ECA Comparison J17 vs. J3

Item Tender Sum PHASE J17 Tender Sum PHASE J3
Building Within Lot Boundaries 22,797,465.58 36,896,539.52
Infrastructure (Including External Electrical Serv.) 3,363,196.37 5,171,769.27
Double Chamber TNB Sub-Station 182,738.05 285,787.06
Prime Cost & Provisional Sum 2,621,600.00 5,002,300.00
Total 28,965,000.00 47,356,395.85
Building Cost / FS 211.25 177.18
Landscaping / Unit - -
Local Infrastructure / Unit 129,353.71 112,429.77
Total Cost Plan Area (CPA sq.ft.) 107,916.00 208,248.00
ELEMENTAL COST ANALYSIS BASED ON TENDER SUM

Overall PHASE J17 Overall PHASE J3
No. Elements Cost / SF CPA Cost / SF CPA
Total Amount (RM) % weightage Total Amount (RM) % weightage
RM / SF RM / SF
1 Preliminaries 1,207,918.95 11.19 5.30% 2,101,000.00 10.09 5.69%
2 Mock-up 84,000.00 0.78 0.37% 32,664.00 0.16 0.09%
3 Piling 465,109.05 4.31 2.04% 206,218.97 0.99 0.56%
4 Substructure
A Work Below Lowest Floor Finish 1,465,097.61 13.58 6.43% 2,686,332.12 12.9 7.28%
B Anti Termite 55,548.36 0.51 0.24% 64,701.00 0.31 0.18%
Total Substructure 1,520,645.97 14.09 6.67% 2,751,033.12 13.21 7.46%
5 Superstructure
A Frame 1,523,530.66 14.12 6.68% 2,326,405.84 11.17 6.31%
B Upper Floor 546,603.46 5.07 2.40% 1,234,345.06 5.93 3.35%
C Staircase Structure 61,979.06 0.57 0.27% 230,861.87 1.11 0.63%
Total Superstructures 2,132,113.18 19.76 9.35% 3,791,612.77 18.21 10.28%
6 Roof
A Roof Structure and Finishes 2,297,556.38 21.29 10.08% 2,770,645.59 13.3 7.51%
B Rainwater Plumbing 37,918.92 0.35 0.17% 174,384.15 0.84 0.47%
Total Roof 2,335,475.30 21.64 10.24% 2,945,029.74 14.14 7.98%
7 Wall
A Internal Wall & Partition 302,064.88 2.8 1.32% 659,451.27 3.17 1.79%
B External Wall 784,024.28 7.27 3.44% 1,588,062.59 7.63 4.30%
Total Wall 1,086,089.16 10.07 4.76% 2,247,513.86 10.80 6.09%
8 Windows, Doors & Ironmongeries 3,171,846.34 29.39 13.91% 4,205,949.36 20.2 11.40%
9 Internal & External Finishes
A Internal Floor Fnishes 794,829.88 7.37 3.49% 1,068,428.64 5.13 2.90%
B Internal Wall Finishes 1,612,703.82 14.94 7.07% 2,485,694.09 11.94 6.74%
C Internal Ceiling Finishes 322,911.68 2.99 1.42% 394,948.46 1.9 1.07%
D Staircase Finishes 24,104.60 0.22 0.11% 127,214.91 0.61 0.34%
E External Finishes 1,334,614.70 12.37 5.85% 1,838,748.38 8.83 4.98%
Total Internal & External Finishes 4,089,164.68 37.89 17.94% 5,915,034.48 28.41 16.03%
10 Handrailing & Balustrading 595,565.10 5.52 2.61% 923,393.37 4.43 2.50%
11 Sanitary Fittings 759,073.12 7.03 3.33% 1,302,883.82 6.26 3.53%
12 Services
A Mechanical & Electrical Services 3,033,660.00 28.11 13.31% 5,648,602.03 27.12 15.31%
B Builders work in connection with services 134,172.74 1.24 0.59% 99,237.54 0.48 0.27%
Total Services 3,167,832.74 29.35 13.90% 5,747,839.57 27.60 15.58%
13 External Works within Lot Boundary 1,855,107.76 17.19 8.14% 4,134,133.12 19.85 11.20%
14 Retaining Wall Between Lot 327,524.23 3.03 1.44% 592,233.34 2.84 1.61%
GRAND TOTAL 22,797,465.58 211.24 100.00% 36,896,539.52 177.19 100.00%

