.14 x (18-3)
= 94.2 in
Spacing between bars = (Perimeter with 3” clear cover)/(number of
bars)
= 94.2/11
= 8.564 in say 9 in
Use 11 # 9 longitudinal bars with 9” c/c spacing in piles.
Spirals shall consists of a continuous bar or wire not less than (3/8)’’ diameter
and the clear spacing between turns of the spiral must not exceed 3 in nor be less than
1 in. Therefore, (3/8)”ф spiral steel3” c/c is used throughout the length of pile as
shown in fig(4.7).
70

(a) Plan

(b)Section
Figure4.7. Pile Reinforcement (a) Plan (b) Section

Check structure single pile capacity.


The allowable stress of steel and concrete is taken as 4% of the yield strength
and cylinder strength of concrete.
71

Structural pile capacity, Qu = (Ags-As)fc+Asfs


fs =0.4 fy =0.4 x 40000 = 16000 psi
fc = 0.4fc’= 0.4x 3000 =1200 psi
Qu = ((1017.36-10.1736)1200 + 10.1736x16000)/1000 =1371.4 kips >345 kips
Structural strength of single pile capacity > allowable bearing capacity of pile
So, Structural design is satisfactory.

4.3.5. Settlement of Single Pile


The settlement of piles in cohesive soil primarily consist of the sum of the
short-term settlement occurring as the load is applied and long-term consolidation
settlement occurring gradually as the excess pore pressures generated by loads are
dissipated.Short term settlement can be estimated by semiempirial and empirial
methods.

(1) Semiempirial method


By using Equation (2.16)
St = Ss + Sp + Sps
St =(Qpa +αs Qfa) L / (Ap Ep)+ CpQpa / (B qp)+ CsQfa / (Dfqp)

Total load on pile group = 345 kips

From section 4.3.4.1

Qp =195.36 kips

Qp(all) =195.36/2.5

= 78.144 kips

Qf = 1193.61 kips

Qf(all) = 1193.61/2.5

= 477.44 kips

Total allowable load = Qp(all) + Qf(all)

=78.144 + 477.44

= 555.59 kips when the actual load on each pile is 345 kips

Qp(actual) = 78.144(345/555.59 ) = 48.52 kips


72

Qf(actual) = 477.44(345/555.59) = 296.475 kips


αs = 0.5 for uniform distribution of skin friction
L = 65 ft
Ap = 7.07 ft2
Ep = 3.12x106 psi for concrete
From Table 2.6,Cp = 0.03 for pile in clay
qp = Qp/Abase = 195.36/ 7.07
= 27.65 kips/ ft2
From Equation 2.20,

Cs = [0.93 + 0.16 x √ Df / B ] Cp
= [0.93+0.16√ 65/3] 0.03
= 0.050

Substituting above values in the expression for St;


From equation 2.17,
Ss= ((48.52+0.5x296.475)65x12x103)/(7.07x144x3.12x106))
=0.04835in
From equation 2.18,
Sp= (0.03x48.52x144)/(3x12x27.65) = 0.2105 in
From equation 2.19,
Sps= ((0.050x296.475x144)/(65x12x27.65)) =0.09897 in
From equation 2.16,
St=0.04835+0.2105+0.09897 = 0.3579 in

(2) Empirical method


By using Equation (2.21)
St = B/100 + (Qua L) / (Ap Ep)
Ep = Ec = 3.12x106 psi
St = 36/100 + (345x65x12x103)/ (7.07x144x3.12x106)
= 0.4448 in
The higher of the above two values estimated by the semiempirical and
empirical method is 0.4448 in.
73

The calculated settlement of single pile is 0.4448 in. This is less than the
allowable settlement of 2 in. Therefore, the designed pile diameter and length is
acceptable.

4.4 Design of Pile foundation and Pile Cap for Case (2)
The design of pile, pile cap and settlement of pile group is calculated by the
following;

4.4.1. Design of Group Pile Foundation under Axial Load


Pile Group (2) is designed for unfactored load on point3, 5, 19, 27, 28, 29, 32,
34, 35, 37. The critical unfactored load is 420.64kips and so higher full value of 421
kips is used. These unfactored column loads have been presented in Table 3.3.

4.4.1.1. Pile dimension and allowable bearing capacity


The required soil data are obtained from soil report and factor of safety is
taken as2.5 for groups in deep foundation. Consider 65ft long, 1.5ft diameter straight-
sided shaft-cast-in-place concrete pile.
The average undrained shear strength,
cu(avg)=1/9[(3885.39+12898.98+5049.37+7003.05+4073.16+4468.92+6272.87
+11754.55+ 7948.77)/2]
=3519.73 lb/ft2
From equation2.12.the ultimate bearing capacity for a pile is,
L = Le
(Qu )ult = A p c u N c + p ∑ c a ΔL
L=0

Where,
π π
Ap = (Bb )2 = (1 .5 )2 = 1 .76 ft 2
4 4
2
c u( base) = 7948. 77 /2=3947 .385 lb/ft
D f 65
= = 43 .33> 4
Bb 1.5
74

Df
> 4 , Nc = 9
From Table 2.1, for Bb

From Table 2.2, for Bb = 1.5ft, Nc= 9


p =πBs =π× 1.5 = 4.71 ft
From Table 3.3, for straight-sided shafts drilled concrete pile installed dry or
by the slurry displacement method, if c u(avg) for silt-clay along pile shaft is
3519.73lb/ft2, then ca/cu(avg) = 0.6.The depth of seasonal variation is 3ft to 5ft.
ca = 0.6 cu(avg) = 0.6 × 3519.73 = 2111.84 lb/ft2
From Table 2.4, Effective pile length
Le = L – (depth of seasonal variation)
= 65 – 5 = 60 ft
Qp = 1.76 × 3947.385 =62.526 kips
Qf = 4.71 × 2111.84 × 60= 597.33 kips
(Qu)ult = Qp+ Qf
= 659.33 kips
(Qu )ult 659 . 33
= = 263 .73 kips
(Qu) all= FS 2. 5

4.4.1.2 Number of pile and their arrangement


The number piles required to support 421 kips column load will be
n=QuG/Qu(all)=421/263.96=1.59
Try a group of 2 piles arranged in a rectangular pattern with on each side. And
place the pile at 4.5ft center-to-center spacing with 7ft x 6.5ft x 3ft thick concrete pile
cap. The pile group arrangement is shown in figure 4.8.
75

3′

Figure 4.8.Pile group Arrangement (2-piles)

The allowable bearing capacity of this pile group can be calculated by the
following two methods.
(a)Block failure of pile group, by using equation (2.13)

(QuG)ult= cuNc( b̄ 2
) + 4 cu( b̄ ) Le
From Table (2.1) Df/B =Df/ ƀ =65/1.5=43.33> 4,Nc =9
From Table (2.2) Bb = 1.5ft, Nc =9

Value cu and Le were obtained above,


(QuG)ult = 3947.385 x 9 x 5.52 + 4 x 3519.73 x 5.5 x 60
= 5720.72 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult /SF=5720.72/2.5= 2288.29 kips

(b)Sum of ultimate loads of single pile, by using Equation (2.15b)


(QuG)ult= Ge ¿ n ¿ (Qu)ult
S/B = 4.5/1.5=3
From Table (2.5) , Ge =0.7
The number of pile = 2 piles
(QuG)ult = 0.7 x 2 x 659.69 = 923.85 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult / SF =932.57/2.5 =369.54 kips
76

Lower of QuG)all is 369.54 kips.


Total load on pile group = unfactored column load + Pile cap weight
= 421+( 7x6.5 x 3 x0.15)
= 441.5 kips > (QuG)all =369.54 kips
Therefore, it is not acceptable from a bearing capacity point of view and a
greater number of piles should use.
Try a group of 3 piles. And place the piles at 4.5ft center-to-center spacing
with 7ftx6.5ftx3ft thick concrete cap. The pile group arrangement is shown in figure
4.9.

S=4.5′

S=4.5′

(a)Plan

4.5′

(b)Section A-A
Figuren4.9. Pile Group Arrangement for Pile Group (2)
77

The allowable bearing capacity of pile group can be calculated by the following
two methods.
(a) Block failure of pile group , by using equation ( 2.13 )

(QuG)ult= cuNc( b̄ 2
) + 4 cu( b̄ ) Le
From Table (2.1) Df/B =Df/ ƀ =65/1.5=43.33> 4, Nc =9
From Table (2.2) Bb = 1.5ft, Nc =6
Value cu and Le were obtained above,
(QuG)ult = 3947.385 x 6 x 5.52 + 4 x 3519.73 x 5.5 x 60
= 5362.49 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult /SF=5362.49/2.5= 2145.0 kips

(b) Sum of ultimate loads of single pile, by using Equation (2.15b)


(QuG)ult= Ge ¿ n ¿ (Qu)ult
S/B = 4.5/1.5=3
From Table (2.5), group efficiency, Ge =0.7
The number of pile = 3 piles
(QuG)ult = 0.7 x 3 x 659.69 = 1385.77 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult / SF =1385.77/2.5 =554.31kips(control)
Total load on pile group = unfactored column load + Pile cap weight
= 421+ (7x6.5 x 3 x0.15)
= 441.5 kips < (QuG)all =554.31 kips
The group capacity is 554.31 kips, which is greater than the actual load
441.5kips on the group. Therefore, it is acceptable from a bearing capacity point of
view.

4.4.1.3 .Pile reinforcement


For piles, a minimum amount of vertical steel reinforcement is 1% of the cross
sectional area of pile and the required longitudinal steel is no.5 bars are used.
As = 0.01 x Ags
=0.01 x π/4 x (1.5)2 x 144 =2.545 in2
Number of bars =As / area of no.5 bar
= 2.545/ 0.31
78

= 8.29 say 9 nos


Perimeter with 3” clear cover = 2 π r
= 2 x 3.14 x (9-3)
= 37.7 in2
Spacing between bars = (Perimeter with 3” clear cover)/ (number of
bars)
=37.7/9
= 4.19 in say 4 in
Use 9 # 5 longitudinal-bar with 4” c/c spacing in piles.
Spirals shall consists of a continuous bar or wire not less than (3/8)’’ diameter
and the clear spacing between turns of the spiral must not exceed 3 in nor be less than
1 in. Therefore, (3/8)”ф spiral steel 3” c/c is used throughout the length of pile as
shown in figure 4.10.

