Professional Documents
Culture Documents
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
COMPANY to CONTRACTOR Comments Sheet (CCS)
Service Order on : Consortium. Saibos s.a.s, (F) European maritime Commerce BV (NL), Saipem
Contracting Nigeria Ltd (Nigeria) , Allied Dominium Oilfield and Shipping
services (Nigeria)
SO number APO/C005/03
Comment revision
1 Page 20 Comment # 1
Subject: Note
December 3, 2007
What conclusion should the reader draw if the actual values are beyond what
is accounted for here?
CONTRACTOR REPLY:
Those tolerances were prescribede in the relevant FLETS and ITAs
fabrication specification and generally achieved.
If and when as-built (or as-laid) survey shows any out-specification
tolerances, the spools and/or jumpers affected will be assessed first and
if necessary re-analyses shall be performed to confirm their acceptance
or rectification to be carried out.
Please also refer to document NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2063
‘Definition of position of FLETs & ITAS following fabrication as-built
data’
CLOSED
2 Page 21 Comment # 1
Subject: Note
December 3, 2007
Please note the CTR dimensional survey of the 4 first FLETs to be fabricated,
indicated linear tolerances more than 10x that indicated here. In at least one
case the angular tolerance exceeds 0.6deg in pitch, which corresponds to 3x
that indicated here.
It would appear now with obvious hindsight that SPS original recommendation
of +/-0.5deg and +/-25mm is more sensible for design.
How should the exceedence of these values now be treated within the spools
PAGE : 1 OF 3
design?
CONTRACTOR REPLY:
Please see Contractor’s reply to Company Comment 1 above.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2063 ‘Definition of position of FLETs & ITAS
following fabrication as-built data’ report is reporting the actual
tolerance and stress recalculation and are included in final
engineering doc of FLETs as agreed with CY. – ref to answer to
previsou comment.
For out of spec FLET, lead to out of tolerance considered in
design of 1.42° - full statistical approach would have lead to 1.45°
(based on 0.6° FLET misalignment).
Spool design was performed on Short-Short and Long-long
configuration (typical for FLET:+/-5 long / +/-2.5 lateral) while
installation lead to FLET inside target of +/-2m (MAX to be
confirmed).
Moreover, max utilisation for out of specification FLET is 0.73
(based on ABAQUS result).
CLOSED
3 Page 24 Comment # 1
Subject: Note
December 3, 2007
CONTRACTOR REPLY:
Those requirements (i.e. constraints) for the spool & jumper design are
relative to installation. Reference to be made to document ‘ NG50-3-200-
ENG-CN-AB-00-9270, Spool & Jumper Installation Analysis’ (mentioned
in this document as reference [64])
Please note also that for all the spools & jumpers final tansporation and
lifting analyses are performed following as built survey of FLETs,
manifolds and trees.
CLOSED
4 Page 32 Comment # 1
Subject: Note
December 3, 2007
The spool may see a lower friction than the production flowline, due to the
differing installation methods.
CONTRACTOR REPLY:
Generally, due to the controlled lowering process for spools & jumpers,
soil friction may be lower in lateral direction, as soil will be much less
distorted, i.e. less embedment, under spools & jumpers than flowlines
by J-lay.
PAGE : 2 OF 3
spools (and jumper for thermal expansion effect) can move laterally
more easily so to reduce the reactions at its ends. Therefore no further
analysis is considered necessary.
CLOSE
5 Page 46 Comment # 1
Subject: Note
December 3, 2007
The point is not clear. Starting with a distorted spool and then forcing an ideal
position, would surely result in a stress free spool?
CONTRACTOR REPLY:
Please disregard the point.
The purpose of the statement was to explain that to simulate the impact
of tolerances on the spool, the rotations and displacements associated
to these tolerances were applied.
