Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Oral Appendices - Final
Oral Appendices - Final
CulturallyResponsiveTeaching
inHighSchoolChorus
Appendices
HoldenMaiorana
IthacaCollege
Summer2021
2
Tableo
fC
ontents
Outlineo
fP
resentation……………………………………………………………………………………………..……………….2
AppendixA
( PresentationS lides)…………………………………………………………………………………...…………..3
AppendixB
( Philosophyo
fM
usicE ducation)………………………………………………………………………….…..7
AppendixC
( Historyo
fC
horalM
usicinA
merica)……………………………………………………………….…….10
AppendixD
( ProjectR
ubric)………………………………………………………………………………………………...…..11
AppendixE ( RepertoireC
onsiderations)……………………………………………………………………………...…...12
AppendixF ( References)……………………………………………………………………………………………..…………...15
Outlineo
fP
resentation
I. MyB
ackground
A. Personalu
pbringing
B. CurrentT eachingS ituation
II. CulturallyR
esponsiveT eaching
A. OriginsinS tudent-CenteredT eaching
B. ModernC
ulturallyR
esponsiveT eaching
III. Applicationa ndA
rtifacts
A. 2020-2021S choolY earC
ontext
B. TikTokT rendsP
rojectA
rtifacts
IV. LookingF orward
A. FutureA
pplications
V. Conclusion
3
Appendix A
Presenta(on Slides
I.
My Background
II.
Responsive Teaching ●
●
Comenius - learn by doing
Pestalozzi - education acquired through senses, discovery
learning
● G. Stanley Hall - music should be relevant to student
interest
● John Dewey - learning should be relevant and meaningful
to students John Dewey, ca. 1945
Culturally Responsive Teaching in High School Chorus Culturally Responsive Teaching in High School Chorus
III.
and
● Pandemic drastically shifted our school schedule
● Constant change in guidance and school policy
made traditional rehearsals nearly impossible
Artifacts
● Each student had a personal computer and
access to internet
● Provided a unique opportunity for instruction
(top to bottom) HS Chorus
virtual class (2020), myself
playing guitar on tennis
courts for hybrid teaching
(2020), students performing
on the football field (2021)
“
TikTok Trends Project
Culturally responsive teaching in music “ ● Live music ceased, music was only accessible to
students virtually
education attempts to center music that ● Popularity of TikTok rises
● TikTok trends come and go, each showcasing
speaks to youth’s realities and interests. various genres of music that students gravitate to
● Each trend has musical value, whether the
students realize this or not
- Hess (2015)
Culturally Responsive Teaching in High School Chorus Culturally Responsive Teaching in High School Chorus
5
“
Caitlin, Sophomore
Popular music education...functions ● “Cup Song” Variation
○ Student can choose any song and
to serve and affirm our students and
“ ➢
develop a rhythm routine with it
Skills developed: vocal technique
their individual and collective (Pr), repertoire selection (Cn),
steady beat/rhythm skills (Pr),
cultures. composition (Cr)
➢ Skills developed: breath control (Pr), vocal technique ➢ Skills developed: intonation (Pr), arranging (Cr),
(Pr), stylistic consideration (Pr) stylistic considerations (Pr), emotional context (Re)
Culturally Responsive Teaching in High School Chorus Culturally Responsive Teaching in High School Chorus
IV.
Key Takeaways
★
★
Students were able to collaborate while apart
V.
Future Applications
● Success of this project leads me to attempt future endeavors in
○
○
Popular music education
Project based learning
Conclusion
○ Opportunities for student choice
○ Small group ensembles and collaborations
● Traditional ensemble model modifications
● Acknowledging race and ethnic background as catalyst for culturally responsive
pedagogy
year, hope to elaborate in the future Clauhs, M., Powell, B., & Clements, A. C. (2021). Popular music pedagogies : a practical guide for music teachers . Routledge.
● My traditional ensemble model may need Gay, G. (2002). Preparing for Culturally Responsive Teaching. Journal of Teacher Education, 53(2), 106–116. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487102053002003
modifications to best fit the needs and interests of my Hess, J. (2019). The Bloomsbury handbook of popular music education : perspectives and practices . Bloomsbury Academic.
students Ladson-Billings, G. (2014). Culturally Relevant Pedagogy 2.0: a.k.a. the Remix. Harvard Educational Review, 84(1), 74-84,135.