9#5@ 4"c/c
9#5 longitudinal steel
18"pile
3/8" spiral @3"c/c @ 4" c/c
3" cover
65' 3/8"spiral @ 3"c/c

3'' cover

18"

Figure 4.10.Pile Reinforcement (a) Plan (b) Section

Check for structure pile group efficiency


The allowable stress of steel and concrete is taken as 4% of the yield strength
and cylinder strength of concrete.
Structural pile capacity, Qu = (Ags-As)fc+Asfs
fs =0.4 fy =0.4 x 40000 = 16000 psi
fc = 0.4fc’= 0.4x 3000 =1200 psi
Qu = (254.5-2.545)1200 + 2.545x16000 = 343 kips/pile
Structure pile group capacity, (QuG) = n x Qu
= 3 x 343
79

=1029.1 kip > 369.43 kips


Structural pile group capacity > allowable bearing capacity of pile
So, Structural pile group capacity is satisfactory.

4.4.2. Design of Pile Cap


From the proposed building, column size, unfactored load, factored load and
material properties are taken as follow;
Square column size = 26” x 26”
Unfactored column load = 421 kips
Factored column load = 937 kips
28-day concrete strength, fc’ = 3 ksi
Yield strength for steel, fy = 40 ksi
Assume effective depth, d = 22.5 in
For pile group (2), choose the 7ft x6.5ftx3ft rectangular pattern concrete cap to
cover the pile group arrangement.
Effective allowable bearing capacity of pile group, Re =(allowable bearing
capacity of
group)-(pile cap
weight)

= 554.3-20.475
= 533.83 kips
Average load factor = factored load/unfactored load
=937/421
=2.23
Pile reaction for strength design, Ru =Re x average load factor
= 533.83 x 2.23
= 1188.13 kips
Ultimate bearing pressure for strength design, qu =Ru/ selected area
= 1188.13/ (7 x 6.5)
= 26.11 ksf

4.4.2.1. Punching shear check


80

The two-way shear is shown in the lower left quadrant of section. Let us
assume that the necessary depth has been found by trial and error procedure and a
check with effective depth d=22.5in. The circular punching shear section is at a
distance d/2 from column face which is 11.25 in around the column. The first term is
four piles on the outside of punching shear section, with the diameter of pile being
18” and the length of pile that lies outside the critical section being 11.25 in as shown
in figure 4.11.

Assume d= 22.5 in
LAB = 7 ft x 6.5 ft
= 45.5 in2
Lab = 26” +22.5”
= 48.5 in
b0 = 4 (26” +22.5”)
= 194 in

7"
18"-pile A B

a b

d 4.5"
c

Two-way area
(11.25in around
C D
column)

Figure4.11.Critical Depth of Punching Shear

Punching shear, Vul =ultimate bearing pressure x punching area

= qu x [(LAB - (Lab)2]

= 26.11 x [(7 x6.5)-(48.5/12)2]

=761.57 kips
Norminal punching shear strength, ΦVul= Φ4 √ fc ' bo d

= (0.85 x 4 x √ 3000x194
81

x22.5)/1000

= 812.875kips >Vu1 (Satisfactory)

So, the depth d=22.5 in is adequate for punching shear.

4.4.2.2. One way shear or Beam shear check

One –way shear section is in the left area of section as shown in figure 4.12. In
this section, one pile is entirely in the critical section.

For X- direction

LAB = 7 ft

y = [3.5 – (13/12)-(22.5/12)]=0.51467ft

L = 3.5- (13/12) =2.42 ft

One way shear, Vu2 = bearing capacity x one way shear

= qu x LAB x y

= 26.11x 7 x 0.5146

= 99.01 kips

Norminal one way shear strength, ΦVu2 = Φ2 √ fc ' b d

= (0.85 x 2 x √ 3000x 7 x12x22.5)/1000

= 175.98 kips > Vu2 (Satisfactory)


7′
A B

26"x26
"
x
6.5′
d
L

C D

Figure4.12. Critical Section of Beam Shear for X-direction


82

For Y direction

LAC = 6.5ft

y = [3.25-(13/12)-(22.5/12)]

= 0.29167ft

L = 3.25-(13/12)

= 2.17ft

7′

A B
L
26"x26"

6.5′
4.5"
d
y
C D

Figure4.13.Critical Section of Beam Shear for Y-direction

One way shear, Vu2 =bearing capacity x one way shear area

= qu x LAC x y

= 26.11 x 6.5 x 0.29167

= 49.51 kips

Norminal one way strength, ΦVu2 = Φ2 √ fc ' b d

= (0.85 x 2 x √ 3000 x6. 5 x 12 x

22.5)/1000

= 163.41 kips > Vu2 (Satisfactory)

So, the depth d = 22.5 in is adequate for beam shear.


83

4.4.2.3. Flexural design

The critical sections for flexure are indicated in the lower right quadrant.
Bending moment at the face of the column,

Mu = ωuL2/2

For X-direction

ωu = qu x LAB = 26.11 x 6.5 =169.72 kips/ft

Mu = 169.72 x 12 x (2.42)2/2 = 5963.51 kips-in

To determine the required steel area,

Assume a=1.53 in

As = Mu / Φfy (d-a/2)

= 5963.51/[0.9 x40 x (22.5 -1.53/2)]

= 7.62 in2

Check

a = Asfy/ (0.85 fc’b)

= 7.62 x 40 / (0.85 x 3 x 6.5 x12)

= 1.53 in (Satisfactory)

Checking the minimum steel ratio,

As(min) =3 √ f c ’ bd/fy ≥ 200bd/fy

= (3 x√ 3000 x 6.5 x12 x22.5)/40000 ≥ (200x 6.5x 12 x 22.5)/40000

= 7.2 in2 ≥ 8.78 in2

Therefore As(min) = 8.78 in2

The controlling value of 8.78 in2 is larger than 7.62 in2 calculated for bending.

For Y-direction

ωu = qu x LAC = 26.11 x 7 =182.77 kips/ft


84

Mu = 182.77 x 12 x (2.17)2/2 = 5163.87 kips-in

To determine the required steel area,

Assume a = 1.22 in

As = Mu / Φfy (d-a/2)

= 5163.87/(0.9 x 40 x (22.5 – 1.22/2))

= 6.55 in2

Check

a = Asfy/(0.85 fc’b)

= 6.55x40/(0.85 x 3 x7x12 )

= 1.22in (Satisfactory)

Checking the minimum steel ratio,

As(min) =3 √ f c ’ bd/fy ≥ 200bd/fy

= (3 x √ 3000 x 7 x12 x22.5)/40000 ≥ (200x 7x 12 x


22.5)/40000

= 7.76in2 ≥ 9.45in2

Therefore,

As(min) = 9.45 in2

The controlling value of 9.45 in2 is larger than the 6.55in2 calculated for
bending.

So, choose 12#8 bars with 7” c/c in pile cap for X-direction, furnish 9.43 in 2 and 13#8
bars with 8” c/c in pile cap for Y-direction, furnish 10.218 in2.

4.4.2.4. Bearing check

All axial forces and bending moment that act at the bottom section of column
must be transferred to the footing at the bearing surface by compression in the
concrete and by reinforcement.
85

Pile reaction for strength design =Pu = 1188.13 kips

The loaded area, A1 = 26” x26”

Design bearing strength, ΦPn = Φ0.85fc’A1√ ( A 2/ A 1) ≤ Φ 0.85 fc’2 A1

A2 =the area of the base of the largest frustum of pyramid

ΦPn = 0.7 x 0.85 x 3000 x26 x 26x √ (7 x 6.5 x 144 /26 x 26)≤ 0.7 x 0.85 x

3000 x 2 x 26 x 26

= 3756.63 kips ≤ 2413.32 kips

So, Design strength = 2413.32 kips > pile reaction = 1188.13 kips (Satisfactory)

Determine the temperature and shrinkage of steel.

For reinforcing yield strength fy = 40000psi, the temp:& shrinkage ratio, ρ= 0.002

At&s =ρbh

= 0.002 x 12 x 30

= 0.72 in2/ft

Select #4 bars on 3” center, furnish As = 0.78 in2/ft

4.4.2.5. Dowel bars

For different concrete compressive strength, the required steel is used no.6
bars in column.

Dowel area = 0.005 x gross area of column

= 0.005 x 26 x 26

= 3.38 in2

From table A-2, use 8#6 bars, furnishing3.35 in2 is adequate.

Required development length for compression steel

Ldb = 0.02 db fy / √ f c ’ ≥ 0.0003 dbfy

= (0.02 x 0.75 x 40000) /√ 3000 ≥ 0.0003 x 0.75 x 40000

= 10.95in ≥ 9in
86

From above the larger of Ldb = 10.95 in say 11in

Allowable length of dowel bars = 22.5 in > Ldb (Satisfactory)

The minimum lap splice = 0.0005 dbfy

= 0.0005 x 0.75 x 40000

= 15 in > minimum splice length = 8 in

Required total dowel length = 11 +15 = 26 in

Take =2.17 ft

For concrete in contact with ground, a minimum cover 3 in is required for


corrosion protection. With d= 22.5 in, measured from the top of the pile cap to the
center of the upper layer of bars, the total thickness of the pile cap that is required in
order to provide 7 in cover for the lowest steel layer.

Total depth of pile cap, h= 22.5+0.5+1+7=31in =2.583 ft

Design result for pile cap (2)

Length of pile cap = 7 ft

Width of pile cap = 6.5 ft

Depth of pile cap = 3 ft

Clear rebar cover = 3 in

Pile head inset = 4 in

Number of pile =3

Spacing of piles = 5.5 ft

Edge distance = 6 in

12#8 for X-direction


26"x26"

13#8 for Y-direction

(a)Plan
87

8#6 dowel 2.17′ long


13#8 for Y-direction
12#8 for X-direction

3" cover
4" pile head

(b)Section

Figure4.14.Pile Cap (2) Reinforcement

4.4.3. Settlement of Pile Group


The settlement of piles in cohesive soil primarily consist of the sum of the
short-term settlement occurring as the load is applied and long-term consolidation
settlement occurring gradually as the excess pore pressures generated by loads are
dissipated.

4.4.3.1. Short-term settlement

Short term settlement can be estimated by semiempirial and empirial methods.

