0

2017

2017

9090509 - 9096379 - 9097074 :
9097073 :
nat_lib_libya@hotmail.com :

ISBN 978-9959-2-4308-9

348/2017

()5 ..................................................... ............................................... 1

()6 ........................................................................................ 2

()6 .................................................. ...................................... 3

()7 ......................................................................................... 4

()7 ................................................................ 4.1

() 8 .............................................................. 4.2

()9 .................................................................. 4.3

()10 ....................................................................... 4.4

()12 ........................................................................................... 5

()15 ....................................................................................... 6

()17 ..................................................................................... 7

()20 ................................................. ....................................... 8

()21 ................................................................ 8.1

()29 .................................................................. 8.2

()94 ..................................................................... 8.3

()95 ............................................................. 8.31

()98 ......................................................... 8.32

()99 ........................................ 8.321

()100 ................................ 8.322

3
()103 ................................................................................................ 9

()103 ............................... 9.1

()144 ........................................................................... 9.2

()144 ................ 9.21 ( )

()152 .... 9.22 ( )

9.23 (

()159 .......................................... )

9.24 ( ))165( ..

()173 .............. 9.25 ( )

9.26 ( ))187(.

4
 1

21 2014 " "

25 2017
.



.
.
" " 1
.
"

" " " 2

.

3
.

1
' 'standarization ""
" "
.
2
http://www.comparativeconstitutionsproject.org
1789
184 ( 190 )2006
350 .

.

3 "" ( )1
.

5




.


.

.
.
.
.

.
.
.
.

( ) (
)
( ).
" "

6

.

4.1

.


.
.


.

.


.


.


.

7

.
.


." "1


.
" " .

. ""

.
4.2


.
" " .

.

.

1
World Values Survey, Sixth Wave, 2014, www.worldvalues.org.
: -


.:
Ronald Inglehart and Christian Welzel, Worldvaluessurvey.org (Findings and
Insights).

8


.

.

.


.

.


.

.

.
.

.


.
4.3

.
.

9

.

" " " " " " " "
" ".



.



.

.


.



.
4.3




.

.

10
 .

.
.
.


.


.


.
.



.

.


.

.

11
 5

"

"

.


.


.





.

.

.


.

.

12

.

.



.

.


.


.

.

( 4
3 2 1
)
.

()16

()12

()8

()4

13
 ()8
()6

()4
()2
()12
()9
()6
()3
()8
()6

()4
()2
()4
()3

()2
()1

.
:
41 : 36 : 31 :
.12 :
.1

1

.

.

14
 6




.
.
:
.


(
).

:
4
3 2 .1


.

.
.
51
(
) .
12
%8.33 .
. .

15



%15 %15.15 %8.33 30
%17 %18.27 %8.33 36
%20 %25.88 %8.33 51
%8 %8.62 %8.33 17
%5 %4.06 %8.33 8
%6 %5.58 %8.33 11
%6 %4.06 %8.33 10
%4 %3.55 %8.33 5
%5 %4.06 %8.33 8
%4 %2.03 %8.33 4
%4 %3.04 %8.33 6
%6 %5.58 %8.33 11
%100 %100 %100 197

15 18 (
.)16.41 %8 17
.%8.33

. 4 36 40
%90 12
( .7.49 = 8.33 x 0.90 )%8.33
( %4
25) 4 x 0.90 .3.6 51
401 %78.62
12 ( %.6.54 = 8.33 7.86 )%8.33
( %20

16
 5) .15.72 = 20 x 7.86
7.49 3.6 6.56 .15.76

.
1
.

. .

.



( )10-1
( 5 ) .
.

7
.
.



.
.

.

1
12 .
.8.33
15 17 20 .
.

17



.
.

.


( )




48
.
.





.



.

.
.

18


.

.
.
%88.33

.

. 10 40 4
24 6 .
%64 .


.

.

.



.


.
.


.

19


.
8

:

(
) .

( )6 5
.

20
 8.1

()1 ()2 ()3 )(4
10 1 2 3 4 1
3 0 0 2 1 2
6 1 0 3 2 3
9 0 2 3 4 4
2 1 0 1 0 5
1 0 1 0 0 6
5 0 1 1 3 7
7 0 1 2 4 8
10 1 2 3 4 9
2 0 1 0 1 10
10 1 2 3 4 11
10 1 2 3 4 12
7 1 2 0 4 13
9 1 2 2 4 14
4 0 2 0 2 15
10 1 2 3 4 16
10 1 2 3 4 17
9 0 2 3 4 18
10 1 2 3 4 19
9 0 2 3 4 20
10 1 2 3 4 21
9 0 2 3 4 22
7 1 1 2 3 23
6 1 1 2 2 24
8 1 2 1 4 25
7 0 2 1 4 26
10 1 2 3 4 27
6 0 1 2 3 28
10 1 2 3 4 29
10 1 2 3 4 30
%75.33 = 300/226 18 47 64 97
15/11.29

21
 :


( )1 ()2 ()3 ()4
9 1 2 2 4 31
9 0 2 3 4 32
10 1 2 3 4 33
8 1 2 3 2 34
10 1 2 3 4 35
8 1 2 3 2 36
5 0 1 2 2 37
9 1 2 3 3 38
9 1 2 3 3 39
10 1 2 3 4 40
10 1 2 3 4 41
10 1 2 3 4 42
10 1 2 3 4 43
10 1 2 3 4 44
10 1 2 3 4 45
10 1 2 3 4 46
10 1 2 3 4 47
9 0 2 3 4 48
7 1 2 2 2 49
7 1 1 2 3 50
10 1 2 3 4 51
7 0 2 2 3 52
8 0 2 3 3 53
8 1 2 2 3 54
8 1 1 2 4 55
7 1 2 2 2 56
10 1 2 3 4 57
10 1 2 3 4 58
8 1 2 3 2 59
9 0 2 3 4 60
10 1 2 3 4 61
8 1 2 2 3 62
10 1 2 3 4 63
10 1 2 3 4 64
6 0 2 3 1 65
9 0 2 3 4 66
%88.33 = 360/318 28 69 99 122
17/15.01

22
 :



