opportunity. The optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty” CHAPTER TWO REVIEW OF LITERATURE
A literature review is the process of
locating, obtaining, reading and evaluating the research literature in your area of interest. Literature review Literature review covers two areas:
(1) the writings of recognized experts, and
(2) previous research
both of which have a significant bearing on
or relation to the problem under study The purpose of literature review 1. A critical review of the literature is necessary to help a researcher develop a thorough understanding of and insight into previous research that relates to his/her research question(s) and objectives. 2. To help the researcher further refine the research question(s) and objectives. The purpose of literature review 3. Literature review will set your research in context by critically discussing and referencing work that has already been undertaken, drawing out key points and presenting them in a logically argued way, and highlighting those areas where they will provide fresh insights. 4. To highlight research possibilities that have been overlooked
5. To discover explicit recommendations for
further research. These can provide you with a justification for your own research questions
6. To avoid repeating work that has been
done already. 6. To discover and provide an insight into research designs that may be appropriate to the current research questions and objectives. 7. It can help you interpret and make sense of your findings, and help you tie your results to the work of those who have preceded you. • Simply put, the more you know about investigations and perspectives related to your topic, the more effectively you can tackle your own research problem Literature Sources Literature sources are generally divided into three categories:
1. Primary sources (published & unpublished)
2. Secondary sources 3. Tertiary sources Primary sources • The original reports of the original work or experience .
– Examples include published sources such as
reports (academic report, government report, market research report, etc). They also include unpublished manuscript sources such as letters, memos, interview, committee minutes, etc. – Primary sources are the most authoritative because the information has not been filtered or interpreted by a second party. Secondary Sources
• Are interpretations of primary data.
• Text books, journals, magazines, etc are the
subsequent publication of primary data.
• Secondary sources provide scholarly
summaries of research
– These publications are aimed at a wider
audience. They are easier to locate than primary literature . Tertiary sources • Also called search tools, are designed either to help locate primary and secondary literature or to provide an introduction to a topic.
• Examples include internet search
engines, abstracts, bibliographies, catalogues, encyclopedia, etc. BE CAUTIOUS USING INTERNET SOURCES!!!
• Currently, the Internet is unregulated
(unlike Secondary and Primary sources)
• The Internet is good for fun and ideas:
– But be cautious!! Literature sources available Using Journals Rather Than Magazines Journals and magazines are both periodicals.
– Periodicals are publications issued on a regular basis.
– Journals are periodicals containing articles often written
by scholars/professionals
– Journals may be classified as
• refereed academic journals or • professional journals. • Refereed academic journals are evaluated by peers before publication to assess their quality.
– They normally contain detailed research
reports, book reviews, issues in methodologies, etc.
– Examples include journal of magt. studies,
journal of accountancy, journal of business strategy, journal of magt., etc. • Professional journals are produced for their members by organizations such as the Institute of Chartered Accountants, the American Institute of Marketing, Chartered Institute of Bankers, etc.
– The professional journals contain a mix of
new-related items and more detailed articles.
– Articles are often of a more practical nature
and more closely related to professional needs. Journals Vs Magazines Journals Magazines 1. Written by a scholar 1. Written by variety of in the field. authors. 2. Scientific research. 2. Mostly opinion-based 3. Uses language of 3. Elementary language the discipline. geared towards audience with minimal 4. Written to appeal to education. specific audience. 4. For wider audience. Journals Magazines 5. Authors write for academic 5. Not so. honor.
6. Contains longer articles (7+ 6. Shorter articles – ½ page to 5
pages). pages.
7. Carefully reviewed by peers 7. Articles chosen by
before publication. editors/authors employed by the magazine. 8. Mostly found in the 8. Found everywhere. libraries/academic settings. 9. Contain graphs/charts. 9. Contain lots of graphics and coloured pictures. 10. Reference citations provided 10. Sources are rarely cited. Guidelines on Literature Review: 1. When planning your literature search you need to . . . – have clearly defined research question(s) and objectives; – define the parameters of their search; – generate key words and search terms; and – discuss their ideas as widely as possible. Guidelines on Literature Review: 2. Identify the relevant data sources. Data may be obtained from published and unpublished works available primarily in the libraries and offices.
