Professional Documents
Culture Documents
org
Evaluation of the penetration depth of sealing plastic concrete walls in the clay core of earth dams.
Abstract: Using of plastic concrete for construction of cutoff wall is known as a method to reduce and control of
seepage which has been developed in recent three decades. Plastic concrete cutoff wall is suggested when a dam is
constructed on an alluvial foundation with high permeability. In these conditions, a proper material is the one that
can carry high stresses of wall, Moreover, this material with its adjacent soils should deflect without failure and
losing sealant of wall. In other words, deformability modulus of this material should be similar to adjacent
foundation. Low permeability, plastic behavior and high flexibility are most important specifications of plastic
concrete. In order to accelerate of dam construction, in first step, an embankment should be constructed up to a
specified height and then plastic concrete cutoff wall would be constructed from the same height. If height of
embankment is increased the construction time will decrease. In this thesis and in order to find a maximum critical
height for embankment, effect of different factors have been investigated by using PLAXIS code such as penetration
depth of cutoff wall into clayey core and changing of mechanical specifications of clayey core, alluvial foundation,
plastic concrete cutoff wall and different properties of interface element. All models have been analyzed with and
without interface element.
[Reza Mahinroosta, Mohammadreza Shoaei, Faranak Pishgar. Evaluation of the penetration depth of sealing
plastic concrete walls in the clay core of earth dams. J Am Sci 2012;8(8):465-473]. (ISSN: 1545-1003).
http://www.jofamericanscience.org. 71
Key Words: dam, plastic concrete, cutoff wall, finite element method, PLAXIS software
465
Journal of American Science 2012;8(8 ) http://www.jofamericanscience.org
coefficient of foundation and sealing wall be close to concentration in this region, six different unions were
each other, the stress and strain of wall is adjusted and studied. Finally, with regard to the leakage and stress -
acceptable. Mirqasmi and colleagues (1380) studied strain analyzes, it was concluded that union systems
the characteristics of plastic concrete used in Karkheh including a plastic concrete cap on the boundary
dam and the impact of various factors on the between the foundation and the dam body is the best
properties of plastic concrete. Experimental results and the union system including a plastic concrete
were evaluated on over 150 plastic concrete mix cover and a clay levee is the most inappropriate
designs. These studies show that the plastics concrete system for the union area. As was observed, various
with less resistance has more plasticity, and it is researchers have studied the interaction of the plastic
impossible to increase plasticity without reducing the concrete sealing wall and alluvial foundation, while
resistance. In the study of Sadrkarimi and colleagues the penetration amount of the sealing wall in the clay
(1381) on the sealing wall of Arasbaran dam, the core, which sometimes is applied to reduce the flow
pattern of stress distribution, the deformation and the concentration in the union area and sometimes to
interaction of the plastic concrete sealing wall and the accelerate the operation of dams, are less studies. In
land of adjacent foundation during the performance of this study, this issue is investigated by using the
dam, was performed using two methods of elastic and general cross-sectional of an earthen dam and the
viscoelastic and by ANSYS software. The results reasonable parameters.
show that firstly, the amount of absorbed strain by the 2 - Numerical Modeling
sealing wall considerably conform to the ratio of In some dam projects in order to accelerate the
bentonite to the cement and also concrete friction implementation of the dam, first the dam embankment
angle between the plastic concrete and the adjacent is performed to a certain level, and then the plastic
soil. Secondly, with regard to the viscoelastic behavior concrete sealing wall through the clay core to the
of plastic concrete, it can be seen that even after alluvium and the bedrock will be implemented from
developing the dam and over time, the plastic concrete the desired level.
extends the deformation and the absorbed strain by the Given that the implementation speed of
wall gradually transfer to the adjacent soil. Sadrkarimi embankment can be high, whatever the embankment
and colleagues (1383) attempted to analyze the depth be greater, the project implementation will be
viscoelastic of the plastic concrete sealing wall in accelerated. The major objective of this study is to
earthen dam due to the changes of reservoir water obtain the maximum critical height of the
surface. In this study, a case from the geometric and embankment of dam body with regard to the
mechanical properties of Arasbaran Dam in East properties of sealing wall and its surrounding areas.
