You are on page 1of 10

ENGLISH MAJORED SENIORS FUTURE JOB CHOICE

AT A UNIVERSITY IN VIETNAM
Đinh Minh Thu
Khoa Ngoại ngữ
Email: thudm@dhhp.edu.vn
Ngày nhận bài: 16/02/2023
Ngày PB đánh giá: 21/3/2023
Ngày duyệt đăng:24/3/2023

ABSTRACT: In Vietnam in recent years, it is claimed that a number of graduates


may pursue the job they are not oriented at university, causing a loss of resources for
the training organization and the graduates themselves. However, little research on
the issue which is related to English - majored seniors is documented in the context
of the country. Motivated from such a scenario, a study on the English majored
seniors’ future job choice at a university in Vietnam was conducted. The study aims
to find out the specific future job choice of the undergraduates together with the
underlying justifications for such (a) choice(s) and their expectations in future job
orientation. A survey questionnaire was the tool to fulfil the aims. It has been found
out that the private sector attracted a majority of students. To be specific, most of
them wanted to work as English teachers. Salary was the dominating factor in most
students’ future job choice. To increase the students’ employability, teachers,
university and companies were expected to interplay. The research findings can raise
one more voice to the decision and action of all the stakeholders in empowering the
students’ readiness for the world of work.
Keywords: future job choice, English major, seniors, Vietnam

L A CH N CÔNG VI C T NG LAI C A SINH VI N NĂM CU I CHUYÊN NGÀNH


TI NG ANH TẠI M T TR NG ẠI H C VI T NAM

TÓM TẮT: Trong những năm gần đây ở Việt Nam, không ít sinh viên tốt nghiệp
làm những công việc không được đào tạo ở trường đại học. Thực trạng này gây ra sự
lãng phí nguồn lực cho cho cơ sở đào tạo và cho chính bản thân sinh viên. Tuy nhiên,
còn có ít nghiên cứu về vấn đề này liên quan đến sinh viên năm cuối chuyên ngành
ngôn ngữ Anh tại Việt Nam. Trước tình hình này một nghiên cứu về lựa chọn công
việc tương lai của sinh viên năm cuối ngành ngôn ngữ Anh ở một trường đại học ở
Việt Nam được tiến hành. Nghiên cứu này nhằm mục đích tìm hiểu những lựa chọn
công việc tương lai của sinh viên ngành ngôn ngữ Anh năm cuối, những lý do cho

16 TR NG Đ I H C H I PHÒNG
sự lựa chọn và mong đợi của sinh viên về sự định hướng công việc. Kết quả nghiên
cứu chỉ ra phần lớn sinh viên chuyên ngành ngôn ngữ Anh lựa chọn công việc là giáo
viên tiếng Anh. Lương cao là yếu tố hấp dẫn nhiều sinh viên nhất. Thêm vào đó, sinh
viên mong muốn có sự kết hợp chặt chẽ giữa trường đại học và công ty trong việc
hướng nghiệp. Kết quả nghiên cứu đóng thêm tiếng nói vào quyết định và hành động
của các bên liên quan trong việc bồi dưỡng năng lực sinh viên sẵn sàng cho thị trường
lao động.
Từ khóa: lựa chọn nghề, chuyên ngành tiếng Anh, sinh viên năm cuối, Việt Nam