(1)Semiempirial method

By using Equation (2.16)


St = Ss + Sp + Sps
St =(Qpa +αs Qfa) L / (Ap Ep)+ CpQpa / (B qp)+ CsQfa / (Dfqp)

Total load on pile group = 441.5 kips

The load per pile = 441.5/ 3

= 147.16 kips

From section 4.4.1.1,

Qp =62.8 kips

Qp(all) =62.8/2.5

= 25.11 kips

Qf = 597.11 kips
88

Qf(all) = 597.11/2.5

= 238.84 kips

Total allowable load = Qp(all) + Qf(all)

=25.11 + 238.84

= 263.96 kips

When the actual load on each pile is 147.16 kips

Qp(actual) = 25.11(147.16/263.96 ) = 14.00 kips

Qf(actual) = 238.84(147.16/236.96) = 133.16 kips


αs = 0.5 for uniform distribution of skin friction
L = 65 ft
Ap = 1.77 ft2
Ep = 3.12x106 psi for concrete
From Table 2.6,Cp = 0.03 for pile in clay
qp = Qp/Abase = 62.8/ 1.77
= 35.53 kips/ ft2
From Equation 2.20,

Cs = [0.93 + 0.16 x √ Df / B ] Cp
= [0.93+0.16√ 65/1.5] 0.03
=0.059
Substituting above values in the expression for St;
From equation 2.17,
Ss = ((14.00+0.5x133.16)65x12x103)/(1.77x144x3.12x106)) =0.079 in
From equation 2.18,
Sp = (0.03x14.00x144)/(1.5x12x35.53) = 0.0946 in
From equation 2.19,
Sps = ((0.059x133.16x144)/(65x12x35.53)) =0.0408 in
From equation 2.16,
St =0.079+0.0946+0.0408 = 0.215 in

(2)Empirical method
By using Equation (2.21)
89

St = B/100 + (Qua L) / (Ap Ep)


Ep = Ec = 3.12x106 psi
St = 18/100 + (147.16x65x12x103)/(1.77x144x3.12x106)
= 0.32 in
The higher of the above two values estimated by the semiempirical and
empirical method is 0.32 in.
Settlement of pile group can be calculated by the equation (2.22)

S
G = St √( b̄/ B )
= 0.32√ (5.5/1.5)

= 0.621 in

4.4.3.2. Long term settlement

Unit weight of soil is taken from layer 2 of soil report data to calculate the

effective stress of soil. The water table is found below the ground surface at 4ft.

'(at length L)
σ

=(53.03x10+71.76x15+49.3x5+51.78x5+58.02x5+57.44x5+45.
55x10+58.65x10+44.34x15)/1000
=4.397 kip/ft2
=2.20 ton/ft2
Moisture content, ω = 22.68%
PL = 24.69%
LL = 43.7%
Liquidity Index = (ω-PL)/(LL-PL)
= (22.68-24.69)/(43.7-24.69)
=-0.11
From figure 2.5, Ṕc = 20ton/ft2
Over Consolidation Ratio (OCR), = Ṕc/ σ'
=20/2.20
90

= 9.10 >4
OCR is greater than 4, therefore the clay soil is highly overconsolidation. So,
the consolidation settlement due to loads on pile foundations would not occur. And
then other layers are also overconsolidation.
The calculated settlement of pile group is 0.621 in. This is less than the
allowable settlement of 1 in. Therefore the design pile diameter, length and group
arrangement is acceptable.

4.4.4. Design of Single Pile Foundation under Axial Load


The design of pile and settlement of single pile is calculated by the following;

4.4.4.1. Pile Dimension and Allowable bearing Capacity


Consider 65ft long, 3ft diameter straight-sided shaft cast-in-place concrete
pile.
From section 4.4.1.1.The average undrained shear strength
cu(avg) =3519.73 lb/ft2
2
c u( base) =3947 .385 lb/ ft

From Equation 2.12


L = Le

( Qu )ult = Ap cu Nc + p L=o ca ΔL

Where,
π π
Ap = (Bb )2 = (3 )2 = 7 . 065 ft 2
4 4
Df 65
= = 21. 67> 4
Bb 3
Df
> 4 , Nc = 9
From Table 3.1, for Bb

From Table 3.2, for Bb = 3ft, Nc=7


The lower of these two values is 7
p =πBs =π× 3= 9.42 ft
91

From Table 3.3, for straight-sided shafts drilled concrete pile installed dry or
by the slurry displacement method, if c u(avg) for silt-clay along pile shaft is
3519.73lb/ft2, then ca/cu(avg) = 0.6.The safety factor 2.5 is used.
ca = 0.6 cu(avg) = 0.6 × 3519.73 = 2111.84 lb/ft2
From Table 2.4,
Le = L – (depth of seasonal variation)
= 65 – 5 = 60 ft
Qp = (7.065x3947.385x7)/1000 =195.36 kips
Qf = (9.42× 2111.84 × 60)/1000= 1193.61 kips
(Qu)ult = Qp+ Qf
= 1388.83 kips
(Qu )ult 1193. 61
= = 555 .53 kips
(Qu) all = FS 2.5
(Qu) all = 555.53kips is greater than 421 kips. Therefore, it is acceptable from a
bearing capacity point of view.

4.4.4.2 Pile reinforcement


For piles, a minimum amount of vertical steel reinforcement is 1 % of the
cross sectional area of pile. The required longitudinal steel in pile is used no.9 bars.
As = 0.01 x Ags
=0.01 x π/4 x (3)2 x 144 =10.1736 in2
Number of bars = As / area of no.9 bar
= 10.1736/ 1
= 10.1736 say 11 nos
Perimeter with 3” clear cover = 2 π r
= 2 x 3.14 x (18-3)
= 94.2 in
Spacing between bars = (Perimeter with 3” clear cover)/(number of
bars)
= 94.2/11
= 8.564 in say 9 in
Use 11 # 9 longitudinal bar with 9” c/c spacing in piles.
92

Spirals shall consists of a continuous bar or wire not less than (3/8)’’ diameter
and the clear spacing between turns of the spiral must not exceed 3 in nor be less than
1 in. Therefore, (3/8)”ф spiral steel3” c/c is used throughout the length of pile.

(a) Plan

(b)Section

Figure4.15.Pile Reinforcement (a) Plan (b) Section


93

Check structure single pile capacity.


The allowable stress of steel and concrete is taken as 4% of the yield strength
and cylinder strength of concrete.
Structural pile capacity, Qu = (Ags-As)fc+Asfs
fs =0.4 fy =0.4 x 40000 = 16000 psi
fc = 0.4fc’= 0.4x 3000 =1200 psi
Qu = ((1017.36-10.1736)1200 + 10.1736x16000)/1000 = 1371.4 kips > 421 kips
Structural strength of single pile capacity > allowable bearing capacity of pile
So, Structural design is satisfactory.

4.4.5. Settlement of Single Pile


The settlement of piles in cohesive soil primarily consist of the sum of the
short-term settlement occurring as the load is applied and long-term consolidation
settlement occurring gradually as the excess pore pressures generated by loads are
dissipated. Short term settlement can be estimated by semiempirial and empirial
methods.

(1)Semiempirial method

By using Equation (2.16)


St = Ss + Sp + Sps
St =(Qpa +αs Qfa) L / (Ap Ep)+ CpQpa / (B qp)+ CsQfa / (Dfqp)

Total load on pile group = 421 kips

From section 4.4.4.1

Qp =195.36 kips

Qp(all) =195.36/2.5

= 78.144 kips

Qf = 1193.61 kips

Qf(all) = 1193.61/2.5
94

= 477.44 kips

Total allowable load = Qp(all) + Qf(all)

=78.144 + 477.44

= 555.59 kips when the actual load on each pile is 421 kips

Qp(actual) = 78.144(421/555.59 ) = 59.214 kips

Qf(actual) = 477.44(421/555.59) = 361.786 kips


αs = 0.5 for uniform distribution of skin friction
L = 65 ft
Ap = 7.07 ft2
Ep = 3.12x106 psi for concrete
From Table 2.6,Cp = 0.03 for pile in clay
qp = Qp/Abase = 195.36/ 7.07
= 27.65 kips/ ft2
From Equation 2.20,

Cs = [0.93 + 0.16 x √ Df / B ] Cp
= [0.93+0.16√ 65/3] 0.03
=0.050
Substituting above values in the expression for St;
From equation 2.17,
Ss = ((59.214+0.5x361.786)65x12x103)/(7.07x144x3.12x106)) =0.059in
From equation 2.18,
Sp = (0.03x59.214x144)/(3x12x27.65) = 0.257 in
From equation 2.19,
Sps = ((0.050x361.786x144)/(65x12x27.65)) =0.1207 in
From equation 2.16,
St =0.059+0.257+0.1207 = 0.4367 in

(2)Empirical method
By using Equation (2.21)
St = B/100 + (Qua L) / (Ap Ep)
Ep = Ec = 3.12x106 psi
95

St = 36/100 + (421x65x12x103)/ (7.07x144x3.12x106)


= 0.4635 in
The higher of the above two values estimated by the semiempirical and
empirical method is 0.4635 in.
The calculated settlement of single pile is 0.4635 in. This is less than the
allowable settlement of 2 in. Therefore, the designed pile diameter and length is
acceptable.

4.5 Design of Pile Foundation and Pile Cap for Case (3)
The design of pile, pile cap and settlement of pile group is calculated by the
following;

4.5.1. Design of Group Pile Foundation under Axial load


Pile Group (3) is designed for unfactored load on point 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 16,
18, 21, 23, 25, 26. The critical unfactored load is 598.27kips and so higher full value
of 599 kips is used. These unfactored column loads have been presented in Table 3.3.