APPENDIX A
DIFFERENCES IN BUILDING COST PER SF BETWEEN BUNGALOW AT PHASE J17 AND PHASE J3
PHASE J17 PHASE J3
Item Remarks
Building cost / FS CPA = RM 211/FS Building cost / FS CPA = RM 177/FS
1. Job scope - 26 units bungalow. Job scope - 46 units bungalow. - Based on economics of scale, Phase J17 would be more expensive
due to the number of units being smaller than Phase J3.
2. Type of units Type of units - Phase J3 would be less expensive due to the types having more 3
2 storey bungalow. 3 storey bungalow - 31 units. storey houses than 2 storey houses as in Phase J17.
2 storey bungalow - 15 units. - 3 storey would be cheaper in terms of cost per FS.
3. No. of tenders - 5 Tenderers. No. of tenders - 8 Tenderers. - Competitiveness of tender for Phase J3.
4. Piling Works Piling Works

(a) Involved 19 units of bungalows out of (a) Involved 7 units of bungalows out of - Due to soil conditions, Phase J3 offers a cheaper option.
26 units. 46 units.
(b) Preparing precast RC pile head was (b) Preparing precast RC pile head was Reasonable rate is between
priced at RM 21.00 / NO priced at RM 5.44 / NO RM15 - RM25/NO. depend on
size of piles.
5. Building Works Building Works

(a) Rate of 100mm diameter UPVC (a) Rate of 100mm diameter UPVC Reasonable rate : RM 28/M - RM
rainwater downpipe : rainwater downpipe : 40/M.
RM 37.06 / M RM 25.04 / M
(b) 6mm thick sandblast glass was priced (b) 6mm thick frosted glass; light green
at RM 109.00 / M2. tinted was priced at RM 58.36 / M2. Tinted glass normally more
expensive than normal glass.
(a) Phase J3 tenderer offered a

(c) 8mm thick clear glass was priced at (c) 8mm thk green tinted glass was low rate and will be rationalised
RM 98.10 / M2. priced at RM 82.20 / M2.
accordingly.
(d) 1.5mm thick powder coated (d) 1.2mm thick powder coated (b) Difference in specifications. The cost difference between
aluminium frame louvres. aluminium frame louvres. 1.2mm and 1.5mm thick
@ Cost / m² = RM 448.00 / M2 @ Cost / m² = RM 267.00 / M2 approximately between 20% -
30%.
ECA/DIFF_J17_J3/Page 2
APPENDIX A
DIFFERENCES IN BUILDING COST PER SF BETWEEN BUNGALOW AT PHASE J17 AND PHASE J3
PHASE J17 PHASE J3
Item Remarks
Building cost / FS CPA = RM 211/FS Building cost / FS CPA = RM 177/FS
(e) 1.5mm thick powder coated (e) 1.4mm thick powder coated
aluminium door frame. aluminium door frame.
(f) Glass door type is folding, sliding, (f) Glass door type is swing doors and Folding glass door is the most
swing, slide & hide doors. sliding doors. expensive doors compared to
sliding glass door and swing
(g) Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes. (g) Floor, Wall & Ceiling Finishes. glass door.
1. Porcelain wall and floor tiles. 1. Porcelain wall and floor tiles.
2. Plasterboard ceiling. 2. Plasterboard ceiling.
ECA/DIFF_J17_J3/Page 3
BUNGALOWS AT DENAI ALAM.
COST COMPARISON PHASE J17 PHASE J3

ITEM DESCRIPTIONS UNIT RATE (RM) AMOUNT (RM) RATE (RM) AMOUNT (RM)
PILING WORKS (ALL PROVISIONAL

QUANTITIES)
GENERAL
Notes to Tenderers
1. All piling works shall commence from

formation level.
2. The quantities given in this Bill are provisional.

