Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chen Aizik M.A Project ישראל - סוריה מנהיגות ברגעי הכרעה
Chen Aizik M.A Project ישראל - סוריה מנהיגות ברגעי הכרעה
M.A
- -
: .
: . .XXXXXXXX
2011
,
.
,
" , . ,
" . , .
,
. ,
. , .
,
" " , ,
" " . , .
, . , ,
.
, MYSAY
. , ,
. ,
, .
, .
, ,
, .
- , , - , : , - - --
,
, - --- , :-
.
- , , . , - : -
, - . - , -- : , . -
, ; - , { .}
-- -
- ,
'
,
, , ,
. ,
.
" ,
, .
. , ,
, .
, , ,
. , ,
.
, , ,
.
, .
, , ," ,
. , ,
- M.A !
:1
.1
1.1
1.2
.1.3
.1
.2
.2
1.4
.2
1.5
:2 -
2.1
2.2
.2
.3
.3
.4
2.3
:3
3.1
3.2
3.3 , -
3.4 -
3.5
.4
.6
.6
.8
.9
.11
.13
:4
.16
4.1 26 1999
4.2
.16
.18
.18
4.4 -
.22
:5 ?
5.1 1999
5.2
.24
.24
.25
5.3
.28
:6
6.1 , 15-16
6.2 - 2000 ?
.29
.29
.36
:7
.43
.47
.50
.51
:1
1.1
:
, ,
.
( ,)Shepherdstown 3- 2000
, -.
,
,
- ( ,1996 ,' .)9,
- 70-
, - ( .)1996 , ,
( )By Proxy . ,
"" ,- ( ;2009 ,' ;1998,
.)1996
,
, "
" ,
.
, '
2000 .
- , "( 1991 ")
.
, 12.01.2000 - .
, "
" ( ;13.01.2000 , ,)2009 ,
.
" , " . ,
.
( )Campbell
) (Campbell, 6791, p.73
,
).(Zartman, 2000
' ( )1974 " :
" 1. ,
, ,
.
1.2 :
:
(?)Shepherdstown
, \ - ,
, :
?
1.3 :
,
, ,
.
1.4 :
( ) , ( ) ,
(
)
(.)Kotter,6771
1.5 :
, ,,
, , , , ,
( )Zartman, 0222
(.)Shepherdstown
1' ( )Kissinger William Zartman. The Timing of Peace Initiatives: Hurting Stalemates :
and Ripe Moments, The Global Review of Ethnopolitics Vol. 1, no. 1, September 2001,p. 8 .
:2
2.1
-
2. ,
,
" " . ,
" "
, (' ;1998 ,;1998 ,
.)2009 ,
, ,1987
, ,
,
, -
,
(' ,1998 , .)55 ,
.
( )Harkabi " ,
,
,
. (
) , ,
" ( ,1990 ,' .)535
,
.
, " "
. , ""
4
.
2.2
" 1987
, "
" " " (',1998 ,
' )56
.
-
, .
.1989 ,
-.
-'
('.)1998 ,
,
, .
2.3
13- ,1992 ,
.
,
, : "
5
".
, ,
,
- .
,
" "
.
,
.
( ;2004 ,.)2005 ,
,
, ,
[(]... ,2007 ,' .)69
, ( )Grinberg
:
,
( ,2007 ,' .)88
, 1992 ,
, ( )Clinton
.
,
.
,
, .
, -
, .
1992-1996
" " (- " ;)1994 " 29( 7-
;)1994 "" (- ,81994 ,)91995
('.)1998 ,
4- 1995 .
1995
, ""
4 . 1967
, ,
.
.
, " " ,
. .
6 ) eyre crowe (1907 - . : M.A
" .
7
() '()
8
" .
9
" .
,
. , ,
.
, . , .
10
:3
3.1
,
. ,
,
.
,
. , ,
" " ,
- (;2008 ,
.)Clinton, 2004; Ross, 2004
" . ,
, '
.
,
"" -.
,
(.)2002 ,
. , -
,
, ,
( ).
,
,
(.)2008 ,
10
: ().
, ,
" ,
.
( )Indyk
, :
(. )2009 ,
- ,
,
, ,
11
.
,
.