● These ideas were formed during my time at the Ladson-Billings, G. (1995). Toward a Theory of Culturally Relevant Pedagogy. American Educational Research Journal, 32(3), 465–491.
The Year 3 cohort enjoying eachothers’ https://doi.org/10.2307/1163320
Ithaca College graduate program company at a restaurant.
Shaw, J. T. (2020). Culturally responsive choral music education : what teachers can learn from nine students’ experiences in three choirs . Routledge.
Villegas, A. M., & Lucas, T. (2002). Preparing Culturally Responsive Teachers: Rethinking the Curriculum. Journal of Teacher Education, 53(1), 20–32.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487102053001003
Culturally Responsive Teaching in High School Chorus Culturally Responsive Teaching in High School Chorus
7
Appendix B
The benefits of music cannot be overstated, and because of this, it is crucial that our
students participate in a lifelong learning and enjoyment. To achieve this, music classes should
allow students to explore music that is of interest to them, provide them with aesthetic
experiences so powerful that they cannot imagine a future without participating in music
(Lehman, 2002), and instruct students on how to find or create music making opportunities
outside of school. The best tool to achieve this objective is repertoire that represents a vast
array of musical styles and is authentic to the style being portrayed. Exposure to the diverse and
ever-expanding repertoire that exists is crucial to allowing students to find their musical tastes.
Once their tastes are refined, they can begin making more complex musical decisions that allow
for fulfilling music making experiences.
Music instruction should emphasize that the emotions that a student feels about music
are valid, and that music has the power to affect the way we feel. Aside from these
intrapersonal skills, for a student to understand music on a deeper level, they should be
instructed in the basic elements of music as well as standard music notation. To accomplish this,
a music teacher should provide their students with opportunities to perform in a concert
setting. These performances allow for shared experiences, though it should be acknowledged
that shared musical experiences can also take place in the classroom during school. A teacher
should also afford their students opportunities to move with music. Connecting one’s body to
music can be a wonderfully freeing experience that can amplify the joy that music brings us
(Sacks, 2018). Students should have the opportunity to create music, be it through formal
notation or composition through the use of technology and digital audio workstations. They
may be more inclined to create music through improvisation, but as long as students are making
music that was previously unheard to the world, they are sharing their musical voice. Lastly, a
teacher should plan activities and authentic repertoire that foster an awareness of music in
other cultures and that bring awareness to current events. Music touches the lives of many,
and it is important for students to explore how music is experienced by other people, and how
it is used in our culture in modern times.
A successful music program has a combination of the aforementioned components, but
these components may manifest in an assortment of ways. For some like myself, properly
structuring traditional ensembles with an array of activities, projects, and performances can be
an effective way to enact all the components of a successful music program. For others, it may
be necessary to restructure their program into non-traditional ensembles or general music
classes that provide access points to students of all ages.
When it comes to music education as a concept, perhaps the thing that I feel most
strongly about is that a music program is for everyone. If I did not believe this, what is the
purpose of becoming a music teacher? I teach music because I wish to show the power of music
to as many students as possible so that they can go forth and share their voice. Upon recent
reflection, I have come to believe that a school music program is not only for its students, but
also the community and the school faculty (Ernst, 2001). Music brings out the best in us, and I
would not be doing my job if I were to keep its benefits away from the entire school and
community.
To ensure that every student has access to a music program, it is crucial that K-5 general
music instruction is available and beyond that, there are entry points for any student interested
in exploring the benefits that music can offer them. This includes traditional ensembles as well
9
as classes outside of the traditional model such as piano/guitar, music technology, or music
industry classes. Within these classes, students should participate in an array of performances,
creative projects/endeavors, and listening experiences (Isbell, 2015). Music is not one skill, it is a
myriad of skills, and students should be exposed to various music making opportunities to
illuminate their unique abilities.
When a student studies music, they gain an understanding of themself. When students
are given the opportunity to interpret music, they learn about the way they think, develop their
unique taste, and come to know why music is special to them as an individual. This knowledge
of self is a crucial and fruitful byproduct of music study, and pairs well with the development of
concrete musical skills in a student. When a student refines the technical ability to perform
music at higher levels, it opens the door to access and perform more difficult repertoire which
in turn can allow for even more exalted musical experiences. This progress is evident within the
student, and recognizing this progress fuels students’ further engagement in music.