( )1 ()3 )(4
)(2
8 1 2 2 3 67
3 1 0 1 1 68
6 0 0 3 3 69
10 1 2 3 4 70
5 0 1 2 2 71
10 1 2 3 4 72
7 0 0 3 4 73
7 1 1 2 3 74
3 1 1 1 0 75
9 0 2 3 4 76
9 0 2 3 4 77
10 1 2 3 4 78
6 0 1 2 3 79
8 1 1 3 3 80
10 1 2 3 4 81
7 0 1 3 3 82
10 1 2 3 4 83
7 1 1 2 3 84
10 1 2 3 4 85
7 1 1 2 3 86
10 1 2 3 4 87
9 0 2 3 4 88
10 1 2 3 4 89
9 0 2 3 4 90
5 0 1 1 3 91
8 0 1 3 4 92
10 1 2 3 4 93
10 1 2 3 4 94
10 1 2 3 4 95
2 0 0 2 0 96
10 1 2 3 4 97
8 0 1 3 4 98
6 1 1 2 2 99
3 0 1 1 1 100
10 1 2 3 4 101
10 1 2 3 4 102
9 0 2 3 4 103

23
 6 0 1 2 3 104
10 1 2 3 4 105
10 1 2 3 4 106
10 1 2 3 4 107
9 0 2 3 4 108
3 0 0 1 2 109
8 0 1 3 4 110
10 1 2 3 4 111
9 1 1 3 4 112
9 1 1 3 4 113
7 1 1 2 3 114
10 1 2 3 4 115
4 0 1 1 2 116
5 0 1 1 3 117
%78.62 = 510/401 30 72 129 170
20/15.72

24
 :

( )1 ))2 ))3 ()4
8 1 1 2 4 118
4 0 2 1 1 119
9 0 2 3 4 120
10 1 2 3 4 121
9 0 2 3 4 122
10 1 2 3 4 123
9 0 2 3 4 124
6 0 2 2 2 125
3 1 1 1 0 126
10 1 2 3 4 127
8 1 2 2 3 128
4 0 1 1 2 129
10 1 2 3 4 130
6 1 1 2 2 131
10 1 2 3 4 132
3 1 1 0 1 133
10 1 2 3 4 134
%75.88 = 170/129 11 29 38 51
8/6.07
:


( )1 ))2 ))3 ()4
9 0 2 3 4 135
6 0 2 1 3 136
10 1 2 3 4 137
8 1 2 2 3 138
5 0 2 1 2 139
7 0 2 1 4 140
10 1 2 3 4 141
5 0 2 1 2 142
%75 = 80/60 3 16 15 26
5/3.75

25
 :

( )1 ()3 ()4
()2
6 0 2 2 2 143
5 0 1 2 2 144
4 0 1 1 2 145
2 0 1 1 0 146
4 1 1 1 1 147
3 0 1 1 1 148
6 0 1 2 3 149
9 0 2 3 4 150
8 0 2 3 3 151
7 1 1 3 2 152
7 0 1 3 3 153
%55.45 = 110/61 2 14 22 23
6/3.32

( )1 ()2 )(3 ()4
7 0 1 2 4 154
6 0 1 2 3 155
4 0 1 1 2 156
8 0 2 2 4 157
10 1 2 3 4 158
5 0 2 1 2 159
9 1 2 3 3 160
2 1 1 0 0 161
10 1 2 3 4 162
8 1 1 3 3 163
%69 = 100/69 5 15 20 29
6/3.84

26
 :



( )1 ()3 ))4
()2
4 0 1 3 0 164
4 1 1 1 1 165
5 0 2 2 1 166
1 1 0 0 0 167
5 1 1 2 1 168
%38 = 50/19 3 5 8 3
4/1.52

( )1 ()3 )(4
()2
9 0 2 3 4 169
2 0 1 0 1 170
10 1 2 3 4 171
10 1 2 3 4 172
10 1 2 3 4 173
10 1 2 3 4 174
10 1 2 3 4 175
10 1 2 3 4 176
%88.75= 80/71 6 15 21 29
5/4.43

( )1 ()3 )(4
()2
9 0 2 3 4 177
9 0 2 3 4 178
10 1 2 3 4 179
8 1 2 3 2 180
%90 = 40/36 2 8 12 14
4/3.6

27


( )1 ))3 )(4
))2
8 0 1 3 4 181
7 1 1 2 3 182
4 0 1 2 1 183
9 0 2 3 4 184
8 1 1 2 4 185
6 1 2 1 2 186
%70 = 60/42 3 8 13 18
4/2.8

( )1 ()2 ()3 )(4
5 0 2 3 0 187
10 1 2 3 4 188
10 1 2 3 4 189
1 1 0 0 0 190
8 1 1 2 4 191
3 0 1 1 1 192
7 1 1 2 3 193
10 1 2 3 4 194
5 0 1 3 1 195
9 0 2 3 4 196
9 0 2 3 4 197
%70 = 110/77 6 16 26 29
6/4.3

28
 8.2
:

( )1 :
.
10 :.

( )2 :


.

.
" " 195 171 91

" "
90 " ".
55
52 160
.
.
" "

.

3 :.

29
 ( )3 : .

6 :.

( )4 : : : .:
. : : .

9 :.

( )5 :
.

.
" "
.

:.

( )6 : .

.
(/)
.
.

: .

( )7 : .

.

30



.

5 :.

( )8 :

.

.

.

7 :.

( )9 :
.

10 :.

( )10 :

.

.
.
.
.
.

:.

31
 ( )11 :

.

10 :.

( )12 :

.

10 :.

( )13 :
.
.

.


.

7 :.

( )14 :
.

.
9 :.

( )15 :

32

.

(
).
.
.

4 :.

( )16 : .
.

10 :.

( )17 :
.

10 :.

( )18 : .

.
. .
.

" ".

9 :.

33
 ( )19 :
.
.

10 :.

( )20 : .


.

9 :.

( )21 :


.

10 :.

( )22 :



. .

" " " ".

9 :.

34
 ( )23 :
.
.

7 :.

( )24 : .
.

.
.
6 :.

( )25 :
.

8 :.

( )26 :
.

" " ( ).

.

7 :.

35
 ( )27 :

.

10 :.

