Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4.1 SYNOPSIS
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
“The best teacher is the teacher who devises classroom methods and techniques
that derive from a comprehensive knowledge of the total process of language
learning, of what is happening within the learner and within the teacher and in the
interaction between the two. All of this knowledge, however, remains somewhat
abstract in the mind of the teacher unless it can be empirically tested in the real
world.”
• Questions asked by the teacher about what has been learnt in a lesson can
be considered a ‘test’.
Revision:
Four basic criteria to devise, use or adapt tests of listening and speaking
• Validity
• Reliability
• Practicality
Validity
• We must make sure that we are testing what we are teaching and what the
students want to be learning. Only then is the test fair and appropriate
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
• We must then design items, tasks, or prompts for the test that measure what
we want to measure
• For example: A student who has not been taught prepositions is tested on
prepositions --> the test can be viewed as lacking in validity because it tests
what the student has not learnt
Reliability
• For example: if you tape record your students speaking in English and ask
another teacher to evaluate the students’ speech using a ten-point scale, your
evaluation and the other teacher’s evaluation should not differ greatly
• Rater reliability Intra (the rater himself) and Inter-rater (between raters)
Can you think of some factors that affect intra-rater and inter-rater reliability?
What can you do to minimise the variability (differences) that exist?
Practicality
• Practicality refers to the fact that a test or other assessment procedure can
only be useful if it does not make unreasonable demands on resources,
including time, money and personnel
• For example: Interviewing each student for thirty minutes (very thorough way
to assess but what if you have 100 students?)
• Does the test encourage people to prepare for speaking tasks, or does it
cause them to study grammar rules or obscure vocabulary items?
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
• For example: Listening and speaking skills are neglected in schools mainly
because the two skills are not tested at the national level and more
importantly, the grades or marks for the testing of listening and speaking skills
are not included in the overall results. Teachers therefore view the teaching of
listening and speaking as an unnecessary thing in schools. Hence, the over
emphasis on the reading and writing skills and a neglect of the listening and
speaking skills in schools (Negative washback effect).
Can you think of some other instances of positive and negative washback effects
of tests on the teaching and learning process in schools?
b.What is a test?
• We test every day in virtually every cognitive effort we make – when we read
a book, listen to the news, or prepare a meal, we are testing hypotheses and
making judgments
We will now deconstruct the definition of a test by H.D. Brown, 1987 to develop a
better understanding of what a test really is:
A Test is a “method”
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
A Test…measuring “a person’s” ability or knowledge
• Competence
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
• Topic tests used to assess how well a student has mastered what has
been taught
• To find out specifically what areas pose difficulties for students diagnostic
tests
• Testing and teaching are very closely interrelated but do not have the
same focus
• Primary function of teacher to ensure learning takes place; tests are one of
the tools to help him do this job well;
• A test is also often used as a guide as to what would be the most important
things to teach a test influences what is taught (backwash effect)
• A test often leaves out certain important skills because of practical constraints
• What is taught should be decided by reference to how important the skills are
to a child’s present or future life
• Teachers should not just teach students only those things that will help them
pass exams
• Some teachers use the exam formats for teaching purposes this is
WRONG!!
• A test usually seeks the most economical way of finding out what the student
already knows; leaves out many things that are important
• Teaching should keep in mind the real reasons for learning and the real
circumstances in which the language or skill would be used
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
• Discrete point tests based on the assumption that language can be broken
down into component parts and tested adequately (listening, speaking,
reading, writing, phonology/ graphology, morphology, lexicon, syntax)
• John Oller (1976, 1979) argued that language competence is a unified set of
interacting abilities which cannot be separated apart and tested adequately
• “If discrete items take language skill apart, integrative tests put it back
together. Whereas discrete items attempt to test knowledge of language one
bit at a time, integrative tests attempt to assess a learner’s capacity to use
many bits all at the same time” (Oller, 1979:37)
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
• Auditory Discrimination
• Intonation tests
– He is here.
– He is here!
– He is here?
– Here he is!
• Reading aloud
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
• Oral interviews – common oral interaction test in which one or two testers
interview a candidate regarding a set of pre-determined topics
Communicative Test
• A communicative test has to meet some stringent criteria. It has to test for:
– Grammatical competence
– Discourse competence
– Sociolinguistic competence
– Strategic competence
– Illocutionary competence
• Has to be pragmatic
• Should be direct
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
• 3. Bias for best need to do everything possible to elicit the very best from
students
• 4. Work for washback we should not teach toward a test but we can use
tests as teaching tools; feedback devices
• When using communicative tests, the teacher constantly faces the dilemma of
deciding which is the focus of the assessment: accuracy or fluency or both
• Both are equally important for language learning and language use.
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
• Fluency activities are important because they allow students to express their
ideas and communicate in a meaningful and enjoyable context.
REFLECTION
As a teacher, which would you consider more important when teaching: accuracy
or fluency?
As a teacher, which would you consider more important when testing: accuracy
or fluency?
Can you think of an activity that focuses on accuracy which can be used to test
L&S skills
Can you think of an activity that focuses on fluency which can be used to test
L&S skills?
o What will the focus of the activity be?
o Ability to communicate? What about errors made?
TUTORIAL TASK
What are positive and negative washback? Provide a few examples of positive
and negative washback effects of testing on teaching.
Think about an important listening and speaking test that you have taken. How
did you prepare for that test? What did your teacher do to help you prepare for
the test? Did that test have a positive or negative impact on you? Describe the
test that you took.
If you have not taken such a test before, think of possible reasons why it was not
carried out.
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
– Deciding on ten out of twenty items that they would take on a 2-week
trip to New York; need to provide justifications
• Discussion
• Relaying instructions
– Making models
• Communication Games
– Story reconstruction
• Problem Solving
– Desert Dilemma
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
• When assessing L&S skills communicatively, what are the sub-skills or areas
you will be looking at?
– Topics to be covered?
– Duration?
– Accuracy? Grammatical?
– Fluency?
– Pronunciation?
– Appropriacy?
– Message conveyed?
– Others?
• What is feedback?
• Why feedback?
• Exercise?
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
What is a feedback?
Why Feedback?
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
Good Feedback
CONSTRUCTIVE APPROPRIATE
Constructive Feedback
Appropriate Feedback
lgp/wsl/kj 2012
TSLB3063 Teaching of Listening and Speaking Skills
in the Primary ESL classroom
A FEEDBACK SANDWICH
• Be non-judgmental
References:
Brown, G., & Yule, G. (1983). Teaching the Spoken Language. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Nunan, D., & Miller, L. (Eds.). (1995). New Ways in Teaching Listening. Alexandria,
VA:
lgp/wsl/kj 2012