You are on page 1of 5

IJSRD - International Journal for Scientific Research & Development| Vol.

3, Issue 01, 2015 | ISSN (online): 2321-0613

Harmonic Analysis in Distribution Network


Somesh Kumar Jayaswal1 Rahul Kumar Tiwari2 Akash Kale3
1,2,3
Department of Electrical Engineering
1,2,3
AISSMS’S IOIT, Pune
Abstract— Harmonics are found to have deleterious effects Frequency Drives or VFDs), the power system harmonics
on power system equipments including transformers, problems has increased its significance. This brings a big
capacitor banks, rotating machines, switchgears and obstacle against the wide application of VFDs. The presence
protective relays. Transformers, motors and switchgears of harmonics on power system causes voltage and current
may experience increased losses and excessive heating. distortion which leads to aging of Electrical appliances and
Shunt filters are effective in minimizing voltage distortions. damages to electrical apparatus.

 Overheating of Electrical Equipment


This paper describes the voltage distortions generated by The effects of Harmonics are listed below.

 Communication Interference
non-linear loads. The harmonic specifications such as

 Resonance
harmonic factor, characteristic harmonic and non-
characteristic harmonic are considered while explaining the
paper. With the implementation of a passive filter at the bus  Other (Installation of Capacitor Bank)
with non-linear load, the harmonics are greatly reduced. For
the specified power system, at all the buses the total A. Overheating of Electrical Equipment:
harmonic distortion has been evaluated. It is common to refer to heating as I2R losses. Electrical
Key words: Harmonics, Harmonic Measurement, Power equipment can be overheated by distorted load current that
Analysis, VFD cause higher eddy current losses inside the equipment. Skin
effect causes harmonic current to flow uniformly across
I. INTRODUCTION entire cross-sectional area of the winding conductor of

 Overheating of generators, motors, transformers, and


In electrical power system the impact of non-linear loads has transformer. Other results of heating are:
been increasing during the last decades. Presently, power

 Excessive losses
system and power quality have been concerned about power cables that lead to early equipment failures.

 Overheating of neutral conductors.


harmonic pollution generated by modern electronic devices

 Capacitor failures, tripping of circuit breakers and


such as adjustable speed drivers, controlled rectifier etc. In
ideal situation, the electric power in a network is supplied at
a constant system frequency, and at specified voltage loss of synchronization on timing circuits.
magnitudes known as the fundamental frequency, however, B. Communication Interference:
in practice under different circumstances the frequency and
voltages are deviated from their designated values. The Magnetic (or electrostatic) coupling [between electrical
deviation of a wave form from its perfect sinusoid is power circuits and communication circuits can cause
generally expressed in terms of harmonics. communication interference. Current flowing in the power
Harmonics in power systems is nothing but the circuit produces a magnetic (or electrostatic field that will
existence of signals, superimposed on the fundamental induce a current (or voltage) in the nearby conductors of the
signal, whose frequencies are integer numbers of the communication circuit. The amount of interference will
fundamental frequency. The presence of harmonics in the depend upon the magnitude of the induced current (or
voltage or current waveform leads to a distorted signal for voltage), frequency, and the efficiency of the magnetic
voltage or current, and the signal becomes non-sinusoidal (electrostatic) coupling.

 Reduction of equipment operating reliability and


signal which causes malfunctions or damage on load. Other types of communication interference are
Harmonic measurement is one of the well-known aspects of

 Induced line noise


power quality monitoring and control. service life.