4.5.1.1. Pile dimension and allowable bearing capacity


The required soil data are obtained from soil report and factor of safety is
taken as2.5 for groups in deep foundation. Consider 65ft long, 1.5ft diameter straight-
sided shaft-cast-in-place concrete pile.
The average undrained shear strength,
cu(avg)=1/9[(3885.39+12898.98+5049.37+7003.05+4073.16+4468.92+6272.87
+11754.55+ 7948.77)/2]
=3519.73 lb/ft2
From equation 2.12, the ultimate bearing capacity for a pile is,
L = Le
(Qu )ult = A p c u N c + p ∑ c a ΔL
L=0

Where,
π π
Ap = (Bb )2 = (1 .5 )2 = 1 .76 ft 2
4 4
96

2
c u( base) = 7948. 77 /2=3947 .385 lb/ft

Df 1.5¿
= 65 ¿ = 43.33> 4¿
Bb ¿
Df
> 4 , Nc = 9
From Table2.1, for Bb

From Table 2.2, for Bb = 1.5ft, Nc= 9


p =πBs =π× 1.5= 4.71 ft
From Table 2.3, for straight-sided shafts drilled concrete pile installed dry or
by the slurry displacement method, if c u(avg) for silt-clay along pile shaft is
3519.73lb/ft2, then ca/cu(avg) = 0.6.The depth of seasonal variation is 3ft to 5 ft.
ca = 0.6 cu(avg) = 0.6 × 3519.73 = 2111.84 lb/ft2
From Table 2.4, Effective pile length
Le = L – (depth of seasonal variation)
= 65 – 5 = 60 ft
Qp = 1.76 × 3947.385x9 =62.5 kips
Qf = 4.71 × 2111.84 × 60= 597kips
(Qu)ult = Qp+ Qf
= 659.5 kips
(Qu )ult 659 .5
= = 263 .8 kips
(Qu) all= FS 2. 5

4.5.1.2 Number of pile and their arrangement


The number piles required to support 599 kips column load will be
n=QuG/Qu(all)=599/263.8=2.27
Try a group of 3 piles arranged in a square pattern with on each side. And
place the pile at 5.5 ft center-to-center spacing with 8 ft x 8ft x 3ft thick concrete pile
cap. The pile group arrangement is shown in fig 4.16.
97

S=5.5′

(a)Plan

(b)Section
Figure 4.16.Pile Group Arrangement
The allowable bearing capacity of this pile group can be calculated by the
following two methods.
(a)Block failure of pile group, by using equation (2.13)

(QuG)ult= cuNc( b̄ 2
) + 4 cu( b̄ ) Le
From Table (2.1) Df/B =Df/ ƀ =65/7=9.29> 4, Nc =9
From Table (2.2) Bb = 7ft, Nc =6

Value cu and Le were obtained above,


(QuG)ult = 3947.385 x 9 x 72 + 4 x 3519.73 x 7 x 60
98

= 7073.68 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult /SF=7073.68/2.5= 2829.5kips

(b)Sum of ultimate loads of single pile, by using Equation (2.15b)


(QuG)ult= Ge ¿ n ¿ (Qu)ult
S/B = 5.5/1.5=3.667
From Table (2.5) , group efficiency, Ge =0.75
The number of pile = 3 piles
(QuG)ult = 0.75 x 3 x 659.69 = 1484.75 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult / SF =1484.75/2.5 =593.90 kips(control)
Total load on pile group = unfactored column load + Pile cap weight
= 599+ (8x8 x 3.5 x0.15)
= 632.6 kips > (QuG)all =593.90 kips
Therefore, it is not acceptable from a bearing capacity point of view and a
greater number of piles should use.
Try a group of 4 piles. And place the piles at 5.5ft center-to-center spacing
with 8ftx8ftx3.5ft thick concrete cap. The pile group arrangement is shown in figure
4.17.
99

3.5′

(a)Plan (b) Section


Figure4.17 Pile Group Arrangement for Pile Group (3)

The allowable bearing capacity of pile group can be calculated by the


following two methods.
(a)Block failure of pile group, by using equation (2.13)

(QuG)ult= cuNc( b̄ 2
) + 4 cu( b̄ ) Le
From Table (2.1) Df/B =Df/ ƀ =65/7=9.29> 4,Nc =9
From Table (2.2) Bb = 7ft, Nc =6
Value cu and Le were obtained above,
(QuG)ult = 3947.385 x6 x 72 + 4 x 3519.73 x 7 x 60
100

= 7073.68 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult /SF=7073.68/2.5= 2829.5 kips

(b)Sum of ultimate loads of single pile, by using Equation (2.15b)


(QuG)ult= Ge ¿ n ¿ (Qu)ult
S/B = 5.5/1.5=3.67
From Table (2.5), group efficiency, Ge =0.75
The number of pile = 4 piles
(QuG)ult = 0.75 x 4 x 659.69 = 1979.67 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult / SF =1979.67/2.5 =791.87kips(control)
Total load on pile group = unfactored column load + Pile cap weight
= 599+( 8x8 x 3.5 x0.15)
= 632.6 kips < (QuG)all =791.87 kips
The group capacity is 791.87 kips, which is greater than the actual load
632.6kips on the group. Therefore, it is acceptable from a bearing capacity point of
view.

4.5.1.3 .Pile reinforcement


For piles, a minimum amount of vertical steel reinforcement is 1% of the cross
sectional area of pile. The required longitudinal steel in pile is no.5 bars are used.
As = 0.01 x Ags
=0.01 x π/4 x (1.5)2 x 144 =2.545 in2
Number of bars = As / area of no.5 bar
= 2.545/ 0.31
= 8.29 say 9 nos
Perimeter with 3” clear cover = 2 π r
= 2 x 3.14 x (9-3)
= 37.7 in2
Spacing between bars = (Perimeter with 3” clear cover)/(number of
bars)
=37.7/9
= 4.19 in say 4 in

Use 9 # 5 longitudinal bar with 4” c/c spacing in piles.


101

Spirals shall consists of a continuous bar or wire not less than (3/8)’’ diameter
and the clear spacing between turns of the spiral must not exceed 3 in nor be less than
1 in. Therefore, (3/8)”ф spiral steel3” c/c is used throughout the length of pile as
shown in figure4.18.

9#5@ 4"c/c
9#5 longitudinal steel
18"фpile
3/8"spiral @3"c/c @ 4" c/c
3" cover
65' 3/8"spiral @ 3"c/c

3'' cover

18"

Figure 4.18 Pile Reinforcement (a) Plan (b) Section

Check for structure pile group capacity


The allowable stress of steel and concrete is taken as 4% of the yield strength
and cylinder strength of concrete.
Structural pile capacity, Qu = (Ags-As)fc+Asfs
fs =0.4 fy =0.4 x 40000 = 16000 psi
fc = 0.4fc’= 0.4x 3000 =1200 psi
Qu = (254.5-2.545)1200 + 2.545x16000 = 343 kips/pile
Structure pile group capacity, (QuG) = n x Qu
102

= 4 x 343
=1372.1 kip > 791.9 kips
Structural pile group capacity > allowable bearing capacity of pile
So, Structural pile group capacity is satisfactory.

4.5.2. Design of Pile Cap


From the proposed building, column size, unfactored load, factored load and
material properties are taken as follow;
Square column size = 26” x 26”
Unfactored column load = 599 kips
Factored column load = 1314kips
28-day concrete strength, fc’ = 3 ksi
Yield strength for steel, fy = 40 ksi
Assume effective depth, d = 33.5 in
For pile group (3), choose the 8ft x8ft square shape concrete cap to cover the
pile group arrangement.
Effective allowable bearing capacity of pile group, Re =(allowable bearing
capacity of
group)-(pile cap
weight)
= 791.9-(8x8x3.5x0.15)
= 758.27 kips
Average load factor = factored load/unfactored load
=1314/599
=2.19
Pile reaction for strength design, Ru =Re x average load factor
= 758.27 x 2.19
= 1663.38 kips
Ultimate bearing pressure for strength design, qu =Ru/ selected area
= 1663.38/(8x8)
= 25.99 ksf

4.5.2.1. Punching shear check


103

The two-way shear is shown in the lower left quadrant of section. Let us
assume that the necessary depth has been found by trial and error procedure and a
check with effective depth d=33.5in. The circular punching shear section is at a
distance d/2 from column face which is 16.75 in around the column. The first term is
four piles on the outside of punching shear section, with the diameter of pile being
18” and the length of pile that lies outside the critical section being 16.75 in as shown
in figure 4.19.
Assume d= 33.5 in
LAB = 8 ft x 8 ft
= 64 in2
Lab = 26” +33.5”
= 59.5 in
b0 = 4 (26” +33.5”)
= 238 in

8′
A B
18′′ pile
5.5′
a b

8′

Two-way area c d
(16.75in around
column
C D

Figure 4.19.Critical Depth of Punching Shear

Punching shear, Vul =ultimate bearing pressure x punching area

= qu x [(LAB - (Lab)2]

= 25.99 x [(8 x8)-(59.5/12)2]

=1024.41kips
Nominal punching shear strength, ΦVul= Φ4 √ f c ' bo d
104

= (0.85 x 4 x√ 3000 x238x33.5)/1000

= 1484.777kips >Vul (Satisfactory)

So, the depth d=33.5 in is adequate for punching shear.

4.5.2.2. One way shear or Beam shear check

One –way shear section is in the left area of section as shown in figure4.20. In
this section, two piles are entirely in the critical section.

For X- direction

LAB = 8 ft

y = [4 – (13/12)-(33.5/12)]=0.125ft

L = 4- (13/12) =2.92 ft

One way shear, Vu2 = bearing capacity x one way shear

= qu x LAB x y

= 25.99x 8 x 0.125

= 25.99 kips

Nominal one way shear strength, ΦVu2 = Φ2 √ fc ' b d

= (0.85 x 2 x √ 3000 x 8x12x33.5)/1000

= 299.45 kips > Vu2 (Satisfactory)

8′
A B

x d
8′
L

C D
105

Figure 4.20.Critical Section of Beam Shear

For Y direction

LAC = 8 ft

y = [4-(13/12)-(33.5/12)]

= 0.125 ft

L = 4-(13/12)

= 2.92 ft

8′

A B

8′

y
C D

Figure4.21 Critical Section of Beam Shear

One way shear, Vu2 =bearing capacity x one way shear area

= qu x LAC x y

= 25.99 x 8 x 0.125

= 25.99 kips

Nominal one way strength, ΦVu2 = Φ2 √ fc ' b d

= (0.85 x 2 x √ 3000 x8 x 12x33.5)/1000


106

= 299.45 kips >Vu2 (Satisfactory)

So, the depth d = 33.5 in is adequate for beam shear.

4.5.2.3. Flexural design

The critical sections for flexure are indicated in the lower right quadrant.
Bending moment at the face of the column,

Mu = ωuL2/2

For X-direction

ωu = qu x LAB = 25.99 x 8 =207.92 kips/ft

Mu = 207.92x 12 x (2.92)2/2 = 10612.71 kips-in

To determine the required steel area,

Assume a=1.47 in

As = Mu / Φfy (d-a/2)

= 10612.71/[0.9 x40 x(33.5 -1.47/2)]

= 9.00 in2

Check

a = Asfy/ (0.85 fc’b)

= 9.00 x 40 / (0.85 x 3 x 8 x12)

= 1.47 in (Satisfactory)

Checking the minimum steel ratio,

As(min) =3 √ f c ’ bd/fy ≥ 200bd/fy

= (3 x √ 3000 x 8 x12 x33.5)/40000 ≥ (200x 8x 12 x 33.5)/40000

= 13.21 in2 ≥ 16.08 in2

Therefore,

As(min) = 16.08 in2

The controlling value of 16.08 in2 is larger than 9.00 in2 calculated for
bending.
107

For Y-direction

ωu = qu x LAC = 25.99 x 8 =207.92 kips/ft

Mu = 207.92 x 12 x (2.92)2/2 = 10612.71kips-in

To determine the required steel area,

Assume a = 1.47in

As = Mu / Φfy (d-a/2)

= 10612.71/(0.9 x 40 x (33.5 – 1.47/2))

= 9.00 in2

Check

a = Asfy/ (0.85 fc’b)

= 9.00x40/ (0.85 x 3 x8x12)

= 1.47in (Satisfactory)

Checking the minimum steel ratio,

As(min) =3 √ f c ’ bd/fy ≥ 200bd/fy

= (3 x √ 3000 x 8 x12 x33.5)/40000 ≥ (200x 8x 12 x33.5)/40000

= 13.21in2 ≥ 16.08in2

Therefore,

As(min) = 16.08in2

The controlling value of 16.08 in2 is larger than the 9.00in2 calculated for
bending.

