You are on page 1of 20

Risk assessment

Background

Name of organization* Orchid Tobacco Industries Dubai


Site location* Jebel Ali , Dubai
Number of workers There are 75 workers working in Orchid Tobacco Industries Dubai
Orchid Tobacco is the backbone for Tobacco Industries based in Dubai engaged in
manufacturing of tobacco Machinery, Spare Parts production and Cigarette
manufacturing company, It’s a medium size single stories two separate floor workshop
with one inventory store room, 1 CNC Room and offices that are constructed on one
side top of building . In workshop all operations are carried out within the building floor.
General description of the
In Orchid Tobacco different activities are being carried out, Designing, Machining
organization
operations, Continuous Tobacco Machinery Installation and maintenance like MK8.
MK9, HLP2, Porto’s.
Work is being carried out in one shift from 8:00 AM-6:00 PM, 6 days in a week
from
Monday-Saturday. Work is not being carried out on Sunday.
This assessment covers manufacturing related activates (Designing lab, All Machining
Description of the area to be
Operations), material store room, Warehouse, offices.
included in the risk assessment

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
I studied ILO standards (C115 conventions and RI67 recommendations), HSE Uk OHS
Standard and code of practice for machinery and some article with regard to Health and
safety for manufacturing industries. Then I decided to use ILO-OHS code of practice as
benchmark for this risk assessment.

To identify hazards I physically visitor Orchid Tobacco workshop, and physically inspect
all activities which are part of my risk assessment.
I gathered site related information through physical observation, physical inspection of
workplace. I physically inspected all the equipment’s and workplace, I checked their
maintenance and inspection record. I observed how workers were performing their jobs,
Outline how the risk assessment Other than physical information; I conducted interviews with floor supervisor and
is carried (sources of information workshop manager with regard to health and safety.
consulted, who I spoke to. And I also checked last 2 years accidents record to identify trend, and what type of
how I identified the hazards, what accidents happening here, and to identify what were the causes of those accidents. As
is already being done) per the discussion with workshop supervisor, many accidents are not recorded.

Detail notes with detailed information taken from workshop site including inventory
detail. What is being investigated that management is not committed towards health
and safety.
No adequate provision of training to workers, There is health and safety policy
documented by management. But I have seen Health and safety policy statement
document hasn’t been established and communicated with workers on workshop floor,
there is lack of communication between workers and management, No other effective
control measures were placed by management. No PPE’s are being used by workers as
I have observed management and workers have casual attitude towards health and
safety.
Management need to aware and priorities health and safety of organization.
Management need to update the process and machinery that are outdated.
Management need to communicate with workers and provide adequate trainings on
health and safety. Management must ensure provision and use of sufficient PPE’s.

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Hazard Identification:

Hazards Who might be What we are already What further controls/actions are Timescales
harmed and how? doing? required? Responsible
person’s job
title

Machinery All workshop workers, There is only breakdown 1. Ensure pre use inspection of
and Tools machine operators who maintenance of machines. all machines on daily bases
use these and lubricate them proper
Unmaintained Unmaintained before use.
and Unsafe use machines, and wear There is no use of PPE’S
of Lathe out tools on daily
Like gloves, helmet and 2. Ensure periodic inspection
Machines, bases. They could be
Milling harmed or face googles by operators. of all machines and maintain
Machines, Drill different type of inspection record.
machine, Most of the machines don’t
disability or injury on HSE
grinders, disk accident. have safety guards installed 3. Ensure preventive Engineer
cutters. while machining, metal maintenance of all machines
Machine operators who chips can significantly harm after every one month, and
use these machines, their body. maintain maintenance
wear out tools on daily records.
bases could be harmed
from incorrect or unsafe 4. Ensure provision of safe
use of these machines. system of work to all
They can face sheering machine operators.
of their body parts,
entanglement due to
loose clothes, trapping
due to lack of attention,

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Can face stabling from 5. Ensure and maintain cutting
lathe, milling and drill tools inventory to eliminate
machines chips on high use of wear out cutting tools.
feed, and can face
abrasion through 6. Ensure use of safety guards
contact with grinder
around machines to protect
abrasive wheel.
operators from metal chips
that could lead to operator
physical injury.