 Interference to communication systems, and


Harmonic measurement and analysis in power
systems is thus a major concern of power system

 Nuisance tripping to protection Relays and plant


administrators as well as engineers. sensitive electronic devices.
The paper is organized as follows: Section II
describes the Effect of Harmonics on power system. In
C. Resonance:
Section III A brief summary of Importance and need for
identification of harmonic contents in power system signals Resonance occurs when a harmonic frequency produced by
for system performance , safety and power quality a non-linear load closely coincides with a power system
monitoring in power system is presented. Section IV natural frequency. There are two forms of resonance which
presents IEEE-519 Recommended harmonic limits. Section can occur: parallel resonance and series resonance. Parallel
V case study. Section VI Mitigation techniques. Section VII resonance occurs when the natural frequency of the parallel
concludes the paper. combination of capacitor banks and the system inductance
falls at or near a harmonic frequency. This can cause
II. EFFECTS OF HARMONCS substantial amplification of the harmonic current that flows
between the capacitors and the system inductance and lead
Due to the dramatic increase in the usage of nonlinear loads to capacitor fuse blowing or failure or transformer
in industrial applications (mainly regarding Variable overheating. Series resonance is a result of a series

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 1082


Harmonic Analysis in Distribution Network
(IJSRD/Vol. 3/Issue 01/2015/284)

combination of inductance and capacitance and presents a fundamental power, harmonic and unbalanced
low impedance path for harmonic currents at the natural quantities in many applications.
frequency. The effect of a series resonance can be a high 3) Analysis and power Quality Monitoring: A distorted
voltage distortion level between the inductance and wave consists of 5th and 7th harmonic and several
capacitance. The interaction between capacitive and other higher harmonics. In certain complex condition
inductive devices at some harmonic frequency causes it consists of inter harmonics and sub harmonics in
unexpectedly large circulating current in some parts of the such cases the energy of the signal at each
circuit. Over voltage and excessive current leads to failure constituting component is required for analysis and
of capacitor banks and oil filled cables. Power factor quality monitoring of the system.
correction capacitors with cable or apparatus inductance
A. Importance of Harmonic Measurement:
may set up current amplifying resonance.
A resonance condition can cause a current Harmonic measurements are an important part of the overall
waveform to have zero crossings occur more than once investigation for a number of reasons. Most importantly, the
every half-cycle the presence of harmonics because it is measurements must be used to characterize the level of
sensing a peak value that does not directly correspond to the harmonic generation for the existing nonlinear loads as it
provide a means for verifying the harmonic model. The
 Misoperation of electronic equipment.
RMS value of the wave shape. Other consequences are:
specific objectives of the measurements include:
 Inaccurate meter readings and errors in measuring 1) Determine the harmonic generation characteristics of
the variable - frequency drives. Which can be done by
 Misoperation of protective relays.
equipment.
performing the current measurements a variety of
 Interference with motor controllers and telephone
locations within the plant. Three-phase measurements
can make so that characteristic and non -
circuits.
characteristic harmonic components can be
D. Other (Installation of Capacitor Bank): determined.
The application of capacitors on a power system in the 2) Determine system response characteristics for
presence of harmonic generating equipment produces a particular conditions and voltage measurements are
harmonic resonance condition. Capacitive reactance used in conjunction with the current measurements,
decreases directly with frequency and inductive reactance both to characterize the system response for specific
increases directly with frequency. At the resonant frequency system conditions. These conditions are then be the
of any inductive-capacitive (LC) circuit, the inductive basis for verifying the analytical models.
reactance will equal the capacitive reactance. In actual 3) Determine the background harmonic voltage and
electrical systems utilizing power factor correction current levels.
capacitors, both series and parallel resonance or a
combination of the two may occur. Occurrence of resonance IV. IEEE-519 EVALUATION OF HARMONIC DISTORTION AND

 Capacitor bank and insulated cable failures.


may cause such problems as RECOMMENDED HARMONIC LIMIT

 Excessive capacitor fuse operation, and


To minimize the impact of facility harmonic distortion on

 Dielectric breakdown or reactive power overload.


