Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An Investigation On Fire Protection and
An Investigation On Fire Protection and
Sonya Afrin
Assistant Professor, Department of architecture
Stamford University Bangladesh
744, Satmosjid Road, Dhanmondi Dhaka-1209, Bangladesh
Email:afrinsonia@yahoo.com
Tahmina Ahsan
Assistant Professor, Department of architecture
Stamford University Bangladesh
744, Satmosjid Road, Dhanmondi Dhaka-1209, Bangladesh
Email: tahminaahsan25@yahoo.com
Muhammad Moniruzzaman
Lecturer, Department of architecture
Stamford University Bangladesh
744, Satmosjid Road, Dhanmondi Dhaka-1209, Bangladesh
Email: mzmithun@hotmail.com
ABSTRACT
Schools are not inherently dangerous places in terms of life safety and fire. Indeed there has not been
a single fatality recorded in a school fire during school hours, as far as can be established, in the
whole history of fire record-keeping in Dhaka. Schools are encouraged to adopt a fire safe approach
to the management of their school and to develop emergency management plans to cover the event of
fire or other emergency. Investigating the consideration for fire safety in the design phase of public
and private school facilities in Dhaka indicated that the designer as well as the users should identify
the need of providing the fire safety requirements: fire detection and notification systems; fire
suppression and extinguishing systems and means of egress and evacuation systems. Such Technology
has revolutionized the design of schools. The objective of this paper is to present a study for the
consideration of fire safety during the design stages of school facilities in Dhaka; and to present the
need and development of a standards and guidelines relating to fire safety whereby existing school
facilities can be evaluated for the purpose of identifying and eliminating fire hazards, and meeting the
minimum requirements of current situation.
Keywords: Designed air-conditioned schools; fire hazards; safety measures; awareness of users
01. INTRODUCTION
A fire has broken out in a readymade garment factory in Tejgaon industrial area, Dhaka on Aug 9,
2010 (bdnews24.com).The old Dhaka Nimtoli neighborhoods, where the deadliest blaze in recent
memory claimed 117 lives on 3rd June 2010, are still numb with grief for the dear ones lost. Dense
neighborhoods with narrow streets and unplanned building boom in the capital were the reasons for
the high number of such casualties. There are many buildings with such casualties all across
Bangladesh. The problem is we only focus on a building after it is on fire, not before. This is to urge
every building owner to survey their respective buildings, whether private and public, corporate and
educational, medical and entertainment, residential and industrial, to check the following issues: if fire
has been addressed, whether sufficient preparation has been taken to prevent fire from starting,
whether there is water and other arrangements to fight fire, and most importantly, whether people can
escape from the building to safety. If the above mentioned attributes are absent, it is the responsibility
of every individual to use his position to take the message across to those who will execute the plan.
[Nizamuddin, 2009]
Figure: 01. a. Students playing at junior laboratory school, b. Scholastica school, c. ISD
Keeping students safe is a school's top priority Schools are not inherently dangerous places in terms of
life safety and fire. Schools, especially K-12 facilities, have unique safety issues because of the young
occupants. [Figure: 01].One of the most important aspects of a school is its fire safety system. Well-
functioning fire safety systems help achieve that priority and are essential to a school's daily
operation. In order to achieve a fully integrated and safely operating fire system for school facilities,
staff training and an emergency preparedness plan must be implemented in addition to standard fire
protection measures such as structural fire protection, architectural construction, sprinkler and
standpipe systems, fire alarm, and smoke control systems.
The architect “is responsible for the fire safety layout, traffic, density, population, and organization
of the whole as well as for each individual building involved”. The architect” requires a wide
understanding of the basic principles of fire prevention and protection, and should be conversant with
recent findings and research on the subject”. [Nizamuddin, 2009]
Reasons
On 15th July 2010, “Schools don’t n’t learn from Kumbakonam tragedy”, Justice K. K Sampath
commission, which inquired into the
he Ju
July 16, 2004, Kumbakonam school fire tragedy thathat claimed the
lives of over 80 students, recommended
ended that schools should have more exits and wider er staircases
s to
enable students to escape during emerergencies, several schools in the city are functionin
ing in narrow
buildings and apartments. [Deccan Chro
hronicle on the web]
Figure: 05.E
Eastern Guilford burns, during the fire.
In the high school started in a second nd-floor chemistry classroom that was reported to o be empty. A
teacher spotted the fire, tried to put it out with an extinguisher, and then pulled the alarm
larm as flames
worsened shortly after 2 p.m. No sprink
rinklers existed in the school because they were not required
req at the
time it was opened in 1974, officials sa
said. The attic's design allowed the fire to race into
o the rafters, in
turn heating steel beams to where theyy pupulled away from the walls.