7. Aware workers and


operators with regard to
health and safety through
toolbox talk.

8. Ensure provision of good


condition PPE’s and Enforce
use of PPE’S, Gloves,
helmet, and googles while
machining and moving
round.

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Hazard Who might be What are you already What further controls/actions are Timescales
Harmed and how? Doing? Required? Responsible
person’s job
title
Noise All workshop employees There is only breakdown Management
and are exposed from noise, and Finance
maintenance. 1. Replace old technology Manager
Vibration and Only machine machines with new technology
of operators are exposed Workers and operators are machines (LikeCNC
Machines from vibration. Who use unaware about the Machines). As CNC machines
and and make contact with
consequence of Noise and produce no or lessnoise and
Other these Unmaintained
Equipment. Machines, wear out
vibration, They are not trained. vibration.
tools on daily bases. 2. Ensure daily pre use Supervisor.
Noise and They could be harmed or inspections for all machines.
Vibration of face different type of
Unmaintained illness and disorders. 3. Ensure Periodic inspections,
Workshop
and Old All workers can loss and preventive maintenanceof
Manager and
technology Temporary or every machine. supervisor
Manual Lathe permanent hearing. And
Machines, particularly from 4. Use other methods to reduce
Milling vibration machines noise and vibration
Machines, operators can face
concentration (Like
Machine, Drill serious muscle floor supervisor
machine, Weakening, nerve damping, isolation of such
grinders. damage, and their machines, which produce high
Compressors. blood supply can be concentration noise and
shut down. vibration).

Visitors and suppliers, 5. Ensure buying and use of


and other person noise and vibration Manager,
moving around in concentration measuring workshop
workshop can face devices.
serious effects of noise
and vibration.
6. Limit the exposure time of
Orchid Tobacco Dubai
Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
workers with breaks or ensure
workshop
job rotation for workers. manager and
safety officer
7. Ensure provision and use of
Noise and vibration protective
PPE’S (e.g. Earplug, gloves). Workshop
Manager

Hazard Who might be What we are you already What further controls/actions are Timescales
harmed and how? doing? Required? Responsi
ble
person’s
jobtitle
Electricity All workers and High voltage electric power 1. Identify all electrical hazards Safety Officer
operators who line are placed on overhead and risks.
operate electric that reduce some contact
power machines, exposure.
technicians

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Electric shocks and Who can be in contact Electrical technician while 2. Ensure provision of safe Workshop
short circuit in with electricity could rectifying electrical devices system of work when working Manager
workshop from high suffer burns, painful and power connections don’t on wires, or near electrical
power lines that are sensations, cardiac uses safety PPE. powered devices or
the power source is arrest, inhalation injury machines.
for different
cannot breath. Earthling of every equipment 3. Ensure periodic inspection of
machinery. supervi
Possible Electricity can cause has placed. all electric wires, Rectify where
sor
malfunction: fire. The worst case connection is lose, Use extra
-Portable can lead to death of Main board has built in low extensions where circuit is
machinery many workers. efficient miniature circuit overloaded, ensure good
-Workstations in breakers. condition of sockets and plug
designing lab. People or visitor is maintained,
moving around 4. Replace some bad quality and
workshop could be faulty wires to double insulated Supervisor
harmed from electric quality wires to eliminate risk of
shocks electric short electric shock.
circuits, and electric 5. Ensure competency of
burns. electrical technicians and Safety
trained them. officer
6. Ensure reporting procedure in
place on electrical incidents
and train first aider for
Safety
immediate actions. Officer

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Hazard Who might be What are you already What further controls/actions are Timescales
Harmed and how? Doing? Required? Responsible
person’s job
title

Fire initiation All workers, machines All doors and windows of 1. Divide workshop into MD and
operators, could be workshops are fire doors that compartment for different workshop
seriously harmed from are capable to resist fire. Manager
Fire initiation operations like machining,
Because of fire. Fire can kill many welding, heat treatment,
grinding, cutting, workers directly and Manual Fire Safety alarms are sheet metalworking.
some could be effected in place but automatic heat and
flammable Separate all three fuels that
because of fire smoke smoke detector are inplace.
materials like inhalation. cause fire.
tobacco, Evacuation roots are defined
smoking, or fire Visitors or moving but some roots are restricted 2. Ensure installation of Finance
can start through around people with different materials and automatic heat and smoke manager and
electric. could be seriously machines. detector with fire safety workshop
harmed from fire. alarms. manager
Fire extinguisher are installed. 3. Evacuation roots must be
clear from any resistance. Safety
No Training provided to Build more evacuation doors Officer
employees on fire emergency. in opposite direction. Ensure
No drill practice Conducted by
and define assembly point in
the management.
case of fire.

