Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By:
1.1.2.What is a switch?
A switch is a device for making and breaking the connection in an electric circuit. A simple
example is the light switch in a room which can be used to turn the lights on or off. In a
substation, Disconnectors, Earthing Switches and Circuit Breakers are typical examples of
switches.
1.2.2 Disconnector:
A disconnector or disconnecting switch a switch used typically in HV and EHV switchgears to
perform off load operations which in turn make the system ready for on load switching. Off load
switching is always done before on-load switching when the system is dead. Disconnecting
switch is sometimes denoted as ‘DS’
For Example :
DS
Power Cable Feeder
Supply Load
CB
ES
*The DS must be closed before closing the CB because if the CB is closed and the DS is allowed to
close after that, it will be on load switching at a very slow speed which will damage the system
due to arching.
*If we want to close the earthing switch, The DS should be open. Otherwise if the CB is closed ,
the power supply will be grounded. Or if the CB is open , anyone can close it which will ground
the power supply.
These are few simple cases which illustrate that in order to safely perform a switching operation,
a certain set of conditions need to be satisfied to allow the operation. In the above cases:
For CB operation, the DS must be closed. If DS is open, it should not allow CB to close.
For DS operation , the ES and the CB must be open. If anyone is close, it should not allow the
DS to operate.
For ES Operation, the DS must be open. If DS is closed, ES should not be allowed to operate.
So we can see that these are the 3 governing conditions or interlocks for ensuring safe switching
operation in the above 3 cases described. In other words, the first condition is the interlock for
the CB. The second condition is the interlock for the DS. And the third condition is the interlock
for the ES.
It should also be noted that interlock exists in both directions. i.e. For operation of disconnector,
the ES must be open. Subsequently , for operating of earth switch , disconnector must also be
open. Before closing of CB, DS must be closed. Subsequently , DS must only be allowed to
operate when CB is open.
All these conditions are included in the control scheme of the switches by wiring. If a bay control
unit relay is available for the bay, then these conditions can be included in soft logic also.
Interlock of earthing switch should always be with service position of the feeder CB.In
switchgears, CB in service means the CB is racked in. In GIS , CB in service means the
disconnectors of CB are closed. If So if DS is closed (or CB is racked in), ES should not be
allowed to close and vice virsa.
Interlock of DS should be with CB and ES.
ES.1
Upper Portion
UPPER
Remote End SS CB
ES.2
DS.2
ES.3
DS.4
Transformer Feeder
Middle Portion
ES.5 DS.3
VT.DS.2
MIDDLE
ES.8
CB
ES.4
Line Feeder
ES.6 VT.DS.1
DS.6
DS.5
ES.7 380KV
DS.7
230KV 13.8KV
ES.9
230KV GIS
Lower Portion
LOWER
CB
13.8KV
ES.1
ES.10 230KV
TRAFO 13.8KV
ES.1 CB
DS.8
BUS2 ES
13.8KV
230KV ES.2
380KV BUS.2 TRAFO
230KV DS 230KV
CB2 CB1
13.8KV BUS
230KV ES.2
Figure-7 : Single Line Diagram of a one and half breaker scheme bay .
Similarly the line feeder can also be connected to the Bus by two methods:
So we can see that three CBs are used to connect two feeders to the bus inside the substation. In
other words , one and half CB per feeder is required in this arrangement. Hence it is called one and
half circuit breaker scheme.
It is to be noted that the general conditions for CB that are not related to switches e.g. All Lock out
relays reset , Synchro check OK , CB spring charged , SF6 pressure normal,have not been mentioned
here. It is assumed that the reader is familiar with these conditions.
For easy understanding, we will break down the single line diagram into 6 portions:
1- The upper CB and its related disconnectors and earth switches or the ‘Upper portion’.
2- The Transformer feeder.
3- The middle CB and its related switches or the ‘Middle portion’.
4- The line feeder.
5- The lower CB and its related disconnectors and earth switches or the ‘lower portion’.
6- Bus Section.
DS.1
ES.1
Upper CB
DS.2
ES.2
As it is described in the previous section , the interlock of DS is with ES and CB. So logically the
interlock of DS.1 should exist with all the earth switches and Circuit Breakers that are directly
connected to DS.1.
So the question arises that what is the reason to include ‘ ES.2 OPEN’ status in the interlock when
the remaining statuses were enough to fulfill the interlock condition. The reason is that , every
switch is provided with several auxiliary contacts (Normally open and Normally Closed). These
contacts are used wherever the status of the switch is required in the scheme. An interlock circuit is
one example. The switch and its auxiliary contacts are tested during the commissioning of the
substation. However, the possibility cannot be over ruled that with the passage of time, there can be
a slight chance of any one of the contacts of one switch to malfunction. The possibility is very less
but it cannot be established that it will never happen.
Now let’s consider that in the given case, one (52-B) auxiliary contact of Upper CB gets stuck in
closed position. This means that its interpreting that the CB is Open. Now even if the CB is closed ,
this particular contact is giving the status that the CB is open. So if the same faulty auxiliary contact
is used in this DS.1 interlock, and the general rule is used to design interlock . i.e.
