EE Comments Phase 1

PROJECT: PARK MCKINLEY WEST
REVIEWER: MEINHARDT PHILIPPINES INC.

DISCIPLINE : ELECTRICAL
ID NO. DOCUMENT SHEET NO. MPI COMMENTS 1st DDTKI'S RESPONSE 2nd MPI COMMENTS 2nd DDTKI'S RESPONSE 3rd MPI COMMENTS 3rd DDTKI'S RESPONSE 4th MPI COMMENTS STATUS REMARKS
PGBC compliance is not part of For Client's direction. - -
agreed/signed Contract Documents
Page 2 1.1 Under Code Excerpts, include Section 10.6.4 of the Philippine Green Building Code. between DDTKI and MC.
1.2 Average Illumination Levels compared to received Lighting Calculatoin. Noted. Acceptable. - -
A. Car Park - Passed

B. Driveway/Ramp - Passed
Closed based on 2nd
Closed batch of MPI Comments
dated 23June2020.
Complied. See attached Car Park Acceptable. - -

Closed based on 2nd
Entrance/Loading Bay Lighting
C. Car Park Entrance/Loading Bays - Missing Lighting Calculation Calculation. Closed batch of MPI Comments
dated 23June2020.
Electrical and
Complied. See attached M&E Plant Acceptable. - -
1.0 Auxiliary System Closed based on 2nd
Rooms Lighting Calculation.
Design Criteria D. M&E Plant Rooms - Missing Lighting Calculation Closed batch of MPI Comments
Page 4 dated 23June2020.
Complied. See attached Acceptable. - -
Closed based on 2nd
Security/Fire Command Center and
E. Security Fire Command Center/Maintenance Office - Missing Lighitng Calculation Maintenance Office Lighting Closed batch of MPI Comments
Calculation. dated 23June2020.
Complied. See attached Acceptable. - -
Closed based on 2nd
Administrarion Office Lighting
F. Administratoin Office - Missing Lighting Calculation Calculation. Closed batch of MPI Comments
dated 23June2020.
G. Stairs - Did not comply Complied. See revised EE Design Acceptable. - -
Brief.
Closed based on 2nd

dated 23June2020.
The term " LOCATION PLAN " was Noted. For Meralco approval for the location of tapping - -
Closed based on 2nd
2.1 Location Plan should be renamed as "Phase 1 Site Development Plan Layout". Kindly reflect the as per PEC CODE. point.
2.0 General Notes EE-01 Closed batch of MPI Comments
tapping point(existing manhole) and should be coordinated with MERALCO.
dated 23June2020.
3.1 Applicable to all lighting layouts: PGBC compliance is not part of For Client's direction. - -
agreed/signed Contract Documents
As per Philippine Green Building Code, occupancy sensors linked to lighting(except for emergency between DDTKI and MC.
and security lighting) shall be installed in areas with variable occupancy. See Section 10.6.4
Basement 3 EE-02.1(Typical
3.0 Lighting System to all Lighting
Layout Layout)
3.2 Tap to Lighting above Complied. See Revised drawing EE- Acceptable. - -
02.1
Closed based on 2nd

dated 23June2020.
Noted. See Revised drawing EE- Acceptable. - -

Basement 3 Closed based on 2nd
05.1 and EE-07.1
4.0 Power System EE-03.1 Risers of Grounding from Basement 3 to Basement 1 should be reflected. Closed batch of MPI Comments
Layout dated 23June2020.
Noted. See Revised drawing EE- Acceptable. Combined services drawing to be provided - -
Basement 1 Closed based on 2nd
Provide riser for the busduct serving MCCs for Chiller Plant Rooms; should be coordinated with 07.1 as shop drawing during construction.
5.0 Power System EE-07.1 Closed batch of MPI Comments
architectural consultant.
Layout dated 23June2020.
Closed based on 2nd
10.1.
6.1 Adjust text that is overlapping the architectural layout and other call-outs. Closed batch of MPI Comments
dated 23June2020.
Closed based on 2nd
10.1.
6.2 Indicate the routing of Genset to synchronization switchgear. Closed batch of MPI Comments
dated 23June2020.
6.3 Verify working clearance and accessibilty of LVSG and MVSG in compliance to PEC Chapters Noted. See Revised drawing EE- Acceptable. - -
1.10.2.1 and 1.10.3.5. 09.1, EE-10.1 and EE-11
Lower Ground
6.0 Power System EE-10.1
Layout
Closed based on 2nd
dated 23June2020.
Noted. See Revised drawing EE- Busduct routing along D-1/25 to G-1/26 still passing thru Noted. This was already considered in our Architectural For verification, no return comments Noted. For Meralco approval of
6.4 As requirement by Meralco for Secondary metering the busdcut routing should not pass through
10.1. inaccessible space/area. For coordination/approval with Ceiling Plan. from MPI. busduct routing. Closed
unaccessible space/areas such tenant space, area with ceiling.
Meralco.
Transformer Vault Room location for Noted. - -
Meralco supplied transformer were
initially coordinated and approved by
Closed based on 2nd
7.1 Location of transformer vault room should be reviewed and approved by Meralco. Transport and MERALCO including provisions of
access route during Closed batch of MPI Comments
during maintenance(if necessary to pull out) of the transformer should be considered in the layout.
transport/hauling, lifting and dated 23June2020.
Overall Power
7.0 EE-11 installation provisons based on their
Center Layout
requirements.
Noted. Transport/hauling including Noted. - -
Closed based on 2nd
7.2 Generator set layout should be considered during the transport, installation and maintenance(if provisions for installation and pull
out during maintenace were Closed batch of MPI Comments
necessary to pull out) in the layout.
considered. dated 23June2020.
Provided. See Revised drawing EE- Acceptable. - -
24TH to 25th Closed based on 2nd
Provide power provision for Constant Pressure Pumps at 24th Floor. Refer to P2-13 and P4-07 in 15 and 27
8.0 Floor Power EE-27 Closed batch of MPI Comments
Plumbing Drawings for pump ratings.
System Layout dated 23June2020.
Equipment Schedule and Mechanical Roofdeck Layout(sheets no. M-3.01 and M-38.01) reflect only Noted. See Revised drawing EE-29 Acceptable. - -
Tower A and B - Closed based on 2nd
two(2) units of Smoke Extraction Fan(SEF-1). While Electrical Layout shows 4 provisions.
9.0 Roof deck Power EE-29 Closed batch of MPI Comments
System Layout dated 23June2020.
10.1 For all 1-BR Types: Noted. See Revised drawing EE-31 Acceptable. - -
Inconsistent ratings with Load Schedule. Refer to Equipment Schedule in Mechanical Drawings,
sheet no. M-3.01, for the ACCU ratings.
Closed based on 2nd