4. Ensure periodic inspection Floor


of all safety extinguishers, supervisor
fire hydrants.

5. Define Master point in case safety


of fire. supervisor

6. Risk assessment must be Safety


carried out on fire hazards. Officer

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Hazard Who might be What are you already What further controls/actions are Timescales
Harmed and how? Doing? Required? Responsible
person’s job
title

Slip Trip and Workers, operators, Cleaning is carried out after 1. Ensure proper and daily Sanitary
fall on cleaning staff, 1 week. housekeeping of building. supervisor
workshop site. engineers, and other
visitors can fall, slip or 2. Ensure maintenance of Maintenance
Slip and trip due trip due to wet Workshop PPE’s like lights, and light must be supervisor
to dim lighting, surfaces, random workshop shoes are installed as per standard
slippery wet placement of different provided but not enforced to height.
surfaces, trip due machinery. Slip and use by management. Safety
to random trip on floor can lead 3. Enforce use of PPE’s all supervisor
placement of to serious bone time. (Like safety shoes and
different parts, fracture, cuts, and helmet)
machinery and muscle strain.
workshop
materials. 4. Place machinery in an engineer
organized manner so
obstruction can be avoided.

5. Provide walking ways with


Floor supervisor
clear signs, and marking for
safe movement.

6. Conduct safety talks for Safety


employees to aware about supervisor
these risks and their
consequences.

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Hazard Who might be What are you already What further controls/actions are Timescales
Harmed and how? Doing? Required? Responsible
person’s job
title

Excessive Workers and They have not consider this 1. Eliminate excessive Workshop
Workload machines operators hazard in risk assessment. workload; Extra work must manager
loads leads to they feel body stress give after consultation with
Body Stress. because of over workers. Workshop
workload, sometime 2. Start new shift in case of manager
Workers and they get enforce to excessive demands.
other machine work extra hours, they
operators are feel body stress 3. Ensure replacement of
overload with because of manual machinery in to
different tasks, Unmaintained and automatic that will minimize MD
and the other manual machinery as human effort.
reason of body well that could lead to
stress is use of pain, long-term injury, 4. Ensure proper maintenance
unmaintained or tissue damage. Supervisor
of machines to minimize
and manual human effort.
machinery take
extra body force 5. Workers should be given
these reasons access to counselling with
leads to body workshop manager for work- Workshop
stress for related information and Manager
workers, assistance.
Operators.
6. Ensure medical assistance
to workers in case of any MD
stress, pain, Body strain.

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Hazard Who might be What are you already What further controls/actions are Timescales
Harmed and how? Doing? required? Responsible
person’s job
title

Work-related All workers, machine There is no practice in place 2. Ensure and define clear role
mental illness operators, who are to identify physiological for every worker. One role for
forced to do extra hazards. Management is one person.
not aware about
Excessive hours work to meet consequences of mental
demands of the demands, those who illness. 3. Select work hours and work
job, extra hours don’t cope up pattern set in consultation
work, deadlines Workload pressure, with workers.
pressure, and those are used for 4. Start extra shift to deal with
one workers for different tasks, could excessive demands,
be harmed from
different tasks mental illness like workload, and deadlines.
that lead to stress, anxiety, 5. Ensure provision of adequate
Depression, depression. information to workers when
fatigue, and they needed additional
other mental counselling with regard to
Illness. work.

