You are on page 1of 8

Research and Reviews: Journal of Mechanics and Machines

Volume 2 Issue 1

Design, Fabrication and Performance Testing of a Hydraulic Ram


Pump System
Mohammad Sultan Mahmud*, Arafater Rahman
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Khulna University of Engineering & Technology,
Khulna, Bangladesh
*Corresponding Author
E-Mail Id: sultankuet01@gmail.com

ABSTRACT
In rural areas, especially at hilly areas people faces multiple problems of using conventional
energy. Unconventional energy is the satisfying solution of these problems. Hydraulic ram
pump is one kind of unconventional energy device. Hydraulic ram pump is a device, which
converts potential energy into kinetic energy and lifts up water from lower height to higher
height. Present work is based on construction of a hydraulic ram pump and test of its output
performance, according on different drive pipe length. When drive pipe length is 0.1m, its
volumetric discharge was obtained 1.7648×10-4 m3/sec, drive pipe discharge was 7.9384×10-
4 3
m /sec and efficiency was obtained 28.73%. At drive pipe length 0.35m, volumetric
discharge was obtained 4.66032×10-5 m3/sec, drive pipe discharge was 1.1232×10-4 m3/sec
and efficiency was obtained 46.32%. At drive pipe length 0.52m, volumetric discharge was
3.8602×10-5 m3/s, drive pipe discharge was 1.27×10-4 m3/sec and efficiency was 36.82%. A
different behaviour of water flow and discharge can be observed for the different length of
drive pipe and also more flow rate of water at discharge pipe. Hydraulic ram pump has a
great potential to be useful device for its simple and reliable pumping mechanism in such
type of hilly areas and remote places where are of no water supply coverage.

Keywords: Hydraulic ram pump, air chamber, drive pipe, volumetric discharge, efficiency

INTRODUCTION manpower or animal power, which has


Although the price of oil is decreasing largely hindered local economy and social
significantly due to COVID-19 epidemic, development. Therefore, efficient water-
it is to expect that in future energy costs lifting has become an urgent problem to be
will tend to increase. Many farmers are solved [2].
dependent on fuel or electrical power for
pumping water to their fields. An escape A complete mechanical device, which is
from this dependency could be provided used to lifts up water from lower height to
by usage of self-powering water lifting higher height without use of any external
devices [1]. Also, in many parts of the power source called Ram Pump or
world, cultivated lands are situated above Hydraulic Ram Pump (Hydram). The
natural streams. Getting adequate water for Hydraulic Ram Pump (Hydram) takes
drinking and irrigation in such habitats has
energy from unconventional energy source
become the most important task for local
like river, canal, and stream etc. This
residents. Because of high electricity
transmission costs across long distances device mainly uses the kinetic energy of
and difficult transportation across complex the water flowing downward and lifts up
terrains, many people still have no easy the water to a higher height than the
access to electric power or supply-water. primary source. So, this is a water
They have to get water with inefficient pumping device that is powered by falling

HBRP Publication Page 1-8 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 1


Research and Reviews: Journal of Mechanics and Machines
Volume 2 Issue 1

water which works by using the energy of delivery valves [5].


water running down a drive pipe to the The closure of the impulse valve creates
body of the hydraulic ram pump. A a pressure rise in the drive pipe. An air
Hydram or impulse pump is an automatic chamber is used as a medium to change
pumping device which doesn't use the high intermittent pumped flows into
electricity or any other power source [3]. It an uninterrupted stream of flow. The air
works spontaneously with a continuous valves in it allow air into the device to
supply of water. A simple Ram Pump replace the air immersed by the water due
consists of an exhaust valve and a delivery to the high pressure and mixing in the air
valve. These valves are movable and chamber.
obviously non-return valve. The ram unit
has an air vessel and an air valve. The Pumps are one of the oldest machines
operating cycle of an automobile hydraulic among of them. They were used in several
ram pump system may be idealized by regions such as ancient Egypt, China,
consideration of three distinct phases (a) India, Greece and Rome. Today,
acceleration (b) pumping and (c) recoil [4]. pumps are the second most commonly
The operation is said to be an used industrial machine after the electric
intermittent operation due to the cyclic motors [6].
opening and closing of the impulse and

Fig. 1: Schematic Diagram of Hydraulic Ram Pump.