3. Develop a systematic procedure and
note-taking skill in collecting literature survey data. • The following are three useful suggestions
– Make each note on a separate sheet
of paper or card. – Make your entries complete and accurate – At the time you make the note, recorded all the information you may possibly need. Strategies for Taking Notes a)Direct quotation.
• The researcher may use direct quotations
only when he/she is convinced that the original author has said something so well or so vividly that he cannot possibly improve upon it.
– Quoting means to repeat another
source word for word, using quotation marks • . • A direct quotation may also be necessary when the researcher wishes to introduce some statement by an authority as evidence in support of some contention of the researcher’s own.
• However, the overuse of direct
quotations from secondary sources indicates that you do not have a clear focus or understanding of the research problem b) Paraphrase. • A paraphrase requires the researcher to restate, in his own words, the thought and meaning, of someone else.
• Paraphrasing means to use the ideas from
another source but change the phrasing into your own words c) Summary note. • A summary note can be taken when the researcher makes a quick overview of factual data that has marginal value. The summary note represents borderline information for your study. It condenses into a brief note the key ideas of a source – Summarizing means to take ideas from a large passage of another source and condense them, using your own words d) Personal notes. • The researcher may also write his personal note card for each of his own ideas, which are not merely borrowed viewpoints. • During your research, make plenty of personal notes to record your own thoughts on the issues. Build your own discourse on the subject. Guidelines . . . 4. Write a concise review of related literature. • The review of related literature should not be a verbatim copied literature. • Data should be presented by topic or variable based on the objectives of the study. 5. Only studies which are related in purpose, method, or findings to current study should be included in the review.
6. Use scholarly journal articles rather
than magazines. Journals offer more reliable evidence than magazines. 7. The review should be logically arranged by topics or themes.
• It should present an authoritative
discussion on the problem and various updates. • Text should be written in the past tense, citing author and date of publication. 8. The writer must learn to blend reference material into his/her writing with unity and coherence. – The researcher must evaluate, organize and synthesize what others have done.
• Thus, quotation, paraphrase,
summary must explain and develop the research topic/problem (unity). • Documentation style should be based on the American Psychological Association (APA) style.
–Use in-text Citations
–Document accurately The APA Format . . • Allows readers to cross-reference your sources easily • Provides consistent format within a discipline • Gives you credibility as a writer • Protects yourself from plagiarism APA Style: There two areas of APA documentation
• Parenthetical (in-text) Citations
• Reference Page When Should You Use Parenthetical Citations?
• When quoting any words that are
not your own
• When summarizing facts and
ideas from a source
• When paraphrasing a source
When using the in-text citation . . .
• Give only information needed to identify
the source on your reference
– Follow the author-date method and (if need
be) the page (s) of the reference
• Do not repeat unnecessary information
Handling Quotes in Your Text • Author’s last name, publication year, and page number(s) of quote must appear in the text. Example • Ferguson and Ferguson (2001) contend that “strategy sets the framework for the evolution of the organization in light of anticipated . . . but does not provide detailed targets and guidelines for its individual parts” (p. 52). • “In 2015, Ghanaians spent more than 3 million Cedis on fried rice alone.” (Mensah, 2016:65). Illustration of In-text Citations While a well-designed strategy is generally accepted as being central to the success of a business organization, it is also beneficial to the non-profit organizations in effectively coping with the challenges of our competitive world. The word “strategy” comes from the Greek world “strategos,” which means a general and the leader of an army (Tsikkiros and Pashiardis, 2002). When used in the contest of the organization as a whole, “strategy describes the way that an organization purses its goals, given the threats and opportunities in the environment and the resources and capabilities of the organization” (Byal et al., 1996:5). Beamish (1996) also described organization strategy as the pattern in the organization’s important decisions and actions, which consists of a few key areas or things by which the firm seeks to distinguish itself.