LOADINGS:

Partition Load = 1000 Pa

Ceiling Load = 1000 Pa

Floor Finish = 600 Pa

Water Proofing = 500 Pa

Size of Beams:
@ Roof Level

300 x 400 mm
@ Second Floor Level

400 x 500 mm

Size of Columns:
@ Roof Level:

350 x 350 mm
@ Second Floor Level

450 x 450 mm

Slab Thickness:
@ Roof Level

130 mm

@ Second Floor Level

150 mm
 COMPUTATION OF DEAD LOADS:
@ ROOF LEVEL:
Slab kN 3818.75 kN
(
¿ ( 0.130 m ) 23.5
m 3 )
( 1250 m2 ) =¿
Ceiling ¿ ( 1.00 kPa ) ( 1250 m2 ) =¿ 1250.00 kN
Floor Finishes ¿ ( 0.60 kPa ) ( 1250 m 2) =¿ 750.00 kN
Partition 3.5 m 262.50 kN
¿ ( 1.00 kPa ) ( 0.30 m )
2( )
( 500 m )=¿
Beam kN 1410.00 kN
(
¿ ( 0.30 m )( 0.40 m ) 23.5 3 ( 500 m )=¿
m )
Column 3.5 m kN 302.27 kN
¿ ( 0.35 m )( 0.35 m ) ( 2 )( )
23.5 3 ( 60 pcs . )=¿
m
2
Water Proof ¿ ( 0.50 kPa ) ( 1250 m ) =¿ 625.00kN
W roof = 8,418.52 kN

@ SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

Slab kN 4406.25 kN
(
¿ ( 0.150 m ) 23.5
m 3 )
( 1250 m2 ) =¿
Ceiling ¿ ( 1.00 kPa ) ( 1250 m2 ) =¿ 1250.00 kN
Floor 750.00 kN
¿ ( 0.60 kPa ) ( 1250 m 2) =¿
Finishes
Partition
¿ ( 1.00 kPa ) ( 0.30 m) ( 3.82 m + 4.002 m ) ( 500 m )=¿ 585.00 kN

Beam kN 2350.00 kN
¿ ( 0.40 m )( 0.50 m ) 23.5
(m 3 )
( 500 m )=¿

Column 3.80 m 4.00 kN 999.69kN

[
¿ ( 0.40 m ) ( 0.40 m) ( 2 )
+ ( 0.45 ) ( 0.45 )
2 ( )] (
23.5 3 ( 60 pcs )=¿
m )
W 2nd = 10,340.94 kN

@ GROUND FLOOR LEVEL:

W column =( 0.45 mx 0.45 m ) ( 60 pcs ) ( 4.002 m )(23.5 kNm )=571.05 kN

3

TOTALWEIGHT =W ROOF +W 3 rd +W 2nd + W ground =28,572.05≈ 28,570 kN

Storey Ct hn(m) T (secs) S C C corr C/Rw C/Rw corr

Roof Deck 0.075 11.3 0.465 1.5 3.124 2.75 0.344 0.344
3rd Floor 0.075 7.8 0.353 1.5 3.754 2.75 0.344 0.344
2nd Floor 0.075 4 0.216 1.5 5.208 2.75 0.344 0.344
SEISMIC LOAD:

V – Base Shear

Z – Seismic Zone Factor (Table 2-2A)

Rw - Numerical Coefficient (Table 2-2G)

I – Importance Factor (Table 2-2D)

W – Total Seismic Dead Load (Sec.2.2.5.1.3)

C – Numerical Coefficient

S – Site Coefficient for Soil Characteristics (Table 2-2B)

T – Fundamental Period of Vibration (in seconds) of the Structure under Construction (Sec. 2.2.5.2.2)

C t - 0.075 for Reinforced Concrete Moment Resisting Space frames and Eccentric Braced Steel Frames

DESIGN OF BASE SHEAR:

Where:

Z = 0.40 (Zone 4)

I = 1.15
Rw = 8

C = 2.75

ZIC 0.40 ( 1.15 )( 2.75 )

V= W total= ( 28,570 kN )=4517.63 kN
Rw 8

FORCE DISTRIBUTION:
( V −F t ) W x hx
F x=
∑ W x hx

SinceT =0.465 sec<0.70 sec ; Ft =0

STOREY LEVEL W x ∈ kN h x ∈meters W x h x ∈kN−m

ROOF 8,418.52 11.30 95,129.28
THIRD FLOOR 9,241.54 7.80 72,084.01
SECOND FLOOR 10,340.94 4.00 41,363.76
 ∑ W x hx 208,577.05
@ ROOF LEVEL:

( 4517.63−0 )
F Roof = ( 95129.28 )=2060.43 kN
208,577.05

@ SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

( 4517.63−0 )
F 2nd = ( 41,363.76 )=895.91 kN
208,577.05

@ TRANSVERSAL SECTION:

2060.43
F roof = =228.94 kN ≈ 228.90 kN
9

895.91
F 2nd = =99.546 kN ≈ 99.550 kN
9

@ LONGITUDINAL SECTION:

2060.43
F roof = =228.94 kN ≈ 228.90 kN
9

895.91
F 2nd = =99.546 kN ≈ 99.550 kN
9

SEISMIC LOAD – LONGITUDINAL SECTION

(FACTOR METHOD)

COMPUTATION OF STIFFNESS
I
K=
L
Where:

b h3
I=
12
 L=length of beams∧columns

FOR COLUMNS:

@ GROUND FLOOR TO SECOND FLOOR:

3
I 450 ( 450 )
K= = =85 × 104 mm3
L 12 ( 4000 )

@ SECOND FLOOR TO THIRD FLOOR:

3
I 400 ( 400 )
K= = =56 × 104 mm3
L 12 ( 3800 )

FOR BEAMS:

@ SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

3
I 400 ( 500 )
K 11−12=K 19−20= = =69× 104 mm3
L 12 ( 6000 )
3
I 400 ( 500 )
K 12−13=K 18−19= = =93 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 ( 4500 )
3
I 400 ( 500 )
K 13−14=K 14−15=K 16−17=K 17−18= = =64 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 ( 6500 )
3
I 400 ( 500 )
K 15−16= = =139 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 (3000 )