( )28 :


.

" " " ".

.

6 :.

( )29 :
.
.

. .

10 :.

( )30 :
.

.

10 :.

36
 :

( )31 :

.

8 :.

( )32 : .
.
.

9 :.

( )33 :
.

10 :.

( )34 :


.

.
.

8 :.

( )35 :
.
.

10 :.

37
 ( )36 :

. .

" "
.

8 :.

( )37 :


.
.

.
.35
"
".


.

.
.
5 :.

( )38 :
.
.

38
 " "
"
".

9 :.

( )39 :
.
.

9 :.

( )40 :

. .

10 :

( )41 :
.
.

10 :.

( )42 :

.

10 :.

39
 ( )43 :

.

10 :.

( )44 :

.
.
.

10 :.

( )45 :

.

10 :.

( )46 :


.

10 :.

( )47 :
.

10 :.

( )48 : .

40

.

""
.
.

9 :.

( )49 :


.
.

7 :.

( )50 :

-1 .

-2 .
.

-3
.

-4
.

-5
. .

41

.

7 :

( )51 :
.

10 :.

( )52 : .

.

.

"
" " ".
.

.
:



.

7 :.

42
 ( )53 :


.

8 :.

( )54 :
.

.

%4
.

8 :.

( )55 :


.

8 :.

( )56 : .
. .
.

43

.
.

7 :.

( )57 :

.
.

10 :.

( )58 :
.
.
.

10 :.

( )59 :

.

8 :.

( )60 :

.
.
.

44
 "
".
9 :.

( )61 : .

.
.

10 :.

( )62 :
. .
. .
. .

" " " ".

8 :.

( )63 :
. .



.
.

10 :.

( )64 : .
.
.
.

10 :.

45
 ( )65 :
.
.
.

" ".

6 :.

( )66 :


.

9 :.

( )67 : :
.

.
.

" " " "

.

8 :.

46
 :
( )68 :

. .
. .

" "
" " .
39 "
" .
.
.
" ".
3 :.

( )69 :


.

.
" "
.
" "
.
" ".

6 :.

( )70 :

.
10 :.

47
 ( )71 :

.

( )
(
) .
.




.
" " .

5 :.

( )72 :

.
( )42
. .
10 :.

( )73 :

.
.
.

48
 .
79 .

" " .
"
" "
".

.

7 :.

( )74 :
.

7 :.

:
( )75 : ()78

.

() 32 . .1

() 26 . .2

() 20 . .3

.
. .

49


.
" "
.

.
39 "
" .

3 :.

( )76 :
.

" "... "

."..

9 :.

( )77 :
. .
.

" "
" ".

9 :.

( )78 :
.
(79 )80
.

10 :.

50
 ( )79 :
:

-1 .

-2 .

-3 .

-4.

-5 .

-6 .

.


.

.

6 :.

( )80 :
:

-1 .

-2 .

-3 .

51
 .

8 :.

( )81 :
( )79

.

10 :.

( )82 :

. .

" "79
.

79 .

7 :.

( )83 :
.

10 :.

( )84 :
( :
).

52

.

7 :.

( )85 :
.

10 :.

( )86:

.1

.

.2

.

.3
.

.

" 37 ".

.
" "
.

7 :.

53
 ( )87

10 :.

( )88 : :

-1 .

-2.

-3.

-4 .

-5.

.
"" .

9 :.

( )89 :

.

10 :.

( )90 : .
- .

.

54

.

" " " ".

9 :.

( )91 :

:

-1 .

-2 .

-3 .

-4 .

-5 .

-6 .

(.)139
" " " ".

.
"
."104

5 :.

55
 ( )92 :

: :

-1 .

-2 .

-3 .

-4 .

" " .

.

.

8 :.

( )93 :
.

.

10 :.

( )94 :
.

10 :.

56
 ( )95 :
( 91 )92
.

10 :.

( )96 :
( )12:1 .
.

12/1
.
1/12
. .

10 :.

( )97 :
.
.

10 :.

( )98 : :

.

"
".

8 :.

( )99 : :

-1 .

57
 -2
.

-3 .

-4 .

-5 .

-6
.

-7 .

6 :.

( )100 :

.

.

.

58

.

.
" "
.

.
.101

3 :.

( )101 :
.

10 :.

( )102 :
( :

).

10 :.

( )103 :
:

-1 .

-2.

-3 .

-4.

59

.

9 :.

( )104 : :

.1 .

.2 .

.3 .

.4 .

.5 .

.6 .

.7 .

.8 .

.9 .

.10 .

.11 .

.12 .

"" "".

60
 :
.
: 109 .
: " "
" " .
:
.
.

6 :.

( )105 :
.

10 :.

( )106 :
.

10 :.

( )107 :
.

10 :.

( )108 :


.
.

"" "" "" " ".

9 :.

61
 ( )109 :


:

-1
.

-2
.
() .

.
" " " ".

.

.

.
" "
.
.

3 :.

62
 ( )110 :

.
.

.
.



. .
. .
( )103 .

. .

.
" " .
" "
.
" " .

8 :.

( )111 : .

10 :.

( )112 : :

-1 .

-2 .

63
 -3 .

. .

9 :.

( )113 : :


.
.

9 :.

( )114 :
( :
).

7 :.

( )115 :




.

10 :.

64
 ( )116 :
.

.

.
:

.

4 :.

( )117 : :

-1 .

-2 .

-3 .

-4 .

-5 .

-6 .

-7 .

-8 .

-9
.

-10
.

-11
.

65
 -12 .

3 : .

.
11 10 .17

5 :.

( )118 :
.
.
.

8 :.

( )119 :
.
.

.17

4 :.

( )120 :

66
 .
.

"" ""
.86

9 :.

( )121 :


. .

10 :.

( )122 :

.

" " .

9 :.

( )123 : .

10 :.

( )124 :

9 :.

67
 ( )125 :

.



. .

.17
.

.

6 :.

( )126 :
.

:
.

3 :.

( )127 :

.
.

10 :.

( )128 : .
.

68
 .

8 :.

( )129 : .


.

()
.

" "
().

4 :.

( )130 :


.

10 :.

( )131 :
.

6 :.

69
 ( )132 :

.