, ""
(Amabile,
) 1983, 1988; Amabile, Conti,Coon, Lazenby & Herron, 1996 ,
,
" :- , .-
, .
" " ( ; 2009 ,
,2009 ,' .)36
"
.
" (. )Daoudy, 2008 ;2000 ,
12
11
: , ,
).(Daft, 1997, 1983; Fayol, 1917
12
A Weyrnouth, Lally, Q & A: We Have To Act, Not Just Talk, The Washington Post,
October 31, 1999, p. B1,(Sunday Outlook).
3.2
,
, ' '' .
,
. ,
.
, , '
. ,
.
, ,
. ,
.
,
:
"
. ,
; ,
.
" .
,
".
13
:
" ( ,)15-20/7/1999 .
" " 14.
.
,
,
15
".
13
- () ;23.6.1999, ,
, [
]26-6-1999 , ,
.
14 ()( 7.7.1999 , - , ).
15 '' ().18.6.1999,
3.3 , -
, ( )
16. ,
,
,
" , .
,
,
17
.
" , ,
23 - , . "
.
18
, .
, .
,
. ,
19
.
16
" " :
, , , , .
. ,
,
. , - "",
. , ( "" " -")
. 23 .12.1999, WWW.TIP.CO.IL ( INTERNATIONAL INTERNET NEWSPAPER) .
17 (
" ").
Morris, Nomi, Syria's Situation Shaky as Ailing Assad Grooms Son for Power, The San Diego18
Union- Tribune,December 3, 1999, p. A16.
" , , () .23.7.1999 , -
- (.
19
, (.)2000 ,
, ,
( 20.)2001 ,
). (Clinton,2004,p.911; Ross, 2004
, ,
,
-.
"The Timing of Peace Initiatives: Hurting Stalemates and :
" Ripe Moments ) (Zartman
.
21
.
, ,
.
( (Zartman, 2001 ;2002 , ,
,
, .
, ,
, , ,
. ,
.
, ,
,
.
( ;2009 , ;2009 ,' ;1998 ,Ross, ;2001 ,
)2004 , ,
.
20
11
22
. , ,
.
,
- . ,
(
) , .
" ,
, ,
.
, " (,
,2009' ]...[ )195 ,
" ".
25 ,1998
, 29- 1998 " "
" " .
4 .1967 "
23
,
.
3.4 -
. , ,
, ,
, .
( ;2009 , ;2009 ,.)Ross, 2004 ;2008 ,
24
23 ' .51
24
" " -
, : M.A
" .
11
15- ,1999
, .
, :
.1 ,
25
, , , .
.2 .
26
.3 .
, " "
.
,
, , .
( )Ross THE MISSING PEACE
"" "" .
.
, " "?
" : , ""
( ,2009 ,' .) Ross, 2004,p.499 ;249
" "
, "" ,
"" , ,
" (.)Ross, 2004,p.499
, ,
.
,
" , ( "1923,
.)2009
25
Maoz ,Moshe , "Can Israel And Syria Reach Peace? Obstacles Lessons And Prospects ",
The James A. Baker III Institute For Public Policy Rice University March 2005
26 Eyre Crowe .1907
: M.A " .
12
, " " ,
,
"" , ,
.
,
, .
, ,
? ,
.
:
" , " ()Ross, 2004,p.498
" 2000
(.)Ross, 2004
27
, 1999 .
, " " "
" :
28
. , ( 29,
)Ross, 2004 ;2009 ,
.
3.5
, ,
30
.
27 " 2000
.
28
1923
. 10
().
29
( ).
30
, , .
13
25- 1999
, .
. ,
4 1976 "
31
" .
, ( )Seale -
,
.
,
15 ,
.
, " "
.
4- 1976 . , .
' ,
.Middle East Insight
98 ,98
.
- ,
-
.
(.)2009 ,
,
.
,
( ;2009 ,.)2008 ,
: ,
""
,
. ,
.
, ,
.
31
14
32 ,
( ;2004 , ;2009 , )2009 ,
.
,
.
,
.
.
, ,
" " ( ,2009 ,'
.)251
" " ,
" ".
, ,
,
.
,
, , .-
33
, .
, :
? . ,
" "
(.)Ross, 2004,p.515
,
,
(.)Ross, 2004
, ,
. ( )
( .)2009 ,
,
. .