Then DS.1 will be allowed to close only if ‘Bus ES’ and ‘ES.1 ‘are open regardless of CB status. It
means that if CB is closed, and ES.2 is also closed , the system will think that CB is open and hence it
will allow DS.1 to close the connect the live bus bar to earth. To cope with this kind of situation, the
interlock is made more efficient by including ES.2 open status.
DS.3
ES.3=
ES.4=
As we can see that the service condition interlock for DS.3 is including switches from 380kV GIS as
well as 230kV GIS and 13.8kV switchgear. Lets break down the interlock into portions
DS.3 SERVICE=
(380kV)
There are 2 reasons for including the 230kV side and 13.8kV side in the interlocks.
1- If the disconnector on the HV side of transformer (DS.3) is closing , the interlock should not
only exist with the HV side earth switches but also the LV and tertiary (if tertiary winding is
available) side earth switches.
2- To avoid back energization. Or in other words , to define the direction of the load flow
through the transformer.
230 CB1 OPEN+230 CB2 OPEN+230 TRAFO ES1 OPEN+230 TIE ES2 OPEN
(230 TRAFO ES1 OPEN + 230 TRAFO ES2 OPEN) is used for condition #1 described above. It is making
sure that if the Transformer DS is going to close on the upper side, the earth switches on lower side
are open.
(230 CB1 OPEN+230 CB2 OPEN) is used for condition #2 described above. It is making sure that if the
Transformer DS is going close on the upper side , the lower side is still open and hence the flow of
load shall only be from upper side to lower side. If this condition was not included , there might be a
possibility that if 230kV Bus Bar is already energized and the respective CB is closed. It can back
energize the transformer.
It should be noted that instead of using (230 CB1 OPEN+230 CB2 OPEN) , (230 TRAFO DS OPEN)
could also be used to fulfill condition #2 for 230kV and avoid back energization. Hence we can see
that a particular interlock condition can be achieved in more than one way.
The 13.8kV Earth switches and CB are also included for the same purpose as 230kV.
DS.4
ES.5=
MIDDLE CB
SERVICE=DS4 CLOSE+ DS5 CLOSE +DS3 OPEN OR CLOSE+DS OPEN OR CLOSE +SYNCH CHECK
OK+CLOSE BLOCK OK +CLOSE AUTH OK
DS.5
ES.6=
ES.7=
DS.6
ES.8=
As we can see that the interlock of ES.8 is having some conditions that are different from the
conditions of all other switches.This holds true for line earth switches and transformer earth
switches. The interlock of Transformer feeder earth switch ES.4 in section 2.2.3 can be seen for
reference.
Now let us analyze the condition for ES.8 earth switch operation.
‘DS.6 OPEN’ is the normal condition which is making sure that the Line ES should not be allowed to
close if the Line DS is already close.But this condition is not enough to guarantee safe operation for
ES.8. The reason is that if the Line is energized from the remote end side the ES should not be
allowed to close in that case also as it will ground an energized line.For this purpose,An Under
Voltage relay is provided in the control panel of every feeder and the second portion of the interlock
is used to make sure that if the earth switch is going to close, it is a 100% safe operation to perform.
Now let us take a deeper look into the second part of the interlock equation.
We can see that it can further be divided into 3 portions. We will discuss the purpose of each
portion.
‘VT DS CLOSE’ :
A safe operation of the line earthing switch is performed by making sure that the line is already de-
energized or dead.For this purpose, on the local side we have already made sure that our line
disconnector is open by including it in the interlock condition. But the remote end line disconnector
is not available to us for using in the interlock.But if the line disconnector of the remote end is
closed, It will supply voltage to our station which can be read by the Line VT of my Feeder as the VT
is present after the Eathing switch.This voltage can then be used in the interlock.But in order for the
line VT to sense the voltage, we have to make sure that the VT disconnector is already closed.And
hence this condition has been added as the first portion of the interlock.
DS.7
ES.9=
LOWER CB
DS.8
ES.10=
DS.11 DS.12
BUS-1A BUS-1B
BS CB
VT-1B VT-2B
DS.1 DS.2 DS DS.1 DS.2
DS
ES.2 ES.2
ES.1 ES.1
LINE TRAFO
CB CB
ES.3 ES.3
DS.3 DS.3
VT DS
VT DS
ES.4 ES.4
115 KV
13.8 KV
REMOTE END
LINE ES
REMOTE END
LINE DS
13.8KV ES1
13.8KV
CB
13.8KV ES2
13.8KV BUS
Consider ‘Figure-8’ above showing the single line diagram representation of a typical double bus
single breaker system. All switches have been labelled for easy understanding. The same general
rules for interlocking will be applied here also as it is in one and half breaker scheme.
Like the one and half breaker scheme , the general conditions for CB that are not related to switches
e.g. All Lock out relays reset , Synchro check OK , CB spring charged , SF6 pressure normal, have not
been mentioned here also and it is assumed that the reader is familiar with these conditions.
