1 Republic of the Philippines

2 Province of Samar
3 MUNICIPALITY OF BASEY
4 -oOo-
5 Office of the Sangguniang Bayan
6
7 JOURNAL OF THE REGULAR SESSION OF THE SANGGUNIANG BAYAN OF BASEY, PROVINCE OF SAMAR HELD ON JULY
8 25, 2022 AT THE SANGGUNIANG BAYAN SESSION HALL.
9
10 Present:
11 Hon. WILFREDO O. ESTORNINOS -SB Member
12 Hon. DORLEEN JOY E. CABANTAC -SB Member
13 Hon. JOQUINT MANUEL L. OREJOLA -SB Member / Presiding Officer
14 Hon. VICENTE C. LABUAC III -SB Member
15 Hon. PERICLES L. CINCO -SB Member
16 Hon. ARIEL P. DURAN -SB Member
17 Hon. ALUDIA C. DURAN -SB Member
18 Hon. ELNORA C. QUEBEC -SB Member
19 Hon. PERLA PERPETUA G. PONFERRADA -ABC Pres. / SB Member
20 Hon. JEYV ANNE M. LOZANO -SK Fed. Pres. / SB Member
21
22 Absent:
23 Hon. HONESTO M. ZETA -Municipal Vice Mayor (on official travel)
24
25 CALL TO ORDER:
26
27 (The Presiding Officer Pro Tempore, Hon. Joquint L. Orejola calls the session to order at 9:58 in the morning.)
28 Secretary – Good morning, may I request everyone to please stand up.
29 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Session is now call to order. Before we proceed to the roll call, may I request Hon. Quebec to lead the prayer.
30 (Hon. Quebec leads the prayer). Thank you, Hon. Quebec. Madam Secretary, will please call the roll?
31 Secretary – Yes, Mr. Chair may I call the roll; Hon. Honesto M. Zeta, Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos, Hon. Dorleen Joy E. Cabantac, Hon. Joquint
32 Manuel L. Orejola, Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III, Hon. Pericles L. Cinco, Hon. Ariel P. Duran, Hon. Aludia C. Duran, Hon. Elnora C. Quebec, Hon.
33 Perla Perpetua G. Ponferrada, and Hon. Jeyv Anne M. Lozano. Mr. Chair, majority of the Sangguniang Bayan members are present.
34 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Madam Secretary. Considering all members are present in this session, the temporary presiding
35 officer, requests quorum. Session is now in order. Madam Secretary will you please read the minutes.
36 Secretary – My apology to the august body that I wasn’t able to prepare the minutes for last session for the reason that I was on travel last few days
37 and I will just send the e-copy of the minutes this week.
38 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Madam Secretary. Considering that our Madam Secretary is on official travel in the past few days,
39 can I recognize Hon. Labuac to defer the reading of the previous minutes. (Hon. labuac is recognized).
40 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Mr. Chair, I move to defer the previous minutes.
41 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – There is a motion of Hon. Labuac to defer the previous minutes. If there are any questions? Hearing none, the
42 motion is now approved. Privilege hour, is there any privilege hour? Before we proceed to the privilege hour and question hour, we have here our
43 visitor in person of Sir Dulcisimo Prieto Jr., the Project Development Officer to Sustainable Livelihood Program of the DSWD, Region VIII to shed
44 us light regarding the Memorandum of Agreement to the authorized of this august body, to Hon. Mayor to enter the Memorandum Agreement for the
45 DSWD and this LGU. Before we proceed, may we give the floor to Hon. Labuac to move for the suspension or our rules.
46 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – I move for the suspension of the house rules, Mr. Chair.
47 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – I second, Mr. Chair.
48 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – There is a motion to suspend the rules duly seconded by all members of this august body. The rules is now
49 suspended.
50
51 SUSPENSION: 10:03 A.M.
52
53 APPEARANCE:
54 1. Dulcisiomo G. Prieto Jr., Project Development Officer to Sustainable Livelihood Program of DSWD, Region VIII
55 (The council together with the Mr. Dulcisimo had further discussions to shed light on the Resolution authorizing the Municipal Mayor to enter into a
56 Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) for the DSWD and Sustainable Livelihood Program (SLP) and Specific Implementation (SIA)).
57
58 RESUMPTION: 10:50 A.M.
59
60 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Mr. Chair, I move for the resurrection of the rules.
61 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Session is now resumed.
62 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Mr. Chair, before we proceed can we excuse first our visitor?
63 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, our visitor, Mr. Prieto you are now excused. Thank you. Okay, we are now in the privilege hour. Anyone
64 who wish to? Yes, Hon. Labuac you are recognized.
65
66 PRIVILEGE HOUR:
67
68 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – As a member han Peace and Order Committee, siguro ini nga concern ighahatag ko ini nga subject ha aton Peace and
69 Order Chairman kan Hon. Cles Cinco nga ma-consider naton an pag-invite han aton Chief of Police, bahin hini nga Peace and Order situation dinhi
70 ha Basay. Kay I am very sad nga mayda usa nga local investor dinhi ha Basay nga ginpatay, ginhold-up, so, kunbaga it’s really damaging ha aton
71 ekonomiya, kon kikitaon naton an ira ginkakaptan an feeds, kanan kahayopan, so, hino pa man it mga investors it mga masakob dinhi ha Basay. Kay
72 usually bisan ngani gab-e, iba it hulagway hit Basay dire parehos han una, kay ano? Han una kase mayda naglilinibot libot nga curfew kutob it hira
73 ala-una, naglilinibot libot hit usa nga lugar. So, name-miss ko it sugad nga situation nga kon kay ano nga it aton yana Chief of Police nga waray man
74 may na-robing dinhi hit aton area? So, Mr. Chair, adi man it aton Peace and Order kon ano ba it iya poydi ma-kuan kay kon magpapatawag ba kita
75 dinhi.
76

77 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Labuac. Actually, earlier with our LCE we had an initial discussions regarding han crime nga
78 natabo han previous days, even the mayor is gusto gihapon niya maka-aro hin updates tapos kon ano it mga pitad nga ginhihimo hit aton PNP dinhi
79 ha Basay. So, earlier nag-suggest gihapon an aton mga membro nga konta mapatawag gihap an aton Chief of Police, ngan as a member hit
80 Sanggunian ini nga legislation kon nagkikinahanglan hin ordinansa, ngan kon ano man it suhestiyon hit aton PNP, babation ta gihapon an ira side. Of
81 course, as elected of our people, usa naton gihapon nga obligasyon para mabaton or ma-address an iba-iba nga problema especially ini nga mga
82 natatabo hit aton munisipyo kay dire la ini harumamay. Thank you, Hon. Labuac.
83 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – It continuation hiton, mga igkase ko business man o parehas ha aton kita nga politiko nga aadi ha lingkuranan parang
84 unsecure para magginawas gawas. Maaram kamo nafi-feel gihapon iton niyo nga bagat mayda ba sugad nga situation nga baga nag-aalang lugod kita
85 imbes hit nga makakagserbisyo lugod kita dinhi hit aton bunto nag-aalang lugod kita kay bangin may interesado dida, dire la kita maaram, it sugad
Page | 1
 86 kase hini nga situation kinahanglan ta proteksyonan an aton mga citizen labi na gud an mga incoming investors, kay ano? Paro’t yana nga mga
87 panhitabo, makuri iton ha aton mga investors made-discourage imbes nga magpapadayon konta pag negosyo nganhi, waray na. ngan usa iton nga
88 problema iton dinhi ha Basay kay makukurian man pagdeposito hit kwarta, waray man naton banko, okay la konta nga ipadayon ta iton nga
89 resolution ta hit aton bungto, kay ano? Kay it mga negosyante it ira mga kwarta ginkikinaputan nala, dire man nadedeposito ha banko, harayo man ha
90 Tacloban, ita-travel mo, delikado. Usa gihapon iton. Kon pagbulig manla hit ekonomiya it aton, buligan naton it mga local investors, naghahangyo
91 ako kon poydi naton e-revive an aton resolution hadto’n mga multi-national bank nga mag create hira hin branches dinhe ha Basay, maupay konta
92 iton nga pitad. Para maging secured an negosyo.
