Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DEP 30.10.60.32-Gen.
February 2015
DEM1
PREFACE
DEP (Design and Engineering Practice) publications reflect the views, at the time of publication, of Shell Global Solutions
International B.V. (Shell GSI) and, in some cases, of other Shell Companies.
These views are based on the experience acquired during involvement with the design, construction, operation and
maintenance of processing units and facilities. Where deemed appropriate DEPs are based on, or reference international,
regional, national and industry standards.
The objective is to set the standard for good design and engineering practice to be applied by Shell companies in oil and
gas production, oil refining, gas handling, gasification, chemical processing, or any other such facility, and thereby to help
achieve maximum technical and economic benefit from standardization.
The information set forth in these publications is provided to Shell companies for their consideration and decision to
implement. This is of particular importance where DEPs may not cover every requirement or diversity of condition at each
locality. The system of DEPs is expected to be sufficiently flexible to allow individual Operating Units to adapt the
information set forth in DEPs to their own environment and requirements.
When Contractors or Fabricators use DEPs, they shall be solely responsible for such use, including the quality of their
work and the attainment of the required design and engineering standards. In particular, for those requirements not
specifically covered, the Principal will typically expect them to follow those design and engineering practices that will
achieve at least the same level of integrity as reflected in the DEPs. If in doubt, the Contractor or Fabricator shall, without
detracting from his own responsibility, consult the Principal.
The right to obtain and to use DEPs is restricted, and is typically granted by Shell GSI (and in some cases by other Shell
Companies) under a Service Agreement or a License Agreement. This right is granted primarily to Shell companies and
other companies receiving technical advice and services from Shell GSI or another Shell Company. Consequently, three
categories of users of DEPs can be distinguished:
1) Operating Units having a Service Agreement with Shell GSI or another Shell Company. The use of DEPs by these
Operating Units is subject in all respects to the terms and conditions of the relevant Service Agreement.
2) Other parties who are authorised to use DEPs subject to appropriate contractual arrangements (whether as part of
a Service Agreement or otherwise).
3) Contractors/subcontractors and Fabricators under a contract with users referred to under 1) or 2) which requires
that tenders for projects, materials supplied or - generally - work performed on behalf of the said users comply with
the relevant standards.
Subject to any particular terms and conditions as may be set forth in specific agreements with users, Shell GSI disclaims
any liability of whatsoever nature for any damage (including injury or death) suffered by any company or person
whomsoever as a result of or in connection with the use, application or implementation of any DEP, combination of DEPs
or any part thereof, even if it is wholly or partly caused by negligence on the part of Shell GSI or other Shell Company. The
benefit of this disclaimer shall inure in all respects to Shell GSI and/or any Shell Company, or companies affiliated to these
companies, that may issue DEPs or advise or require the use of DEPs.
Without prejudice to any specific terms in respect of confidentiality under relevant contractual arrangements, DEPs shall
not, without the prior written consent of Shell GSI, be disclosed by users to any company or person whomsoever and the
DEPs shall be used exclusively for the purpose for which they have been provided to the user. They shall be returned after
use, including any copies which shall only be made by users with the express prior written consent of Shell GSI. The
copyright of DEPs vests in Shell Group of companies. Users shall arrange for DEPs to be held in safe custody and Shell
GSI may at any time require information satisfactory to them in order to ascertain how users implement this requirement.
All administrative queries should be directed to the DEP Administrator in Shell GSI.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................ 5
1.1 SCOPE........................................................................................................................ 5
1.2 DISTRIBUTION, INTENDED USE AND REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS ......... 5
1.3 DEFINITIONS ............................................................................................................. 5
1.4 CROSS-REFERENCES ............................................................................................. 7
1.5 SUMMARY OF MAIN CHANGES ............................................................................... 7
1.6 COMMENTS ON THIS DEP ....................................................................................... 7
1.7 DUAL UNITS ............................................................................................................... 7
1.8 NON-NORMATIVE TEXT (COMMENTARY) .............................................................. 7
1.9 PRECEDENCE OF DOCUMENTS ............................................................................. 7
2. QUALITY PROGRAM ................................................................................................ 9
2.1 GENERAL ................................................................................................................... 9
2.2 PERSONNEL COMPETENCES ................................................................................. 9
2.3 INSPECTION AND TEST PLAN ............................................................................... 10
2.4 DEVIATIONS ............................................................................................................ 10
2.5 FINAL ACCEPTANCE .............................................................................................. 10
3. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS .................................................................................. 11
3.1 WELDING PROCESSES .......................................................................................... 11
3.2 MATERIALS .............................................................................................................. 11
4. WELDING PROCEDURE PREPARATION AND QUALIFICATION ....................... 14
4.1 GENERAL ................................................................................................................. 14
4.2 PREVIOUSLY QUALIFIED PROCEDURES ............................................................ 14
4.3 PROCEDURE DOCUMENTATION .......................................................................... 14
4.4 ESSENTIAL VARIABLES ......................................................................................... 14
4.5 WELDING PROCEDURE QUALIFICATION TESTING ............................................ 15
5 WELDER QUALIFICATION ..................................................................................... 20
5.1 GENERAL ................................................................................................................. 20
5.2 WELDER IDENTIFICATION ..................................................................................... 20
5.3 WELDER PRE-QUALIFICATION ............................................................................. 20
5.4 QUALIFICATION DOCUMENTATION ..................................................................... 20
5.5 TIME LIMITATIONS .................................................................................................. 20
6. PREHEATING AND POSTWELD HEAT TREATMENT .......................................... 21
6.1 PREHEATING ........................................................................................................... 21
6.2 POSTWELD HEAT TREATMENT ............................................................................ 22
7. WELD INSPECTION ................................................................................................ 28
7.1 METHODS AND EXTENT OF NONDESTRUCTIVE EXAMINATION...................... 28
7.2 TESTING QUALIFICATIONS ................................................................................... 28
8. WELD REPAIRS ...................................................................................................... 30
8.1 DEFECT REMOVAL ................................................................................................. 30
8.2 RE-WELDING ........................................................................................................... 30
8.3 NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING ................................................................................ 30
8.4 DEFECT AND REPAIR RATE RECORDS ............................................................... 30
9. HEALTH, SAFETY, SECURITY, AND ENVIRONMENT CONSIDERATIONS ....... 31
9.1 GENERAL ................................................................................................................. 31
9.2 WELDING EQUIPMENT ........................................................................................... 31
9.3 ALIGNMENT ............................................................................................................. 31
10. MATERIAL-SPECIFIC ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS ........................................ 32
10.1 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS ................................................................................... 32
10.2 WPQR MONITORING .............................................................................................. 32
10.3 WPQR REQUIREMENTS ......................................................................................... 32
10.4 PARAMETER MONITORING ................................................................................... 33
10.5 CMN STEELS NOT INTENDED FOR LOW TEMPERATURE SERVICE ................ 34
10.6 IMPACT TESTED CMn STEELS (LTCS) ................................................................. 36
APPENDICES
APPENDIX A REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR WELDING QUALIFICATION ............. 64
APPENDIX B RECOMMENDED PRACTICE FOR DETERMINING VOLUME
FRACTION OF FERRITE IN DUPLEX STAINLESS STEEL
WELDMENTS BY SYSTEMATIC POINT COUNTS ....................................... 66
APPENDIX C INSPECTION AND TEST PLAN EXAMPLE .................................................. 70
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 SCOPE
This new DEP specifies requirements and gives recommendations for organising and
managing quality assurance (QA) and quality control (QC) for welding of metals, based on
ISO standards.
This DEP is a counterpart to DEP 30.10.60.18-Gen., which is based on API RP 582.
This DEP is written in accordance with the latest regulations in force within the European
economic area including the European Pressure Equipment Directive (PED) 97/23/EC and
is based on the referenced standards, which cover all aspects of the design and fabrication
of pressure equipment.
This DEP recognises and builds on the expertise and good practices developed in previous
Shell specifications.
The scope of this DEP does not include pipeline or civil structural welding.
DEP 61.40.20.30-Gen., DEP 37.81.40.31-Gen. and DEP 30.10.60.30-Gen. cover pipeline
welding, and DEP 37.81.10.34-Gen. covers civil structural welding.
This DEP contains mandatory requirements to mitigate process safety risks in accordance
with Design Engineering Manual (DEM) 1 - Application of Technical Standards.
1.3 DEFINITIONS
1.3.1 General definitions
The Contractor is the party that carries out all or part of the design, engineering,
procurement, construction, commissioning or management of a project or operation of a
facility. The Principal may undertake all or part of the duties of the Contractor.
The Fabricator is the party that manufactures or fabricates the equipment and provides
services to perform the duties specified by the Contractor.
The Principal is the party that initiates the project and ultimately pays for it. The Principal
may also include an agent or consultant authorised to act for, and on behalf of, the
Principal.
The word shall indicates a requirement.
The capitalised term SHALL [PS] indicates a process safety requirement.