Azarbaijan province was used for modeling in This issue is investigated using PLAXIS software
PLAXIS software. In this study, the interaction angle (2000), and the effect of the changes of various factors
between sealing wall and adjacent soil on the stress such as the penetration depth of sealing wall into the
distribution and the deformations of the plastic core dam and the resistance properties of the plastic
concrete sealing wall and soil subsidence during the concrete materials of sealing wall and also the changes
dam developing and its services were studied. The of interface element properties were studied.
obtained results show that firstly, due to the 2-1 geometry and Limited element Network
compressive stresses transfer of adjacent soil, by In Figure 1, the two-dimensional model of
increasing the wall depth, the compressive stresses earthen dam and its foundation can be seen. The dam
show increasing trend that this process is highly has a height of 80 meters which is built on alluvial soil
influenced by the angle of interaction between the with a depth of 40 meters. The dam shell has an
wall and adjacent soil. Secondly, the creep behavior of upstream and a downstream slope of %2 horizontal to
plastic concrete causes that the wall subsidence to be a vertical and the dam core has an upstream and a
continued even after the dam development. The downstream slope of 0/25 horizontal to a vertical.
obtained results also show that due to the creep The final height of dam reservoir is considered 70
behavior, the time is needed that the wall transfer and meters from the alluvial bed and the width of dam
the soil to reach a coordination and by the plastic crests is considered 10 meters. To sealing the alluvial
deformation, the wall transfer will never return to the foundation, the plastic concrete sealing wall with the
primary site. Ghanbari and colleagues (2008) width of one meter was used in the total height of
presented the hydro-mechanical behavior of the alluvial foundation which the wall penetration depth
attachment systems of sealing wall to the clay core. into the clay core is variable in various models. All
The difference between the clay core rigidity and the points will be studied on the three cross sections of
sealing wall causes the stress concentration at the AA, BB and CC. AA section is passed on the
union which led to increasing the deformation in this symmetry line of section and within the sealing wall,
region. To reduce the hydraulic gradient and the stress whiles the BB section is depicted across the depth of
466
Journal of American Science 2012;8(8 ) http://www.jofamericanscience.org
alluvial foundation. CC is depicted in transverse across the level of 10 m above the foundation.
As can be seen, the Levee body of dam should be built performed in 2 months. After filling the dam reservoir,
on an alluvial land. Consequently, the land is it is turn to analyze in the exploiting conditions or in
considered as the initial stress of model. With regard the stable leak state. The long-term consolidation of
to the total height of levee body which is 80 meters, dam body is performed which is defined with
with assuming 5 meter layers, 16 layers are defined to assumption of 10 year duration. It should be noted that
complete the analysis. During the analysis, a in addition to the investigation of the effect of sealing
computational phase is defined as plastic phase wall penetration into the core, the measuring
(Plastic) per each 5 layers which the load is actually sensitivity on the resistance properties of the plastic
exerted on it and the pore water pressure of dam concrete materials of sealing wall and also the
increases due to loading. A consolidation phase is properties of interface are performed. Limited element
defined per each plastic phase to reduce the pore water network in prepared model is in accordance with
pressure at each stage. In each model, given the figure (2). As can be seen in figure, due to the increase
circumstances, the height of sealing wall is specified in the pore water pressure in the dam core and also the
and the sealing wall is placed in one of the phases. For presence of the sealing wall at different heights, the
example, if the penetration depth of sealing wall in the elements network is considered in this part more
core dam be 5 meters, first 5 meter layer as the plastic detailed than elsewhere.
and then the consolidation phase is defined. In these 15 - Node triangular elements in the limited element
conditions, in the site of sealing wall, still there aren’t network of desired model and standard boundary
materials related to the alluvial foundation and the conditions in program were used for the boundary of
clay core. In the next phase and while the height of the model.