@ROOF LEVEL:
3
I 300 ( 400 )
K 31−32=K 39−40= = =27 × 104 mm3
L 12 ( 6000 )
3
I 300 ( 400 )
K 32−33=K 38−39= = =36 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 ( 4500 )
3
I 300 ( 400 )
K 33−34=K 34−35=K 36−37=K 37−38= = =25 ×104 mm3
L 12 ( 6500 )
3
I 300 ( 400 )
K 35−36= = =53 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 (3000 )
 COMPUTATION OF GIRDER FACTOR, G FOR EACH JOINT

GIRDER FACTOR=
∑ K COLUMN
∑ K GIRDER

CONSIDER ROOF LEVEL: 36

G37−36 ¿ =¿ 0.419
86
36 36
G 31−32 ¿ =¿ 0.571
G37−38 ¿ =¿ 0.419
63 86
36 36
G 32−31 ¿ =¿ 0.364
G38−37 ¿ =¿ 0.371
99 97
36 36
G 32−33 ¿ =¿ 0.364
G 38−39 ¿ =¿ 0.371
99 97
36 36
G 33−32 ¿ =¿ 0.371
G 39−38 ¿ =¿ 0.364
97 99
36 36
G 33−34 ¿ =¿ 0.371
G 39−40 ¿ =¿ 0.364
97 99
36 36
G 34−33 ¿ =¿ 0.419
G 40−39 ¿ =¿ 0.571
86 63
36
G 34−35 ¿ =¿ 0.419
86
36
G 35−34 ¿ =¿ 0.316
114
36
G 35−36 ¿ =¿ 0.316
114
36
G 36−35 ¿ =¿ 0.316
114
36
G 36−37 ¿ =¿ 0.316
114
CONSIDER SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

141
G 11−12 ¿ =¿ 0.671
210
141
G 12−11 ¿ =¿ 0.465
303
141
G 12−13 ¿ =¿ 0.465
303
141
G 13−12 ¿ =¿ 0.473
298
141
G 13−14 ¿ =¿ 0.473
298
141
G 14−13 ¿ =¿ 0.524
269
141
G 14−15 ¿ =¿ 0.524
269
141
G 15−14 ¿ =¿ 0.410
344
141
G 15−16 ¿ =¿ 0.410
344
141
G 16−15 ¿ =¿ 0.410
344
141
G 16−17 ¿ =¿ 0.410
344
141
G 17−16 ¿ =¿ 0.524
269
141
G 17−18 ¿ =¿ 0.524
269
141
G 18−17 ¿ =¿ 0.473
298
141
G 18−19 ¿ =¿ 0.473
298
141
G 19−18 ¿ =¿ 0.465
303
141
G19−20 ¿ =¿ 0.465
303
141
G20−19 ¿ =¿ 0.671
210
 COMPUTATION OF COLUMN FACTOR, C
COLUMN FACTOR=1−GIRDER FACTOR
C 40−30 ¿ 1−0.571=¿ 0.429
CONSIDER ROOF TOP:

C 31−21 ¿ 1−0.571=¿ 0.429

C 32−22 ¿ 1−0.364=¿ 0.636

C 33−23 ¿ 1−0.371=¿ 0.629

C 34−24 ¿ 1−0.419=¿ 0.581

C 35−25 ¿ 1−0.316=¿ 0.684

C 36−26 ¿ 1−0.316=¿ 0.684

C 37−27 ¿ 1−0.419=¿ 0.581

C 38−28 ¿ 1−0.371=¿ 0.629

C 39−29 ¿ 1−0.364=¿ 0.636

CONSIDER SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

C 11−21 ¿ 1−0.671=¿ 0.329

C 11−1 ¿ 1−0.671=¿ 0.329
C 12−22 ¿ 1−0.465=¿ 0.535
C 12−2 ¿ 1−0.465=¿ 0.535
C 13−23 ¿ 1−0.473=¿ 0.527
C 13−3 ¿ 1−0.473=¿ 0.527
C 14−24 ¿ 1−0.524=¿ 0.476
C 14−4 ¿ 1−0.524=¿ 0.476
C 15−25 ¿ 1−0.410=¿ 0.590
C 15−5 ¿ 1−0.410=¿ 0.590
C 16−26 ¿ 1−0.410=¿ 0.590
C 16−6 ¿ 1−0.410=¿ 0.590
C 17−27 ¿ 1−0.524=¿ 0.476
C 17−7 ¿ 1−0.524=¿ 0.476
C 18−28 ¿ 1−0.473=¿ 0.527
C 18−8 ¿ 1−0.473=¿ 0.527
C 19−29 ¿ 1−0.465=¿ 0.535
C 19−9 ¿ 1−0.465=¿ 0.535
C 20−30 ¿ 1−0.6710=¿ 0.329
C 20−10 ¿ 1−0.671=¿ 0.329
 COMPUTATION OF GIRDER MOMENT FACTOR, Q
Q 36−35 ¿ 53 ( 0.474 ) =¿ 25.122
Q 36−37 ¿ 25 ( 0.526 )=¿ 13.138
CONSIDER THE ROOF LEVEL:
Q37−36 ¿ 25 ( 0.577 ) =¿ 14.425
Q31−32 ¿ 27 ( 0.753 )=¿ 20.331 Q 37−38 ¿ 25 ( 0.605 )=¿ 15.113
Q32−31 ¿ 27 ( 0.650 ) =¿ 17.550 Q 38−37 ¿ 25 ( 0.581 )=¿ 14.513
Q 32−33 ¿ 36 ( 0.550 )=¿ 19.782 Q38−39 ¿ 36 ( 0.553 )=¿ 19.908
Q 33−32 ¿ 36 ( 0.553 )=¿ 19.908 Q39−38 ¿ 36 ( 0.550 )=¿ 19.782
Q33−34 ¿ 25 ( 0.581 )=¿ 14.513 Q 39−40 ¿ 27 ( 0.650 ) =¿ 17.550
Q 34−33 ¿ 25 ( 0.605 )=¿ 15.113 Q 40−39 ¿ 27 ( 0.753 )=¿ 20.331
Q34−35 ¿ 25 ( 0.577 ) =¿ 14.425
Q 35−34 ¿ 25 ( 0.526 )=¿ 13.138
Q 35−36 ¿ 53 ( 0.474 ) =¿ 25.122
CONSIDER THE SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

