Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Educational Journeys, Struggles and Ethnic Identity: The Impact of State Schooling On Muslim Hui in Rural China 1st Edition Xinyi Wu (Auth.)
Educational Journeys, Struggles and Ethnic Identity: The Impact of State Schooling On Muslim Hui in Rural China 1st Edition Xinyi Wu (Auth.)
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-state-schooling-and-
identity-diversifying-education-in-europe-1st-edition-kari-
kantasalmi/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-sinews-of-state-power-the-
rise-and-demise-of-the-cohesive-local-state-in-rural-china-1st-
edition-wang/
https://textbookfull.com/product/historic-roots-and-impact-of-
ethnic-uzbeks-on-political-circumstances-in-afghanistan-1st-
edition-nurshod-nurkulov/
https://textbookfull.com/product/hegemonic-transformation-the-
state-laws-and-labour-relations-in-post-socialist-china-1st-
edition-elaine-sio-ieng-hui-auth/
Women s Voices in the Field of Educational Technology
Our Journeys 1st Edition J. Ana Donaldson (Eds.)
https://textbookfull.com/product/women-s-voices-in-the-field-of-
educational-technology-our-journeys-1st-edition-j-ana-donaldson-
eds/
https://textbookfull.com/product/managing-chineseness-identity-
and-ethnic-management-in-singapore-1st-edition-daphnee-lee-auth/
https://textbookfull.com/product/biota-grow-2c-gather-2c-cook-
loucas/
https://textbookfull.com/product/identity-strategies-of-
stateless-ethnic-minority-groups-in-contemporary-poland-ewa-
michna/
https://textbookfull.com/product/japanese-schooling-and-identity-
investment-overseas-exploring-the-cultural-politics-of-
japaneseness-in-singapore-1st-edition-glenn-toh/
Educational Journeys,
Struggles and
Ethnic Identity
The Impact of State Schooling on
Muslim Hui in Rural China
X I NYI WU
Palgrave Studies on
Chinese Education in a
Global Perspective
Palgrave Studies on Chinese Education
in a Global Perspective
Series editor
Fred Dervin
Department of Teacher Education
University of Helsinki
Helsinki, Finland
Xiangyun Du
Confucius Institute
Aalborg University
Aalborg, Denmark
“This remarkable volume offers deep insights into the lives of children from the
Hui minority in China, a unique Islamic group of over ten million with their own
autonomous region in China’s northwest. Extensive field work using critical eth-
nography in an impoverished southern county of Ningxia highlights the dilemmas
they face between state schooling and religious education. As both insider and
outsider, the author depicts their struggles in ways that are both vivid and
authentic.”
—Ruth Hayhoe
University of Toronto, Canada
The transformation of China into a global super-power is often attributed
to the country’s robust education system and this series seeks to provide a
comprehensive, in-depth understanding of the development of Chinese
education on a global scale. The books in this series will analyze and prob-
lematize the revolutions, reforms, innovations and transformations of
Chinese education that are often misunderstood or misrepresented beyond
its own borders and will examine the changes in Chinese education over
the past 30 years and the issues as well as challenges that the future of
Chinese education faces. For more information or to submit a proposal
please contact Eleanor Christie (eleanor.christie@palgrave.com)
Educational Journeys,
Struggles and Ethnic
Identity
The Impact of State Schooling on
Muslim Hui in Rural China
Xinyi Wu
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, PA, USA
This book examines how state schooling in China has economically, cul-
turally, and ideologically impacted and gradually transformed a traditional
Muslim Hui village in rural northwestern China. By discussing the inter-
pretation and appropriation of dominant educational discourse of “qual-
ity” in the rural context, it illustrates the dichotomies of poverty and
prosperity, civility and uncivility, and religiosity and secularity as they are
perceived and understood by teachers, parents, and students. Based on an
original ethnographic research conducted in a secondary school, it further
touches upon Muslim Hui students’ negotiations of filial, rural, and eth-
noreligious identities when they struggle to seek a life of their own in the
educational journey to prosperity.
