Team’s Knowledge of Science & Technology (50%)

Score 5 4 3 2 1
Shows
Shows a full Shows a good Does not understand
understanding of
understanding of the understanding of the the scientific
parts of the
Technical scientific principles scientific principles principles underlying
scientific principles
Knowledge underlying the underlying the the inventions very No evidence
underlying the
(20%) inventions and their inventions and their well and their depth
inventions and their
depth of knowledge depth of knowledge of knowledge in the
depth of knowledge
in the field in the field field is very shallow
in the field
Prototype is Prototype is working
working fine with 1 fine but needs
Prototype Prototype is working Prototype is working
or 2 plenty of
functionality excellently well until exceptionally well No evidence
troubleshooting troubleshooting
(15%) session ends. during the time given.
during the during the
demonstration. demonstration.
The complexity of The complexity of The complexity of
The complexity of the
Prototype the functions and the functions and the functions and
functions and coding
Complexity coding of the coding of the coding of the No evidence
of the prototype is at
(15%) prototype is at prototype is at prototype is very
advance level.
expert level. intermediate level. basic.

Internal
 Appearance/Presentation of Model or Proof of Concept (30%)

Score 5 4 3 2 1
The whole project,
The whole project
Quality of including the The whole project The whole was
was successfully
workmanship & supporting props are including the developed without
produce but there No evidence
durability excellently produced supporting props are putting much thought
are areas that could
(8%) even up until the fine well produce. on it.
be well-organized.
detail.
The
product/service
The product/service The product/service The product/service
Significant of The product/service does not meet
meets the needs of meets the needs of almost meet the need
prototype & How it meets the needs of the the need of the
the intended user and the intended user of the intended user
address the problem intended user and is intended user and
is very beneficial to but is only slightly and not beneficial to
(8%) beneficial to them. not beneficial to
them. beneficial to them. them.
them.

Presentation (model) Presentation (model)

Presentation (model) Presentation (model)
Aesthetic appeal was very visually was exceptionally
was visually attractive was attractive in
(creative design attractive in terms of visually attractive in
in terms of color use, terms of color use, No evidence
features) color use, lighting, terms of color use,
lighting, sound effect lighting, sound effect
(3%) sound effect, neatness lighting, sound effect
and neatness (etc.) and neatness (etc.)
(etc.) and neatness (etc.)
Prototype shows a
Prototype shows Prototype shows
Prototype shows a Prototype shows a slightly positive
Commercialization slightly impact to negative impact
very positive impact to positive impact to impact to
value & Cost environment and to environment
environment and user, environment and user, environment and
efficiency user, plus high long- and user, plus
plus low long-term plus low long-term user, plus high long-
(7%) term maintenance high long-term
maintenance cost maintenance cost term maintenance
cost maintenance cost
cost
Safety issue There are no safety 1 or 2 safety issues > 5 safety issues
3 safety issues found. 4 safety issues found.
(4%) issues found. found. were presence

Internal
 Team’s Style & Delivery (20%)

Score 5 4 3 2 1
Consistently
Body Posture stands up straight Stands up straight Stands up Slouches and/or No
(2%) with confidence with confidence straight looks intimidated evidence
and looks relaxed
Displays effort
Language Consistent use of Use of proper No
to use proper Unclear language
(3%) proper language language evidence
language
Consistently
speaks clearly and Consistently
Speaks clearly Often mumbles
distinctly all the speaks clearly and
Speaking and distinctly in causing
time in a very distinctly in a very No
Consistency an organized misunderstandings
organized manner organized manner evidence
(3%) manner most of or mispronounces
with all words where audience
the time several words
properly easily understands
pronounced
Able to delegate
Able to delegate
works efficiently, Able to delegate
work and have a
communicate works and
Team Work good
effectively among communicate well Able to delegate work No evidence
(3%) communication
team members among team
among tem
especially during members
members
critical time

Internal