EE-31 Closed batch of MPI Comments
dated 23June2020.
10.2 Bathroom branch circuits shall have no other outlets connected as per Chapter 2.10.1.11 ( C ) of Complied. See Revised drawing EE- Revised drawing still does not comply the PEC 2.10.1.11 Revised Bathroom Branch Circuit were in compliance to Noted on the Section 2.10.2.6(B). However, as per Noted. See revised EE-31, EE-33, Acceptable
the Philippine Electrical Code 2017 31, EE-33, EE-35, EE-37 and EE-39 (C). PEC Section 2.10.2.6(B) which read as follows " A 30- PEC Section 2.10.2.6, "In no case shall the load EE-35, EE-37 and EE-39. To comply
ampere branch circuit shall be permitted to supply fixed exceed the branch-circuit ampere rating. A branch with Philippine Electrical Code
( C ) Dwelling Units. lighting units with heavy-duty lampholders in other than circuit supplying two or more outlets or Chapter 2.10.1.11 ( C ).
dwelling unit(s) or utilization equipment in any receptacles shall supply only the loads specified
Residential Unit 3. Bathroom Branch Circuits. In addition to the number of branch circuits required by other parts of occupancy. A rating of any one cord-and-plug according to its size as specified in 2.10.2.6(A)
Blow-up Plans this section, at least one 230-volt, 20-ampere branch circuit shall be provided to supply a bathroom connected equipment shall not excedd 80 percent of through (D) and as summarized in 2.10.2.7 and
10.0 receptacle outlet(s). Such circuits shall have no other outlets. the branch circuit ampere rating.
Power System Table 2.10.2.7",
Layout A
Note: Utilization Equipment as defined by PEC as, See below table 2.10.2.7
Equipment that utilizes electric energy for electronic,
electromechanical, chemical, heating, lighting or similar
puposes.
EE-31, EE-33, EE-

Closed
35, EE-37, EE-39
The code only allows a 20-ampere circuit to supply outlet

with other equipment within the same bathroom
Kindly verify the availability of a 30A GFCI outlet.
Noted. See Revised drawing EE-31 Acceptable. - -

Closed based on 2nd
11.1 Inconsistent ACCU ratings with blow-up power layout for Typical Residential Panel: 1-Bedroom. Closed batch of MPI Comments
dated 23June2020.
11.0 Load Schedule EE-42
Noted. See Revised drawing EE-31, Acceptable. - -
Closed based on 2nd
EE-33, EE-35, EE-37 and EE-39
11.2 Inconsistent Ampere Frame sizes with blow-up power layouts. Closed batch of MPI Comments
dated 23June2020.
Noted. See Revised drawing EE-48 Not reflected in updated EE-48 Refer to drawing sheet EE-49 Acceptable. Refer to drawing sheet EE-49 Closed Closed based on 3rd
12.1 Consider the use of 4000 Amps
batch of MPI Comments
dated 13July2020.
EE-48
Tower B Power
12.0 Riser Schematic
Diagram
12.2 CPS pumps should be Triplex, 3-Hp. Refer to P4-07 in Plumbing Drawings. Noted. See Revised drawing EE-15 Acceptable. - -
Closed based on 2nd
and EE-27
EE-54 Closed batch of MPI Comments
dated 23June2020.
13.1 2000 kVA transformer rating as per Schematic Diagram. Noted. see revised specification Sec. Acceptable. - -
26 12 19
Closed based on 2nd