So, choose 21#8 bars with 5” c/c in pile cap for X-direction, furnish 16.506in2
and 21#8 bars with 5” c/c in pile cap for Y-direction, furnish 16.506 in2.

4.5.2.4. Bearing check


108

All axial forces and bending moment that act at the bottom section of column
must be transferred to the footing at the bearing surface by compression in the
concrete and by reinforcement.

Pile reaction for strength design =Pu = 1663.38 kips

The loaded area, A1 = 26” x26”

Design bearing strength, ΦPn = Φ0.85fc’A1√ ( A 2/ A 1) ≤ Φ 0.85 fc’2 A1

A2 =the area of the base of the largest frustum of pyramid

ΦPn = 0.7 x 0.85 x 3000 x26 x 26x √ (8 x 8 x 144 /26 x 26)≤ 0.7 x 0.85

x 3000 x 2 x 26 x 26

=4455.36 kips ≤ 2413.32 kips

So, Design strength = 2413.32 kips > pile reaction = 1663.38 kips (Satisfactory)

Determine the temperature and shrinkage steel.

For reinforcing yield strength fy= 40000psi, the temp;& shrinkage ratio ρ=0.0002

At&s =ρbh

= 0.002 x 12 x 42

=1.008 in2/ft

Select #5 bars on 3” center, furnish As = 0.91 in2/ft

4.5.2.5. Dowel bars

For different concrete compressive strength, the required steel is used no.6
bars in column.

Dowel area = 0.005 x gross area of column

= 0.005 x 26 x 26

= 3.38 in2

No.6 bars are used in column.

From table A-2, use 8#6 bars, furnishing3.35 in2 is adequate.


109

Required development length for compression steel

Ldb = 0.02 db fy / √ f c ’ ≥ 0.0003 dbfy

= (0.02 x 0.75 x 40000) / √ 3000≥ 0.0003 x 0.75 x 40000

= 10.95in ≥ 9in

From above the larger of Ldb = 10.95 in say 11in

Allowable length of dowel bars = 33.5 in > Ldb (Satisfactory)

The minimum lap splice = 0.0005 dbfy

= 0.0005 x 0.07 x 40000

= 15 in > minimum splice length = 8 in

Required total dowel length = 11 +15 = 26 in

Take =2.17 ft

For concrete in contact with ground, a minimum cover 3 in is required for


corrosion protection. With d= 33.5 in, measured from the top of the pile cap to the
center of the upper layer of bars, the total thickness of the pile cap that is required in
order to provide 7 in cover for the lowest steel layer.

Total depth of pile cap, h= 33.5+0.5+1+7=42in =3.5 ft

Design result for pile cap (3)

Length of pile cap =8 ft

Width of pile cap = 8 ft

Depth of pile cap = 3.5 ft

Clear rebar cover = 3 in

Pile head inset = 4 in

Number of pile =4

Spacing of piles = 5.5 ft

Edge distance = 6 in
110

21#8 for Y-direction

(a) Plan

21#8 for X-direction

21#8 for Y-direction

(b) Section
Figure 4.22 Pile Cap (3)

4.5.3. Settlement of Pile Group


The settlement of piles in cohesive soil primarily consist of the sum of the
short-term settlement occurring as the load is applied and long-term consolidation
111

settlement occurring gradually as the excess pore pressures generated by loads are
dissipated.

4.5.3.1. Short-term settlement

Short term settlement can be estimated by semiempirial and empirial methods.

(1)Semiempirial method

By using Equation (2.16)


St = Ss + Sp + Sps
St =(Qpa + αsQfa) L / (Ap Ep)+ CpQpa / (B qp)+ CsQfa / (Dfqp)

Total load on pile group = 632.60 kips

The load per pile = 632.60/ 4

= 158.15 kips

From section 4.5.1.1

Qp =62.78 kips

Qp(all) =62.78/2.5

= 25.11 kips

Qf = 597.11 kips

Qf(all) = 597.11/2.5

= 238.84 kips

Total allowable load = Qp(all) + Qf(all)

=25.11 + 238.84

= 263.96 kips

When the actual load on each pile is 158.15 kips

Qp(actual) = 25.11(158.15/263.96 ) = 15.05 kips

Qf(actual) = 238.84(158.15/263.96) = 143.10 kips


αs = 0.5 for uniform distribution of skin friction
112

L = 65 ft
Ap = 1.77 ft2
Ep = 3.12x106 psi for concrete
From Table 2.6,Cp = 0.03 for pile in clay
qp = Qp/Abase = 62.8/ 1.77
= 35.53 kips/ ft2
From Equation 2.20,

Cs = [0.93 + 0.16 x √ Df / B ] Cp
= [0.93+0.16√ 65/1.5] 0.03
= 0.059
Substituting above values in the expression for St;
From equation 2.17
Ss = ((15.05+0.5x143.10)65x12x103)/(1.77x144x3.12x106)) =0.0849 in

From equation 2.18


Sp = (0.03x15.05x144)/(1.5x12x35.53) = 0.10166 in
From equation 2.19
Sps = ((0.059x143.10x144)/(65x12x35.53)) =0.0438 in
From equation 2.16
St =0.0849+0.10166+0.0438 = 0.231 in

(2)Empirical method, by using Equation (2.21)


St = B/100 + (Qua L) / (Ap Ep)
Ep = Ec = 3.12x106 psi
St = 18/100 + (193.15x65x12x103)/(1.77x144x3.12x106)
= 0.34 in
The higher of the above two values estimated by the semiempirical and
empirical method is 0.34 in.
Settlement of pile group can be calculated by the equation (2.22)

S
G = St √( b̄/ B )
= 0.32√ (7/1.5)

= 0.724 in
113

4.5.3.2. Long term settlement

Unit weight of soil is taken from layer 2 of soil report data to calculate the

effective stress of soil. The water table is found below the ground surface at 4ft.

σ'(at length L)
=(53.03x10+71.76x15+49.3x5+51.78x5+58.02x5+57.44x5+45.
55x10+58.65x10+44.34x15)/1000
=4.397 kip/ft2
=2.20 ton/ft2
Moisture content,ω = 22.68%
PL = 24.69%
LL = 43.7%
Liquidity Index = (ω-PL)/(LL-PL)
= (22.68-24.69)/(43.7-24.69)
=-0.11
From figure 2.5, Ṕc = 20Ton/ft2
Over Consolidation Ratio (OCR), = Ṕc/ σ'
=20/2.20
= 9.10 >4
OCR is greater than 4, therefore the clay soil is highly overconsolidation. So,
the consolidation settlement due to loads on pile foundations would not occur. And
then other layers are also overconsolidation.
The calculated settlement of pile group is 0.724 in. This is less than the
allowable settlement of 1 in. Therefore the design pile diameter, length and group
arrangement is acceptable.

4.5.4. Design of Single Pile Foundation under Axial Load


The design of pile and settlement of single pile is calculated by the following;

4.5.4.1. Pile Dimension and Allowable Bearing Capacity


Consider 65ft long, 4ft diameter straight-sided shaft cast-in-place concrete
pile.
114

From section 4.5.1.1.The average undrained shear strength


cu(avg) =3519.73 lb/ft2
2
c u( base) =3947 .385 lb/ ft

From Equation 2.12


L = Le

( Qu )ult = Ap cu Nc + p L=o ca ΔL

Where,
π π
Ap = (Bb )2 = ( 4 )2 = 12. 57 ft 2
4 4
Df 65
= = 13. 45> 4
Bb 4
Df
> 4 , Nc = 9
From Table 3.1, for Bb

From Table 3.2, for Bb = 4ft, Nc=6


The lower of these two values is 6
p =πBs =π× 4= 12.57 ft
From Table 3.3, for straight-sided shafts drilled concrete pile installed dry or
by the slurry displacement method, if c u(avg) for silt-clay along pile shaft is
3519.73lb/ft2, then ca/cu(avg) = 0.6. The safety factor 2.5 is used.
ca = 0.6 cu(avg) = 0.6 × 3519.73 = 2111.84 lb/ft2
From Table 2.4, Effective length,
Le = L – (depth of seasonal variation)
= 65 – 5 = 60 ft
Qp = (12.57x3947.385x6)/1000 =297.71 kips
Qf = (12.57× 2111.84 × 60)/1000= 1592.75 kips
(Qu)ult = Qp+ Qf
= 1890.46 kips
(Qu )ult 1890 . 46
= = 756 . 184 kips
(Qu) all = FS 2 .5
(Qu) all = 756.84kips is greater than 599 kips. Therefore, it is acceptable from a
bearing capacity point of view.
115

4.5.4.2 Pile reinforcement


For piles, a minimum amount of vertical steel reinforcement is 1 % of the
cross sectional area of pile. The required longitudinal steel in pile are used n0.9 bars.
As = 0.01 x Ags =0.01 x π/4 x (4)2 x 144 =18.096 in2
Number of bars =As / area of no.9 bar
= 18.096/ 1
= 18.096 say 19 nos
Perimeter with 3” clear cover = 2 π r
= 2 x 3.14 x (24-3)
= 131.95 in
Spacing between bars = (Perimeter with 3” clear cover)/ (number of
bars)
= 131.95/19
= 6.945 in say 7 in
Use 19 # 9 longitudinal bar with 7” c/c spacing in piles.
Spirals shall consists of a continuous bar or wire not less than (3/8)’’ diameter
and the clear spacing between turns of the spiral must not exceed 3 in nor be less than
1 in. Therefore, (3/8)”ф spiral steel3” c/c is used throughout the length of pile as
shown in figure4.23.
116

4′фpile
19#9longitudinal
19#9@7′′c/c steel@7′′c/c

4′

(a)Plan
(b) Section
Figure 4.23 Pile Reinforcement (a) Plan (b) Section

Check structure single pile capacity.


