Professional Documents
Culture Documents
O p s A p n K flxeiiMMCOH
nOCTMOAEPH113M MJIM
KyJIbTYPHAfl HOrMKA
nOSAHErO KAnMTAJIMSMA
18
O p e A e p M K A ^ e M M M C O H
19
O p e A e p M K A ^ e M M M C O H
20
n o c T M O A e p H M 3 M K H M K y n b T y p H O i i j i o r M K O n o 3 A H e r o K a n M T a i i M 3 M a
21
O p e A e p M K A ^ K e J i M M C O H
22
f l o c T M O A e p H M B M MJIM K y j i b T y p H a s i J i o r M K O n o s A H e r o k o h m t o j i m s m o
KOHCHHOM CHCTC, GbiTb onpcacjicHa KaK BHyTpH 5oace OHCBuaHbix "momchtob a«H"
KaTcropHajibHaa omnGKa. Bce 3to CTancT Goace nocTMoaepuHCTCKOH KyabTypbi? H , e c a n m m mo^kcm,
OHeBHflHbIM, CCJIH Mbl BblCOpOCHM n03HUHK) HCT a n B a H a a c K T H H C C K O M B3ra>!ae u a hctophhcckoc
KyjibTypHoro KpHTHKa h Mopajincra; nocjieaHHH, paSBHTHC, npeaCTaBaCHHOM BbHUC, HCrO-TO KpaHHC
BMCCTC CO B C C M H H a M H , C C T O f l H a CTOJlb FJiyGOKO uapaaH3yK)mcro; hc crpcMHTca an oh
norpyACH b hoctmoacphhctckoc npocTpancTBO, aeMo6HaH3HpoBaTb nac h o6peHb u a uaccHBuocTb h
CTOJlb r j i y G o K O O K p a m c H h aapa^KCH e r o hobmmh SecuoMOiuHocTb n y r c M CHCTCMaTHHccKoro
KyjIbTypHblMH KaTCrOpHSMH, HTO pocKomb ycTpancHua bo3mo>khoctch aeiicTBOBaTb noa
CTapOMOflHOH HflCOJIOTHHCCKOH KpHTHKH, HCnpOHHUaCMblM UOKpOBON HCTOpHHCCKOH
BOSMymcHHoc MopajibHoe ocyjKfleHHC apyroro HCHSGOKHOCTH? CtOHT o6cyaHTb 3TH aBa
CiaHOBHTCa HeB03M0H(HbIM. (COOTHOCHMMX) nyUKTa B TCpHHUaX HaaHHHMX
PasaHHHC, K O T o p o e a 3aecb npoBO>Ky, h m c c t a c a o B03M0>KH0CTen aaa hckoh 3(j)(})eKTHBH0n
C OanOH KaHOHHHCCKOH (jJOpMOH B FCrCaCBCKOM c o B p c M c n n o H K y a b T y p u o n n o a u T H K H h aJia c o s a a n n a
pasaHHCHHH MbiuiacHHa HHaHBHayaabHOH n o a a n n n o H noauTHHCCKon Kyabr/pbi.