When students graduate from a music program, they should walk away with knowledge
of music from all cultures, an understanding of basic elements of music to help aid their further
music study, and an intimate knowledge of the power of music and what it means to them. I
want my students to recognize that music is everywhere, and it has the power to change our
state of being. There are so few natural things on this earth that wield that power. Music
teaches skills such as discipline, emotional intelligence, and listening that can be applied to all
other aspects of life, and therefore it is essential.
A successful music program is one that is accessible to all students and provides its
students with opportunities to experience music in a way that is meaningful to them as
individuals. For many students, the traditional music program model is not working. Music is
essential for the development of each student, but also for the development of society at large.
We as educators cannot be afraid to change our programs. In fact, it is crucial that we are
constantly assessing our own programs and asking: is my program accessible to all students,
faculty, and community members? Are my students being given opportunities to experience
music in ways that are meaningful to them? I am so fortunate to be able to devote my life to the
pursuit of teaching children about music. It is my ultimate goal that the generation of students I
teach will make the world a better place through the skills that they learned while in my music
class.
10
Appendix C
Appendix D
Project Rubric
TikTok Chorus Project
Complete the TikTok music challenges and trends and record yourself on video doing so. Each video is worth a certain amount of
points. You can do each challenge as many times as you’d like (in different iterations), unless it says “can only do once”. Remember,
videos should be less than 60 seconds. If there is a trend that involves musical skills that is not listed and you’d like to try it, let Mr. M
know and he will approve it/assign a point value to it.
You must earn at least: 15 POINTS
4 POINTS 3 POINTS 1 POINT
➔ ORIGINAL SONG ➔ HARMONY DUET ➔ RHYTHM CHALLENGE #1
◆ Write and record yourself singing an ◆ Find a TikToker singing harmony to a ◆ Complete the following rhythm
original song. song you know and duet singing melody. challenge.
➔ FREESTYLE RAP ➔ SNOWMAN CHALLENGE ● Can only do once.
◆ Find or create a beat and write a rap ◆ Sing Sia’s “Snowman” for as long as you ➔ RHYTHM CHALLENGE #2
over it. can in one breath. ◆ Complete the following rhythm
➔ ORIGINAL TIKTOK MUSICAL ● Can only do once. challenge.
◆ Write a song that would be featured in ➔ POPCORN DUET ● Can only do once.
an original TikTok Musical (like ◆ Perform a popcorn duet (singing every ➔ RHYTHM CHALLENGE #3
Ratatouille) other word). ◆ Complete the following rhythm
➔ LAYERING CHALLENGE ➔ PLAY AN INSTRUMENT challenge.
◆ Record yourself layering your voice ◆ Play a song on an instrument. ● Can only do once.
using Soundtrap/GarageBand. ➔ SING A COVER ➔ RHYTHM CHALLENGE #4
➔ GENRE SWITCHING COVER ◆ Sing a song you like either a cappella, ◆ Complete the following rhythm
◆ Take a song you love, switch the genre of with a karaoke track, or with live challenge.
it, and record yourself singing a cover. instruments. Put your own spin on it! ● Can only do once.
➔ ALTERNATE PERSPECTIVE COVER ➔ 60 SECOND MUSIC THEORY LESSON ➔ RHYTHM CHALLENGE #5
◆ Take a popular tune and rewrite it from ◆ Explain any music theory concept in 60 ◆ Complete the following rhythm
a different perspective. Can be silly or seconds (rhythm notes, note names, challenge.
serious. scales, solfege, etc.) ● Can only do once.
➔ SONG PARODY COVER ➔ RHYTHM DOTS CHALLENGE
◆ Take an existing song and write a ◆ Complete the following rhythm
parody of it. challenge.
➔ “CUP SONG” VARIATION ● Can only do once.
◆ Student can choose any song and ➔ CONDUCTING CHALLENGE
develop a rhythm routine with it ◆ Complete the following conducting
challenge.
● Can only do once.
➔ 60 SECOND ALBUM/MUSICAL REVIEW
◆ Review an album or musical in 60
seconds. Discuss what you like and what
could use improvement.