Q 11−12 ¿ 69 ( 0.904 ) =¿ 62.376

Q 12−11 ¿ 69 ( 0.801 )=¿ 55.269
Q 12−13 ¿ 93 ( 0.702 )=¿ 65.286
Q 13−12 ¿ 93 ( 0.706 ) =¿ 65.658
Q 13−14 ¿ 64 ( 0.735 )=¿ 47.040
Q 14−13 ¿ 64 ( 0.761 ) =¿ 48.704
Q 14−15 ¿ 64 ( 0.729 )=¿ 46.656
Q 15−14 ¿ 64 ( 0.672 ) =¿ 43.008
Q 15−16 ¿ 139 ( 0.615 )=¿ 85.485
Q16−15 ¿ 139 ( 0.615 )=¿ 85.485
Q 16−17 ¿ 64 ( 0.672 ) =¿ 43.008
Q 17−16 ¿ 64 ( 0.729 )=¿ 46.656
Q 17−18 ¿ 64 ( 0.761 ) =¿ 48.704
Q 18−17 ¿ 64 ( 0.735 )=¿ 47.040
Q18−19 ¿ 93 ( 0.706 ) =¿ 65.658
Q19−18 ¿ 93 ( 0.702 )=¿ 65.286
Q 19−20 ¿ 69 ( 0.801 )=¿ 55.269
Q20−19 ¿ 69 ( 0.904 ) =¿ 62.376
COMPUTATION OF COLUMN MOMENT FACTOR, Q

CONSIDER THE SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

Q 21−11 ¿ 56 ( 0.489 )=¿ 27.356
Q11−21 ¿ 56 ( 0.491 )=¿ 27.496
Q 22−12 ¿ 56 ( 0.796 ) =¿ 44.548
Q12−22 ¿ 56 ( 0.799 )=¿ 44.744
Q23−13 ¿ 56 ( 0.785 )=¿ 43.932
Q13−23 ¿ 56 ( 0.788 )=¿ 44.100
Q 24−14 ¿ 56 ( 0.709 )=¿ 39.704
Q14−24 ¿ 56 ( 0.712 )=¿ 39.844
Q25−15 ¿ 56 ( 0.881 )=¿ 49.336
Q15−25 ¿ 56 ( 0.883 )=¿ 49.448
Q 26−16 ¿ 56 ( 0.881 )=¿ 49.336
Q16−26 ¿ 56 ( 0.883 )=¿ 49.448
Q 27−17 ¿ 56 ( 0.881 )=¿ 39.704
Q17−27 ¿ 56 ( 0.712 )=¿ 39.844
Q 28−18 ¿ 56 ( 0.785 )=¿ 43.932
Q 18−28 ¿ 56 ( 0.788 )=¿ 44.100
Q29−19 ¿ 56 ( 0.796 ) =¿ 44.548
Q19−29 ¿ 56 ( 0.799 )=¿ 44.744
Q 30−20 ¿ 56 ( 0.489 )=¿ 27.356
Q 20−30 ¿ 56 ( 0.491 )=¿ 27.496

∑ Q=¿ ¿ 821.016
CONSIDER THE GROUND FLOOR:

Q 11−1 ¿ 85 ( 1.165 )=¿ 98.983

Q 1−11 ¿ 85 ( 0.829 )=¿ 70.465
Q12−2 ¿ 85 ( 1.268 )=¿ 107.738
Q 2−12 ¿ 85 ( 1.035 )=¿ 87.975
Q 13−3 ¿ 85 ( 1.268 )=¿ 107.738
Q 3−13 ¿ 85 ( 1.035 )=¿ 87.975
Q 14−4 ¿ 85 ( 1.264 ) =¿ 105.230
Q 4 −14 ¿ 85 ( 1.027 )=¿ 82.960
Q 15−5 ¿ 85 ( 1.238 )=¿ 110.075
Q 5−15 ¿ 85 ( 0.976 ) =¿ 92.650
Q 16−6 ¿ 85 ( 1.238 )=¿ 110.075
Q 6−16 ¿ 85 ( 0.976 ) =¿ 92.650
Q 17−7 ¿ 85 ( 1.264 ) =¿ 105.230
Q 7−17 ¿ 85 ( 1.027 )=¿ 82.960
Q 18−8 ¿ 85 ( 1.035 )=¿ 107.738
Q 8−18 ¿ 85 ( 1.051 )=¿ 87.975
Q 19−9 ¿ 85 ( 1.268 )=¿ 107.738
Q 9−19 ¿ 85 ( 1.035 )=¿ 87.975
Q20−10 ¿ 85 ( 1.165 )=¿ 98.983
Q 10−20 ¿ 85 ( 0.829 )=¿ 70.465

∑ Q=¿ ¿ 1901.538
 COMPUTATION FOR CONSTANT, N X

N X=
∑ H ( h)
∑ QCOLUMN
Where:

N X - Moment constant at x storey

∑ H - Sum of the lateral forces for the storey

∑ QCOLUMN - Sum of all column moment factor for the storey
h – Height of every storey

2ND
FLOOR
EQ= 821
EH= 402.4
h= 3.8
402.4 X 3.8
N=   821  

N= 1.862473

1ST FLOOR
1901.53
EQ= 8
EH= 501.95
h= 4
 501.95 X 4
N=   1902  

N= 1.055882

COMPUTATION FOR COLUMN MOMENT

M =N X ( COLUMN MOMENT FACTOR )

FOR THE SECOND FLOOR:

M 21−11 ¿ 0.1284 ( 27.356 )=¿ 3.513

M 11−21 ¿ 0.1284 ( 27.496 )=¿ 3.531
M 22−12 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.548 )=¿ 5.720
M 12−22 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.744 )=¿ 5.745
M 23−13 ¿ 0.1284 ( 43.932 )=¿ 5.641
M 13−23 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.100 )=¿ 5.663
M 24−14 ¿ 0.1284 ( 39.704 )=¿ 5.098
M 14−24 ¿ 0.1284 ( 39.844 )=¿ 5.116
M 25−15 ¿ 0.1284 ( 49.336 )=¿ 6.335
M 15−25 ¿ 0.1284 ( 49.448 )=¿ 6.349
M 26−16 ¿ 0.1284 ( 49.336 )=¿ 6.335
M 16−26 ¿ 0.1284 ( 49.448 )=¿ 6.349
M 27−17 ¿ 0.1284 ( 39.704 )=¿ 5.098
M 17−27 ¿ 0.1284 ( 39.844 )=¿ 5.116
M 28−18 ¿ 0.1284 ( 43.932 )=¿ 5.641
M 18−28 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.100 )=¿ 5.663
 M 29−19 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.548 )=¿ 5.720
M 19−29 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.744 )=¿ 5.745
M 30−20 ¿ 0.1284 ( 27.356 )=¿ 3.513
M 20−30 ¿ 0.1284 ( 27.496 )=¿ 3.531

