COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS RUBRICS (55 POINTS)

Criteria Unsatisfactory Satisfactory Competent Very Good Excellent

6 points 1 2 3 4 5
Quality of Analysis No analysis at all. There are traces of Similarities and Mastery of Mastery of content is
POCs are not comparison. Some Differences are content is evident. Similarities
comparable to POCs are not adequately evident. and differences are
chosen schools, too comparable to identified. POCs Similarities and completely identified,
many incorrect chosen schools, are comparable differences are POCs are comparable
points many points are to chosen completely to chosen schools,
incorrect schools, some identified. POCs Complete and correct
points are not are comparable analysis
correct to chosen
schools, complete
but some points
are incorrect
3 points 1 2 3 4 5
Organization and Almost no details Not very detailed, Not very detailed, Detailed, Very detailed in
amount of details and explanation, some explanations explanation is explanation is explanation, well-
almost are lacking, adequate, adequate, well- organized essay
incomprehensible sequence of ideas is organized essay organized essay
confusing
2 points 1 2 3 4 5
Grammar and Spelling 10 and above errors 5-10 errors in 3-4 errors in 1-2 errors in Perfect Grammar,
and Format in grammar and grammar and grammar and grammar and spelling and
format format format format punctuation, followed
the format
*POC: Points of comparison