The first of this kind of pumps were force force pump which also known to the
pumps and that a pump used by the Greeks Romans are now preserved in the British
in 300 B.C incorporated an air vessel as museum. But use of this pump was
the earliest known example. The use of evidently lost in recent century at the end
this device was discontinued in the of the Roman Empire [3].
middle-ages and again revived in the
sixteenth century when a German The aims of the present study are to
translation of the Greek work identifying investigate the performance and
the pump was published. The most former effectiveness of hydraulic ram pump
pump to be used was the hand pump. More towards discharges and efficiency for
advanced pumps were the double cylinder different drive pipe lengths.

HBRP Publication Page 1-8 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 2


Research and Reviews: Journal of Mechanics and Machines
Volume 2 Issue 1

Fig. 2: Components of the Hydraulic Ram Pump [7].

WORKING PRINCIPLE spontaneously and after a moment it will


When velocity of water flow is low against be closed. But check valve or delivery
waste valve, water can easily discharge valve works inversely. When velocity of
through it. But, when velocity is high then water is high enough, then valve is open,
drag force of water against waste valve is because it is a one way valve.
too high, so that valve cannot work

Fig. 3: Hydraulic Ram Pump Layout.

But when, velocity deceases, then valve will be open and water lift up into air
starts to close. At the starting of an chamber and compress the air inside of
operation, water has low velocity but due chamber. Due to compression, kinetic
to constant gravitational acceleration, energy of water converts to pressure
velocity increases as time increases. After energy, this pressure energy try to push
a certain time, velocity of water will be back water but check valve is non-return
more than threshold value of waste valve, valve, so water back out by delivery pipe.
and then waste valve may acts as closed
valve. Due to closure of waste valve, water THEORY AND DESIGN ANALYSIS
hammer blow is created, which applied Hydraulic ram pump is an automatic
force on check valve. So, that check valve device which generally uses gravitational

HBRP Publication Page 1-8 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 3


Research and Reviews: Journal of Mechanics and Machines
Volume 2 Issue 1

energy. It converts potential energy of The exit pressure which is much greater
stored water into kinetic energy and lifts than that of the inlet at a point is given by
the water to a required height, which is the equation (8).
more than initial storage height. Water (8)
which will be at one hydraulic head flow
Equation (9) represents the power
into a higher hydraulic head. It basically
developed by the hydraulic ram.
uses water hammering effect in order to
(9)
develop the pressure.
Equation (10) represents the hydraulic
pump efficiency.
There is a sudden stoppage of the flow
of water in a pipe which creates a very (10)
high-pressure surge. Equation (1) shows
the total discharge of the fluid from the As an important component of Hydraulic
drive pipe [3]. Ram Pump, the drive pipe must have
ability to sustain at high pressure due to
the closing of the waste valve. To
determine the drive pipe length, the
Due to the gravity affect the fluid flows empirical relationships are used as follow,
inside the pipe with a velocity which is
given by the equation (2). 6H< L <12H (Europe & North America);
L = h + 0.3 (h/H) (Eytelwein);
L = 900 H / (n2 * D) (Russian);
The nature of flow (Laminar, transitional L = 150 < L/ D< 1000 (Calvert);
or turbulent) is determined by using a
dimensionless number which is calculated Where, n is the Number of Beats/min, L is
by using equation (3). drive pipe length, D is drive pipe diameter,
(3) h is delivery head and H is supply head.
According to many researchers for better
Equation (4) represents a mathematical
guidelines, the Calvert’s equation is
relationship given by Blasius to determine
suitable one [8].
frictional factor f with the use of
dimensionless number.
For Air chamber, it is recommended that
(4) the volume of the air chamber should be
Darcy-Wersbach equation which is shown around hundred times the volume of water
in equation (5) used to evaluate the loss in delivered per cycle. Experiments with
the head for fluid flow in pipes. different sizes indicate that the air valve
size has negligible effect on an operation.
Head Loss ( ) (5) A small hole is sufficient, if it may be less
Fluid which is present accelerates enough than one millimeter. The flow area through
to close the waste valve this is due to the the waste valve should equal to or exceed
drag and the pressure in the water which the cross-sectional area of the drive pipe to
equals the waste valve weight. Equation avoid "chocking" of the flow. For delivery
(6) represents the drag force. (Check) valve operation, it is
( ) (6) recommended that the water delivery
Equation (7) represents the force that through this valve should be 1.45 cm2 of
accelerates the fluid which is given by area for every liter of water. With simple
weighted impulse valves, the supply head
( ) (7) should not exceed limit of four meters,
otherwise the valve will be closing very