FOR THE FIRST FLOOR:

M 11−1 ¿ 0.0884 ( 70.465 )=¿ 6.231

M 1−11 ¿ 0.0884 ( 98.983 )=¿ 8.753
M 12−2 ¿ 0.0884 ( 87.975 ) =¿ 7.780
M 2−12 ¿ 0.0884 ( 107.738 ) =¿ 9.528
M 13−3 ¿ 0.0884 ( 87.295 ) =¿ 7.720
M 3−13 ¿ 0.0884 ( 107.398 ) =¿ 9.498
M 14−4 ¿ 0.0884 ( 82.960 )=¿ 7.336
M 4−14 ¿ 0.0884 ( 105.230 ) =¿ 9.306
M 15−5 ¿ 0.0884 ( 92.650 )=¿ 8.193
M 5−15 ¿ 0.0884 ( 110.075 )=¿ 9.734
M 16−6 ¿ 0.0884 ( 92.650 )=¿ 8.193
M 6−16 ¿ 0.0884 ( 110.075 )=¿ 9.734
M 17−7 ¿ 0.0884 ( 82.960 )=¿ 7.336
M 7−17 ¿ 0.0884 ( 105.230 ) =¿ 9.306
M 18−8 ¿ 0.0884 ( 87.295 ) =¿ 7.720
M 8−18 ¿ 0.0884 ( 107.398 ) =¿ 9.498
M 19−9 ¿ 0.0884 ( 87.975 ) =¿ 7.780
M 9−19 ¿ 0.0884 ( 107.738 ) =¿ 9.528
M 20−10 ¿ 0.0884 ( 70.465 )=¿ 6.231
M 10−20 ¿ 0.0884 ( 98.983 )=¿ 8.753

COMPUTATION OF JOINT FACTOR; J FOR GIRDER

J=
∑ M column moment at joint
∑ Q girder at joint

CONSIDER THE ROOF LEVEL:

 1.610
@ JOINT 31= =0.079
20.331
2.451
@ JOINT 32= =0.066
17.550+19.782
2.423
@ JOINT 33= =0.070
19.908+14.513
2.224
@ JOINT 34= =0.075
15.113+14.425
2.661
@ JOINT 35= =0.070
13.138+25.122
2.661
@ JOINT 36= =0.070
13.138+25.122
2.224
@ JOINT 37= =0.075
15.113+14.425
2.423
@ JOINT 38= =0.070
19.908+14.513
2.451
@ JOINT 39= =0.066
17.550+19.782
1.610
@ JOINT 40= =0.079
20.331

CONSIDER THE THIRD FLOOR LEVEL:

3.513+1.467
@ JOINT 21= =0.124
40.128
5.720+2.304
@ JOINT 22= =0.103
35.640+41.979
5.641+2.276
@ JOINT 23= =0.109
42.185+30.484
5.098+2.074
@ JOINT 24 = =0.116
31.509+30.176
6.335+2.528
@ JOINT 25 = =0.107
27.819+55.269
6.335+2.528
@ JOINT 26= =0.107
27.819+55.269
5.098+2.074
@ JOINT 27= =0.116
31.509+30.176
5.641+2.276
@ JOINT 28= =0.109
42.185+30.484
 5.720+2.304
@ JOINT 29= =0.103
35.640+41.979
3.513+1.467
@ JOINT 30= =0.124
40.128

CONSIDER THE SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

6.231+3.531
@ JOINT 11 = =0.157
62.376
7.780+5.745
@ JOINT 12= =0.112
55.269+ 65.286
7.720+5.663
@ JOINT 13= =0.119
65.658+47.040
7.336+5.116
@ JOINT 14= =0.131
48.704 +46.656
8.193+6.349
@ JOINT 15= =0.113
43.008+85.485
8.193+6.349
@ JOINT 16= =0.113
43.008+ 85.485
7.336+5.116
@ JOINT 17= =0.131
48.704 +46.656
7.720+5.663
@ JOINT 18= =0.119
65.658+47.040
7.780+5.745
@ JOINT 19= =0.112
55.269+65.286
6.231+3.531
@ JOINT 20= =0.157
62.376

COMPUTATION OF GIRDER MOMENT

M =J ( GIRDER MOMENT FACTOR )

CONSIDER THE ROOF LEVEL: M 31−32 = 1.441 x 20.331 = 29.297

 M 32−31 = 1.195 x 17.550 = 20.972 M 36−37 = 1.265 x 13.138 = 16.620
M 32−33 = 1.195 x 19.782 = 23.639 M 37−36 = 1.37 x 14.425 = 19.762
M 33−32 = 1.281 x 19.908 = 25.502 M 37−38 = 1.37 x 15.113 = 20.705
M 33−34 = 1.281 x 14.513 = 18.591 M 38−37 = 1.281 x 14.513 = 18.591
M 34−33 = 1.37 x 15.113 = 20.705 M 38−39 = 1.281 x 19.908 = 25.502
M 34−35 = 1.37 x 14.425 = 19.762 M 39−38 = 1.195 x 19.782 = 23.639
M 35−34 = 1.265 x 13.138 = 16.620 M 39−40 = 1.195 x 17.537 = 20.957
M 35−36 = 1.265 x 25.122 = 31.779 M 40−39 = 1.441 x 20.331 = 29.297
M 36−35 = 1.265 x 25.122 = 31.779