The book captures the changing rural–urban dynamic as state school-
ing continues to guide local formal educational activities, as well as creat-
ing tension and confusion for both teachers and parents. It also introduces
audiences to multiple ways in which Muslim Hui students construct and
negotiate identities through state schooling, especially the educational
heterogeneity experienced by various Muslim youths, as more Muslim
Hui parents have developed diverse perceptions of compulsory education.
Most importantly, the book challenges stereotypes about Muslim Hui stu-
dents across China being assimilated into mainstream culture. It demon-
strates how Muslims in some parts of rural northwestern China find ways
to maintain their religion through living, studying, praying, and fulfilling
the five pillars of Islam while being educated with mainstream ideologies
in school. It will be highly relevant to students and researchers in the fields
of education, anthropology, sociology, and religious studies.
v
Prologue
vii
viii PROLOGUE
rural ethnic group that is less known but struggles against poverty while
maintaining the practices of Islamic traditions. State schooling, believed
by the government as a pathway leading to prosperity, is questioned and
challenged by local Muslim Hui students about its promised value of edu-
cation. The dichotomies between mainstream ideologies and Islamic
teachings never cease to shape Muslim Hui students’ heterogeneous expe-
riences, as they manage to construct different educational journals to
prosperity through negotiating their multiple identities.
Acknowledgements
In writing this book, I have benefited enormously from the assistance and
support of many people. My foremost gratitude is to the teachers, stu-
dents, families, and community members in the village and county in
Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region where I conducted my fieldwork. I
want to thank them for giving me the opportunity to listen to their life
stories and experience a new world in their classrooms, at their homes, and
on their roads. I am especially indebted to two local scholars, Jinbao Ma
of The Journal of Muslim Hui Minority Studies and Genming Wang of
Ningxia University, who facilitated my access to the research site and
ensured my safety during my fieldwork. Special thanks also goes to
Professor Huaizhong Yang of Ningxia Social Science Academy for his
mentorship and long-term support of my study. Because of the people’s
hospitality, genuineness, and sincerity, the months of staying in a village
surrounded by barren mountains, blown by sandstorms, and constrained
by water shortages were pleasant and enjoyable. The weekend meals pre-
pared by every family I visited kept me warm and encouraged me to persist
through the bad days.
I would also like to express my gratitude to an outstanding circle of
mentors, colleagues, and friends at University of Minnesota-Twin Cities,
who inspired me to use qualitative inquiry to pursue my scholarly interest
and challenged me in my thought process. My greatest indebtedness goes
to my co-advisors, Dr. Joan DeJaeghere and Dr. Frances Vavrus, whose
stimulating comments and insights constantly illuminated my ideas and
thoughts at different stages of my research and writing. Their encourage-
ment, guidance, and support during the time I was in the field were
xi
xii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
xiii
xiv CONTENTS
Appendices 187
References 197
Index207
List of Figures
xv
CHAPTER 1
The bus carefully passes through and makes its rough turns alongside the
rugged mountains. As soon as the winding road ends, it is broadened up
and leads further to a land of barrenness with small villages remotely scat-
tered where mosques are seen standing in the middle of the harsh land-
scape and nestled at the foot of mountains, far away from the main road
but glittering at passersby with their shiny crescent moons and stars on the
top. Gongbeis, or enshrined tombs, are built magnificently containing the
remains of spiritual Islamic heroes or founders of various sects, stretching
a few blocks in villages; Qingzhen (Halal) restaurants line the streets of
counties and township, decorated with boards written Tasmi in Arabic
scripts that read, “In the name of God, the most gracious, the most merci-
ful.” Images of Al-Masjid Al-Haram, the Sacred Mosque or the Grand
Mosque in the city of Mecca, are hung up on the walls, while Hancan
(non-Halal) restaurants are nearly invisible. Men and women are often
seen in white hats and colorful headscarves on their scooters and bicycles
or driving small trucks and vans. This wide space is called Xihaigu, a name
unknown to many Chinese people, but a place that generations of Muslim
Hui call home. In the past, accessing this heartland of northwestern China
is nearly impossible. Today, it is still not easy to access, even with regular
bus and train schedules and asphalt-paved roads. It requires an approxi-
mate four-hour bus ride from Yinchuan, the capital city of Ningxia
Autonomous Region, or an eight-hour bus ride from Xi’an, the capital city
Fig. 1.1 Houses and Mosques scattered and nestled in a valley of the Xihaigu
region
of Shaanxi, to reach a main county center in the area, and it takes another
hour or more to get to the towns and villages within the county. There is
still no high-speed train stopping by the Guyuan City where the nearest
train station is located; with slow trains occasionally make their stops in
Guyuan, getting from the train station to any parts of county still needs
hours more of traveling (Fig. 1.1).
