MIS Department – Video & Report Evaluation form

Video Evaluation

Category Unacceptable (0)
Content Details on video have nothing
to do with the topic of
assignment.
Delivery Video does not stay on topic,
difficult to understand, uses
incomplete sentences, little or
no consideration of audience,
difficult to hear.
Quality of visual text is difficult to read and
aids understand, spelling/grammar
errors evident. Graphics are not
used or not clear.
Time and Pace Goes way over time/ short,
rushes to finish, pace slow or
fast.
Defending choices Presenter unable to answer
questions.
Overall Evaluation F: 0-4
Needs Enhancement (1)
Lacks or demonstrates -
limited idea development with
few (or general) details and/or
weak supporting evidence.
Video appears to be relevant
but lacks good preparation.
Video grasps some elements
of visual aids, however, the
used graphics are hardly
related to the topic.
Few minutes requested to
finish.
Answers are somehow vague
or contain errors.
C: 4-6
Acceptable (2)
Demonstrate some depth of
idea development about the
topic with sufficient
supporting evidences.
Video is adequately delivered
with information being
communicated clearly to
audience. Video shows
satisfactory preparation.
Video is easy to follow and to
understand. Key words are
used. Graphics are put
forward as relevant to the
topic.
Ends on time but some
portions appeared to have
more allocated time.
Students answered question
correctly. However, not
confidently.
B: 7-8
Excellent (3)
Demonstrate analytical
and/or critical insight about
the topic; provides thorough
supporting evidence.
Video is effectively and
creatively delivered with
techniques.
Video is professionally
prepared with graphics are
used creatively to aid
audience understanding.
Ends on Time. Time is
allocated to each portion
effectively.
Self-confident in answering
questions. Answers are clear
and complete.
A: 9-10

Comments: Score is 8. A point for innovative idea. Interesting and new topic. Discord is a platform service that could be used in many ways by organizations. Your report
should focus on one service such as creating learning management systems or sharing and communication services. You seem to focus on communication but without linkage
to organizations other than Discord. Use related clips and graphs otherwise it will be a distraction. The music is a little loud which cover the voice. Organize your thoughts by
starting with a big picture and a problem/ opportunity and work it down to a solution and implementation.
 MIS Department – Video & Report Evaluation form

Report Evaluation:

Category Unacceptable (0) Needs Enhancement (1) Acceptable (2) Excellent (3)
Unable to clearly Lacks specification of Sufficiently states the Clear statement of the
Statement of outline the purpose of purpose with statement purpose and is able to problem, including the
purpose the project. that could be classified as identify and list the background and the need for
“vague”. objectives the project.
The report appears to The report appears to The structure of the project The report is creatively well-
Adherence to miss out on guidelines include few elements of was adhered with sections organized, with appropriate
project structure for submitting the the project structure. put forward reasonably well. introduction, body,
project. conclusions, appendices, etc.
The report is rambling The organisation of the The report grasps The report is well organised
and unfocused; with report (headings and organisation of topics with around the central them in a
Organisation details presented in a subheadings) is themes presented coherently well-planned framework to
non- coherent manner. misleading, as it does not and discernible. relate ideas.
help reader to understand.
Diagrams, figures and Diagrams, figures and Diagrams, figures and tables Appropriate symbols of
tables are not used in tables are used somewhat are used in the project with diagrams along with proper
Quality of visual
the project. poorly. little explanations on their labelling of figures and
aids
relevance to the body of the tables (adequate textual
report. explanations of visuals)
Writing appears as Writing is not clear with Writing is clear with good Writing is clear, concise,
unstructured, non- paragraph and sentence paragraph and sentence but conveying relevant; good
Critical thinking coherent and contains presented poorly. appears as more descriptive. paragraph and sentence
errors and structures with conclusion
grammatical issues. drawn critically.
Overall F: 0-4 C: 4-6 B: 7-8 A: 9-10
Evaluation

Comments: Score 9. Adhere to the requirements such as file name, font size, and don’t leave too many spaces to make your report longer in pages! Use figures and diagrams
to make your report more enjoyable to read. Avoid too long paragraphs. Divide your ideas into several paragraphs.
Discord is a platform that can be used by organizations in many ways. Excellent choice in picking such an interesting topic, but your report is limited by your narrow
understanding of how this platform can be applied. I wish if you have focused on one major component such as gaming, communication or education capabilities in Discord.
You have included multiple paragraphs describing general information of MIS not specific to Discord. Your score includes an extra point for innovativeness.