Payment shall be made based on actual quantities of
work executed.
3. All piles to be installed by low noise and low

vibration injection pile system to S.O. approval.
4. Pay length for driving of piles shall be measured

from the bottom of the pile toes to cut-off level.
5. The rate for bringing to site and subsequent

removal of plant and equipment off site and
maintaining, moving and handling plant and
equipment on the site shall cover for any
additional/omission in respect of numbers and
lengths of piles to be installed during the
Completion Period or any extended Completion
Period.
6. The rate for driving of piles shall include driving

through whatever depth and soil strata.
7. The Contractor shall be deemed to have allowed

in the Completion Period the time required to install
the test piles for testing, load test and awaiting
Architect's instruction to commence the working
piles.
8. Tenderers shall have to refer to the Trade

Preambles of this document. Tenderer is deemed to
have fully understood the meaning of foregoing
NOTE TO TENDERERS and no claim will be
entertained on the grounds of inadequate
information or ignorance on the part of the tenderer.
Total Carried to Collection



QUANTITIES) (Cont'd)
Specifications
1. All piles shall be constructed in accordance to

the relevant standard specification of precast
reinforced concrete piles.
2. The supply of the piles shall only commence

upon the Engineer's instruction which will be issued
soon after the completion of all preliminary data
tests.
3. Design working load for the 150mm x 150mm

precast reinforced concrete pile is 20.0 tonnes.
GENERAL ITEM
Plant and Equipment
A Allow for the provision of all necessary piling

equipment, plant, tool and ancillary equipment
including transportation to site, handling,
assembling and removal off site after completion of
the piling works.
Item 31,500.00 16,332.00
B Allow for maintaining, moving and handling all
necessary piling equipment, plant, tool and ancillary
equipment on the site and providing staging to
different platform levels as may required, as often
and whenever necessary for the whole operation
including excavations, filling to make-up levels,
install piles on embankments or slopes and idling
time etc.
Item 5,250.00 2,177.60
Piling Record
C Submit piling records as specified in triplicate, duly
signed by the contractor and the engineer and
deliver to the Architect / S.O. as the work proceed.
Item 3,150.00 1,088.80
As-Built Drawing
D Upon completion of the piling works, the contractor
shall submit an as-built drawing on the pile position
certified by a License Land Surveyor and deliver the
same to the Architect / S.O..
Item 12,867.75 3,810.80
Total Carried to Collection 52,767.75 23,409.20



PRECAST REINFORCED CONCRETE PILES
WORKING PILES
Supply, deliver, unload, handle, transport and pitch

for driving of precast reinforced concrete Grade 45
piles including all necessary moulds, reinforcement
bars, stirrups and binders.
A 150mm x 150mm initial piles in 6.00m lengths

complete with mild steel head and mild steel shoe
NO. 119.70 97,794.90 236.38 193,122.46
B Ditto extension piles in 6.00m lengths; exceeding

3.0m long M 23.10 77,477.40 39.41 132,181.14
C Ditto extension piles in 3.0m lengths; exceeding

3.0m long M 25.20 39,009.60 49.54 76,687.92
Drive only vertical reinforced concrete piles through

all types of soil to all various range of depth by
using approved hydraulic injection method to the
required set.
D 150mm x 150mm piles M 7.35 72,059.40 16.33 160,099.32
Precast reinforced concrete piles connection;

including mild steel plate and bituminous paint to
the approval of Architect.
E 150mm x 150mm piles NO. 10.50 15,351.00 8.71 12,734.02
Cut off precast reinforced concrete piles heads at

required level; including remove surplus lengths and
debris from site
F 150mm x 150mm piles NO. 21.00 17,157.00 23.95 19,567.15
1.2mm thick powder coated aluminium