CLOSED
PAGE : 3 OF 3
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................................. 5
1.1 Project Overview.......................................................................................................................... 5
1.2 Description of System F............................................................................................................... 5
1.3 Description of Sub-System FT..................................................................................................... 5
1.3.1 Definitions ...................................................................................................................................... 6
1.4 Battery Limit................................................................................................................................. 7
1.4.1 Spools and Jumpers characteristics .............................................................................................. 7
1.4.2 Spools and Jumpers connectors ................................................................................................... 8
1.5 Objective ...................................................................................................................................... 8
1.6 Scope........................................................................................................................................... 8
2. CODES, STANDARDS AND REFERENCES............................................................................................... 10
2.1 Codes & Standards.................................................................................................................... 10
2.1.1 Prime Code Reference ................................................................................................................ 10
2.1.2 Other Relevant Codes & Industry Standards ............................................................................. 10
2.2 Company References ................................................................................................................ 11
2.2.1 Project Specific Documents ......................................................................................................... 11
2.2.2 General Company Specifications ................................................................................................ 11
2.2.3 Contract ....................................................................................................................................... 12
2.3 Contractor Documents............................................................................................................... 12
2.4 Supplementary Project Documents ........................................................................................... 12
3. DEFINITIONS AND ABBREVIATIONS ........................................................................................................ 14
3.1 Definitions .................................................................................................................................. 14
3.2 Abbreviations ............................................................................................................................. 15
4. FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS ................................................................................................................. 16
4.1 Pigging Requirements ............................................................................................................... 16
4.2 Connector System ..................................................................................................................... 16
4.3 Tolerances ................................................................................................................................. 17
4.3.1 Installation Tolerances ................................................................................................................. 18
4.3.2 Metrology Tolerances .................................................................................................................. 18
4.3.3 Spool and Jumpers Fabrication Tolerances ................................................................................ 19
4.3.4 Connector’s Hub to Receptacle Tolerances ................................................................................ 20
4.4 Spool & Jumper Size Envelope ................................................................................................. 24
5. MECHANICAL DESIGN DATA..................................................................................................................... 25
5.1 General ...................................................................................................................................... 25
5.2 Material Data ............................................................................................................................. 26
5.3 External Coating Description ..................................................................................................... 26
5.4 Field Joint coating...................................................................................................................... 26
5.5 Anodes properties...................................................................................................................... 26
6. DESIGN & OPERATING DATA.................................................................................................................. 27
6.1 Design Pressure Definition ........................................................................................................ 27
6.2 Pressure & Temperature ........................................................................................................... 27
6.2.1 Production .................................................................................................................................... 27
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
1. INTRODUCTION
TOTAL UPSTREAM NIGERIA LIMITED a company organised and existing under the laws of
Nigeria, as operator of the Oil mining Lease (OML) 130 with a 24% share, and its partners
NIGERIAN NATIONAL PETROLEUM CORPORATION (50%), BRASOIL OIL SERVICES
COMPANY NIGERIA (16%) and SOUTH ATLANTIC PETROLEUM LIMITED (10%), are
developing the AKPO Field, estimated to contain reserves of 1 billion barrels of oil and 4 trillion
cubic feet of natural gas.
Saibos s.a.s. has been awarded the UFR (Umbilicals, Flowlines and Risers) contract of the AKPO
Field Development Project. The UFR has been divided into five systems which are:
As spools and jumpers are included in System F a brief description of this system is outlined in the
following section.
• 4 x 10-inch thermally insulated production flow loops (P10, P20, P30 and P40) and steel
catenary risers to the FPSO,
• 1 x 8-inch gas injection line (GI 40) and steel catenary riser to the FPSO,
• 4 x 10-inch water injection line (WI10, WI20, WI30 and WI50) and steel catenary risers to
the FPSO.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
From the 72 jumpers, 28 are future and 44 are part of the current contract as listed below:
From the 44 jumpers listed above only 22 are required for start-up and first oil. These twenty two
jumpers are to be designed, fabricated and installed by UFR CONTRACTOR in phase 1 as defined
in COMPANY reference [30]. UFR CONTRACTOR shall supply materials for the remaining 22
jumpers which shall be defined as phase 2 jumpers to differentiate them from jumpers defined as
“future” in the block diagram, ref. [29], which are not part of the current contract.
1.3.1 Definitions
The following sketch shows a typical arrangement at a Drill Center : Flowline End
Terminations, Spools, Jumpers, Manifold and Wells.
- Jumpers make the connection between manifold and wellhead or FLET/ ITA.
- Spools make the connection between FLET and manifold or between 2 FLETS.
Note: Connections between two FLETs are termed by ”interconnection spools” and their
design shall be in accordance with this BOD.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Well
Manifold
Flowlines
JUMPER
FLET SPOOL
The following table presents the main preliminary characteristics for the WI, GI and
production spools and jumpers. The values are extracted from reference [48].
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The spools and jumpers have subsea horizontal type connectors at each end.
The subsea connectors are Cameron Collet horizontal connectors which will be free
issued to UFR CONTRACTOR by COMPANY.
1.5 Objective
This document forms the basis for the detailed design and analysis of the all the listed above
spools and jumpers for the AKPO Development Project as describe in Section 1.3.
1.6 Scope
The spools and jumpers shall be designed to withstand all relevant operational, environmental and
installation loads based on provided input data and methodology referred to in this document. The
list of applicable sources of information is shown in Section 2. The primary reference is DnV OS-F-
101.
The design engineering consists of detail design and analysis of the 44 Jumpers and 31 Spools for
the Water Injection, Gas Injection and Production lines.
It should be noted that all spools and jumpers shall be designed based on UFR CONTRACTOR
installation methodology.
Preliminary Design:
The scope is to identify jumpers & spools preliminary configuration, wall thicknesses and
maximum dimensions. The objectives of this pre-detailed engineering phase are:
- To define the quantities of bends and linepipe required.
- To evaluate loads transmitted to FLETs, ITAs, Manifolds & Wells.
Detailed Design:
The objectives of the detailed design phase are to:
- Produce final spool and jumper configuration
- Perform final analysis
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
- Finalise MTO
- Produce isometrics and GA drawings
Installation : Spools and jumpers will be installed with the SaiBOS FDS according to the
eventual sea states limitations defined in the installation analyses, Ref. [64].