32
.
33 ,
(.)Ross, 2004,p.515
15
:4
4.1 26 1999
) ,(Nick Rasmussen
.
()Carey Cavanaugh
34
.
26- ,1999 ,
,
(.)Ross, 2004 ;2009 ,
,
, ""
.
.
, ,
"" ,
.
,
. ,
, .
35.
,
. , ,
,
36.
,
.
,
, ,
. , " ,
34
Carey Cavanaugh
-.
35 ,
( ,2009 ,' .)213
36
, , , .
16
. " . ,
, .
, " " ,
": 4 ."?1967
, " 4
"1967 ,
. ,
" " ( .)Ross, 2004,p.769
, .
.
, " " .
,
37
.
" " "" ,
.
. " "
"" " 10
" . " ,
, " (.)Ross, 2004
, , ,
. ,
, .
,
,
. ,
37
) (AMPLIFIERS :
AMPLIFIERS-
.
.
) (Gladstein, 1984 Schmidt & Kochan, 1972:
Jehn, K. & Bendersky, C (2003). Intragroup conflict in organizations: A contingency perspective on
intragroup conflict and group performance, Academy of Management Journal; Apr 2001the conflictoutcome relationship. Research of Organizational Behavior, 25: 187-242
17
,
"" .
4.2
,
. , -
.
,
.)Ross, 2004( .
38
,
. 400-
( ) .
39
,
. " :
" )Ross, 2004,p.706( 40
.
,
.
" -
" .
, ,
.1999
, .
,
(.)2009 ,
38
,
, ,
.
39 ' :58 THE MISSING PEACE :
( ,2004 ,' .)522
40
" " .
18
41
15 - ,1999
, (,
)Ross, 2004 ;2009 ,
.
. 42
43.
,
(.)Ross, 2004
, .
,
,
.
, .
, ,
4 ,1967 "
, ".
" :
.
"(;Ross, 2004
.)Daoudy, 2008
,
. , " .
[ ]...
.
4 1996 ( "1923,
,2009' .)252 .
41 Bethesda " -" , .
, [.]...
42 ( ,2009 ,' .)523
43
() , . ,
. .
19
,1923
- 1923 .
44
1991 .
,
.
, .
.
10
45
.
,
-
- ,
4- ,1996
.
" "
- ,
" "
(.)Ross, 2004
46
.
" , ?".
1923 10-
, .
, ,
, : ,
,
?
44 .1991
45
10 1923 4 1967 ,
() ( 1949
,... .).... - ,1923
. 1948- .
" 46 " " " ,
Fisher, Roger., and Ury, William.. Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement :
Without Giving In. Penguin Books, 1991 .
21
.
, 50- ,
,
, (.)Ross, 2004
, 50 ,
, .
,
. 50
.
, "
" ,
" : " ( )Peace Park
, .
,
, ,win-win -
.
47
.
.
. ,
, .
48
.
, 18- 1999
,
.
.
50 ,
,
4- 1967
.
47
21
- , :
,
. ,
, .,
- (.)Ross, 2004
4.4 -
- ,
,1999
" " ,
1998
.
, 4 . 1967
,
,
.
? 4
,1967
,
(.)Ross, 2004
.
4 - 1996
,
.
-
.
- ,
(.)Ross, 2004, p.528
-
;
22
,
49
, 4 1967
.
" ".
- ,
,
()Ross, 2004
, -
.
" "
1923 4- .1976
-
, -
.
,
, .
, - " "
,
( .)Ross, 2004-
,
.
, " ".
,
( ;2009 ,2009 ,
;. (Ross, 2004
- .
, .
-,
,
(.)Ross, 2004
49
4- 1967 .1923
23
OSCE - ,
, ,
,
. ,
.
:5 ?
5.1 - 1999
3- ,
.
( )Shock , "
".
, ,
( ) ""
, .
50. .
51
.
,
"
" .
( )Shock
(.(Ross, 2004; 2009 ,
, ,
- . ,
.
50
51
, .
, .
24
,
. , " ",
, ,
, . ,
.
, " ," ,
, " "
" " 52.
,
" -" ,
-
,
(.(Ross, 2004;2009 ,
: " ,
,
""(" . ,2009 ,' .)210
,
, " "
" " ( ,2009,' .)210 ,
,
53
, "" ,
5.2 ,
,
7- ,1999
,
. - .