PRECAST REINFORCED CONCRETE PILES

(Cont'd)
WORKING PILES (Cont'd)
Preparing precast reinforced concrete pile heads;

including trimming, stripping, dressing for key and
exposing rod reinforcement, straightening and
bending rod reinforcement at cut off level to bond
into pile caps (measured separately)
A 150mm x 150mm piles NO. 21.00 17,157.00 5.44 4,444.48
Testing
Carry out initial static load test on precast reinforced
concrete piles to 2 times the working load; including
bring to site for testing purposes all calibrated
instrument, equipment, kentledge, labour and
materials and remove the same on completion.
B 150mm x 150mm single pile (Working Load = 20

Tonne) NO. 5,250.00 10,500.00 7,077.20 14,154.40
Carry out dynamic load test on precast reinforced

concrete piles; including provision of pile driving
hammer, associated apparatus and computer
simulation analysis
C 150mm x 150mm piles NO 1,155.00 65,835.00 544.40 31,030.80

Collection Page
BQ/piling/1 - -
BQ/piling/2 52,767.75 23,409.20
BQ/piling/3 318,849.30 594,392.01
BQ/piling/4 93,492.00 49,629.68
TOTAL AMOUNT CARRIED TO SUMMARY

465,109.05 667,430.89
PAGE
CYPRESS RESIDENCES ASTELIA RESIDENCES

Building Within Lot Boundaries 23,899,065.58 39,378,839.52
Provisional Sum 1,520,000.00 2,520,000.00
Total 28,965,000.00 47,356,395.85
Total Gross Floor Area (GFA sq.ft.) 123,116.00 223,118.00

Overall PHASE J3 - 15 units 2 storey + 31
Overall PHASE J17 - 26 units 2 storey
units 3 storey
No. Elements
Cost / SF GFA Cost / SF GFA
RM / SF RM / SF
1 Preliminaries 1,207,918.95 9.81 5.05% 2,101,000.00 9.42 5.34%
2 Mock-up 84,000.00 0.68 0.35% 32,664.00 0.15 0.08%
3 Piling 465,109.05 3.78 1.95% 206,218.97 0.92 0.52%
4 Substructure
B Anti Termite 55,548.36 0.45 0.23% 64,701.00 0.29 0.16%
5 Superstructure
A Frame 1,523,530.66 12.37 6.37% 2,326,405.84 10.43 5.91%
B Upper Floor 546,603.46 4.44 2.29% 1,234,345.06 5.53 3.13%
6 Roof
Total Roof 2,335,475.30 18.97 9.77% 2,945,029.74 13.20 7.48%
7 Wall
B External Wall 784,024.28 6.37 3.28% 1,588,062.59 7.12 4.03%
Total Wall 1,086,089.16 8.82 4.54% 2,247,513.86 10.08 5.71%
B Internal Wall Finishes 1,612,703.82 13.1 6.75% 2,485,694.09 11.14 6.31%
12 PCSUM - Engineered Timber Flooring 1,101,600.00 8.95 4.61% 2,482,300.00 11.13 6.30%
13 Services
Total Services 3,167,832.74 25.73 13.26% 5,747,839.57 25.76 14.60%
GRAND TOTAL 23,899,065.58 194.12 100.00% 39,378,839.52 176.50 100.00%
Building cost only excluding M&E 20,865,405.58 169.48 33,730,237.49 151.18


Building Within Lot Boundaries 23,899,065.58 739,018.25
Provisional Sum 1,520,000.00 2,520,000.00
Total 28,965,000.00 8,716,574.58