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
This basis of design is based upon the requirements contained in the documents referenced below
with the following order of precedence
[1] DNV Offshore Standard OS-F101 – Submarine Pipeline Systems, January 2000, Amendments and
Corrections of January 2003
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
2.2.3 Contract
Note:
CONTRACT contains the scope of work in Exhibit A , a list of all relevant COMPANY documentation in
Exhibit E and Engineering Track Changes Doc NG50-PJ-UFR-GEN-PR-001 Rev 8C which contains most
updated information of all COMPANY documentation.
[65] Fugro - AE.03.RG.OF.0192C Rev 1, Offshore Soil Investigation – Factual Report (Dec’03)
[66] Fugro - AE.03.RG.OF.0192d Rev 1, Soil Design Parameters
[67] C&C Technologies No 3351/3441, Geohazard Assessment AKPO Field Development (Mar 03)
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
3.1 Definitions
Extreme value: most probable greatest value during the given period
Waves:
Hmax: Maximum Wave Height
THmax: Maximum wave height period
Sea State:
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
3.2 Abbreviations
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
4. FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS
The jumpers and spools shall be designed to meet the general and specific functional
requirements as given in the Jumper & Spool Specification, ref. [13].
All spools shall be capable of being pigged. Bends in piggable lines shall have a radius of
minimum 5 times pipe ID, Refs. [13] (Sections 3.5 and 3.6). Jumpers are not required to be
piggable and bends shall have a minimum of 3 times pipe ID.
The connection system shall utilize Cameron’s horizontal connection system which employs
existing collet connector technology and is comprised of a body, collet segments, actuator ring,
top plate and outer body ring, ref. [69]. The “female” connectors shall be assembled to the
ends of the spool/jumper and a diverless subsea connection shall be made to the “male” hubs
on the connecting structure. Refer to drawings [70] to [75] for examples of the “female” &
“male” assemblies. As base case, the following connector configurations shall be used:
Connector Connector
Connector Pup Piece Size
Component Weight in Air Weight in Water Reference
Type (mm)
(kg) (kg)
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
4.3 Tolerances
All spool and jumper designs shall accommodate the following tolerances:
1- Installation
2- Metrology Measurement
3- Spool Fabrication
A distinction should be made between the installation tolerance which will be determined
during metrology and the other tolerances which can not be determined and have to be
accommodated in the design of the spool and jumpers. These other tolerances will be
assumed to follow a uniform probability and the total tolerance to be accommodated by the
spool and jumper will be bases on a probability of a 1/1000 or mean plus three standard
deviations. The design values for the rotational misalignment tolerances to be considered in
the verification of the spools are jumpers are defined in Appendix B and summarised in table
below. These design values are based on a probability of exceedance of 1/1000 based on
certain assumptions related to the breakdown in the tolerances due to the fabrication of the
host structure. For information, the manifolds and the trees are made of two separate
structures. Here it is assumed that the total tolerance is made up of three components two of
which are related to the fabrication of each structure and the third related to assembly of
these two structures.
As Landed Operating
Pitch Yaw FLET/ITA Side Manifold Side Tree Side
Pitch Yaw Pitch Yaw Pitch Yaw
Metrology 0.30° 0.30° 0.30° 0.30° 0.30° 0.30° 0.30° 0.30°
0.20° 0.30° 0.20° 0.30° 0.20° 0.30° 0.20° 0.30°
- 0.40° - 0.40° - 0.40° - 0.40°
Spool Fabrication 0.50° 0.50° 0.50° 0.50° 0.50° 0.50° 0.50° 0.50°
Host Structure - - 0.20° 0.20° 0.25° 0.25° 0.25° 0.25°
Fabrication - - - - 0.25° 0.25° 0.25° 0.25°
- - - - 0.75° 0.64° 0.25° 1.70°
Design Values 0.91° 1.29° 1.02° 1.33° 1.68° 1.84° 1.28° 2.85°
The assumption of a uniform probability can be justified given that the tolerances being
considered are extreme limits indicating that the deviation from the theoretical position can be
anywhere within these limits. The assumption of a uniform probability is conservative as it is
assumed that this deviation can be anywhere within these limits with equal probability. In
reality each of these tolerances could be a stack-up of a number of tolerances and a more
realistic but less onerous assumption would be a normal probability distribution.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The installation tolerances are provided in Table 4-2. These shall be used for the spools and
jumpers sizing.
Metrology tolerances are due to degree of accuracy for the followings measured values
(Sketch 1):
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Sketch 1
Spools and jumpers fabrication tolerances are given in Table 4-3. These tolerances shall be
considered in the stress analyses of the spools and jumpers.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Tolerance Value
Tolerances described in this section are in two parts which shall be considered in the stress
analyses of spools and jumpers:
Tolerances for FLETs and ITAs are due to fabrication inaccuracies as both receptacle and
male hub will be mounted on the same structure. Sketch 2 shows the FLETS fabrication
achievable tolerances. In addition to these FLET fabrication tolerances, any displacements of
the FLETS and ITAs resulting from the in-service conditions will also be considered in the
verification of the spools and jumpers.
Tolerances for manifolds and trees (Sketch 3) are mainly due to the fact that the receptacles
will be mounted on a sub-structure foundation frame which will be installed separately
(installed first) from the main structure which holds the male hubs of the CHC system
(installed second). Additionally the main structure for both manifold and tree have been
designed such that both can be recovered and installed back in place during life time of the
field, hence there is a possibility for a large tolerances variation for both these structure in
accordance with the SPS contractor document Ref. [79].