10 :.

( )133 :

.

3 :.

( )134 :
.

10 :.

( )135 : :



.

""
.

9 :.

70
 ( )136 :
.





.
.

" " "

".

" " " ".

6 :.

( )137 :
( :
).

10 :.

( )138 :

.


.

71
 .

8 :.

( )139 : :

-1 .

-2 .

-3 .

-4 .

-5 .

-6 .

-7 .

-8 .

-9 .

3
( .)109

6 7
.

5 :.

( )140 :
.

72
 .

7 :.

( )141 :

.

10 :.

( )142 :


.

5 :.

( )143
.

6 :.

( )144 :

73


.

" " "

"...

5 :.

( )145 :
. .

.


.

4 :.

( )146 :

. .

.
.

.

.

74
 .

:.

( )147 :


. .

( )148
.
" "
.

4 :.

( )148 :



.
.
.

165
.

147
.

151 .

75
 " "
.
"
"
.

3 :.
( )149 :
.

.
"" "".
6 :.

( )150 :
.
.

" " " " "

".
" " .

9 :.

( )151 :



.

8 :.

76
 ( )152 :

.

7 :.

( )153 :
:

-1
.

-2
.

-3 .

.
""
.

7 :.

( )154 :


.

77
 .
7 :.

( )155 :

.

.
.
.

6 :.

( )156 :

.

.
.

.

4 :.

( )157 :

.

:
.

8 :.

78
 ( )158 :

.
.

10 :.

( )159

. :

-1
.

-2 .

-3 .

-4
.

-5 .

.

.
.

79
 " "
.

5 :.

( )160


.

9 :.

( )161 : :

-1
.

-2
.

-3
.

-4 .

80
 ( )
.
.

.

.

:.

( )162 : :

-1 .

-2
.

-3 .

-4
.

10 :.

( )163 :


.

8 :.

81


( )164 :
:

-1 .
-2

.
-3
.
-4 .
-5 .
" " " " "
" " ".

.
.

5 :.

( )165 :

. .

148
.

.

4 :.

82
 ( )166 :
.

.
.


.
5 :.

( )167

.

.
.

.
.
.
: .

( )168



.

" ".
" "
.

83


.

5 :.

( )169


.

9 :.

( )170

.
.

79
.


.
.
.
.

84
 :.

( )171 :
.
.

.

10 :.

( )172 :

.

10 :.

( )173 :


.

10 :.

( )174 :

.

10 :.

( )175 :
.

10 :.

85
 ( )176
.

10 :.

( )177

.

" " "

".

9 :.

( )178 :


.
.

" "
.

9 :.

( )179 :
.
.

10 :.

86
 ( )180 .

.

.

8 :.

( )181 :

-1
.

-2

.

" " " ".

.
" " " ".

8 :.

( )182 :

.

" "

" "
.

7 :.

87
 ( )183

-1
.

-2
.
.

-3



.

-4
.

.
" :

".

.

88
 "
" " "
.

4 :.

( )184 :
.

9 :.

( )185 :

.

12

.2011
" " " ".

8 :.

( )186

-1 .

-2 2011/2/17

.

-3
.

89
 .4

2011/2/15 .

" ".
2011 /2/ 17
.

.
" " "" .4

6 :.

( )187 :

.

.

.

.
.

.
" " " ".

5 :.

90
 ( )188
.

.

.


.

10 :.

( )189

-1
.

-2 ( )34 32 31

.

-3 .

-4 .

-5 .

-6
.

-7
.

-8

.

10 :.

91
 ( )190 : .

: .

( )191 :

.

.

.

.

8 :.

( )192 :
.

.

.

3 :.

( )193 :


.

92

.

7 :.

( )194 :
.

10 :.

( )195

-1 .

-2


.

-3

.

-4

.

-5
.

.6
.

.7 .

93

.
" " .
"" .

5 :.

( )196 :



.

" " " ".

9 :.

( )197 : .
.
.

9 :.

8.3



( )10-1 (
5 ) .
.

94

. .
8.31

15/11.29 %75.33 226 30
17/15.01 %88.33 318 36
20/15.72 %78.62 401 51
8/6.07 %75.88 129 17
5/3.75 %75 60 8
6/3.32 %55.45 61 11
6/3.84 %64 69 10
4/1.52 %38 19 5
5/4.43 %88.75 71 8
4/3.6 %90 36 4
4/2.8 %70 42 6
6/4.2 %70 77 11
100/76.59 _ 1509 197

( )%90
( )%88.75 ( )%88.33
( )%38 ( )%64 (.)%55.45
.

%33.50 66 10
%16.75 32 9
%12.69 23 8
%10.15 20 7
%6.09 15 6
%5.58 13 5

95
 %7.61 10 4
%2.03 9 3
%2.03 6 2
%1.01 3 1
%99.98 197

( )%33.5
( )%24.36 ( .)7-5
( )10-8 %61.42
(.%14.21 = 197/28 = )4-1
%61.42
.
( )%14.21
.

:

( 10( )12) (.)11

( 10( )19) (.)15

( 8( )55) (.)2

( 10( )105) ( 10( )106) ( 10( )107)

(.)104

58 .


.
.
.

96


300/226 30/18 60/47 90/64 120/97

30
75.33 %60 %78.33 %71.11 %80.83

360/318 36/28 72/69 144/122 108/99

36
%88.33 %77.77 %95.83 %84.72 %91.66

510/401 51/30 153/129 102/72 204/170

51
%78.63 %58.82 %84.31 %70.59 %83.33

170/129 17/11 34/29 51/38 68/51

17
%75.88 %64.71 %85.29 %74.51 %75

80/60 8/3 16/16 24/15 32/26

8
%75 %37.5 %100 %62.5 %81.25

110/61 11/2 33/22 22/14 44/23

11

%55.45 %18.18 %66.66 %63.64 %52.27

100/69 10/5 20/15 30/20 40/29

10
%69 %50 %75 %66.67 %72.5

50/19 5/3 15/5 20/8 10/3

5

%38 %60 %33.33 %40 %30

97
 80/71 8/6 24/21 16/15 32/29

8
%88.75 %75 %87.5 %93.75 %90.63

40/36 4/2 12/12 16/14 8/8

4
%90 %50 %100 %87.5 %100

60/42 6/3 24/18 12/8 18/13

6
%70 %50 %75 %66.66 %72.22

110/77 11/6 22/16 44/29 33/26

11
%70 %54.55 %72.73 %65.91 %78.79

1970/1509 197/117 485/399 571/419 717/574 197

%76.59 %59.39 82.26 %73.38 %80.05

8.32

.