(Ross, ;2009 ,
.)2004. p,536
52 ' -
. : ," . " . ,13.08.2011 ,' .33
53
( )2009' .215
25
,
,
.
.
- .
.
,
.
,
54.
, : (Clinton, ;2009 ,
.)2004
55
, ,
, .
; ,,
" " ( ,2009 ,' .)Ross, 2004 ;247
, : 4
1967 ? .
,
,
.
" ,
, [ ]... "
( ,2009 ,' .)247
.
,
""
,
: -?
54
?
55
" , , ()23.7.1999 ,
26
" " ,
"" .
,
, .
- , ,
,
56
.
- ,
" , "
" : !".
; , ,
.
? ,
" : ,
,
, .
" ( ,2009 ,' .)249
, ,
, ,
.
,
. , " , "
).(Clinton, 2004; Ross, 2004
-
, ,
.- ,
( .)Ross, 2004
, -
" : "
( ,)Ross, 2004,p.543
( ,2009 ,' .)215
56 ' ,1974-
( ,2009 ,' ; 248 ,2002 ,' )64 , -
.
27
,
.
,
. .
, .
, ? ,
" " ,
. ,
, ,
, ()
.
.
5.3
8- .
, .
,
.
( )2002 , "
.
, ,
" " . "
20 . " .,
,
" " ,
(,2002 ,
' .)68
" : , ,
? .
" . " :
57
" ( ,2002 ,' .)69
57
. , . ,.05.09.2002 ,
http://www.7th-day.co.il/tzahal/yispor.htm .62.21.0266 :.20:60 :
28
,
, ,
58
.
.
60% 40% .
. ,
.
.
,
,
59
(.)Ross, 2004 ;2009 ,
:6
6.1 , 15-16
:
. ( , , ' ').
. ( , ,
).
. ( ? ,1948 ,1923
,4 ,1949 1967 ?).
,
- 4- .1967
,
.
, " .
.
, .
"" .
Clinton, 2004,p.716 58
59
- () !
29
67 .
" ( ;2009 ,Ross, 2004 ;2009 ,
; )Clinton, 2004 -
,
.
15-16-
, .
,
.
- . -
,
.
.
,
. , ,
. "
" ( ,)2002 , .
,
. , ,
. ,
.
- ,
4 ,1996 ,
( ,2009 ,' Ross, ;257
.)2004,p.539
60
" .
. []...
[]... " - ,
,
( ,2009 ,' .)219
-
.
60
( .)2009 : " , , .
31
61,
.
" " ,
.
, , .
- . "
" ( ,2009 ,'
62
61
- Robert Malley .
62
, .
63 : , , , .
: - , , , , .
: , .
64
\ ,
.
31
- " : .
, .
,
" (.)2009 ,
- 4 67
" ,67 , ,
" (,
;2009,
;2009
.1999
32
.
\ , 4- 1967
- .
, .
,
,
( .(Ross, 2004 , ,
: ,
4- 1967 ,1923
.
4- ,
.
.
- .
-
. - ,
.
, .
( ,2009 ,' " .)259
. ,
" , ( .)2009 ,
66
, 3-
.2000
,
( ,2009 ,' ,)258-259
.
,
" ,"
, : 10-
, 12-
66
33
, 13-
(.)Ross, 2004, p.546
67,
,
.-
,
, F22-
.
, ,
68. 3 - 1999
,
" , ,
" , .
, , " : ?
?
" : . ,
".
" : ".
" : , ". (,
,2003' )213 (,
69
,2002'.)89 ,
,
.
( .)Ross, 2004 ;2009 ,
: ,
, , ,
.
-
, .
.
67
.
68
, .
69 13 , 1999 ,
" . "
http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Speeches%20by%20Israeli%20leaders/1999/Statement%20to
%20the%20Knesset%20by%20PM%20Barak%20on%20the%20Renewa
34
.
" - "
" ,
" " ( .)2002 , ,
.
19- 1999
,
,
70
: , .
,
.
.
, , .
.
,
).(Clinton, 2004
,
.
71 . :
- ,
,
(.)Ross, 2004
70
72
"
" , ,
. , ,
, " , ".