Table 4-4 and Table 4-5 summarises the applicable tolerances for manifolds and trees
respectively in accordance with Ref. [79].
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
top view
angle 1 = 0.2deg
side view
angle 2 = 0.2 deg
Sketch 2
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Sketch 3
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Spool & jumper design shall take into consideration maximum envelope for installation
purposes. Spool and jumper sizing shall consider installation limitations (spreader bar, cargo
barge,..).Spool & jumper design shall also take into consideration field layout constraint in
accordance with item relevant to each drilling centre.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
5.1 General
Table 5-1 below gives the general characteristics of the spools and jumpers to be designed
as per Ref. [48].
ID(spools)/OD(jumpers)
System Item Material Grade
[mm]
Spool 203.2
Gas Injection Jumper 168.3
Spool 254.0 API 5L X65
Water injection Jumper 168.3
Spool 254.0
Production
Jumper 168.3 Duplex UNSS31803
The wall thicknesses will be determined in accordance to this document and will be detailed
in Refs [48] and [47].
The wall thicknesses shall include the following corrosion allowance in accordance to
reference [15].
The internal corrosion allowance for the flowlines is presented in Table 5-2. External corrosion
allowance is 0mm.
System Description
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The pipeline material for the spools and jumpers are presented in Table 5-3, Refs. [1], [59] & [60].
Unit Value
System Gas Injection Water Injection Production
Production Jumper
Spools/Jumpers Spools/Jumpers Spool
Grade
- API 5L X65 API 5L X65 API 5L X65 Duplex UNSS31803
(1)
SMYS MPa 448 490
(1)
Derated SMYS MPa 431@ 75°C - 418 @ 107°C 360@ 107°C
SMTS MPa 530 620
Derated SMTS MPa 513 @ 75°C - 500 @ 107°C 496@ 107°C
3
Density kg/m 7850 7800
5 5
Youngs Modulus MPa 2.07x10 2.00x10
Derated Youngs 5
MPa - - - 1.94x10 @ 107°C
Modulus
Poisson Ratio - 0.3
Expansion -1 -6 -6
°C 11.6x10 13.0x10
Coefficient
(1) values shown are YS at 0.2% proof strain
Specification [51] describes the main parameters of the insulation coating system for
production spools & jumpers.
For the GI & WI spools & jumpers, 3LPE coating has been selected in accordance with
references [36] & [52] .
Anode properties, which are to be used for design purpose, are specified in the General Cathodic
Protection Philosophy document, ref. [45]
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Detailed definition of the extreme pressure and temperatures which may occur in the AKPO
flowlines and risers during normal and abnormal operating conditions is given in reference [18].
Pressure and temperature cycles are contained in addendum of reference [15] and further
explained for flowline design in reference [48].
In relation to pipelines, maximum internal pressure during normal operation, referred to reference
height which is MSL with the FPSO at 10m draft, to which the pipeline or pipeline section shall be
designed. The design pressure must take account of steady flow conditions over the full range of
flow rates, as well as possible packing and shut-in conditions, over the whole length of the pipeline
or pipeline section which is to have a constant design pressure.
In accordance with references [1] & [57] design pressure definition as represented in Figure 6-1
and the design pressures tabulated in Section 5.2 will be used for the AKPO spools/jumpers detail
design. Spools & jumpers design pressure is as per flowlines.
Reference [57] details design and hydrotest pressures at the various elevations in accordance with
reference [26].
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Pressures have been obtained from COMPANY references [15] & [18] as follows.
The following should be noted:
6.2.1 Production
The governing load case for the production flowlines is the injection of methanol when production
flowlines are full of dead oil after preservation operations, ref. [18].
Table 6-1 & Table 6-2 show the maximum allowable operating, incidental and design pressures
and temperatures respectively, Ref. [63].
Table 6-1: Maximum Allowable Operating , Incidental & Design Pressures for the Production Lines
Pressure Definition Units Value
Max. Allowable Operating Pressure (MAOP)
Riser top ( @ MSL) bara 369
Riser base ( MSL- 1320 m) bara 471
Flowline, spools & jumpers (MSL -1400 m ) bara 477
Design
Riser top ( @ MSL) bara 387
Riser base ( MSL- 1320 m) bara 489
Flowline, spools & jumpers (MSL -1400 m ) bara 495
Incidental
Riser top ( @ MSL) bara 425
Riser base ( MSL- 1320 m) 527
Flowline, spools & jumpers (MSL-1400m) bara 533
Table 6-2: Maximum & Minimum Operating & Design Temperatures For Production Flowlines
Operating Design
o
Maximum Temperature ( C) 102 107
o
Minimum Temperature ( C) -13 -18
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Table 6-3 & Table 6-4 show the maximum allowable operating, incidental and design pressures
and temperatures respectively, Ref. [63].