I. INTRODUCTION current study is motivated, aiming at


Future job choices are the uncovering English majored seniors’
significant issue not only for future job choice. The study is
undergraduates but the training significant for the majors and their
institution since the success in the job family to reflect themselves, the
can help the undergraduates earn their university to have more effective career
living and the institution affirm its training and orientation, and the
reputation in the education market. interested researchers to have more data
Furthermore, their reasonable job choice in their coming research.
can make the parents and the society Three research questions are
satisfied in such a way that their formulated as follows:
investment proves to be effective. 1. What future job do the English
Nonetheless, complaints about the majored seniors at a university in
mismatch between the training and the Vietnamese choose?
actual chosen job were still heard (Manh 2. What factors affect the future job of
Doan, 2022; My Ha, 2022; Siddiky & the English majored seniors at a university
Akter, 2021). Such mismatches can in Vietnamese choose?
cause the waste in education investment 3. What expectations do the English
and reduce the success in that majored seniors at a university in
occupation. According to Vietnam Vietnamese propose in relation to their
Chamber of Commerce and Industry future job?
(Manh Doan, 2022), Vietnam annually
II. LITERATURE REVIEW
has 38% graduates who do not have job
orientation, leading to an ambiguous job 2.1. Conceptualisation of job
choice. This situation occurs in many Prior to an investigation into the
majors while English major is assumed English majored seniors’ future job
to be affected less. There is little research choice a case study at a university in
on the actual scenario of English majors’ Vietnam, job as the key term of the
future job choice in Vietnam. Hence, this research must be defined clearly.

T P CHÍ KHOA H C S 59, Tháng 7/2023 17


According to Cambridge career if it performs a long-life
Dictionary, Collin and Oxford professional goal and experiences a
Dictionary, the word job has a number of long-term training.
definitions, and the chosen definition for The selected participants in the
this study is the regular work that gets present research are English-majored
payment. That definition is exploited by seniors, which means that they are more
MBN (n.d) and specified into three likely to discuss their job, to earn their
staple types, including trades, living, than to imagine a lifelong
professions and unskilled jobs. The trade professional goal. Therefore, the adopted
group concerns manual work with a working definition of the future job in
course of training of practical work, for this research is their future paid post of
example plumber, electrician, etc. The regular employment.
professions require a university
2.2. Popular jobs for English
qualification like doctor and teacher. The
majors in Vietnam
last group needs the least and the shortest
training, for instance, cleaner and guard. As stated in the curriculum of many
Another way to classify jobs based on universities which have the English major
the working hours divide jobs into part- training programme, a wide range of posts
time ones and full-time ones. In addition, are proposed for the graduates. They can
jobs can fall into each of these categories work as translators, interpreters, event
as self-employment, consulting, odd organisers, tour guides, consultants,
jobs, seasonal, temporary, or contract. teachers and researchers in national and
Indeed Editorial Term (2022) also international companies, schools or other
defines a job as It full time or part time organisations (Haiphong University,
work and required a set of certain skills Hutech, Yersin University, etc.). It is
to fulfil it. undoubted that the English majors have a
A closely-related term to job is wide range of job opportunities although
career. As presented by Indeed Editorial among them there are jobs which require
Term (2022) and Johnson (2022), a further training in addition to their English
career means the job(s) a person pursues capacity, for example, teachers,
during their working life and a long consultants and tour guides. It depends on
professional journey which earns a their capacity and ambition to choose the
person a wide range of benefits including job they expect to pursue. In this research,
finance, interests and self-actualization. the questions are, at the researched
It requires ongoing training and university, what jobs are most chosen by
advancement. Two terms are the students, what the underlying
distinguished on the basis of its motivations for the choice are and what
sustainability (Indeed Editorial Term, expectations they give about their future
2022). Interestingly, a job can become a job orientation.

