The document summarizes a study that compared the effectiveness of three small-group reading fluency interventions - repeated reading, listening passage preview, and listening only - with a control condition of students simply reading passages. Four 2nd grade students participated and received 16 intervention sessions. The study found that repeated reading was the most effective strategy, followed by listening passage preview, and both improved reading fluency more than the control condition. The results suggest these small-group interventions can be effective in improving reading fluency over brief periods when materials are practiced.
The document summarizes a study that compared the effectiveness of three small-group reading fluency interventions - repeated reading, listening passage preview, and listening only - with a control condition of students simply reading passages. Four 2nd grade students participated and received 16 intervention sessions. The study found that repeated reading was the most effective strategy, followed by listening passage preview, and both improved reading fluency more than the control condition. The results suggest these small-group interventions can be effective in improving reading fluency over brief periods when materials are practiced.
The document summarizes a study that compared the effectiveness of three small-group reading fluency interventions - repeated reading, listening passage preview, and listening only - with a control condition of students simply reading passages. Four 2nd grade students participated and received 16 intervention sessions. The study found that repeated reading was the most effective strategy, followed by listening passage preview, and both improved reading fluency more than the control condition. The results suggest these small-group interventions can be effective in improving reading fluency over brief periods when materials are practiced.
Increasing Elementary-aged Students’ Reading Fluency with
Small-group Interventions: A Comparison of Repeated Reading,
Listening Passage Preview, and Listening Only Strategies Abstract In research found from Begeny et al. (2009), small-group interventions are practical and often more time efficient than individualized interventions aimed to address this problem. The primary purpose of this study was to examine three small-group reading interventions that have been used to improve students’ reading fluency (repeated reading, listening passage preview, and listening only).
Method - 4 second grade students participated in the study
- 2 female, 2 male, two African-American, 1 Hispanic, & 1 caucasian - Students were selected based off of a Winter screening assessment - All participants read between 25th & 50th percentile - 3 in-school psychologists implemented the intervention - Interventions were evaluated immediately after implementation & 2 days after using a CBM measurement (Begeny et al., 2009) - DIBELS/ORF-CBM used in this study - Students received 16 simultaneously sessions - Control condition: students read the passage - Listening Passage Preview (LLP): Students were group together, instructor read scripted directions & explicitly instructed students what to do in each lesson (Begeny et al., 2009). Instructor would read the passage multiple times. Students would read after the instructor read the passage 4-5 times. Students would follow along on the passage. - Repeated Readings: the student group leader would read the passage, while the other students read Along quietly with the leader. Students would switch roles & read the same passage. - Listening Only: Students would only listen to their instructor read the passage twice. Students were not provided the passage while their instructor read aloud.
Results - Research found from Begeny et al. (2009), supported the
repeated reading intervention, followed by listening passage preview, as most effective. Findings also suggested that improvements from each intervention remained 2 days later. - Each of the intervention strategies outperformed the Control condition Discussion - The data from this study do suggest that small-group interventions can be effective in improving students’ reading fluency of materials practiced for relatively brief periods of time (Begeny et al., 2009). - Educators need to provide these interventions to students who are struggling with reading fluency
Begeny, J. C., Krouse, H. E., Ross, S. G., & Mitchell, R. C. (2009). Increasing
Elementary-aged Students’ Reading Fluency with Small-group Interventions: A
Comparison of Repeated Reading, Listening Passage Preview, and Listening Only
Strategies. Journal of Behavioral Education, 18(3), 211–228.
Evidence-Based Practices Applications of Concrete Representational Abstract Framework Across Math Concepts For Students With Mathematics Disabilities Notes 3