Table 6-3: Maximum Operating, Incidental & Design Pressures for the Water Injection Lines
Table 6-4: Maximum & Minimum Design Temperatures For Water Injection Flowlines
Operating Design
o
Maximum Temperature ( C) 38 48
o
Minimum Temperature ( C) 4 -1
In accordance with reference [18], potential pressurization sources of the gas injection pipeline are:
Table 6-5 & Table 6-6 show the maximum allowable operating, incidental and design pressures
and temperatures respectively, Ref. [63].
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Table 6-5: Maximum Operating , Incidental & Design Pressures for the Gas Injection
Flowline.
Table 6-6: Maximum & Minimum Design Temperatures For Gas Injection Flowline
Operating Design
o
Maximum Temperature ( C) 10 75
o
Minimum Temperature ( C) -1 -6
Hydrotest pressures listed in the table below are in accordance with reference [57]:
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The cyclic requirements for the different types of flowlines are given in Ref [15]
7. GEOTECHNICAL DATA
Soils evaluation and coefficients of friction are in accordance with reference [58]. Shear strength
profiles are provided in Table 7-1 & Table 7-2.
Table 7-3 gives the soil friction coefficient values that are used in the preliminary design. These
values are inline with Ref. [17] and shall also be used for detailed design analyses. The soil vertical
stiffness will be in accordance with Ref [5].
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
8. ENVIRONMENTAL DATA
Summaries of relevant environmental data shown in following sections have been extracted from
reference [19].
U9m above seabed 0.32 0.26 0.20 When required the current
profiles near the seabed can
be calculated using formula
22.3 from ref [19] and shall be
applied to any direction
Water Levels (m)
Crest Elevation 4.4 3.6 2.8
HAT/LAT 2.0
MHWS/LAT 1.8
MSL/LAT 1.0
Storm Surge 0.5 0.4 0.2
Return Periods for Environmental Loads shall be combined in accordance with Table 8-2 below.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The following table gives the water density to be used for the spool and jumper design:
The seawater temperature profile at water depths from 0 to 1368 m is given in reference [19]. For
engineering purposes the seawater temperature at seabed shall be taken as follows:
o
• Minimum = 4.0 C
o
• Maximum = 4.5 C
As per reference [19], no marine growth is considered within water depths below 150 m
The water depths at the spools and jumpers locations are shown in Table 8-4.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Pipeline Water
Structure
Reference Depth (m)
GI 40 MG41 1370
TW 11 1387
TW 12 1403
WI 10 TW 13 1409
TW 14 1411
FW 13 1431
TW 21 1325
TW 22 1336
WI 20 TW 23 1372
TW 24 1401
FW 21 1443
TW 31 1299
TW 32 1297
WI 30
TW 33 1315
FW 31 1322
WI 50 FW 51 1316
MP 11 1310
P 10
MP 12 1336
MP21 1340
P 20
MP22 1391
MP31 1329
P 30
MP32 1353
MP41 1322
P40 MP42 1358
MP43 1360
Hydrodynamic coefficients are shown in Table 8-5 below in accordance with reference [3].
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
9. ALLOWABLE LOADS
The allowable loads for connectors are extracted from reference [68] and summarized in Table
9-1. The maximum loads below are to be taken at the centre of connector hub face.
Table 9-1 Allowable Connector Loads
@ 0 PSI @ 7500 PSI
Bending Torsion Tension Bending Torsion Tension
Connector
Moment Moment (kN) Moment Moment (kN)
Type
(kNm) (kNm) (kNm) (kNm)
My/Mz Mx Fx My/Mz Mx Fx
6” 541 81 7048 456 81 5947
10” 714 187 6116 433 187 3710
12” 732 205 6276 329 205 2820
The allowable receptacle loads are My=Mz=136kNm as defined in Ref. [80]. This values are
specified with reference to the coordinate system shown in Sketch 3.
10.1 General
The spools and jumper design shall be checked in accordance with DnV OS-F-101, ref. [1]. In
accordance with this prime reference the design will be based upon limit state and partial safety
factor methodology, also called Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) which ensures a
satisfactory level of safety where the design load effect does not exceed the design resistance.
The spool/jumper components (e.g. bends & reducers) shall be designed in accordance with
DNV OS-F101, Ref. [1] Section 12, F1200, and stress intensification factors at bends shall use
ASME B31.8, Ref. [11].
In accordance with Section 5, B506 & B507of DNV OS-F101, Ref. [1], Duplex linepipe require
special considerations of the susceptibility of environmentally assisted cracking (including SSC
and hydrogen induced cracking related to cathodic protection). The precautions are only related
to the production jumper design and will be covered in this item’s respective design report. The
special considerations are mainly a reduced strength utilisation and reduced cathodic protection
potential, ref [53].
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
In accordance with Ref. [43], resistances, except for pressure containment resistance,
shall be calculated based on wall thickness as follows:
where tcorr is the corrosion allowance which is to be taken as per Table 5-2. The collapse
resistance will be considered in accordance with Ref [2].
Characteristic material properties shall be used in the resistance calculations. The yield
stress and tensile strength shall be based on the engineering stress-strain curve. The
characteristic material strength values to be used are given in Table 10-1.
Safety classes shall be as defined in Table 10-2 below. Location class 2 shall be considered.