12
Appendix E
Choral Repertoire Considerations
HIGH SCHOOL CHORUS: Arranger: Huff
Title: The Awakening Voicing: SATB
Composer: Martin Genre/Period classification: Pop
Voicing: SATB (div) Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Genre/Period classification: Contemporary
Ensemble type: HS Chorus Title: Sanctus (from Requiem)
Composer: Faure
Title: O Sifuni Mungu Voicing: SATB
Arranger: Emerson Genre/Period classification: Romantic
Voicing: SATB Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Genre/Period classification: Pop/fusion
Ensemble type: HS Chorus Title: Este Momento en Punto
Composer: Sosa
Title: An die Musik (Schubert) Voicing: SATB
Arranger: Stetseko Genre/Period classification: Latin
Voicing: SATB Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Genre/Period classification: Romantic
Ensemble type: HS Chorus Title: Sisi Ni Moja
Composer: Narverud
Title: Take Me to the Water Voicing: SATB
Arranger: Dilworth Genre/Period classification: Fusion
Voicing: SATB Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Genre/Period classification: Spiritual
Ensemble type: HS Chorus Title: Lacrymosa (from Requiem)
Composer: Mozart
Title: The First Nowell Voicing: SATB
Arranger: Wilberg Genre/Period classification: Classical
Voicing: SATB Ensemble type: HS Chorus (with string
Genre/Period classification: Holiday quartet)
Ensemble type: HS Chorus (with orchestra)
Title: Ain’t That A-Rockin’
Title: Ain’a That Good News Composer: Gibbs
Composer: Dawson Voicing: SATB (div)
Voicing: SATB (div) Genre/Period classification: Holiday
Genre/Period classification: Spiritual Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Title: Lo V’Chayil
Title: Imbakwa Arranger: Levine
Composer: Papoulis Voicing: SATB (div)
Voicing: SATB (div) Genre/Period classification: Holiday
Genre/Period classification: Fusion Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Title: Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)
Title: Stand by Me Arranger: Shaw
13
Appendix E
Choral Repertoire Considerations
Voicing: SATB Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Genre/Period classification: Holiday
Ensemble type: HS Chorus Title: All I Want for Christmas is You
Arranger: Huff
Title: We Can Mend the Sky Voicing: SATB
Arranger: Runestad Genre/Period classification: Holiday/Pop
Voicing: SATB (div) Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Genre/Period classification: Contemporary
Ensemble type: HS Chorus Title: Oye
Composer: Papoulis
Title: Gloria in Excelsis Deo (from Gloria) Voicing: SATB
Arranger: Vivaldi Genre/Period classification: Fusion
Voicing: SATB Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Genre/Period classification: Baroque
Ensemble type: HS Chorus Title: Seize the Day
Arranger: Emerson
Title: The Road Home Voicing: SATB
Arranger: Paulus Genre/Period classification: Musical theatre
Voicing: SATB (div) Ensemble type: HS Chorus
Genre/Period classification: Contemporary
Ensemble type: HS Chorus MIDDLE SCHOOL CHORUS:
Title: South African Suite (Tshotsholoza,
Title: Sililiza Siyahamba)
Composer: Papoulis Arranger: Leck
Voicing: SATB (div) Voicing: SAB
Genre/Period classification: Fusion Genre/Period classification: Protest
Ensemble type: Ensemble type: 7/8 Chorus
Title: Count on Me
Arranger: Day
Voicing: SAB
Genre/Period classification: Pop
Ensemble type: 7/8 Chorus
ELEMENTARY CHORUS:
Title: Blue Skies
Arranger: Emerson
15
Appendix F
References
Clauhs, M., Powell, B., & Clements, A. C. (2021). Popular music pedagogies : a practical guide for
music teachers . Routledge.
Gay, G. (2002). Preparing for Culturally Responsive Teaching. Journal of Teacher Education,
53(2), 106–116. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487102053002003
Hess, J. (2019). The Bloomsbury handbook of popular music education : perspectives and
practices . Bloomsbury Academic.
Ladson-Billings, G. (2014). Culturally Relevant Pedagogy 2.0: a.k.a. the Remix. Harvard
Educational Review, 84(1), 74-84,135.
Shaw, J. T. (2020). Culturally responsive choral music education : what teachers can learn from
nine students’ experiences in three choirs . Routledge.
Villegas, A. M., & Lucas, T. (2002). Preparing Culturally Responsive Teachers: Rethinking the
Curriculum. Journal of Teacher Education, 53(1), 20–32.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487102053001003