93 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Sige, before we go further, we will the floor to the Chair of Peace and Order to say something.
94 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Thank you, Mr. Chair. Kasumpay gadla hadto hank an Hon. Labuac, iton nga ginpatay nga negosyante, actually, barkada
95 koi ton, kausa ko’t hiya pagbike, konbaga ha kamagsangkay, nakabulig ngani it hiya yana ha akon han kampanya, pero kay siring man makuri, bisan
96 ngani ha akon baga mabug-at nga dughan han nanabo ha iya ngan dire la ini para ha iya, para na ha aton ngatan, ngatanan nga aadi ha Basay, makuri
97 it kabutang, pareho han kasang-gab-e, hi Remos ginpusil ha may Bangon, so, bagan makluba na gud nga duro nga waay na pili, kunbaga hin-o na gud
98 siguro it patayon, madali nala ngan mas delikado ngani kita kay mga opisyal kita hit bungto, pero nagka-ada kita hini hin solusyon han una han diba
99 may ginpusil ha Tingib an paragkalamsi, an paragbaligya hin kidya, adto mismo pira ka semana la’t ada, nakapasa kita hin ordinansa nga baga
100 makagpugong pugong la it mga tawo nga may-ada maraot nga intension ha aton, an pagtanggal han helmet ngan kon ano man nga nakakatago han ira
101 mga personalidad and ira mga nawong an mga matawo nga lugar, an problema hini kay puro la kita ordinansa, ha implementasyon kita nagkukulang.
102 Ini nga aton chief yana, dire ak hin nag-aalang, waray lipod lipod, talaga maluya in hiya han mga naglabay nga mga chief kay kon manunumdom
103 kamo, an panahon ni Chief Malibago, amo adto nak pinakamaupay nga chief, adlaw gab-e adto naro-robbing, nan-ngangapkap ha mga tindahan,
104 irignuman, bast amagrobbing hira mangangapkap adto hira hin may nasasabtan hin may pisaw o pusil, tapos an baga mag-isog isog, danay pa ngani
105 nira tinutumba so, amo adto an akon baga inuupayan hadto kay nabilib a khan sugad hadto nga chief kay an sumunod hadto ha iya nga mga Chief of
106 Police dinhi ha Basay puro gud may ginpapabilin nga legasiya. Hi Chief Sumpo, an mga paragmotor damo na gihap adto an iya mga nagkai-
107 impound, hi Chief Munoz, asya gihap iton an mga mag-aringasa nga mga motor, basat damo adto an mga waray permit, an mga waray lesinsya nga
108 paraghabal habal, nadakop niya, basat ini la nga chief it waray ko kinikita nga baga accomplishment nga maupay nga baga makakapabilib ha aton
109 kay baman an usa, an mga naglabay nga chief okay man, dinhi an una namon nga termino nagging bisita namon iton, ambot kon kita na adto nga set,
110 an nagpatawag kita han mga traffic enforcer, nga an iya rason han mga napila dida ha may ML kay kairo man kuno it mga pamilya hiton, irarason ba
111 iton hin usa nga pulis? Nga chief of Police pagud hiya, ha madagmit nga Istorya, dire ak hit naayon ha iya ngan tikang liwat pag chief niya, sunod
112 sunod na nga nahihinabo nga kremin dinhi, an pira pala kabulan an naglabay mayda gintigbas dida nga parag pedicab. So, kulang hin police
113 visibility. Ha Tingib mayda gikuan nga resolution nga magkaada kita hin ma-duty naman la nga pulis, may sub-station, it rason pirme manla balik
114 balik, kulang hira hin tawo, so, amo iton, Mr. Chair.
115 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – Can I intervene?
116 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, are you done, Hon. Cinco?
117 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Yes, Mr. Chair.
118 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Hon. Quebec is recognized.
119 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to suggest that a Committee Meeting; Committee Hearing be done with regards to this
120 because a discussion like is not enough, we have to come-up with a concrete session with regards to this. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
121 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, thank you, Hon. Quebec. Duly note with your suggestions.
122 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Mr. Chair, kadugangan la, ngan dire ta ini problema hit kanan SB Committee on Peace and Order kundi mayda ta
123 tinatawag nga kabug-usan, Municipal Peace and Order Council. So, kinahanglan ma-meeting ini. Dapat ngani ha aton balaud mayda kita hiton
124 meeting, quarterly meeting iton nga MPOC, and Municipal and Order Council. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
125 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Cinco. Hon. Estorninos is recognized.
126 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – At this juncture, Mr. Chair. As already mentioned by Hon. Quebec, I would like to move that we constitute a
127 committee of the whole so that the chief of police be invited during our session, so that they will know what’s the plan, operational plans in order to
128 address the criminalities in our community as our co-league, Hon. Labuac mentioned we are an unsecure situation because of lack of law
129 enforcement in the municipality. Besides, if there is a need for the PNP to come-up with strategic plan in order to address the problem. I so move,
130 Mr. Chair.
131 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec and Hon. Ariel P. Duran – I second the motion.
132 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, there is a suggestion of Hon. Estorninos that the body will act as committee as a whole regarding hini nga
133 mga issues. I would like to ask Hon. Estorninos to move it for the inclusion in our agenda.
134 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – I move, Mr. Chair that this motion be included in our agenda for the privileges.
135 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – There’s a motion that the proposed…. (asked clarification from SB Secretary).
136 Secretary – Can I say something? Maybe, Hon. Estorninos is just suggesting that the body will constitute as a committee as whole to treat this issue,
137 on the next session, Hon. Estorninos?
138 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Can we have it this afternoon? The Police Officer is just around.
139 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – So, in as much we are in a privilege hour, so, maybe it’s our time also to immediately know the status, pero if the
140 body request na magka-ada hin committee hearing rather than discussing in this session, it’s up to the body kon ano it iyo suggestions kon ma-
141 conduct kita hin Committee Hearing.
142 Secretary – The body will conduct a committee hearing.
143 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – That’s why I am suggesting that said motion be referred to first reading for proper referral to the committee.
144 Hon. Perla Perpetua G. Ponferrada – Mr. Chair, mayda ko la ig-aadd konta, nga iton aton imbitasyon kan chief, kumanhi konta hiya kay damo na
145 iton nga committee nga puro la representative, bisan ha amon dire iton hiya narepresenta. so, kon poydi hiya iton it makakanhi para makagbaton hiya
146 hit aton concern.
147 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, duly noted. May we suggest the secretary to send invitation to the Chief of Police to be present as
148 committee as whole to discuss hini nga mga issues. Thank you, honorables. Any other privilege speech? None? Question hour? Yes, Hon. Cinco.
149 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – kaparte la ini han panhatag, dire la ak sigurado kon ano nga ahensya, an AICS (Assistance to Individuals in Crisis
150 Situation) ngani? Kon hin-o an agency, maupay konta kon ma-imbitahan ta hit aton meeting kay para maka-eksplekar hiya kay it iba dinhi nga
151 konsehal kay puro kita it inpapakianhan ngan dire kita nakakabaton kaparte hini. Kon hin-o an pinan-nagan han tag three thousand tapos baga pinili
152 la, pero ginpo-post didto nga an makakarawat hini an poorest of the poor tapos aadto an nagpakakarawat mag-upay an mga panginabuhi, so an aton
153 dinhi kon hino man an concerned nga ahensya dinhi nga poydi maka-eksplekar dinhi hit aton kasugaran ngan kon naano an ira paagi han pamili kay
154 makuri hini kay kita nga mga opisyal han bungto papakianhan kita tapos dire kita nakakabaton, it huhuna-hunaon hit nira waray kita labot bagan
155 tubtob la kita palaum, waray na. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
156 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Cinco. I think, the MSWD is very knowledgeable hito nga concern, an Assistance to Individuals
157 in Crisis Situation, hira ini an may-ada knowledge pati na an selection, parte hini ngapanhatag han ayuda. Anyway, said item, Madam Secretary is
158 properly referred to Committee on Social Services and I would like to suggest also to our Secretary to send invitation han aton MSWDO next
159 session. Hon. Duran is duly recognized.