Term Definition
ANSI American National Standards Institute
ASME American Society of Mechanical Engineers
ASTM American Society for Testing and Materials
AWS American Welding Society
B Maximum nominal pipe wall thickness for “as-welded” application
C Carbon (chemical element)
CI Confidence Interval
CMn Carbon Manganese
CSWIP Certification Scheme for Weld Inspection Personnel
EWF European Federation for Welding, Joining and Cutting
FCAW Flux Cored Arc Welding
GMAW Gas Metal Arc Welding
GTAW Gas Tungsten Arc Welding
HAZ Heat Affected Zone
IIW International Institute of Welding
ITP Inspection & Test Plan
IVB Independent Verification Body
MT Magnetic Particle Inspection
NDE Nondestructive Examination
NOBO Notified Body
OD Outside Diameter
PED (European) Pressure Equipment Directive
PREn Pitting Resistance Equivalent number
PT Liquid Penetrant Examination
PWHT Postweld Heat Treatment
RT Radiographic Testing
SAW Submerged Arc Welding
SMAW Shielded Metal Arc Welding
T Nominal Pipe Wall Thickness
TMCR Thermo-Mechanically Controlled Rolled
TOFD Time Of Flight Diffraction
USC United States Customary
UT Ultrasonic Testing
VT Visual Testing
Term Definition
WPQR Welding Procedure Qualification Record
WPS Welding Procedure Specification
1.4 CROSS-REFERENCES
Where cross-references to other parts of this DEP are made, the referenced section or
clause number is shown in brackets ( ). Other documents referenced by this DEP are listed
in (11).
Feedback that has been registered in the DEP Feedback System by using one of the above
options will be reviewed by the DEP Custodian for potential improvements to the DEP.
2. QUALITY PROGRAM
2.1 GENERAL
1. Welding QA/QC of equipment and piping components shall be implemented under a
Fabricator quality management system that conforms to ISO 9001 and ISO 3834.
2. Comprehensive quality requirements shall be selected to be applied for all welded
components. This is specified in more detail in ISO-3834-2.
3. The Fabricator shall operate a quality system in accordance with ISO 3834-2 and
ISO 9001. This system shall be certified by an IVB unless otherwise approved by the
Principal.
4. For each WPS, the Fabricator shall specify the specific welding consumables, welding
processes, and welding operators. Approval for use shall be obtained from the
Principal.
5. Fabricator shall refer to ISO 3834-6 in the development and maintenance of its quality
system related to welding activities.
6 A welding procedure specification (WPS) shall be considered an engineering
document and is part of the detailed design of a component.
7. The requirements specified in ISO 3834-5 are applicable even if not specifically
referenced in this DEP.
2.4 DEVIATIONS
1. All deviations and non-conformances to the requirements in this DEP shall be
approved by the Principal. This approval shall be obtained in writing.
2. Any conflicts between the requirements of this DEP and other relevant documents
shall be referred to the Principal for resolution.
3. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
2. Gas shielded processes (GTAW, GSFCAW, GMAW, MCAW, PAW) shall be used in
the field only if adequate weather shielding, that is approved by the Principal, is
provided.
3. SAW systems shall be fully mechanised (automated).
4. GMAW or MCAW may be allowed if the Fabricator can demonstrate to the Principal’s
satisfaction, adequate experience with the processes, ongoing control over the
process, and the continued competence of the welders.
5. Unless otherwise approved by the Principal, the root and second pass of all single-
sided welds shall be made using GTAW.
6. Unless otherwise specified, all GTAW machines shall be equipped with arc starting
devices, e.g., high frequency starting unit, crater-eliminating, slope-out control, etc. If
regulations do not permit arc starting devices, alternative proposals shall be submitted
to the Principal for approval.
7. Permitted applications of the welding processes listed in (3.1, Item 1) are specified in
the relevant material section of this DEP.
3.2 MATERIALS
3.2.1 Grouping
1. Material groupings for substrate/parent materials and weld metals are defined in
ISO/TR 15608. Substrate/parent materials identified under different groupings shall be
defined as dissimilar metals to be welded.
2. Similar parent material welded with other grouping weld metal shall be treated as a
dissimilar metal weld.
3.2.2 Parent materials certification
1. Materials used for qualification of WPSs shall be representative of materials to be used
in production welding. The Principal shall confirm if a material used on a WPQR is
considered representative of the production material.
2. Materials shall be supplied to a recognised manufacturing specification and certified in
accordance with EN10204 (ISO 10474), inspection certificate 3.1.
4.1 GENERAL
1. Welding procedures for all welded joints SHALL [PS] be prepared and qualified n
accordance with ISO 15614, and this DEP.
2. Each Fabricator shall prepare its own WPSs and qualify its own welding procedures.
WPSs shall contain information as specified in ISO 15609 and (Appendix A).
3. The testing results for WPQR/weld test record shall be presented in a detailed format
and with traceable document trail (Appendix A).
4. Unless otherwise specified, multi-pass fillet welds may be qualified by the qualified
procedure for groove welds in accordance with ISO 15614, although separate WPSs
for groove and fillet welds shall be submitted. Single pass fillet welds shall be
separately qualified in accordance with ISO 15614.
5. The basis for rejection of WPSs shall be either non-compliance with this DEP, or non-
conformance to industry practice (ISO/TR documents).
6. The approval of WPSs by the Principal is subject to acceptable performance in
subsequent production welding. Approval may be withdrawn where excessive repair
rates are encountered that cannot be attributed to bad workmanship.
Weaving is restricted as quality control in addition to heat input and mitigation of air
ingress to minimize risk of porosity on gas shielding welding processes.
2. Visual examination of completed welds shall be conducted by both the Fabricator and
the Principal, or its representative. When NOBO witness is required this shall be
arranged by the Fabricator.
a. Cutting of a test piece for mechanical testing should not take place until it has
been visually examined and accepted by the NOBO or a recognised
independent third party.
b. Should the test piece diameter be too small to allow proper examination of the
weld root, the test piece shall be cut longitudinally to facilitate examination.
c. For new welding procedure qualifications where alternative or additional NDE
methods are proposed for production welding (e.g.; time-of-flight diffraction
(TOFD)), the test piece shall also be subjected to these methods.
3. When acceptance criteria is not defined in the purchase specifications, the acceptance
criteria shall be defined as “the design code requirements or ISO 5817 quality level B.”
The NDE acceptance criteria are normally covered by the selected design code for
the equipment or piping, for example PD 5500 or EN 13445.
4.5.3 Macro section examination
4.5.3.1 General
1. Macro sections shall be prepared so that the whole cross section of the weld, inclusive
of HAZ, and adjacent parent material can be examined. These shall be etched to
reveal individual passes and the full extent of the HAZ.
2. Macro sections shall be examined under magnification. This should typically be
between 3x to 8x.
3. WPQR documentation shall include photographs of the macro sections. Any hardness
survey indentations shall be visible on the photographs. Photographs shall be marked
to indicate the magnification. Only original photographs or good-quality digital images
shall be accepted as part of the WPQR documentation.
4. For weld acceptance the examination of the macro section shall not reveal any cracks,
lack of fusion (root, sidewall or inter-run) or volumetric defects (slag, porosity, etc.) that
are outside the limits set by the design code or ISO 5817 quality level B.
5. At the request of the Principal, volumetric defects shall be investigated further by
grinding and/or re-sectioning the macro section to determine the extent of the defects.
4.5.3.2 Hardness testing
1. Hardness surveys, as specified in ISO 15614, shall be carried out on macro sections
using Vickers hardness at 10 Kg load.
2. Hardness testing shall be in accordance with ISO 6507-1.
3. Unless otherwise specified, the following general hardness requirements for base
material, HAZ, and weld metal shall apply:
a. For sour environments in oil and gas production facilities, all hardness testing
and acceptance values shall meet the requirements of DEP 30.10.02.15-Gen.
b. For wet H2S environments in petroleum refining and related processing
environments, all hardness testing and acceptance values shall meet the
requirements of that DEP 30.10.02.17-Gen.
c. In general, for carbon steel with base metal thickness ≤ 10 mm (3/8 in), 250
HV10 maximum hardness is permitted for the full weld thickness. However for
thickness > 10mm (3/8 in), 275 HV10 hardness is permitted in the cap when
the hardness impression is located at least 8 mm (5/16 in) from the internal
surface.(See sketch below).
d. For ferritic metals (for instance low allow steels) in process services, including
H2 service conditions, the maximum permitted hardness is 250Hv10 for the
entire weld and the HAZ.
e. For ferritic metals in sweet service without sour/H2S exposure, the maximum
permitted hardness is 300 HV10 for the HAZ and 275Hv10 for the weld metal.
f. For ferritic metals in utility services (steam, air, water, non-sour service), the
maximum permitted hardness is 300 HV10.
g. For 9 % Ni steels in the as-welded condition, the maximum permitted
hardness is 350 HV10.
h. For 9Cr-1Mo-V steel (P91, T91) in the PWHT condition, the maximum
permitted hardness is 290 HV10 and API TR 938-B shall be followed for
guidance.
i. For structural steels not directly welded to pressure containing parts, the
maximum permitted hardness is 325 HV10.
j. For 3.5 % Ni steel with base metal thickness ≤ 9.5 mm (3/8 in), the maximum
permitted hardness is 250 HV10. However, for joint thickness > 9.5mm (3/8
in), 275 HV10 hardness is permitted in the mid-thickness and cap when the
hardness impression is located at least 8 mm (5/16 in) from the internal
surface.
k. For duplex stainless steels, the maximum hardness for quality control purpose
shall target 334 Hv10 for 22%Cr DSS and for 25Cr DSS shall target 378 Hv10.
l. For austenitic stainless steels, the maximum hardness shall be 250 Hv10.