Xihaigu is a mountainous area in the southern Ningxia autonomous
region. This extended mountainous region is shaped as a turtle, sur-
rounded by Gansu province on the southwest with six counties in Guyuan
city, and Yinchi and Tongxin counties of Wuzhong city of Ningxia.
Located on the Loess Plateau and the Silk Road, it was historically an
important hub for importing and exporting trades, where many Muslim
traders finally settled and integrated into Chinese society. Xihaigu is also
the place where the culture of pastoralism from the north interacted and
integrated with the culture of farming in the central plain. Local farmers
rely heavily on crop farming and livestock husbandry with some house-
1 INTRODUCTION TO EDUCATION FOR RURAL MUSLIM HUI 3
Fig. 1.2 A village mosque standing in the middle of the harsh landscape
but also actively engage in a variety of religious rituals, both at home and
in the community, such as fulfilling five pillars of Islam and observing holi-
days according to the Islamic calendar. As a tradition, Muslim men and
women are required to wear white hats and cover their heads with colorful
headscarves, and they do not take them off except when they go to sleep.
Boys and girls who attend mosque education to learn Koranic texts also
wear white hats and colorful headscarves to show their statuses as Manla,
apprentices of Ahongs (Imams) of mosques. In contrast, people rarely wear
sleeveless shirts, shorts, or skirts, as overexposure of the skin in public is
culturally unacceptable. Although I, as an urban Muslim Hui, was not
expected to dress alike, I was reminded by my local Muslim Hui friends
that I needed to keep long pants and long-sleeved shirts handy in case I
was invited to events at the mosques or casual meetings with local Muslim
Hui. As my local Muslim friends explained, because Muslim Hui is the
majority in the area and they are strict about this dress code for everyone,
one would be criticized for dressing inappropriately regardless of one’s
nationality. To accommodate the Muslim Hui’s needs, markets in the area
MUSLIM HUI IN CHINA, NINGXIA, AND XIHAIGU 7
usually sell all kinds of daily necessities specifically for Muslim Hui, such as
Tangpings for washing purpose (plastic ewers), hats, headscarves, large
water containers, Halal food (rarely available in other parts of China), and
prayer rugs. When people drive from their villages to gather in a large field
for the markets, their various head coverings often create a beautiful scene
to show their uniqueness.
Not only does the traditional clothing distinguish Muslim Hui in the
region from other people residing in rural areas, but regular practice of
Islam also tells them apart. For Muslim Hui, learning Islamic practices is
considered essential for preserving and inheriting Hui culture and tradi-
tions. Education, as a fundamental mechanism, carries much responsibility
for continuing these traditions. Traditionally, Muslim Hui’s education is
religious, and it is carried out both in families and in the mosques. With
religious education at home, Muslim Hui children develop their ethnic
consciousness by following their parents’ religious practices and inheriting
Islamic knowledge from their parents. By attending religious lessons in the
mosques, Muslim Hui children learn how to read Koranic texts and the
basic teachings of Islam. Modern education, or what we call state school-
ing, has not been very attractive to Muslim Hui, as it is perceived to assim-
ilate ethnic minority groups into the Han culture (Hansen, 1999; Kaup,
2000; Mackerras, 1999; Zhu, 2007) and children would lose their eth-
noreligious identity (Gladney, 1991; Lin, 2007).