A building becomes more dangerouss when it is air conditioned and covered by glass. ss. Apart from
arson, major causes of school firess ininclude improper handling and storage of flammab mable liquids,
overloaded electrical outlets and excess
essive accumulation of rubbish. Fire risk areas in scho
chools are:
In terms of materials
Combustible materials: Combustible m materials are substances that can be burned to provrovide heat or
power. Flammable liquid vapors and co combustible materials can cause serious accidents in the home.
General: Books, Paper, Cardboard, d, ddisplay areas, carpets, blinds/curtains, desks, plastic
pla chairs,
waste materials, pupils’ clothes, bagss and outdoor clothing.
Main Hall: Foam Gymnasium mats, wooden furniture, Musical Instruments and Seasonal Displays.
Laboratory:
In terms of areas
03. OBJECTIVES
Prevention is the key in eliminating conditions which may contribute to the cause of any fire.
[a] Present a study for the consideration of fire safety during the design stages of school facilities in
Dhaka.
[b] Create awareness to the users [students, faculty, officers, and guardians] for establishing a Fire-
safe and secured environment in the schools.
[c] Emphasize on the lack of standards and guidelines relating to safety and security.
[d] Develop set of standards relating to fire safety whereby existing school facilities can be evaluated
for the purpose of identifying and eliminating fire hazards, and meeting the minimum requirements of
current situation.
04. METHODOLOGY
• Photographic and Observational study to depict the school environment and safety measures.
• Questionnaire survey to understand users [teachers, students, staffs] responses.
• Literature review[books, journal ,articles ,website]
Fires causing loss and damage can occur wherever human activity occurs. Perhaps the most frequent
location for fires is within buildings. These include both domestic and non domestic premises
[Rasbash, 2004] .Schools is not inherently dangerous places in terms of life safety and fire safety.
However, when a fire does happen, it is a traumatic event in the life of a school. So objectives and
requirements of fire safety should be understood. Fire safety objectives are:
01. To protect life
02. To protect property
03. To ensure that a disaster, which has caused the fire safety activity, “must never happen again”.
[ Rasbash, 2004]
For the study purpose five designed AC schools have taken for case studies and those are:
Figure: 09. Manarat Dhaka International School, Gulshan 02, Dhaka,Figure: 10. Oxford International School,
Dhanmondi
The following analysis through observation highlights “MEANS OF ESCAPE” which act as safely
discharge route in times of fire hazards in schools as well as other building types.
ESCAPE PLAN
EXIT DISCHARGE
[1] Exit access: A route from any point in a building to a final exit.
[2] Exit: The termination of an exit ac
access from a building giving direct access to a stre
treet, walkway
or open space and sited to ensure thee rap
rapid dispersal of persons from the vicinity of a buil
uilding so that
they are no longer in danger from fire.
[3] Exit discharge: Open to sky space
[4] Risk area: The area where there is a possibility of fire hazard.
06. FINDINGS
All the designed schools should develop evacuation plan and checklists for a quick and orderly
evacuation thorough assessment of the fire hazards likely to be encountered on route from classrooms
and other activity rooms to safe, open-space areas. Following tables show the findings after field and
questioner surveys of the selected designed schools in terms of evacuation route, placement of exit,
proper utilization of fire fighting equipments and their maintenances [Table 02]. Table 03 points out
the implementation of building code as well as existing situation.
Table 02:Safety measures checklist
School Dhaka
International
International
International
Scholastica
Laboratory
Manarat
Oxford
School
School
School
school
Dhaka
Junior
[ISD]
Safety measures Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes No
01. Fire Risk Assessment No No No No No
02. Effective means of Yes No No No No
escape route
03. Effective assembly Yes Yes Yes Yes No
point[indoor]
04. Effective assembly Yes Yes Yes Yes No
point[out door]
05. Travel path/ escape Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
route free from
obstacles
06. Primary exit Yes Yes No Yes No
07. Secondary/alternate Yes Yes No No No
exit
08. Enclosed staircase No No No No No
09. Elevators No Yes Yes Yes Yes
10 Fire evacuation drill Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
11. Staff fire training Yes No No No No
12. Fire alarm Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
13. Smoke detection Yes Yes No No No
14. Sprinklers No No No No No
15. Fire fighting Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
equipment
16. Fire hose Yes No No No No
17. Fire hydrant Yes No No No No
18. Fire door No No No No No
19. Fire awareness Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
20. Fire compartments No No No No No
21. Water retention Yes No No No
22. Proper use of Signage Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
23. Emergency plan Yes No No No No
display
24. Maintenance of AC, Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Electrical equipment
and wiring
25. First aid boxes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
26. General cleanliness Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Table 03:Comparative findings between existing situation and Building Construction Rules,
2008 [institutional Bidg]
For educational Building Construction Rules ISD SS JLS MIS OIS
Building[B] 2008
[Porishishto-1[bidhi 59(cho)]
Aisle width Width should be 0.9m[2.9’] for 6’-6” 5’-0” 5’-0” 6’-9” 12’-0”
less than 50 users, 1.1[3.6’]m
for more than 50 users and
above 150 users
1.8m[5.9’][06.02]
Min fire Stair 2.0m[6.5’][table 04] 4’-2” 5’-0” 5’-0” 5’-0” 5’-0”
width
Distance to exit 23.0m[75.5’][table 03] 38’-0” 60’-0" 36’-0” 80’-0” 48’-0”
No of exit For 500 users-02 no exit 02 02 none 02 none
For 501 to 1000-03 no exit
Above 1000-04 no exit[12.03]
Emergency exit Within 25m from any point on Present Present Absent Present Absent
a floor[13]
Necessary One extinguishers 450m2,two Present Present Present Present Present
number of fire extinguishers per floor
extinguishers
[ISD: International School Dhaka, SS: Scholastica School, JLS: Junior Laboratory School, MIS: Manarat
Dhaka International School,OIS: Oxford International School]
Table 04: Existing fire safety provisions are adequate or need improvement
Schools Adequate or Need improvement Necessary action to control the Risk
Adequate Among the five designed school, ISD have taken
better fire safety measures. For fire prevention
International School
Figure: 18
Need improvement Each lab has smoke detector and fire extinguishes.