4.5.3.3 Low temperature, impact testing
1. For impact testing, ISO/TR 15608 specifies additional material group-specific
requirements.
The materials within each group have a unique response to low temperature
conditions, therefore, weld qualification impact testing is group specific.
2. The following Tables 2 and 3 shall be used in lieu of Tables 3 and 4 in ISO 15614-1 for
range of qualification for materials:
a. Covers the equal or lower specified yield strength steels of the same group
b. Covers steels in the same sub-group and any lower sub-group within the same
group
c. Covers steels in the same sub-group
Table 3 Range of qualification for nickel alloy and nickel alloy/steel groups
5 WELDER QUALIFICATION
5.1 GENERAL
1. All welders and welding operators shall be qualified in accordance with ISO 9606.
Qualifications to other equivalent codes may be considered when reviewing the
performance range of the welder.
6.1 PREHEATING
6.1.1 Preheat temperature
1. For carbon-manganese and low alloy steels, the minimum preheat temperature shall
be as calculated in accordance with ISO/TR 17671-2 using the maximum carbon
equivalent allowed for the material to be welded and the weld metal hydrogen level
guaranteed by an approved consumable control procedure.
2. If higher preheat temperatures are necessary to meet the hardness values required by
this DEP, particularly for sour service conditions, in accordance with
DEP 30.10.02.15-Gen. or DEP 30.10.02.17-Gen., as applicable, the temperature
margin above the minimum required by ISO/TR 17671-2 shall be applied to all
thicknesses to be welded.
3. For reinforced branch fittings, such as “olets”, that are to be welded, the minimum
preheat temperature shall be 50°C (90°F) above that specified by ISO/TR 17671-2.
4. If preheat is not explicitly required by this DEP and ambient temperature is below 5°C
(41°F), or if condensation/moisture is apparent on work surfaces, then sufficient
preheat shall be applied to ensure work surfaces are dry and remain warm to the
touch.
5. For 3½ % nickel steels, a minimum preheat temperature of 100 °C (212 °F) shall be
used for welding all thicknesses.
6.1.2 Preheat application
6.1.2.1 General
1. For materials with wall thickness up to and including 19 mm (3/4 in), preheating shall be
by gas torch or electrical resistance heaters. For wall thickness above 19 mm (3/4 in),
electric resistance heating mats shall be used, unless it is agreed with Principal that access
or location makes it impractical.
2. Electrical resistance elements shall be controlled by thermocouples attached on or
adjacent to the weld preparation.
3. Thermocouple devices shall be regularly calibrated as specified in ISO 17663 and
ISO 60548-2, with a maximum interval of six months.
4. Preheating with oxy/fuel gas should only be by soft flame burners designed for the
purpose.
5. Handheld oxy/fuel gas burners should only be used for welds on pipes less than
168.3 mm OD (DN150 (NPS 6)) or attachment welds less than 300 mm (12 in) long.
This only applies where preheat above 20 °C (68 °F) is required.
6. The temperature of preheat implemented by non-electrical means shall be measured
using contact pyrometers, temperature indicating crayons, or thermocouples.
a. If there is access, temperature measurement shall be taken on the surface
opposite of the one being heated.
i. Measurement shall be taken at a location that is displaced from the
source of heat by a minimum of 25 mm (1 in) in a direction parallel to
the vessel, process piping, or other equipment axis.
ii. Measurement shall be taken after removal of the heat source.
b. If there is no access to the opposite surface, temperature measurement shall
be taken 75 mm (3 in) from both weld toes / edges and delayed for a period
not less than two seconds per mm of material thickness after removal of the
heat source.
7. Temperature indicating crayons shall be certified to be free (less than 1 ppm) of lead
and sulphur or any other low melting constituent.
8. Residue from crayons shall be removed from the weld surface before proceeding with
the weld.
9. Thermocouples shall be installed under resistance heater mats, unless test trials prove
the process will not expose the component to temperatures above the lower critical
transformation temperature of the base metal alloy.
6.1.2.2 Welding interruption considerations
1. When interruption of welding is required, loss of specified preheat temperature is
permitted for unalloyed steels (Group 1) with UTS of 450 N/mm² (65 ksi) or lower, or
for steels with UTS of 490 N/mm² (70 ksi) when welded with low hydrogen
consumables and with a welded thickness of less than 28 mm (1.1 in).
2. Unless otherwise specified, at least 30 % of the weld joint thickness shall have been
completed prior to interrupting welding. After interruption, the joint shall be slow cooled
under insulation. Preheating shall be restored to the specified temperature before
welding is recommenced.
3. If welding is interrupted, with associated cooling, and the completed weld ligament
depth is less than 30 % of the total joint thickness, then the appropriate surface
inspection (e.g., MT or PT) shall be performed to ensure freedom from deleterious
defects.
4. Other materials may allow for interruption of welding, but only as permitted by the
applicable code and relevant industry standards, and as a minimum, the root and
second pass shall be completed before it is permissible to interrupt welding progress
and allow the joint to cool.
6.1.3 Interpass temperature
1. In general, the maximum welding interpass temperature for production welding shall
not exceed that measured during welding procedure qualification WPQR by more than
50°C (122°F), though there may be additional limitations in the relevant material-
specific section.
Where conflict between this requirement and the base material temper develops, it
shall be brought to the attention of the Principal for resolution.
6. The Contractor or Fabricator shall purchase materials which will allow the additional
heat treatment cycles after welding.
7. When production test coupons are requested they shall have the same PWHT
conditions as the actual items in the assembly. This includes the heating method either
in a furnace or local heat treatment by resistance mats or induction coils
a. Total soak time and cycles for coupons shall be set according to the thickness
of the coupons and equipment thickness.
b. Soak time on the WPQR shall not be less than what is expected for the
maximum thickness range in production welding.
c. If additional PWHT cycles need to be applied on the material, additional
production test coupons exposed to the same heat cycle are required to verify
the mechanical properties stated in the WPQR are maintained.
8. Procedures for PWHT of dissimilar metal welds shall be approved by the Principal.
9. No welding or heating shall be carried out after final PWHT.
10. Unless otherwise agreed with the Principal, all welds in AISI 4130 material shall be
subject to PWHT.
11. Cooling in still air is permitted below 300°C (572°F).
6.2.2 Piping PWHT
1. If there is no subsequent machining operation, all piping threads and gasket surfaces
shall be protected from oxidation whilst the equipment is subjected to PWHT.
2. Non-ferrous and austenitic materials do not normally require PWHT. However, if
approval is granted or if directed by the Principal (e.g. where austenitic steel is to be
welded to CMn steel), PWHT shall be carried out generally in accordance with this
DEP section. Additional requirements as deemed necessary for the materials involved
will be advised by the Principal.
6.2.3 PWHT procedure
1. A PWHT procedure shall be submitted for approval to the Principal prior to
commencing PWHT. As a minimum, the procedure shall include the following
information:
a. name of (sub-)Contractor;
b. ruling specification;
c. material and item type;
d. method of heating;
e. fuel gas and method of atmosphere control (if gas-fired furnace);
f. size and type of electrical element (if electrical resistance);
g. type, location and number of thermocouples;
h. method of thermocouple attachment and removal;
i. details of loading and supporting arrangements to avoid distortion;
j. provisions to avoid flame impingement (if flame heated)
k. holding time and temperature;
l. heating and cooling rates;
m. type of recording equipment including number of channels;
n. chart speed.
o. Calibration documentation
2. All PWHT shall be carried out in accordance with the approved procedure
6.2.4 Furnace PWHT
1. Unless otherwise approved by the Principal, PWHT shall be performed in a fully
enclosing furnace.
2. Fuel powered furnaces shall have adequate flame controls to avoid an oxidising
furnace atmosphere. Flame impingement onto PWHT items is not permitted.
3. Unless otherwise specified by the applicable code, the temperature during heating and
cooling shall not vary by more than 150 °C (270 °F) in any 4.5 m (15 ft) length of
piping.
4. The number of thermocouples shall be sufficient to ensure that the temperature and
thermal gradients of the whole of the work are within the required range.
5. One thermocouple shall be attached directly to each spool at the point of greatest wall
thickness.
6. If a large number of small spools are to be treated in one batch, thermocouples may
be attached to a representative number (no less than one in four) of the spools.
6.2.5 Local PWHT
1. Local PWHT may be used if size or installation restrictions prevent furnace PWHT.
2. For local PWHT, heating shall be by electrical resistance heating elements, unless
otherwise specified. Other heating methods may be considered. These shall be
submitted for review and approval by the Principal.
3. For local PWHT the soak temperature shall be achieved and maintained in a band
2.5 x weld thickness either side of the weld centre line. The width of the thermal
insulation shall be 7.5 x weld thickness either side of the weld centre line.
4. Circulation of air in the bore of the process piping or equipment work shall be
prevented.
5. The minimum number and position of thermocouples on pipe shall be as follows:
6. Thermocouples shall be located on the weld centre line and shall be held in intimate
contact with the surface of the weld by mechanical means or by capacitance discharge
welding. The attachment points of capacitance discharge welded thermocouples shall
be dressed by grinding after removal.
7. For 2G oriented welds the thermocouples shall be placed below the bottom toe of the
weld bevel.
6.2.6 Equipment calibration
1. The sub- Contractor shall approve calibration procedures for all equipment measuring
and recording temperature. As a minimum, temperature recorders shall be calibrated
every three months.