160 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Thank you, Mr. Chairman, only a suggestion for the updating ordinance, I would like to request to the honorable body, the
161 committee can invite the MPDC so that we can align our funds on how we can update or we can have our master plan in the future, so, I would like
162 to request a committee meeting in our next meeting, most likely on Tuesday next week.
163 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Is it a Committee Meeting or a Committee Hearing?
164 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Committee Meeting lang muna.
165 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Duly noted, Hon. Ariel Duran. Said matter is duly referred to….
166 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – If on Monday is not loaded for a committee level, we can have it on the afternoon.
167 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – The chair would like to……
168 Hon. Aludia C. Duran – Is it a committee as whole or not?
169 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Committee lang muna. Committee on House and Land Use, which is yours truly is your chairman.
Page | 2
170 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Duran said matter is duly referred to your committee.
171 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Conflict pala sa Monday yung sa LTRFB, I think Tuesday yata. Aw tomorrow.
172 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – So, what’s the final schedule for the committee meeting?
173 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Next Monday, after our session.
174 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, the Committee on Housing and Land Use would like to convene a meeting on Monday afternoon after the
175 session, properly referred to your committee being the chair.
176
177 FIRST READING AND REFERRAL:
178
179 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, let’s move on the First Reading and Referral, First Item under the First Reading, the Resolution authorizing
180 the Municipal Mayor to enter into a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) for the DSWD and Sustainable Livelihood Program (SLP) and Specific
181 Implementation Agreement (SIA) referred to the Committee on Social Services. Second Item, Resolution authorizing the Municipal Mayor, Hon. Luz
182 Chu Ponferrada to enter into a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) through the
183 Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) DENR Compound, Diliman, Quezon City, represented by Director, Engr. William P. Cunado referred to
184 as the Donor referred to Committee on Environment. Third is the review of Barangay Revenue Code of Brgy. Loyo, Basey, Samar referred to
185 committee on Ways and Means and Committee on Finance. Fourth is the review of Brgy. Ordinance No. 001, Series of 2022 of Brgy. Guirang,
186 Basey, Samar, an ordinance authorizing the office of the Municipal Treasurer to issue Barangay Clearance and Collect corresponding barangay
187 clearance fee in the application for any business-related transactions subject to the remittance of the aforesaid fees to the barangay and conditions
188 hereunder referred to Committee on Ways and Means, Committee on Finance and Committee on Legal Matters. Also, for third item be referred to
189 committee on Finance considering that this is an ordinance. Do we have any urgent request? Okay, before we proceed, may we discussed the certified
190 urgent and necessary by our LCE, the first item is the Resolution authorizing the Municipal Mayor to enter into a Memorandum of Understanding
191 (MOU) for the DSWD and Sustainable Livelihood Program (SLP) and Specific Implementation Agreement (SIA), so, being considered urgent and
192 necessary, the chair would like to open the discussion for deliberation for its approval. Yes, Hon. Labuac is recognized.
193 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – To properly discuss it for the deliberation, I move it in 2nd reading, Mr. Chair.
194 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – I think, there’s no need to move for 2nd reading considering that the item is considered as urgent and necessary. If
195 the body has no more question pertains to the approval of the said measure, I think the chair is now ready to accept motion for its adoption. May we
196 give the floor to the chair-committee.
197 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Mr. Chair, since this request is urget and necessary, the people, the recipient of this program, I move for the approval
198 for the 3rd and Final Reading.
199 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Dire, it Committee Chair nala it mamotiona.
200 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – There is a suggestion of Hon. Cinco that the said item be properly moved for the chairman Committee on Social
201 Services. Anyway, kanina gin-refer ta man ini ha Committee on Social Services.
202 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Mr. Chair, I move for the withdrawal of my motion.
203 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, thank you, Hon. Labuac, any discussion with regards to this measure? Being none, chairman is now ready to
204 accept any motion from the chair on Social Services. Hon. Duran is now recognized.
205 Hon. Aludia C. Duran – Mr. Chair, considering that this is an urgent request, I move for the approval for this.
206 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – I second.
207 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, there is a motion of approval of this measure; resolution authorizing the Municipal Mayor to enter into a
208 Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) for the DSWD and Sustainable Livelihood Program (SLP) and Specific Implementation Agreement (SIA)
209 duly seconded by Hon. Labuac, any objection? Hearing none, the motion is now certified. Another Item certified urgent request from our Municipal
210 Mayor authorizing her, Hon. Luz Chu Ponferrada to enter into a Memorandum of Agreement with the Department of Environment and Natural
211 Resources (DENR) through the Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) DENR Compound, Diliman, Quezon City, represented by Director,
212 Engr. William P. Cunado referred to as the Donor and now the chair would like to solicit any queries or questions. May we ask any member to ask
213 regarding this measure? Waray? Okay, before we move, Hon. Ariel Duran is recognized.
214 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Thank you, Mr. Chairman, since this morning we had a discussion in the Mayor’s Office, I move that the resolution request
215 from Municipal Mayor, I move for the approval of this reasolution.
216 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Before we proceed to the approval, I would like to give the floor to Hon. Estorninos to say something.
217 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – After reading the resolution, it does not mention any subject at all, so, I do believe, Mr. Chair that this resolution be
218 given need and cite what particular Memorandum of Agreement is being entered into by our Municipality cared by our Municipal Mayor, it does not
219 define the subject, it only says; Resolution authorizing the Municipal Mayor, Hon. Luz Chu Ponferrada to enter into a Memorandum of Agreement
220 (MOA) with the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) through the Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) DENR, there
221 is nothing, there is no mention of what is to be entered upon, so, we have to implement this resolution, Mr. Chair.
222 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, thank you, Hon. Estorninos. May we give the floor to Hon. Quebec to answer.
223 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – Thank you, Mr. Chair. Actually, the document, the company in this Memorandum of Agreement between under mayor
224 and DENR are actually in good donation, the DENR is donating 250kg of waste shredder, waste shredder with a minimum of 250 kg, this is a great
225 help to us because if there is no shredder, the cell in our, didto ha may Roxas mapupuno na, so, we really need that shredder that nga mga plastic nga
226 ano nga ma-ishred hira, another is a composter with the capacity of 1,000kg per operation powered by 5HD by electric motor with steel reducer,
227 karuyag sidngon, the DENR is manifesting a great help to us by donating these equipments, so, Hon. Estorninos is correct that the statement does not
228 really manifests kon ano it iya gusto, so, siguro, we’ll just change some items, some words in it kay it iya gud jest is a Deed of Donation.
229 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, thank you, Hon. Quebec, just a clarification from the gentlemen, it is right and proper that we authorize our
230 mayor to sign a Deed of Donation, not to enter into a MOA kay this is just a grant from the DENR paghatag hin mga equipment nganhi ha aton LGU,
231 I think, there’s no need to authorize to a MOA rather to authorize her to sign a Deed of Donation. Okay, may we ask the chair on Committee on
232 Environment.
233 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Mr. Chair, I have to revise my motion.
234 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – May we give the floor to Hon. Ariel Duran to make a formal motion with the revise title.
235 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – As the inquiry were already clarified, I would like to move to change my motion on the Item No. 2, authorizing the
236 Municipal Mayor, Hon. Luz Chu Ponferrada to sign a Deed of Donation instead of Memorandum of Understanding.
237 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Duran duly seconded by all. There is a motion by Hon. Ariel Duran to pass a resolution
238 authorizing the Municipal Mayor to sign the Deed of Donation instead of the MOU, Deed of Donation with the Department of Environment and
239 Natural Resources duly seconded by all. The item is now approved. Third Item, the review of Barangay Revenue Code of Brgy. Loyo, Basey, Samar
240 referred to the Committee on Ways and Means, legal matters and Finance, said item still on the Committee Level, schedule will follow nalang
241 afterwards also the fourth item, the review of Brgy. Ordinance No. 001, Series of 2022 of Brgy. Guirang, Basey, Samar, an ordinance authorizing the
242 office of the Municipal Treasurer to issue Barangay Clearance and Collect corresponding barangay clearance fee in the application for any business-
243 related transactions subject to the remittance of the aforesaid fees to the barangay and conditions hereunder, still at the Committee Level, schedule
244 will follow nalang for the Committee Hearing to be announced later. Any other agenda? None.