18 TR NG Đ I H C H I PHÒNG
2.3. Factors affecting English promote or hinder students on their
majored graduates’ career choice career decision making.
The future job choice is believed to From the previous research, this
be the interplay of many decisive factors study will investigate the factors
(Connor & Dewson, 2001; Looker & affecting the English majored
Lowe, 2001; Özlen & Arnaut, 2013; undergraduates’ future job choice in
Reay, David, Ball, 2001; Siddiky & terms of two aspects: the external aspect
Akter, 2021). The orientation from their and the internal one. The external aspect
family and teacher(s) as well as the will be detailed into the family circle, the
income dominates in all the studies. university conditions, and the job
Siddiky & Akter (2021, p.422) market. The internal aspect will be the
review two significant theories which undergraduates’ ability and interests.
determine students’ future job choice: III. METHOD
the social cognitive career theory The research was conducted at a
(SCCT) suggested by Lent, Brown & foreign language department at a
Hackett (2002) and the social learning university in Vietnam. The department at
theory (SLT) by Ireh (2000). The first
the studied time had four classes of
theory introduces self-efficacy, outcome
English majored seniors with the total
expectations and personal goals as the
number of students being 126 students.
interplay for job decision. Self-efficacy
The future job decision was among the
refers to the aptitude for the job and
biggest concerns of almost all of them on
outcome expectations mean the benefits
the entrance of graduation. Therefore,
from the job while personal goals
they were purposefully selected as the
consider the intention to reach the
efficacy and outcomes. By comparison, respondents for the research. The
the second theory approaches a wider curriculum for English majors includes
coverage of the career decision with four the core subjects of an English major.
factors: genetic endowment, However, unlike in the curriculum for
environmental conditions, learning pre-service English teachers, seven
experiences and task-approach skills. In subjects relating to translation and
this theory, the genetic endowment interpretation are included while
includes race, gender, colour, methodological subjects are excluded.
intelligence, special ability, etc. The The translation and interpretation
environmental conditions base on the subjects are assumed to be essential for
family, the teacher, the job market, etc. their future career. A survey
The learning experiences and task- questionnaire was designed on the google
approach skills are those related to the form to investigate their choices and the
knowledge and methods the students underlying reasons. The survey method
prepare for the job. Those factors can was selected by other researchers with the

T P CHÍ KHOA H C S 59, Tháng 7/2023 19


same research interest (Connor & 4.1. Demographics
Dewson, 2001; Looker & Lowe, 2001; At the researched university,
Özlen & Arnaut, 2013; Reay, David, Ball, most students studied the English
2001; Siddiky & Akter, 2021). The language are females. 97.1%
survey rubric contained four sessions. respondents were of the same gender.
The first was the participants’ A relatively equal proportions of
demographic information. The second students in four English majored
included their future job choice. The next classes joined the survey, with the
related to the underlying reasons for those highest proportion at 31.4% of the
choices and the final session was students coming from English Major 2
extended to the students’ expected about Class. The number of respondents was
the job orientation at university. To promising for the further investigation.
ensure the reliability and validity, the
4.2. Undergraduates’ future
questionnaire was piloted with four
job choice
students randomly selected from each
class, and the questions were adjusted With regards to the future job
slightly. Then, the survey was sent to the choice, two major questions were raised,
participants 85 feedbacks were received. including the selected working sector
The data were analysed descriptively then and the specific career. The first question
discussed in relevance to the findings offered three options: state-owned
from the previous research. companies, private companies and self-
employment.
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Chart 1. Undergraduates’ chosen job sectors.

20 TR NG Đ I H C H I PHÒNG
It is prominent from the chart that Surprisingly, the respondents belonging
over half of the respondents selected the to the majored English classes which
private sector, while a small number were not purposefully trained as English
dared to work for themselves. In teachers reported nearly half of them
Vietnam, working in the private sector is wanted to work as an English teacher.
said to suit those who are young, active The subjects of translation and
and enthusiastic (Dang, 2022; Huynh, interpretation which they were trained a
2022; HR Insider, 2022). The finding great deal seemed not to significantly
was different from that in Siddiky & affect their future job choice. Only 11,1
Akter (2021) where many students % and 5,6% of the surveyed
expected to work in the public sector. undergraduates expressed their
expectation to work as a translator and
The second question sought the
interpreter correspondently.
undergraduates’ intended career choices.