4. The number and positions of thermocouples shall be in accordance with the design
code. As a minimum, three thermocouples shall be directly attached on a work piece,
as indicated in Figure 2 below. For a hollow configuration, there shall be one additional
thermocouple on the inside.
5)7) 8)
2.25Cr 1Mo all 200°(392)-250°(482) all 630°(1166)- 680°(1265) 5
6) 7)
680°(1265)- 720°(1328)
7)9)
720°(1328)- 750°(1382)
5) 7 8)
5Cr 0.5Mo 9Cr 1Mo all 200°(392)-250°(482) all 680°(1265)- 720°(1328) 5
7) 9)
720°(1328)- 760°(1400)
10)
12-17 Cr martensitic ss all 200°(392)-300°(492) all 700°(1292)- 790°(1454) 2,5
NOTES: 1. If ambient temperature is below 5°C (41F) pre-heating at 40°C (104F) is recommended. (see also
6.1.1.)
2. Minimum holding time 1 hour.
3. Low hydrogen filler metals have to be used.
4. PWHT is required for Ceq ≥ 0,45 or C ≥ 0,23.unless otherwise agreed with the Principal.
5. For optimum high temperature creep properties in general the lower side of the temperature range
is used.
6. Temperature range in the case of service for hydrogen (H2) or general refinery services.
7. Minimum 10° below refinement temperature.
8. For the larger thickness (>25mm (>1in)) components De-Hydrogenation Treatment (DHT) need to
be considered when Intermediate Stress Relief (ISR), according to the industry best practices
such as API 934.
9. Temperature range for maximum softening.
10. PWHT temperature selection is based on the original heat treatment temperature of the base
metal used.
11. The higher temperature range is specifically for resistance to amine cracking 620°(1148) -
650°(1202) and carbonate cracking 649°(1200) - 663°(1225).
7. WELD INSPECTION
8. WELD REPAIRS
8.2 RE-WELDING
1. If back purging was used on the original weld, the back purge shall be re-established if
the repair excavation encroaches closer than 6 mm (1/4 in) to the inside surface of the
vessel, process piping or equipment.
9.1 GENERAL
1. Unless local regulations are more stringent, the following shall apply:
a. Protective clothing for use in welding and allied processes shall conform to
ISO 11611;
b. Equipment for oxygen and acetylene shall conform to ISO 14114 and
ISO 5172;
c. Welding equipment shall conform to IEC 60974-x;
d. Ventilation of welding and cutting fumes shall conform to ANSI Z49.1 /
AWS Z49.1.
e. There are no ISO/IEC documents available to support a fume or ventilation
specification. Trichlorethylene, Acetone and other hydrocarbon based solvents
that produce toxic gases upon welding shall not be used as degreasing
agents.
Dedicated cleaning agents are available on the market for degreasing of
the weld bevel and consumable bare wire (GTAW).
2. HSSE assessment for confined space entry, ventilation, and welding is required as
part of the confined space entry and permit-to-work system. Specific attention shall be
paid to the oxygen depletion risks and visual inspection ability/restrictions for the
welder.
3. Welding close to live (gas) plant facilities shall require specific safety and risk
assessment, with regard to the use of habitats and specific requirements for gas
detection and power/circuit breakers of the equipment used.
4. Whilst it is generally undesirable to change the type of tungsten electrode used for
GTAW from that qualified (e.g., move away from thoriated tungsten), this change shall
not be considered an essential variable change when made for health and safety
reasons provided that there are no other significant welding procedure changes.
5. Thoriated tungsten electrodes shall not be used in production welding, unless
specifically approved by the Principal. In case approval is granted, automated
sharpeners with dust removal facilities shall be used, along with an approved removal
procedure. The number of thoriated tungsten electrodes at the welder location shall be
limited to three.
6. All equipment shall be in good condition and properly maintained with records to
support its ongoing safe operation.
9.3 ALIGNMENT
1. Equipment used to hold and support process equipment, vessels, piping, etc., shall be
capable of bearing the load in a safe manner whilst maintaining the stability required
for working in both the vertical and horizontal planes.
12. Electrode / Filler Rod SMAW filling & cap passes, Normal practice is one electrode
Size diameter change is allowed within the consumable
manufacturer recommended optimal parameters settings, max
4mm diameter use.
13. PWHT Increase in total PWHT time exceeding 25% requires
requalification
14. Automation a. Semi-automated and automated welding processes such
as orbital GTAW, Adaptive GMAW such as STT (Surface
Tension Transfer), RMD (Regulated Metal Deposition),
ESAB QSET (optimal short arc parameters settings) and
CMT (Cold Metal Transfer), require additional quality
control.
b. The full parameter settings shall be reported during
qualification, archived and fully traceable during the
fabrication stage.
c. Automatic weld parameter monitoring is required during the
qualification process. Optionally automatic welding
parameter monitoring may be selected for quality control
during fabrication.
15. Cladding of corrosion a. The heat input is restricted in reference with the
resistant alloys ISO 15614-7 by -10 / +25%. Also the electrode diameter
(process 111/SMAW) may be selected one diameter
up/down from the qualified condition.
b. The restriction for all changes to the “non-essential”
parameters is that the effect to the dilution of the base
material shall be minimal to the condition qualified.
c. For example, for the 111/SMAW process, the normal
recommended amperage and volt ranges shall be
implemented (not same amperage for lower electrode
diameter).
1. WPQR NDE Visual examination, Radiography + MPI (plus other, if used for
production)
2. Charpy Impacts, T Specification to be made by reference to design code,
> 5mm (0.2inch) DEP 30.10.02.31-Gen. and/or PED requirements. The
standard PED requirement is 27J minimum average (weld and
HAZ) at the minimum design temperature unless waived by the
appropriate harmonised design standard.
3. Charpy Impacts, T Specification to be made by reference to design code,
> 20mm (0.8inch) DEP 30.10.02.31-Gen. and/or PED requirements The standard
PED requirement is 27J minimum average (weld and HAZ) at
the minimum design temperature unless waived by the
appropriate harmonised design standard
4. Macro + Hardness Required as per EN ISO 15614. Photo-macrographs to be
Survey included with indicated magnification not less than 1X and
clearly showing all hardness indentations.
5. Maximum Hardness Refer to (4.5.3.2)
1. Carbon Equivalent Production CEq max = WPQR CEq +0.03, or 0.38 whichever is
higher.
Relaxation of this variable may be permitted based upon the
Contractor demonstrating QC controls which ensure the
application of suitable preheat for higher CE values and
implementation of appropriate production hardness testing,
approved by the Principal.
2. Thickness Limits As-welded thickness limit is defined in the selected design
(other) code
3. Bevel Angle Total included angle shall not be decreased by more than 10°
from WPQR
4. Electrode / Filler Rod Root electrode or filler wire size shall not be changed.
Size SMAW, Normal practice is one electrode diameter change is
allowed within the consumable manufacturer recommended
optimal parameters settings, max 4 mm (5/32 in) diameter use.
5. Preheat Decrease from that qualified is not permitted.
Deletion or addition is not permitted, except that maximum
50 C (122°F) is allowed for condensation mitigation
6. Interpass may be 50°C (90°F) above WPQR maximum
raised by
7. Interpass Limit 300°C (572°F) maximum
8. Heat Input or Arc Arc energy maximum recommended is 2.5 KJ/mm (63.5kJ/in)
Energy
9. Repair Welding Repair WPS to be issued. Separate WPQR not required
unless essential variables change.
1. Typical Materials ASTM A537, A352, A333 Gr6, A350 LF2, A420 Gr WPL6, API
5L X##, A694 F##
2. Approved Root GTAW (141)
Processes
3. Approved Fill and GTAW (141), SMAW (111), FCAW (136), SAW (121,125)
Cap Processes
4. Consumable SMAW electrodes : Shall be type EXX16 or EXX18
Restrictions
5. Consumable a. Generic applications:
Chemistry No additional restrictions to the standard.
b. Corrosive service:
For CO2 containing process service, root and second pass
limited to max 0.2% Ni, 0.6% Si, 0.5% Mo to avoid
preferential weld corrosion (see also section 9.6 in
information part of this DEP)
c. For HF service:
The limitation is Cr + Cu + Ni < 0.15% and 0.3% Mo
d. Typical matching type welding consumables are as follows:
Type Code Designation
Bare Wire AWS A5.18/A5.18M ER70S-3
ISO 636 W 42 5 W2Si
ISO 14341 G 42 2 M G2Si
Coated AWS A5.1 E7018-1 H4R
Electrode
E7016 H4R
ISO 2560-A E 46 4 B 32 H5
E 42 3 B 12 H5
6. Hydrogen Control <= 5ml/100g to EN ISO 3690
1. Carbon Equivalent Production CEq max = WPQR CEq +0.03, or 0.38 whichever is
higher.
Relaxation of this variable may be permitted based upon the
Contractor demonstrating QC controls which ensure the
application of suitable preheat for higher CE values and
implementation of appropriate production hardness testing,
approved by the Principal.
2. Material Supply Charpy impact and hardness acceptability for normalised,
Condition TMCR, Q&T materials shall be qualified or demonstrated in
accordance with low temperature qualification requirements
(4.5.3.3) and table 5.
3. Thickness For WPQRs with T < 5 mm (0.2 in), impact tests are not
required unless the WPS is to be used on material with
thickness greater than 5mm (0.2in)
4. Thickness Limits As-welded thickness limit is defined in the selected design
(other) code
5. Simple / Compound Change to/from compound bevel requires approval by the
Principal.