245
246 COMMITTEE REPORT:
247
248 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Let’s proceed to the Committee Report. For Item No. 1, the review of Barangay Appropriation Ordinances /
249 Barangay Budget and Annual Investment Plan for CY 2022 of the following barangays: Brgy. Old San Agustin, Brgy. Baloog, Brgy. Bacubac, Brgy.
250 Pelit, Brgy. Buenavista and Brgy. Magallanes. (Hon. Labuac is recognized).
251 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Point of inquiry, an kan Hon. Estorninos ginpa-include ha First Reading, an kanan committee as a whole?
252 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Said measure is duly referred to Committee as a whole, pag committee as a whole dire man naton kinahanglan ig-
253 refer ha kuan, bali, as suggested, the Secretary will just send a communication ha aton Chief of Police.

Page | 3
254 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Thank you, Mr. Chair.
255 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, Hon. Cinco?
256 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Mr. Chair, poydi gihap naton ma-invite it AFP (Arm Forces of the Philippines)?
257 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – I do believe, Mr. Chair it’s a Police matter, we can’t invite the Army, the army has specific functions, besides the
258 Local Chief Executive can call an immediate meeting with the Municipal Peace and Order Council, where upon the police as well as the military can
259 be invited before the council, as of now, what we need is the chief of police.
260 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Mr. Chair, nahingadayan ko la ini pagmention kay han pagkabuwas hadto nga nahinabo dida han gab-e, actually, dida la
261 ako magka-ada hin inpormasyon han intel han army, hiya an nag-inistorya ha akon kay maaram adto hiya kay usa hiton hit ira nakikita hiton nga
262 pagtikas bangin kuno mga taga igbaw ngan an usa nira nga nakikita nga nagsusugad kay makuri man it ira kabutang ha igbaw tungod kay mga sarang
263 man yana it sundalo amo iton nga pag-iristorya ta yana sumulod la haak huna-huna amo nga nagsuggest ako kay bangin liwat hira makabulig ha ira
264 intelligence.
265 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Cinco. Hon. Quebec is recognized.
266 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – Thank you, Mr. Chair. This just a suggestion medjo mailap la hiton nga parte, aton ngani pagdunganon it AFP ngan PNP,
267 mayda gihap hiton nira competition, so, possible ma-hurt it usa, so, since it aton focus is iton nga pagka-involve hiton police, I would like to suggest
268 nga police la anay, PNP la anay, afterwards, anyway, mag-iiristorya man kita about hiton nga imo ginsisiring nga intel, afterward poydi na kita mag-
269 invite, pero sisiguraduhon naton nga suggestion ni Hon. Ponferrada nga sinisiring nga dire na-attend, siguraduhon naton nga mag-attend iton hiya.
270 That’s all.
271 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Quebec, I think, with the suggestion of Hon. Estorninos, siguro magpersonal nala kita pagsiring
272 kan mayor pagsuggest ha iya para pag-convene han Peace and Order Council para mahingadayan ini nga issues and concerns with the presence han
273 ngatanan nga mga miyembro han council, ada naman iton it Chief of Police, AFP ngan iba pa nga mga miyembro hit council, duly noted of the
274 suggestion of Hon. Quebec. Okay, let’s go back to our Committee Report. First Item, still in the Committee Level considering that this afternoon is
275 our Committee Hearing with these barangays, still in the Committee Level. Second Item, Ordinance creating the Office of Internal Audit Services
276 referred to Committee on Ways and Means and Committee on Finance.
277 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – Mr. Chair, I would like to suggest that this be given attention, committee meeting is not enough, I already have proposed
278 ordinances, Municipal Nutrition Office and Office of Internal Audit Services that this can be done kay madugay na ini nga, this can be given maybe
279 20 minutes or 30 minutes for each, we will be able to have this on the second reading.
280 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – So, there is a suggestion or comment, if I am not mistaken of the said item to have a discussion.
281 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – Committee meeting.
282 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Considering that said item is properly referred to the committee, I suggest next session we discuss this, pag-
283 convene la anay kita as a whole if okay la? Agreed by this august body, because ini nga item, bali nakinahanglan ini hin discussion especially hini
284 nga august body. Okay for Item No. 4, review of Barangay Ordinance No. 001-2021, Barangay Revenue Code of Brgy. Buenavista, Basey, Samar
285 referred to Committee on Finance and Barangay Affairs, still in the Committee Level this afternoon also. Item No. 5, an ordinance renaming three (3)
286 unnamed streets located at the New Basey Public Market and Transport Terminal Area referred to Committee on Laws and Legal Matters, still in the
287 Committee Level. (Hon. Ariel Duran is recognized).
288 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Is there a proponent of this ordinance, none? So, we can archive this item if there is no sponsor of this item.
289 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you for your suggestion, Hon. Duran. May we ask our Madam Secretary kon hino an sponsor hini nga
290 ordinansa kay kon waray naman hini sponsor, maybe this item can be taken out from our item until such time nga mayda somebody nga member na
291 nabuhi hini nga ordinansa, kon hino it magiging proponent. (Hon. Labuac is recognized).
292 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Siguro ini nga ordinansa, kon tatrabahuon, ig-upod nala it pabahay kay dadamuro talaga it kalsada nga waray ngaran,
293 pagsearch ko ha google maps, pag-oorder ko waray ngani nabibilngan, konta ngatanan bibilngan hin ngaran.
294 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – May I repeat my question who is the proponent of this item?
295 Secretary – It was Hon. Delovino.
296 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – The proposed ordinance has sponsor? So, any suggestion from the body? Yes, the chair on legal matters is
297 recognized to shedlight.
298 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Maybe this day, remain at the committee level.
299 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – I suggest nalang to our Secretary to furnish nalang a copy for Hon. Estoninos.
300 Secretary – I already furnished copies to each.
301 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Point of inquiry, Mr. Chair.
302 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, what is your point of inquiry?
303 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – As a vice-chair han Committee on rules, nakinahanglan ba iton nga patay na it ngangaranan? Dire ada it tawag hiton.
304 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Alley.
305 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Kay haligot la iton, public market la iton.
306 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Actually dapat mag ngaran ngani patay na iton dapat, tapos ada iton nga law, mayda hiton batas, after 10 years han imo
307 kamatay, poydi na iton ipa-legislate.
308 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, thank you, Hon. Ariel Duran for answering the inquiries of Hon. Cinco kon waray hiton nga mga balaud,
309 waray hiton nga mga ngaran hiton nga mga buhi. Yes, Hon. Estorninos is recognized.
310 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Actually, Hon. Duran is right because you cannot accumulate to someone who is still alive. That’s why we have
311 Macapagal Street Avenue in the name of person.
312 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, so much for that, I think, the chair on Committee on Rules suggested that……
313 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – I support to the suggestion of Hon. Labuac kay damo nga mga streets an waray ngaran ha pabahay. Poydi man ini marefer ha
314 Committee on land Use para mapag-iristoryahan. Mayda man option, poydi man dire la ngaran it igbutang hit dida.
315 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, noted, Hon. Duran.
316 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – This regards to the proposed ordinance at the committee level, how about kon ihatag naton iton ha Committee on Tourism
317 and Heritage, so, upod man iton dida hit heritage, we will be talking kay nagsiring man hi Hon. Ariel Duran nga it ngaran kinahanglan patay na,
318 kunbaga heritage na hiya, so, therefore, there is a need to study on that and the proposal of Hon. Labuac was good. So, nakinahanglan gud hin
319 discussion para bangin liwat kita hiton awayon hit mga igkasi ta Basaynon kay nakabasa ak hiton, Macasaet, mayda Colinares, ngahin Caboboy ada
320 adto, baga sugad ba hiya hiton. I think, I go for it.
321 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Quebec the said measure is properly referred, Committee on Laws, Committee on Land Use and
322 Committee on Tourism. Yes, Hon. Labuac is recognized.
323 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Siguro, mas maupay kon Committee as whole hiya, kay ano? We should be part of the history, we create a history kay
324 ini nga aton gin-ngangaranan nga mga kalsada, igsusurat ini hit history hit Basay.