Chart 2. Undergraduates’ chosen jobs

There was one more question English. That means the English major
which was open to the students’ choice, can play a supportive role for the
which is “job which is NOT relevant to students to extent their future job choice.
English”. The feedback were 4.3. Factors affecting the future
businessmen and receptionists. job choice
According to Bui (2021, cited in My Ha, The future job choice was assumed
2022), Ministry of Education in Vietnam to be affected by a number of factors.
released that only 56% graduates did the The current study found out the factors
job they were trained at university. in terms of two aspects: the external one
Compared to the data in this research, the of the family circle, the university
students did not select the job they were conditions, and the job market and the
directly trained. Nonetheless, almost all internal one of the undergraduates’
the selected jobs were relevant to ability and interests.

T P CHÍ KHOA H C S 59, Tháng 7/2023 21


Regarding the objective reasons, a suggest them to choose that job.
third proportion of students chose the job Amongst these objective factors, the job
their parents advised. Most of them, factor was significant to the students.
61.1% wanted the job which was High salary was noted as the most
different from their parents’. It was a attractive factor to choose a job, at
good sign that 44.4% students though 58,3%. Being ranked the second
they selected the job because they were attractive factor was the training
trained it at university. Friends were also opportunity. Opportunities for travelling,
influential in students’ job selection, at promotion, flexible working time,
16,7%. From the data, most students did comfort, challenge accounted for the
not have their parents do the job they relatively equal number. Pension drew
wanted to do but many had their parents their least attention.

Chart 3. The job-itself factors

Also related to the job factor, the was the factor which affected the
students who wanted to work in the state- students the least, at 5.6%, By contrast,
owned sector reported its advantages as their internship experience made the
high salary, stability and gentleness for biggest impression on the students, at
over a half of students choosing this.
women, training opportunity and
Part-time job, like experience made
friendly environment. By comparison,
some meaning to the students’ choice. In
those interested the private sector or self-
addition, their consciousness of their
employment expected the same above
personalities and ability added the
benefits except that they did not expect
important reasons for the choice
the stability but challenge and
although they did not weigh as much as
experience with different jobs.
the knowledge the students got from the
There were a number of suggested job through their internship and part-
personal reasons for the choice. Gender time job.

22 TR NG Đ I H C H I PHÒNG
4.4. Students’ expectations interested by many respondents. They
On investigating the future job suggested the workshop of the major
choice, students’ expectations in and the soft skills. Knowing and
relation to the issue are worth meeting these expectations can help
considerations. Three options for their the university to increase their
expectations were offered, including undergraduates’ employability.
having more job orientation from V. CONCLUSION
companies in the first year, having In conclusion, a majority of
more job orientation from companies English majored seniors expected to
in the fourth and last year, and having work in the private sector, as an English
more internship. A majority of language teacher, having high salary. To
students (48,6%) selected the second facilitate their future job choice, job
option of job orientation in the final orientation was expected in the final
year. The final option of the practicum year. The role of a teacher was not the
seemed to be the least importance to focused training in the English major
them. An open-ended question was programme at the researched university;
raised for other students’ expectations. therefore, another short training must be
Not all the students gave their required for the post.
feedback; some answers were
The study promotes the better link
irrelevant; and many answers shared
among the career guidance, work market
the ideas. The relevant answers can be
and the students. Another
arranged into three groups:
recommendation is the provision of the
expectations about the major,
teacher training short courses for English
expectations about the companies,
majors at university; hence, they can be
expectations about the orientation. For
ready for their needs in the work market.
the major, the students said that “I
wanted the teachers to expand the There exist certain limitations in the
knowledge about the subject of study which can be solved in the future
translation and interpretation.” and investigation. In terms of the method, this
“more speaking skills with foreign study mainly used the quantitative data
teachers”. In addition, they hoped the while qualitative data should be collected
university would link the students with to make the triangulation, increasing the
the companies from the first year or in data value. According to the participants,
the final year so that they had more there was the restriction to the English
choices. Some students wished to work majored seniors at a university. The
for the non-governmental participants can be widened to other
organisations. The orientation was institutions in Vietnam.