6. Bevel Angle Total included angle shall not be decreased by more than 10°
from WPQR
7. Process The welding process, combination of processes or order of
Combination welding processes shall not be changed unless approved by
the Principal.
8. Consumable The consumable brand name is an essential variable, though
the Principal may agree to changes for solid wires.
9. Electrode / Filler Rod Electrode or filler wire size shall not be changed at any stage
Size of welding
10. Polarity / Current Any change in polarity or current type requires requalification.
Type
11. Preheat Decrease from qualified preheat is not permitted.
12. Interpass may be 50°C (122°F) above WPQR maximum
raised by
13. Interpass Limit 250°C (482°F) maximum
14. Repair Welding Repair WPS to be issued. Separate WPQR not required
unless essential variables change.
A333 Gr 3, A350 LF3, A420 WPL3 -80 (-112) (3) 27 (20) 19 (14)
NOTES 1. The acceptance criteria for subsize specimens shall be reduced to:
7.5mm x 10mm (0.3 x 0.39in) 0.83 x full size values
5mm x 10mm (0.2 x 0.39in) 0.67 x full size values
2.5mm x 10mm (0.1 x 0.39in) 0.5 x full size values
2. The application of duplex stainless steels is limited to -50 °C (-58 °F) and 40 mm (1.5 in) maximum
thickness, unless a fracture mechanics assessment is carried out to justify lower temperatures or
greater thicknesses, and is approved by the Principal. (see DEP.30.10.02.31-Gen)
3. If the design temperature is lower than -80°C (-112F), the test temperature shall be the same as
the minimum design temperature.
4. The Principal may accept pre-qualified procedure that are tested at -46degrees C with the same
acceptance criteria depending on actual minimum design temperature.
4. Charpy V-notch specimens shall be prepared and tested in accordance with ISO 148-
1. For welds made with a maximum heat input of 2 kJ/mm (51 kJ/in), a set of three
Charpy impact specimens shall be taken with notches (1) at the weld centre line, (2) at
the fusion line, and (3) at the fusion line + 2 mm (0.08 in) as shown in Figure 3 below.
2mm
2mm
2mm
2mm
(6) C2 = Notch at 2mm from
fusion line (and C5 = at 5mm
for heat inputs over 2kJ/mm)
2 or 5mm
NOTE:
(1), (2) and (3) - All welds
(4) - Additional for ferritic steels with wall thicknesses over 20mm.
(4), (5) and (6) - Additional for duplex stainless steels with wall thickness over 20mm.
8. Full size (10 mm x 10 mm (0.39 in x 0.39 in)) impact test specimens shall be used
wherever possible. Where this is not possible, the larger of three quarter size (7.5 mm
x 10 mm (0.3 in x 0.39 in)) or half size (5 mm x 10 mm (0.2 in x 0.39 in)) specimens
shall be used. Reduced acceptance values for reduced size samples are given in
Table 5, Note 1.
9. Unless otherwise specified, no impact test result shall be less than the specified
minimum individual value and not more than one result shall be less than the minimum
average value specified.
a. If the above requirements cannot be met, three additional specimens shall be
tested.
b. The average of the six specimens shall be not less than the minimum
specified average.
c. Only two values may be below the specified minimum average value and only
one of those may be below the specified minimum individual value.
10. Fabrication of impact tested CMn piping and fittings, for process piping service (i.e.
ASTM A333 gr6, A350 LF2, etc.), shall be subject to PWHT based on the
requirements in the applicable design code and DEP 30.10.02.31-Gen.
11. If the governing thickness for PWHT is ‘B’ for weld/pipe thickness in accordance with
the applicable code, the weld thickness above which PHWT is required for branch
connections shall be determined as in Figure 4 below.
A A
PWHT if
t 4B
t 38mm
1. Typical Materials ASTM A333 Gr3, A350 LF3, A420 Gr WPL3, A765 Gr III, A352
LC3, A203 D
2. Approved Root GTAW (141)
Processes SMAW (111): Alternating current shall be used for root pass
welding, to avoid magnetic arc blow problems and consequent
lack of fusion.
3. Approved Fill & Cap GTAW (141), SMAW (111), SAW (121,125)
Processes
4. Consumable Matching : GTAW : ER80S-Ni2 / SMAW electrodes : Shall be
Restrictions 7016C2L, 7018C2L, 8016C2 or 8018C2
1. Typical Materials ASTM A 387 types 0.5 Mo, 1 Cr-0.5 Mo, 1.25 Cr- 0.5 Mo, 2.25
Cr-1 Mo steels,5Cr 1Mo, 9Cr 1Mo, P91 (9Cr, 1Mo-V), AISI
4130
2. Approved Root GTAW (141) and GMAW (1xx) for P3 to P9
Processes
3. Approved Fill & Cap GTAW (141), SMAW (111), SAW (121,125)
Processes
4. Hydrogen Control <= 5ml/100g to EN ISO 3690
1. WPQR NDE Visual examination, Radiography + MPI (plus other, if used for
production)
2. Charpy Impacts, Specification to be made by reference to design code, low
T > 5mm (0.2in) temperature DEP 30.10.02.31-Gen. and/or PED requirements
3. Charpy Impacts, Specification to be made by reference to design code, low
T > 20mm (0.8in) temperature DEP 30.10.02.31-Gen. and/or PED requirements
4. Macro + Hardness 1 Required per EN ISO 15614. Photo-macrographs to be
Survey included with indicated magnification not less than 1X and
clearly showing all hardness indentations
5. Maximum Refer (4.5.3.2).
Hardness
6. Backing gas A back purge with high purity Argon shall be required for
GTAW of 2.25 Cr steels and higher alloys unless otherwise
approved by the Principal.
7. Electrode / Filler Electrode or filler wire size shall not be changed at any stage
Rod Size of welding outside what was qualified in the WPQR.
8. Preheat A minimum preheat of 100 °C (212 °F) shall be used for
welding all thicknesses.
Decrease from that qualified is not permitted.
9. Interpass may be 25°C (45°F) above WPQR maximum
raised by
10. Interpass Limit 250°C (482°F) maximum
11. Repair Welding Repair WPS to be issued. Separate WPQR not required
unless essential variables change.
1. Typical Materials AISI 300 Series, Grades 304L, 304, 316L, 316, 321, 347
2. Approved Root GTAW (141)
Processes
3. Approved Fill & Cap GTAW (141), SMAW (111), GMAW (135), SAW (121,125)
Processes FCAW (136): This can be used for design temperatures up to
150°C (302°F).
4. Consumable Matching filler materials to be used.
Restrictions
1. WPQR NDE Visual examination, Radiography + DPI (plus other, if used for
production)
Acceptance criteria for oxidation of stainless steel weldments
DEP 30.10.60.31-Gen
2. Macro + Hardness Required per EN ISO 15614. Photo-macrographs to be
Survey included with indicated magnification not less than 1X and
clearly showing all hardness indentations.
3. Maximum Hardness Maximum hardness shall be 250 Hv10.
4. Micro Examination 5G or 6G: 2 off representing min and max heat input, 1 off for
other positions. Microstructure of weld and HAZ shall show
appropriate phase distribution and absence of micro-phases
considered deleterious to mechanical or corrosion properties.
Photomicrographs shall be provided of each region (typically
250X) with the WPQR.(ISO 9042, equivalent to ASTM E562)
5. Ferrite Test Ferrite number (FN) shall be 3-8FN in the root, cap and fill (i.e.
mid thickness) passes as per ISO 8249.Alternative acceptable
range may be specified for specific application, e.g. LNG flare
line.
1. Bevel Angle Total included angle shall not be decreased by more than 10°
from WPQR
2. Process The welding process, combination of processes or order of
Combination welding processes shall not be changed, unless otherwise
approved by the Principal.
3. Electrode / Filler Rod Electrode or filler wire size shall not be changed at any stage
Size of welding outside of what was qualified in WPQR
4. Polarity / Current Any change in polarity or current type (including pulse
Type characteristics) requires requalification.
5. Interpass may be 25°C (45°F) above WPQR maximum
raised by
6. Interpass Limit 175°C (347°F) maximum
7. Repair Welding Repair WPS to be issued. Separate WPQR not required
unless essential variables change.
1. Typical Materials UNS S31254, UNS N08367, UNS N08925, UNS N08926
2. Approved Root GTAW (141)
Processes
3. Approved Fill & Cap GTAW (141), SMAW (111), FCAW (136), SAW (121,125)
Processes
4. Consumable Type ERNiCrMo-3
Restrictions
5. Consumable Principal alloying additions should not be made through flux
Chemistry additions.
6. Autogenous Welding Not permitted
1. Typical Materials UNS S31803, UNS32205 (22% Cr) and UNS S32550, UNS
S32750, UNS S32760 (25% Cr), excluding UNS32304
2. Approved Root GTAW (141)
Processes
3. Approved Fill & Cap GTAW (141), SMAW (111), FCAW (136), SAW (121,125)
Processes
4. Consumable Root and 2nd pass of 22% duplex shall be made with 25%
Restrictions duplex consumable unless nitrogen containing shield gas and
purge are used.
5. Consumable Shall overmatch nickel content (typically 2209 type for 22%
Chemistry duplex and 2509 type for 25% duplex). Principal alloying
additions should not be made through flux additions.