.

98

.


.




.




.



.

8.321

.

.


.

99
 " "
( )37 " " ( )80"
" ( )15" " (.)151

"" "" ""

"" "" "" "" " "" "" ""
"" ""
.
""
.
" "
""

" " .
.
105
107 106 " ""
" " ".

( )197 "
" ( )184 .
( 69)
( 99).
( )84(.)102

8.322


.

100

.

.

(.)126( )147( )46( )5

.
.

.

" "
" " .

.

.



.


( )151 148 (.)182
78 75
"
(79 )80 [ ]
" . 78

101

.

.
75
144 .

.
%81




.
" "..
%17.9 100.


.
( )8-10
( )1-4 .

.

102
 9
9.1

" "
" "
.

% 0.00 : %15
% 15 : %25
% 25 : %40
% 40 : %50
% 50.00 : %55
% 55 : %65
% 65 : %80
% 80 : %100

103


/



%95.1 6

14

%91.8


16
%94.6

17

%73.9 181

186
29

%81


100 30
%17.9

31

%91.8
31

66
46
%30.4 2



47
%69.6 2

104
 48

%77.7


49



%3.3 181




50

%93.5

51

%89.1 '' 42

''

53



%82.2
114 /102 /84





54

%91.3 ''

''
55
' '
%82.6
''

56
%77.2 ' '
' '

105
 57
%79.3

59
%71.7 '' 34
''

59

''

%56.5 190/ 114 /84







60

%90.8
//


61
%39.1 ''
50
''
.

63


%94.6

106

65
%15.8 4


66

%53.8 3


67

%55.4 197/5


68
%65.8 197/ 5

69
%19.0 5


70

%98.4 195



:



72

%35.3 195

78

%68.5 195

107
 79
%4.3 195

83


%88.0

()

84
/98 /97:
%69.0
111

85

%6.5 98


86

%42.8 98 /97 :
'
'
87

%17.9 111
'
'
88

%1.6 98 /97 :


89
%54.3 100

90
%1.1 100

92
%48.9 101

93

%33.7 100

108
 94
%27.7 35 99



%38.0

.
%3.3



%16.3
95
99

. %1.1



%2.2



%62.0

.
96
%77.7 110 /103

%41.3
97

110
%26.6

%31.5

109

111



%47.8 103
15




112 110

%34.2


113

%65.8

( )

114

%50.0 108



115

%16.3 108


116

%4.9 108


119
%88.6 105

121

%60.9 111


122
%62.5 113

126
%57.1

110
 127
%66.3

128
%3.3 30 113
.
129

%22.8

%1.1 -


- 130
%19.6
113
-

%8.2
.
%22.3

131
%65.2 115


132
%51.0 115

147



%51.6 109

148
%2.2 116

111
 149
%38.0

150

%80.4


151

%80.4


154
%67.9

157


%36.4
( :

)
158
%37.0

159
%37.0

163

%98.4 111

/
167
%41.8
115 /104
%71.7 /

174

%16.3 129

112
 182

%90.2 187


183
%66.3 187

184

%0 187

186
%30.4
187
%27.7


187

%58.7 189




%6.0 189


189
%3.3

190

%100 67
(
)

191

%42.4 67

113




196

%23.9 92 / 91






197
%1.1 ( 68 /67
)
198
%9.8 80

199

%1.1 68


200

%94.4 73


202

%90.0 68


203
%2.2

68



204
%25.5 68

220

22.8 25 ( 69
)

114


221

59.8
69
%60.9




222

%45.7 4 70
( )

223

%83.2

( )

224

%4.9 185 /68

( )

226
%26.1 75/67

227
%6.1

78
228

%57.6 75

229

%38.6 79

115
 231
%16.3 75

232
%8.7 75

233
%4.9 75

249

%3.4 40 76






250


%26.1 76







251

%7.1 4 77



252

%0.5 77
[

]

253
%8.7 75

116
 254
%3.3
75
%3.3


255

%62.4 109



257
%66.8 88

259


%14.7 89



260

%83.7 86


261
%33.3 74

262

%53.8


%38.0
%12.5 263
/104 /72 /42

%44.6 117

%14.1
264
%22.3 71

117
 270


%80.4 ( 73


)

271

(
%28.8



)

272

/


%2.7 72

(



)
273

%59.2 73


274
%40.2 73

275

%29.3


276

%83.7 167

295


%3.8 87

118
 297
%71.2
104 /92
%8.7

298


%4.5 191 / 85
(

)
299

%7.1 193

/
300

%7.1 96


301

%49.5 93
( )

302
%20.7 93

303

%9.2
(
)

304

%71.7 92/78/71

119
 305
%0.5 ( 92/78/71
)
307
%77.7 72


308
%33.7 127 /121

%44.6 309

%30.4 133 /141- 135

310

%76.1 118/124
()

311

%86.4


312

%67.4


315

%85.9

316

%90.1

120
 349

%67.4


360

%7.6 140


361


%2.7 140



362
%12.0

363

%9.2 140


364
"
%33.2 141
"

370

%91.3

""
371
%70.1 120

372
%29.9 120

382

%70.1

121
 383
%56.5

384
%27.7 143

385
/ /
%69.0 144


387

%14.1


388



%14.1




389

%14.1 1


391

%83.7

411


%92.4

122
 412


%92.4



413

%82.6 40


414

%54.3 40




415

%78.3






417

52.2




419

%71.2

42
421




72 %21.7 72/42
(

)

123
 422
%2.7

423

%60.9 104


424
%34.2 104

426
%13 39

427
%62.5 18 68 /72

429

%73.9 39


430

%60.9 58 /67 /42


431


%39.1 157



444

%91.3


445
%77.2 100 /75 /68

446
%80.4

124
 447

%88.6


448


%94.0



449

%65.2


450
%73.9

451

%32.6 158


457
%39.7 168

%2.7 464 168

125
 466


%15.8 163



469
%66.8 124
/
470
%4.9 163

475


%12.0 17

(
)
476
12.5 159




479





(

%67.9 160 163







)

483

%77.7 13 /12

126
 484

%69.0
'' '
'
485
%69.0

486

%64.7 104 /12


487
%68.5 107



488
% 3.8 106



490

%90.2 13


491
%22.8 104


492
%20.7 91


496
%36.4 139

497

%26.6 13


500

%73.9 56

/

127
 501
%42.4 48

502


%60.9 55

.