Mechanical interlocks are also not mentioned although one example is given in Line Feeder
interlocks (ES.3) for understanding how mechanical interlocks work.
As we can see that in double bus single breaker scheme , the bus section is also having a circuit
breaker unline the one and half breaker scheme.Also for coupling of the two buses (for load transfer
or load sharing purpose) , two bus couplers are available.
For easy understanding, we will break down the single line diagram into 5 portions:
1- Line Feeder
2- Transformer feeder.
3- Bus Coupler -1
4- Bus Section
5- Bus Coupler-2
TEST = DS.1 OPEN + DS.2 OPEN + DS.3 OPEN + ALL LOR RESET
DS1:
SERVICE=ES.1 OPEN + ES.2 OPEN + ES.3 OPEN + ES.11 OPEN + DS.2 OPEN + CB OPEN
BUS TRANSFER: CB CLOSE + DS.2 CLOSE + { BC1 SERVICE CLOSE* OR (BC2 SERVICE CLOSE*+ BS
SERVICE CLOSE) } * Service close means Circuit breaker along with disconnectors on its both sides.
DS2:
SERVICE=ES.2 OPEN + ES.1 OPEN + ES.3 OPEN + ES.21 OPEN + DS.1 OPEN + CB OPEN
BUS TRANSFER: CB CLOSE + DS.1 CLOSE + { BC1 SERVICE CLOSE* OR (BC2 SERVICE CLOSE*+ BS
SERVICE CLOSE) } * Service close means Circuit breaker along with disconnectors on its both sides.
(LINE) DS.3 :
SERVICE = ES.1 OPEN + ES.2 OPEN + ES.3 OPEN + ES.4 OPEN + CB OPEN
ES.4:
DS.3 OPEN+ ALL 3 PHASES UV RELAY PICKED UP + LINE PT DS & VT BOX MCB CLOSED + VT MCB FOR
UV RELAY IN LCC PANEL ON
LINE VT DS:
As it has already been discussed that the interlock of an earth switch exists with service position of
CB. Now let us consider Figure-9 to analyze the portion of line feeder . To put the CB in service
position for this feeder , we need to close ‘DS.1 OR DS.2’ on the upper side of CB and DS.3 on the
lower side of CB.
DS.1
DS.2
ES.1
ES.2
CB
ES.3
DS.3
ES.4 VT DS
Figure-9 : Single line diagram of Line Feeder in Double Bus –Single Breaker arrangement
Hence according to the rules discussed above, the interlock of ES.3 should be as followes.
The reason for not mentioning DS.3 is that sometimes in GIS , the disconnector and earth switch
come as one unit that are mechanically interlocked with each other. In this case , the ES can not be
closed unless the DS of the same DS/ES unit is open. Hence the interlock of ES.3 in this particular
case exists with DS.3 also but as it is a mechanical interlock so it is not available in the electrical
interlocks.And hence not mentioned in Interlock equation also on purpose.
It is to be mentioned here that when reviewing a GIS interlocking scheme , you may face a similar
situation where you may not be able to find a necessary interlock in the electrical ciruit.In this case it
has to be verified that the mechanical interlock exists before establishing that the scheme is having
an error.
It should also be considered that , depending on the GIS model and manufacturer, the same DS.3
and ES.3 may not be present as a signle unit in some GIS and in that case the electrical interlock for
DS.3 will be included for ES.3
TEST = DS.1 OPEN + DS.2 OPEN + DS.3 OPEN + ALL LOR RESET
DS1:
SERVICE= ES.1 OPEN + ES.2 OPEN + ES.3 OPEN + ES.12 OPEN + DS.2 OPEN + CB OPEN
BUS TRANSFER: CB CLOSE + DS.2 CLOSE + { BC2 SERVICE CLOSE OR (BC1 SERVICE CLOSE+ BS SERVICE
CLOSE) }
DS2:
SERVICE= ES.2 OPEN + ES.1 OPEN + ES.3 OPEN + ES.22 OPEN + DS.1 OPEN + CB OPEN
BUS TRANSFER: CB CLOSE + DS.1 CLOSE + { BC2 SERVICE CLOSE OR (BC1 SERVICE CLOSE+ BS SERVICE
CLOSE) }
DS.3 :
SERVICE = ES.1 OPEN + ES.2 OPEN + ES.3 OPEN + ES.4 OPEN + CB OPEN+ LV SIDE ES OPEN
ES.3:
ES.4:
DS.3 OPEN+ ALL 3 PHASES UV RELAY PICKED UP + LINE PT DS & VT BOX MCB CLOSED + VT MCB FOR
UV RELAY IN LCC PANEL ON
TRAFO VT DS:
DS.1:
BUS.1 ES OPEN
DS.1 OPEN + BUS SEC DS.1 OPEN + ALL 3 PHASE UV + BUS PT DS CLOSE + ALL BUS-1 FEEDERS DS
OPEN + ES KEY ENABLE + PT BOX MCB CLOSE + LCC MCB GOING TO UV RELAY CLOSE.
DS.1:
INNER ES.1
OTHER DS OPEN