325 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, so much for that. With the discussion with this matter, niyan nala an announcement han schedule and we
326 will just decide hini nga matter kon ikukuan ta as a committee as a whole kon ano an ma-take charge hini nga discussion hit Committee Hearing.
327 Thank you, my dear co-leagues. Next item, a comprehensive Municipal Organic Agriculture Ordinance institutionalizing, promoting, conservation,
328 developing and protection of natural resources referred to Committee on Agriculture.
329 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – I will call a committee meeting on Wednesday.
330 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, 6th item, still at the committee level schedule on Wednesday at 9 o’clock in the morning.
331 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Or make it 10.
332 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Are you amenable with the schedule proposed by Hon. Estorninos? Okay, schedule will be finalized, okay, at the
333 committee level. Next item, review of Barangay Ordinance providing for a revenue code of Barangay Pelit, Basey, Samar referred to Committee on
334 Finance and Legal matters considering that it’s a Barangay Ordinance, still at the Committee Level. Next Item, Resolution authorizing the Municipal
335 Mayor to sign into a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with the Provincial Government of Samar for the implementation of Community Based
336 Monitoring System (CBMS). Next item, a Resolution concurring the appointment of Balbino B. Estorninos as Municipal Administrator referred to
337 the Committee on Human Resources and Employees Welfare, still in the Committee level.
Page | 4
338 Secretary – There’s a letter coming from the administrator.
339 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, there’s a letter by Mr. Balbino Estorninos to the Hon. Vice Mayor, Presiding Officer and to the honorable
340 members of this sangguniang bayan. May we ask the secretary to read the letter. (SB Secretary reads the letter from Mr. Balbino Estorninos).
341 Considering that the said concurrence is still referred to the Committee on Human Resource, may we ask the pressure of the chairman of the human
342 resource. Let me ask for the pressure of the body, are we going to wait lang muna?
343 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Do we have the appointment already?
344 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Aw mayda na. okay, based on the reply han aton administrator nga baga waray hiya maka-attender hadto kay
345 mayda niya BAC Meeting hadto nga Lunes, so, I suggest this afternoon, imbitaron ta nala hi Sir Balbin, aadi man kita ngatanan ano? Para ma-discuss
346 nala ini. Hon. Quebec is recognized.
347 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – Thank you, Mr. Chair, I just would like to ask, what’s really our purpose why we’re asking him to be present here kay
348 nakilala naman kita ha iya, maaram naman kita ha iya nga piira n aka-termino nga administrator hiya, para ha akon baga hin, I think, we can forego,
349 it’s only my opinion. For me, we can forego asking him to be here, syempre, ambot la, baga akon la iton nga nalalainan liwat ako hiton nga
350 ginpapatawag ta hiya for what reason? Sugad yana nga magurang na naton hiya, are we doubting his capacity? Kay ano pa ba it aton ipapakiana ha
351 iya? So, on my part, I would like to suggest na i-forego ta nala nga ayaw ta nala it hiya pagpinakanhi-a for respeto nala kay he is one ha kuan hit aton
352 bungto, dam’it iya ginkakaptan, very knowledgeable hiya, so, that’s only my opinion. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
353 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Quebec, siguro it imo pakiana kon kaylangan pa hiya pakahi-on or dire, it depends to the body.
354 The majority wanted him to appear before this august body, it’s up to you, it’s up to the majority, pero base ha akon eksperyensya adto nga akon tulo
355 ka termino, an concurrence manggud nga baga nahigaraan nga nakanhi anay hira, ginpreresentar it ira mga kalugaringon, actually, waray na damo
356 nga pakiana. We will try this afternoon, pero siring ko pa kanina, kon mayor hiya ha aton or it august body it magdecide nga aprobaran ini without
357 appearing before the august body, it’s up to you. Anyway, as chair, I’m just making a ruling kon ano it iyo aprobaran. Hon. Duran, any additional.
358 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – It akon liwat, since nagpe-perform na hiya hiton hit iya duty pero waray pa man naton concurrence which is ano man it legal
359 basis hit iya performance ha yana kay waray pa man magco-courtesy call hiton iya performance yana, just only comment, Mr. Chair.
360 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Actually, an position ni Sir Balbin Estorninos is co-terminos, karuyag sidngon an term niya madepende han term
361 ni mayor, tapos it appointment ngahaw kaylangan hin concurrence hit Sanggunian Bayan, so, before hiton nga iya position kaylangan hin
362 concurrence kay ginkikinahanglan iton ha Civil Service hit concurrence hit Sangguniang Bayan without the concurrence, dire iton maho-honor it iya
363 papel ngadto ha Civil Service Commission, that’s only my opinion.
364 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Being said that, Mr. Chairman, an iya activity tikang han usa ka-bulan is not valid unless otherwise, hi mayor nag-appoint hin
365 OIC one day before the concurrence of this august body, Mr. Chair.
366 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Siguro amo iton it matatabo
367 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Dapat appoint hi mayor as an OIC Administrator while waiting for the concurrence of this Sanggunian while waiting han
368 appointment ni Balbin Estorninos.
369 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Kay before hiya makapasa as Municipal Administrator, make sure to had been concurred before the Sangguniang
370 Bayan, otherwise kon waray pa hiton niya concurrence waray pa hiton niya legal personalities nga pagperfom hini nga functions as Municipal
371 Administrator. Hon. Labuac is recognized.
372 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Siguro para dire nala naton ini pagpahalabaon ba, kon ano talaga it proseso, sundon nala naton, this is a salary grade
373 24, baga pondo gud ini hit gobyerno ngan asya it mandates ha aton ngan request ini hit aton mayor, it akon nala pakiana, kon baga babalansehon
374 liwat naton ha kaluyo nga parte, poydi nala ini naton ini ma-approban nala kay urgent request man ini hiya, siguro, adto liwat nga service advantage,
375 usa gihapon iton han aton pag-approve han aton internal rules nga danay kase mayda obligasyon ta nga department head nga igkakatuman ta la hit
376 aton session, pero it akon la kase dire naka-klarohan kase ha pagkayana, ano ba it mas matimbang, it BAC Meeting ba o it pagpatwag hit SB? Siguro
377 la kon kaya naton sundon an tama nga proseso, i-approve naton hi Sir balbin ngan ig-invite la gihap hiya nganhi ha SB. Amo tak nakikita kay
378 nakikita ko. Amo la, Mr. Chair.
379 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Anyways, according to his reply, amenable man hiya pag-attend, only that, last session conflict an iya schedule
380 because of the BAC Meeting, that is why I am suggesting this afternoon kon poydi hiya maka-attender by next week kon makaka-appear hiya hit
381 session depende han pressure han body, let’s just decide accordingly.
382 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Mr. Chair, according to the protocol, kon dire hiya mag-aattend si Sir Estorninos, then, ig-inform naton hiya kase bangin hiya
383 maging tradition ba, nga pag-abot han panahon masiring hira nga tawo, sige approve nala kay okay man iya qualifications, but as long the protocol is
384 concern, kaylangan mag appear ha Sanggunian, so, kon kaylangan an appearance para ma concurred an usa nga applicant ba it tawag hiton or
385 appointed, then, let’s have it in a proper protocol, Mr. Chair to appear in this august body concurred by the appointment, that’s only my observation.
386 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Duran. Siguro, poydi gad iton, anyway, we still have time, let’s call on Mr. Balbin yana kon
387 maka-attender hiya yana, bangin kanina mayda hiya mga buruhaton, tapos yana okay na, we can proceed to the approval of this measure. Sige, let’s
388 try, Madam Secretary, anyway, magkulop man kita kay para kita mahuman. Okay, let’s go to the next item, under the Committee Reports, the
389 Ordinance creating position of the Municipal Department Head 1 (Chief Tourism Operations Officer) under Municipal Ordinance No. 40, series of
390 2018, and providing supplemental budget thereto, thus dissolving the position of Municipal Government Assistant Department Head 1 (Tourism
391 Officer) under the 2021 and 2022 Municipal Budget referred to Committee on Human Resource, Committee on Finance, and Committee on Ways &
392 Means, still in the Committee Level. Yes, Hon. Labuac is recognized.
393 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Actually, ini nga concern kase inin urgent kase in hiya kay magpapatron ngani it aton Bungto hit Basay and if it
394 would be possible nga hast ngada yana waray pa ngani ini ka-appoint o waray pa kita Municipal Tourism Officer, so, I think kon okay la ha iyo,
395 poydi ta man pakadaon hi Ma’am Vangie kay kon kikitaon naton it technicalities, mayda didi ginyayakan, ordinance. So, kaylangan in hiya nga
396 pakadion gud naton hi Ma’am Vangie.