Overall PHASE J17 - 26 units 2 storey Phase 2 - AMAYA
No. Elements
RM / SF RM / SF
1 Preliminaries 1,207,918.95 9.81 5.05% 36,542.25 9.81 4.94%
2 Mock-up 84,000.00 0.68 0.35% 0 0.00%
3 Piling 465,109.05 3.78 1.95% 61,000.00 16.38 8.25%
4 Substructure
A Work Below Lowest Floor Finish 1,465,097.61 11.9 6.13% 50,000.00 13.42 6.77%
B Anti Termite 55,548.36 0.45 0.23% 1,576.00 0.42 0.21%
Total Substructure 1,520,645.97 12.35 6.36% 51,576.00 13.84 6.98%
5 Superstructure
A Frame 1,523,530.66 12.37 6.37% 40,000.00 10.74 5.41%
B Upper Floor 546,603.46 4.44 2.29% 24,000.00 6.44 3.25%
Total Superstructures 2,132,113.18 17.31 8.92% 65,862.50 17.68 8.91%
6 Roof
A Roof Structure and Finishes 2,297,556.38 18.66 9.61% 69,508.50 18.66 9.41%
Total Roof 2,335,475.30 18.97 9.77% 70,663.25 18.97 9.56%
7 Wall
B External Wall 784,024.28 6.37 3.28% 23,728.25 6.37 3.21%
Total Wall 1,086,089.16 8.82 4.54% 32,854.50 8.82 4.45%
8 Windows, Doors & Ironmongeries 3,171,846.34 25.76 13.27% 56,582.75 15.19 7.66%
A Internal Floor Fnishes 794,829.88 6.46 3.33% 65,000.00 17.45 8.80%
B Internal Wall Finishes 1,612,703.82 13.1 6.75% 48,797.50 13.1 6.60%
D Staircase Finishes 24,104.60 0.2 0.10% 745.00 0.2 0.10%
E External Finishes 1,334,614.70 10.84 5.58% 40,379.00 10.84 5.46%
Total Internal & External Finishes 4,089,164.68 33.22 17.11% 164,681.00 44.21 22.28%
11 Sanitary Fittings 759,073.12 6.17 3.18% 22,983.25 6.17 3.11%
12 PCSUM - Engineered Timber Flooring 1,101,600.00 8.95 4.61% 0 0.00%
13 Services
A Mechanical & Electrical Services 3,033,660.00 24.64 12.69% 88,400.00 23.73 11.96%
Total Services 3,167,832.74 25.73 13.26% 92,460.25 24.82 12.51%
14 External Works within Lot Boundary 1,855,107.76 15.07 7.76% 55,875.00 15.0 7.56%
GRAND TOTAL 23,899,065.58 194.12 100.00% 739,018.25 198.39 100.00%
Building cost only excluding M&E 20,865,405.58 169.48 650,618.25 174.66


Building Within Lot Boundaries (incldg M&E) 23,918,575.05 39,380,994.62
Infrastructure Works 2,625,961.10 3,998,692.11
External Electrical Services 737,235.25 1,173,077.16
Provisional Sum 1,520,000.00 2,520,000.00
Total 28,965,000.00 47,356,395.85
Building Cost (incldg M&E) / FS 194.28 176.50
Local Infrastructure (incldg electrical) / Unit 129,353.71 198,914.20
ELEMENTAL COST ANALYSIS BASED ON CONTRACT SUM (After Rationalised)

units 3 storey
No. Elements
RM / SF RM / SF
1 Preliminaries 1,598,550.00 12.98 6.68% 2,107,862.27 9.45 5.35%
2 Mock-up 50,000.00 0.41 0.21% 32,664.00 0.15 0.08%
3 Piling 462,001.90 3.75 1.93% 199,329.23 0.89 0.51%
4 Substructure
B Anti Termite 49,322.00 0.4 0.21% 68,701.00 0.31 0.17%
5 Superstructure
A Frame 1,528,235.10 12.41 6.39% 2,317,445.68 10.39 5.88%
B Upper Floor 555,132.50 4.51 2.32% 1,225,769.36 5.49 3.11%
6 Roof
Total Roof 2,138,162.50 17.37 8.94% 3,022,693.76 13.55 7.68%
7 Wall
B External Wall 771,784.00 6.27 3.23% 1,621,364.07 7.27 4.12%
Total Wall 1,077,999.00 8.76 4.51% 2,280,815.34 10.23 5.79%
B Internal Wall Finishes 1,601,059.20 13 6.69% 2,501,331.59 11.21 6.35%
12 PCSUM - Engineered Timber Flooring 1,101,600.00 8.95 4.61% 2,482,300.00 11.13 6.30%
13 Services 0.00%
Total Services 3,168,165.80 25.73 13.25% 5,729,688.89 25.68 14.55%
16 Anticlimb perimeter fencing 0 0.00% 0 0.00%
GRAND TOTAL 23,918,575.05 194.28 100.00% 39,380,994.62 176.51 100.00%