In front of the lab area a lift without door locks. So
if fire takes place cause of lift there is no way out.
As in front of the lift a stair is there a proper should
be constructed. [Figure: 19]
Scholastica
School
Figure: 19
Needs improvement Each floor has two extinguishers in the corridor.
Lift open on landing of a main stair. [Figure: 20] So
must accommodate a fire stair which will act as an
emergency exit.
Laboratory School
Figure: 20
Need improvement Every lab has fire extinguisher but not in proper
Manarat International
Figure: 21
Need improvement Every lab has fire extinguisher and school have fire
International
Figure: 22
07. RECOMMENDATIONS
• Fire Awareness
• In Case of Emergency: Fire Safety in Schools Maintenance is Key
• Emergency plan and fire notices
• Fire safety training
• Choose the Right Design Team
• Responsibility of Users, Professionals and concerned institution.
• Evaluation of fire code
• Fire Safety and Design Guidelines for Schools
Fire Awareness
• Fire Awareness Day: Inform and educate our community to improve awareness of fire safety
matters.
• Giving demonstrations and instructions to help people get a better understanding of safety matters
• Increases Situational Awareness during Fires
Consequent to the Kumbakonam fire tragedy, an awareness programme was conducted at St. Thomas
Matric H.S. School, Broadway. Rajesh Khanna, district fire officer, along with his team staged a
demonstration on averting accidents caused by fire. [Figure: 23] He explained the various ways in
which victims can be taken to safety in the event of a fire. Various methods of extinguishing fire were
also demonstrated by a mock drill.
There should be two ways out of every area of the school. If the primary exit is blocked by smoke
or fire, the user can use second exit. Emergency/ escape plan help to quickly identify users’ location
and direct those to all emergency exits.
Figure: 24 Escape plan
Students/Teachers/Staff training
All the Members of a school should also be given training in:
• The operation of the fire alarm control panel
• The procedure for alerting the fire service
• The location of fire fighting equipment
• The use of fire fighting equipment
• The arrangements for the safe evacuation of disabled staff and pupils
The training will help the users to gain knowledge on six cores: fundamental of fire protection, fire
protection system, fire behavior and combustion, water supply, building construction for fire
protection and fire prevention.
REFERENCES:
Books:
Billington M. J, Copping Alex, Ferguson Anthony, 2002, “Means of Escape from Fire”, ISBN: 978-0-
632-03203-7, Blackwell Science Ltd, chapter 01, pg 03
Rasbash D, Ramachandran G, Kandola B, Watts J, Law M, 2004, “Evaluation of Fire Safety”, ISBN:
978-0-471-49382-2, John Wiley and Sons Ltd, England, chapter 01, pg 04
W. Klinoff Robert, 2006, “Introduction to fire protection”, ISBN 0-7668-4958-9, chapter 04, pg-85
Ahmed N. (2009) Designing for fire safety: Case study Dhaka IV, The Daily star, 2009-04-18.
Ahmed N. (2009) Roundtable on 'Fire Safety in our Buildings’, jointly organized by The Daily Star
and Institute of Architects Bangladesh (IAB), Sunday May 3, 2009.
Karim Elita (2009),”a blazing problem”, Star weekend magazine, Vol.08 Issue 64, April 03, 2009
Srinivasan.G (2004). 87 children die in school fire. “THE HINDU”, online edition of India's National
Newspaper Saturday, Jul 17, 2004
St. Thomas Matric H.S. School, Broadway, “THE HINDU”, online edition of India's National
Newspaper Saturday, Friday, Jan 07, 2005
Townsend J.S Eric, Fernandez Jennifer, Killian Joe (2006) Title: Fire destroys Eastern Guilford High
School, ‘we’re worried now... what happens next?’ November 2, 2006, Paper: Greensboro News &
Record (NC).