397 Secretary – Mr. Chair, can I say something. Considering, Hon. Labuac that it is an ordinance that it has to go through an referred to the committee.
398 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Mr. Chair, it akon la hini, it akon la igsisiring, ini hiya, kon ano talaga it mayda hini ha iya kon kay ano ini kasugad hi
399 Ma’am Vangie kay bisan ngani ako.
400 Secretary – Actually, anybody can….
401 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Point of order, Mr. Chair, kon poydi ig invite naton, kon hino man it nakakakuan hini nga committee, pag-abot hin
402 Committee level ig invite niyo hi Ma’am Vangie ky amo it makakag-explain hini nga kabutangan.
403 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, thank you. The said item is also being properly referred to Committee on Tourism, it will be a joint
404 committee. The joint committee will schedule nalang for Committee Hearing, poydi buwas, poydi Wednesday para pag next session, the joint
405 committee will just render committee report kon ano an nag-transpire han Committee Hearing.
406 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Ig-upod nala it Committee on Tourism.
407 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, definitely. Yes, noted Hon. Labuac, thank you for your observation. Hon. Cinco is now recognized.
408 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Thank you, Mr. Chair. Diba mayda hadto gincre-create nga office, an Tourism? Ano pa adto pa an iba?
409 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – Waray na, dire na. Enterprise and investment.
410 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – So, ano naman adto hiya?
411 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – May I answer that one, the Civil Service Commission did not accept it, so, bumalik lugod han uru-una nga ordinansa an
412 Tourism Development nga Ordinance No. 40, pero iton iya mga trabaho investment, pwede hiya ig add-on nga mga trabaho, nga responsibility hit
413 Tourism Officer, but the title dire poydi Enterprise, Investment and Tourism Officer.
414 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Thank you, Hon. Quebec. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
415 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Cinco, as far as the creation of position is considered, I suggest ha mga committee pag-andam
416 kita hin Committee Hearing ngan ig-invite ta gihap an aton Finance Committee as our Resource Speaker kay based in our seminar last week dako
417 manggud an iban han aton NTA (National Tax Allocation) around 48 million, if I am not mistaken, amo iton nga mga consideration nga mga angay
418 naton kitaon ngan with presence gihapon han aton Budget Officer, kon hi kita dre na exceed han aton limitation kay mayda manggud hiton sinisiring
419 nga 40%. I suggest to the committee nga ig invite naton ini nga as resource speaker ini nga mga Department Heads. Thank you. Next item, the
420 Resolution authorizing the Municipal Mayor, Hon. Luz Chu Ponferrada to enter into a memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with the Anti-Red Tape

Page | 5
421 Authority (ARTA) represented herein by its Director General Secretary Jeremiah B. Belgica referred to Committee on Information and
422 Communication Technology. Hon. Labuac is recognized.
423 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Mr. Chair, ini nga dire manla ini madugay mag-committee hearing, kadungan liwat han kanan Tourism. An kanan
424 Tourism siguro hit Miyerkules ini kay may mga schedule yana nira, pero ini nga kanan ARTA, usally nakita ko ini ha mga major cities ngan first
425 class municipalities, ada ngani kita hit google, pag-open naton, aadi it pagkuha hit mga schedule hit business permit naton hit pagkukuha, nagagmit
426 ini nga ARTA, so, kon okay la kahuman hini, dire manla ini madugay.
427 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – So, you mean to say that we will schedule a Committee Hearing? After hit session. Okay, duly noted, Hon.
428 Labuac. Next item, Calendar of Business.
429
430 CALENDAR OF BUSINESS:
431
432 A. Unfinished Business:
433
434 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – The request of the MPDC to the local sanggunian for the review of the Local Public Transport Route Plan 2022-
435 2024 of the Municipality of Basey. May we give the floor to Hon. Ariel Duran.
436 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Thank you. We have had our Committee Hearing last week and we have seen clarifications and to invite other resource
437 person, we have scheduled meeting for tomorrow, 9AM, so kung sino ang gustong mag-attend hini nga Committee Hearing, tomorrow, 9AM. Thank
438 you, Mr. Chair.
439 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, thank you, Hon. Ariel Duran. Said item is still in the committee level. Okay, Business of the Day for 2 nd
440 reading, none. Business under 3rd and final reading, none. Unassigned or announcement?
441
442 ANNOUNCEMENT:
443
444 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Any announcement?
445 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Mr. Chair, I would like to schedule a Committee meeting, Committee on Agriculture.
446 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Committee on Agriculture scheduling a Committee Meeting this coming Wednesday, 10 o’clock.
447 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – It amon gihap Mr. Chair, kahuman hiton amon liwat hit kanan Tourism.
448 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Ano nga oras/
449 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Sunod nga time, mga 11.
450 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, thank you gentlemen, suggestion for schedule is duly noted and may request to send invitation nala han
451 mga members.
452 Secretary – Yes, noted.
453 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, Hon. Duran is recognized.
454 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – That’s all my concern.
455 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, Thank you, Hon. Duran. May we ask our secretary kon ano an update ni Sir Balbin. By the way, I would
456 like to take the opportunity ano, an last week nag-attender kami han kanan Association of Local Budget Officers han Region VIII didto ha Cebu in
457 which na-discuss didto parte han kanan aton budget preparation han next year for FY 2023, bali gin emphasize la ngadto parte han aton DTP
458 (Devolution Transition Plan) kon poydi ba kita mag amend kay diba gin amend naman ini han previous nga set of officials with the Department
459 Heads, so ginyakan didto just for the record and for the information of everybody, anytime an aton DTP poydi hiya amendaron as long as the LCE
460 will schedule, magconvene nala an tana an mga department heads, an bag-o nga set of officials para pag amend hini kon mada naton pag-aamendaron
461 ngan gin emphasize gihapon didto kon ano an mga naka-include nga mga projects and programs ha aton DTP, kaylangan iton mapondohan para hit
462 succeeding nga years, so amo it pinaka basis hit aton pagbudget especially we are in budget preparation yana nga time. So, that’s all. In addition, may
463 we give the floor to Hon. Duran.
464 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Don sa mga deadlines danay nagkakaada hin mga problema hini nga deadlines hiton
465 pagsa-submit hiton AIP, as I remember the AIP should be submitted June 30 and then yung budget is October 16, so, hiton nga mga deadlines
466 maaram kita, sopposed to be pag nagsubmit na ini nga mga barangay nga nabibitin naton it ira AIP dapat ma inform na naton hira nga an deadline hit
467 AIP is June 30 and for the budget is October 16, so, kon magsasubmit man hira didto hit MPDC ngan kon hino man it nagre-review hiton, dapat i-
468 informa na naton ang mga Barangay Captains, ini liwat nga aton MPDCO or any department heads nga concern, tutdoan para dire na magbinalik
469 balik, so, amo man it nahihinanabo yana as, kunbaga napansin ko ini nga nagdudugay it budget hit barangay kay ginpipinabalik balik naton, why not
470 ini nga mga department heads kon knowledgeable talag hira hit pagprepare hini hit AIP, tutduan an barangay han proper nga pagprepare hini nga AIP
471 or for the buget matter. Amo la, thank you very much.