6. Hydrogen Control <= 5ml/100g to EN ISO 3690
7. Autogenous Welding Not permitted
8. Back purging Inert back purge of the internal surface shall be maintained
rd
until completion of the 3 pass of the groove weld.
9. Material certification Both base metal and consumable material certification for
qualification shall be in accordance with ISO 10474 – 3.2
certificate.
1. WPQR NDE Visual examination, Radiography + DPI (plus other, if used for
production)
Acceptance criteria for oxidation of stainless steel weldments
DEP 30.10.60.31-Gen
2. Charpy Impacts, T > a. Root : Weld, Fusion Line, FL+2 mm (and FL+5 mm (0.2 in)
5mm when heat input > 1.75 kJ/mm(44 kJ/in))
b. Criteria for duplex include lateral expansion >0.38 mm. See
also Table 5.
3. Charpy Impacts, T > Root & Cap : Weld, Fusion Line, FL+2mm (and FL+5mm when
20mm heat input > 1.75kJ/mm (44kJ/in))
4. Macro + Hardness 5G or 6G : 3 off - 3 or 9 o’c, 6 o'c, 12 o'c positions. Other
Survey positions 1 off. Photomacrographs to be included with
indicated magnification not less than actual size and clearly
showing all hardness indentations.
5. Maximum Hardness The maximum hardness for quality control purpose shall target
334 Hv10 for 22%Cr DSS and for 25Cr DSS shall target
378 Hv10
6. Root Chemical All principal alloying additions : minimum C, Si, Mn, P, S, Cr,
Analysis Ni, Mo, Cu, Al, (W) and N and calculated PREn
7. Corrosion Test a. In an as welded condition by ASTM G48 Method A, the test
temperature 22°C for 22% duplex and 35°C for 25% duplex
for 24 hours.
b. The acceptance criteria shall be a weight loss < 4 g/m² and
no initiation of localised corrosion > 0.025mm at the test
face. Note that only corrosion (e.g., pitting) at the test face
counts.
c. If the weight loss is > 4 g/m² and it can be positively
identified that this is only due to corrosion at the cut faces,
the test shall be invalid. In this case re-testing shall be
carried out on replacement specimens.
d. If pickled and passivated, testing by ASTM G48 Method A
shall be done at a test temperature of 25°C for 22% duplex
and 40°C for 25% duplex for 24 hours with the same
acceptance criteria as above.
8. Micro Examination a. 5G or 6G : 2 off representing min and max heat input, 1 off
for other positions.
b. Microstructure of weld and HAZ shall show appropriate
phase distribution and absence of micro-phases considered
deleterious to mechanical or corrosion properties.
c. Photomicrographs shall be provided of each region
(typically 250X and 500X) with the WPQR.
10. Ferrite Test Shall be 40-60% in parent and 30-70% in weld/HAZ according
to method in (Appendix B). Measurements to be made 1mm
from root and cap in weld, HAZ, and parent metal.
14. Heat Input Limits a. The arc energy and interpass temperature shall be
controlled to ensure an optimum cooling rate of the weld
with respect to the thickness. Typical arc energies are in the
range 0.5 to 1.75 kJ/mm.
b. The second pass is normally deposited at lower arc energy
than that of the root pass.
15. Repair Welding Separate procedure to be qualified
1. Typical Materials UNS N08825 (Alloy 825), UNS N06625 (Alloy 625), UNS
N04400 (Alloy 400), UNS N06600 (Alloy 600), UNS N0x925
(Alloy 925), UNS N0x718 (alloy 718), UNS N10276 (Alloy
C276)
2. Approved Root GTAW (141)
Processes
3. Approved Fill & Cap GTAW (141), SMAW (111), SAW (121,125)
Processes
4. Consumable a. The welding consumables shall be from equivalent
Restrictions chemical composition as specified by the materials
producer. The specific designation can be according ISO
14172, AWS 5.11 or EN 1600 for covered electrodes.
b. For wire the specific designation can be according ISO
18274 or AWS 5.14
c. For selection of non-matching welding consumable
approval from the Principal is required.
5. Consumable Principal alloying additions should not be made through flux
Chemistry additions.
1. Typical Materials a. Cu/Ni alloys in the range of 90/10 and 70/30 materials
composition
Al-Brass alloys
Al-Bronze alloys
unalloyed copper
b. With reference to metallic materials DEP 30.10.02.11-Gen.
2. Approved Root GTAW (141)
Processes
3. Approved Fill & Cap GTAW (141), SMAW (111), SAW (121)
Processes
4. Consumable a. The welding consumables shall be from equivalent
Restrictions chemical composition as specified by the materials
producer.
b. The specific designation can be according ISO 14172, AWS
5.11 or EN 1600 for covered electrodes. For wire the
specific designation can be according ISO 18274 or AWS
5.14
c. For selection of non-matching welding consumable
approval from the Principal is required.
5. Materials condition For the welding of copper materials it is evident to report the
materials supply condition (hardness/strength/deformation
grade/heat treatment, aging).
The weldability is very dependent on the actual material
condition.
1. WPQR NDE Visual examination, Radiography + DPI (plus other, if used for
production)
2. Macro + Hardness Required as per ISO 15614. Photo-macrographs to be
Survey included with indicated magnification not less than 1X and
clearly showing all hardness indentations.
3. Maximum Hardness a. The maximum hardness is determined by the ordering
specifications. Normally the annealed condition hardness
requirement is also applicable for the weld area.
b. Specific service conditions in relation to ammonia and
mercury exposure require individual specifications by the
principal
1. Joint Type Multi-pass fillets may be qualified by butt weld fill and cap
parameters.
2. Bevel Angle Total included angle shall not be decreased by more than 10°
from WPQR
3. Process The welding process, combination of processes or order of
Combination welding processes shall not be changed unless approved by
the Principal.
4. Electrode / Filler Rod Electrode or filler wire size shall not be changed at any stage
Size of welding
5. Polarity / Current Any change in polarity or current type (including pulse
Type characteristics) requires requalification.
6. Interpass may be 25°C (45°F) above WPQR maximum
raised by
7. Interpass Limit 175°C (347°F) maximum
8. Repair Welding a. For new fabrication:
Repair WPS to be issued. Separate WPQR not required
unless essential variables change.
b. Repair/maintenance:
The WPS/WPQR shall be reviewed in relation to the
process contaminations for additional requirements in shop
and field repairs on process exposed components .
10.14 TITANIUM
10.14.1 General requirements
1. WPQR NDE Visual examination, Radiography + DPI (plus other, if used for
production).
2. Macro + Hardness 5G or 6G: 3 off - 3 or 9 o’c, 6 o'c, 12 o'c positions. Other
Survey positions 1 off. Photo-macrographs to be included with indicated
magnification not less than 1X and clearly showing all hardness
indentations.
3. Maximum Hardness a. Annealed condition is specified for base materials
(140 HV10 for plates).
b. ISO 15156-3 is indicating 100 HRB for sour service and
DEP 30.10.02.17-Gen. is indicating max 80°C for
application.
c. The maximum hardness for the weldment is base material
hardness + 50 HV10 or 200HV5, whichever is lower.
6. Bevel Angle Total included angle shall not be changed by more than
+10°/-5° from WPQR.
7. Process The welding process, combination of processes or order of
Combination welding processes shall not be changed unless approved by the
Principal.
8. Consumable The consumable brand name is an essential variable, though
the Principal may agree to changes for solid wires.
9. Electrode / Filler Electrode or filler wire size shall not be changed at any stage of
Rod Size welding.
10. Polarity / Current Any change in polarity or current type (including pulse
Type characteristics) requires requalification.
11. Interpass may be 0°C (0°F) above WPQR maximum.
raised by
12. Interpass Limit 175°C (347°F) maximum.
13. Repair Welding Repair WPS to be issued. Separate WPQR not required unless
essential variables change.
2. A list/record of dissimilar welds shall be kept from the beginning of the project and
updated as the project progresses.
3. Suitability of a dissimilar weld design shall be decided after considering the service,
weldment and the weld design together. Their use shall be limited to applications
where other solutions are either deemed not practical or to involve excessive cost.
4. If welding materials with different hardenability, preheat and PWHT procedures shall
achieve sufficient tempering of the more hardenable material while preventing
excessive weakening or loss of toughness of the softer material.
a. Results of welding procedure qualification tests shall demonstrate
implementation of the above requirements.
b. Hardness tests and results meeting requirements of this DEP or NACE
RP0472 are mandatory for all dissimilar weld WPQRs.
10.15.2 Groups of dissimilar joints
1. There are two groups of dissimilar joints, equal physical properties joints and different
physical properties joints:
2. Group 1 – Equal physical properties joints
a. Joints between ferritic materials (carbon, Mo and Cr-Mo steels) – Dissimilar
joints between ferritic low-alloy and carbon steel shall be made by using filler
material with a chemical composition matching the lower-grade material.
b. Joints between austenitic materials (AISI 304, 321, 317, 347).
c. Joints between high-nickel alloys (Monel, Alloy 700, Hastelloys B and C, or
equivalents).
3. Group 2 – Different physical properties joints
a. Joints between ferritic and austenitic materials – This group of joints shall be
made by using a buffer filler material
The selection of weld metal largely depends on the service conditions, such
as temperature, thermal cycling, and possible galvanic corrosion.