Building cost only excluding M&E 20,884,915.05 169.64 33,732,392.59 151.19

Building Within Lot Boundaries (incldg M&E) 24,405,631.30 39,101,832.75
Infrastructure Works 2,391,356.29 3,726,557.45
External Electrical Services 635,861.32 912,373.16
Provisional Sum - -
Total 27,587,190.16 44,022,959.30
Building Cost (incldg M&E) / FS 198.23 175.25
Local Infrastructure (incldg electrical) / Unit 116,431.45 178,420.41
ELEMENTAL COST ANALYSIS BASED ON FINAL CONTRACT SUM

units 3 storey
No. Elements
RM / SF RM / SF
1 Preliminaries 1,598,550.00 12.98 6.55% 2,107,862.27 9.45 5.39%
2 Mock-up 50,000.00 0.41 0.20% 32,664.00 0.15 0.08%
3 Piling 384,976.60 3.13 1.58% 240,152.75 1.08 0.61%
4 Substructure
B Anti Termite 49,322.00 0.4 0.20% 68,701.00 0.31 0.18%
5 Superstructure
A Frame 1,528,235.10 12.41 6.26% 2,317,445.68 10.39 5.93%
B Upper Floor 555,132.50 4.51 2.27% 1,225,769.36 5.49 3.13%
D Roof Structure 715,595.50 5.81 2.93% 971,040.29 4.35 2.48%
Total Piling + Substructure + Superstructures 4,724,858.20 38.38 19.36% 7,637,067.61 34.23 19.53%
6 Roof
A Roof Finishes 1,416,516.80 11.51 5.80% 1,877,269.32 8.41 4.80%
Total Roof 1,455,542.80 11.83 5.96% 2,051,653.47 9.19 5.25%
7 Wall
B External Wall 771,784.00 6.27 3.16% 1,621,364.07 7.27 4.15%
Total Wall 1,077,999.00 8.76 4.42% 2,265,790.14 10.16 5.79%
B Internal Wall Finishes 1,601,059.20 13 6.56% 2,501,331.59 11.21 6.40%
Finishes 4,207,472.40 34.17 17.24% 5,919,378.84 26.52 15.14%
12 PC SUM - Engineered Timber Floor
A Engineered Timber to staircase 345,252.30 2.8 1.41% 623,613.30 2.79 1.59%
B Engineered Timber to internal floor 670,586.20 5.45 2.75% 1,380,900.50 6.19 3.53%
C PCSUM - Profit and Attendance 81,391.90 0.66 0.33% 64,190.30 0.29 0.16%
Total Engineered Timber Flooring 1,097,230.40 8.91 4.50% 2,068,704.10 9.27 5.29%
13 Services
Total Services 3,055,039.80 24.81 12.52% 5,722,064.63 25.64 14.63%
Total Architectural Element + Finishes 14,134,278.70 114.81 57.91% 22,711,729.43 101.78 58.08%
16 Anticlimb perimeter fencing 363,472.50 2.95 1.49% 382,734.40 1.72 0.98%
GRAND TOTAL 24,405,631.30 198.24 100.00% 39,101,832.75 175.25 100.00%
Total Building cost only excluding M&E 21,485,097.30 174.52 33,460,854.98 149.97
PROPOSED 46 UNITS 2 & 3 STOREY BUNGALOW AT PHASE J3, DENAI ALAM
SUMMARY
3 Storey Bungalow 2 Storey Bungalow 3 Storey Bungalow