472 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, thank you, Hon. Duran, hi ako gihapon as chairman hit Commttee on Finance, gusto ko gihapon iton
473 klaruhon ha aton mga department managers especially the Finance Committee, I would also like to suggest nga mag set kami hin meeting, the
474 committee and hini nga mga department head nga involve han budget preparation sugad han AIPs han aton barangay para makita anay naton an mga
475 problema, kon ano anmga rason kon kay ano nga AIPs and Budgets han barangay nadidilatar ura ura kay base ha amon seminar, gin advice ha amon
476 nga konta ma-observe na gihapon iton nga an proper nga time han submission han AIPs ngan Barangay Budgets kay an natatabo, dire pa ngani
477 approve an budget, dire pa ngani approve and AIP, sige na an ira paggasto han ira mga pondo which is para ha amon ngan dire la para ha amon as
478 mentioned ha amon seminar, illegal iton nga paggamit han pondo kon dire pa mga approve an budget han mga barangay. Yes, Hon. Labuac.
479 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Siguro, Mr. Chair an iyo pagkadto maupay iton nga duro konbaga waray na nakaklusot hit aton budget preparation
480 yana, na-notice ko la nga ha aton opisina nga kinahanglan na naton ig enhance liwat it aton services labi na gud kunbaga hi kita mayda na kita pondo
481 an aton Sangguniang Bayan, paupayon naton it response ngadi hit aton mga trabahuon, sugad hini nga damo ini nga papel, damo nga asikasuhon, so,
482 konta ma-consider naton ini ha aton Devolution Transition Plan nga magka-ada na manggud kita hin plantella position kada tagsa tagsa nga konsehal,
483 tag-urusa, kay ano? Damo man iton mga knowledgeable nga mga tawo nga poydi naton makuha, halimbawa, sweldohan hit aton opisina Salary
484 Grade 4 iton co-teminos position kada konsehal tag-urusa, ini nga mga irencodon nga mga papel, poydi ta la hira tawagan, sige schedule hit
485 Committee Hearing, mayda naton hiton close communication hiton nga tawo pero, I don’t iton nga ngatan yana hit aton J.O. kaya iton nga trabahuon
486 samantala kita ngatana nga mga konsehal may-ada kita plantella position tag-urusa, kon nagcocommitte hearing kita, ini hira nagmiminutes kunbaga
487 aton ika-duha dinhi ha SB, and then pagmeeting asya ini an napag-iristoryahan, mabulig hit pagformulate hit mga result hit Committee Hearing. So,
488 magkakada kita hin maupay nga output pantrabaho, ha pagkayana, tungod hit kamahaln hit sweldo, dire manggud iton masige us aka professional
489 nga halimbawa encoder o secretary nga nagtitinrabaho nga it sweldo 100 it minimum, makuri iton, it bug-at nga ginhahatag ha aton kadako, pero hit
490 aton lawas dire naton kaya, kamatuoran la. Kon okay la, igkuan gud naton iton. It Devolution kay kanan Madanas Ruling man iton i-puch na naton
491 iton nga magka-ada kita hin tag-urusa hiton nga plantella position kay ha iba nga lugar may-ada man hiton. Kon damo it aton trabahuon tapos dire
492 nakaya hit aton personalidad, dire kita nagkaka-ada hin ungod nga trabaho danay, halimbawa hit pagsakob ngadi hit first reading, ha aton committee,
493 pagsulod hiton referral, iton nga aton plantella position asya it magtitnrabaho, mamati didto nga may speaker didto ngan ginrerecord it mga tranauon
494 ni Konsehal, maupay it output hini nga aton ordinansa, it nanabo, sige it aton yakan it aton mga ideya, ginkukurian kita pagformulate, pag-collaborate
495 hiton nga tawo, pagconpile hiton nga mga ideyas, Keanu? Dire man naton kaya kon kita la nga usa.
496 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, thank you, Hon. Labuac. Maupay iton nga suhestyon kunbaga siring pa hini nga higayon nga siniring nga
497 devolution kunbaga hi kita as public servant, as member hit Sangguniang Bayan kunbaga ma-strictt gud kita tikang yana kutob hit sunod nga mga
498 panahon, damo ini nga mga trabahuon nga angay naton pagbuhaton. Kon hi kita la, baga kukurian na kita ngan hiton nga imo suhestyon baga
499 naabuyon ako hiton siguro pati an aton iba nga miyembro para mapadagmit an aton paghimo hin mga palisiya, mga balaudnon, mga resolusyon,
500 siguro it’s our time nga bisan manla plantella position hin usa nga researcher, diba? Manginginano hin mga proposal nga hiya it ma-suggest ha aton
501 nga buhata niyo ini nga mga ordinansa kay para hit ato kabug-usan nga mulupyo hit ikaka-upay, bisan researcher maupay gud iton nga mayda kita
502 researcher dinhi ha aton SB kay baga ha akon pagkabaro madugay naman iton nga proposal dinhi ha aton SB nga magkaada kita hin assistant, bisan
503 naman la legal researcher kon may-ada man, I don’t kon ano an nanabo hini kon mayda naba kita mga bag-o nga creation. May we ask our Madam
504 Secretary kon may-ada ba kita hini mga updates especially para hit aton newly elected Sangguniang Bayan Members just for the record ano? With
505 the connection of the manifestation of our Hon. Labuac.
Page | 6
506 Secretary – We have newly appointed employees dinhi ha office, Legal Assistance mayda kita, Legislative Assistant, mayda liwat kita Legistaltive
507 Assistant Employee, may Legistlative Staff, all in all mayda lima nga nahisulod nga bag-o nga appointees hini nga opisina, pero mas maupay ada kon
508 ma-oorient hira hit ira mga functions kay as of now dire it hira maaram kon ano it nakatutok ha ira, dire pa it hira na-function pa as of yana.
509 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – So, ibig sabihin, ma’am, ha akon nabatian, mayda ta mga bag-o nga gin-create, kakan-o la ini hira gincreate nga
510 mga item?
511 Secretary – An kanan 2022 it hiya.
512 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – So, mayda na hini mga tawo?
513 Secretary – Oo, an Legal Assistant, an expectation ko kase’t ha iya amo an ma-assist han mga sanggunian pagtrabaho han ordinances.
514 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Hino it hiya, hi De Maing?
515 Secretary – Oo, dire man liwat it hiya nareport ha opisina. Dire ak maaram kon ano it update kon nagle-leave, pero dire ko it hiya nakikit-an dinhi ha
516 opisina, ungod la, dire ako maaram kon ano it naka-assign ha iya nga trabaho.
517 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, Hon. Duran is recognized.
518 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – As I noticed ha explanation ni Secretary, can we request that yung mga position na yan appeal to us para mapakianhan naton
519 kon kaya nira iton nga trabaho nga ginhatag ha ira, total appointee man iton, an iba hiton regular position man, diba?
520 Secretary – Yes, regular.
521 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Since regular naman it ira position, can we request, Mr. Chairman to appear to us next meeting para mapakianhan la naton
522 kon kaya nira. Halimbawa, Legal Assistant, kaya ba niya magprepare hin draft resolutions para makabulig ha aton dinhi ha sanggunian kay amo man
523 iton pagbutanga ha imo hiton dida, kase kon dire hiya capable, balyuan naton hin usa nga capable para makabulig hit aton mga trabaho kay paro hiton
524 nga suggestion ni Hon. Labuac nga magka-ada kita hin individual legal officer or assistant, as of today as I heard, we have standing legal officer to
525 have us draft resolution to help us para maging magaan an aton trabaho, pero dire nagpe-perform, so, useless kon mag-aappoint kita hin mga position
526 nga dire nagpe-perform an bata, an tawo or iton nga officer, then, bakit gincre-create yan. Mr. Chair, my suggestion is papuntahin natin, tanungin
527 natin kung kaya bang magperform or not. Thank you.
528 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, thank you, Hon. Ariel Duran. Yes, Hon. Estorninos.
529 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Na mention kanina ni Secretary, waray kapa’t kita ha ira?
530 Secretary – Kumita na ako, hi Gilbert De Maing nakikit-an ko lat hiya danay ada ha gawas, nakaka-usa la hit usa aka-semana. Yana gud kay pira na
531 ka-months, dire ak maaram kon on leave hiya, as in waray gud hiya kakadi.
532 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Kay kakan-o pa man it hiya gin appoint?