CONSIDER THE SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

M 11−12 = 1.935 x 40.12 = 77.64
M 12−11 = 1.609 x 8
35.64 = 57.34
M 12−13 = 1.609 x 0
41.97 = 67.54
M 13−12 = 1.696 x 9
42.18 = 71.54
M 13−14 = 1.696 x 5
30.48 = 51.70
M 14−13 = 1.811 x 4
31.50 = 57.06
M 14−15 = 1.811 x 9
30.17 = 54.64
M 15−14 = 1.659 x 6
27.81 = 46.15
M 15−16 = 1.659 x 9
55.26 = 91.69
M 16−15 = 1.659 x 9
55.26 = 91.69
M 16−17 = 1.659 x 9
27.81 = 46.15
M 17−16 = 1.811 x 9
30.17 = 54.64
M 17−18 = 1.811 x 6
31.50 = 57.06
M 18−17 = 1.696 x 9
30.48 = 51.70
M 18−19 = 1.696 x 4
42.18 = 71.54
M 19−18 = 1.609 x 5
41.97 = 67.54
M 19−20 = 1.609 x 9
35.64 = 57.34
M 20−19 = 1.935 x 0
40.12 = 77.64
8

SUMMARY TABLE
LONGITUDINAL SECTION – FACTOR METHOD
 MOMENT kN-m
JOINT MEMBERS
GIRDER COLUMN
1 1-11 104.514
2 2-12 113.759
3 3-13 113.400
4 4-14 111.110
5 5-15 116.226
6  6-16 116.226
7  7-17 111.110
8  8-18 113.400
9  9-19 113.759
10  10-20 104.514
 11-1 74.403
11  11-12 125.625  
    11-21 51.211
 12-2 92.891
12  12-11 80.803  
    12-13 95.448  
   12-22 83.334
 13-3 92.173
13  13-12 101.573  
   13-14 72.771  
   13-23 82.135
 14-4 87.596
14  14-13 82.651  
    14-15 79.175  
   14-24 74.208
 15-5 97.827
15  15-14 63.566  
    15-16 126.347  
   15-25 92.096
 16-6 97.827
16  16-15 126.347  
    16-17 63.566  
   16-26 92.096
 17-7 87.596
17  17-16 79.175  
    17-18 82.651  
   17-27 74.208
 18-8 92.173
18  18-17 72.771  
   18-19 101.573  
   18-28 82.135
 19-9 92.891
19  19-18 95.448  
    19-20 80.803  
   19-29 83.334
 20-10 74.403
20  20-19 125.625
    20-30 51.211
 21-11 50.950
21  21-22 77.648  
    21-31 26.685
 22-12 82.969
22  22-21 57.345  
    22-23 67.544  
   22-32 41.923
 23-13 81.822
23  23-22 71.546  
    23-24 51.701  
   23-33 41.403
 24-14 73.948
 SEISMIC LOAD – TRANSVERSAL SECTION
(FACTOR METHOD)

COMPUTATION OF STIFFNESS
I
K=
L
Where:

b h3
I=
12
L=length of beams∧columns

FOR COLUMNS:

@ GROUND FLOOR TO SECOND FLOOR:

3
I 450 ( 450 )
K= = =85 × 104 mm3
L 12 ( 4000 )

@ SECOND FLOOR TO THIRD FLOOR:

3
I 400 ( 400 )
K= = =56 × 104 mm3
L 12 ( 3800 )

FOR BEAMS:

@ SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

3
I 400 ( 500 )
K 11−12=K 19−20= = =69× 104 mm3
L 12 ( 6000 )
3
I 400 ( 500 )
K 12−13=K 18−19= = =93 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 ( 4500 )
3
I 400 ( 500 )
K 13−14=K 14−15=K 16−17=K 17−18= = =64 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 ( 6500 )
3
I 400 ( 500 )
K 15−16= = =139 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 (3000 )

@ROOF LEVEL:
3
I 300 ( 400 )
K 31−32=K 39−40= = =27 × 104 mm3
L 12 ( 6000 )
3
I 300 ( 400 )
K 32−33=K 38−39= = =36 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 ( 4500 )
3
I 300 ( 400 )
K 33−34=K 34−35=K 36−37=K 37−38= = =25 ×104 mm3
L 12 ( 6500 )
 3
I 300 ( 400 )
K 35−36= = =53 ×10 4 mm3
L 12 (3000 )

COMPUTATION OF GIRDER FACTOR, G FOR EACH JOINT

GIRDER FACTOR=
∑ K COLUMN
∑ K GIRDER

CONSIDER ROOF LEVEL: 36

G 37−36 ¿ =¿ 0.419
86
36 36
G 31−32 ¿ =¿ 0.571
G 37−38 ¿ =¿ 0.419
63 86
36 36
G 32−31 ¿ =¿ 0.364
G 38−37 ¿ =¿ 0.371
99 97
36 36
G32−33 ¿ =¿ 0.364
G 38−39 ¿ =¿ 0.371
99 97
36 36
G33−32 ¿ =¿ 0.371
G 39−38 ¿ =¿ 0.364
97 99
36 36
G33−34 ¿ =¿ 0.371
G 39−40 ¿ =¿ 0.364
97 99
36 36
G34−33 ¿ =¿ 0.419
G 40−39 ¿ =¿ 0.571
86 63
36
G34−35 ¿ =¿ 0.419
86
36
G35−34 ¿ =¿ 0.316
114
36
G35−36 ¿ =¿ 0.316
114
36
G36−35 ¿ =¿ 0.316
114
36
G36−37 ¿ =¿ 0.316
114
CONSIDER SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

141
G11−12 ¿ =¿ 0.671
210
141
G12−11 ¿ =¿ 0.465
303
141
G12−13 ¿ =¿ 0.465
303
141
G13−12 ¿ =¿ 0.473
298
141
G13−14 ¿ =¿ 0.473
298
141
G14−13 ¿ =¿ 0.524
269
141
G14−15 ¿ =¿ 0.524
269
141
G15−14 ¿ =¿ 0.410
344
141
G15−16 ¿ =¿ 0.410
344
141
G16−15 ¿ =¿ 0.410
344
141
G16−17 ¿ =¿ 0.410
344
141
G17−16 ¿ =¿ 0.524
269
141
G17−18 ¿ =¿ 0.524
269
141
G18−17 ¿ =¿ 0.473
298
141
G 18−19 ¿ =¿ 0.473
298
141
G 19−18 ¿ =¿ 0.465
303
141
G19−20 ¿ =¿ 0.465
303
141
G20−19 ¿ =¿ 0.671
210
 COMPUTATION OF COLUMN FACTOR, C
COLUMN FACTOR=1−GIRDER FACTOR
C 40−30 ¿ 1−0.571=¿ 0.429
CONSIDER ROOF TOP:

C 31−21 ¿ 1−0.571=¿ 0.429

C 32−22 ¿ 1−0.364=¿ 0.636

C 33−23 ¿ 1−0.371=¿ 0.629

C 34−24 ¿ 1−0.419=¿ 0.581

C 35−25 ¿ 1−0.316=¿ 0.684

C 36−26 ¿ 1−0.316=¿ 0.684

C 37−27 ¿ 1−0.419=¿ 0.581

C 38−28 ¿ 1−0.371=¿ 0.629

C 39−29 ¿ 1−0.364=¿ 0.636

CONSIDER SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

C 11−21 ¿ 1−0.671=¿ 0.329

C 11−1 ¿ 1−0.671=¿ 0.329
C 12−22 ¿ 1−0.465=¿ 0.535
C 12−2 ¿ 1−0.465=¿ 0.535
C 13−23 ¿ 1−0.473=¿ 0.527
C 13−3 ¿ 1−0.473=¿ 0.527
C 14−24 ¿ 1−0.524=¿ 0.476
C 14−4 ¿ 1−0.524=¿ 0.476
C 15−25 ¿ 1−0.410=¿ 0.590
C 15−5 ¿ 1−0.410=¿ 0.590
C 16−26 ¿ 1−0.410=¿ 0.590
C 16−6 ¿ 1−0.410=¿ 0.590
C 17−27 ¿ 1−0.524=¿ 0.476
C 17−7 ¿ 1−0.524=¿ 0.476
C 18−28 ¿ 1−0.473=¿ 0.527
C 18−8 ¿ 1−0.473=¿ 0.527
C 19−29 ¿ 1−0.465=¿ 0.535
C 19−9 ¿ 1−0.465=¿ 0.535
C 20−30 ¿ 1−0.6710=¿ 0.329
C 20−10 ¿ 1−0.671=¿ 0.329
 COMPUTATION OF GIRDER MOMENT FACTOR, Q

CONSIDER THE ROOF LEVEL:

Q31−32 ¿ 27 ( 0.753 )=¿ 20.331

Q32−31 ¿ 27 ( 0.650 ) =¿ 17.550
Q 32−33 ¿ 36 ( 0.550 )=¿ 19.782
Q 33−32 ¿ 36 ( 0.553 )=¿ 19.908
Q33−34 ¿ 25 ( 0.581 )=¿ 14.513
Q 34−33 ¿ 25 ( 0.605 )=¿ 15.113
Q34−35 ¿ 25 ( 0.577 ) =¿ 14.425
Q 35−34 ¿ 25 ( 0.526 )=¿ 13.138
Q 35−36 ¿ 53 ( 0.474 ) =¿ 25.122
Q 36−35 ¿ 53 ( 0.474 ) =¿ 25.122
Q36−37 ¿ 25 ( 0.526 )=¿ 13.138
Q 37−36 ¿ 25 ( 0.577 ) =¿ 14.425
Q 37−38 ¿ 25 ( 0.605 )=¿ 15.113
Q 38−37 ¿ 25 ( 0.581 )=¿ 14.513
Q38−39 ¿ 36 ( 0.553 )=¿ 19.908
Q39−38 ¿ 36 ( 0.550 )=¿ 19.782
Q 39−40 ¿ 27 ( 0.650 ) =¿ 17.550
Q 40−39 ¿ 27 ( 0.753 )=¿ 20.331
CONSIDER THE SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

Q 11−12 ¿ 69 ( 0.904 ) =¿ 62.376

Q 12−11 ¿ 69 ( 0.801 )=¿ 55.269
Q 12−13 ¿ 93 ( 0.702 )=¿ 65.286
Q 13−12 ¿ 93 ( 0.706 ) =¿ 65.658
Q 13−14 ¿ 64 ( 0.735 )=¿ 47.040
Q 14−13 ¿ 64 ( 0.761 ) =¿ 48.704
Q 14−15 ¿ 64 ( 0.729 )=¿ 46.656
Q 15−14 ¿ 64 ( 0.672 ) =¿ 43.008
Q 15−16 ¿ 139 ( 0.615 )=¿ 85.485
Q16−15 ¿ 139 ( 0.615 )=¿ 85.485
Q 16−17 ¿ 64 ( 0.672 ) =¿ 43.008
Q 17−16 ¿ 64 ( 0.729 )=¿ 46.656
Q 17−18 ¿ 64 ( 0.761 ) =¿ 48.704
Q 18−17 ¿ 64 ( 0.735 )=¿ 47.040
Q18−19 ¿ 93 ( 0.706 ) =¿ 65.658
Q19−18 ¿ 93 ( 0.702 )=¿ 65.286
Q 19−20 ¿ 69 ( 0.801 )=¿ 55.269
Q20−19 ¿ 69 ( 0.904 ) =¿ 62.376
 COMPUTATION OF COLUMN MOMENT FACTOR, Q

CONSIDER THIRD FLOOR LEVEL:

Q 31−21 ¿ 36 ( 0.591 )=¿ 21.276
Q21−31 ¿ 36 ( 0.539 )=¿ 19.386
Q 32−22 ¿ 36 ( 0.900 )=¿ 32.400
Q22−32 ¿ 36 ( 0.846 ) =¿ 30.456
Q33−23 ¿ 36 ( 0.890 )=¿ 32.022
Q23−33 ¿ 36 ( 0.836 ) =¿ 30.078
Q 34−24 ¿ 36 ( 0.817 ) =¿ 29.394
Q 24−34 ¿ 36 ( 0.762 )=¿ 27.414
Q35−25 ¿ 36 ( 0.977 ) =¿ 35.172
Q25−35 ¿ 36 ( 0.928 )=¿ 33.408
Q 36−26 ¿ 36 ( 0.977 ) =¿ 35.172
Q 26−36 ¿ 36 ( 0.928 )=¿ 33.408
Q 37−27 ¿ 36 ( 0.817 ) =¿ 29.394
Q 27−37 ¿ 36 ( 0.762 )=¿ 27.414
Q 38−28 ¿ 36 ( 0.890 )=¿ 32.022
Q28−38 ¿ 36 ( 0.836 ) =¿ 30.078
Q39−29 ¿ 36 ( 0.900 )=¿ 32.400
Q29−39 ¿ 36 ( 0.846 ) =¿ 30.456
Q 40−30 ¿ 36 ( 0.591 )=¿ 21.276
Q30−40 ¿ 36 ( 0.539 )=¿ 19.386