In addition, Muslim Hui are also regularly engaged in various kinds of
activities to express their ethnoreligious identity. Celebrating Islamic festi-
vals is one of the major events Muslim Hui grandly observe and collec-
tively participate in, as opposed to celebrating Chinese national holidays,
during which they rarely give each other greetings. Local Muslim Hui
employees with government appointments are also given days off to
observe Islamic holidays; and some Muslim Hui families who have
migrated to other cities usually travel back to celebrate, such as Shangfen,
or visiting ancestors’ tombs. Although Muslim Hui are granted a few days
off for state-recognized national holidays, they only take advantage of
these days to rest and finish family chores. For instance, when some
national holidays fall onto the crop harvest season, Muslim Hui parents
have their children help finish the work on the farms. In a word, Islamic
holidays play an indispensable role in reinforcing religious education.
Zanshengjie, the Eid al-adha or the Feast of Sacrifice, an important
Islamic festival, is also widely observed throughout the region. Muslim
Hui students who attend state schooling usually receive a day off to
8 1 INTRODUCTION TO EDUCATION FOR RURAL MUSLIM HUI
prayer held every Friday. Muslims who have jobs do not usually pray five
times a day due to the conflict of work and prayer schedules, but they
generally attend Zhuma once a week. Local mosques can be fully packed
with crowds, and mosques with facilities for female Muslims, mostly in
large towns, also attract large numbers of female Muslim Hui. Cars are
seen parked randomly on the street, and nobody seems to care about
whether the cars are blocking the roads. Public shower services are closed
for a few hours to the general public but reserved for worshippers prior to
Zhuma. The purpose of such closure is to ensure that as many Muslims as
possible can make Wudu, or cleaning any impurities of their bodies by
washing their hands, mouth, throat, nose, ears, arms up to the elbow, and
feet. However, among these large masses of local people, few Muslim
youths could attend it because the school schedule does not accommodate
the prayer schedule, even though they are taught to pray and attend
Zhuma from nine years old.
While prayers are widely practiced in the community, Chaohezi in the
local language or the pilgrimage to Mecca is only fulfilled by relatively
affluent Muslims because it usually costs a local Muslim his or her life sav-
ings to complete this fifth pillar of Islam. When making ends meet is
already difficult due to consistent poverty, going on such a trip is unthink-
able. As so few people had and would have the opportunity to complete
this once-in-a-lifetime event, Chaohezi is more than an individual fulfill-
ment of fifth pillar—it is a community celebration of blessings brought
back by local Muslim Hajjis who have successfully completed the pilgrim-
age to Mecca. Therefore, the return of Hajjis is one of the grandest rituals
every year for the local community. Muslim Hui children and youths are
usually brought or asked by their parents to join the celebration. On the
day of Hajjs’ return, people as old as 80 and as young as babies in their
mothers’ arms line up on the side of the road, anxiously waiting for cars
and vans transporting Hajjs to arrive. The cars and vans are decorated with
red signs reading “Welcome Hajji” on their dashboards. Hajjis, usually
the elderly, wearing garlands of red flowers, step out of cars and vans and
stroll down the road to greet crowds. Local people receive blessings by
being touched by Hajjs and firmly shaking their hands. The ritual contin-
ues, as Hajjis go to other neighboring villages. An elder Muslim Hui once
expressed his admiration for Hajjs, since it was too expensive for him to
go. After Hajjs return, they still need to sacrifice a cow for more than
10,000 RMB ($1500 USD) and share with the villagers. Thus, joining the
celebration of Hajjs’ return gives local Muslim Hui blessings that they
10 1 INTRODUCTION TO EDUCATION FOR RURAL MUSLIM HUI
look forward to but are not able to receive in person. Attending the cele-
bration, the younger generation of Muslim Hui learn about Islamic tradi-
tions and keep their wish to fulfill the most challenging pillar of Islam.