TYPE A TYPE B TYPE C Type D Type E
ELEMENT DESCRIPTION
Amount per Total Amount Amount per Total Amount Amount per Total Amount Amount per Amount per
Amount (RM)
unit (RM) (RM) unit (RM) (RM) unit (RM) (RM) unit (RM) unit (RM)
BUILDING WORKS - SUPERSTRUCTURE AND ARCHITECTURAL ELE 7.00 22.00 15.00
2 Frame 46,677.96 326,745.72 54,316.28 1,194,958.16 46,933.16 703,997.40 46,138.12 45,606.28 2,317,445.68
3 Upper floor 29,852.32 208,966.24 28,569.50 628,529.00 21,950.17 329,252.55 27,634.73 31,386.84 1,225,769.36
4 Roof and rainwater goods
4.1 : Roof structure 18,973.20 132,812.40 21,813.10 479,888.20 21,115.74 316,736.10 18,987.20 22,616.39 971,040.29
4.2 : Roof finishes 31,215.48 218,508.36 37,529.84 825,656.48 50,500.98 757,514.70 40,196.26 35,393.52 1,877,269.32
4.3 : Rainwater plumbing 2,996.15 20,973.05 3,899.79 85,795.38 4,099.01 61,485.15 4,062.00 2,068.57 174,384.15
5 Staircase
5.1 : Staircase structure 5,381.49 37,670.43 6,310.29 138,826.38 2,852.54 42,788.10 5,667.29 5,381.49 230,333.69
5.2 : Staircase finishes 2,551.12 17,857.84 3,032.32 66,711.04 0.00 0.00 3,000.96 2,551.12 90,120.96
5.3 : Staircase railings 7,011.90 49,083.30 9,015.30 198,336.60 6,010.20 90,153.00 7,011.90 7,011.90 351,596.70
6 External walls
6.1 : External walls 30,756.91 215,298.37 31,573.72 694,621.84 43,283.32 649,249.80 27,865.03 34,329.03 1,621,364.07
6.2 : External railings 15,177.94 106,245.58 8,928.20 196,420.40 2,678.46 40,176.90 15,177.94 8,928.20 366,949.02
7 Windows And Vents 42,614.58 298,302.06 58,658.20 1,290,480.40 65,420.90 981,313.50 38,950.98 42,373.78 2,651,420.72
8 Doors And Ironmongeries 46,727.26 327,090.82 37,461.43 824,151.46 42,443.17 636,647.55 51,546.32 45,609.17 1,885,045.32
9 Internal walls
9.1 : Internal walls 13,311.03 93,177.21 14,207.31 312,560.82 15,128.35 226,925.25 12,966.30 13,821.69 659,451.27
9.2 : Internal railings 2,003.40 14,023.80 5,509.35 121,205.70 4,507.65 67,614.75 0.00 2,003.40 204,847.65
10 Internal wall finishes 50,535.70 353,749.90 57,404.63 1,262,901.86 52,105.12 781,576.80 48,994.24 54,108.79 2,501,331.59
11 Internal floor finishes 23,176.30 162,234.10 23,108.49 508,386.78 24,405.68 366,085.20 22,447.29 23,176.30 1,082,329.67
12 Internal ceiling finishes 8,590.41 60,132.87 8,943.16 196,749.52 8,075.16 121,127.40 8,348.26 8,590.41 394,948.46
13 External finishes 35,796.30 250,574.10 42,688.92 939,156.24 34,164.66 512,469.90 78,755.55 69,692.37 1,850,648.16
14 Sanitarywares and Fittings 31,432.33 220,026.31 27,755.45 610,619.90 27,755.45 416,331.75 31,402.93 31,402.93 1,309,783.82
15 Builder's Work In Connection With Services 1,766.66 12,366.62 1,761.22 38,746.84 1,761.22 26,418.30 1,777.55 1,777.55 81,086.86
16 External Works Within lot boundary 101,482.40 710,376.80 79,608.28 1,751,382.16 73,107.04 1,096,605.60 104,918.74 121,217.73 3,784,501.03
BQ/BLDG/5.2(a)/SUM/14/Add2
PROPOSED 46 UNITS 2 & 3 STOREY BUNGALOW AT PHASE J3, DENAI ALAM
SUMMARY
3 Storey Bungalow 2 Storey Bungalow 3 Storey Bungalow

