1

2015

, , "-
"
,
.
" " ;
. ,
,
, .
,
) ,(OSCE
.OSCE-
, .
,

.

.
,
,
. ,
, " " ,
.
, .
.1
, -
1987 :
"
, , ,
, ,
".
, , - ,
.
, - ,
, , ,
. ,
, ,
.

" , , 2016

" .2011-"
"" ,
" "
."
.
, " "
,
.
.. 10) . ,(2013
,. ,. , ,
. . . )"
)( 6749-08-11 .. 17) . .((2013
.
"-" , . ) 9 ,(2014
- . ,
,64
. - ,
, , .
, ,
, , )"
)"( 23751-02-10 . ) 28 .((2014
.
, , ,
,
. ,
. ,
.
, . ' ) 12 ,(2010
, ,
. , ,
.
""
, .
, 4- , ,
,
. 24- ,
20- ,
.
, . ) 27 ,(2014
, -
" " ,
, "- " ,
)" 9612/10 . ) 27
,(2014 .(76

" , , 2016

,
,
.

, ,
"" . , ,
.
, , (1 :
, , ; (2'
, ,2011 ,
" .
.
' ,
.'
, . ,
.
, .
. . ,
, .
, . .
. , .
, ) (
.
, . :
(1 "-" ,
- , ,
- ; (2
, ,
, "" .
2 3- ,
, ,
. , ,
. , ,
"" .
.
" " ,OSCE-
,OSCE-:
" , ,
,
".

, .


" , , 2016

,
.

.
,
,
- .
.2
" " , :
,
.
,
. ,
,
" ,
"
.
,

.
" " ,
:
;
,
, ;

,
;
" "
.
,
, .
, , ,
, "".
.3
" " , ,
, ,

, ,
.

" , , 2016

"- " "" , "

" .
.
. ,
,
.
" " , ,

, , 70--
.80
. .
,
1987- 2011- ,
" ".
" 2011" :
,
. '
'
. , ' '- ,
".
, ,

"".
United States v. Fishman , 13 ) 1990CR-88- .
,(0616 DLJ
, .
, , 11- ,
. , , " " "" ,
," " ' , .
, "
" . "
]."[delusional
" , "
] [ , " " ,
".
,

,50- "
, ,CIA- ,

".

" " ,
" , , 2016

,
.
" " ,
) (APA
) ,[(ASA :
" , , APA- ASA-
" " (...) .
APA- - ,
.80- , APA-
" .APA-
" (...) . APA-
" ,
.1988 APA- " "
, .
-,
(...) . ,APA-" ASA-
-".
:
" ] " " [ ,
"] .
[
,APA-" ,
, " ".
" APA-
, ,
, .
Margaret Singer and Richard Ofshe v. American
,
,.Psychological Association, et al 9 ) 1993CIV. 6082 92 .
,(((LMM
. Margaret Singer et al. v. ,
.American Psychological Association, et al 17 ) 1994-730012 .
,(B "
] [
".
80,000$" " SLAPP- ,

1
.
" ,
" "
, .
1
,
.
, .

" , , 2016

.
.
, ," ,
,

.
"-" ,
"" "- " .
- ,
, .
,
.
, ,- ,
,
, , , ,
.
, , - .
" , ,
, , ,
,
,

".
, . ' ) 12 ,(2010
." , ,
. , , ,
.
, .
34 , - ,
:(
, (2 , .
, ,
.
, " , -
" " :
"" , ,
' .
, ,
,
.
, )
(
) (
.
" , , 2016

, , .
, :
"' ,
. ,
. ,

.
:
" " ,
,
, ,
.
, ,
.
.

. , 10 .2010
" ' '" )
,(129 :
"

, ,
, " ) .(111
, " ,
,
" , .
"
" , "
,
, 9
] [
") . .(118
,
.
, , :
" , '
' ,
-
,
".
, " .
, :
" , , 2016

,
".
, ,

.

,
.
, ,
,
,

.
" " , 15
)""( ,
, ,

.
- , "
" "" "
" ,
.
.
.
" " ,2001
, - ,
.
' 313-4 ,
, , " ,
, " )
, , , , (.
" "
"" . ,223-15-2 ,
, "

,
".
"" .
Le Semaine Juridique 28
,2001 - , ,
,Lille Il-:
" , , , ,

" , , 2016

10

. , . ,
.
.
, ,
, ,
, ,
.
,
. ,
, , ,
? .
, .
,
".
- ".
" 18-29- 2,2005 ',
" :
" .87 , ,
, . -
, , 1309
) ,(2002 '
, 9
) , () 10 , ( ) 11- (
, ]...[
".
, .
- , ,2011
35 , 4-5
. ,
,Neophare- 20 .
, . ,
, .
.
,Justice Actualites ) (ENM :
" 2001 ,
, . ,
) "- "" , "
'( , . ,
3
".

2
E/CN.4/2006/5/Add.4, 8 .2006

3
,Justice Actualites ,8 . ,2013' .42

" , , 2016

11

, " "
,
.
"-" "-" , ,
,
, ,
. "-" ,
"-" ,
.
.4
" " ,
,
.
:

,

. ,


.
" " ,

, " , OSCE- .