Section 26 12 19 -
Page 3
dated 23June2020.
13.2 Codes and Standards to be used for the project shall be the latest edition Noted. see revised specification Sec. Acceptable. - -
Closed based on 2nd
Section 26 12 19 - 26 12 19
Page 6
dated 23June2020.
13.3 2000 kVA transformer rating as per Schematic Diagram Noted. see revised specification Sec. Acceptable. - -
26 12 19
Closed based on 2nd

Section 26 12 19 -
Page 9
dated 23June2020.
13.4 Average Illumination Levels are shown as per Design Criteria. Please confirm what will govern. Design Criteria ( Average Calculated values for stairs already acceptable. However, Noted. See Revised Technical Specification and Design Acceptable. Noted. See Revised Technical Closed Closed based on 3rd
Technical Illumination ) will prevail. See on the revised design criteria, requried illumination for Brief. Specification and Design Brief. batch of MPI Comments
13.0 Revised Sec. 26 51 00 of Technical stairs are only 100.
Specifications dated 13July2020.
Specification.
Section 26 51 00 -
Page 4
Minimum required illumination for stairs as per NFPA 101

is 108.
Kindly specify what the asterisk(*) denotes.

REVIEWER: MEGAWORLD COMMERCIAL DEPARTMENT
STATUS REMARKS
MC COMMENTS (4-28-2020) DDTKI'S RESPONSE (07-07-2020) MC RESPONSE (7-13-2020) DDTKI'S RESPONSE (07-15-2020) MC COMMENTS (7-23-2020)
ID NO. DOCUMENT SHEET NO.
Noted, requesting for updated plan
Closed based on 3rd
HALLWAY LIGHTING FIXTURES SHALL
1 Electrical Plans EE-01 NOTED. WE WILL CONSIDER. COMPLIED. REFER TO UPDATED EE-01 WITH CLOUD. DONE CLOSED batch of MC Comments
BE LED TYPE
dated 23July2020.
For procurement comment and verification COMMERCIAL ADMIN OFFICE WAS NOT REFLECTED ON EE AND ECE
AGREED BID PLANS.
ELECTRICAL
BID PLAN
COMMERCIAL ADMIN OFFICE AT COMPLETE POWER AND LIGHTING
BASEMENT 1 (SEE PLANS WITH LAYOUT INCLUDING RELATED
COMMENT) AUXILIARY LAYOUT WILL BE PROVIDED
1.PROVIDE COMPLETE POWER AND UNDER ISSUANCE OF SEPARATE
LIGHTING LAYOUT (REFER TO LATEST CONSTRUCTION BULLETIN
2 Electrical Plans EE-06.1 FOR PROCUREMENT COMMENT AND VERIFICATION
AR. PLAN CONSIDERING THAT COMMERCIAL
INCLUDE AUX PANEL POWER PROV. ADMINISTRATION OFFICE WAS NOT
SEE ECE PLANS WITH COMMENT) INCLUDED IN ISSUED BID DOCUMENTS
2. PROVIDE DEDICATED PANEL BOARD AND NOT PART OF AGREED/SIGNED
MIN. 60AT, 3-PHASE. CONTRACT DOCUMENTS.
AUXILIARY
BID PLAN
60AT MINIMUM ON SINGLE PHASE Noted, requesting for updated plan

Closed based on 3rd
PROV.
3 Load Schedule EE-41 NOTED. WE WILL CONSIDER. COMPLIED. REFER TO UPDATED EE-13.1 & EE-41 WITH CLOUD. DONE CLOSED batch of MC Comments
(APPLY TO ALL RETAIL SPACES EXCEPT
dated 23July2020.
KIOSK/WALLSHOP)
Noted, requesting for updated plan
Closed based on 3rd
Commerical MVSG, LVSG, MCC and
4 Technical Specification NOTED. WE WILL CONSIDER. COMPLIED REFER TO UPDATED TECHNICAL SPECS. DONE CLOSED batch of MC Comments
Genset shall be BMS ready.
dated 23July2020.

EE Comments Phase 1

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

EE Comments Phase 1

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

PROJECT: PARK MCKINLEY WEST

REVIEWER: MEINHARDT PHILIPPINES INC.

A. Car Park - Passed

Complied. See attached Car Park Acceptable. - -

Closed based on 2nd

Closed based on 2nd

Noted. See Revised drawing EE- Acceptable. - -

Closed based on 2nd

EE-31, EE-33, EE-

The code only allows a 20-ampere circuit to supply outlet

Kindly verify the availability of a 30A GFCI outlet.

Noted. See Revised drawing EE-31 Acceptable. - -

Closed based on 2nd

Closed based on 2nd

Minimum required illumination for stairs as per NFPA 101

Kindly specify what the asterisk(*) denotes.

60AT MINIMUM ON SINGLE PHASE Noted, requesting for updated plan

You might also like