533 Secretary – March 16, an iya effectivity. Damo gihap it mga empleyado it nagpapakiana, nakakapansin, o kon ano la. Mayda man kita mga proposed
534 postions ano, han pagdevolution planning naton, so, nasiring nga, ‘ayaw na kamo pagpropose kay waray man mga gamit (quote and quote) it iyo mga
535 gin-aappoint kay adi manla iton ha gawas.
536 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – So, they are still receiving salary?
537 Secretary – Yes po.
538 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Who signs his DTR?
539 Secretary – The Vice Mayor po.
540 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – The position is not co-terminos? Permanent position?
541 Secretary – Yes po. Kay dapat ngani siring ko, mayda kami hiton mga comitement hiton amon mga trabahuon, nasiring man ako, naano dawla it pag
542 rate ha iya? So, nakakalusot hiya kay amo na tak siniring kay makuri gadman in nga at opisina kay bisan dire na function kay dire man ak
543 makaksiring nga na dire na function kay dire man ako magre-rate because of the political situation.
544 Hon. Wilfredo O. Estorninos – Dire, kay kada position may-ada hiton PDF, Position Description Forms, kay amo konta iton it babasaran kon ano it
545 iya trabaho. Kon asya iton, let’s consult this first to our vice mayor.
546 Secretary – Yes, and he is aware actally, Mr. Chair kay bis ngani it iya recommendation performance dire na follow, maupay nala ig-invite nala
547 gudman hiya dinhi.
548 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Pakianhan naton kay bangin dire na niya kaya hit iya trabaho, magbiling kita hin capable.
549 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, ini nga aton ano, it’s just a matter of coordination. Let’s call the attention of these employees especially
550 nga mga permanent employees ini hira.
551 Secretary – An mga iba nga mga permanent employees dinhi, an iba dire la gud ada hira informed hit ira mga trabahuon kay hi Ma’am Quebec ngani
552 iya iton ginsa-suggest ngadi kan vice nga kon poydi kami igmeeting, kon ano it aton mga functions.
553 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – so, parang natigdaan la liwat kita nga may-ada ngay-an ini nga mga sugad nga plantella or mga position dinhi ha
554 opisina. Yes, Hon. Labuac.
555 Hon. Vicente C. Labuac III – Kunbaga nakikita ko, pagkarag la iton hin kwarta, nakikita ko ini liwat nga aton journalist kitaa nagsisinurat, proud ak
556 hit ha iya kay pirme present, pero it akon la ginsisiring, iton nga mga tawo nga mga dire nagpe-perform kinahanglan gud naton kita nga mga
557 konsehal mayda gud tag-urusa nga sidngon mayda ta tag-urusa nga administrator dida hit aton lamesa, itin hiya, it aton trust and confidence nga
558 ighahatag naton ha iya, kaya. Kita man it ma identiy hiton, kita man it makuha, tag-usa usahon naton kay iton nga may legal researcher, o kon ano pat
559 dida nga mga item, pag-abat ko dire liwat iton kaya hit mga trabahuon nga nanapulo kita nga mahimo hin ordinansa tapos uusa la hiya, 20 nga
560 ordinansa hiy usa kabulan, makuri iton hiya, samantala kita mayda kita ginkakaptan, tag-usa, tagduha, tagnapulo, iton nga ig-aassign nga tawo asya it
561 iya kakaptan gihapon nga task, researcher. Amo la iton it akon karuyag sidngon.
562 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Bali kunbaga natigdaan kita hini nga parte nga may-ada ngay-an mga empleyado nga gin-appoint nga dire
563 naperform han ira duty, siguro as your temporary presiding officer and kumo usa gihapon nga miyembro hit sangguniang bayan, I think, siguro,
564 personal kita nga mag-appeal hit aton department head, kan vice nga hi kita nakasabot kita hini nga mga empleyado konta macall-up an attention ini
565 nga mga permament employees kay kunbaga ha kuan nga istorya, unfair iton nga mga iba nga empleyados nga mga permanet employees nga
566 naperform hit ira duty everyday tapos adi hira ginswe-sweldohan dire ngani napakita hit ira lambong. Siguro, ini nga aton august body, I suggest nga
567 ayaw naton ig tolerate, sugad hini nga mga empleyado. Sige, Hon. Quebec muna is recognized.
568 Hon. Elnora C. Quebec – Thank you, Mr. Chair. I can feel that this is the fortune time, maiha na ini nga panahon, pero yana pala ako makakayakan
569 kay ginmention man, base on my observation, may-ada talaga problema, one, even it aton SB Secretary, ano gud it iiya authority over hit mga
570 empleyado? Kan kanay gud ini nga trabaho? Kanan Vice Mayor or kanan SB Secretary? Things like that, so, dire man iton hiya nakakasita nga mga
571 non-performing, waray man iton klaradoha nga ikaw kay permament ka man nga empleyado, under ka hini, so, waray ka-klaradohan, so, therefore, it
572 should be a major activity, I consider that as a major activity nga aton iton pag-iristoryahan, I mean, let us be pro-active, let us be positive kay puros
573 man ini pagpaka-upay hit aton sangguniang bayan nga han hadto nga mga panahon waray pa man iton nga mga empleyado nga yana ginbutangan na
574 hiton nga mga empleyado which is really good, so, ibutang naton dida, himoa ta nga agenda or executive session nalang with the vice mayor nga
575 tagan naton iton hin attention kay kon halimbawa, madaot it SB kita la gihapon iton ngatanan, so, amo la iton, Mr. Chair, maupay ngani kay na-
576 mention naton iton hiya.
577 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Thank you, Hon. Labuac for sharing hiton nga imo manisfestation. Yes, Hon. Cinco.
578 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mas madiru-dig-on ada kon napagkaka-urusahan naton hit sanggunian i-pormal ta, himoan ta hin
579 resolution, labot la nga makaka-storya ta hi vice, resolusyonan ta nga magkamay-ada hira hin orientation hit ira mga trabahuon.
580 Secretary – Actually, nahulat la it aton HR hit invitation kay hi vice manggud iton, it pondo aanhi man hit aton opisina, so, hi vice la iton it
581 magkukuan nga magkamay-ada hini nga activity. So, madepende la hit aton opisina.
582 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Oo, kay an akon la hadto nga magmarig-on nga tikang gihap ha aton.
583 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Internal man iton, dire na kaylangan ng resolution, I think, magpropose nalang siguro tayo para han Executive Session para
584 magperform ini nga mga appointees’ kay permanent naman iton hira, kay kase kon i-tolerate ta iton hira, saying an opportunity nga makakbulig konta
585 ha aton.
586 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Dire, ig-orient anay hira, bisan pira ka adlaw it ira orientation seminar para mabaro hira hit duties kon ano.
587 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Yes, in as much it aton Department Head is waray yana dinhi, so, I strongly suggest on next regular session,
588 anyway, temprano pa man kita nga aanhi kay it flag raising ceremony, alas otso man, 8:30 nahuhuman naman hira, so, let’s conduct an executive
589 meeting with our department head.
Page | 7
590 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – Mas maupay gihapon nga magmay-ada hin orientation hiton hit Civil Service kay para liwat mahibaro, kay usahay it
591 politika, kay danay it hira nagugupong kon hin-o it susundon, kon SB Secretary o kon it Vice Mayor kay manggud it hiya nga department head.
592 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay sige, let’s discuss it with our Municipal Vice Mayor next Monday prior to our session.
593 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – Mr. Chair, in addition, may Human Resource Committee man kita iglalayon ta nala para magperform it Human Resource.
594 Secretary – Update tikang han aton staff na kumadto na kumadto ha opisina ni Sir Balbin, aadto la kuno hiya hit iya opisina, dire kuno hiya
595 makakakadi.
596 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Okay, no more agenda. Any motion for adjournment?
597 Hon. Ariel P. Duran – I move for adjournment.
598 Hon. Pericles L. Cinco – I second, Mr. Chair.
599 Presiding Officer Pro Tempore – Session is now adjourned.
600 (Session is adjourned at 12:30 in the afternoon).
601
602
603 CERTIFIED TRUE AND CORRECT:
604
605
606 ROSENIE B. MALIBAGO
607 Stenographer

Page | 8