The allowable stress of steel and concrete is taken as 4% of the yield strength
and cylinder strength of concrete.
Structural pile capacity, Qu = (Ags-As)fc+Asfs

fs =0.4 fy =0.4 x 40000 = 16000 psi


fc = 0.4fc’= 0.4x 3000 =1200 psi
117

Qu = ((1809.6-18.096)1200 + 18.096x16000)/1000 = 2438 kips > 599 kips


Structural strength of single pile capacity > allowable bearing capacity of pile
So, Structural design is satisfactory.

4.5.5. Settlement of Single Pile

Short term settlement can be estimated by semiempirial and empirial methods.

(1)Semiempirial method

By using Equation (2.16)


St = Ss + Sp + Sps
St =(Qpa + αsQfa) L / (Ap Ep)+ CpQpa / (B qp)+ CsQfa / (Dfqp)

Total load on pile group = 599 kips

From section 4.5.4.1,

Qp =297.71 kips

Qp(all) =297.71/2.5

= 119.084 kips

Qf = 1592.75 kips

Qf(all) = 1592.75/2.5

= 637.1 kips

Total allowable load = Qp(all) + Qf(all)

=119.084 + 637.1

= 756.184 kips when the actual load on each pile is 599 kips

Qp(actual) = 119.084(599/756.184) = 94.33 kips

Qf(actual) = 637.1(599/756.184) = 504.669 kips


αs = 0.5 for uniform distribution of skin friction
L = 65 ft
Ap = 12.57 ft2
Ep = 3.12x106 psi for concrete
118

From Table 2.6,Cp = 0.03 for pile in clay


qp = Qp/Abase = 297.71/ 12.57
= 23.703 kips/ ft2
From Equation 2.20,

Cs = [0.93 + 0.16 x √ Df / B ] Cp
= [0.93+0.16√ 65/4 ] 0.03
=0.047
Substituting above values in the expression for St;
From equation 2.17
Ss = ((94.33+0.5x504669)65x12x103) / (12.57x144x3.12x106))
=0.04792in

From equation 2.18


Sp = (0.03x94.33x144)/ (3x12x23.703)
= 0.3582in
From equation 2.19
Sps = ((0.047x504.666x144) / (65x12x23.703))
=0.1847 in
From equation 2.16
St =0.04792+0.3582+0.1847
= 0.5908 in

(2)Empirical method
By using Equation (2.21)
St = B/100 + (Qua L) / (Ap Ep)
Ep = Ec = 3.12x106 psi
St = 48/100 + (599x65x12x103)/ (12.57x144x3.12x106)
= 0.5628 in
The higher of the above two values estimated by the semiempirical and
empirical method is 0.5908 in.
The calculated settlement of single pile is 0.5908 in. This is less than the
allowable settlement of 2 in. Therefore, the designed pile diameter and length is
acceptable.
119

4.6. Design of Pile Foundation and Pile Cap for Case (4)
The design of pile, pile cap and settlement of pile group is calculated by the
following;

4.6.1. Design of Group Pile Foundation under Axial load


Pile Group (4) is designed for unfactored load on point 13, 14, 15 20, 22, 24.
The critical unfactored load is 835.08kips and so higher full value of 836 kips is used.
These unfactored column loads have been presented in Table (3.3).

4.6.1.1. Pile dimension and allowable bearing capacity


The required soil data are obtained from soil report and factor of safety is
taken as2.5 for groups in deep foundation. Consider 65ft long, 1.5ft diameter straight-
sided shaft-cast-in-place concrete pile.
The average undrained shear strength,
cu(avg)=1/9[(3885.39+12898.98+5049.37+7003.05+4073.16+4468.92+6272.87
+11754.55+ 7948.77)/2]
=3519.73 lb/ft2
From equation (2.12).the ultimate bearing capacity for a pile is,
L = Le
(Qu )ult = A p c u N c + p ∑ c a ΔL
L=0

Where,
π π
Ap = (Bb )2 = (1 .5 )2 = 1 .76 ft 2
4 4
2
c u( base) = 7948. 77 /2=3947 .385 lb/ft
D f 65
= = 43 .33> 4
Bb 1.5
Df
> 4 , Nc = 9
From Table 3.1, for Bb

From Table 3.2, for Bb = 1.5ft, Nc= 9


120

p =πBs =π× 1.5= 4.71 ft


From Table 3.3, for straight-sided shafts drilled concrete pile installed dry or
by the slurry displacement method, if c u(avg) for silt-clay along pile shaft is
3519.73lb/ft2, then ca/cu(avg) = 0.6. The depth of seasonal variation is 3ft to 5ft.
ca = 0.6 cu(avg) = 0.6 × 3519.73 = 2111.84 lb/ft2
From Table 2.4, Effective length
Le = L – (depth of seasonal variation)
= 65 – 5 = 60 ft
Qp = 1.76 × 3947.385x9 =62.526kips
Qf = 4.71 × 2111.84 × 60= 596.806kips
(Qu)ult = Qp+ Qf
= 659.33 kips
(Qu )ult 659 . 33
= = 263 .73 kips
(Qu) all= FS 2.5

4.6.1.2 Number of pile and their arrangement


The number piles required to support 836 kips column load will be
n=QuG/Qu(all)=836/263.73=3.17
Try a group of 4 piles arranged in a rectangular pattern with on each side. And
place the pile at 6ft center-to-center spacing with 9ft x 13.4ft x 4ft thick concrete pile
cap. The pile group arrangement is shown in figure 4.24.
121

(a)Plan

(c) Section
Figure4.24 Pile Group Arrangement (4-piles)

The allowable bearing capacity of this pile group can be calculated by the
following two methods.
(a)Block failure of pile group, by using equation (2.13)

(QuG)ult= cuNc( b̄ 2
) + 4 cu( b̄ ) Le
From Table (2.1) Df/B =Df/ ƀ =65/8=8.1> 4 ,Nc =9
From Table (2.2) Bb = 8ft, Nc =6
Value cu and Le were obtained above,
(QuG)ult = 3947.385 x 6 x 82 + 4 x 3519.73 x 8 x 60
= 8273.68 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult /SF=8273.68/2.5= 3309.5kips

(b)Sum of ultimate loads of single pile, by using Equation (2.15b)


(QuG)ult= Ge ¿ n ¿ (Qu)ult
S/B 6/1.5=4
From Table (2.5), group efficiency Ge =0.75
The number of pile = 4 piles
(QuG)ult = 0.75 x 4 x 659.69 = 1979.67 kips
122

(QuG)all = (QuG)ult / SF =1979.67/2.5 =791.87 kips(control)


Total load on pile group = unfactored column load + Pile cap weight
= 836+( 9x13.4 x 4 x0.15)
= 908.4 kips > (QuG)all =791.9 kips
Therefore, it is not acceptable from a bearing capacity point of view and a
greater number of piles should use.
Try a group of 5 piles. And place the piles at6ft center-to-center spacing with
9ftx13.4ftx4ft thick concrete cap. The pile group arrangement is shown in figure 4.25.

(a)Plan

(b)Section
Figure2.25 Pile Group Arrangement for Pile Group (4)

The allowable bearing capacity of pile group can be calculated by the


following two methods.
123

(a)Block failure of pile group, by using equation (2.13)

(QuG)ult= cuNc( b̄ 2
) + 4 cu( b̄ ) Le
From Table (2.1) Df/B =Df/ ƀ =65/1.5=8.1 > 4,Nc =9
From Table (2.2) Bb = 8ft, Nc =6

Value cu and Le were obtained above,


(QuG)ult = 3947.385 x6 x 82 + 4 x 3519.73 x 8 x 60
= 8273.68 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult /SF=8273.68/2.5= 3309.5 kips

(b)Sum of ultimate loads of single pile, by using Equation (2.15b)


(QuG)ult= Ge ¿ n ¿ (Qu)ult
S/B = 6/1.5=4
From Table (2.5), Ge =0.75
The number of pile = 5 piles
(QuG)ult = 0.75 x 5 x 659.69 = 2474.59 kips
(QuG)all = (QuG)ult / SF =2474.59/2.5 =989.84kips(control)
Total load on pile group = unfactored column load + Pile cap weight
= 836+ (9x13.4 x 4 x0.15)
= 908.4 kips < (QuG)all =989.84 kips
The group capacity is 989.84 kips, which is greater than the actual load
908.4kips on the group. Therefore, it is acceptable from a bearing capacity point of
view.

4.6.1.3 .Pile reinforcement


For piles, a minimum amount of vertical steel reinforcement is 1% of the cross
sectional area of pile and the longitudinal steel is no.5 bars are used.
As = 0.01 x Ags
=0.01 x π/4 x (1.5)2 x 144 =2.545 in2
Number of bars = As / area of no.5 bar
= 2.545/ 0.31
124

= 8.29 say 9 nos


Perimeter with 3” clear cover = 2 π r
= 2 x 3.14 x (9-3)
= 37.7 in2
Spacing between bars = (Perimeter with 3” clear cover)/ (number of
bars)
=37.7/9
= 4.19 in say 4 in
Use 9 # 5 longitudinal bar with 4” c/c spacing in piles.
Spirals shall consists of a continuous bar or wire not less than (3/8)’’ diameter
and the clear spacing between turns of the spiral must not exceed 3 in nor be less than
1 in. Therefore, (3/8)”ф spiral steel3” c/c is used throughout the length of pile as
shown in figure4.26.

9#5@ 4"c/c
9#5 longitudinal steel
3/8"pile
18" spiral @3"c/c @ 4" c/c
3" cover
65' 3/8"spiral @ 3"c/c

3'' cover

18"

Figure 4.26 Pile Reinforcement (a) Plan (b) Section

Check for structure pile of group capacity


The allowable stress of steel and concrete is taken as 4% of the yield strength
and cylinder strength of concrete.
Structural pile capacity, Qu = (Ags-As)fc+Asfs
fs =0.4 fy =0.4 x 40000 = 16000 psi
fc = 0.4fc’= 0.4x 3000 =1200 psi
Qu = (254.5-2.545)1200 + 2.545x16000 = 343 kips/pile
Structure pile group capacity, (QuG) = n x Qu
= 5 x 343
125

=1715.1 kip > 989.8 kips


Structural pile group capacity > allowable bearing capacity of pile
So, Structural pile group capacity is satisfactory.

