Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Urban Governance
City Organization
The population per city official of Cebu City is 126 persons. This indicator does not
reflect the efficiency of city officials' work. However, it is observed in the city's
frontline services that in order to be cost-effective, the smaller the number is rather
better as this requires a minimal budget for personal services. The present City
organization needs restructuring considering the current demands of modernizing
urban governance, consideration of the new planning directions, both national and
global. Local governance recently shifted from a traditional local government unit to
that of having a corporate power. This new role is provided in the local code of
1991.
Most of the offices are mandatory. Their creations were provided for under the new
local government code, empowering local government units (LGUs) consistent with
the Constitution, through devolution, decentralization and local autonomy policies
of national government.
The exercise of the executive functions of the City is headed by the City Mayor, as
the Chief Executive Officer, which oversees the general supervision and control
over all programs, projects, services and activities of the City.
SANGGUNIANG
PANLUNGSOD
DEPT. OF MANPOWER OFFICE FOR CITY DEPT. OF SOCIAL CITY ASSESOR’S OFFICE OF
DEVT. AND LEGAL SERVICES TREASURER’S WELFARE AND DEVT. OFFICE LOCAL
PLACEMENT OFFICE REGISTRAR
CITY HEALTH DEPT. OF DEPT. OF DEPT. OF VET. DEPT. OF PUBLIC CEBU CITY
DEPARTMENT ENGINEERING AGRICULTURE MEDICNE AND SERVICES MEDICAL CENTER
FISHERIES
CREMDEC was formally created as an independent operational unit in July 14, 1999
through City Ordinance No. 1775. The unit originally was conceptualized in 1987
from the CVRP-1. It was initially established two years after as Regional Resource
Management Training Center (RRMTC) which was institutionalized in 1991 by then
President Aquino through Presidential Proclamation 773 that declared the 9.2
hectare campus in Taptap, Cebu City.
When it was devolved to the Cebu City Government three years later, it was
renamed as the Cebu City Resource Management Training Center through City
Ordinance # 1509. In 1996, it was finally merged with the Hillyland Projects Office
and became the Cebu City Hillyland Resources Management Training and
Development Commission through City Ordinance No. 1609.
The basic goals of CREMDEC is for Cebu City to have an internationally credible
Education and Research Institution that will;
To date, CREMDEC has proved and justified its creation by performing creditably
well in the duties and responsibilities given to it.
Cebu City, in its aim to have a competent, effective, efficient and highly professional
servants, formed the Organization and Management Appraisal Committee or OMAC
in November 1999. CREMDEC was named OMAC Secretariat.
The Committee was tasked to determine the effectiveness and efficiency levels of the
City Hall Employees. It was also tasked to have every department/office come up
with clear goals, objectives and functions with its corresponding structures and
manpower requirements.
In June this year, the TWG of OMAC has submitted the initial outputs of the meetings
and workshops it had conducted the past several weeks. Initial agreements on some
revisions in the organizational structures and the action plan have been identified.
These are shown in Table 2.15.1. The recommendations is reflected in the revised
organizational structure shown in Figure 2.15.2
CHD CCMC DSWS DWUP & DMDP Civil Agriculture & DEMPS DEPW CCTMSD
Housing Registrar Veterinary
Table 2.15.1
Reorganization Agreements
The City of Cebu Port Authority
DEMPS - DEMPS Proposed Organizational Structure has - DPS, CCAT & CCPPC to meet on June
already incorporated/included CCCAT & 29, 2000 at DPS to come up with
CCPPC. appropriate position titles.
- From “Street Cleaning Division” to “Drainage - Ms. Nora del Rosario of DEPW is
Maintenance / Street / Estero Cleaning requested to inform/update Engr.
Division” Sanchez re: transfer of function
especially on Drainage Maintenance
- Bantay Sapa should be under the “River, from DEPW to DEMPS
Coastal Eco. System Division”
- Initially discussed privatization for the - DEMPS to include Bantay Sapa in their
improvement/maintenance of parks, structure.
playground & collection of garbage, etc.; role
of government as overseer.
DEPW - Equipment & Motorpool Division was already - DEPW requested GSD to “return” the
transferred to GSD likewise “transferring” the item/position & the person who heads
items/ positions/ staff concerned the Equipment Division
CCBDC - CAD & Bantay Dagat for incorporation/ - DVMF, CAD & Bantay Dagat to discuss
inclusion in DVMF structure; to be named as separately on the new structure/staffing
Agriculture Veterinary & Fisheries Department, pattern. Meeting is scheduled on June
Vet. As Dept. Head with 2 Asst. Dept. Heads – 1 28, 2000 at Hillyland Conference Room.