10.15.3 Metal combinations of dissimilar joints
10.15.3.1 Welding carbon manganese or 0.5 Mo steels to Cr-Mo steels
1. The following shall be followed for PWHT of welds of carbon manganese or 0.5 Mo
steels to Cr-Mo steels:
a. An intermediate temperature shall be chosen between the PWHT temperature
ranges of the two materials, but lower than the tempering temperature of the
lowest grade.
b. The holding time specified for the higher grade shall be increased by 1.5
times. However, if the PWHT temperature so selected will not result in the
individual base materials and weld metal achieving the specified mechanical
properties, then a buffering technique shall be applied on the higher grade
side as shown in the sketch below:
c. After buffering, PWHT shall be applied at the temperature suitable for the
buffered base material (2.25Cr-1Mo). After this PWHT, the joint shall be
completed and PWHT shall then be carried out at the temperature suitable for
the lower grade base material (C-Mn steel)
For dissimilar welds in steel operating in the creep range (e.g. 9Cr-1Mo or 9Cr-1Mo
modified to 2.25Cr-1Mo steels) carbon depletion in the low Cr base material or weld can
occur (carbon diffusion out of low chromium material into the neighbouring high
chromium steel) and will adversely affect the creep life.
10.15.3.2 Welding C steel to Ni or Cu alloys
1. The following consumables shall be used for welds of C steel to Ni or Cu alloys:
a. C-Mn steel shall be welded to Ni alloys with AWS A5.11 ENiCrFe-2, Alloy 182
or Alloy 82 consumables.
b. C steels shall be welded to Ni or Cu alloys with Monel 187/190 (ENiCu7).
c. C steels shall be welded to Ni-Cr-Fe alloys with AWS A5.11 ENiCrFe-2.
d. C steel shall be welded to aluminium bronze with special buffer-type
electrodes of Cu-8Al or Cu-10Al-1Fe.
10.15.3.3 Welding ferritic steel to austenitic steel
1. For hydrogen service, welds shall not be made between ferritic steel and austenitic
steel, unless approved by the Principal.
Welds between austenitic steel and ferritic steel are potentially sensitive to
cracking. The sensitive area is the local hard zone in the immediate vicinity of the
fusion line in the weld metal.
2. Welding of ferritic steel to austenitic steel in hydrogen service is restricted to a
maximum operating temperature of 350°C (660°F). This restriction does not apply for
short-term temperature excursions above 350°C (660°F) (e.g. hot hydrogen stripping)
because there is an incubation period necessary before hot hydrogen attack occurs.
The risk of cracking increases with temperature for reasons of thermal fatigue
(start-up/shut-down) particularly in the case of AISI 309 type of welds.
3. Limitations for sour and hot hydrogen service dissimilar welding shall be avoided for
application in wet H2S/sour service or other services where acid corrosion can occur or
in services over 450°C (842°F) in presence of hydrogen. If dissimilar welds have to be
used in such services the Principal’s Materials Specialist shall be consulted.
4. Care shall also be taken to avoid hot cracking in the weld metal. The weld preparation
shall be cleaned carefully and every weld bead deposited shall be ground smooth prior
to the next weld bead.
5. Chemical cleaning or pickling shall not be applied.
6. During weld procedure qualification, a micro-hardness survey on an etched sample
shall be done on the fusion line between the buffer layer and base material. The hard
zone on the interface may contain individual hard spots provided there is not a
continuous network (sequence) of hard spots.
7. Where PWHT is required for the ferritic material, in particular for wall thickness above
25 mm (1 in), the ferritic weld bevel shall be buttered with a buffer type consumable
followed by PWHT. After PWHT the buffer layer is then welded with matching to the
austenitic material – See sketch below:
8. For wall thicknesses below 25 mm (1 in) a stainless steel pup piece/ring shall be
welded to the ferritic material with a buffer consumable followed by separate PWHT,
as buttering buffer layer onto "thin" materials is cumbersome. After PWHT the
stainless steel safe end is welded matching to the austenitic steel.
10.15.3.4 Welding austenitic stainless steel to Ni-Cr-Fe alloys
1. For high temperature applications, AWS A5.11 ENiCrFe-2 or Alloy 82 filler metal shall
be used.
2. For low temperature applications, Alloy 112/625 or AWS A5.11 ENiCrFe-2 filler metal
shall be used.
10.15.3.5 Welding other metal combinations
1. Welds for other metal combinations shall be designed with the input and approval of
Principal.
2. Design concepts used for the above combinations can be utilised on welds for other
metal combinations where applicable.
3. For design temperatures over 454°C (850°F), welds amongst different grades of
austenitic stainless steel shall be considered to be “other metal combinations”.
10.15.4 Nondestructive examination considerations
The weak link of dissimilar welds is the fusion boundary between a base metal and weld
made from the different material.
1. NDE coverage of dissimilar welds shall reflect their design and criticality. NDE
coverage shall be developed/assigned by the Project Material Specialist.
2. Dissimilar welds may require NDE coverage different from that required by the piping
class or standard project NDE schedules.
3. Dissimilar welds shall be designed to allow volumetric examination and shall be
examined by at least one such suitable method.
4. Critical dissimilar welds and pressure retaining welds not suitable for volumetric
examination and their NDE shall be approved by the Principal’s designated Technical
Authority.
10.15.5 Dissimilar weld register
1. All dissimilar welds shall be recorded in a dissimilar weld register prepared by the
Fabricator and included in the welding plan/map. As a minimum, the register shall
contain the following information:
a. Weld identifier;
b. Relevant drawing identifier (P&ID/MEFD/isometric or equipment fabrication
drawings);
c. P numbers of the alloys to be welded and brief description of the weld;
d. Criticality rating of the weld (as per Project criticality-rating procedures -
pressure-retaining welds should be considered critical);
e. Applicable welding procedure identifier (includes the name of the organisation,
which welded such weld.);
11. REFERENCES
In this DEP, reference is made to the following publications:
NOTES: 1. Unless specifically designated by date, the latest edition of each publication shall be used,
together with any amendments/supplements/revisions thereto.
2. The DEPs and most referenced external standards are available to Shell staff on the SWW (Shell
Wide Web) at http://sww.shell.com/standards/.
SHELL STANDARDS
DEP feedback form DEP 00.00.05.80-Gen.
Metallic materials – Selected standards DEP 30.10.02.11-Gen.
Materials for use in H2S-containing environments in oil and gas DEP 30.10.02.15-Gen.
production (amendments and supplements to ISO 15156:2009)
Wet H2S requirements for downstream pressure vessels and piping DEP 30.10.02.17-Gen.
Metallic materials – Prevention of brittle fracture in new assets DEP 30.10.02.31-Gen.
Materials and fabrication requirements for 2¼Cr-1Mo, 2¼Cr-1Mo- DEP 30.10.02.32-Gen.
¼V, 3Cr-1Mo & 3Cr-1Mo-¼V heavy wall pressure vessels
Welding of metals (amendments/supplements to API RP 582) DEP 30.10.60.18-Gen.
Oxidation of stainless steel weldments DEP 30.10.60.31-Gen.
Unfired pressure vessels DEP 31.22.00.31-Gen.
Shop and field fabrication of piping DEP 31.38.01.31-Gen.
Project quality assurance DEP 82.00.10.10-Gen.
Shell HSSE & SP Control Framework, Design Engineering Manual DEM1
(DEM) 1 – Application of Technical Standards
http://sww.manuals.shell.com/HSSE/
AMERICAN STANDARDS
Safety in Welding, Cutting and Allied Processes ANSI Z49.1
Qualification Standard for Welding and Brazing Procedures, ASME/BPVC Sec IX
Welders, Brazers, and Welding and Brazing Operators Welding
and Brazing Qualifications
Petroleum and Natural Gas Industries — Materials for Use in H2S- NACE MR0175
Containing Environments in Oil and Gas Production
Standard Recommended Practice – Methods and Controls to NACE RP0472
Prevent In-Service Environmental Cracking of Carbon Steel
Weldments in Corrosive Petroleum Refining Environments
EUROPEAN STANDARDS
Non-destructive testing – Qualification and certification of NDE EN 473
personnel – General principles
Metallic products – Types of inspection documents EN 10204
Brazing – Destructive tests of brazed joints EN 12797
Brazing – Non-destructive examination of brazed joints EN 12799
Brazing – Procedure approval EN 13134
Unfired pressure vessels EN 13445
INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS
European pressure equipment directive (PED) 97/23 Directive 97/23
Arc welding equipment IEC 60974-x
Expression of the properties of sampling oscilloscopes IEC 60548-2
Metallic materials – Charpy pendulum impact test – Part 1: Test ISO 148
method
Welding consumables – Rods, wires and deposits for tungsten inert ISO 636
gas welding of non-alloy and fine-grain steels – Classification
Welding consumables – Covered electrodes for manual metal arc ISO 2560
welding of non-alloy and fine grain steels – Classification
Welding and allied processes – Determination of hydrogen content ISO 3690
in ferritic steel arc weld metal
Quality requirements for fusion welding of metallic materials ISO 3834-x
Information Processing – Magnetic tape cassette and cartridge ISO 4341
labelling and file structure for information interchange first edition
Gas welding equipment – Blowpipes for gas welding, heating and ISO 5172
cutting
Welding. fusion-welded joints in steel, nickel, titanium and their ISO 5817
alloys (beam welding excluded) – Quality levels for imperfections
Metallic materials – Vickers hardness test ISO 6507
Welding and allied processes – Classification of geometric ISO 6520-1
imperfections in metallic materials – Part 1: Fusion welding
Welding – Determination of Ferrite Number (FN) in austenitic and ISO 8249
duplex ferritic-austenitic Cr-Ni stainless steel weld metals
Quality management systems – Fundamentals and vocabulary ISO 9000
Quality management systems — Requirements ISO 9001
Steels – Manual point counting method for statistically ISO 9042
estimating the volume fraction of a constituent with a point grid
Approval testing of welders – Fusion welding ISO 9606-x
Non-Destructive Testing – Qualification and Certification of ISO 9712
Personnel
Steel and steel products – Inspection documents ISO 10474
Protective clothing for use in welding and allied processes ISO 11611
Brazing – Qualification test of brazers and brazing operators ISO 13585
Gas welding equipment – Acetylene manifold systems for welding, ISO 14114
cutting and allied processes – General requirements
Welding consumables – Solid wire electrodes, tubular cored ISO 14171
electrodes and electrode/flux combinations for submerged arc
welding of non-alloy and fine grain steels – Classification
Welding consumables – Covered electrodes for manual metal arc ISO 14172
welding of nickel and nickel alloys – Classification
Welding consumables — Wire electrodes and weld deposits for gas ISO 14341
shielded metal arc welding of non-alloy and fine grain steels —
Classification
B.1 SCOPE
This appendix describes a recommended practice for estimating the volume fraction of
delta ferrite in duplex stainless steel by systematic point counts on transverse
metallographic sections.
