Sinhgad Technical Education Society’s

Sinhgad College of Engineering,

Vadgaon (Bk), Pune-41
Accredited with 'A+' grade by NAAC
Department of Mechanical Engineering
AY 2023-24, Semester I

COURSE NAME: Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and

Refrigeration (402041, BE COURSE 2019)
Name of Student:
Name of Experiment: Test on Ice plant test rig.
Course Outcome: CO1
Perform Date: ___ | ___ | 2023 Submission Date: ___ | ___ | 2023

Laboratory Continuous Assessment Rubric

SCALE
DIMENSION SCORE
1 2 3 4 5
Absent on Attended Attended Attended Attended
scheduled date practical practical practical practical
Regularity and & late session on session on session on session and
punctuality submission scheduled date; scheduled date; schedule; submitted as per
submitted three submitted two submitted one schedule
weeks late weeks late week late
Neither shows States the Can only state Understands Understands
any objective very the objective objective but objective and
Understanding
understanding vaguely but shows poor cannot placed it can relate it to
and
of the objective understanding in context of a an appropriate
preparation
nor can relate it theory theory topic
for Objective
to theory.

Does not Participated in Participated

Participated in Participated in
participate in experiment experiment experiment experiment
Participation experiment conduction conduction conduction on conduction on
in experiment conduction only with the with some
own without own without
performance help from supervisorysupervisory supervisory
& supervisor/othe help; but forgot
help; help; understood
Understanding rs and is some crucial
understood all all crucial
of theory confused concepts to
crucial concepts and
discuss conceptbut less discussed
discussion properly.
Cannot follow Follows Follows right Follows right Follows right
thepractical practical practical practical practical
Post practical guidelines and guidelines half- guidelines; but guidelines and guidelines; and
session skills do any work heartedly cannot interpret can interpret it interpret it with
it justification

Total out of 20 Marks

Total out of 06 Marks

Faculty Signature
 Sinhgad Technical Education Society’s
Sinhgad College of Engineering,
Vadgaon (Bk), Pune-41
Accredited with 'A+' grade by NAAC
Department of Mechanical Engineering
AY 2023-24, Semester I

COURSE NAME: Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and

Refrigeration (402041, BE COURSE 2019)
Name of Student:
Name of Experiment: Performance Simulation of Central Air-conditioning plant using
Newton Raphson Method.
Course Outcome: CO1, CO6
Perform Date: ___ | ___ | 2023 Submission Date: ___ | ___ | 2023

Laboratory Continuous Assessment Rubric

SCALE
DIMENSION SCORE
1 2 3 4 5
Absent on Attended Attended Attended Attended
scheduled date practical practical practical practical session
Regularity and & late session on session on session on and submitted as
punctuality submission scheduled date; scheduled date; schedule; per schedule
submitted three submitted two submitted one
weeks late weeks late week late
Neither shows States the Can only state Understands Understands
any objective very the objective objective but objective and
Understanding
understanding vaguely but shows poor cannot placed it can relate it to
and
of the objective understanding in context of a an appropriate
preparation
nor can relate it theory theory topic
for Objective
to theory.

Does not Participated in Participated in

Participated in Participated in
participate in discussion only discussion with
discussion on discussion on
Participation discussion with the help some own without own without
in discussion from supervisorysupervisory supervisory
about supervisor/othe help; but forgot
help; help; understood
understanding rs and is some crucial
understood all all crucial
of theory confused concepts to
crucial concept concepts and
discuss but less discussed
discussion properly.
Cannot follow Follows Follows right Follows right Follows right
the practical practical practical practical practical
Post practical guidelines and guidelines half- guidelines; but guidelines and guidelines; and
session skills do any work heartedly cannot interpret can interpret it interpret it with
it justification

Total out of 20 Marks

Total out of 06 Marks

Faculty Signature
 Sinhgad Technical Education Society’s
Sinhgad College of Engineering,
Vadgaon (Bk), Pune-41
Accredited with 'A+' grade by NAAC
Department of Mechanical Engineering
AY 2023-24, Semester I

COURSE NAME: Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and

Refrigeration (402041, BE COURSE 2019)
Name of Student:
Name of Experiment: Building heat load simulation using suitable software (Trace 700,
Energy plus etc.)
Course Outcome: CO4
Perform Date: ___ | ___ | 2023 Submission Date: ___ | ___ | 2023

Laboratory Continuous Assessment Rubric

SCALE
DIMENSION SCORE
1 2 3 4 5
Absent on Attended Attended Attended Attended
scheduled date practical practical practical practical session
Regularity and & late session on session on session on and submitted as
punctuality submission scheduled date; scheduled date; schedule; per schedule
submitted three submitted two submitted one
weeks late weeks late week late
Neither shows States the Can only state Understands Understands
any objective very the objective objective but objective and
Understanding
understanding vaguely but shows poor cannot placed it can relate it to
and
of the objective understanding in context of a an appropriate
preparation
nor can relate it theory theory topic
for Objective
to theory.