MopaabHocTH H a n MopaansaTopcTBa h coBcpmcHHO C4)OKycHpoBaTb upoSacMy noaoGnbiM o6pa30M
HHOrO M H p a K O a a C K T H B H b l X C O H H a a b H b l X UCHHOCTCH 3 H a H H T , K O H C H H O yKC, H C M C a a C H H C H O C T a B H T b GoJlCC
11 n p a K T H K . H o OHO H a X O a U T CBOK) saBcpmcHHyK) TOHHMH Boupoc o cyabGc KyabTypbi b ueaoM, h o
(j)opMy B MapKCOBOM upcacTaBacHHH 4)yHKUHH KyabTypbi B OCOScHHOCTH KaK O HCKOCM
MaTcpuaaHCTHHCCKOH a u a a c K T H K H , H a u S o a e e apKO - couuaabHOM ypoBHC u a u HUCTauuHH b
Ha T C X K a a c c H H c c K H x CTpaHHuax MaHucjjccTa, HocTCOBpcMCHHyK) 3py. B c c npcauiecTByK)uicc
KOTopbic ynaT TpyauoMy ypoKy ucKOcro 5oaee 0 6 c y > K a C H H C H O a B O a H T K B b l B O a y O T O M , H T O BCC T O ,
HCTHHHOrO auaJlCKTHHCCKOrO CHOCoGa HOCTHACHHa H T O M M H a S M B a a U H 0 C T M 0 a e p H H 3 M D M H C O T a C a H M O OT,
HCTopHHCcKoro pa3BHTHa H HSMCHCHHa, T c M O H y p o K a H HCMMCaHMO 5C3 rHnOTC3bI HCKOCH
aB.iacTca. KaK h 3 b c c t h o , h c t o p h h c c k o c pasBHTUc ( } ) y H a a M e H T a a b H O H M y r a u u H C(j)epbi K y a b T y p b i b M u p e
caMoro KanHTaaH3Ma u pasBcpxbiBaHHC H03aHcro KanHTaaH3Ma, KOTopaa npcauoaaracT
cnemi4)HHCCK0H 6ypyKya3HOH KyabTypbi. B luupoKO BajKHyK) MoaHcfjUKauHK) ec c o u H a n b H o i i (jiyuKUHH. Ill
H3BCCTHOM nacca>KC M a p K C H a c T O H H U B O sacTaBaacT HpOKHHC aHCKyCCHH HO HOBOAy UpOCXpaHCTBa,
nac c a e a a T b h c b o 3 m o > k h o c , a h m c h h o , n o M b i c a u T b 3 t o (JjyHKUHH H a H c(i)cpbi KyabTypbi (iiaH5oaec HSBCCTuaa
paSBllTHC O a H O B p C M C H H O HOSHTHBHO H HCraTHBHO; H3 H H X - KaaccHHecKoe 3cce FcpGepTa MapKyse
TpyrHMH caoBaMH, aocTHHb TaKoro cnoco6a "yTBcpaHTcabUbiH xapaicrcp KyabTypbi") HacTauBajiu
Mbiiii.icHHa, KOTopbifi 6 b i a 6bi c u o c o G c h yxsaTUTb u a TOM, HTO H a a p y r o M asbiKc mohcho o b i a o 5bi HasBaTb
OHCBHaUO SaOBCIUHC HCpTbl KaUHTaJlH3Ma "uoay-aBTOHOMHCH" KyabTypuoH C(j)epbi: ec
OZIHOBpCMCHHO C CTO HC06blHHbIM H n p H 3 p a H H o e , aa>Ke yTOUHHCCKoe, cyuiecTBOBauHC, bo
O C B O O O a U T C a b H b l M a H H a M H 3 M 0 M B O a H O M H T O M >KC HMa a o 5 p a H a u 3aa, u o B c p x upaKTHHCCKoro Mupa
aKTC M b i c a u , H C C M a r n a a u u o a u y h 3 c n a oGohx Bcero cymecTByK)mero, h c h 3cpKaabHbiH o6pa3 ona
cyvKacHHH. M b l K a K H M - T O o 5 p a 3 0 M a o a ) K H b i H o a u a T b OTdpacbiBacT nasaa b 4)opMax, Koropbie Bapbupyrorca
iiamy Mbicab a o nyHKTa, b KOTopoM CTaHOBHTca OT acruTHMauHH jiecTHoro cxoacTBa ao
B03MO>KHbiM u o H a T b , H T O K a n H T a a H 3 M a B a a c T c a b oupoBcpraTcabHoro oGBUHCUHa k p h t h h c c k o h caTupbi
O a H O H T O >Ke B p C M a ayHLUCH BCUtbK), KOTopaa u a u yTOUHHCCKOH 5oaH.