utility power system and neighboring facilities, IEEE
standard was developed in 1982 and updated in 1992.[22]
IEEE 519 standard propose limits of current harmonic
III. NEED OF FAST AND ACCURATE IDENTIFICATION OF injection from end user /customer to supply grid so that
FUNDAMENTAL AND HARMONIC QUANTITIES voltage harmonic levels on overall power system remains
In industrial and commercial power system fast and accurate within acceptable limit.[26] The practices are used for
guidance in the design of power systems with non-
identification of the signal is required for evaluation of
initial and future system performance. It is also essential to A. Current Distortion limits:
study system reliability and finding its ability to grow with
production for operating requirements. It is also required to
ensure whether the system will operate safely, economically,
and efficiently over the expected life of the system or not
depending on following:
1) Power Quantities: In a power system, different
measures of power quantities such as power
frequency 60/50 Hz or fundamental of active,
reactive, , and apparent powers are defined these
three basic quantities are the quintessence of power
flow in electrical networks and should be calculated
based on the information embedded in voltage and
current signals. Table 1: Current Distortion limits.
2) Detection of Fundamental Frequency: A power signal linear loads, such as adjustable speed drives and
when distorted is consists of fundamental and one or uninterruptible power supplies. The standard also discusses
more harmonics. Fundamental voltage and current power system response characteristics, the effects of
components should be properly detected to get harmonics, methods for harmonic control, and provides

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 1083


Harmonic Analysis in Distribution Network
(IJSRD/Vol. 3/Issue 01/2015/284)

recommended limits for harmonic current and voltage V. CASESTUDY: ESTA 2


distortions. The following chart indicates the limits for Measurements were carried out at manufacturing company.
harmonic current distortion imposed by this standard. The 2 transformers of 22KV, 150/5A each which receives power
limits are based up on ratio of available short circuits current through MSEDCL. Further supply is given to a transformer
(Isc) at PCC to maximum demand load current (IL) The of 22/6.6KV, 2MVA, from here voltage is step downed to
analysis is generally performed at the point of where facility 6.6/0.4KV,2MVA by another transformer & supply is given
power is connected to utility power system. This point to ESTA 2.
generally called as PCC.
B. Voltage Distortion limits:

Table 2: Voltage Distortion limit

Fig. 1: Single Line diagram of electrical distribution


Reading at PCC
With Capacitor With Capacitor VI. MITIGATION TECHNIQUES
Parameters
ON OFF
A. System Filtering Methods:
Voltage. (V) 231.30 230
Current. (I) 370.06 145 As a method, system filters, whether active or passive, have
Active Power (KW) the advantage of being retro-fit but the disadvantage of
187 82 being possibly only a temporary solution. If the power
Max.
system changes, for example, if more non-linear load is
Reactive Power
161.50 32 added, the design assumptions will also change.
(KVAR)Max
1) Passive Filters:
THD i % 35 13.60
Passive filters can be designed to reduce harmonic voltages
THD v % 4.7 1.9
and notch effects at particular points in the power system.
5th % 29 10 Each installation is different and the size and placement of
7th % 13 7.5 the filters varies accordingly. Usually, the passive filters
Table 3: Reading at PCC include different types of parallel paths that present

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 1084


Harmonic Analysis in Distribution Network
(IJSRD/Vol. 3/Issue 01/2015/284)