Does not Participated in Participated

Participated in Participated in
participate in experiment experiment experiment experiment
Participation experiment conduction conduction conduction on conduction on
in experiment conduction only with the with some
own without own without
performance help from supervisorysupervisory supervisory
& supervisor/othe help; but forgot
help; help; understood
Understanding rs and is some crucial
understood all all crucial
of theory confused concepts to
crucial concept concepts and
discuss but less discussed
discussion properly.
Cannot follow Follows Follows right Follows right Follows right
the practical practical practical practical practical
Post practical guidelines and guidelines half- guidelines; but guidelines and guidelines; and
session skills do any work heartedly cannot interpret can interpret it interpret it with
it justification

Total out of 20 Marks

Total out of 06 Marks

Faculty Signature
 Sinhgad Technical Education Society’s
Sinhgad College of Engineering,
Vadgaon (Bk), Pune-41
Accredited with 'A+' grade by NAAC
Department of Mechanical Engineering
AY 2023-24, Semester I

COURSE NAME: Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and

Refrigeration (402041, BE COURSE 2019)
Name of Student:
Name of Experiment: Performance analysis of Counter flow or cross flow cooling tower.
(Theoretical/Practical)
Course Outcome: CO4
Perform Date: ___ | ___ | 2023 Submission Date: ___ | ___ | 2023

Laboratory Continuous Assessment Rubric

SCALE
DIMENSION SCORE
1 2 3 4 5
Absent on Attended Attended Attended Attended
scheduled date practical practical practical practical session
Regularity and & late session on session on session on and submitted as
punctuality submission scheduled date; scheduled date; schedule; per schedule
submitted three submitted two submitted one
weeks late weeks late week late
Neither shows States the Can only state Understands Understands
any objective very the objective objective but objective and
Understanding
understanding vaguely but shows poor cannot placed it can relate it to
and
of the objective understanding in context of a an appropriate
preparation
nor can relate it theory theory topic
for Objective
to theory.

Does not Participated in Participated in

Participated in Participated in
participate in discussion only discussion with
discussion on discussion on
Participation discussion with the help some own without own without
in discussion from supervisorysupervisory supervisory
about supervisor/othe help; but forgot
help; help; understood
understanding rs and is some crucial
understood all all crucial
of theory confused concepts to
crucial concept concepts and
discuss but less discussed
discussion properly.
Cannot follow Follows Follows right Follows right Follows right
the practical practical practical practical practical
Post practical guidelines and guidelines half- guidelines; but guidelines and guidelines; and
session skills do any work heartedly cannot interpret can interpret it interpret it with
it justification

Total out of 20 Marks

Total out of 06 Marks

Faculty Signature
 Sinhgad Technical Education Society’s
Sinhgad College of Engineering,
Vadgaon (Bk), Pune-41
Accredited with 'A+' grade by NAAC
Department of Mechanical Engineering
AY 2023-24, Semester I

COURSE NAME: Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and

Refrigeration (402041, BE COURSE 2019)
Name of Student:
Name of Experiment: Design of cold storage with process layout
Course Outcome: CO4,CO5
Perform Date: ___ | ___ | 2023 Submission Date: ___ | ___ | 2023

Laboratory Continuous Assessment Rubric

SCALE
DIMENSION SCORE
1 2 3 4 5
Absent on Attended Attended Attended Attended
scheduled date practical practical practical practical session
Regularity and & late session on session on session on and submitted as
punctuality submission scheduled date; scheduled date; schedule; per schedule
submitted three submitted two submitted one
weeks late weeks late week late
Neither shows States the Can only state Understands Understands
any objective very the objective objective but objective and
Understanding
understanding vaguely but shows poor cannot placed it can relate it to
and
of the objective understanding in context of a an appropriate
preparation
nor can relate it theory theory topic
for Objective
to theory.

Does not Participated in Participated in

Participated in Participated in
participate in discussion only discussion with
discussion on discussion on
Participation discussion with the help some own without own without
in discussion from supervisorysupervisory supervisory
about supervisor/othe help; but forgot
help; help; understood
understanding rs and is some crucial
understood all all crucial
of theory confused concepts to
crucial concept concepts and
discuss but less discussed
discussion properly.
Cannot follow Follows Follows right Follows right Follows right
the practical practical practical practical practical
Post practical guidelines and guidelines half- guidelines; but guidelines and guidelines; and
session skills do any work heartedly cannot interpret can interpret it interpret it with
it justification

Total out of 20 Marks

Total out of 06 Marks

Faculty Signature
 Sinhgad Technical Education Society’s
Sinhgad College of Engineering,
Vadgaon (Bk), Pune-41
Accredited with 'A+' grade by NAAC
Department of Mechanical Engineering
AY 2023-24, Semester I

COURSE NAME: Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and

Refrigeration (402041, BE COURSE 2019)
Name of Student:
Name of Experiment: Analysis of VCC by Cool pack software.
Course Outcome: CO1,CO2
Perform Date: ___ | ___ | 2023 Submission Date: ___ | ___ | 2023

Laboratory Continuous Assessment Rubric

SCALE
DIMENSION SCORE
1 2 3 4 5
Absent on Attended Attended Attended Attended
scheduled date practical practical practical practical session
Regularity and & late session on session on session on and submitted as
punctuality submission scheduled date; scheduled date; schedule; per schedule
submitted three submitted two submitted one
weeks late weeks late week late
Neither shows States the Can only state Understands Understands
any objective very the objective objective but objective and
Understanding
understanding vaguely but shows poor cannot placed it can relate it to
and
of the objective understanding in context of a an appropriate
preparation
nor can relate it theory theory topic
for Objective
to theory.