ciynaaacb c hcjiobchcckhm poaoM, h xyaiucH. M m aoa)KHbi ceiiHac cnpocuTb ce6a, hc
riaacHHC H3 3 T o r o c y p o B o r o auaacKTHHecKoro paspymena an hmchho 3Ta uoay-aBTOHOMua
HMOcpaTHBa B S o a e c KOMCjjopTaGcabHoc noao>KeHHC K y a b T y p H O H c4)cpbi a o r u K O H u o s a u c r o KauHTaausMa'.''
npHHaTua MopajibUbix h o s h u h h abaacTca ray6oKO OanaKO apryMCHT, h t o KyabTypa ccroaua 6ojice ne
yKOpCHHBUIHMCa H CJIHHIKOM HCJIOBCHCCKHM: n a a e a e n a oTHOCHTcabuoH aBXOHOMnen, KOTopoH o n a
HeOTJ10>KHOCTb T C M b l T p c S y C T , HTo6bl Mbl XOTa 6bl noab30Baaacb p a n e e KaK h c k h h ypoBcnb cpean
noHbiTaaucb noMbicauTb KyabTypuyio 3bojtk)uhio a p y r n x n a p a n n n x CTaanax KauHTaansMa (nc roBopa
no3aHcro KanHTaaH3Ma anaacKTHHecKH - KaK y^c o aoKauHTaaHCTHHCCKHX o6uxecTBax), ne
KaTacTpoc[)y h u p o r p e c c oauoBpcMCHUo. o6a3aTeabHO noapasyMesacT ee HCHCsnoBeHne nan
TaKaa noubiTKa npeauoaaracT aaa y r a c a n n e . H a n p o T U B , m m MO>KeM yTBep>KaaTb, h t o
HCHOCpCaCTBCUHblX BOUpOCa, KOTOpblMH Mbl yTpara asTOHOMHon c4)epM KyabTypbi aoa>KHa,
3aKaK)HHM H a i U H p a s M b i u i a c H u a . M o ) k c m an mm CKOpee, 6biTb u p e a c T a B a e n a b T c p M H u a x Bspbisa: KaK
aCHCTBHTCJIbHO O H p C a C a U T b H C K H H " M O M C H T H C T H H b l " BceoGbCMarouiec pacnpocTpaHCHHC KyabTypbi n a bck)
23
O p e A e p M K A ^ K e M M M c o H
24
r i o c T M O A e p H M S M MJIM K y j i b T y p H a s i J i o r M K O n o 3 A H e r o K o n M T O J i M a M O
25
O p e A e p M K A > K e M M M C O H
26
n o c T M O A e p H M 3 M MJTiM K y n b T y p H o s i n o r M K O n o s A H e r o k o h m t o j i m s m o
npoGacMy xaKHM o5pa30M SHannx xaK^e cpasy )Ke 3XHX aByx pasannubix HSMcpennH. HcxopHUHCxcKHH
CTOJTKHyXbCH C X B M H CaMblMH XpyflHOCXHMH B B3raaa Ha 3x0 onpcaeacHHC xoxea 5bi ao6aBHXb, hxo
Kapxorpa(J)HH, Koxopbie ocxpo h opHrnaaabHO noaoGnaa KOopannauHa, npoHSBoacxBO
nocxaBjicHbi xcm caMbiM rjio6ajibHbiM n p o c x p a n c x B O M (JiyHKUHOHaabHbix h ^ h b h x n a e o a o r H H , p a s a n n n o b
nocxMojiepHHCxcKoro hjih MyjibXHHauHOHajibHoro p a 3 H b l X H c x o p H H C C K H X C H X y a U H a X , H, KpOMC x o r o , HXO
MOMCHxa, KoxopbiH M M oGcy^KflajiH sflecb. 3xo MOJKcx B 0 3 H H K H y x b HCxopHHccKaa CHxyauHa, B
xpy/iHocxH He n p o c x o x c o p e x H H C C K o r o xapaKxepa; KOXOpOH OHO BOBCC H C B 0 3 M 0 a C H 0 - H, H O - B U a H M O M y ,
OHH B j i C K y x 3 a C 0 6 0 H n a c x o H X C J i b H b i e n p a K X H H C C K O - 3X0 KaK pa3 n a i u a c u x y a u n a x c K y m c r o KpnsHca.
nOJlHXHHCCKHC HOCJlCflCXBHS, KOXOpbIC BblXCKaiOX H 3 H o aaKanoBCKaa CHCxcMa TpoHHua, a n e ayaabua.