503

%77.2


504

%58.7 29





505

%43.5 9




.



506

%72.3 56

507

%100 40

128

508


%100 56




509


%78.8



510

%96.7
(
)
511
%7.6 32



512


%31.5 44





513
%39.7

514
/
%71.2

515
%75.0 64 /63

()habeas corpus

129
 516


%63.6 62

( nulla poena sine
)lege
517
%29.9 122

518

%96.7


519
%37.0

520

%91.3


521

%13.6 63


522

%70.7


523

%78.8 62
( ex post
)facto

524

%31.5 64

130
 525
%47.3 61

" 526
%42.4 61
"


527

%64.7 121

528
%71.7 62

529


%35.9 63



530

%12.5 121
/

532


%50.5 (


)

533
%49.5 63
( )Miranda

131
 534

%71.7 63


535
%29.9 63

537
%94.0

538


%75.5 /10

.

543

%53.8 10


546
%28.3 10

547

%63.6


548

%57.6 44


549

%90.8 44

551

%50.5

132
 552


%97.3 7



556

%94.6


558

%83.7








559


%28.3 46












560


%7.1 46

561

%64.1

133
 562

%18.5 6


563

%11.4 6


564
%6.5


565
%1.1 6
()
()
566

%96.2
(
)
567

%70.7


568

%96.2


569

%90.2 58

570
%42.9 58

134
 571

%66.3 58


572

%3.8 58



573

%73.4 50
-

.
574

%48.4 56


575


%72.3 56



576

%51.6

577

%57.6

578
%20.7 50

135
 579

%81.0


580

%91.8


581
%65.2

582
%15.8 51

583

%35.9 15
/

584
%79.9

585

%45.7 50


587
%14.1

588
%76.6
/
589
%11.8 61

590

%53.8 56

136
 591
%37.5 56
/



592

%65.2





593
%70.1





594
%11.4 27





595

%99.5



596

%59.2 27

598
%66.8

137
 599
%37.5 59

600

%87.5


601

%82.6


602
%48.9 48

603

%22.3 48


604
%74.5 31

605


%41.8 34



606
%74.5 34

607

%77.2 34


608

%82.6 35

609
%85.3 44

138
 610

%18.5
/

611

%93.5 37


612

%53.3 42



614
%8.2 35
"

615

%62.0 38


616

%67.4


618

%92.4 43


619
%8.2

620

%64.7 65 /31

621

%76.6

139
 622


%74.5



623


%43.5 14



624

%97.3


626

%72.8 18


627
%59.2 18


628
%38.6 176 /169


629


%52.2 169

(
).
630

%28.3 169

631

%54.9 55

140
 632
%40.8

634
%60.3

635
%66.8

636
%62.5

637

80.4


638
:

%8.2 38



639

%91.3


640
73.4 106

646

%6,7 36


647
%79.9

652
%78.8

141
 654

%86.4


655
" %45.4 2
"
656

%7.6 2



657
%79.9 2


658
%45.1
160 /55 /2

659

%90.2 52


660

%58.2 52


661
( )
%41.8 52


662

%62.5 52


663
( )
%8.2 52

142
 664
%32.1 53

665
%10.3 53

( ... ) 357
:
%20.16 = 72 :
%6.72 = 24 :
%13.72 = 49 :
%7.28 = 26 :
%47.89 = 171 :
%4.48 = 16 :
%9.24 = 33 :
%19.88 = 71 :
%18.48 = 66 :
%52.10 = 186 :

.
%27 ( [ )]%25 .
%38 ( [ %65 ]) .

143
 9.2

9.21

" " ( )2017
.

.

() .

1
() .
.

[ ]2003 []1962
[ ]2014/1980 [ ]1971 []1973
[ ]1972 [ ]2011 [ ]2012/1973/1950 [ ]2005/1973

( ) ( 1

)
.

.

144
 1
[]1968/1964
2
() .

" "
.

.

.
"" "" " ".

2.1

.


.

.

.
500
200 .
.

1
: " : "
2015.12-7 .
2

( )1970/1964
" " ( )2017 .

145

.

-
- .
( )

(
i
) .

2.2

"" ""

.
" " .

2.3 " "

"" ( .)1970/1964
"" ""

.
.

. " " " "
""
.

146
 " "
" " .

.

"
" " "
. " "

" "
.

" "
( ) . "
" ( )


.

( ) ( )

.
.

.

.

.
" "
.
.

147

.

""
"" .

" "
.

: "
" (" )44 "
(" )45 " ( )47

.
.
.
.

( ) ( )
( ) ( ).

.
( ) ( )
( ) ( ) .
( )

148
 ( ) .
) (contradictories ) (contraries
) (subcontraries .

.
( )

.

.
" "


.
.

. .


.
.

.


.


.

149

.

""
.

.

" "


.

.
.

:1

""

1
" "
.

150

.
" " " "
" " " "
.


" "
.

. "
"


.

.

151
 9.22

.

.
:

.

.
.
.

.
.
.
.


. :

.

.
.

152


.

"

" ( .)109

(
.)110


.
( )

.

:
:

( )
.
:

.
.
.
.

153
 .
( )
. ( )
() .
( )75


.

.

( )79
( .)82
( . 72 .)73

.

.
.

.
:

1+%50 :
.

1+%50 :
.

154
 :
.

.


.

( . )73

.
( )
.

() .


.

-1
:

-
.

-
.

155
 -
.

-
.

-
.

-

.

-2

( )
.
:
-1
.
-2
( ).
-3
.
-4
.

.
:

156



.
.




.