Does not Participated in Participated

Participated in Participated in
participate in experiment experiment experiment experiment
Participation experiment conduction conduction conduction on conduction on
in experiment conduction only with the with some
own without own without
performance help from supervisorysupervisory supervisory
& supervisor/othe help; but forgot
help; help; understood
Understanding rs and is some crucial
understood all all crucial
of theory confused concepts to
crucial concept concepts and
discuss but less discussed
discussion properly.
Cannot follow Follows Follows right Follows right Follows right
the practical practical practical practical practical
Post practical guidelines and guidelines half- guidelines; but guidelines and guidelines; and
session skills do any work heartedly cannot interpret can interpret it interpret it with
it justification

Total out of 20 Marks

Total out of 06 Marks

Faculty Signature
 Sinhgad Technical Education Society’s
Sinhgad College of Engineering,
Vadgaon (Bk), Pune-41
Accredited with 'A+' grade by NAAC
Department of Mechanical Engineering
AY 2023-24, Semester I

COURSE NAME: Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and

Refrigeration (402041, BE COURSE 2019)
Name of Student:
Name of Experiment: Visit to Refrigeration or cold storage Plant
Course Outcome: CO4,CO5
Perform Date: ___ | ___ | 2023 Submission Date: ___ | ___ | 2023

Laboratory Continuous Assessment Rubric

SCALE
DIMENSION SCORE
1 2 3 4 5
Absent on Attended Attended Attended Attended
scheduled date practical practical practical practical session
Regularity and & late session on session on session on and submitted as
punctuality submission scheduled date; scheduled date; schedule; per schedule
submitted three submitted two submitted one
weeks late weeks late week late
Neither shows States the Can only state Understands Understands
any objective very the objective objective but objective and
Understanding
understanding vaguely but shows poor cannot placed it can relate it to
and
of the objective understanding in context of a an appropriate
preparation
nor can relate it theory theory topic
for Objective
to theory.

Does not Participated in Participated in

Participated in Participated in
Participation participate in discussion only discussion with
discussion on discussion on
in industrial discussion with the help some own without own without
visit & from supervisorysupervisory supervisory
correlate the supervisor/othe help; but forgot
help; help; understood
practical rs and is some crucial
understood all all crucial
aspects and confused concepts to
crucial concept concepts and
applications discuss but less discussed
discussion properly.
Cannot follow Follows Follows right Follows right Follows right
the practical practical practical practical practical
Post Industrial guidelines and guidelines half- guidelines; but guidelines and guidelines; and
Visit Skills do any work heartedly cannot interpret can interpret it interpret it with
it justification

Total out of 20 Marks

Total out of 06 Marks

Faculty Signature
 Sinhgad Technical Education Society’s
Sinhgad College of Engineering,
Vadgaon (Bk), Pune-41
Accredited with 'A+' grade by NAAC
Department of Mechanical Engineering
AY 2023-24, Semester I

COURSE NAME: Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and

Refrigeration (402041, BE COURSE 2019)
Name of Student:
Name of Experiment: Visit to Air Conditioning Plant.
Course Outcome: CO6
Perform Date: ___ | ___ | 2023 Submission Date: ___ | ___ | 2023

Laboratory Continuous Assessment Rubric

SCALE
DIMENSION SCORE
1 2 3 4 5
Absent on Attended Attended Attended Attended
scheduled date practical practical practical practical session
Regularity and & late session on session on session on and submitted as
punctuality submission scheduled date; scheduled date; schedule; per schedule
submitted three submitted two submitted one
weeks late weeks late week late
Neither shows States the Can only state Understands Understands
any objective very the objective objective but objective and
Understanding
understanding vaguely but shows poor cannot placed it can relate it to
and
of the objective understanding in context of a an appropriate
preparation
nor can relate it theory theory topic
for Objective
to theory.

Does not Participated in Participated in

Participated in Participated in
Participation participate in discussion only discussion with
discussion on discussion on
in industrial discussion with the help some own without own without
visit & from supervisorysupervisory supervisory
correlate the supervisor/othe help; but forgot
help; help; understood
practical rs and is some crucial
understood all all crucial
aspects and confused concepts to
crucial concept concepts and
applications discuss but less discussed
discussion properly.
Cannot follow Follows Follows right Follows right Follows right
the practical practical practical practical practical
Post Industrial guidelines and guidelines half- guidelines; but guidelines and guidelines; and
Visit Skills do any work heartedly cannot interpret can interpret it interpret it with
it justification

Total out of 20 Marks

Total out of 06 Marks

Faculty Signature