HBRP Publication Page 1-8 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 4


Research and Reviews: Journal of Mechanics and Machines
Volume 2 Issue 1

rapidly and frequently, so no useful work We know, discharge through drive


will be achieved. In that case, the valve pipe, = × ×L
should be assisted by a spring to regulate
its closure. 3.1416
⁄ .
FABRICATION AND
PERFORMANCE TESTING By, volumetric discharge
A hydraulic ram pump was designed and

fabricated using PVC and fittings which is
locally, reliable and not expensive shown
in Figure 4-6. The performance test was So, Efficiency,
conducted in the fabricated test rig shown
in figure 4-6. The outcomes of the
performance test are as follow,
When drive pipe length, L = 0.1m
Then, speed of diaphragm, n =
94 ⁄
We know, discharge through drive
pipe, = × ×L
3.1416
⁄ .

By, volumetric discharge


So, Efficiency, Fig. 5: Hydraulic Ram Pump Construction


at Drive Pipe Length, L = 0.35 m.

When drive pipe length, L = 0.52m


Then, speed of diaphragm,

We know, discharge through drive
pipe, = × ×L
3.1416
⁄ .

By, volumetric discharge



Fig. 4: Hydraulic Ram Pump Construction
at Drive Pipe Length, L = 0.10 m.
So, Efficiency,
When drive pipe length, L = 0.35m
Then, speed of diaphragm,

HBRP Publication Page 1-8 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 5


Research and Reviews: Journal of Mechanics and Machines
Volume 2 Issue 1

Discharge slightly increases though it is


not up to the mark. From calculation it is
observed that, at L = 0.1m, no. of
revolution is ⁄ , in fact a
cycle completed in a very short time
(0.638sec). So, operation is too quickly,
the rate of discharge of water through
waste valve is increases but it has negative
impact on efficiency. Less pressure
Fig. 6: Hydraulic Ram Pump Construction introduce to air chamber, so less water lifts
at Drive Pipe Length, L = 0.52 m. up through delivery pipe, hence efficiency
of ramp pump is not up to the mark. While
Results and Discussion drive pipe length is increasing then its
From graph Drive pipe discharge vs drive output performance is increases, because
pipe length, it is observed that, for L = water takes much time than short length
0.1m, drive pipe discharge is, for decreasing through waste valve, so
good amount of water lifts up through the
⁄ When drive pipe
check valve in proportion with waste valve
decreases. But when drive pipe is too long
length increases to, L = 0.35m, then drive (L = 0.52m) then efficiency of ram pump
pipe discharge decreases to is decreases due to decreasing delivery
⁄ . From figure slope tends to discharge, though waste valve discharge is
better than previous (L = 0.35m)
downward direction. At length, L = observation.
0.52m. ⁄ .

0.001
Drive-pipe Discharge , (m3/sec)

0.0008

0.0006

0.0004

0.0002

0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
Drive pipe length (m)

Fig. 7: Effect of Drive Pipe Length on Discharge Water through Drive Pipe.

From graph, Volumetric discharge vs difference between drive pipe discharge


Drive pipe length, it is observed that, at L and volumetric discharge is least when
= 0.1m, but drive pipe length = 0. 35m, then efficiency
when length increases its discharge of ram pump is the highest than other two
decreases simultaneously. But the observations and cyclic time is quite good.