KOHBCHUHOHajibHbix o m y m c H H H FIcpBbix MnpoBbix MapKCOBo-aabTioccepoBCKOH o h u o s h u h h naeoaorHH
cy5-beKX0B, h KOxopbic 3K3HcxeHHHajibHO (hjih H nayKH cooTBCTCTByioT ToabKO aBC H3 Tpex
"3MnHpHHCCKH") HaBOflHHK)X "nocxHHflycxpHajibHOc aananoBCKHX (JiyHKUHH: B o o 6 p a > K a e M o e h P c a a b n o e
OOmeCXBO", H3 KOXOpOrO HCHCS XpaflHUHOHHblH COOTBCCTBCHHO.
cnoco6 npoH3BojicxBa, h rae counaabHbie Kaaccbi O a n a K O n a m e O T C T y u a e u H C b KapTorpa(|)Hio c ee
KjiaccHHCCKoro xnna 6oaec nc cymeexByioT - (j)HHajIbHbIM OTKpblTHCM CoGCTBCHHO
yoe^Kaenne, Koropoe HenocpeacxBenno Banacx na penpeseHTauHOHHOH anaaeKTHKu KoaoB n
nojiHXHHCCKyio npaKXHKy, B03M0>KH0CTCH H U a H B H a y a a b H b l X a3bIKOB H a H MCaUa
BxOpOH BblBOa COCXOHX B XOM, HXO B 0 3 B p a X K nanoMHHacT uaM, h t o ao cnx nop 6biao ynymeno
jiaKaHOBCKOMy n o a x B c p > K a c H H K ) ajibxioccepoBCKOH H3MepeHne coGctbchho aaKanoBCKOio
xeopHH MOACT a a x b noac3Hbie n npoayKXHBnbie CHMBOaUHCCKOrO.
MCToaoaorHHccKHC HOBUiecTBa (enrichments). 3cTeTHKa KorHHTHBHoii Kapxorpa4)HH -
AjibXK)ccepoBCKa>i (J3opMyanpoBKa BOcnpoHSBoanx ucaarorHHCCKaa noanxHHecKaa Kyabxypa, KOxopaa
npOKHCC, H B a a j I b H C f i m C M KaaCCHHCCKOC, MapKCOBO cxpcMHXca naaeanxb HnanBHayaabHbiH cyGtCKX
pa3JiHHCHHC n a y K H n naeoaornn, Koxopoe He HCKHM HOBblM BOSBbUnCHHblM HyBCXBOM CrO MCCXa B
noTcpajTo aaa nac uchhocxh aa)Ke ceroana. rao6aabHOH chcxcmc - o6a3axeabHO aoa>KHa
3K3HcxeHUHaabHoe ~ noao>KCHHe n n a H B H a y a a b H o r o npnsnaBaxb 3xy ceroana HpesBbiHaiino caoKuyio
cyGbCKxa, onbix noBccaHCBnoH a h s h h , penpe3CHxauH0HHyio anajicKXHKy n n3o5pcxaxb
MOHaaHHecKaa " x o H K a s p e n n H " n a M n p , K o x o p w M m m , paaHKaabHO noBwe (|)opMbi, H x o 6 b i n o a n o c x b i o cc
KaK S H O J l O r H H C C K H e C y G t C K X b l , c Heo6xOaHMOCXbK) paCKpblXb. i l C H O , HXO 3XO HC HpOCXO npH3bIB K
orpaHHHCHbi - B aabxioccepoBCKOH 4)opMyae B03Bpaxy K HCKOCMy n p o K H C M y MCxannsMy, ncKOCMy
HMii.xHUHXHo npoTHBonocxaBacHO napcxBy npoKHCMy H Goaee npospannoMy naunonaabHOMy
aocrpaKXHoro SHanna, uapcxBy, Koxopoe, KaK npocxpancxBy, n a n ncKOCMy 5oaec x p a a H u n o u n o M y
HanoMHHaex H a M j l a K a n , n n K o r a a n c n o M c m e n o b yBepcHHOMy nepcucKXHBHOMy n a n MHMCXHHCCKOMy