B.3 TERMINOLOGY
Point count Number of grid points which lie within areas of a specific phase (in
this case delta ferrite).
Point fraction (Pp) Point count divided by the total number of points in the test grid.
Volume fraction (Vv) Volume of a specific phase per unit volume, expressed as a fraction.
B.6 APPARATUS
B.6.1 Microscope
1. An optical light microscope that projects an image of the magnified micro-structure
onto a viewing screen shall be used. Preferably the microscope should have
graduated x and y translation controls.
2. The magnification shall be selected such that the ferrite particles have an average
dimension approximately one half of the grid point spacing. This should be judged
visually in more than one field of view, before measurements are made. For many
weldment microstructures, particularly in re-heated areas, a magnification in the range
x500 - x1000 is suitable, and is preferred.
B.6.2 Test grid
1. A test grid shall be marked on a transparent sheet that shall be superimposed on the
magnified image of the microstructure.
2. The grid shall consist of a square array of equally spaced points, produced by the
intersection of fine parallel lines (maximum width 0.3 mm (12 mils)), and shall have 16
or 25 points.
3. It is recommended that the spacing of the points should be 10 mm (3/8 in) along both
directions parallel to the edges of the grid, e.g. as in Figure B.1. At a magnification of
1000x this corresponds to a point spacing on the actual microstructure of 10 μm
(0.4 mils).
Figure B.1 Two grid types suitable for systematic manual point counting of delta ferrite in
duplex stainless steel
B.7 PROCEDURE
B.7.1 Counting of points
1. Superimpose the test grid on the magnified image of the microstructure in the chosen
area of the parent material or weldment.
2. Count the number of points that lie within the delta ferrite phase; any points that cannot
be assigned positively to either phase shall be counted as one half.
Delta ferrite is the phase that is stained dark by the etch, although its colour may
vary significantly throughout the weldment. The austenite phase remains light
coloured in all areas after etching.
3. Move the specimen by a small amount in x and/or y so that another field is chosen.
4. Perform a second point count in the new field, provided that this field of view still falls
within the specified region of the parent material or weldment. If the field of view falls
outside the area of interest, move the specimen back, without rotating, to an
appropriate position within the specified area.
5. Where possible, move the specimen without looking at the micro-structure in order to
avoid bias in the choice of fields. It is recommended that the use of overlapping fields
be avoided.
6. Continue this process until a minimum of 400 points have been counted.
B.7.2 Heat affected zone considerations
1. When measurements are being made within the coarse grained HAZ, the operator
shall first assess whether the test grid can be superimposed over an area that is
entirely within the coarse grained HAZ.
a. The above can be done simply by attempting to fit the grid within a single
coarse grain. If the grid size is less than the grain size, then the procedure in
B.7.1 shall be used.
b. If the whole grid is too large, a smaller area of the grid shall be used, by
ignoring one or more whole rows of grid points.
c. The area chosen may be either square or rectangular. If a rectangular grid is
used, the specimen shall be rotated so that the long axis of the rectangle is
kept parallel to the fusion boundary.
2. Measurements in the coarse grained HAZ shall be made within approximately two
grain diameters of the fusion line.
B.7.3 Estimating volume fraction of ferrite
1. The volume fraction of delta ferrite shall be estimated by taking an average of the point
fractions counted in each of the n fields as follows:
where
3. The accuracy of the estimate shall comply with the allowable errors specified in
Table B.1.
Volume % Error
45-50 ± 10%
40-45 ± 11%
35-40 ± 12%
0-35 ± 14%
B.8 REPORTING
1. The following shall be included in the ferrite determination report.
a. The number of sections taken from the weld.
b. The locations of sections taken along the weld.
c. The polishing procedure and etching conditions.
d. The magnification used.
e. The number of points and shape of the grid.
f. Whether the fields were chosen randomly or at regular intervals. If regular
intervals were employed, report the spacings used.
g. The location of the areas in which measurements were made, preferably on
sketch or photograph and in words, specifying parent metal or the weld pass,
the region of the weld pass (i.e. weld metal or HAZ) and, where practical,
whether the area was re-heated or not. Any uncertainty should be indicated.
h. A list of the point fractions of delta ferrite in each field.
i. An estimate of the volume fraction of delta ferrite, calculated as the average of
the point fractions.
j. The calculated value of the 95% CI.
k. Stage of manufacture, i.e. procedure qualification, production test, etc.
l. Location of sample and cast number.
m. Statement of conformance with specified ferrite content.
n. Signature of operator responsible for ferrite determination.
B.10 SAFETY
This recommended practice involves materials, equipment and procedures that may
represent a health hazard. This document does not attempt to address the safety issues
associated with the described practice. It is the responsibility of the testing
establishment to ensure that the appropriate health and safety precautions are taken.
B.11 REFERENCES
1. ASTM E3-80 (Reapproved 1986) ‘Methods of Preparation of Metallographic
Specimens’.
2. Gladman T and Woodhead JH: ‘The Accuracy of Point Counting in Metallographic
Investigations’, JISI 1960, 194, 189-193.
C.1 GENERAL
1. The ITP should begin with a list of applicable Shell DEPs, National and International
Standards/Specifications, and Fabricator procedures/method statements, plus any
relevant subcontractor procedures/method statements if their activities are included
instead of appearing on a separate ITP.
C.2 DEFINITIONS
1. The following definitions shall apply as specified in DEP 82.00.10.10-Gen:
a. Hold Point (H): A critical step in fabrication and testing where it is mandatory
that the Principal inspect the component/equipment or witness an activity.
i. Activities designated as a Hold Point shall not proceed unless the
Principal/Representative is present or the Hold Point is formally waived.
ii. The Principal shall be notified at a duration specified in the contract in
advance of the activity.
b. Witness Point (W): A critical step in fabrication and testing where it is desirable
that the Principal/Representative inspect the component/equipment or witness
an activity.
i. The Principal shall be notified at a duration specified in the contract in
advance of the activity.
ii. Once proper notification is given, the activity may proceed according to
the schedule regardless of the Principal’s attendance.
c. Monitor Point (M): A critical step in fabrication and testing where it is optional
that the Principal inspect the component/equipment or witness an activity.
i. The Principal shall be notified at a duration specified in the contract in
advance of the first occurrence of the activity at each worksite. No
further notification for like activities at each worksite shall be required.
ii. The activity may proceed with or without the Principal’s attendance.
d. Approval Point (A): A critical step in design, procurement, and or fabrication
and testing where it is mandatory that the Principal approve a
document/qualification/equipment/or activity.
i. The Principal shall be notified at a duration specified in the contract in
advance of the first occurrence of the activity or provided the document
in a period of time specified by the contract.
ii. The activity may not proceed without the Principal’s approval.
e. Review Point (R): A critical step in design, procurement, and or fabrication and
testing where it is desirable that the Principal review the
document/qualification/equipment/or activity.
i. The Principal shall be notified at a duration specified in the contract in
advance of the first occurrence of the activity or provided the document
in a period of time specified by the contract.
ii. The activity may proceed with or without the Principal comments or
review.
2. The above definitions are specific to the Principal column. For use in other columns,
replace the word Principal with the named party.
3. The ‘Inspect/Test’ intervention may be used to describe any other activities such as
raising documentation, performing the work (e.g. welding), and should be the
Fabricator column default when none of the other interventions are applicable.
4. The ‘Monitor’, ‘Witness’, and ‘Hold’ interventions are carried out at the Fabricator’s (or
their subcontractor’s) site.
5. The ‘Document Review’ intervention may be carried out at site or will be requested to
be sent to the project document control centre (DCC)
6. The ‘Document Approval’ intervention requires formal submission of the document
through the agreed project DCC.
7. The items enclosed in <> symbols in the ‘Controlling Procedure/Method Statement’
column are intended to be substituted by the Fabricator’s controlling document number
/ reference.
Print Name
Date