( )


.

o
.
o


.
o
.

157



. :

158
 9.23

.
.

( )1 () : (
) .


.




.
( )2 () :
.
.
( )
.


.


.

159

:
:
()


.


.
:
.
:


.


. (
)

.

.
:

.1 .

.2
.
.3 .

160
 .4

.
.5 .
.6
.
.7
.
.8
.
.9
.
.10
.
.11
.

.1

.
(
) :
(
)

.
.2
.

161


.



.
(
).
.3 :

:


.
.
5002

31 .

120.052 .
.
300

.


.
:
"" " "
103

162

.
103
.


103 .


.



.
:


.


.
:


.

( )
.
:
.

163

.
.4 :


.

(




) .

.



.

.

164
 9.24

2014


2017

.

" "

:
" "


" :


.
".

165
 :

" "


1
.

2
:

.

375

.3

.

1
.
2
2011
19 " "
3
( ) 375 .
"
.

. "

166


.1

: ""

" :
" " :
" " :
".2

" ".

( )1697
.

.3

1
: :
51
2
" "
.
3
94 :
" ".

167
 :

( %45
)% 30
185 "

"
" "


20 .

2014
46 " :
"
15 4 2012
1
!

2
.

1
15 :
"...
2
2011 115 "
"
.

168



:
.



50 .

27
:
. .

"

" 1 :
2

.3

"
"
.

19 1988. 1

2
: 1959 2002
b28 .
3

2016 .75:

169
 50
:
.

""
.

1





.2

65 " :
.
. "

.

13

1
"
"
2

( 3 2013 "
13 10 84 9 94).

170

" "

.

1

" "


.

.

.2

3 4 .1

1
.
2
: .
3
() :
2016..
4
" " 46 :
.

171
 :

42

141

159
"
.

2015 " .
" 7:
. 2015.
1
:
.

172
 9.25

.


1
.
2017

2.




3.
36 %18.27

1
1789
16 "
".
2
( )1875 ()1953
( )1811 ( )1922( )1983 ( )1966 ( )1985 ( )1852
( )1992 ( )1924 ( )1983()1961 ( .)1976
3
74
184 .
350
1789 .2006
2014
Elkin Zachary. Tom Ginsberg. And James Melton.2010.Characteristics of National
Constitutions. Version1.0. Comparative Constitutions Project. Last modified. May
14. 2010. Available at http//www. Comparative constitutions project. Org/index.htm

173
 40
1
.

.



.

1

2.


.

.
1.1

.
.

22 74
50 ( )1991 ( )1996 ()1992
( )20032006 ( )1991 ( )1976 ( )1994 ( )1988
( )1987 ( )1991 ( )1999 ( )1992 (.)1980
2
"
" .

174

.


1948



.


1.1993
2001 2


3. " " 2000

1

1993 "

"
2





....
.
3
167/58 2003

175
 .
.
1.2


.



.

1
.


1948
2
" ".






. ( )

1
David S. Law, Globalization and the Future of Constitutional Rights, 102 Nw. U.L.
)Rev. 12771306 (2008
2
Mark Tushnet, The Inevitable Globalization of Constitutional Law, 49 Va. J. Intl L.
)985, 989(2009

176

.

( ) .

1
" " 1948 .
1947
" " ( )1948
17.6 1949
31 %90



( )

1
%98
%53
.%31

177

1980
1984
"

".
%
2006 1949 1948 1915 1914 1789
350 104 122
1.4 3.8 8.2
24.0 37.5 47.5
14.3 22.1 36.9
30.5 44.1 59.0
43.1 22.1 2.5
64.0 20.2 11.5

57.7 25.0 25.4

57.7 25.0 3.3
70.9 45.2 56.6
32.9 4.8 4.9

30.9 14.4 9.8

88.9 87.5 50.0
71.4 57.7 41.8
38.3 13.5 0.0
18.0 1.9 1.6
69.4 32.7 4.1
60.3 39.4 23.8
76.3 71.2 60.7

35.7 19.2 1.6

57.7 42.3 33.6
30.6 11.5 10.7
24.3 7.7 5.7
39.1 13.5 1.6
58.0 26.0 28.7
31.4 6.7 0.0

178
 2

.




.




.
.
:


.
.
:


.
:

.
.

.

.

179

.
.
.

2.1


.

1951
.
.


1
.


" ".
27 "
"......
195 .

1
43 35
1948
8
( )1995 ( )2008 ( )2004 ( )1987 ()1994
( )1991 ( )2009 (.)1999

180
 .
1

.






.







.
.

2
3
4

1
.
9 1953 2

1957 9 .
3
1951 1954
1952 1965
4
HRI/ GEN /LREV.4

181





.


. 13 "
"
.
.

.

" "


1969 46

27

.



6
139

182

1
.

2


.
3

1
59 "

"
" "

.
2
" " ( )1966"
" ( )1966 15 1976 "
"
16 1989
3 1968 1989
1993 2004

2004

.2008
3
2
.

.
1965
1979
.1967

183

.
2.2


.

.
.




.



1951
.
37

1951
33
21 "
."...


1989

184
 %39.1
.






.

2.3






.




.







.

185

2014 "
"
2005 " "

1992 1996 "
".





.





.

186
 62.9

2015
.
.
.

.
.
:
.
.

.

.

.1

2011
.
.

.

187

" "
.
.

.

.

:
1
.

.
1977 .

2.
.
2011.

.
.

1
Algheitta, N. F. 2011. Protecting human rights of the accused in the Libyan
criminal justice system. University of Aberdeen: doctoral dissertation. Pp 61-66.
2
.

188
 1951 .



1
.

.2

. ( )30
. " "
.

2
.

. ( )30
.
( )60
( )30
.

1
29 . .2012 : .
https://shuoon.wordpress.com/2012/11/29/ :---
-- ./ 28 : .2017

2
.

189


1.
.


.
2012
( )60 .
.
2
.

.

.

5 2012 .

.

( .)2015 . : . .61 1

2
30 "
"."
."... "
"."
...
."...

190
1
.
20 2013
.

.
.
.

.

.

. ( )120 ( )60

.
( )30 8 2012
20 .2014 .

( )18
21 2014 20 .2015

.