T P CHÍ KHOA H C S 59, Tháng 7/2023 23


REFERENCES jobs. Retrieved on April 2, 2023 from
1. Bloomer, M. & Hodkinson, P. https://marketbusinessnews.com/fina
(1997). Moving into FE: The voice of ncial-glossary/job-definition-
the learner. London: Further meaning/
Education Development Agency. 9. Manh Doan, (2022). Vì sao 60% sinh
2. Dang, M.L. (2022). Mới ra trường thì viên làm trái ngành nghề, trong khi
nên làm nhà nước hay tư nhân? thiếu lao động tay nghề cao?
Retrieved on February 7, 2023 from Retrieved from
https://dangmylinh.com/moi-ra-truong- https://giaoduc.net.vn/vi-sao-60-
thi-nen-lam-nha-nuoc-hay-tu-nhan/ sinh-vien-lam-trai-nganh-nghe-
3. Huynh, L. (2022). Nên làm nhà nước hay trong-khi-thieu-lao-dong-tay-nghe-
tư nhân? Retrieved on February 7, 2023 cao-post223413.gd
https://kenhtuyensinh.vn/nen-lam-nha-
10. My Ha, (2022). Chỉ 56% sinh viên
nuoc-hay-tu-nhan
tốt nghiệp làm đúng ngành nghề đào
4. HR Insider (2022). Mới tốt nghiệp: tạo. Retrieved from
Chọn làm nhà nước hay công ty tư https://dantri.com.vn/giao-duc-
nhân? Retrieved on February 7, 2023 huong-nghiep/chi-56-sinh-vien-tot-
from nghiep-lam-dung-nganh-nghe-dao-
https://vietnambusinessinsider.vn/m tao-20221009125812317.htm
oi-tot-nghiep-chon-lam-nha-nuoc- 11. Indeed Editorial Term (2022).
hay-cong-ty-tu-nhan-a27675.html What’s the difference between a job
5. Hutech (2022). Ngành ngôn ngữ Anh and a career? Retrieved on January
là gì? Ra trường làm gì? Retrieved 13, 2023 from shorturl.at/eJMU6
on January 14th, 2023 from 12. Johnson, J. (2022). What is a career?
shorturl.at/iptU4 Retrieved on January 13, 2023 from
6. Haiphong University (2022). Ngành shorturl.at/brzOQ
ngôn ngữ Anh. Retrieved on January 13.Özlen, M. K. & Arnaut, D. (2013)
14th, 2023 from shorturl.at/htALR Career decision of university’s
7. Looker, D. & Lowe, G.S. (2001). students. Journal of Community
Post-secondary access and student Positive Practices, XIII (2)2013,92-
financial aid in Canada: Current 107
knowledge and research gaps. 14.R.W. Lent, S.D. Brown, & G.
Retrieved on January 14th, 2023 from Hackett, Social cognitive career
www.millenumscholarship.ca/en/ theory in D. Brown and
foundation/publications/pareport/cpr Associates,Eds.,Career choice and
n-bkgnd.pdf, accessed 20 May 2013 development. San Francisco:
8. MBN (n.d). What is a job? Types of Jossey-Bass, 2002, pp. 255-311.

24 TR NG Đ I H C H I PHÒNG
15. Reay, D., David, M. & Ball, S. preparedness strategies: A social
(2001). Making a difference? environmental perspective. IJIRE.
Institutional habituses and higher Vol.10, No.2, June2021, pp.
education choice. Sociological 421~431
Research Online, 5(4).Retrived from 17. Yersin University (2022). Cơ hội việc
www.socresonline.org.uk/5/4/reay.ht làm của các ngành liên quan đến
ml, accessed 20 May 2013 ngôn ngữ Anh. Retrieved on January
16.Siddiky, M. R & Akter, S. (2021). 14th, 2023 from shorturl.at/wDIQZ
The students’ career choice and job

T P CHÍ KHOA H C S 59, Tháng 7/2023 25

You might also like