However, in accordance with ref. [81], location class 1 can be considered for equivalent stress
check.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Partial Safety Factors for Location Class 2 shall be as presented in Table 10-3 below.
γ F , γ E and γ A are the functional, environmental and accidental load effect factors and
γ C is the load condition factor. The load factors are given in Table 10-4 and Table 10-5.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
where:
γm shall be taken as 1.15 for serviceability, ultimate and accidental limits states and 1.00
for fatigue limit states.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
For load controlled conditions, pipe members subjected to combined loading and internal
overpressure shall be designed to satisfy the following requirements:
Under load controlled conditions, pipe members subjected to combined loading and
external overpressure shall be designed to satisfy the following requirements:
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The spool and jumper bends are checked, in addition to local buckling as stated in Section 10.1
above, for the stress the based criteria in accordance with DnV OS-F-101, Section 12, F1200, ref.
[1]. The stress based criteria of Section 12 F1200 applied provided that:
• The applied moment and axial load can be considered displacement controlled
• That the pipe not has a potential for collapse. This can be considered ok if the system
collapse design capacity is three times the external overpressure in question.
• That the imposed ovality is acceptable.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Where
σe Equivalent stress
σl Longitudinal stress
η Usage factor as given in Table 5-7
fy Yield stress
fy = (SMYS - fy.temp) x αu
where fy.temp – derating value due to temperature of the yield stress
τth Tangential shear stress
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
If the combined loading criteria are not satisfied, the design of the spools can be checked
against global and local non-linear strain based criteria as described in APPENDIX A.
The fatigue design of the spools and jumpers will be performed taking into account all sources
of stress variations due to repeated shut down cycles and VIV. The number of shut down
cycles is given in Ref. [15]. Fatigue verification will be performed in accordance with DNV RP
C203. The VIV verification will be in accordance with Ref. [6].
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The spools and jumpers shall be subject to the functional loads during installation and operation.
These are summarized in Table 11-1.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
This section outlines the methodology for the major aspects of AKPO spool and jumper
mechanical design. For more details on design methodology, refer to specific spool and/or jumper
detailed design report.
12.1 General
The analysis shall be carried out using the piping system analysis programme, Autopipe version
6.3. Autopipe is a PC-based pipe stress analysis program developed by Rebis Industrial
Workgroup Software which uses a finite element method to calculate the piping response to
various external loads (weight, expansion loads, platform guide deflections etc.) taking into
account the piping stiffness.
The non-linear analyses for strain based design shall be carried out using the finite element
software Abaqus version 6.6.1.
In order to optimize the design for different systems, at least the following spools & jumpers
typologies shall be analysed:
Pipeline end expansions and rotations shall be applied at the end of the model where applicable.
The analysis shall also consider all applicable displacements due to gravity and environmental
loads. Detailed design input is provided in Appendix A.
All the computer models to be generated shall have the following common features:
- Both installation and operating load cases shall be considered. The installation
load cases will consider that the spools and jumpers are installed flooded.
- The model ends shall be anchored and pipeline end expansion (for spools)
applied at the end of the model
- Soil shall be modeled as spring with both lower bound and upper bound axial
and lateral friction coefficients to be considered in derivation of the stiffness for
axial and lateral springs respectively. Spring values for downward stiffness shall
be obtained based on method proposed in DNV-RP-F105, March 2002.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Jumper & spool detail design will take into consideration the following stages:
All spools and jumpers will be designed in accordance with CONTRACTOR’S installation
methodology. Specific spools & jumpers detailed design reports will contain in detail how the
installation methodology and the various tolerances are addressed.
The loads will be applied in the following sequence. It should be noted that a general methodology
is presented and may be subject to change during detail design.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
- A range of load cases are to be defined to simulate the in-place condition. These in-
place conditions take into account a tolerance of +/-70mm on the seabed elevation.
- The interface loads shall be reported which will be derived from the spool design
and issued to COMPANY. COMPANY will review the loads and confirm acceptability
or otherwise. To allow assessment of the tie-in loads for each load case analysed,
CONTRACTOR will report the loads, compared against the maximum allowable
connector loads, as defined in Table 9-1.
For the in-place condition the following loads shall be applied in the hydrotest and operational
cases.
Hydrotest
- Apply gravitational loads
- Apply translations and rotations to simulate tie-in at end 1
- Apply translations and rotations to simulate tie-in at end 2
- Apply hydrotest pressure
Operational
- Apply translations and rotations to simulate tie-in at end 1
- Apply translations and rotations to simulate tie-in at end 2
- Apply design pressure
- Apply temperature differential
- Apply pipeline end expansions at FLET for spools
All the combinations due to metrology and fabrication tolerances will be considered in the
installation analysis model for the jumpers and spools.
Operational load cases are presented in Table 12-1 as an example of how the load cases are
considered in Autopipe.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The above cases will be analysed in the following sequences as noted below:
• First; Gravity
• Second; U
• Third; Thermal, which is based on U
• Fourth; Pressure, which is based on Thermal.
• Fifth; W which are based on Pressure.
Both jumper and spool analyses will be performed considering the same methodology except the
spool model will consider loads imposed due to pipeline end expansion. Resultant loads will be
checked against allowable loading as defined in Section 9.2.