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Hazard Who might be What are you already What further controls/actions are Timescales
Harmed and how? Doing? Required? Responsible
person’s job
title

Work related Designers, There is no practice in 1. Ensure risk assessment is Safety


musculoskeletaland draftsman, while place to identify this being carried out of the supervisor
upper limb disorders. performing designing hazard. Management designer’s workstations. And
(Ergonomics) task sitting on a stole is not aware about technicians line work With
in front of screen and consequences of regard to ergonomics.
Mechanical designers, other assembly line poor posture of body 2. Ensure provision of safe Managing
draftsman, while workers who move while working. system of work. director and
workshop
performing design in forward, backward, 3. Ensure the equipment’s and manager
task sitting on a stolein bend, twist to environment meet the
front of screen and assemble different standard requirement with
other assembly line mechanical parts. regards to good ergonomics
Workers who move Such task with poor design. Safety supervisor
forwardbackward, posture Can cause 4. Ensure provision of frequent
bend, twist to assemble muscle strain, Back breaks between long hours
different mechanical pain, upper limb for designers and Machinist.
parts. Such taskwith disorders, and other 5. Ensure training is being Floor supervisors
poor posturecause chronic tissue provided with regard to
musclestrain, Back injuries. health risks due to poor body
pain,upper, limb posture.
Disorders, and other 6. Provide health surveillance
chronictissue injuries. and medical facility (Like free
eye test for screen users)

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Hazard Who might be What are you already What further controls/actions are Timescales
Harmed and how? Doing? Required? Responsible
person’s job
title

Hazardous Operators who works PPE’s are not given to 1. Identify hazards and carry Safety Officer
substance on machines, and workers like googles, mask out Proper and sufficient risk
Tobacco welders who and helmet. Etc. assessment.
Operates welding
plants could be 2. Enclose or segregate area
Inhalation or harmed from for welding activity from Workshop
Manager
ingestion of inhalation, ingestion other operations.
airborne solid or injection of
particles due to airborne dust fumes 3. Ensure and reduce
Floor
grinding, milling, of metals while exposure time for welders supervisor
floor dust, welding, machining, and machining workers.
Fumes airborne grinding, Inhalation
metallic of Tobacco smell. 4. Change exhaust fans to FM AND
particles due to Resulting is skin efficient exhaust and MD
welding. tissue damage, skin ventilation system.
Inhalation of inflammation and
Tobacco smell. irritation, lungs 5. Provide sufficient PPE’s with Workshop
infection and respiratory protective Manager
Respiratory issue like equipment as well and make and safety
asthma. sure their use. officer

6. Ensure health surveillance


for all workers who are MD
exposed in such activities.

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Hazard Who might be What are you already What further controls/actions are Timescales
Harmed and how? Doing? Required? Responsible
person’s job
title

Mould and Sanitary staff who PPE’s are not provided to 1. Ensure cleaning of building Floor
Fungi on used to clean the cleaning staff (mask and from biological agents. supervisor
workshop walls building after an other PPE’s).
roof, and interval, workers who 2. Ensure proper and sufficient
washrooms. passes under Exhaust fans are installed risk assessment must be Safety Officer
cleaning process for moisture control. carried out including
Because of could be harm biological hazards.
moisture, through interaction
because of poor moulds, fungi, 3. Ensure use of PPE’s while
air exhaust insects, these cleaning including masks, Safety officer
system, there are biological hazards clothing, and gloves.
moulds, fungi, can cause lungs
insects infection, skin 4. Get aware and give
interaction with Irritation, Fungal instructions to all workers,
these can cause infection. cleaning staff through tool Safety Officer
health issues, box talk with regard to such
lungs infections, hazards.
skin irritation and
fungal infection. 5. Install efficient
ventilation system in Safety officer
workshop building.

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Orchid Tobacco Dubai
Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Moral, financial and legal arguments for ALL actions
Moral, general legal and financial MORAL ARGUMENTS:
arguments
1. Employer has moral duty and duty of care towards its all the workers, and other staff
to make sure their prevention from any kind of suffering, pain and lose. When health
and safety of company will not be managed properly, workers, people, and many of
us can injured or killed and suffered from terrible diseases. Because of such suffering
their families and dependents can also suffer, this type of sorrow is not morally
acceptable. It is the moral responsibility of employer to ensure provision of safe
workplace, safe work environment, safe work equipment, safe system of work, and
procedures. It is moral responsibility of employer to invest on health and safety of
employees. By investing and updating new technological machines that are more safe
and efficient, ergonomically better, by segregating all operational activates, by
providing sufficient PPE’s. Employer will fulfil his moral duty provision of safe
workplace, safe work equipment, and personal protection for every other worker or
visitor moving around.
FINANCIAL ARGUMENTS:
2. Investment on Purchasing advance technological machines, the cost is very high in
purchasing CNC Machines but in long run it would increase production, save time, it
will ensure low risk of accidents for employees as compare to manual machines. It will
reduce the workers involvement with these machines, workers efforts, workers
Physical fatigue. This investment will ultimately increase production, will produce