.nroooii K O H K p c x H b i n c y 6 x . C K x n a n apxHKyanpoBano anKaaBy: hoboc noanxHHCCKOc HCKyccxBO (ecan o n o
HM, a a p T H K y a n p o B a n o , C K o p e c , x c m crpyKxypnbiM BooGme B03M0>KH0) aoa>KHO npuaep'/KHBaxbca
BaKvyMOM, K o x o p u H Ha3biBacxcH le sujet suppose n c x H H b i n o c x M o a e p H H 3 M a , x.e. ee c j i y n a a M e n T a x b H o r o
savoir ( n p c a n o a a r a c M M H c y G t C K x s n a n u H ) , c y G t c K X - oGbCKTa - MupoBoro npocTpancTBa
MCCTO 3 H a H H 5 ! . y X B C p A a a C X C J ! O X H l O a b H C T O , H X O M b l M y a b T H H a u n o n a a b H o r o KannTaaa - b t o caMoe BpcMa,
H e MO/KC.M 3 H a x b M n p H e r o x o x a a b H o c x b hckhm Koraa ono aocTuracT npopbisa b ao cnx nop
aGcxpaKXHbiM n a n " n a y H H b i M " o 6 p a 3 0 M . MapKCOBa ncBooGpasiiMbiH hobbih chocoS penpesenTaunn
"nayKa" KaK p a 3 - x a K H u p e a o c x a B a a e x x a K o f l c n o c o 6 nocaeanero, b KoxopoM mm moacm cnoBa nanaxb
3HaHHH H K o n u c u x y a j i n s a u n H M u p a a G c x p a K x n o , b y a a B a u B a x b n a n i c n o a o A c n n e KaK n n a n B H a y a a b U b i x
CMbicjic, b K O T o p o M , K u p H M c p y , o r p o M u a H Knnra n KoaaeKXHBHbix cyGtCKXOB, h BnoBb oGpexaxb
Manaejia npcaaaraex Goraxoe h pasBHXoe SHanne x o h cuocoGnocxb aciicxBOBaxb n oopoxbca, KOXopaa
r.ao6a.nbHOH M H p o B O i i C H C x c M b i , o K o x o p o i i saecb ceroana HciixpaaH30Bana n a m n M npocTpancTBcnnbiM
H H K o r a a HC r o B o p n u o c b , h x o o n a n e n o s n a B a c M a , a n couHaabHMM saMcmaTcabCTBOM. HoauTHHCCKaa
roBopHJiocb a n u i b , h x o o n a H c p e n p c s e n x H p y e M a , a (|)opMa H O C T M o a e p n n s M a , e c a n TaKOBaa BooGme
3T0 C O B e p U I C H H O p a S H b l C B C U I H . A a b x i o c c c p o B C K a H HMCCTca, GyacT npHSBana nsoGpcTaTb n
(})opMyia, a p y r u M H c a o B a M n , o 6 o 3 H a H a c x paspbiB, upocKTupoBaTb raoGaabnyio KornnTHBHyio
ipemHHy MesKay 3K3HcxenuHaabHbiM oumxom h KapTorpacfinio, KaK na counaabnon, TaK n na
HayHHbiM s n a H H C M . O o s x o M y (|)ynKUH>i Haeojiornn npocTpancTBCHHoir lUKaae.
COCTOHT B X O M , H X 0 6 b I H a H X H C U O C o G COHaeHCHHa
27
O p e A e p M K A ^ K e M M M C O H
28