Actively practicing five pillars of Islam has played a critical role in enforc-
ing learning and teaching about the Islamic religion, as an essential com-
ponent of their everyday life. A strict observance of consuming Halal food
is also considered as a way that local Muslim Hui distinguish themselves
from the Han by their dietary restrictions “not eating pork and non-Halal
food.” Non-Halal food includes but is not limited to food that is prepared
by Han members of the community, cooked by cookware and cooking
utensils used to cook non-Halal food, and food not prepared in an appro-
priate religious way or prepared clean. Eating non-Halal food is perceived
as wrong, thus expecting and enforcing this strict observance would con-
tinue when young Muslim Hui go to college in other cities dominated by
Han. When Halal food is unavailable, Muslim Hui are suggested to con-
sume substitutes, such as eggs and fruits, and cook this themselves with
their own cookware and utensils. Water, the most precious resource in the
community, is also separately used by Hui and Han, and Hui would not
drink or use water offered by Han. When I first arrived in the area, some
students asked me if I was Hui or Han, and I was puzzled and did not
understand why this even mattered. Later, a teacher enlightened me,
“When Hui students ask you, they most likely want to find out if it would
be fine for them to borrow water from you whenever it is needed.” As not
everyone is Hui, it is important for the Hui students to find out who are
and are not Hui so that they would not mistakenly consume non-Halal
food.
To many Muslim Hui in Xihaigu, preserving Islamic traditions is as
important as expressing ethnoreligious identity, and endogamous mar-
riage, in this sense, is critical to conserving and inheriting Huiness and
Hui culture. Although intermarriage is allowed, it has to be that a Muslim
boy marries a Han girl; if a Muslim girl decides to marry a Han boy, her
family would generally prohibit it. Muslim Hui believe that if a Muslim
boy marries a non-Muslim girl, she would join the Muslim family, become
a Muslim, and practice Islam together with her husband. On the contrary,
a Muslim girl would eventually stop practicing Islam if she is married to a
Han boy. Such belief is widely accepted by the young Muslim Hui girls, as
they have never thought of marrying Han boys, even when they are in big
cities where very few Muslim Hui boys are available for marriage. During
RELIGIOUS EDUCATION IN XIHAIGU 11
Since both religious education and state schooling are available for stu-
dents to attend, with the former being fundamental and the latter being
mandatory, the dilemma arises when Muslim Hui students need to make
the commitment to attend either or both forms of education. The phrase
Nianjing (literally translated as “read Koranic scriptures”) refers to receiv-
ing religious education, mainly Jingtang education for Muslim children
and youths; and Nianshu (literally translated as “read books”) means
attending state schooling and is the nine years of compulsory education.
Nianjing, as a traditional home-based and community-supported form of
education, is widely accepted as a pathway to learn basic knowledge and
practices of Islam, acquire Hui identity, and fulfill their responsibilities to
inherit and transmit Hui culture. Nianshu, on the contrary, is a modern
form of education that teaches students to acquire skills and knowledge to
adapt to the modern state and mainstream Han culture. In the past,
Nianjing itself seemed to satisfy the spiritual needs of Muslim Hui f amilies,
since the living skills of farming and sedentary pastoralism could be
passed down through families; but nowadays when poverty is persistent,
MUSLIM HUI STUDENTS’ DILEMMAS BETWEEN NIANSHU... 15
Nianjing has become limited in meeting the needs of Muslim Hui society.
Skills that were used for making a living are no longer suitable for tackling
challenges that have emerged from globalization and the knowledge
economy that “demands a large portion of the workforce with a university
education and with access to lifelong learning opportunities” (Brown,
Lauder, & Ashton, 2008, p. 135). For example, migrant workers who
used to be physical laborers need technical and specialized skills to com-
pete in an increasingly competitive job market. Nianshu became an option
for promoting the economic development of the Hui, and Nianjing is
sometimes seen as holding the Muslim Hui back in terms of development
due to its traditional teachings. In the meantime, the concept of Nianjing
goes beyond solely referring to religious education: it also includes teach-
ings of ethnic Hui culture, as Hui are also members of an ethnic group
(Li & Wang, 2003).
