You are on page 1of 4

1.

SNSD is a kpop girl group or kpop boy group


SNSD is not a kpop boy girl group
Therefore SNSD is a kpop girl group

Solution

Let P: SNSD is a kpop girl group

Q: SNSD is a kpop boy group

The Arguments becomes

Premise: p ⱽ q

Premise: P

Conclusion: -q

Symbolic Form [(pⱽq)]^p]→-q

P q pⱽq (p ⱽ q)^p -q [(pⱽq)]^p]→-


q
1 1 1 1 0 1
1 0 1 1 1 1
0 1 1 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 1 1
Since [(pⱽq)]^p]→-q not a tautology, then the given argument is invalid.

Fallacy of the inclusive or

pⱽq

∴-q

2. Invalid (Fallacy of the inclusive or)

Either you will have an exam today or the next day.

You are having an exam today.

Therefore, you will not have an exam tomorrow

Let p: you will have an exam today

Q: you will have an exam tomorrow

pVq

= -q
3. Valid (Law of Detachment)
If we search the Internet, then we will find information about logic.
We searched the Internet.
Therefore, we found information on logic.

Let p: we search the internet


Q: we will find information about logic
p q
p
=q

4. ???
I am going shopping, or I am going to the museum.
I went to the museum.
Therefore, I did not go shopping.

Let p: I am going shopping


Q: I am going to the museum
pVq
?
?

5. Valid (Law of Hypothetical Syllogism)


If we serve salmon, then Vicky will join us for lunch.
If Vicky joins us for lunch, then Marilyn will not join us for lunch.
Therefore, if we serve salmon, then Marilyn will not join us for lunch.

Let p: we serve salmon


q: Vicky will join us for lunch.
r: Marilyn will not join us for lunch
p q
q r
=p r

6. Invalid (Fallacy of the inverse)


If a number is odd, then it is a prime number.
The number is not odd.
Therefore, the number is not a prime number.

Let p: a number is odd


q: it is a prime number
p q
-p
= -q
7. Invalid (Fallacy of the inverse)
If I go to beach for summer break, then I will not study.
I did not go to the beach for summer break.
Therefore, I studied.

Let p: I go to beach for summer break


q: I will not study
p q
-p
= -q
8. Valid (Law of Contraposition)
If the power goes off, then the air condition unit will not work.
The air condition unit is working.
Therefore, the power is not off.

Let p: the power goes off


q: air condition unit will not work
p q
-q
=-p
9. Valid (Law of Contraposition)
If the stock market rises, then the bond market will fall.
The bond market did not fall.
Therefore, the stock market did not rise.

Let p: the stock market rises


q: the bond market will fall
p q
-q
=-p
10. Valid (Law of Detachment)
If you help your classmate cheat, then you shall also be reprimanded.
You help your classmate cheat.
Therefore, you should be reprimanded.

Let p: you help your classmate cheat


q: you shall also be reprimanded
p q
p
=q

You might also like