∑ Q=¿ ¿ 582.012
CONSIDER THE GROUND FLOOR:

Q 11−1 ¿ 85 ( 1.165 )=¿ 98.983

Q 1−11 ¿ 85 ( 0.829 )=¿ 70.465
Q 12−2 ¿ 85 ( 1.268 )=¿ 107.738
Q2−12 ¿ 85 ( 1.035 )=¿ 87.975
Q 13−3 ¿ 85 ( 1.268 )=¿ 107.738
Q 3−13 ¿ 85 ( 1.035 )=¿ 87.975
Q 14−4 ¿ 85 ( 1.264 ) =¿ 105.230
Q 4 −14 ¿ 85 ( 1.027 )=¿ 82.960
Q 15−5 ¿ 85 ( 1.238 )=¿ 110.075
Q 5−15 ¿ 85 ( 0.976 ) =¿ 92.650
Q 16−6 ¿ 85 ( 1.238 )=¿ 110.075
Q 6−16 ¿ 85 ( 0.976 ) =¿ 92.650
Q 17−7 ¿ 85 ( 1.264 ) =¿ 105.230
Q 7−17 ¿ 85 ( 1.027 )=¿ 82.960
Q 18−8 ¿ 85 ( 1.035 )=¿ 107.738
Q 8−18 ¿ 85 ( 1.051 )=¿ 87.975
Q 19−9 ¿ 85 ( 1.268 )=¿ 107.738
Q 9−19 ¿ 85 ( 1.035 )=¿ 87.975
Q 20−10 ¿ 85 ( 1.165 )=¿ 98.983
Q10−20 ¿ 85 ( 0.829 )=¿ 70.465
 ∑ Q=¿ ¿ 1901.538

COMPUTATION FOR CONSTANT, N X

N X=
∑ H ( h)
∑ QCOLUMN
Where:

N X - Moment constant at x storey

∑ H - Sum of the lateral forces for the storey

∑ QCOLUMN - Sum of all column moment factor for the storey
h – Height of every storey

2ND
FLOOR
EQ= 821
EH= 402.4
h= 3.8
402.4 X 3.8
N=   821  

N= 1.862473

1ST FLOOR
1901.53
EQ= 8
EH= 501.95
h= 4
N= 501.95 X 4
   1902  

N= 1.055882

COMPUTATION FOR COLUMN MOMENT

M =N X ( COLUMN MOMENT FACTOR )

FOR THE SECOND FLOOR:

M 21−11 ¿ 0.1284 ( 27.356 )=¿ 3.513
M 11−21 ¿ 0.1284 ( 27.496 )=¿ 3.531
M 22−12 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.548 )=¿ 5.720
M 12−22 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.744 )=¿ 5.745
M 23−13 ¿ 0.1284 ( 43.932 )=¿ 5.641
M 13−23 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.100 )=¿ 5.663
M 24−14 ¿ 0.1284 ( 39.704 )=¿ 5.098
M 14−24 ¿ 0.1284 ( 39.844 )=¿ 5.116
M 25−15 ¿ 0.1284 ( 49.336 )=¿ 6.335
M 15−25 ¿ 0.1284 ( 49.448 )=¿ 6.349
M 26−16 ¿ 0.1284 ( 49.336 )=¿ 6.335
M 16−26 ¿ 0.1284 ( 49.448 )=¿ 6.349
M 27−17 ¿ 0.1284 ( 39.704 )=¿ 5.098
M 17−27 ¿ 0.1284 ( 39.844 )=¿ 5.116
M 28−18 ¿ 0.1284 ( 43.932 )=¿ 5.641
M 18−28 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.100 )=¿ 5.663
M 29−19 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.548 )=¿ 5.720
M 19−29 ¿ 0.1284 ( 44.744 )=¿ 5.745
M 30−20 ¿ 0.1284 ( 27.356 )=¿ 3.513
M 20−30 ¿ 0.1284 ( 27.496 )=¿ 3.531
FOR THE FIRST FLOOR:

M 11−1 ¿ 0.0884 ( 70.465 )=¿ 6.231

M 1−11 ¿ 0.0884 ( 98.983 )=¿ 8.753
M 12−2 ¿ 0.0884 ( 87.975 ) =¿ 7.780
M 2−12 ¿ 0.0884 ( 107.738 ) =¿ 9.528
M 13−3 ¿ 0.0884 ( 87.295 ) =¿ 7.720
M 3−13 ¿ 0.0884 ( 107.398 ) =¿ 9.498
M 14−4 ¿ 0.0884 ( 82.960 )=¿ 7.336
M 4−14 ¿ 0.0884 ( 105.230 ) =¿ 9.306
M 15−5 ¿ 0.0884 ( 92.650 )=¿ 8.193
M 5−15 ¿ 0.0884 ( 110.075 )=¿ 9.734
M 16−6 ¿ 0.0884 ( 92.650 )=¿ 8.193
M 6−16 ¿ 0.0884 ( 110.075 )=¿ 9.734
M 17−7 ¿ 0.0884 ( 82.960 )=¿ 7.336
M 7−17 ¿ 0.0884 ( 105.230 ) =¿ 9.306
M 18−8 ¿ 0.0884 ( 87.295 ) =¿ 7.720
M 8−18 ¿ 0.0884 ( 107.398 ) =¿ 9.498
M 19−9 ¿ 0.0884 ( 87.975 ) =¿ 7.780
M 9−19 ¿ 0.0884 ( 107.738 ) =¿ 9.528
M 20−10 ¿ 0.0884 ( 70.465 )=¿ 6.231
M 10−20 ¿ 0.0884 ( 98.983 )=¿ 8.753
COMPUTATION OF JOINT FACTOR; J FOR GIRDER

J=
∑ M column moment at joint
∑ Q girder at joint

CONSIDER THE ROOF LEVEL:

1.610
@ JOINT 31= =0.079
20.331
2.451
@ JOINT 32= =0.066
17.550+19.782
2.423
@ JOINT 33= =0.070
19.908+14.513
2.224
@ JOINT 34= =0.075
15.113+14.425
2.661
@ JOINT 35= =0.070
13.138+25.122
2.661
@ JOINT 36= =0.070
13.138+25.122
2.224
@ JOINT 37= =0.075
15.113+14.425
2.423
@ JOINT 38= =0.070
19.908+14.513
2.451
@ JOINT 39= =0.066
17.550+19.782
1.610
@ JOINT 40= =0.079
20.331
CONSIDER THE THIRD FLOOR LEVEL:

3.513+1.467
@ JOINT 21= =0.124
40.128
5.720+2.304
@ JOINT 22= =0.103
35.640+41.979
5.641+2.276
@ JOINT 23= =0.109
42.185+30.484
5.098+2.074
@ JOINT 24 = =0.116
31.509+30.176
6.335+2.528
@ JOINT 25 = =0.107
27.819+55.269
6.335+2.528
@ JOINT 26= =0.107
27.819+55.269
5.098+2.074
@ JOINT 27= =0.116
31.509+30.176
5.641+2.276
@ JOINT 28= =0.109
42.185+30.484
5.720+2.304
@ JOINT 29= =0.103
35.640+41.979
3.513+1.467
@ JOINT 30= =0.124
40.128

CONSIDER THE SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

6.231+3.531
@ JOINT 11 = =0.157
62.376
7.780+5.745
@ JOINT 12= =0.112
55.269+ 65.286
7.720+5.663
@ JOINT 13= =0.119
65.658+47.040
7.336+5.116
@ JOINT 14= =0.131
48.704 +46.656
8.193+6.349
@ JOINT 15= =0.113
43.008+85.485
8.193+6.349
@ JOINT 16= =0.113
43.008+ 85.485
7.336+5.116
@ JOINT 17= =0.131
48.704 +46.656
 7.720+5.663
@ JOINT 18= =0.119
65.658+47.040
7.780+5.745
@ JOINT 19= =0.112
55.269+65.286
6.231+3.531
@ JOINT 20= =0.157
62.376

COMPUTATION OF GIRDER MOMENT

M =J ( GIRDER MOMENT FACTOR )

CONSIDER THE ROOF LEVEL: M 36−35 = 1.265 x 25.122 = 31.779

M 36−37 = 1.265 x 13.138 = 16.620
M 31−32 = 1.441 x 20.331 = 29.297 M 37−36 = 1.37 x 14.425 = 19.762
M 32−31 = 1.195 x 17.550 = 20.972 M 37−38 = 1.37 x 15.113 = 20.705
M 32−33 = 1.195 x 19.782 = 23.639 M 38−37 = 1.281 x 14.513 = 18.591
M 33−32 = 1.281 x 19.908 = 25.502 M 38−39 = 1.281 x 19.908 = 25.502
M 33−34 = 1.281 x 14.513 = 18.591 M 39−38 = 1.195 x 19.782 = 23.639
M 34−33 = 1.37 x 15.113 = 20.705 M 39−40 = 1.195 x 17.537 = 20.957
M 34−35 = 1.37 x 14.425 = 19.762 M 40−39 = 1.441 x 20.331 = 29.297
M 35−34 = 1.265 x 13.138 = 16.620
M 35−36 = 1.265 x 25.122 = 31.779

CONSIDER THE SECOND FLOOR LEVEL:

M 11−12 = 1.935 x 40.12 = 77.64
M 12−11 = 1.609 x 8
35.64 = 57.34
M 12−13 = 1.609 x 0
41.97 = 67.54
M 13−12 = 1.696 x 9
42.18 = 71.54
M 13−14 = 1.696 x 5
30.48 = 51.70
M 14−13 = 1.811 x 4
31.50 = 57.06
M 14−15 = 1.811 x 9
30.17 = 54.64
M 15−14 = 1.659 x 6
27.81 = 46.15
M 15−16 = 1.659 x 9
55.26 = 91.69
M 16−15 = 1.659 x 9
55.26 = 91.69
M 16−17 = 1.659 x 9
27.81 = 46.15
M 17−16 = 1.811 x 9
30.17 = 54.64
M 17−18 = 1.811 x 6
31.50 = 57.06
M 18−17 = 1.696 x 9
30.48 = 51.70
M 18−19 = 1.696 x 4
42.18 = 71.54
M 19−18 = 1.609 x 5
41.97 = 67.54
M 19−20 = 1.609 x 9
35.64 = 57.34
M 20−19 = 1.935 x 0
40.12 = 77.64
8
 SUMMARY TABLE
TRANSVERSAL SECTION – FACTOR METHOD
 MOMENT kN-m
JOINT MEMBERS
GIRDER COLUMN
1 1-11 104.514
2 2-12 113.759
3 3-13 113.400
4 4-14 111.110
5 5-15 116.226
6  6-16 116.226
7  7-17 111.110
8  8-18 113.400
9  9-19 113.759
10  10-20 104.514
 11-1 74.403
11  11-12 125.625  
    11-21 51.211
 12-2 92.891
12  12-11 80.803  
    12-13 95.448  
   12-22 83.334
 13-3 92.173
13  13-12 101.573  
   13-14 72.771  
   13-23 82.135
 14-4 87.596
14  14-13 82.651  
    14-15 79.175  
   14-24 74.208
 15-5 97.827
15  15-14 63.566  
    15-16 126.347  
   15-25 92.096
 16-6 97.827
16  16-15 126.347  
    16-17 63.566  
   16-26 92.096
 17-7 87.596
17  17-16 79.175  
    17-18 82.651  
   17-27 74.208
 18-8 92.173
18  18-17 72.771  
   18-19 101.573  
   18-28 82.135
 19-9 92.891
19  19-18 95.448  
    19-20 80.803  
   19-29 83.334
 20-10 74.403
20  20-19 125.625
    20-30 51.211
 21-11 50.950
21  21-22 77.648  
    21-31 26.685
 22-12 82.969
22  22-21 57.345  
    22-23 67.544  
   22-32 41.923
 23-13 81.822
23  23-22 71.546  
    23-24 51.701  
   23-33 41.403
 24-14 73.948