TYPE A TYPE B TYPE C Type D Type E
ELEMENT DESCRIPTION
Amount per Total Amount Amount per Total Amount Amount per Total Amount Amount per Amount per
Amount (RM)
unit (RM) (RM) unit (RM) (RM) unit (RM) (RM) unit (RM) unit (RM)
TOTAL AMOUNT PER UNIT CARRIED TO FINAL
548,030.84 562,094.78 548,297.98 595,849.59 609,047.46 25,631,667.79
SUMMARY OF TENDER Page FS/2
BQ/BLDG/5.2(a)/SUM/15/Add2

ECA Comparison J17 vs. J3

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

ECA Comparison J17 vs. J3

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Item Tender Sum PHASE J17 Tender Sum PHASE J3

Building Within Lot Boundaries 22,797,465.58 36,896,539.52

Infrastructure (Including External Electrical Serv.) 3,363,196.37 5,171,769.27

Double Chamber TNB Sub-Station 182,738.05 285,787.06

Prime Cost & Provisional Sum 2,621,600.00 5,002,300.00

Total 28,965,000.00 47,356,395.85

Building Cost / FS 211.25 177.18

Local Infrastructure / Unit 129,353.71 112,429.77

Total Cost Plan Area (CPA sq.ft.) 107,916.00 208,248.00

ELEMENTAL COST ANALYSIS BASED ON TENDER SUM

GRAND TOTAL 22,797,465.58 211.24 100.00% 36,896,539.52 177.19 100.00%

due to the number of units being smaller than Phase J3.

4. Piling Works Piling Works

5. Building Works Building Works

(a) Phase J3 tenderer offered a

COST COMPARISON PHASE J17 PHASE J3

PILING WORKS (ALL PROVISIONAL

1. All piling works shall commence from

2. The quantities given in this Bill are provisional.

3. All piles to be installed by low noise and low

4. Pay length for driving of piles shall be measured

5. The rate for bringing to site and subsequent

6. The rate for driving of piles shall include driving

7. The Contractor shall be deemed to have allowed

8. Tenderers shall have to refer to the Trade

Total Carried to Collection

COST COMPARISON PHASE J17 PHASE J3

PILING WORKS (ALL PROVISIONAL

1. All piles shall be constructed in accordance to

2. The supply of the piles shall only commence

3. Design working load for the 150mm x 150mm

Plant and Equipment

A Allow for the provision of all necessary piling

Total Carried to Collection 52,767.75 23,409.20

COST COMPARISON PHASE J17 PHASE J3

PILING WORKS (ALL PROVISIONAL

PRECAST REINFORCED CONCRETE PILES

Supply, deliver, unload, handle, transport and pitch

A 150mm x 150mm initial piles in 6.00m lengths

B Ditto extension piles in 6.00m lengths; exceeding

C Ditto extension piles in 3.0m lengths; exceeding

Drive only vertical reinforced concrete piles through

D 150mm x 150mm piles M 7.35 72,059.40 16.33 160,099.32

Precast reinforced concrete piles connection;

E 150mm x 150mm piles NO. 10.50 15,351.00 8.71 12,734.02

Cut off precast reinforced concrete piles heads at

F 150mm x 150mm piles NO. 21.00 17,157.00 23.95 19,567.15

1.2mm thick powder coated aluminium

Total Carried to Collection 318,849.30 594,392.01

COST COMPARISON PHASE J17 PHASE J3

PILING WORKS (ALL PROVISIONAL

PRECAST REINFORCED CONCRETE PILES

WORKING PILES (Cont'd)

Preparing precast reinforced concrete pile heads;

A 150mm x 150mm piles NO. 21.00 17,157.00 5.44 4,444.48

B 150mm x 150mm single pile (Working Load = 20

Carry out dynamic load test on precast reinforced

C 150mm x 150mm piles NO 1,155.00 65,835.00 544.40 31,030.80

Total Carried to Collection 93,492.00 49,629.68

PILING WORKS (ALL PROVISIONAL

BQ/piling/2 52,767.75 23,409.20

BQ/piling/3 318,849.30 594,392.01

BQ/piling/4 93,492.00 49,629.68