Asst. Dept. Head for Agri. & Fisheries Div. & 1
Asst. Dept. Head for Veterinary Medicine Div. TWG recommendations:
CREMDEC - As R & D of the Cebu City government, this - To be attached to the Mayor’s Office.
office should not be attached to any office be it - TWG has recommended CREMDEC to
HRD or Planning. This should be under the be placed at the left side of the
Office of the City Mayor. organizational structure (HUC Model
A-1) before City Admin.
MAYOR’S OFFICE - Admin. Division with 3 Sections, namely: - To include Executive Assistants in the
Property, Records & Business Permit proposed organizational structure
- To c o m e u p w i t h a p r o p o s e d
- Business Permit should remain under organizational structure (from BP
Mayor’s Office to maintain check and balance; Section to BP Division)
CTO shall be responsible in the collection - To submit Position Paper justifying why
only it should remain at the Mayor’s Office
as well as a full blown Division
- Commissions under Office of the Mayor - Abolish/remove Commissions not
should be transferred to a department which existing/ functioning anymore
are inter-related.
CTO - Market management and operations (EEM) - To privatize market management and
can not be absorbed by CTO except the operations
A p p r a i s a l f u n c t i o n w h i c h s h a l l b e- To privatize messengerial services c/o
incorporated in the CTO structure under GSD
“Appraisal Division”
I C O / I N T E R N A L- IAS should not be with Accounting; Accountant - To amend ordinance creating IAS re:
AUDIT SERVICE cannot be an Internal Auditor at the same time; position titles used
(IAS) there’s no check & balance - TWG recommended that all
departments should have operations
- IAS should be under the Office of the Mayor manual by Dec. 2000
instead of under Management Services Cluster
per HUC Model
The institutional development features of the Local Government Code, calls for the
redesigning of the local government structure that would attain cost-effective delivery
of the twenty six basic services all LGUs should provide. However, the degree and
level of delivery of the services, as outlined in the code, depends on the income
classification of LGUs that will be the basis in establishing an appropriate fiscal and
manpower staffing configurations. Per initial review of the basic services delivered,
the City has concentrated first on the Minimum Basic Needs (Survival Needs,
Security Needs and Enabling Needs), which was iniated in 1995.
The basic services and facilities delivered among others, include the following:
- Water Supply, through the Barrio Waterworks System (Level I and II) and the
Barangay Water Service Office delivery trucks
- Social welfare programs, projects and services through the community Day
Care Centers
The City has been subject to criticisms on poor management because of alleged
series of violations of existing Government guidelines the COA Audit findings claimed
in its 1999 Audit Report.
The existing market structure was already demolished that cause displacement
and severe inconvenience to the market vendors that had caused drops in their
daily sales and income. Until now, the project is still suspended.
While the City has submitted to COA their answers and formal clarifications on each
of the above, a deeper assessment of the situation reveals that most of the above
transactions were committed because of the absence of people or staff really
knowledgeable in all aspects of bidding and procurement process for Government
projects and programs who shall sit in the PBAC and/or Committee on Awards at all
times and shall be responsible for ensuring that existing Government regulations are
strictly adhered.
Most of the shortcomings are corrected by the City but unless institutionalized, there
will still be the tendency to deviate from the correct procedures of procurement and
bidding.
The other cause of these violations are short cutting in the prequalification and
bidding procedures in order to start project implementation immediately to catch up
lost times because of shortcomings in forward planning.
The income of the City reached P1,126.47 million in 1998 from P821.13 million in
1994. The annual average growth rate for the 1994-1998 period was 7.9%.
The top-five income generators during the period were the following:
The city revenue per capita in 1998 was P1,624.63. It is noted that the financial
condition of Cebu City is relatively healthier than Lapu-lapu City at P1,426 and Roxas
City at P1,355 but much lesser than Dapitan City at P2,490 and Olongapo city at
P2,300.
Expenditure of the City increased to P1,124.47 million in 1998 from P785.59 million
in 1994. Annual average growth rate of expenditure for the 1994-1998 period was
8.96%. The top-five expenditure items for the last five-year period were the following:
Budget in 1998 was P1,271.78 million with an average annual growth rate of 5.19%
with reference to the 1994-1998 period. Personal Services and MOOE accounted to
36% and 44%, respectively in 1998. Average annual budget for Capital Outlay is
about P270.04 million.
Internal Revenue Allotment (IRA) increased to P456.23 million in 1998 from P336.59
million in 1994 or an average annual growth rate of 7.6%.
The 20% Development Fund was noted to have the lowest growth rate of 2.03%,
among the fiscal indicators available for the 1994-1998 period.