4.6.2. Design of Pile Cap


From the proposed building, column size, unfactored load, factored load and
material properties are taken as follow;
Square column size = 26” x 26”
Unfactored column load = 836 kips
Factored column load = 1770kips
28-day concrete strength, fc’ = 3 ksi
Yield strength for steel, fy = 40 ksi
Assume effective depth, d = 39.5 in
For pile case (4), choose the 9ft x13.4ft rectangular shape concrete cap to
cover the pile group arrangement.
Effective allowable bearing capacity of pile group,Re =(allowable bearing capacity of
group)-(pile cap weight)
= 989.8-(9x13.5x4x0.15)
= 917.48 kips
Average load factor = factored load/unfactored load
=1770/836
=2.12
Pile reaction for strength design, Ru =Re x average load factor
= 917.48 x 2.12
= 1942.50 kips
Ultimate bearing pressure for strength design, qu =Ru/ selected area
= 1942.50/ (9x13.4)
= 16.11 ksf

4.6.2.1. Punching shear check


The two-way shear is shown in the lower left quadrant of section. Let us
assume that the necessary depth has been found by trial and error procedure and a
check with effective depth d=39.5in. The circular punching shear section is at a
distance d/2 from column face which is 19.75in around the column. The first term is
126

four piles on the outside of punching shear section, with the diameter of pile being
18” and the length of pile that lies outside the critical section being 19.75in as shown
in figure 4.27.

Assume d= 39.5 in
LAB = 9 ft x 13.4 ft
= 120.6 in2
Lab = 26” +39.5”
= 65.5 in
b0 = 4 (26” +39.5”)
= 262 in
18"pile

Two-way area
(19.75in around
column

Figure 4.27 Critical Depth of Punching Shear

Punching shear, Vul =ultimate bearing pressure x punching area

= qu x [(LAB - (Lab)2]

=16.11 x [(9 x13.4)-(65.5/12)2]


127

=1462.62kips
Norminal punching shear strength, ΦVul= Φ4 √ fc ' bo d

= (0.85 x 4 x √ 3000
x262x39.5)/1000

= 1927.249kips >Vul (Satisfactory)

So, the depth d=39.5 in is adequate for punching shear.

4.6.2.2. One way shear or Beam shear check

One-way shear section is in the left area of section as shown in figure4.28. In


this section, one pile is entirely in the critical section.

For X- direction

LAD = 13.4 ft

y = [4.5 – (13/12)-(39.5/12)]=0.125ft

L = 4.5- (13/12) =3.42 ft

One way shear, Vu2 = bearing capacity x one way shear

= qu x LAD x y

= 16.11x 13.4 x 0.125

= 26.98 kips

Norminal one way shear strength, ΦVu2 = Φ2 √ fc ' b d

= (0.85 x 2 x √ 3000 x 13.4 x12 x

39.5)/1000

= 591.42kips > Vu2 (Satisfactory)


128

x
L

Figure 4.28 Critical Section of Beam Shear for X-direction

For Y direction

LAC = 9 ft

y = [6.7-(13/12)-(39.5/12)]

= 2.325 ft

L = 6.7-(13/12)

= 5.62 ft

One way shear, Vu2 =bearing capacity x one way shear area

= qu x LAC x y

= 16.11 x 13.4 x 2.235

= 508.81 kips

Norminal one way strength, ΦVu2 = Φ2 √fc' b d

= (0.85 x 2 x √3000 x13.4 x 12

x39.5)/1000

= 591.42 kips > Vu2 (Satisfactory)


129

Figure 4.29 Critical Section of Beam Shear for Y-direction

So, the depth d = 39.5 in is adequate for beam shear.

4.6.2.3. Flexural design

The critical sections for flexure are indicated in the lower right quadrant.

Bending moment at the face of the column,

Mu = ωuL2/2

For X-direction

ωu = qu x LAC = 16.11 x 13.4 =215.83kips/ft

Mu = 215.83x 12 x (2.325)2/2 =40853.32kips-in

To determine the required steel area,

Assume a = 2.91in

As = Mu / Φfy (d-a/2)

= 40853.32/ (0.9 x 40 x (39.5 – 2.91/2))


130

= 29.83in2

Check

a = Asfy/ (0.85 fc’b)

= 31.76x40/ (0.85 x 3 x 13.4x 12)

= 2.91in (Satisfactory)

Checking the minimum steel ratio,

As(min) =3 √fc’ bd/fy ≥ 200bd/fy

= (3 x √ 3000 x 13.4 x12 x39.5)/40000 ≥ (200x 13.4x 12 x

39.5)/40000

= 26.09in2 ≥ 31.76in2

Therefore,

As(min) = 31.76in2

The controlling value of 31.76 in2 is larger than the 29.83in2 calculated for
bending.

For Y-direction

ωu = qu x LAB = 16.11 x 9 =144.96kips/ft

Mu = 144.96x 12 x (3.42)2/2 = 10153.43kips-in

To determine the required steel area,

Assume a=1.05 in

As = Mu / Φfy (d-a/2)

= 10153.43/[0.9 x40 x(39.5 -1.05/2)]

= 7.24 in2

Check

a = Asfy/ (0.85 fc’b)

= 7.24 x 40 / (0.85 x 3 x 9 x12)

= 1.05 in (Satisfactory)

Checking the minimum steel ratio,


131

As(min) =3 √ f c ’ bd/fy ≥ 200bd/fy

= (3 x √ 3000 x 9 x12 x39.5)/40000 ≥ (200x 9x 12 x 39.5)/40000

= 17.52 in2 ≥ 21.33 in2

Therefore As(min) = 21.33 in2

The controlling value of 21.33 in2 is larger than 7.24in2 calculated for bending.

So, choose and 41#8 bars with 3” c/c in pile cap for X-direction, furnish
32.226 in2and 28#8 bars with 6” c/c in pile cap for Y-direction, furnish 22.008in2

4.6.2.4. Bearing check

All axial forces and bending moment that act the bottom section of column
must be transferred to the bearing surface by compression in the concrete and by
reinforcement.

Pile reaction for strength design =Pu = 1940.50 kips

The loaded area, A1 = 26” x26”

Design bearing strength, ΦPn = Φ0.85fc’A1√ ( A 2/ A 1) ≤ Φ 0.85 fc’2 A1

A2 =the area of the base of the largest frustum of pyramid

ΦPn= 0.7 x 0.85 x 3000 x26 x 26x √ (9 x 13.4 x 144 /26 x 26)≤ 0.7 x0.85 x3000x2x 26

x 26

=6115.99 kips ≤ 2413.32 kips

So, Design strength = 2413.32 kips > pile reaction = 1663.38 kips (Satisfactory)

Determine the temperature and shrinkage steel.

For reinforcing yield strength fy = 40000psi, the temp:& shrinkage ratio, ρ= 0.002

At&s =ρbh
132

= 0.002 x 12 x 48

= 1.152 in2/ft

Select #5 bars on 3” center, furnish As = 0.91 in2/ft

4.6.2.5. Dowel bars

For different concrete compressive strength, the required steel area are used
no.6 bars in column.

Dowel area = 0.005 x gross area of column

= 0.005 x 26 x 26

= 3.38 in2

No.6 bars are used in column.

From table A-2, use 8#6 bars, furnishing3.35 in2 is adequate.

Required development length for compression steel

Ldb = 0.02 db fy / √fc’ ≥ 0.0003 dbfy

= (0.02 x 0.75 x 40000) / √3000 ≥ 0.0003 x 0.75 x 40000

= 10.95in ≥ 9in

From above the larger of Ldb = 10.95 in say 11in

Allowable length of dowel bars = 33.5 in > Ldb (Satisfactory)

The minimum lap splice = 0.0005 dbfy

= 0.0005 x 0.07 x 40000

= 15 in > minimum splice length = 8 in

Required total dowel length = 11 +15 = 26 in

Take =2.17ft

For concrete in contact with ground, a minimum cover 3 in is required for


corrosion protection. With d= 33.5 in, measured from the top of the pile cap to the
center of the upper layer of bars, the total thickness of the pile cap that is required in
order to provide 7 in cover for the lowest steel layer.
133

Total depth of pile cap, h= 39.5+0.5+1+7=48in =4ft

Design result for pile cap (4)

Length of pile cap =9ft

Width of pile cap = 13.4ft

Depth of pile cap = 4ft

Clear rebar cover = 3 in

Pile head inset = 4 in

Number of pile =5

Spacing of piles = 6ft

Edge distance = 6 in

41#8 for x-direction

28#8 for Y-direction

(a) Plan
134

41#8 for x-direction

28#8 for x-direction

(b) Section
Figure4.30.Pile Cap (4) Reinforcement

4.6.3. Settlement of Pile Group


The settlement of piles in cohesive soil primarily consist of the sum of the
short-term settlement occurring as the load is applied and long-term consolidation
settlement occurring gradually as the excess pore pressures generated by loads are
dissipated.

4.6.3.1. Short-term settlement

Short term settlement can be estimated by semiempirial and empirial methods.

(1)Semiempirial method, by using Equation (2.16)

St = Ss + Sp + Sps
St =(Qpa +αs Qfa) L / (Ap Ep)+ CpQpa / (B qp)+ CsQfa / (Dfqp)

Total load on pile group = 908.36 kips

The load per pile = 908.36/ 5


135

= 181.67 kips

From section 4.6.1.1,

Qp =62.78 kips

Qp(all) =62.78/2.5

= 25.11 kips

Qf = 597.11 kips

Qf(all) = 597.11/2.5

= 238.84 kips

Total allowable load = Qp(all) + Qf(all)

=25.11 + 238.84

= 263.96 kips when the actual load on each pile is 181.67kips

Qp(actual) = 25.11(181.67/263.96 ) = 17.28 kips

Qf(actual) = 238.84(181.67/263.96) = 164.39 kips


αs = 0.5 for uniform distribution of skin friction
L = 65 ft
Ap = 1.77 ft2
Ep = 3.12x106 psi for concrete
From Table 2.6,Cp = 0.03 for pile in clay
qp = Qp/Abase = 62.8/ 1.77
= 35.53 kips/ ft2
From Equation 2.20,

Cs = [0.93 + 0.16 x √ Df / B ] Cp
= [0.93+0.16√ 65/1.5] 0.03
= 0.059
Substituting above values in the expression for St;
From equation 2.17
Ss = ((17.28+0.5x164.39)65x12x103)/(1.77x144x3.12x106)) =0.0976 in
From equation 2.18
Sp = (0.03x17.28x144)/(1.5x12x35.53) = 0.1167 in
136

From equation 2.19


Sps = ((0.059x164.39x144)/(65x12x35.53)) =0.0504 in
From equation 2.16
St =0.0976+0.1167+0.0504 = 0.265 in

(2)Empirical method
By using Equation (2.21)
St = B/100 + (Qua L) / (Ap Ep)
Ep = Ec = 3.12x106 psi
St = 18/100 + (181.67x65x12x103)/(1.77x144x3.12x106)
= 0.36 in
The higher of the above two methods estimated by the semiempirical and
empirical method is 0.36 in.
Settlement of pile group can be calculated by the equation (2.22)

S
G = St √( b̄/ B )
= 0.36√ (8/1.5)

= 0.828 in

4.6.3.2. Long term settlement

Unit weight of soil is taken from layer 2 of soil report data to calculate the

effective stress of soil. The water table is found below the ground surface at 4ft.