As required in reference [16], flow lines construction, installation fatigue analysis will be performed.
The scope of the fatigue study (location, degree of detail) will be defined in the detailed design
report.
Fatigue analyses due to cycle of shutdown / start-up (for production, water injection, and gas
injection lines) will be evaluated in detailed design in accordance with Section 6.3, as well as VIV,
if applicable. Fatigue criteria, SN-curves and SCF’s will be in accordance with DNV RP C203, ref
[16].
The transition piece will be modelled where there is a diameter reduction from the connector to the
pipe section or from a bend to thinner pipe section. This may be modelled directly in Autopipe as a
pipe element similar to a concentric reducer. If necessary a further SIF will be applied for
determination of stresses.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The forces and moments will be extracted from the output files and compliance will be checked in
accordance with DNV-OS-F101 (Section 9.2), load controlled local buckling criterion. An in-house
developed spreadsheet, developed for importing the results from Autopipe and performing the
local buckling check will be used to process the results of the analyses for all cases.
13. INSTALLATION
Spools and jumpers will be installed with the SaiBOS FDS according to the eventual sea states
limitations defined in the installation analyses, Ref. [64]. The detailed design of spools and jumpers lift
arrangement, transportation grillage and seafastening arrangement shall be covered in Ref. [64] and
as a minimum the following shall be considered;
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
A1-Introduction
For the AKPO field development, the spools and jumpers design is required to accommodate
forced end rotations and linear displacements to accommodate the installation and fabrication
tolerances. These forced rotations and displacements are largely the governing design parameters
contributing to a large proportion of the stress state and potentially causing stresses beyond the
allowable WSD limits.
Given that a large proportion of the stress state is driven by imposed displacements, the
verification of the spools and jumpers can be performed for non-linear strain based design. The
methodology for the verification of the spools and jumpers for the non-linear strain based design is
described in sections below in accordance with DNV, Ref. [76].
A2-Allowable strains
The allowable compressive strains for the straight sections of the spools and jumpers will be
determined as the lower limit of 0.3% or the allowable limits of DNV OS F101. The same applies
for the bends where these will be the lower limit of 0.3% or the allowable limits determined by finite
element methods incorporating a safety factor of three on the critical strain limits.
For straight sections of the spools and jumpers, the limitation to 0.3% can be exceeded locally and
at areas of strain concentrations provided that the magnified strains are less than the allowable
limits determined according to DNV OS F101, sections 5 D 567 & D 508, or 0.6% (whichever is
lower).
For bends in the spools and jumpers, no strain concentrations are expected as the bends are free
from any welds and have straight ends with a length 500mm.
For the duplex jumpers, and in addition to the maximum compressive strains defined as above, a
reduced strain utilization will be considered to avoid HISC. This additional requirement is defined
according to the maximum principal strain limits shown Figure A2.1.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
(1) (1)
(1)
(1) The increased strain shall not extend over more than 5% of the wall thickness
Figure A2.1: Summary of allowable maximum principle strains for duplex jumpers
The allowable compressive strains for the straight section of the spools and jumpers will be
determined according to DNV OS F101. The allowable compressive strains for the
different spools and jumpers are shown in Table A2.1 below. The allowable compressive
strains have been conservatively calculated assuming zero hoop stress (i.e the hoop stress
correction factor has been ignored).
The compressive strain is calculated with the formula (5.25) of DNV OS F101:
In Table A2.1, it is shown that the straight sections of the spools and jumpers can
accommodate compressive strains in excess of 1.0%. However, and as conservative
assumption a reduced allowable limit of 0.3% will be considered for the AKPO project. At
regions of strain concentrations, the allowable compressive strains should not exceed 0.6%.
The allowable strains for the duplex jumpers are based on maximum principle strains as
shown in Table A2.2
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Table A2.1: Allowable Compressive Strains for Straight Sections (traditional carbon steels).
WT OD OD/WT Safety
Allowable Max Principal Strains
(mm) (mm) Class(%)
Adopted Limits (1)
Weld Regions Away from
Welds
Prod Jumper 18.3 168 9.20 High 0.25 0.3
Note 1: Allowable Limits shown are for nominal strains away from any stress raisers
Table A2.2: Allowable Maximum Principal Strains for Straight Sections (Duplex steels).
A2.2 Bends
The allowable compressive strain for the bends will be determined by non-linear finite element
methods. The allowable compressive strains will conservatively be determined for zero hoop
stress and for the corroded condition. The condition when the spools are empty during operation
will also be examined. However, it is worth noting that the spools and jumpers will be installed
flooded and will be hydro-tested and commissioned before the condition of minimum design
pressure arises. In this respect it is expected that the spool and jumper will develop residual
strains which will not result in the collapse of the bends due to depressurization. Nevertheless, the
effect of load history will be included in determining the bend capacity and this will be detailed in
the respective detailed design reports.
In the FE models for bends, two material behaviours were used: Duplex for the production jumpers
and X65 for all the others spools and jumpers. The Duplex behaviour is based on ref [60] (see
Table 5-3), the X65 behaviour is based on the Ramberg Osgood relationship.
