TAN COLLEGE Institute of Arts and Sciences 2nd Semester AY 2021-2022
Utilization and Application of Instructional Materials
GE Science, Technology, and Society Rubrics for Oral Presentation CRITERIA Level Beginning (1) Developing (2) Proficient (3) Mastery (4) A. Content Topic lacks relevance of Topic would benefit Topic is adequately Topic is tightly focused Importance of topic, relevance, focus; presentation from more focus; focused and relevant: and relevant; accuracy of facts, overall; contains multiple fact presentation contains major facts are accurate presentation contains treatment of topic errors some fact errors or and generally complete accurate information omissions with no fact errors B. Organization/Clarity Ideas are not presented Some ideas not Most ideas are in logical Ideas rea presented in Appropriate introduction, body, in proper order; transition presented in proper order with adequate logical order with and conclusions; logical ordering are lacking between order: transitions are transitions between most effective transitions of ideas; transitions between major ideas; several needed between some major ideas; presentation between major ideas, major points parts of presentation are ideas: some parts of is generally clear and presentation is clear wordy or unclear presentation may be understandable and concise wordy or unclear C. Completeness Presentation does not Additional depth is Presentation provides Presentation provides Level of detail, depth, appropriate provide adequate depth, needed in places; adequate depth; few good depth and detail; length, adequate background of key details are omitted or important information needed details are ideas well developed; information undeveloped, omitted or not fully omitted; major ideas facts have adequate presentation is too short developed, presentation adequately developed; background; or too long is too short or too long presentation is within presentation is within specified length specified length D. Grammar/Mechanics Presentation contains Presentation may Presentation has no Presentation contains Correct grammar and usage that several major contain some grammar serious grammar errors; no grammar errors; is appropriate for audience (s) grammar/usage errors; or sentence errors; sentences are mostly sentences are free of sentences are long, sentences may contain jargon-free, complete jargon, complete and incomplete or contain jargon or are too long or and understandable easy to understand excessive jargon hard to follow E. Documentation Little or no message Some message support Adequate message Effective message Proper support and sourcing for support provided for provided by facts and support provided for key support provided in the major ideas, inclusion of visual major ideas; visual aids visual aids; sourcing concepts by facts and form of facts and visual aids that support message are missing or may be outdated, or visual aids; sourcing is aids; sourcing is current inadequate; little or no thin, visual aids need generally adequate and and supports major sourcing provided work current ideas F. Delivery Low volume or energy; More volume/energy Adequate volume and Good volume and Adequate volume, appropriate pace too slow or fast; needed at times; pace energy; generally good energy; proper pace pace, diction, personal poor diction; distracting too slow or fats; some pace and diction; few or and diction; avoidance appearance, enthusiasm/energy, gestures or posture; distracting gestures or no distracting gestures; of distracting gestures; posture, effective use of visual unprofessional posture; adequate professional appearance; professional aids appearance; visual aids appearance; visual aids visual aids used properly appearance; visual aids poorly used could be improved used effectively G. Interactions Little or no eye contact Additional eye contact Fairly good eye contact Good eye contact with Adequate eye contact with with audience; poor needed at times; better with audience; displays audience; excellent audience, ability to listen and/or listening skills; listening skills needed; ability to listen; provides listening skills; answers answer questions uneasiness or inability to some difficulty adequate answers to audience questions answer audience answering audience audience questions with authority and questions questions accuracy.