levee is 5 meters, inactive only the material related to 2-2 - Behavioral model and material properties
the foundation and the core in desired site for the In order to modeling of dam and the penetration depth
plastic concrete sealing wall , and instead of that, the impact of the plastic concrete of sealing wall in clay
material properties of the plastic concrete sealing wall core, the behavioral model of Moher - Coulomb was
will be assigned to the desired location. The rest of the used. In PLAXIS software, this behavioral model in
embankment layers are defined as 5 meter layers to section is as non-associated flow rule and acts in
finally reach the height of 80 meters or the location of tensile rupture as associated flow rule. Specifications
dam crest. The total period of the construction of dam of the materials used in the modeling of earthen dams
levee body development is considered5/2 years. is according to Table 1: d dry density, t wet
After the dam development, the dewatering step of
dam reservoir is modeled to the height of 70 density, C attachment coefficient, Friction angle,
meters. Dewatering will be done in three steps which E elasticity coefficient, Poisson's ratio, t Tensile
in the first step is dewatered to the height of 20 m and
in the next step to the height of 30 to finally reach the resistance and permeability coefficient. The
total height of 70 meters, to complete the dewatering Poisson's ratio for the clay materials of core and
step of dam. The total duration of dewatering is plastic concrete is assumed 0.35 and for the alluvial
assumed 6 months and dewatering process is materials and the membrane is assumed 0.3.
467
Journal of American Science 2012;8(8 ) http://www.jofamericanscience.org
3 – Investigation of the penetration rate effect of penetration depth causes the increases of the volume
the plastic concrete sealing wall in the clay core strain in the wall located in the foundation, gets stable
In this section, the penetration depth effect of in all three steps of the end phase of development,
the plastic concrete sealing wall in the clay core is dewatering and seepage, which is shown in figure 4 as
studied. In first model, it is assumed that the sealing an example. Increase in the wall penetration depth
wall is located in total height of the foundation and is cause further strength on adjacent wall and leads to
not penetrated the wall of water into the core. In the increasing on the volume strain rate.
next model the wall penetration depth is assumed 5 m 140 Y(m)
till the end phase of first layer and in the next model Penetration Depth=0m
120
the wall penetration depth is enhanced to two layers, Penetration Depth=15m
100
namely the penetration depth reaches 10 m and this Penetration Depth=30m
procedure continues until the penetration depth of 50 80
-0.4
Due to the difference between the properties
of clay and plastics concrete materials, a sudden Figure (5) the investigation of penetration depth
increase occurs in the volume strain rate in the effects on the distribution of horizontal shift in the
interface of clay core and wall. Increase in the end phase of development in section CC.
468
Journal of American Science 2012;8(8) http://www.jofamericanscience.org
3-1 - investigation of the penetration depth effects of drown in three different situations of the wall in the
the sealing wall on the strain at the top of wall. clay core in figure (7).
In performed analysis, the most critical state As can be seen, at the end phase of
of sealing wall was in the end phase of development. development, the most critical state for the plastic
According to figure (6), in the end phase of dam formation of materials occurs, but in the dewatering
development, increasing the penetration depth of and the steady leakage steps, the materials of sealing
sealing wall to 10 m leads to decreasing in the strain wall distance from the rupture envelop and the sealing
of its top, but when the depth exceeds 10 m, the strain wall stabilizes.
rate at the top of sealing wall increases along with the q'(KN/m^2)
increase of penetration depth. 1600
Mohr-Coulomb's Envelope
1400
Strain of End of Penetration Depth=0m
Cutoff Wall %
14 1200 Penetration Depth=15m
10 800
8 600
6 400
4 200
2 0
0 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 p'(KN/m^2)
Penetration Depth (m)
Figure (7) the position of stress and the rupture
Figure (6) effect of the penetration depth on the
envelop of sealing wall for the penetration depth
strain at the top of wall in the end phase of effect.
development. a. the end phase of development,
b. dewatering
3-2 - Evaluation of the plastic parts of sealing wall. c. steady leakage
In this section, the location of plastic
formation points in the plastic concrete sealing wall is According to figure (8) prior to 10 m penetration
studied. For this purpose, push of Mohr - coulomb is depth of the sealing wall into the core, plastic points
drawn in the p' - q' space regarding to the following won't occur, but afterwards the plastic points are seen
relations: The effective stress along, which was at the height of the wall. With increasing on the
studied, were also transformed to the main stress and
penetration depth of sealing wall in the clay core, the
was drown in the p'-q' space for different models. For plastic parts amounts in the wall increases. Also,
this purpose the following equation is used: because the foundation is relatively stronger in
comparison with clay core, in none of the penetration
Equation 2: depth, the sealing wall in alluvium is transformed to
Rupture envelope and stress state in the the plastic.
height of the sealing wall of concrete plastic are
Figure (8) the range of plastic parts in the sealing wall at the end phase of development and different penetration
depths
469
Journal of American Science 2012;8(8) http://www.jofamericanscience.org
Table (2), the plastic concrete parameters in three states of weak, moderate, strong.