71 , , , ,.
72
,
( ) , .
35
,
-
15 73,
74
.
,
75.- , ,
(.)Clinton, 2004
,
. "
, ,
, ".
76
":
" 77, "
" " ."1 ,
" " ( ,2002 ,' .)90
? ,
.
.
"How Barak Failed The
" Peace With Syria ,
,
.
73
Dagoni. Ran, US: Golan Heights Evacuation Requires Appropriate Financial Compensation, Globes,
January 4,2000.
Broder, John, Israel and Syria Resuming Search for Major Accord, The New York Times,. January 4 74,
2000, p. Al.
74 ... ' .173 172
75
http://secretary.state.gov/www/statements/1999/991216.html
( 76 ,.)3.1.00 :
77
90- .
36
. , ,
, -
78
.
, "
,
79, ,
.
80
6.2 - 2222 ?
3- ,2000
,
-
'.
, ,
. ,
.
,
, " :
[ ]... ,
[ ]...
" ( ,2009 ,' )254 ,
: .
.
,
.
, 1996
"" , " "
( ..)2009 ,
, ;
,
. , ,
78 .
79 Robert Jervis (1976). Perception and Misperception in International Politics. Princeton :
Princeton University Press
80
.)02.26.0226( http://www.mediamonitors.net/tanyairit.html
37
,
, ,
.
,
: , , .
5- 2000
. " (') ,
. ,
.
.
. " 81
.
.
.
,
- .
"
.
, " ( ,2009 ,' .)242
, "
. ,
,
67- ( ,2009 ,'
.)242
, (,2009 ,
' .)263
, .
,
, , " :
? .
82
, " ( ,2009 ,' .)263
81" ".
82
242 "" "" .1967
38
,
, 12:5
.
,
83
, ,
, , 50
4 84.1967 ,
).(Ross, 2004,p.561
,
.
- ,
,
.
. 67
, ( 1923;2009 ,
. (Ross, 2004
-
,
,
. , .
, .
, ,
, .
- , ,
"" .
85
.
39
,
, " "
.
,
(.)Ross, 2004 ;2009 ,
,
. ()
, .
. ,
86
,
,
-
, .
6- 2000 ,
- ,
.
.
.
- 4 ,1967
" , ,
87
".
,
67 1923 10 (
) ,
.1923
- : "
" ,
, (,
;2009 . (Ross, 2004 ;2009 ,
86
41
, - ,
(.)2009 ,
,
88
, .
, ,
89
.
, 7- 2000
.
,
-
.
,
,
. -
90
.
,
"" 4- 1967
91
(.)2009 ,
, ,
.
" ,
4- ,' 67
.
,
" ( ,2009 ,' Ross, ;252
.)2004
9- ,
,
.
92
88
- .
89
.
90 : " " : ,2009 ,' .418
: ,2009 ,' .246-247
91 .1923
92
( ,2009 ,' )268
41
.
, "
: , " , .
" ,
. , ,
, .
.
93
, .
.
, . ,
, , .
.
, .'67
[ ]... ]...[ . .
, .
.
.
" ( ,2009 ,' .)254
.
" .!" " ,
, - "
, ,
.
94
(.)2009 ,
,
"" ( )03.08.2001 " ",
:
,'67
" .
- . - ,
- .
. , , ,
93 .
94
73%
63% " "
( ,2009 ,' .)267
42
-
95
.'67
13- 2000
96
-.
- ,
97
( ,2009 ,' .)267
:7
-
. ,
.
.
,
,
, \
.
, - (
) ,
.
-,
,
, .
,
.
,
.
, ,
95 ,;8.3.01 ,
http://www.7th-day.co.il/mehumot/gorem.htm 25.07.2011 :.00:05 :
96 .2009 , ( )
(
) ' .442
97
' .53 : , ( ,)2009 .' .423-418
43
98 ,
1979
99
, ,.
.
,
, .
, ,
, .
, " :
"1967-1974
,
. ,
, ,
.:
)1 " .1947
)2 .1953
)3 " 1956.
-
,1982
.
"
. " " ,
100
, ".
,
101 ,
98
.
"" () .
" .
- , : ( : -.)2001 ,
99
-" , : ,1973
" ,.125-140 ,2007 ,31 ,
100
" , : ,"1974-1976 () , ,
, ,1984 ,' .314-289
44
" " . ,
,
.