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Quality products, as these machines are safer, Investment on segregation of all
activities in a separate space, Investment on buying new and sufficient PPE’s for all
workers will make sure their personal protection.
By investing on such actions employer can save or minimize direct cost associated
with accidents like medical cost, sick leave, compensation claim cost or fire initiation
or equipment damage costs, lost production costs.
Employer can have indirect cost benefits like it will increase good reputation of
business, it will increase customer goodwill, by using new technological machines
that will increase productivity with good quality products, employer will be able to fulfil
orders timely.
LEGAL ARGUMENTS:
ILO-OSH-R14 and C155 Provide legal guidance and placed legal obligations on employer.
3. Employer has legal duty to ensure safe equipment, Safe workplace, and safe work
environment with no risk to health. Unmaintained machines, unsafe use of manual
machines can harm workers, welding radiations, and airborne solid particles can harm
other workers and people, use of chemicals in heat treatment plants can harm.
Employer could receive improvement notice if legal provisions are insufficient are
incomplete, Because of presence of any serious accident risk, any possibility of loss
that could lead to legal prohibition notice for employer, those activities could be stop.
As employer is breaching law in many area, employer can face legal prosecution
notice from court as well. Successful prosecution can lead to employer heavy fine and
imprisonment of workers, engineers, and mangers.
By having any type of accident or illness employer could receive civil claim from
effected workers, high cost is associated with these compensation claims, (legal
costs, lawyers cost).
If any accident happen employer can lose Business reputation, current orders,
contracts, future projects.

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
Review, communicate and check
Planned review date/period I have selected annual review date is January 2023. There are many reason for selecting 1
and year period for action and review. The first reason is there is a company health and safety
Reasoning policy that recommends to review risk assessment annually. The second reason of this
review date is ILO recommends annual review.

But it could be reviewed before the annual review date. If


Any new CNC machine is installed.
If legislation comes with new code of practice and recommendations.

How I’m going to communicated risk This risk assessment will be placed on table with management including Managing director,
assessment findings. workshop Manager, and Finance manager. And finding of this report will be presented to
them. With open feedback questioning answering section and views from other meeting
members.

After approval from management all the risk assessment findings, minutes of meetings, and
management suggestions will be communicated through tool box talk to all workers,
operators to get them aware about hazards and risk associated with their workplace. To
share control measure or solution this will positively impact on workers behavior they will
somehow start behaving safely. And this help in improving the safety culture.

Minutes of meetings, and suggestion on an all action. All the document will be pasted on
workshop noticeboards. Hard print outs will also be distributed among all workers.

Orchid Tobacco Dubai


Address: Jebel Ali Free Zone Area, Contact: 050120236 Email: orchidtobocco@gmail.com
This document contains proprietary information of Orchid Tobacco Dubai. Use of this Document without authorization is prohibited.
How I will follow up and Monitor on I will create a reminder note for follow up on all actions.
the risk assessment to check that the I will speak to every responsible person for every action by every 15 days of due date to
actionshave been carried out? monitor the progress of that action.
I will speak to finance manager to make sure the sufficient resources allocated for new
machinery and segregation, will communicate with workshop manager for their tasks.
If any action would be overdue, not completed on time, I will find out the reason why this is
not completed. Then I will immediately consult with finance manager and managing director
to allocate resources and provide any type of required assistance on time.
I will create a checklist for all activities to ensure that every equipment is well maintained and
inspected before use.
I will get daily reports from supervisors about daily tool box talk is conducted with relevant
topic and knowledge. I will personally make sure the Proper use of PPES, I will conduct
meetings with workers to aware all worker on importance of health and safety.

Learner number: 00578699 Learner name: Rehan Bin Safeer Page 19 of 26


Learner number: 00578699 Learner name: Rehan Bin Safeer Page 20 of 26

You might also like