Elasticity Modulus kg 2 Friction Angle Deg Cohesion kg 2 Plastic concrete
cm cm
800 30 1 Low Strength
2000 35 4 Medium Strength
10000 38| 8 High Strength
The analysis performed showed that with increasing sealing wall at the end phase of development for the
the resistance and elasticity coefficient of sealing wall, less steady penetration depth of 15 is shown in figure (11).
strain will occur in the sealing wall in both foundation and With accordance to this figure, a separate rupture is
core. For example, a volumetric strain along the height of drawn for all three weak, moderate and strong plastic,
the sealing wall which has a penetration depth of 15 m in but as shown in figure (12), the plastic points are
the clay core is as figure (9). As can be seen, increase in created in all three states.
the plastic concrete strength, leads to reducing the volume
strain diagrams in all the three stages. 140 Y(m)
Poor Plastic Concrete 120
470
Journal of American Science 2012;8(8 ) http://www.jofamericanscience.org
20
15
Table (3) the resistance reduction coefficient
parameter of interface element in three states of 10
Magnitude Rinter 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
0.5 Weak Interface Penetration Depth (m)
0.75 Medium Interface Figure (14) the effect of penetration depth on the
strain at the top of wall in the end phase of
0.95 Strong Interface development.
5-1 measuring the sensitivity on the specifications of
interface element
In the section, the measuring interface on the
resistance reduction coefficient ( Rinter ) of interface
element is performed, which is shown in the following
table.
471
Journal of American Science 2012;8(8) http://www.jofamericanscience.org
In this section, the graphs are studied in the penetration depth of 15 m are shown in figure (18) and
penetration depth of 15 m. As expected, with decrease figure (19). As observed, several points in the sealing
in Rinter coefficient, the possibility of soil slip at wall is converted to plastic form which indicates that
the end phase of development is very critical, and with
sealing wall increases, and consequently the
horizontal shift in three states of the end phase of increase in Rinter coefficient, the plastic ranges
development, dewatering, steady leak, and the vertical decrease and it shows that if the sealing wall contains
shift in the end phase of development increase. an appropriate attachment with surrounding soil, it
Decrease in Rinter leads to decreasing in the effective will be less damaged.
vertical and total strain, since while force shifts, due to q'(KN/m^2)
2000
decrease in shear resistance of interface, the occurred 1800
slip and strain shift lessen, which is shown in figure 1600
(17). 1400
1200
1000
Y(m) 800 Mohr-Coulomb's Envelope
140
600 Weak Interface
R=0.5
120 R=0.75
400 Medium Interface
200 Strong Interface
R=0.95
100 0
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000
80 p'(KN/m^2)
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4
Horizontal Displacement (m)
140 Y(m)
R=0.5 Figure (18) the effect of Rinter coefficient changes
R=0.75 120
R=0.95 on the plastic points ranges formed in the sealing
100 wall in the end phase of development at the depth
80 of 15 m
60
6- Conclusion
40 In this article, an earthen dam with clay core,
20
alluvial foundation and plastic concrete sealing wall
with specified dimensions was modeled as two
0 dimensional using PLAXIS limited elements program
-3500 -3000 -2500 -2000 -1500 -1000 -500 0
and the penetration effect of plastic concrete sealing
Effective Vertical Stress (KN/m^2)
wall and its attachment with surrounding soil by the
Figure (16) Rint er coefficient effect on the interaction of concrete wall to the surrounding soil
distribution of vertical strain in the steady leak were studied. According to performed studies the
following results are obtained:
state at section AA.
Increase in the penetration depth of sealing wall
5-2- investigation of the Rinter coefficient changes on into the core leads to increasing in maximum
plastic points horizontal shift and the volume strain of plastic
In this chapter, the push rupture of q'-p' with concrete sealing wall.
regard to Rinter coefficient changes in the end phase Increase in the penetration depth of sealing wall
into the core leads to decreasing in the total
of development are studied. These graphs for the
472
Journal of American Science 2012;8(8 ) http://www.jofamericanscience.org
6/6/2012
473