, ,
, ,
, "
".
, ,
1999-2222
,
.
,
.
26 2000' , " "
,
.
- ,
- . ,
102 ,
, .
,
?
,
2002
" " 103 ,
- .
,
, .
101Robert D. Putnam. Diplomacy and Domestic Politics: The Logic of Two-Level Games, :
International Organization, Vol. 42, No. 3 (Summer, 1988), pp. 427-460, Published by: The
MIT Press.
102
.
103
' .55
45
-
.
.
,
,
,
.
, ,
104,
,
,
.
105
,
:
, , , , .
, ,
,
106
.
- , 2006
" ,
,2010 ,
.
,
.
104 : ,
(http://www.nrg.co.il/online/1/ART1/737/853.html , (NRG ,25.05.2008
( ,30.07.2011:)21:24:
105
106
: , , ,
. - ,)21.10.2004 ,
( http://news.walla.co.il/?w=/2971/614610 ,30.07.2011 :.)21:34:
46
, . - , -.2003 ,
, . , : . .2009 ,
- ," . : ,1973
" . ,2007 ,31 ,' .125-140
," . " ,.05.09.2002 ,
- , . : .-.2001 ,
, . , : ,
.2226-1992 :.2007 ,
, .- ..2002 ,
, . :
. : . .2008 ,
, .- ?! . .1996 ,
," . " . () ,M.A
.2005 ,
, . . .2004 ,
47
,) (,"1974-1967 : " . ,
.314-289 ' ,1984 , .
.1998 , .1992-1996 . ,'
.1998 , . . ,
A Weyrnouth, Lally, Q & A: We Have To Act, Not Just Talk, The
Washington Post, ,(Sunday Outlook). October 31, 1999, p. B1.
Daft, Richard .L (1983), Organization theory and design, The West series in
management., West Pub. Co., cop.
Dagoni. Ran, US: Golan Heights Evacuation Requires Appropriate
Financial Compensation, Globes, January 4,2000.
48
Daoudy, Marwa. "A Missed Chance For Peace: Israel And Syria's
Negotiations Over The Golan Heights". Columbia University of New
York. Journal of International Affairs Spring/Summer 2008, vol. 61, no. 2,
.
Fayol, Henri, Administration industrielle et gnrale; prvoyance,
organisation, commandement, coordination, controle, Paris, H. Dunod et E.
Pinat, 1917.
Robert D. Putnam. "Diplomacy and Domestic Politics: The Logic of TwoLevel Games", International Organization, Vol. 42, No. 3 Summer, 1988,
pp. 427-460, Published by: The MIT Press.
49
Ross, Dennis. The Missing Peace: The Inside Story Of The Fight For
Middle East Peace. Farrar, Straus And Giroux, New York, 2004.
http://news.walla.co.il/?w=/2971/614610
.( 23:45 : .10.6.2011 :(
http://www.7th-day.co.il/tzahal/yispor.htm
.) 02:18 : .10.06.2011 :(
http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Speeches%20by%20Israeli%20lea
ders/1999/Statement%20to%20the%20Knesset%20by%20PM%20Barak
%20on%20the%20Renewa
.)22:12 : .21.06.2011 :)
http://secretary.state.gov/www/statements/1999/991216.html
.)00:36 : .22.07.2011 :(
http://www.mediamonitors.net/tanyairit.html
.)18:35 : .25.07.2011 :(
http://www.7th-day.co.il/mehumot/gorem.htm
.)01:11 : .28.07.2011:(
http://www.nrg.co.il/online/1/ART1/737/853.html
.)23:52 : .30.07.2011 :(
http://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-3867822,00.html
.)10:48 : .09.08.2011 :(
51
http://news.walla.co.il/?w=/2971/614610
( .10.08.2011 :.)01:18 :
.1 .
51
52
.2 (
13.21.2221- : ,2229 ,' .)423-418
53
54
55
56
.4 (WIN-WIN :.(2229 ,
57
.5 :1 ( )
' ( .18 :.)2224 ,
58
.6 :2 12
1923 4- .1976
59
.7 :3 .
61
.8 :4 ( ).
61
.9 :5 " ".
62