relatively low impedance to the various harmonics. decreases, resulting in less of a need for cancellation. It is
Harmonic currents flow into this reduced impedance such possible for a facility with a large number of AFDs to feed
that the harmonic voltage at that point is reduced. In some two halves of the distribution from phase-shifted
cases, there will be sufficient source impedance at the transformers, yielding a large reduction in harmonic levels
location at which harmonics must be reduced that a single for minimal cost, and allowing a higher percentage of AFD
filter at that location can absorb harmonics from the multiple loads under IEEE Std. 519-1992 guidelines. Multiple
harmonic sources. This point might be the point of common transformers can be used to develop different phase shifts
connection, but in any event, the filter must be designed so between sources of harmonic currents. For example, two
as not to be overloaded by harmonic currents from other transformers with a 50Hz phase shift of 30 degrees between
parts of the power system. These filters are much more them will resulting cancellation of the 5th, 7th, 17th, and 19,
difficult to use in conjunction with auxiliary generators for etc. harmonics and will resemble 12 pulse drive system.
two reasons. Firstly, the generators cannot normally support Four transformers shifted by 15 degrees with respect to each
more than about 20% leading KVAR because armature other will result in a 24-pulse distribution and will
reaction may cause over-excitation and voltage regulator significantly minimize the resulting harmonics upstream of
instability. Secondly, frequency variations expected with an the common bus.
auxiliary generator are much greater than those of the utility;
therefore, the filter design is complicated. Passive filters are
widely used in conjunction with utility-type static VAR
compensators and electric arc furnaces with megawatt
ratings. In this type of application, the major source of
harmonic disturbance is well known, and the probability of
system changes affecting the filter performance is small.
2) Add-On Active Filters:
In this method, an additional power electronic convertor is
used to supply the power source line with the harmonic
currents required by the non-linear load. In essence, the
filter is a power amplifier and must have adequate
bandwidth to compensate for the harmonic currents required Fig. 3: Twelve pulse transformer solution
by the electronic equipment, at least up to the 25th harmonic.
Technically, this method is undoubtedly very effective. The VII. CONCLUSION
main drawback lies in its cost, which, with development, is
This paper presented Harmonic measurement and analysis
expected to be comparable to an inverter of similar rating. In
as one of the well-known aspects of power quality
contrast with typical motor drive inverters, which operate
monitoring and control. Analyzing harmonics, at Vishay
from a stable dc link voltage, the active filter is exposed to
Components it was observed that Present harmonic levels at
voltage stresses caused by normal and fault conditions in the
PCC were exceeding recommended levels. And 5th and 7th
power system. This puts additional demands upon the
order harmonic are amplified due to use of PF improvement
semiconductor switching devices; hybrid arrangements of
capacitors.
active and passive components are also feasible. The supply
To limit harmonic level, several multi pulse based
voltage imbalance from the load terminal voltage is
phase Autotransformers topologies to meet standard IEEE
eliminated by a series-active filter which also forces an
519.Compared with other solutions, autotransformers
existing shunt-passive filter to absorb all the current
possess such advantages as being simple, reliable, no
harmonics produced by a non-linear load.
resonance problem and relatively cost effective, as well as
B. Six Pulse: small physical size.

REFERENCES
[1] IEEE Std. 519-1992. IEEE Recommended Practice
and Requirements for Harmonic Control in Electrical
Power
[2] Mack Grady W., Surya Santoso, Understanding
Power System Harmonics, IEEE Power Engineering
Review, Volume 21, Issue 11, Nov. 2001, Page(s): 8
Fig. 2: Six Pulse Arrangement –11
C. Twelve Pulse: [3] Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers,
IEEE Std 1459- 2010: IEEE Standard Definitions for
This is similar to a 12-pulse converter, on a macro-scale. If the Measurement of Electric Power Quantities Under
two AFDs of equal HP and load are phase shifted by feeding Sinusoidal, Non-sinusoidal, Balanced, or Unbalanced
one AFD from a delta/wye-transformer, and feeding the Conditions, Piscataway, USA, March 2010.
second through a delta/delta transformer or a line reactor of [4] Yilmaz Luy, Xiaodong Liang, Member,“Investigation
equivalent impedance, performance similar to 12-pulse may of Input Harmonic Distortions of Variable Frequency
be achieved. The cancellation will degrade as the loads vary Drives” IEEE proceeds, 2007.
from AFD to AFD, although as the load on single AFD
decreases, the individual distortion contribution percentage

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 1085


Harmonic Analysis in Distribution Network
(IJSRD/Vol. 3/Issue 01/2015/284)

[5] Fusheng Z., Zhongxing G., and Wei Y., “The


algorithm of interpolating windowed FFT for
harmonic analysis of electric power system,” IEEE
Trans. Power Del., vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 160–164, Apr.
2001.
[6] Hidalgo R. M., J. G. Fernandez, R. R. Rivera, and
Larrondo H. A., “A simple adjustable window
algorithm to improve FFT measurements,”
IEEETrans. Instrum. Meas., vol. 51, no. 1. 31–36,
Feb. 2002.

All rights reserved by www.ijsrd.com 1086

You might also like