.

1
28 59 26 . .2013 . .10 18 .2
.2013

191
 .
.

.
. %45
%14
1
10 .

.3

.

.

: .
6 2014
.
.



.

1
Eljarh, Mohamed. 28 April 2014. Libya's assembly faces major challenges. Middle
East Eye. http://www.middleeasteye.net/columns/libyas-assembly-faces-major-
challenges-1273681924. Last accessed 28 September 2017.

192

.

.
.


1
.

.


.


.

. 2014 )1( :
)2( )3( )4(
)5( )6( )7(
() )8( .
.
. ( )47
. ( )52

1
( )2014-2010
58
39.3 . :
.http://www.worldvaluessurvey.org/WVSOnline.jsp

193
 .
1
.

.
2014
2.
.


( 30 ).

( )60 .
. 22 2014

3.
.
.

.

( )60
.

.
.
.

1
4.
2
4.
3
http://www.cdalibya.org/ :----.-
28 : .2017

194
 . 24
2014 .

.4

24 2014 ( )63
1 .
.
:
.

.
.

.1963
.
/
.
.
:

.

1
http://www.cdalibya.org/ :- . 28 : .2017

. . : .:
.
2-1 .2015 :
.http://uob.edu.ly/assets/uploads/pagedownloads/9f412-.pdf 28 :
.2017

195
 .
1.
:

- :

-
-
-

.

.
.

.

.1"
.2 .

3.

1
- 2013 %78
. %45
( )%28
( .)%5 %28 "
" ( )%60 " "
%7 " " .
.2013 :
http://uob.edu.ly/assets/uploads/pagedownloads/70b47-.pdf 28
.2017

196
 ".
. ( )10

. (
23 33 ) ( )
"
8
".

.




.
.

. ( )
"
. "
( )
..." :
.3 ...: .4 . .5 .
". .... ( )
" .1 :
."...

:
( )5
"

197

"
.

.


. ( )1
"
" "
" .
( )1 ( )3
.
1
.

( )8 "



2
."...

1
.
17 . .2015 :
https://www.facebook.com/downtownlibya/photos/pcb.765975870124576/76597484
3458012/?type=1&theater
2
. . :
.
2-1 .2015 :
.http://uob.edu.ly/assets/uploads/pagedownloads/9f412-.pdf 28 :
.2017

198

.
.
.

.
1.
.
.
:
:



.
.
2
.

.
2013
3.

.

1
. . 93
.23
2
5.
3 %87 %10
.
.2013 http://uob.edu.ly/assets/uploads/pagedownloads/70b47-.pdf :
28 .2017

199


1
.

" "
2.

.
3
.

.

.
.

4
.

. 30 . 1

.2012 http://www.alhayat.com/Details/448571 : 28 :
.2017
2
" " 13 . .2014
.http://www.alwasat.ly/ar/news/libya/31011 28 : .2017
3
" " 13 . .2014
/http://www.alhadath.net/alhadath/2014/08/13------
- .html. 28 : .2017
4
. . . .

200
 2011
.

. "" ""


.
.


.
1
24 .2014

.
.

.5

.
2.
.

.

1
" . " . 24 . .2014
.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nW7xOh75Fvc : 28 :
.2017
2
. . : 1 .
.2015

201
 23 2015 ( )12
.

.

. 28 2015
"
[ ...]
" 1.
.
6
2015 .
.

( )211 ( )12
.
. ( )7 "
" "
" []
" [ ]" .

.

" " .

" " 23 . 1

.2015 .https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sUVQ80qaY14 :
28 : .2017

202
 .

.

2011 .

1
.

2
.

( .)30

.

.
.

1 ( )106 ( )12 )6( : ( )3

( )3
.
.
2
.
17 . .2015 :
https://www.facebook.com/downtownlibya/photos/pcb.765975870124576/76597484
3458012/?type=1&theater

203
 .
.
.
.

( )159-153
. :

.
:
:
... .
.

.


.

.


.
( .)2/191

20 2015 .
.

.
.

204
 .
.


.
. 6 2015

1
.

.

.

2. 28 2016 ( )11
.
.

3
.

.

.

1
Draft Constitution to be ready by 20 October: Tarhouni, Libyaherlad. 6
September 2015. Available online: https://www.libyaherald.com/2015/09/06/draft-
constitution-to-be-ready-by-20-october-tarhouni/
2
" .
"
14 . .2015 http://www.akhbarlibya24.net/2015/10/14/ :-
---- ./ 28 : .2017

3
" 11 " " " . 28 . .2016
/http://alwasat.ly/ar/news/libya/94137 : 29 : .2017

205


""
1
.

27 2015 3 2016
.
.
. ( )2
( )3 :

: ( )109
( )102 ( )147
.

.
( )8 ( )7
. "
"

.

.

( .)58

( .)111 "" %25
( )3 .

1
" " . :
.2016 . http://www.eanlibya.com/wp-:
.content/uploads/2016/02/photovfk7l1ifkx.pdf 29 : .2017

206
 3 2016

1
.

.
.

: .

.
. :

.
16
2016 34 39
.
21 2016
. .

2
.2016

.
6 : 6

1
3 . .2016 . :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MJJjtYzPIk 28 : .2017
2
" " 7 . .2016 .
.https://www.218tv.net/ 29 : .2017

207
" "
. 16 2017

. 18 2017

. 1 .
29 2017 43 44
2
.

.
:
2017
32 : 78
26 : 20 .

"
" . "" ""
" " "



3
".

""
18 . .2017 . 1

http://www.alwasat.ly/ar/news/libya/142270/?articleid=142270 :
28 .2017
2
" """ 30 . .2017 .
./http://alwasat.ly/ar/news/libya/148798 29 : .2017
3
"" : " "31 .
.2017 /http://alwasat.ly/ar/news/libya/148829 . 29 :
.2017

208

1
.
. 16 2017
2.

.
.

.

.

.
.


.
.


.

1
" .. " 4 . .2017 .
./http://alwasat.ly/ar/news/libya/149217 29 : .2017
2
" : " " 18 . .2017 .
./http://alwasat.ly/ar/news/libya/150443 29 : .2017

209
 .
:



:

.

.

210


7102

211