, 14 :1948
" ... , , , ;
;
".
, " , ,"-
, , ,
) ".' 55' (.
.1
' 18 , .
"
, ,22 . ,1 :18
" 18 ,- ,
. "" "-" . 18

. ,

" , , 2016

12

, ,
".
"
" )
, '( "
" .

,
, ,
.
, ' ," 2006 ,
""
) 26 .(A/HRC/4/21 ,2006
,d'Almeida Ribeiro , "
, , ,
] , [ .
, ,
, . ,
" ,E/CN.4/1990/46) . .(110
,Adelfattah Amor , "
, , , .
. ,
. , ,
? ) ,E/CN.4/1997/91 .(95
,
,
,,
, .
:
" , ,
22 . ' ,
.
;
, 3 18
,CCPR/C/SR.1166) ". .(48
Adelfattah Amor" 1997 . ,
" ,
,
" ,E/CN,4/1997/91) . ] (99 [
, "" "
" , .
,
.
.

" , , 2016

13

,Heiner Bielefeldt "

" 5 (A/69/261) :2015
(...) .61 , ,
"" ,
, .
, ,
, .
.62 ,
, , .
, .
, ,
, .

. ,
.
, ,

" ] [
"- "
,
, .
, , .
.2 OSCE-
.,
OSCE-
.
"- " ,
.

,
.
OSCE- ,
, "
".
, ,
"- "
(CDL-AD(2014)023) :
.1 .
. ,
,
,
. , , ,
. ,

" , , 2016

14

,
] . [
, "" ,
"" "-":
.2 "" . ""
)""" , " '( .
, . ,
,
.
. , ,
, . , ""
. ,

".
, ,
, ,OSCE- ,
"
" , .
.3
, 137
"-" " .1996
" ,2005- "
:
" ,
-
" ,
".
, "
,

") . (112
, "
) ".1996-
(114
) MIVILUDES -
( ,
"" ,
.
"" ,
-
"".
17 ,2014 , , ,MIVILUDES
" " " ,
" , , 2016

15

,
.
" ,
,
" , MIVILUDES- "- ".
" ,
, / " ,
" , /
, ,
" " ".
"
" " "
.
" "
, ) 9 ( -
) 14 ( . ,
"" ,
, .
) ( ,
(2014) 1992:
" .4 .
' 9-
14 .
)(...
.9
,
, ,
, ,
,

".
.
MIVILUDES "
"MIVILUDES " ,
.
2013 , MIVILUDES
) -
( MIVILUDES-
" ,
4
,MIVILUDES " , ".

4
Justice Actualites ,8 . ,2013' .50

" , , 2016

16

,

.
.5
"" ,
:
:.
' 14 ,
,
, ,
.
" ,
,2001
,
,
25-25 , ;2002
" , "
, , 27 , 7
.1990
" " , ,
"
" ' 2 . :
"
. ,
, , ".
: ,
"- " .
" , 32 14:
" , ,14 ,1
. ,
,
.
,
".
. ,
,
; ,
.
" " ,
,
") .' (1.3

" , , 2016

17

" , "
, , , , ,
".
, ,
" " ,
.
.6
, 10
" ".
:
"
,
".
"-
" , 2 :
"
".
.
-
" " .
.
14:
" .3 , , ) :(
, , ".
, ,
.
32 . ,
, :
" ,14 ,2 ,
. ,
, ,
,
, .
,
.

.
"] . [
,
" "
, .

" , , 2016

18

.7
" "
.
.1
)33( 1962
,
, , .
, "
."2015
,
.
"
:2011
" - 1962 -
,
,
" .

, ,
.
,
,
.
, ,
.
"" ,
,
.
.
.2
" " " ".
" 2011
" "
, " " . ,
,
,"- ".
, " " ""
, 18-2
,:
" ".
" , , 2016

19

" ."
.
" ,2011- :
,
,
, .
) ,(intervention
. 80-90-
, ,Exit Counseling-
.

:
" " .
,, " "
, "-" .
" 80- ,"90- "" , ,
5
" " , .
, " "
. 18.3 ,
.
" " "
" " "
? ?
? ) . , , (2010
" , " . "
" .
1991-
,' , .
3 ,1995
' -
. 875,000$
4- $ 3 , $ -
, ).(CAN
- , , ,CAN-
. :
" ,
,
5
" " ) (deprogramming 80-" , "
" ,
, . .

" , , 2016

20

. ,
] .[... -
,

.
,
, .Haslip ,

".
, "
" , " ,
CAN ,

] ". [
.
, -
" ][ ",
" .2011-
"" , "
" - ,
" ".
-
, .
,International Journal of Law and Psychiatry
,Elsevier
.
:
"" , -
) ,(Ikeda, 1996; Watanabe, 1999
) Galanter, 1989; Lewis,
.(1987; Lifton, 1961, 1989; Maleson, 1981 ,-

)] ".(Watanabe, 1999 [
" ,
6
-".
"
" ,
, , .

6
Forced deprogramming from a religion and mental health: a case report of PTSD, Keiko Ikemoto
. and Masakazu Nakamura, International Journal of Law and Psychiatry :
.www.sciencedirect.com

" , , 2016

21

,
. ,
.

" , , 2016