HBRP Publication Page 1-8 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 6


Research and Reviews: Journal of Mechanics and Machines
Volume 2 Issue 1

When length = 0.52m, its delivery pipe through waste valve and air chamber feels
discharge reaches at lowest value rather less pressure by upcoming air through
than other two observation, because of check valve and thereby efficiency of ram
cyclic time of ram pump is too long that pump is again decreasing.
means water takes long time to discharge

0.00025
Volumetric Discharge (m3/sec)

0.0002

0.00015

0.0001

0.00005

0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
Drive pipe length (m)

Fig. 8: Effect of Drive Pipe Length on Volumetric Discharge for Hydraulic Ram Pump.

From graph, Efficiency vs Drive pipe so, operation occurs too slowly .That’s
length, from calculation it is observed that, why efficiency affected by this length
at L = 0.1m, no. of revolution .But, at L = 0.35m, then cyclic time is
is ⁄ , in fact a cycle 1.5789sec, then volumetric discharge is
completed in a very short time (0.638sec). greater than first observation but drive
So, operation is too quickly, that effects on pipe discharge decreases greatly. So,
output performance, efficiency is too bad. efficiency of the ram pump increases to
Again, when drive pipe length is too large 46.32%, which is better than other two
(L = 0.52m), then cyclic time is 2.0683sec. observations.

60
50
Efficiency (%)

40
30
20
10
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
Drive pipe length (m)

Fig. 9: Effect of Drive Pipe Length on Efficiency for Hydraulic Ram Pump.

HBRP Publication Page 1-8 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 7


Research and Reviews: Journal of Mechanics and Machines
Volume 2 Issue 1

CONCLUSION 3. Sampath S.S., et al. Estimation of


From graphical analysis of different power and efficiency of Hydraulic
performance parameters (Drive pipe Ram Pump with Re-circulation
discharge, volumetric discharge, and system. International Journal of
efficiency) along with drive pipe length, it Computer–aided Mechanical Design
is observed that, hydraulic ram pump and Implementation. 2015, 1(1), 7-
performance is strongly dependent on 18p.
drive pipe length. For a satisfying output 4. Young B.W. Design of Hydraulic
performance, Drive pipe length must be Ram Pump Systems. Proceedings of
calculative. the Institution of Mechanical
Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power
So, it is recommended that, before and Energy. 1995. 209(3), 313-322p.
installation of a hydraulic ram pump, it is 5. Mohammed S.N. Design and
need to concern about the appropriate Construction of a Hydraulic Ram
drive pump length for getting better output Pump. Leonardo Electronic Journal of
performance. From above observation, it is Practices and Technologies. 2007, 11,
quite easy to reach a conclusion that ram 59-70p.
pump cyclic operation time should 6. Sheikh S. Design Methodology for
between 1.5 to 2 sec. Hydraulic Ram Pump (HYDRAM).
International Journal of Mechanical
REFERENCE Engineering and Robotic Research.
1. Inthachot M., Saehaeng S., Max J.F.J., 2013, 2(4), 170-175p.
Müller J., Spreer W. Hydraulic Ram 7. Fatahi-alkouhi R., Lashkar-ara B.,
Pumps for Irrigation in Northern Keramat A. Determine the Efficiency
Thailand. Agriculture and Agricultural of Hydraulic Ram-Pumps. Soil
Science Procedia. 2015, 5, p. 107-114. Structure Interaction Journal (SSIJ).
2. Guo X., Li J., Yang K., et al. Optimal 2018, 3, 54-61p. ISSN: 2645-4319.
design and performance analysis of 8. Balgude R.D., Rupanavar S.P., et al.
hydraulic ram pump system. Proc I Designing of Hydraulic Ram Pump.
Mech E Part A: J Power and Energy. International Journal of Engineering
2018, 1–15p. and Computer Science. 2015, 4(5),
11966-11971p. ISSN: 2319-7242.

HBRP Publication Page 1-8 2020. All Rights Reserved Page 8

You might also like