σ'(at length L)

=(53.03x10+71.76x15+49.3x5+51.78x5+58.02x5+57.44x5+45.
55x10+58.65x10+44.34x15)/1000
=4.397 kip/ft2
=2.20 ton/ft2
Moisture content, ω = 22.68%
PL = 24.69%
LL = 43.7%
137

Liquidity Index = (ω-PL)/ (LL-PL)


= (22.68-24.69)/(43.7-24.69)
=-0.11
From figure 2.5, Ṕc = 20 ton/ft2
Over Consolidation Ratio (OCR), = Ṕc/ σ'
=20/2.20
= 9.10 >4
OCR is greater than 4, therefore the clay soil is highly overconsolidation. So,
the consolidation settlement due to loads on pile foundations would not occur. And
then other layers are also overconsolidation.
The calculated settlement of pile group is 0.828 in. This is less than the
allowable settlement of 1 in. Therefore the design pile diameter, length and group
arrangement is acceptable.

4.6.4. Design of Single Pile Foundation under Axial Load


The design of pile and settlement of single pile is calculated by the following;

4.6.4.1. Pile Dimension and Allowable bearing Capacity


Consider 65ft long, 5ft diameter straight-sided shaft cast-in-place concrete
pile.
From section 4.6.1.1.The average undrained shear strength
cu(avg) =3519.73 lb/ft2
2
c u( base) =3947 .385 lb/ ft

From Equation 2.12


L = Le

( Qu )ult = Ap cu Nc + p L=o ca ΔL

Where,
π π
Ap = (Bb )2 = (5 )2 = 19 .63 ft 2
4 4
D f 65
= = 13> 4
Bb 5
138

Df
> 4 , Nc = 9
From Table 3.1, for Bb

From Table 3.2, for Bb = 5ft, Nc=6


The lower of these two values is 6
p =πBs =π× 5= 15.708 ft
From Table 3.3, for straight-sided shafts drilled concrete pile installed dry or
by the slurry displacement method, if c u(avg) for silt-clay along pile shaft is
3519.73lb/ft2, then ca/cu(avg) = 0.6. The safety 2.5 is used.
ca = 0.6 cu(avg) = 0.6 × 3519.73 = 2111.84 lb/ft2
From Table 2.4, effective length
Le = L – (depth of seasonal variation)
= 65 – 5 = 60 ft
Qp = (19.63x3947.385x6)/1000 =464.92 kips
Qf = (15.708× 2111.84 × 60)/1000= 1990.37kips
(Qu)ult = Qp+ Qf
= 2455.29kips
(Qu )ult 2455 . 29
= = 1227 .64 kips
(Qu) all = FS 2. 5
(Qu) all = 1227.64kips is greater than 836 kips. Therefore, it is acceptable from
a bearing capacity point of view.

4.6.4.2 Pile reinforcement


For piles, a minimum amount of vertical steel reinforcement is 1 % of the
cross sectional area of pile. The required longitudinal steel in pile are used n0.9 bars.
As = 0.01 x Ags
=0.01 x π/4 x (5)2 x 144 =28.2743 in2
Number of bars = As / area of no.9 bar
= 28.2743/ 1
= 28.2743 say29 nos
Perimeter with 3” clear cover = 2 π r
= 2 x 3.14 x (30-3)
= 169.56in
Spacing between bars = (Perimeter with 3” clear cover)/(number of
139

bars)
= 169.56/29
= 5.85 in say 6 in
Use 29 # 9 longitudinal bars with 6” c/c spacing in piles.
Spirals shall consists of a continuous bar or wire not less than (3/8)’’ diameter
and the clear spacing between turns of the spiral must not exceed 3 in nor be less than
1 in. Therefore, (3/8)”ф spiral steel 3” c/c is used throughout the length of pile as
shown in figure 4.31.

(a)Plan

(b)Section
Figure 4.31 Pile Reinforcement (a) Plan (b) Section
140

Check structure single pile capacity

The allowable stress of steel and concrete is taken as 4% of the yield strength

and cylinder strength of concrete.

Structural pile capacity, Qu = (Ags-As)fc+Asfs

fs =0.4 fy =0.4 x 40000 = 16000 psi


fc = 0.4fc’= 0.4x 3000 =1200 psi
Qu = ((2827.43-28.2743)1200 + 28.2743x16000)/1000 = 3809.4 kips > 836 kips
Structural strength of single pile capacity > allowable bearing capacity of pile
So, Structural design is satisfactory.

4.6.5. Settlement of Single Pile


The settlement of piles in cohesive soil primarily consist of the sum of the
short-term settlement occurring as the load is applied and long-term consolidation
settlement occurring gradually as the excess pore pressures generated by loads are
dissipated. Short term settlement can be estimated by semiempirial and empirial
methods.

(a)Semiempirial method

By using Equation (2.16)


St = Ss + Sp + Sps
St =(Qpa + αsQfa) L / (Ap Ep)+ CpQpa / (B qp)+ CsQfa / (Dfqp)

Total load on pile group = 421 kips

From section 4.6.4.1,

Qp =464.92 kips

Qp(all) =464.92/2.5

= 185.97kips

Qf = 1990.37 kips

Qf(all) = 1990.37/2.5

= 796.148 kips

Total allowable load = Qp(all) + Qf(all)


141

=185.97 + 796.148

= 982.118 kips when the actual load on each pile is 836kips

Qp(actual) = 185.97(836/982.118 ) = 158.27 kips

Qf(actual) = 796.148(836/982.118) = 677.73 kips


αs = 0.5 for uniform distribution of skin friction
L = 65 ft
Ap = 19.625ft2
Ep = 3.12x106 psi for concrete
From Table 2.6,Cp = 0.03 for pile in clay
qp = Qp/Abase = 464.82/ 19.625
= 23.685 kips/ ft2
From Equation 2.20,

Cs = [0.93 + 0.16 x √ Df / B ] Cp
= [0.93+0.16√ 65/5] 0.03
= 0.045
Substituting above values in the expression for St;
From equation 2.17
Ss = ((158.27+0.5x677.73)65x12x103)/ (19.625x144x3.12x106))
=0.04398in
From equation 2.18
Sp = (0.03x158.27x144)/ (3x12x23.685)
= 0.4811 in
From equation 2.19
Sps = ((0.050x677.73x144)/ (65x12x23.685))
=0.2377 in
From equation 2.16
St =0.04398+0.4811+0.2377
= 0.76283 in

(b)Empirical method
By using Equation (2.21)
St = B/100 + (Qua L) / (Ap Ep)
142

Ep = Ec = 3.12x106 psi
St = 60/100 + (836x65x12x103)/(19.625x144x3.12x106)
= 0.67396 in
The higher of the above two values estimated by the semiempirical and
empirical method is 0.76283 in.
The calculated settlement of single pile is 0.76283 in. This is less than the
allowable settlement of 2 in. Therefore, the designed pile diameter and length is
acceptable.

4.7 Comparison between Group Pile and Single Pile


The design result, settlement, concrete volume and steel reinforcement of
group pile and single are as follows;

Table 4.3.Design Result for Pile Group


Type No. Diameter Length Capacity Main Steel Spiral Cover
(in) (ft) of pile Reinforcement steel (in)
group reinforce-
(kips) ment

I 2 18 65 369.43 9#5bars @ 4′′ (3/8)′′ф 3


c/c spiral@3′
spacing ′c/c
II 3 18 65 554.31 9#5bars @ 4′′ (3/8)′′ф 3
c/c spiral@3′
spacing ′c/c
III 4 18 65 791.87 9#5bars @ 4′′ (3/8)′′ф 3
c/c spiral@3′
spacing ′c/c
IV 5 18 65 989.84 9#5bars @ 4′′ (3/8)′′ф 3
c/c spiral@3′
spacing ′c/c
143

Table4.4Design Result for Pile Cap of Group Piles


Pile Cap(1) Pile Cap(2) Pile Cap(3) Pile Cap(4)
Length(ft) 7 7 8 9
Width(ft) 6.5 6.5 8 13.4
Depth(in) 2.5 3 3.5 4
Pile head inset 4 4 4 4
(in)
No. of Piles 2 3 4 5
Spacing of 4.5 5.5 5.5 6
pile(ft)
Edge 6 6 6 6
distance(in)
Reinforcement 12#8 bars @ 7′ 12#8 bars @ 7′ 21#8 bars @ 5′ 41#8 bars
′ c/c for X ′ c/c for X ′ c/c for X @ 3′′ c/c
direction and direction and direction and for X
11#8 bars @8′′ 13#8 bars @8′′ 21#8 bars @5′′ direction
c/c for Y c/c for Y c/c for Y and 28#8
direction direction direction bars @6′′
c/c for Y
direction
Cover(in) 3 3 3 3

Table4.5Design Result for Single Piles


144

Type Diameter Length Capacity Main Steel Spiral steel Cover


(ft) (ft) of single Reinforcement Reinforcem (in)
pile(kips) ent
I 3 65 555.53 11#9bars @ 9′′ (3/8)′′ф 3
c/c spiral@3′′
spacing c/c
II 3 65 555.53 11#9bars @ 9′′ (3/8)′′ф 3
c/c spiral@3′′
spacing c/c
III 4 65 756.84 19#9bars @ 7′′ (3/8)′′ф 3
c/c spiral@3′′
spacing c/c
IV 5 65 1227.64 29#9bars @6′′ (3/8)′′ф 3
c/c spiral@3′′
spacing c/c

Table4.6 Comparison the Settlement of Group Pile and Single Pile


Type Settlement
Group(in) Single(in)
I 0.75 0.4448
II 0.621 0.4635
III 0.724 0.5908
IV 0.828 0.76283

Table4.7 Comparison the Required Concrete Volume and Steel Reinforcement for
Group Piles and Single Piles
Typ
Group Single
145

e
Concrete(ft3) Steel(lb) Concrete(ft3) Steel(lb)

I 343.46 1590.37 459.46 2432.37

II 481.09 2238 459.46 2432.98

III 683.46 3258.7 816.81 4202.43

IV 1056.72 5054.31 1276.27 6414.24

For proposed building, single piles should be used because of settlement


control for all cases. But for economy, group piles should be used for all case.

You might also like