The model will be constructed with shell elements. One end of the model will be restraint and the
other end will be subjected to an imposed rotation. An illustration of the model boundary
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
conditions and general geometry for the production spool bend is shown in Figure A2.2. The
critical compressive strain will be defined as the strain where the moment reaches its maximum
value. This is illustrated in Figure A2.2. In this figure which is relevant to the bends of the
production spool, it is shown that the critical compressive strain is 2%. Adopting a safety factor of
3, the maximum allowable compressive strain is 0.67%. However and in cases where the
allowable compressive strains are greater than 0.3%, a reduced allowable limit of 0.3% will be
considered for the AKPO project.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
It is worth noting that bends of the spools and jumpers are oversized against collapse and have a
low D/t ratio which makes their capacity equivalent to that of the mother pipe. This is illustrated in
Figure A2.4 which shows that at 1.2 strain, the capacity of the pipe is 1.12 the capacity of the
bend.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
8.0E+05
7.0E+05
6.0E+05
5.0E+05
Moment (Nm)
4.0E+05
Bend
Straight
3.0E+05
2.0E+05
1.0E+05
0.0E+00
Figure A2.4: Comparison between the capacity of the bend and the capacity of the pipe for the
production spool.
A detailed analysis to determine the capacity of the bends will be detailed in the design documents
for the different types of spools and jumpers. However, preliminary results for the different bends
of the AKPO spools and jumpers are summarised in Tables A2.3 and A2.4. The analysis was
performed for the empty condition (zero hoop stress) with the pipe in a corroded condition. The
table shows that the critical compressive strain is related to the D/t ratio and the bend radius but
the minimum critical compressive strain is for the WI spool bend which is of the maximum D/t ratio.
The critical compressive strain for this bend is 1.1%.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
Table A2.3: Allowable Compressive Strains for Bends for traditional carbon steels.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The verification of the spools and jumpers requires a detailed analysis to define the most onerous
combinations of rotational tolerances, linear tolerances, seabed friction and settlement of the
foundations. For example, each end of the spool will have two rotational tolerances (horizontal
and vertical), three linear tolerances (axial, horizontal and vertical) which result in a minimum
number of 128 load cases to be analyzed. These load cases have to be analyzed taking into
account the tolerance on the measured seabed height and the lower and upper bound soil
conditions. Considering the above load cases for the landing, Stroking, hydro-test and operating
conditions, the number of load cases to be considered is too significant to be considered in a non-
linear strain based design. Hence, a screening criterion based on linear elastic analysis will be
employed to define the governing load cases. The software used for the screening analysis will be
AUTOPIPE.
1. The maximum reaction moments at the ends of the spool or jumper (interface loads)
2. The maximum stress in the bends.
3. The maximum stress in the straight sections.
These governing load cases will then be analyzed in further detail using the non-linear strain based
design criteria. The software used for the strain based design will be ABAQUS.
ABAQUS will be used for the FE modeling of the spools and jumpers. The FE model will be made
with ELBOW31 elements. This type of elements:
1. Provide accurate modeling of the nonlinear response of initially circular pipes and
pipebends when distortion of the cross-section by ovalization and warping dominates the
behavior
2. Appear as beams but are shells with quite complex deformation patterns allowed
3. Use plane stress theory to model the deformation through the pipe wall;
A number of load cases will be modeled with reduced integration shell elements in order to verify
the results obtained with elbow elements. The objective here is not the verification of the elbow
elements provided by ABAQUS but to ensure that the consistent results are obtained using
different modeling approaches.
The mesh used for finite element analysis shall be selected to model accurately the geometry,
boundary conditions and applied loads. In addition, mesh convergence analysis will be provided to
ensure that the size of the elements are adequate to capture the response of the spool or jumper.
The finite element analysis shall be based on von Mises yield criterion and associated flow rule.
Isotropic strain hardening will be assumed. In the absence of more representative material plasticity
models, the stress-strain curve will be based on the Ramberg Osgood relationship.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
The FE model will include stiffness discontinuities across the weld. This will be achieved by
incorporating a weak joint at the most onerous location. In the FE model the spool or jumper will
be modeled with nominal dimensions and stress strain curve of the weak joint will be modeled with
reduced dimensions and yield strength. For the weaker joint, the wall thickness will be calculated
as:
t w = t n − 2 Sd w
where t w is the wall thickness of the weaker pipe, t n is the nominal wall thickness of the pipe and
Sd w is the standard deviation of the wall thickness. The standard deviation of the pipe will be
calculated based on the maximum and minimum wall thickness in tolerance as:
t max − t min
Sd w =
6
The yield strength of the weaker joint will be calculated as the nominal YS minus one standard
deviation times the square root of two. The covariance of the yield strength will be considered 4%.
The verification of the spool or jumper will be established taking into account the history of the load
sequence from landing to operation.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.
NIGERIA - OML 130 AKPO
AKPO Field Development Project LOGO
REPORT
Doc reference Rev.
NG50-3-200-ENG-RP-AB-00-2235-001.3.doc
WARNING: This document as printed may not be the latest version. Please refer to the electronic file in the MDR tools.