The item on Unliquidated Balances, was the most alarming among fiscal indicators
which grew to P81.86 million in 1998 from P60.89 million in 1994. The average
unliquidated balance was P76.61 million per year during the period.
Likewise, the Local Development Investment Program (LDIP), which translated the
LDP into concrete action plan, is also prepared with the same time frame as the
LDP's. However, its component, the Annual Investment Program or AIP (which also
includes the Capital Investment Program or CIP), rigidly follows the annual budgeting
and programming cycle.
Vertical planning is exercised with inputs from the barangays or community level
planning mostly done through people participatory processes. Horizontal planning is
applied through the sectoral departments and implementing agencies. If new
programs or projects will require national funding, including Official Development
Assistance (ODA) and Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT), an endorsement from the
Regional Development Council or RDC is required.
To date, the City has not yet adopted the LPPM, or the formulation of City
Performance Indicators, as directed by the DILG, Bureau of Local Government
Supervision (BLGS). The LPPM guidelines were released only recently and its
process requires a much longer time of preparation. Inventory of Management Tools,
a subset of the LPPM is also required in this process as this relates to the effective
delivery of basic services and improvement of the internal management system.
One specific indicator that would proximate productivity is the analysis of the Budget
Allocation on a per capita basis. A sample analysis using the 1999 annual budget is
given below:
Table 2.15.2
The 1999 Annual Budget
Figure 2.15.3
1999 Annual Budget Cebu City
Other Services
14%
The City is also the first LGU that accessed direct funding from ODA sources,
specifically, the Japanese Government OECF (now JBIC) for the MCDP III-
South Reclamation Project. The arrangement for the release of the loan
proceeds for the project is coursed through a GFI-conduit Land Bank of the
Philippines (LBP). The city put up a project coordination unit and created a
special project monitoring and evaluation committee for purposes of the
reclamation project. However, since this is something new in urban
governance, some systems and procedures need to be further studied and
institutionalized.
Lately, the RDC created the Metro Cebu Development Council (MCDC) in
cognizance of the demands of more inter-city and inter-LGU cooperation and
coordination in the implementation of metro-wide programs and projects.
Constraints
c) Organizational Streamlining
Potentials
b) Financial Capability
- Religiosity
- Flexible and hardworking labor force
- Survival attitude (ingenuity)
e) Highly Educated/Qualified and Development-oriented Elective Officials
and Department Heads
Sectoral Vision
By 2020, Cebu City shall have achieved and sustained an efficient, effective and
people oriented seat of Government.
Sectoral Mission
To create, project to the world and sustain a seat of Government that is professional,
self-sustaining, reputable civil servants, ISO Certified and committed involvement
and participation of the Private Sector.
Sectoral Objectives
.15.3 Strategies
a. Administrative Governance:
1. Reengineering, Streamlining
Adopt and inculcate the orientation of public service by treating the public as
customers.
2.Performance Indicator
The City shall prepare a scoreboard will indicate the level of local productivity
and performance. The indicators must include the following:
3.Information Technology
Expand the use of information technology to enhance productivity, efficiency
and effectiveness of government operations. Proper and judicious use of IT
will ensure compatibility, sustainability and cost-effectiveness vis-à-vis
adopted systems and procedures and to create a value-chain for the
customers or clients of public service.
4.Capability Building
The CREMDEC as the Technical Secretariat of OMAC and the lead unit
responsible for most the above shall be supported fully and sustained
appropriately.
b. Economic Governance:
2.Privatization
3.Poverty Alleviation
Enhance government responsiveness to the poor by ensuring that policies on
poverty alleviation are supported by specific programs and projects.
Encourage community participation to fully and comprehensively addressed
the poverty situation.
c.Political Governance
1.Community Participation
2.Law Enforcement
Improve peace and order and law enforcement. Professionalize the police
force; improve recruitment standards and training and increasing the salaries
and performance incentives for policemen.
4.Sister City
Pursue a sister city relationship and arrangements with local and foreign
cities.
d. Fiscal Governance
With the expected increase in the local tax revenue of the city, comes with it,
the need to redirect prioritization in the utilization of local funds. The new
funds that will come in the following years should be reserved for the
implementation of urgent projects and programs.
As provided by the 1991 LGC, the Cebu City Government Unit can “exercise
powers as a political subdivision of the national government and as a
corporate entity representing the inhabitants of its territory.” As such, the city
government can acquire and convey real or personal property, enter into
contracts and exercise such other powers granted to corporations.
One of the schemes that will widen the city government’s use of corporate
powers is through the conduct of build-operate-transfer (BOT) business with
private investors. The BOT further broadens the area for private sector
participation for infrastructure development.