The relationship between Nianjing and Nianshu also carries new inter-
pretations. According to Li and Wang (2003), Nianshu is newly advo-
cated among Muslim Hui to be essential to preserving religion because
cultural knowledge gained through Nianshu could help better understand
religion during Nianjing. It is also regarded as a mechanism to educate
Muslim Hui talents who play the critical role of developing the Hui group
and its society. Furthermore, Nianshu also leads to material prosperity,
with which Muslim Hui would become stronger as individuals and as an
ethnic group while maintaining the practice of Nianjing. With Nianshu,
the ethnic Hui group would possess its religious leaders and personnel as
well as the talented in all occupations, including teachers, engineers, doc-
tors, and businessmen, etc.
However, as both the government and some Muslim Hui strive to inte-
grate Nianjing and Niangshu, certain conflicts remain unsolved. Many
Muslim Hui families have not positively recognized the value of Nianshu
since the early 1980s. Seeing no children make it to college in the 1980s
and an approximate 15% graduation rate among Muslim Hui in the mid-
1990s, majority of local Muslim Hui would rather be migrant workers at
earlier age to earn extra money than wait to graduate for potential unem-
ployment. Muslim Hui parents’ long-term preference for Nianjing over
Nianshu also contributes to students’ lack of interest in state schooling
(Lin, 2007). One of the reasons for this preference is that they are afraid
of their children being assimilated into the Han culture if they are educated
in state schooling. Muslim Hui students, similarly, feel unmotivated to
study in a secular learning environment with which they are unfamiliar
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
—Daa’s net! t’jonge … doar lait ’n lekker hoekie wind
hier! Sel d’r bloase hebbe f’murge, toen Ant d’r hier
plukt hept. Se waa’s d’r ook soo meroakels koud, dat ’t
waif hep stoan bibbere aa’s ’n koors hee? Se hep d’r
de heule murrege mit main jas anloope! Op ’t pad
hebbe se d’r aige naskraiuwt: Lamme Krelis! làmme
Krelis!
—Aa’s wai dá’ weertje nou d’r moar houê, riep ouë
Gerrit in ’t voorbij gaan tegen Dirk.
[Inhoud]
IV.
En die Piet! hep d’r nog acht sint moakt! Waa’s d’r
puur ’n meroakel! hoho! aa’s die noar stad gong.…
waa’s ’t alletait ’n kwart meer aa’s Dirk, die krek vaif
sint hoalt!
Ouë Gerrit wist zich niet goed meer te roeren. Dirk gaf
’m eerst na den grootsten worstel, de ontvangen
guldens uit den zak. De Ouë kromp van angst, als ie
’m dronken van den marktdag zag den dorsch
inschommelen, angst dat ie den heelen boel zou
verzopen hebben, of verspeeld. En als ie dan maar ’n
kik gaf, blafte Dirk hem nijdig tegen z’n hielen, dat ie
schrok, en afgebluft loenschte. Piet gaf alles dadelijk,
al gapte ie ’r later weer van weg voor de zuip, maar
Dirk hield de duiten in z’n ijzeren knuisten heet
gevangen.—Dan eindelijk, moest ie na z’n verbluffing
opspelen, schreeuwen, stompen en beuken in
bloedspuw van nijd, en traag ging de klepzak dan
eindelijk open, klefferden de morsige dubbeltjes,
kwartjes en centen naar buiten, naar hèm toe, onder
één grom en snauw. Ging hij natellen dan vloekte Dirk.
„Tel aa’s je je koarsies uitbloast”, hoonde die, en
sarrend liet ie ’m zien de notities, wel wetend, dat ouë
Gerrit toch niet lezen kon, ’n letter zoo groot als ’n
paardekop niet.—
—Gerrit goan d’r bai s’n bulle waif, sain bulle waif!
hoho!